{0}------------------------------------------------
**Staff Report March 25, 2024** 

## **Case A23-0624-Skyline Neighborhood Utility Facility Conditional District Zoning Map Amendment** 

## **Request** 

Skyline Telephone Membership Corporation has submitted a Conditional District Zoning Map Amendment petition to amend the existing 2007 Conditional District Zoning designation on property on West Hilltop Drive to construct a 144 square foot equipment shelter to add use 6.01, Utility Facility, Neighborhood to the existing Conditional District approval. 

**Packet Pg. 27**
{1}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0624 Skyline Neighborhood Utility Facility - Conditional District Zoning Map Amendment**[2] 

_Staff Note:  Since the high school parcel is quite large, a second map is shown below zooming in on the portion of the property to be disturbed._ 

**==> picture [471 x 9] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
243.<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Packet Pg. 28**
{2}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0624 Skyline Neighborhood Utility Facility - Conditional District Zoning Map Amendment**[3] 

|**Parcel Information**<br>**Address:**<br>**Property Owner:**<br>**Watauga County PIN:**<br>**Lot size :**<br>**Jurisdiction:**<br>**Access:**<br>**SFHA:**<br>**Watershed District:**<br>**Corridor District:**<br>**NCD:**<br>**Viewshed:**<br>**Steep Slope:**<br>**Very Steep Slope:**<br>**Transitional Zone:**<br>**Current Zoning:**<br>**Current Use:**<br>**Proposed Use:**|(TBD) West Hilltop Drive<br>Watauga County<br>2910-88-3456-000<br>92.02 Acres; Utility Facility has a leased area of 2,500 square feet<br>Town of Boone<br>West Hilltop Drive (Town maintained)<br>Yes, however subject 2500 square foot area is located over 1,400 feet from the<br>SFHA.)<br>No<br>No<br>No<br>Yes, a small portion of the property located along to southern portion of W Hilltop<br>Drive is in the viewshed, however, the lease area for the Utility Facility is outside<br>of this area.<br>Yes, however, none on the leased area for the Utility Facility is disturbing any<br>steep or very steep slope<br>No<br>No<br>**Split zoned: Conditional District OI and Conditional District B3**<br>Use 9.04 High School<br>Addition of Use 6.01 Utility Facility, Neighborhood<br>Utility facilities that are designed to serve the immediately surrounding<br>neighborhood and for reasons associated with the purpose of the utility in<br>question must be located in or near the neighborhood where such facilities are<br>proposed to be located.|
|---|---|



||**Zoning & Use of Adjacent Properties**||
|---|---|---|
||**Adjacent Zoning**|**Adjacent Land Use**|
|North|B3 General Business|Cemetery, Multi-family residential|
|East|B2 Neighborhood Business|Single-family Dwelling|
|South|CDOI Conditional District Office Institutional|High School|
|West|B3 General Business|Undeveloped/Vacant|



Note: This assessment was based only on the area where the Neighborhood Utility Facility is being located due to the size of the overall tract (92 acres). 

**Packet Pg. 29**
{3}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0624 Skyline Neighborhood Utility Facility - Conditional District Zoning Map Amendment**[4] 

## **Procedural Analysis:** 

Pursuant to UDO Subsection 14.01.02(C) a Conditional District (CD) is a zoning district in which the use and development of a property pursuant to a site-specific development plan is approved through the legislative process pursuant to Article 9 of this Ordinance. A CD utilizes a proposed general use zoning district, is limited to the authorized uses and development standards mandated within that district, and may be subjected to conditions that make the development more desirable. 

A site-specific vesting plan is defined in UDO Article 34 as “A plan submitted to a local government in which the applicant requests vesting in accordance with Section 4.13, describing with reasonable certainty on the plan the type and intensity of use for a specific parcel or parcels of property. The plan may be in the form of, but not be limited to, any of the following plans or approvals: a subdivision plat, a preliminary or general development plan, a special use permit, a conditional district zoning plan. The plan shall include the approximate boundaries of the site; significant topographical and other natural features affecting development of the site; the approximate location on the site of the proposed buildings, structures, and other improvements; the approximate dimensions, including height, of the proposed buildings and other structures; and the approximate location of all existing and proposed infrastructure on the site, including water, sewer, roads, and pedestrian walkways.” 

See below for details on the applicant’s compliance with the Conditional District procedural requirement for a neighborhood meeting as set forth in UDO Subsection 9.09.02 and the development’s overall compliance with UDO standards specific to the development: 

## **Compliance with UDO Subsection 9.09.02 Neighborhood Meeting:** 

- A. The applicant shall conduct a neighborhood meeting prior to the submission of the application for a Conditional District Zoning Map Amendment.  This meeting will allow the applicant to explain the proposed development and to be informed of the concerns of the neighborhood and surrounding property owners. 

- B. A meeting notice must be mailed to property owners within 300’ of the development at least 25 days prior to the meeting in accordance with Subsection 1.13.02 herein.  A copy of the notice shall also be provided to the Planning Department.  The notice shall contain a summary of the proposed development, the applicants contact information, the date, time, and location of the meeting. 

- C. The meeting must be held at an accessible and convenient location and time in light of available options.  Upon coordination through the Planning Department, the meeting may be held at Town Council Chambers if that location is available. 

- D. At the meeting, the petitioner, at a minimum, shall present all the following information: 

   1. Contact information of the parties involved in the ownership, design, and development of the property; 

   2. The location of the property and general information on the current conditions of the site; 

   3. Proposed use(s) and site development; 

   4. Any preliminary plans or renderings, if available; and 

**Packet Pg. 30**
{4}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0624 Skyline Neighborhood Utility Facility - Conditional District Zoning Map Amendment**[5] 

- E. The applicant shall provide the Administrator with a summary report of the meeting which includes a list of all attendees and details the meeting including all concerns expressed by attendees and commitments made by the petitioner.   This report shall be included in the staff report. 

_Staff Note: The applicant held a neighborhood meeting on November 2, 2023.  A recap of the meeting along with the certification of mailing to the property owners is included in the board packet (Exhibit 3)._ 

## **Zoning Analysis** 

## **B3 Intensity Standards:** 

|**Standard**<br>Minimum Gross Land Area: 20,000 sq. ft.<br>Minimum Lot Width: 80 feet<br>Minimum Street Frontage: 64 feet<br>Minimum Livability Space: .40<br>Interior Setback: 13’<br>Street Setback: 20’<br>Maximum Building Height: 4 Stories|**Proposed**|**Compliance**|
|---|---|---|
||92 acres|Yes|
||Varying widths|Yes|
||Approximately 400 feet|Yes|
||.538|Yes|
||Varies|Yes|
||20’|Yes|
||1 story/10’|Yes|



## **Parking:** 

|**Parking:**|||
|---|---|---|
|**Required**|**Proposed**|**Compliance**|
|Automobile Space – maximum of 3 spaces|3|Yes|
|Bicycle, Short-Term – not required|0|Yes|
|Bicycle, Long-Term – not required|0|Yes|
|Motorcycle – not required|0|Yes|



## **Use Compliance** 

## **Compliance with limited use requirements in UDO Section 15.16 Utility Facility** 

Pursuant to UDO Section 15.16, each utility facility shall meet the following standards: 

**15.16.01** Utility facilities in or adjoining residential zoning districts must maintain district setback, be fenced (unless totally enclosed within a structure), and either be screened from view or designed to have a residential appearance. 

_Staff Note:  The applicant’s site plan shows evergreen screening and demonstrates compliance. (See Exhibits 4 and 5)._ 

**15.16.02** Equipment producing noise or sound may not exceed 60 decibels at any adjoining property line. 

_Staff Note:  The applicant has indicated they will be in compliance with this requirement._ 

## **ANALYSIS BY OTHER TOWN STAFF** 

**Public Works:** 

**Utilities Division (Robbie Jones, Utility Services Technician)** 

**Packet Pg. 31**
{5}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0624 Skyline Neighborhood Utility Facility - Conditional District Zoning Map Amendment**[6] 

Approved. 

**Services Division (Justin Stines, Deputy Public Works Director)** 

Approved. 

## **Fire Department (Amy Flieg, Fire Marshal)** 

Approved. 

## **CONFORMITY TO ADOPTED PLANS** 

## **COMPREHENSIVE PLAN UPDATE** 

## **1.1 Overall Objectives for the Boone Comprehensive Plan (p. 15):** 

The following objectives, which have not been listed in any particular order of importance, are deliberately broad in scope and less specific than either a policy statement or an implementation action. 

**Economic Development:** Acknowledge the area’s natural beauty, university, and medical center presence as the Town’s greatest assets for economic development and jobs creation. Treat them accordingly. 

**Community Appearance and Community Character:** Blend the built environment with the natural, scenic, and historic character of a High-Country small town. Especially discourage commercial strip development, cluttered signage, and “cheap” apartment buildings. 

**Open Space:** Integrate open space and greenways into the urban fabric of the Town.  Preserve the countryside by discouraging suburban sprawl.  Avoid development in floodplains, on ridgetops, and on steep slopes. 

**Environmental Quality:** Address and monitor growth factors and activities that contribute to water, air, light, and noise pollution. 

**Trees:** Conserve existing trees and plant new trees, especially hardwoods. 

**Infrastructure:** Engage in long range planning for water and sewer systems, stormwater runoff, natural gas, and other utility systems. Place overhead utilities underground whenever feasible. 

**Public Safety:** Maintain a high level of policing and fire protection and plan the expansion of public safety services to coincide with projected population increases and identified needs. 

**Energy and Waste:** Reduce waste generation, and the consumption of energy and water. Develop area recycling programs to the fullest. Encourage an anti-litter consciousness among residents and visitors. **Neighborhoods:** Ensure the livability of neighborhoods, especially through land use and traffic planning. 

**Public Involvement:** Encourage active public involvement and volunteerism to expand the effectiveness of community planning and action. 

**Packet Pg. 32**
{6}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0624 Skyline Neighborhood Utility Facility - Conditional District Zoning Map Amendment**[7] 

**1.2 Growth Strategy Map (p. 17):** The property is located within Primary Growth Area. 

The property is located within the Primary Growth area. The Primary Growth Area is that portion of the urban growth area where urban level or facilities are already in place or can be provided most cost effectively. This is the area where near term growth and development is to be especially encouraged. 

The Secondary Growth Area is that portion of the urban growth area where urban level services can be provided, but on a lower priority basis than in the primary growth area. 

Additionally, for comparison, the Rural Area is that portion of the planning study area that is influenced by urban area growth forces, but within which urban level development should be strongly discouraged. Urban level services and associated development densities should not be planned for this area, except in case by case evaluations of major economic development projects. 

Staff has reviewed land use and comprehensive plan policies, and listed those policies which in staff’s opinion have a bearing on the request.  The Commission and Council should review these policies carefully.  Each member may make his or her own interpretation as to the relevance of each and which carry the most weight thereby shaping their overall recommendation.  See below: 

## **2.1 Economy** 

… 

## **2.1.1 Economic Development** 

- A. The Town shall protect and enhance a high quality of life, image, cultural amenities, and natural beauty as the most effective, long term component of an economic development strategy. 

- D. Economic development efforts shall encourage the revitalization and reuse of currently unused or underutilized structures, sites and infrastructure in appropriately located areas. 

**Packet Pg. 33** [|
{7}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0624 Skyline Neighborhood Utility Facility - Conditional District Zoning Map Amendment**[8] 

... 

## **2.1.2 Commercial Development** 

- F. Commercial uses may be encouraged to develop by consolidation and expansion of existing commercially zoned property, only when such consolidation and expansion does not encroach upon a viable residential area. 

## **2.3 THE COMMUNITY** 

- A.   Urban type development within the Urban Growth Area shall meet appropriate Town standards. 

## **2.3.1 Community Appearance** 

- A. Measures to improve the effectiveness of grading, landscaping and buffering standards for new and existing developments shall be encouraged. 

- B. The significance of street trees in providing visual relief, summer cooling, improved air quality and livability shall be recognized through public policies and actions to encourage their planting and maintenance. 

## **2.3.2 Community Character** 

- A. The identification, restoration and active use of structures, buildings, monuments, and neighborhoods of historic or architectural significance shall be encouraged as a means of enhancing their economic and cultural value to the planning area. 

- C. Wise development of the tourism potential of the area’s architectural, historic, scenic and natural resources shall be encouraged. 

- D.  The destruction of significant architectural, historic, scenic, natural and archaeological resources in the planning area shall be discouraged. 

- E. New development, redevelopment and rehabilitation of structures and sites shall occur in a manner which is consistent with the neighborhood and architectural context of the immediate area, and supportive, whenever possible, of Boone’s original community character as a High Country small town. 

## **2.3.3 Housing & Neighborhoods** 

- A.  The protection and rehabilitation of viable neighborhoods shall be encouraged to insure their continued existence as a major housing source and as a reflection of the area’s image as an attractive, highly livable community. 

- G.  Compact, full service neighborhoods, offering opportunities for living, working, shopping, and gathering places, shall be encouraged in newly planned developments, as well as for redeveloping areas. 

## … 

## **Certificate of Mailing** 

I, Brenda Henson, certify that individual notices meeting the requirements of Article 9 of the Town of 

Boone UDO were placed in the mail (first class) on March 1, 2024. 

/s/ Brenda Henson 

Brenda Henson, Administrative Support Specialist 

## **Certification of Posting** 

**Packet Pg. 34**
{8}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0624 Skyline Neighborhood Utility Facility - Conditional District Zoning Map Amendment**[9] 

- I, Brandon Wise, certify that the subject property was posted as required in Article 9, Subsection 9.03.03(B)(2) of the Town of Boone UDO on March 1, 2024. 

- /s/ Brandon Wise 

Brandon Wise, Environmental Specialist 

## **Conclusion** 

The following conditions are automatically included and a part of any approval. 

1. Where there is a conflict between the application information and the plans (dated received on December 13, 2023), the plans shall control.  Insignificant deviations may be permitted to comply with the requirements of the UDO. 

2. Any commitments and representations concerning the proposed development made by the applicant or its (his or her) representatives at the public hearing shall also become a condition of the permit, and a basis for a stop work order and/or permit revocation if violated. 

3. The applicant shall submit the necessary applications, plans, details and specifications which meet the requirements of the Town Code, UDO, Building Code and any other applicable codes for review and approval necessary to issue Zoning and Building Permits. 

Any other conditions agreed upon by the applicant and Town Council: 

1. Any other conditions agreed upon … 

**Packet Pg. 35**
{9}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0624 Skyline Neighborhood Utility Facility - Conditional District Zoning Map Amendment**[10] 

## **Planning Commission Recommendations** 

Per NCGS 160D-604(b), subsequent to initial adoption of a zoning regulation, all proposed amendments to the zoning regulation or zoning map shall be submitted to the Planning Commission for review and comment. If no written report is received from the Planning Commission within 30 days of referral of the amendment to that board, the Town Council may act on the amendment without the Planning Commission report. The Town Council is not bound by the recommendations, if any, of the Planning Commission.  Per NCGS 160D-604(d), when conducting a review of proposed zoning text or map, the Planning Commission shall advise and comment on whether the proposed action is consistent with any comprehensive plan that has been adopted and any other officially adopted plan that is applicable. The Planning Commission shall provide a written recommendation to the governing board that addresses plan consistency and other matters as deemed appropriate by the Planning Commission, but a comment by the Planning Commission that a proposed amendment is inconsistent with the comprehensive plan shall not preclude consideration or approval of the proposed amendment by the governing board. 

**Vote 1:** The proposed amendment to the Town’s zoning map  **is** OR   **is not** consistent with the Town’s comprehensive plan and any other adopted plan(s) of the Town that are applicable because: 

_**Note 1** : describe elements of controlling land use plans and how the amendment is or is not consistent._ 

_Note 1_ 

**Vote 2:** The Planning Commission recommends  **approval** OR  **denial** of Ordinance #A23-0624 within Exhibit A and believes  **approval** OR  **denial** is reasonable and in the public interest because: 

_Note 2_ 

_**Note 2** : briefly explain why, factors may include (i) the size, physical conditions, and other attributes of the area proposed to be rezoned, (ii) the benefits and detriments to the landowners, the neighbors, and the surrounding community, (iii) the relationship between the current actual and permissible development on the tract and adjoining areas and the development that would be permissible under the proposed amendment; (iv) why the action taken is in the public interest; and (v) any changed conditions warranting the amendment._ 

**Packet Pg. 36**
{10}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0624 Skyline Neighborhood Utility Facility - Conditional District Zoning Map Amendment**[11] 

## **TOWN COUNCIL ACTION - Adoption of Ordinance** 

Per NCGS 160D-605, when adopting or rejecting any zoning text or map amendment, the Town Council shall approve a brief statement describing whether its action is consistent or inconsistent with an adopted comprehensive plan. The requirement for a plan consistency statement may also be met by a clear indication in the minutes of the governing board that at the time of action on the amendment the governing board was aware of and considered the planning board's recommendations and any relevant portions of an adopted comprehensive plan. If a zoning map amendment is adopted and the action was deemed inconsistent with the adopted plan, the zoning amendment shall have the effect of also amending any future land-use map in the approved plan, and no additional request or application for a plan amendment shall be required. A plan amendment and a zoning amendment may be considered concurrently. 

**Vote 1:** The proposed amendment to the Town’s zoning map  **is** OR   **is not** consistent with the Town’s comprehensive plan and any other adopted plan(s) of the Town that are applicable because: 

_**Note 1** : describe elements of controlling land use plans and how the amendment is or is not consistent._ 

_Note 1_ 

**Vote 2:** The Town Council  **approves** OR  **denies** and believes  **approval** OR  **denial** of Ordinance #A23-0624 in Exhibit A is reasonable and in the public interest because: 

_Note 2_ 

_**Note 2** : briefly explain why, factors may include (i) the size, physical conditions, and other attributes of the area proposed to be rezoned, (ii) the benefits and detriments to the landowners, the neighbors, and the surrounding community, (iii) the relationship between the current actual and permissible development on the tract and adjoining areas and the development that would be permissible under the proposed amendment; (iv) why the action taken is in the public interest; and (v) any changed conditions warranting the amendment._ 

**Packet Pg. 37**
{11}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0624 Skyline Neighborhood Utility Facility - Conditional District Zoning Map Amendment**[12] 

## **Exhibit A** 

## **Ordinance A23-0624** 

WHEREAS, pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. §160D-601, the Town may amend its zoning map after giving proper public notice and holding a public hearing; and 

WHEREAS, the Planning Commission and Town Council has received the request to amend the Official Zoning Map of the Town of Boone, North Carolina to modify the CD B3 General Business sitespecific development plan for the Watauga High School approval by allowing Use 6.01 Neighborhood Utility Facility. 

Addresses: (TBD) West Hilltop Drive Watauga County PIN:  2910-88-3456-000 Property Owner: Watauga County 

WHEREAS, the Boone Town Council held a duly-noticed public hearing March 25, 2024 with respect to this rezoning request; and 

WHEREAS, the Boone Town Council has taken into full consideration any information offered at the public hearing; and 

WHEREAS, this Town Council has reviewed the written recommendations of the Town of Boone Planning Commission; and 

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED as follows: 

**SECTION 1** . The Boone Town Council hereby approves and adopts the modifications to the Town Zoning Map as set forth herein. 

**SECTION 2** . All provisions of any Town ordinance in conflict with this ordinance are hereby repealed to the extent of such conflict. 

**SECTION 3** . This Ordinance shall be effective immediately upon its adoption by Town Council. 

Adopted this the 24th day of April, 2024. 

## **The Honorable Tim Futrelle, Mayor** 

**Attest:** 

**Nicole Harmon-Church, Town Clerk** 

**Packet Pg. 38**
