{0}------------------------------------------------
**Staff Report January 22, 2024 Case A24-0011 Town Utility Facility Modification -UDO Text Amendment Request** 

Modify language in UDO Article 14 Zoning District clarifications to provide clarification on the permitting requirements for Use 5.13 Town Utility Facilities. 

This modification would allow that town utility facility related improvements, to be exempt except in specific circumstances from zoning requirements due to the overall public benefit of these improvements. These improvements may include but are not limited to: communication towers, equipment/material storage areas/buildings, pump stations, salt barns, or other similar facilities that are not typically open to the public. 

## **CONFORMITY TO ADOPTED PLANS** 

## **COMPREHENSIVE PLAN UPDATE** 

## **1.1 Overall Objectives for the Boone Comprehensive Plan** 

The following objectives, which have not been listed in any particular order of importance, are deliberately broad in scope and less specific than either a policy statement or an implementation action. 

**Economic Development:** Acknowledge the area’s natural beauty, university, and medical center presence as the Town’s greatest assets for economic development and jobs creation. Treat them accordingly. 

**Community Appearance and Community Character:** Blend the built environment with the natural, scenic, and historic character of a High Country small town. Especially discourage commercial strip development, cluttered signage, and “cheap” apartment buildings. 

**Open Space:** Integrate open space and greenways into the urban fabric of the Town.  Preserve the countryside by discouraging suburban sprawl.  Avoid development in floodplains, on ridgetops, and on steep slopes. 

**Environmental Quality:** Address and monitor growth factors and activities that contribute to water, air, light, and noise pollution. 

**Trees:** Conserve existing trees and plant new trees, especially hardwoods. 

**Bikeways:** Implement the planned system of bikeways as a legitimate transportation alternative. Unify with greenways and other pedestrian facilities where possible. 

**Pedestrian Movement:** Encourage a system of sidewalks, paths, crosswalks and compact development patterns which make it easy to get around Boone on foot. 

**Infrastructure:** Engage in long range planning for water and sewer systems, stormwater runoff, natural gas, and other utility systems. Place overhead utilities underground whenever feasible. 

**Public Safety:** Maintain a high level of policing and fire protection and plan the expansion of public safety services to coincide with projected population increases and identified needs. 

**Energy and Waste:** Reduce waste generation, and the consumption of energy and water. Develop area recycling programs to the fullest. Encourage an anti-litter consciousness among residents and visitors. 

**Downtown:** Support and enhance the cultural and historic significance of downtown Boone, and affirm its appealing, pedestrian orientation. 

**Packet Pg. 42** [
{1}------------------------------------------------
**Case A24-0011 Town Utility Facility Modification -UDO Text Amendment** | **2** 

**Neighborhoods:** Ensure the livability of neighborhoods, especially through land use and traffic planning. **Public Involvement:** Encourage active public involvement and volunteerism to expand the effectiveness of community planning and action. 

**Comprehensive Plan Policies:** Staff has reviewed land use and comprehensive plan policies, and listed those policies which in staff’s opinion have a bearing on the request.  The Commission and Council should review these policies carefully.  Each member may make his or her own interpretation as to the relevance of each and which carry the most weight thereby shaping their overall recommendation. 

## **COMPREHENSIVE PLAN POLICIES** 

## **2.1 THE ECONOMY** 

## **2.1.1 Economic Development** 

- A.  The Town shall protect and enhance a high quality of life, image, cultural amenities, and natural beauty as the most effective, long term component of an economic development strategy. 

   - A.1 Continue to evaluate and amend development regulations to help insure aesthetic quality in the area and preserve the natural beauty of the area. 

… 

- E. The Town shall encourage a public service and regulatory environment conducive to business recruitment and expansion, while at the same time enhancing the area’s physical and human resources. 

   - E.1 Continue to look for ways to make development regulations and permit procedures more predictable and timely. Evaluate opportunities for administrative review and permit issuance for development projects which, due to their small size or relatively minor impacts,  may not require review by a formal public commission or board. 

- … 

**Packet Pg. 43**
{2}------------------------------------------------
**Case A24-0011 Town Utility Facility Modification -UDO Text Amendment** | **3** 

## **PLANNING BOARD REPORT/RECOMMENDATIONS** 

Per NCGS 160D-604(b), subsequent to initial adoption of a zoning regulation, all proposed amendments to the zoning regulation or zoning map shall be submitted to the Planning Commission for review and comment. If no written report is received from the Planning Commission within 30 days of referral of the amendment to that board, the Town Council may act on the amendment without the Planning Commission report. The Town Council is not bound by the recommendations, if any, of the Planning Commission.  Per NCGS 160D-604(d), when conducting a review of proposed zoning text or map, the Planning Commission shall advise and comment on whether the proposed action is consistent with any comprehensive plan that has been adopted and any other officially adopted plan that is applicable. The Planning Commission shall provide a written recommendation to the governing board that addresses plan consistency and other matters as deemed appropriate by the Planning Commission, but a comment by the Planning Commission that a proposed amendment is inconsistent with the comprehensive plan shall not preclude consideration or approval of the proposed amendment by the governing board. 

**Vote 1:** The proposed amendment to the Town’s zoning ordinance  **is** OR  **is not** consistent with the Town’s comprehensive plan and any other adopted plan(s) of the Town that are applicable because: 

_**Note 1** : describe elements of controlling land use plans and how the amendment is or is not consistent._ 

_Note 1_ 

**Vote 2:** The Planning Commission recommends  **approval** OR  **denial** of Ordinance A24-0010 within Exhibit A and  **approval** OR  **denial** is reasonable and in the public interest because: 

## _Note 2_ 

_**Note 2** : briefly explain why, factors may include (i) the size, physical conditions, and other attributes of the area proposed to be rezoned, (ii) the benefits and detriments to the landowners, the neighbors, and the surrounding community, (iii) the relationship between the current actual and permissible development on the tract and adjoining areas and the development that would be permissible under the proposed amendment; (iv) why the action taken is in the public interest; and (v) any changed conditions warranting the amendment._ 

**Packet Pg. 44**
{3}------------------------------------------------
**Case A24-0011 Town Utility Facility Modification -UDO Text Amendment** | **4** 

## **TOWN COUNCIL ACTION – Adoption of Ordinance** 

Per NCGS 160D-605, when adopting or rejecting any zoning text or map amendment, the Town Council shall approve a brief statement describing whether its action is consistent or inconsistent with an adopted comprehensive plan. The requirement for a plan consistency statement may also be met by a clear indication in the minutes of the governing board that at the time of action on the amendment the governing board was aware of and considered the planning board's recommendations and any relevant portions of an adopted comprehensive plan. 

**Vote 1:** The proposed amendment to the Town’s zoning ordinance  **is** OR   **is not** consistent with the Town’s comprehensive plan and any other adopted plan(s) of the Town: _**Note 1** : describe elements of controlling land_ 

_**Note 1** : describe elements of controlling land use plans and how the amendment is or is not consistent. Town Council members may reference the comprehensive plan policies in the Planning Commission’s recommendations, or use the other comprehensive plan policies as the Council member see relevant and pertinent to the_ 

_Note 1_ 

**Vote 2:** The Town Council  **approves** OR  **denies** Ordinance #A24-0010 to the Town’s zoning ordinance and believes  **approval** OR  **denial** is reasonable and in the public interest because: 

_case._ _**Note 2** : briefly explain why, factors may include (i) the size, physical conditions, and other attributes of the area proposed to be rezoned, (ii) the benefits and detriments to the landowners, the neighbors, and the surrounding community, (iii) the relationship between the current actual and permissible development on the tract and adjoining areas and the development that would be permissible under the proposed amendment; (iv) why the action taken is in the public interest; and (v) any changed conditions warranting the amendment._ 

_Note 2_ 

**Packet Pg. 45**
{4}------------------------------------------------
**Case A24-0011 Town Utility Facility Modification -UDO Text Amendment** | **5** 

|**ORDINANCE # A24-0010**|
|---|
|**AN ORDINANCE TO REVISE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE RELATING TOWN UTILITY FACILTIES**|
|WHEREAS**,**the Boone Town Council desires to modify the requirements for town utility facilities,|
|and|
|WHEREAS, the Boone Town Council held a duly-noticed public hearing on January 22, 2024 with|
|respect to this ordinance; and|
|WHEREAS, the Boone Town Council has taken into full consideration any information offered at|
|the public hearing; and|
|WHEREAS, this Town Council has reviewed the written recommendations of the Town of Boone|
|Planning Commission; and|
|WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that it is in the best interest of the Town and its citizens that|
|Town Council directly consider and, with input from the public as deemed appropriate by Council; and|
|WHEREAS, the Boone Town Council is authorized to enact this Ordinance pursuant to its zoning|
|authority under G.S. Chapter 160D, Article 6;|
|**NOW THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOONE TOWN COUNCIL THAT:**|
|**SECTION 1**.<br>The Town of Boone Unified Development Ordinance (“UDO”) is hereby revised as set|
|forth in the attached**Exhibit A**to this Ordinance, which is incorporated by reference, with|
|deletions and additions shown in~~red~~ andbluerespectively:|
|**SECTION 2**.<br>All provisions of any Town ordinance in conflict with this ordinance are hereby repealed|
|to the extent of such conflict.|
|**SECTION 3**.<br>In the event any section, subsection, subdivision, paragraph, subparagraph, item,|
|sentence, clause, phrase or word of this ordinance is declared or adjudged to be invalid|
|or unconstitutional, such declaration or adjudication shall not affect the remaining|
|provisions of this ordinance, which shall remain in full force and effect as if the portion so|
|declared or adjudged invalid or unconstitutional was not originally a part of this|
|ordinance.|



**SECTION 4** . This Ordinance shall be effective immediately upon its adoption by Town Council. 

Adopted this the 14th day of February, 2024. 

**The Honorable Tim Futrelle, Mayor** 

**Attest:** 

**Nicole Harmon, Town Clerk** 

**Packet Pg. 46**
{5}------------------------------------------------
**Case A24-0011 Town Utility Facility Modification -UDO Text Amendment** | **6** 

## **Exhibit A** 

**Article 14 Districts and Uses** 

… 

## **14.02.03 Uses Not Requiring Development Approvals** 

- **A.** Notwithstanding any other provisions of this ordinance, no zoning-related permit is required for the following uses: 

   1. Public streets, sidewalks, or greenways. 

   2. Electric power, telephone, telegraph, cable television, gas, water and sewer lines, wires or pipes, together with supporting poles or structures, located within a public right-of-way with the permission of the public owner. 

   3. Town utility facilities located within the Town’s right-of-way or on Town property ~~with the permission of the Town;~~ _provided_ , that if the proposed Town utility facility would materially exceed or contravene a ~~ny~~ otherwise- ~~a~~ pplicable development standard relating to setback o ~~r,~~ height ~~, size, intensity of use~~ , or standards related to a Historic District ~~s~~ or a Historic Landmark ~~s,~~ or would require issuance of a Certfcate of Appropriateness in the absence of this provision, then in any such case (i) the Administrator shall notify the Town Council and Town Council may direct that a hearing be held to solicit public comment with respect to the proposed ~~facility~~ utlity facility; and (ii) if the parcel at issue is in or adjoins a historic district or historic landmark, the Administrator shall present the proposal to the Historic Preservaton Commission so that the HPC may provide such advice or recommendatons to the Town Council as the HPC sees ft. For clarifcaton, Town utlity facilites remain subject to the requirements of 15.16. 

   4. Electric vehicle charging stations installed on Town property or the public right-ofway. 

… 

## **15.16 Utility Facility** 

**15.16.01** Utility facilities in or adjoining residential zoning districts must maintain district setback, be fenced (unless totally enclosed within a structure), and either be screened from view or designed to have a residential appearance. 

**15.16.02** Equipment producing noise or sound may not exceed 60 decibels at any adjoining property line. 

**Packet Pg. 47**
{6}------------------------------------------------
**Case A24-0011 Town Utility Facility Modification -UDO Text Amendment** | **7** 

|**Use #**|**Specific Use**|||||||||||**Zoning**|**Districts**|**Districts**|**Districts**|**Districts**|**Districts**|||||||**Reference**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|||**Low Density**<br>**Residential**||||**Medium to High Density**<br>**Residential**|||||||**Commercial/Industrial**||||||||||||
||||||||**Residential**|||||||||||||**Education**|||||
|||**RA**|**R1**|**R1A**|**RR**|**R1S**|**R2**|**R4**|**MH**|**R3**|**R5**||**B1D**<br>**C**|**B1DI**|**B2**||**W**<br>**D**|**M1**|**U1**|**E1**|**E2**|**E3**|**E4**||
|||||||||||||**OI**||||**B3**|||||||||
||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|**5.0 Government Uses**|||||||||||||||||||||||||
|5.01|Government Cultural<br>Facility|||||||||||P|P|P||P|||||||||
|5.02|Government Neighborhood<br>Cultural Facility, Indoor<br>ActivityOnly|S|S|S|S||S|S||||P|P|P|P|P|||||||||
|5.03|Government Neighborhood<br>Cultural Facility, Includes<br>Outdoor Activity|||||||||||P|P|P||P|||||||||
|5.04|Recreation Facility,<br>Category1|P||||||||P||P|P|P|P|P||P|||||||
|5.05|Recreation Facility,<br>Category2|P|P|P|P||P|P||||P|P|P|P|P||P|||||||
|5.06|Recreation Facility,<br>Category3|PT50|S|S|S||S|S||P||PT50|PT50|PT50|PT50|PT50||PT50|||||||
|5.07|Event Venue, Category 1||||||||P|P||P|P|P|P|P|||||||||
|5.08|Event Venue, Category 2||||||||S|S||P|P|P|P|P|||||||||
|5.09|Event Venue, Category 3|||||||||||PT50|PT50|PT50|PT50|PT50|||||||||
|5.10|Landfill|||||||||||||||||S|||||||
|5.11|Solid Waste Processing|||||||||||||||||S|||||||
|5.12|Police Substation|P|P|P|P||P|P||||P|P|P|P|P||P|||||||
|5.13|Utility Facility, Town|L|L|L|L|L|L|L||||L|L|L|L|L||L||||||15.16|
|5.14|Utility Facility,<br>Government,<br>Neighborhood|L|L|L|L|L|L|L|P|P||L|L|L|L|L||L||||||15.16|
|5.15|Utility Facility,<br>Government,Regional|LT300|||||||L|L||LT300||||LT300||LT300||||||15.16|
|5.16|Government Facility|P|||||||L|L||P|P|P|P|P||P|||||||



**Packet Pg. 48**
{7}------------------------------------------------
**Packet Pg. 49**
{8}------------------------------------------------
**Case A24-0011 Town Utility Facility Modification -UDO Text Amendment** | **9** 

## **Article 34 Definitions** 

## … 

## **Event Venue, Category 1** 

A facility for meetings and gatherings, such as reunions, weddings, conventions, anniversaries, and other similar ceremonies take place within fully enclosed buildings. 

## **Event Venue, Category 2** 

A facility providing outdoor space for meetings and gatherings, such as reunions, weddings, conventions, anniversaries, and other similar ceremonies which take place between 6 a.m. and 10 p.m. 

## **Event Venue, Category 3** 

A facility providing outdoor space for meetings and gatherings, such as reunions, weddings, conventions, anniversaries, and other similar ceremonies, in which any portion takes place between 10 p.m. and 6 

a.m. 

## **…** 

## **Government Cultural Facility** 

A building owned or operated by a government entity in which objects of interest or performances in the fine arts, humanities, or sciences are displayed, preserved or presented for exhibition or education of the general public. 

## **Government Neighborhood Cultural Facility** 

A government cultural facility which does not exceed 5,000 square feet. 

## **…** 

## **Government Facility** 

A building, structure, or use of land, excluding the other uses specifically listed in Government Uses 5.0, operated by a governmental entity that is used to provide government services such as administration of a political subdivision of the State, or centralized operations of cultural resources, fire protection, law enforcement, planning and zoning, public utilities or public works. 

## **…** 

## **Landfill** 

A government facility for the disposal of solid waste in or on land authorized by N.C. Gen. Stat. Chapter 130A Article 9 of the North Carolina General Statutes. 

## **…** 

## **Recreation Facility, Category 1** 

A facility in which regularly scheduled recreation activities take place within completely enclosed buildings. 

## **Recreation Facility, Category 2** 

A facility providing outdoor space in which regularly scheduled recreation activities take place, and which does not utilize outdoor event lighting. 

**Packet Pg. 50**
{9}------------------------------------------------
**Case A24-0011 Town Utility Facility Modification -UDO Text Amendment** | **10** 

## **Recreation Facility, Category 3** 

A facility providing outdoor space in which regularly scheduled recreation activities take place, and which utilizes outdoor event lighting. 

## **…** 

## **Solid Waste Processing** 

A solid waste management facility permitted by the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources that receives municipal solid waste for processing or treatment. 

## **…** 

## **Utility Facility** 

Any above-ground structures or facilities other than buildings, unless such buildings are incidental to the operation of such structures or facilities operated by a public utility as authorized by North Carolina law and used in connection with the production, generation, transmission, delivery, collection, or storage of water, sewage, electricity, gas oil, or electronic signals (other than use category 7.0 Telecommunication Uses).  Excepted from this definition are utility lines and supporting structures such as electric power, telephone, telegraph, cable television, gas, water and sewer lines, and wires or pipes located within public right-of-way authorized by the appropriate government entity pursuant to Section 14.02.03(A)(2). 

## **Utility Facility, Government** 

A utility facility owned or operated by a government entity other than the Town. 

## **Utility Facility, Neighborhood** 

Utility facilities that are designed to serve the immediately surrounding neighborhood and for reasons associated with the purpose of the utility in question must be located in or near the neighborhood where such facilities are proposed to be located. 

## **Utility Facility, Regional** 

All utility facilities other than neighborhood facilities. 

## **Utility Facility, Town** 

Any ~~above-ground structure, or~~ use of land ~~owned or operated~~ by the Town ~~and used i~~ n connection with the town’s public enterprise and/or public works operatons, including water supply, sewer, stormwater, and street/sidewalk maintenance. ~~the producton, generaton, transmission, delivery, collecton, or storage of water, sewage, stormwater or electronic signals.~~ This includes but is not limited to: communicaton towers, equipment/material storage areas/buildings, pump statons, salt barns, or other similar facilites that are not typically open to the public.  Any uses that comes within the purview of another use in 5.0 Government Use (i.e. government facility, police substaton, government facility, etc.) shall be governed by the terms of that use and not as a town utlity facility. 

… 

**Packet Pg. 51**
