{0}------------------------------------------------
**Exhibit 2** 

###### **Staff Report** 

###### **January 27, 2025 Public Hearing Case A24-0081 – App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment** 



|Request .................................................................................................................................................................................. 1|
|---|
|Parcel Information ................................................................................................................................................................ 2|
|History .................................................................................................................................................................................... 3|
|Procedural Analysis ............................................................................................................................................................... 3|
|Zoning Analysis ...................................................................................................................................................................... 3|
|Permissible Uses ............................................................................................................................................................... 3|
|Intensity Regulations ...................................................................................................................................................... 10|
|Height .............................................................................................................................................................................. 10|
|Occupancy ....................................................................................................................................................................... 10|
|Certificate of Mailing........................................................................................................................................................... 10|
|Certification of Posting ....................................................................................................................................................... 10|
|Conformity to Adopted Plans: Potentially Relevant Comprehensive Plan Provisions ..................................................... 11|
|Planning Commission Recommendations ......................................................................................................................... 15|
|Town Council Action - Adoption of Ordinance .................................................................................................................. 16|
|Exhibit A – Ordinance A24-0595 ........................................................................................................................................ 17|





<!-- Start of picture text -->
[a }<br>aN ‘wey RINEER IDG: OS i” ey!<br><!-- End of picture text -->

###### <mark>Request</mark> 

The Board of Trustees of the Endowment Fund of Appalachian State University have submitted a General Use Zoning Map Amendment Application requesting to rezone 21.83 acres of a 77.63-acre parcel of land located off Mountaineer Ridge Drive from B3 General Business to E2 Educational District (Watauga County PIN:  2910-02-7414-000).   On the map above, the 21.83-acre area proposed to be rezoned is outlined in green with green hash marks, while the entire 77.63-acre parcel is outlined in blue. 

**Packet Pg. 11** Co)
{1}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment | 2 

Portions of this property lie outside the Town of Boone corporate limits.  Note:  The University has received preliminary plat approval for an exempt plat to divide this parcel into 3 tracts, each over 10 acres. 

Tract 1:  12.49 acres; to remain B3 General Business 

<mark>Tract 2: 21.83 acres; request to rezone from B3 General Business to E2 Educational.</mark> 

Tract 3: 40.32 acres with 26.37 within the Town’s jurisdiction.  Area within Town to remain E1 Educational. 

<mark>Parcel Information (area requested to be rezoned)</mark> **Address:** Mountaineer Ridge Drive **Property Owner:** The Board of Trustees of the Endowment Fund of Appalachian State University **Watauga County PIN:** 2910-02-7414-000 **Lot size:** 21.83 acres **Jurisdiction:** Town of Boone **Access:** Mountaineer Ridge Drive (NCDOT maintained) 





|**SFHA:**|No|
|---|---|
|**Watershed District:**|No|
|**Corridor District:**|Yes|
|**NCD:**|No|
|**Viewshed:**|Yes|
|**Steep Slope:**|Yes|
|**Current Zoning:**|**B3 General Business**|



The B3 General Business District is primarily intended to accommodate a wide range of office, restaurant, retail, service, and multi-family residential uses in a mixeduse environment. The regulations for this district are intended to create a comfortable, healthy, safe, aesthetically pleasing, and pleasant environment for all appropriate uses. 

**Proposed Zoning: E2 Educational** 

The E2 Educational District is established to provide for appropriate uses by colleges or universities outside of the ASU main campus, which uses may include residential uses. The owner of a property zoned E2 must be a college or university. In the event that a property or portion of a property zoned E2 is sold to a third 

**Packet Pg. 12** Co
{2}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment 3 

party that is not a college or university, no use of the property shall be permitted until the property is rezoned. 

###### **Current Use:** 

###### Parking Lot 

**<mark>Zoning & Use of Adjacent Properties (area requested to be rezoned)</mark>** 

||**Zoning**|**Land Use**|
|---|---|---|
|North|B3 General Business|Vacant property, restaurant, and personal service<br>establishments|
|East|B3 General Business|Veterinary Office; Multi-Family|
|South|E1 Educational|Public College and University|
||E1 Educational; B3 General Business;|Multi-Family in Mixed Use; Club/Lodge; Public|
|West|R3 Multiple-Family|College and University|
|History|||



05-09-2019 Boone Town Council approved a request from the Board of Trustees of the Endowment Fund of Appalachian State University to rezone a portion of the property from B3 General Business to E1 Educational. 

###### <mark>Procedural Analysis</mark> 

Pursuant to UDO Subsection 9.07.01, in deciding whether to adopt a proposed amendment to this Ordinance, the central issue before the Council is whether the proposed amendment advances the public health, safety, or welfare. All other issues are irrelevant, and all information related to other issues at the public hearing may be declared irrelevant by the Mayor and be excluded. In particular, when considering proposed general use map amendments, the Council shall not consider any representations made by the petitioner that if the change is granted the rezoned property will be used for only one of the possible range of uses permitted in the requested classification. Rather, the Council shall consider whether the entire range of permitted uses in the requested classification is more appropriate than the range of uses in the existing classification. Additionally, the Council shall only consider the impact of the proposed change on the public at large. 

###### <mark>Zoning Analysis</mark> 

Please see this section for relevant excerpts from both UDO Article 14 and UDO Appendix B. 

###### Permissible Uses: 

Excerpt of B1.01 Complete Table of Principal Uses 

||**Specific Principal Use**|**B3**|**E1**|**E2**|**Reference**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**1.0 Ho**|**usehold Living**|||||
|1.01|Single-FamilyDwelling|||||
|1.02|Manufactured Home “Class A”||||15.01|
|1.03|Manufactured Home “Class B”||||15.01|
|1.04|Manufactured Home “Class C”|||||
|1.05|Manufactured Home Park||||15.02|
|1.06|Duplex(one duplex building per lot)|||||
|1.07|Duplex(more than one duplex building per lot)||||15.03|
|1.08|Townhouse(upto 30 bedrooms)||||15.03|



**Packet Pg. 13**
{3}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment 4 

||**Specific Principal Use**|**B3**<br>**E1**|**E2**<br>**Reference**|
|---|---|---|---|
|1.09|Townhouse(31-100 bedrooms)||15.03|
|1.10|Townhouse(> 100 bedrooms)||15.03|
|1.11|Multi-FamilyDwelling (upto 30 bedrooms)||15.03|
|1.12|Multi-FamilyDwelling (31-100 bedrooms)||15.03|
|1.13|Multi-FamilyDwelling (> 100 bedrooms)||15.03|
|1.14|Multi-FamilyDwellingin Mixed Use(upto 30 bedrooms)|L|15.04|
|1.15|Multi-FamilyDwellingin Mixed Use(31-100 bedrooms)|CD|15.04|
|1.16|Multi-FamilyDwellingin Mixed Use(> 100 bedrooms)|CD|15.04|
|1.17|Adult LivingCommunity|||
|**2.0 Gr**|**oup Living**|||
|2.01|FamilyCare Home||15.06|
|2.02|FamilyCare Institutions||15.07|
|2.03|Residential Reentry,Category1||15.07|
|2.04|Residential Reentry,Category2||15.07|
|2.05|Residential Care Facility|P||
|2.06|Fraternityor SororityDwelling||15.09|
|2.07|BoardingHouse|L|15.10|
|**3.0 Tra**|**nsient Living**|||
|3.01|Home for Survivors of Domestic Violence||15.11|
|3.02|Shelter for Homeless,Category1|L|15.12|
|3.03|Shelter for Homeless,Category2|L|15.12|
|3.04|Bed and Breakfast,Category1||15.13|
|3.05|Bed and Breakfast,Category2|L|15.13|
|3.06|Vacation Rental|L|15.14|
|3.07|HomestayRental|L|15.05|
|3.08|Motel|CD||
|3.09|Hotel,Small|P||
|3.10|Hotel,Large|CD||
|3.11|Hotel,extended stay|CD||
|**4.0 Ins**|**titutional**|||
|4.01|Airport/LandingStrip||15.15|
|4.02|Heliport|||
|4.03|Funeral Home Establishment|P||
|4.04|Crematorium|CD||
|4.05|Cemetery|P||
|4.06|Post Office|P||
|4.07|Post Office,Distribution|||
|4.08|Animal Sanctuary|||



**Packet Pg. 14**
{4}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment 5 

||**Specific Principal Use**|**B3**|**E1**|**E2**|**Reference**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**5.0 Go**|**vernment Uses**|||||
|5.01|Government Cultural Facility|P||||
|5.02|Government Neighborhood Cultural Facility,Indoor ActivityOnly|P||||
|5.03|Government Neighborhood Cultural Facility,Includes Outdoor Activity|P||||
|5.04|Recreation Facility,Category1|P||||
|5.05|Recreation Facility,Category2|P||||
|5.06|Recreation Facility,Category3|CD||||
|5.07|Event Venue,Category1|P||||
|5.08|Event Venue,Category2|P||||
|5.09|Event Venue,Category3|CD||||
|5.10|Landfill|||||
|5.11|Solid Waste Processing|||||
|5.12|Police Substation|P||||
|5.13|UtilityFacility,Town|L|||15.16|
|5.14|UtilityFacility,Government,Neighborhood|L|||15.16|
|5.15|UtilityFacility,Government,Regional|L|||15.16|
|5.16|Government Facility|P||||
|**6.0 No**|**n-Government Utility Facility**|||||
|6.01|UtilityFacility,Neighborhood|L|||15.16|
|6.02|UtilityFacility,Regional|CD|||15.16|
|**7.0 Wi**|**reless Communication**|||||
|7.01|Small Wireless Collocation|L|L|L|15.18|
|7.02|Wireless FacilityCollocation on ExistingWireless Support Structure or UtilityPole|L|L|L|15.17|
|7.03|Stealth Wireless FacilityAttached to ExistingBuildingor Structure|L|L|L|15.17|
|7.04|Non-stealth Wireless FacilityAttached to ExistingBuildingor Structure||||15.17|
|7.05|Non-stealth Wireless FacilityCollocation on Electrical Transmission Towers|L|L|L|15.17|
|7.06|Stealth Wireless Support Structure|L|L|L|15.17|
|7.07|Non-stealth Wireless Support Structure|L|||15.17|
|7.08|EmergencyResponse Communication Antenna|P|P|P||
|**8.0 As**|**sembly**|||||
|8.01|Religious Assembly,Category1|P||||
|8.02|Religious Assembly,Category2|P||||
|8.03|Religious Assembly,Category3|CD||||
|8.04|Club/Lodge|CD||||
|**9.0 Ed**|**ucation**|||||
|9.01|Public colleges and universities||P|P||
|9.02|Private colleges and universities||CD|CD||
|9.03|Trade school|||||



**Packet Pg. 15**
{5}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment 6 

||**Specific Principal Use**|**B3**<br>**E1**|**E2**<br>**Reference**|
|---|---|---|---|
|9.04|High school|||
|9.05|Elementaryschool|||
|9.06|Boardingschool|||
|9.07|College- or university-operated communityenterprise||15.63|
|9.08|College- or university-operated child daycare center||15.19|
|**10.0 Da**|**ycare**|||
|10.01|Child Daycare,Large|L|15.19|
|10.02|Child Daycare Center|L|15.19|
|10.03|Adult Daycare,Large|L|15.19|
|10.04|Adult Daycare Center|L|15.19|
|10.05|All Other Daycare|CD||
|**11.0 Ge**|**neral Sales and Service**|||
|11.01|Kennel|CD|15.20|
|11.02|VeterinaryOffice/Hospital with Outdoor Kennels|CD|15.20|
|11.03|VeterinaryOffice/Hospital without Outdoor Kennels|P||
|11.04|Financial Institution ≤ 5,000 ft<sup>2</sup>|P||
|11.05|Financial Institution > 5,000 ft<sup>2</sup>|P||
|11.06|Restaurants ≤ 3,500 ft<sup>2</sup>|P||
|11.07|Restaurant > 3,500 ft<sup>2</sup>open to thepublic during10pm – 6 am|P||
|11.08|Other Restaurants > 3,500 ft<sup>2</sup>|P||
|11.09|ABC Store|P|15.66|
|11.10|Personal Service Establishments|P||
|11.11|Retail Store upto 5,000 ft<sup>2</sup>|P||
|11.12|Retail Store more than 5,000 but less than 25,000 ft<sup>2</sup>|P||
|11.13|Retail Store 25,000 ft<sup>2</sup>andgreater|L|15.21|
|11.14|Business or Professional Office|P||
|11.15|Medical Office,Category1|P||
|11.16|Medical Office,Category2|P||
|11.17|Medical Office,Category3|P||
|11.18|Medical Office,Category4|P||
|11.19|Hospital|||
|11.20|Medical EmergencyResponse|P||
|11.21|Open Air Market,Recurring|L|15.22|
|11.22|Vehicle Sales and Service|L|15.23|
|11.23|Equipment Sales and Service|L|15.24|
|11.24|Moped Sales and Service|P||
|11.25|Boat or Marine Craft Sales and Service|L|15.25|
|11.26|Impound Lot/TowingService|L|15.26|



**Packet Pg. 16**
{6}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment 7 

||**Specific Principal Use**|**B3**<br>**E1**|**E2**<br>**Reference**|
|---|---|---|---|
|11.27|Gas Station|CD||
|11.28|Car Wash|CD||
|11.29|Seasonal Retail Activities and Amusements|P||
|11.30|Electric-Vehicle ChargingStation|CD|15.65|
|**12.0 Re**|**creation & Entertainment Uses**|||
|12.01|Indoor ShootingRange|S|15.27|
|12.02|Outdoor ShootingRange|||
|12.03|Indoor Theater|P||
|12.04|Outdoor Theater|CD||
|12.05|Event Venue,Category1|P||
|12.06|Event Venue,Category2|P||
|12.07|Event Venue,Category3|P||
|12.08|Campground and Recreational Vehicle Park|L|15.28|
|12.09|Coliseum|CD||
|12.10|Recreation Facility,Category1|P||
|12.11|Recreation Facility,Category2|P||
|12.12|Recreation Facility,Category3|CD||
|12.13|Racetrack|||
|**13.0 Ag**|**riculture**|||
|13.01|Garden,Community|L|15.29|
|13.02|Garden,Residential|L|15.30|
|13.03|Agricultural Operation ExcludingLivestock|||
|13.04|Agricultural Operation IncludingLivestock|||
|13.05|Swine Farm|||
|13.06|Confined Animal FeedingOperation(CAFO)|||
|13.07|Custom Slaughterhouse|||
|13.08|Other Slaughterhouse|||
|13.09|Forestry|L|15.31|
|**14.0 M**|**anufacturing**|||
|14.01|Microbrewery/Microdistillery|L|15.32|
|14.02|Brewpub|L|15.32|
|14.03|Brewery/Distillery|L|15.33|
|14.04|Brewery/Distillery,Other||15.34|
|14.05|WineryAssociated with a Vineyard||15.35|
|14.06|Winery|L|15.35|
|14.07|Winery,Other|||
|14.08|Extraction of Earth Materials|||
|14.09|Machine/WeldingShop|L|15.37|



**Packet Pg. 17**
{7}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment 8 

||**Specific Principal Use**|**B3**|**E1**<br>**E2**<br>**Reference**|
|---|---|---|---|
|14.10|Manufacturing,Other||15.38|
|**15.0 Pa**|**rking**|||
|15.01|ParkingLot|L|15.39|
|15.02|ParkingStructure|L|15.40|
|15.03|Park and Ride Lots|L|15.39|
|**16.0 St**|**orage **|||
|16.01|Self-Storage Facilities|CD|15.41|
|16.02|Outdoor Storage||15.42|
|16.03|Warehouse|||
|16.04|Fuel Storage Facility|L|15.67|
|16.05|Chemical Storage Facility|||
|**17.0 Tr**|**ansportation**|||
|17.01|Passenger Terminals|CD||
|17.02|Truckingor freight terminal ≤ 10,000 ft<sup>2</sup>|CD||
|17.03|Truckingor freight terminal > 10,000 ft<sup>2</sup>|||
|**18.0 W**|**aste Related Uses**|||
|18.01|RecyclingDrop-off Station||15.42|
|18.02|Recyclingand Salvage||15.42|
|18.03|Junkyard|||
|18.04|Private Landfill|||
|**19.0 Pa**|**rticular Activities Which Pose Particular Concern About Public Health**|||
|19.01|Electronic and Internet Gaming|S|15.43|
|19.02|Adult Establishments|S|15.44|



###### **Excerpt of B1.02 Complete Table of Accessory Uses** 

||**Accessory Use**|**B3**|**E1**|**E2**|**Reference**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|A-1|Secondarysuite|L|||15.45|
|A-2|Home occupation|L|||15.46|
|A-3|Accessorydwellingunit|L|||15.47|
|A-4|Drive-through|CD|||15.48|
|A-5|Outdoor display|L|||15.49|
|A-6|Outdoor storage|L|||15.50|
|A-7|Outdoor dining|L|||15.51|
|A-8|Automated teller machine(ATM)|P||||
|A-9|Automated teller machine(ATM),freestanding|L|||15.52|
|A-10|Produce stand||||15.53|
|A-11|Poultry|L|||15.54|
|A-12|Livestock,small|L|||15.55|
|A-13|Livestock,large||||15.56|



**Packet Pg. 18**
{8}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment 9 

||**Accessory Use**|**B3**|**E1**|**E2**|**Reference**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|A-14|Bees|L|||15.57|
|A-15|Garden,residential|L|||15.58|
|A-16|Satellite receivingantennas less than 1 meter in diameter|P||||
|A-17|Satellite receivingantennas less than 2 meters in diameter|P||||
|A-18|Satellite receivingantennas 2 meters andgreater in diameter|S||||
|A-19|Helistop|S||||
|A-20|Swimming pools,spas,and hot tubs|L|||15.59|
|A-21|Caretaker's residence|L|||15.60|
|A-22|Vehiculargate|L|||15.61|
|A-23|Reserved|||||
|A-24|Chemical storage facility|CD||||
|A-25|Open air market,accessory|L|||15.22|
|A-26|Daycare,small|P||||
|A-27|Limited structure to enable recreational use of open rooftops|CD|||14.03.07(F)<br>14.19.06(H)(8)(d)|
|A-28|Solar EnergySystem|L|||15.64|
|A-29|Electric-Vehicle ChargingStation|L|||15.65|



###### **Excerpt of B1.03 Complete Table of Temporary Uses** 

||**Temporary Use**|**B3**|**E1**|**E2**|**Reference**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|T-1|Temporaryfamilycare structure|L|||15.62|
|T-2|Temporaryconstruction or repair dwelling|L|||15.62|
|T-3|Temporaryconstruction trailer|L|||15.62|
|T-4|Temporarymobile medical unit|L|||15.62|
|T-5|Temporaryclassroom|L|||15.62|
|T-6|Temporary portable storage containers|L|||15.62|
|T-7|Temporarystaging|L|||15.62|
|T-8|Temporarynon-fixed site event venue|L|||15.62|
|T-9|Carrier on wheels(cow)|L|||15.62|
|T-10|Yard sales|L|||15.62|
|T-11|Itinerant merchant/peddler|L|||15.62|
|T-12|Open air market,temporary|L|||15.62|
|T-13|TemporaryUse 9.01 Public Colleges and Universities|L|||15.62|
|T-14|TemporaryDisaster Relief|L|L|L|15.62|



**Packet Pg. 19**
{9}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment 10 

###### Intensity Regulations 

|**Zoning District**|**Minimum Gross**<br>**Land Area**|**Minimum Lot**<br>**Width**|**Minimum Street**<br>**Frontage**|**Minimum Livability**<br>**Space Ratio***<br>**(LSR)**|**Minimu**<br>**Street**|**m Setbacks**<br>**Interior**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|Commercial/Ind|ustrial Zoning Dist|ricts|||||
|B3|5,000 sq. ft.|50 ft.|40 ft.|.27|20 ft.|17 ft.|
|Educational Zon|ing Districts||||||
|E1|5,000 sq. ft.|50 ft.|40 ft.|.27|20 ft.|17 ft.|
|E2|5,000 sq. ft.|50 ft.|40 ft.|.27|20 ft.|17 ft.|



###### Height 

|Zone|Height Limitation|
|---|---|
|B3<br>3 st|ories/45’ (primary)-4 stories/56’ (secondary)|
|E1, E2, E3<br>3 st|ories/45’ (primary)-5 stories/67’ (secondary)|
|ccupancy<br>**Occupancy Regulation (persons per dwelling unit)**|**Zoning District**|
||1. R3 Multiple-Family|
|One family or up to 4 unrelated|2. WD Wellness District|
|Note:  a dwelling occupied by a family (but not unrelated<br>persons) may also have one (1) roomer.|3. B3 General Business<br>4. M1 Manufacturing|
||5. E2 Educational District|
||1. E1 Educational District|
|No Residential Uses Allowed|2. E3 Educational District|
||3. E4 Educational Child Daycare District|



###### Occupancy 

###### <mark>Certificate of Mailing</mark> 

I, Jane Shook, certify that individual notices meeting the requirements of Article 9 of the Town of Boone UDO were placed in the mail (first class) on January 6, 2025. 

/s/ Jane Shook, Director of Planning and Inspections 

###### <mark>Certification of Posting</mark> 

I, Darrell Pulliam, certify that the subject property was posted as required in Article 9, Subsection 9.03.03(B)(2) of the Town of Boone UDO on January 6, 2025. 

###### /s/ Darrell Pulliam, Building Code Compliance Official 

**Packet Pg. 20**
{10}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment 11 

###### <mark>Conformity to Adopted Plans: Potentially Relevant Comprehensive Plan Provisions</mark> **1.1 Overall Objectives for the Boone Comprehensive Plan (p. 15):** 

The following objectives, which have not been listed in any particular order of importance, are deliberately broad in scope and less specific than either a policy statement or an implementation action. **Economic Development:** Acknowledge the area’s natural beauty, university, and medical center presence as the Town’s greatest assets for economic development and jobs creation. Treat them accordingly. **Community Appearance and Community Character:** Blend the built environment with the natural, scenic, and historic character of a High Country small town. Especially discourage commercial strip development, cluttered signage, and “cheap” apartment buildings. 

**Open Space:** Integrate open space and greenways into the urban fabric of the Town.  Preserve the countryside by discouraging suburban sprawl.  Avoid development in floodplains, on ridgetops, and on steep slopes. 

**Trees:** Conserve existing trees and plant new trees, especially hardwoods. 

**Automobile Transportation:** Maximize the efficiency of existing facilities, but not at the expense town and neighborhood character and livability. Build or expand transportation facilities and parking areas as needed, but with care. Work to reduce auto dependency, use, and congestion. 

**Mass Transit:** Enhance and support the mass transit system as an effective alternative to the congestion created by the individual automobile. 

**Pedestrian Movement:** Encourage a system of sidewalks, paths, crosswalks and compact development patterns which make it easy to get around Boone on foot. 

**University:** Emphasize cooperative planning among the Town, County, and University. 

**Neighborhoods:** Ensure the livability of neighborhoods, especially through land use and traffic planning. 

**Public Involvement:** Encourage active public involvement and volunteerism to expand the effectiveness of community planning and action. 

**Comprehensive Plan Policies:** Staff has reviewed comprehensive plan policies, and listed those policies which in staff’s opinion have a bearing on the request.  The Commission and Council should review these policies carefully.  Each member may make his or her own interpretation as to the relevance of each and which carry the most weight thereby shaping their overall recommendation. 

**Packet Pg. 21**
{11}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment | 12 

###### **1.2 Growth Strategy Map (p. 17):** The property is located within Primary Growth Area. 



<!-- Start of picture text -->
r )<br><!-- End of picture text -->

The property is located within the Primary Growth area. The Primary Growth Area is that portion of the urban growth area where urban level or facilities are already in place or can be provided most cost effectively. This is the area where near term growth and development is to be especially encouraged. 

The Secondary Growth Area is that portion of the urban growth area where urban level services can be provided, but on a lower priority basis than in the primary growth area. 

Additionally, for comparison, the Rural Area is that portion of the planning study area that is influenced by urban area growth forces, but within which urban level development should be strongly discouraged. Urban level services and associated development densities should not be planned for this area, except in case by case evaluations of major economic development projects. 

Staff has reviewed land use and comprehensive plan policies, and listed those policies which in staff’s opinion have a bearing on the request.  The Commission and Council should review these policies carefully.  Each member may make his or her own interpretation as to the relevance of each and which carry the most weight thereby shaping their overall recommendation.  See below: 

###### **2.1 THE ECONOMY** 

###### **2.1.1 Economic Development** 

- A.  The Town shall protect and enhance a high quality of life, image, cultural amenities, and natural beauty as the most effective, long term component of an economic development strategy. 

   - A.1 Continue to evaluate and amend development regulations to help insure aesthetic quality in the area and preserve the natural beauty of the area. 

   - A.2 Adopt analytically sound, technically based hillside development regulations to preserve natural beauty. 

   - A.3 Support the Arts Council, Jones House, ASU and others in attracting quality cultural events to Boone. 

**Packet Pg. 22** Co)
{12}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment 13 

   - A.4 Balance the benefits of economic development projects with special concern for environmental quality issues. 

- D.  Economic development efforts shall encourage the revitalization and reuse of currently unused or underutilized structures, sites and infrastructure in appropriately located areas. 

- E. The Town shall encourage a public service and regulatory environment conducive to business recruitment and expansion, while at the same time enhancing the area’s physical and human resources. 

   - E.1 Continue to look for ways to make development regulations and permit procedures more predictable and timely. Evaluate opportunities for administrative review and permit issuance for development projects which, due to their small size or relatively minor impacts,  may not require review by a formal public commission or board. 

- I.  Small business start-ups, expansions and spin-offs shall be encouraged. The presence of ASU and Caldwell Community College and Technical Institute shall be recognized as a necessary and important resource for area businesses. 

###### **2.2 INFRASTRUCTURE** 

###### **2.2.2 Utilities** 

- B.  Water and sewer services shall be concentrated within the limits of a geographically defined Urban Growth Area. The Primary Growth Area shall receive first priority for the provision or enhancement of water and sewer services. 

- E.  The Town shall employ incentives to encourage a concentration of intense urban type development within the Urban Growth Area. 

###### **2.3 THE COMMUNITY** 

- A.  Urban type development within the Urban Growth Area shall meet appropriate Town standards. 

- B.  Properly planned, mixed use developments that promote efficient provision of public services shall be encouraged within the Urban Growth Area. 

- D.  Coordinated inter-governmental and university-town planning for urban area land use and development, transportation, utilities, recycling, environmental management, law enforcement, education, recreation, tourism and economic development shall be encouraged. 

###### **2.3.1 Community Appearance** 

- A.  Measures to improve the effectiveness of grading, landscaping and buffering standards for new and 

###### **2.3 THE COMMUNITY** 

###### **2.3.2 Community Character** 

- C.  Wise development of the tourism potential of the area’s architectural, historic, scenic and natural resources shall be encouraged. 

- E.  New development, redevelopment and rehabilitation of structures and sites shall occur in a manner which is consistent with the neighborhood and architectural context of the immediate area, and supportive, whenever possible, of Boone’s original community character as a High Country small town. 

###### **2.3 THE COMMUNITY** 

###### **2.3.3 Housing and Neighborhoods** 

- A.  The protection and rehabilitation of viable neighborhoods shall be encouraged to insure their continued existence as a major housing source and as a reflection of the area’s image as an attractive, highly livable community. 

**Packet Pg. 23**
{13}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment 14 

- B.  Street system designs which discourage through traffic on purely local streets while allowing for free circulation within the neighborhood shall be encouraged. 

- C.  Proposed residential development which would expose residents to harmful effects of incompatible development or to environmental hazards shall be prohibited. 

- D.  Innovative and flexible land planning and development practices shall be encouraged to create livable developments which better safeguard land, water, energy and historic resources. 

   - D.1 Continue to evaluate opportunities in the zoning ordinance for flexibly designed and located single-family and multi-family residential developments. 

   - D.2 Establish ongoing relationships with ASU’s departments of Geography and Planning, Appropriate Technology, and Sustainable Development to develop, enhance, and implement efforts toward creating affordable housing, appropriate infill development, neighborhood livability standards, and design standards for multi-family development. This should include attention to lighting, bike and pedestrian pathways, and federal, state, and local funding sources. 

- E.  Factors in determining preferred locations for high density residential development shall include: close proximity to the university, employment or shopping centers; access to major thoroughfares and the transit system; the availability of public services and facilities; and compatibility with adjacent land uses. 

- G.  Compact, full service neighborhoods, offering opportunities for living, working, shopping, and gathering places, shall be encouraged in newly planned developments, as well as for redeveloping areas. 

- H.  The overall housing unit density for proposed infill residential development or redevelopment should be compatible with the average density of existing areas. 

**Packet Pg. 24**
{14}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment 15 

###### <mark>Planning Commission Recommendations</mark> 

Per NCGS 160D-604(b), subsequent to initial adoption of a zoning regulation, all proposed amendments to the zoning regulation or zoning map shall be submitted to the Planning Commission for review and comment. If no written report is received from the Planning Commission within 30 days of referral of the amendment to that board, the Town Council may act on the amendment without the Planning Commission report. The Town Council is not bound by the recommendations, if any, of the Planning Commission.  Per NCGS 160D-604(d), when conducting a review of proposed zoning text or map, the Planning Commission shall advise and comment on whether the proposed action is consistent with any comprehensive plan that has been adopted and any other officially adopted plan that is applicable. The Planning Commission shall provide a written recommendation to the governing board that addresses plan consistency and other matters as deemed appropriate by the Planning Commission, but a comment by the Planning Commission that a proposed amendment is inconsistent with the comprehensive plan shall not preclude consideration or approval of the proposed amendment by the governing board. 

**Vote 1:** The proposed amendment to the Town’s zoning map  **is** OR   **is not** consistent with the Town’s comprehensive plan and any other adopted plan(s) of the Town that are applicable because: 

**_Note 1_** _: describe elements of controlling land use plans and how the amendment is or is not consistent._ 

###### _Note 1_ 

**Vote 2:** The Planning Commission recommends  **approval** OR  **denial** of Ordinance #A24-0081 within Exhibit A and believes  **approval** OR  **denial** is reasonable and in the public interest because: 

###### _Note 2_ 

**_Note 2_** _: briefly explain why, factors may include (i) the size, physical conditions, and other attributes of the area proposed to be rezoned, (ii) the benefits and detriments to the landowners, the neighbors, and the surrounding community, (iii) the relationship between the current actual and permissible development on the tract and adjoining areas and the development that would be permissible under the proposed amendment; (iv) why the action taken is in the public interest; and (v) any changed conditions warranting the amendment._ 

**Packet Pg. 25**
{15}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment 16 

<mark>Town Council Action - Adoption of Ordinance</mark> 

Per NCGS 160D-605, when adopting or rejecting any zoning text or map amendment, the Town Council shall approve a brief statement describing whether its action is consistent or inconsistent with an adopted comprehensive plan. The requirement for a plan consistency statement may also be met by a clear indication in the minutes of the governing board that at the time of action on the amendment the governing board was aware of and considered the planning board's recommendations and any relevant portions of an adopted comprehensive plan. If a zoning map amendment is adopted and the action was deemed inconsistent with the adopted plan, the zoning amendment shall have the effect of also amending any future land-use map in the approved plan, and no additional request or application for a plan amendment shall be required. A plan amendment and a zoning amendment may be considered concurrently. 

**Vote 1:** The proposed amendment to the Town’s zoning map  **is** OR   **is not** consistent with the Town’s comprehensive plan and any other adopted plan(s) of the Town that are applicable because: 

**_Note 1_** _: describe elements of controlling land use plans and how the amendment is or is not consistent._ 

_Note 1_ 

**Vote 2:** The Town Council  **approves** OR  **denies** and believes  **approval** OR  **denial** of Ordinance #A24-0081 in Exhibit A is reasonable and in the public interest because: 

_Note 2_ 

**_Note 2_** _: briefly explain why, factors may include (i) the size, physical conditions, and other attributes of the area proposed to be rezoned, (ii) the benefits and detriments to the landowners, the neighbors, and the surrounding community, (iii) the relationship between the current actual and permissible development on the tract and adjoining areas and the development that would be permissible under the proposed amendment; (iv) why the action taken is in the public interest; and (v) any changed conditions warranting the amendment._ 

**Packet Pg. 26**
{16}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0081 App State General Use Zoning Map Amendment 17 

<mark>Exhibit A – Ordinance A24-0081</mark> 

###### **Ordinance A24-0081** 

WHEREAS, pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. §160D-601, the Town may amend its zoning map after giving proper public notice and holding a public hearing; and 

WHEREAS, the Planning Commission and Town Council has received the request to amend the Official Zoning Map of the Town of Boone, North Carolina to rezone 21.83 acres of a 77.63-acres parcel from B3 General Business to E2 Educational. 

Address: Mountaineer Ridge Drive Watauga County PIN:  2910-02-7414-000 Property Owner: Board of Trustees of the Endowment Fund of Appalachian State University 

WHEREAS, the Boone Town Council held a duly-noticed public hearing January 27, 2025 with respect to this rezoning request; and 

WHEREAS, the Boone Town Council has taken into full consideration any information offered at the public hearing; and 

WHEREAS, this Town Council has reviewed the written recommendations of the Town of Boone Planning Commission; and 

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED as follows: 

**SECTION 1** . The Boone Town Council hereby approves and adopts the modifications to the Town Zoning Map as set forth herein. 

**SECTION 2** . All provisions of any Town ordinance in conflict with this ordinance are hereby repealed to the extent of such conflict. 

**SECTION 3** . This Ordinance shall be effective immediately upon its adoption by Town Council. 

Adopted this the 26th day of February, 2025. 

###### **The Honorable Tim Futrelle, Mayor** 

**Attest:** 

**Nicole Harmon-Church, Town Clerk** 

**Packet Pg. 27**
