{0}------------------------------------------------
Exhibit 1 

## **Staff Report August 12, 2025** 

## **Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Work** 

Table of Contents Request ......................................................................................................................................................... 1 Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................... 2 Parcel Information ........................................................................................................................................ 3 Recent Zoning History ................................................................................................................................... 4 Zoning Analysis (B1 Downtown Interface) .................................................................................................... 4 Architectural Survey/Designation Report Information ................................................................................. 6 Inventory Classification ............................................................................................................................. 6 Designation Report ....................................................................................................................................... 6 Architectural Survey ...................................................................................................................................... 7 Library of Congress - Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps ................................................................................... 10 Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook Analysis ................................. 10 Narrative ................................................................................................................................................. 10 Design Standards for Residential Properties .......................................................................................... 10 “Residential Property” Defined............................................................................................................... 10 Design Standards for Historic Streetscapes, Landscapes, Monuments, and Other Resources in the District .................................................................................................................................................................... 18 Automatic Conditions of Approval .............................................................................................................. 23 Historic Preservation Commission Procedure ............................................................................................ 23 Historic Photos ............................................................................................................................................ 24 Request 

The Town of Boone has submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Work for 150 Clay House Dr (WT0530 R. L. Clay House), designated as a Historic Landmark within the Town of Boone, for the renovation of the accessory building for the addition of ADA accessible restrooms. Work includes upgrading and installing water and sewer lines, adding ADA-accessible restrooms to the interior of the building, repairing the exterior of the building where needed, installing ventilation systems to the interior of the building, repairing stairs located at the back of the building that leads to the upstairs storage area, and reinforcing the floor in the upstairs storage area. The subject property is outlined in green on the Zoning Map included below. 

Pursuant to UDO Article 8, required by Subsection 8.03.01 and the Table of Minor Work and Major Work located in Subsection 8.05.03 and Appendix D, an applicant is required to obtain a Certificate of 

**2**
{1}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **2** 

Appropriateness (COA) for the modification of an accessory building to the non-tertiary elevation visible from a public street. 

_**Staff Notes**_ can be found throughout the report marked in _**bold green italicized text**_ . 

Zoning Map 

2 | P a g e 

**3**
{2}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **3** 

Parcel Information 

**Address:** 150 Clay House Dr **Property Owner:** Town of Boone **Watauga County Pin:** 2900-78-3934-000 **Lot Size (Total):** 0.26 ac **Jurisdiction:** Town Of Boone **Access:** Clay House Dr (Private) **SFHA:** No 

**Watershed District:** No **Corridor District:** No **NCD:** No **Viewshed:** No **Steep Slope:** No **Current Zoning:** B1 Downtown Interface with Historic Landmark Designation 

The B1 Downtown Core, together with the B1 Downtown Interface District encompass the Town of Boone’s downtown area and represent, in large measure, the remaining vestiges of the Town’s historic character. Regulations in these districts are intended to preserve and maintain a small town, high country atmosphere. Preservation and adaptive reuse of existing historic buildings are encouraged and new construction shall be appropriately scaled to be sympathetic to the existing built environment. Design and regulatory standards for these districts reinforce the character of the downtown as a pedestrian friendly area by encouraging architectural solutions that are visually interesting, and are compatible in scale and character to the surrounding area. To help accomplish this, the area is divided into two (2) districts, each with its own character and scale which contribute to the overall vitality of the downtown area. Identification of the districts is listed below: 

1. B1 Downtown Core District: The Downtown Core District is the center of the downtown area and contains the greatest concentration of historic commercial buildings. This district establishes a continuous building facade at the street frontage to strengthen the identity of downtown as a pedestrian destination where pedestrians feel comfortable through the careful selection of building materials, human scale design, and ground floor fenestration. Standards in this district reinforce the historic nature of the existing built environment through regulation of appearance, height, scale and mass. 

2. B1 Downtown Interface District: The Downtown Interface District serves as a gateway into the downtown area and as the transition between the B1 Downtown Core District and adjacent zoning districts. Development in this district must be sensitive to issues of compatibility with the Downtown Core District as well as surrounding zoning districts, many which are low-density residential. 

3 | P a g e 

**4**
{3}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **4** 

The Historic Landmark designation is where local governments may designate individual properties as historic landmarks and groups of properties as historic districts because of their historical, pre-historical, architectural, or cultural significance. To qualify for designation, a property or area must also show integrity of design, setting, workmanship, materials, feeling, or association. Integrity enables a property or area to convey its significance to the observer; it mainly has to do with the intactness of the property’s physical features. 

_**Staff Note: After the designation of a landmark, no exterior portion of any building shall be erected, altered, restored, moved, or demolished within such district until after an application for a Statement of Conformity (SOC) for minor work or a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) for major work has been approved. A COA may be issued subject to any reasonable conditions necessary to carry out the purposes of Article 8 and is required whether or not a building or other permit is necessary. Where requirements conflict, overlay district standards supersede.**_ 

|**Zoning**|**& Use of Adjacent Properties**||
|---|---|---|
||**Adjacent Zoning**|**Adjacent Land Use**|
|North|R1 Single Family Residential / Conditional<br>District B1 Central Business|Single familyhomes / Apartments|
|East|B1 Downtown Interface / R3 Multi-Family<br>Residential|Retail / Apartments|
|South|R1 Single FamilyResidential|Single familyhomes|
|West|R1 Single FamilyResidential|Single familyhomes|



Recent Zoning History 

- **06-26-2024** Ordinance A24-0107, A24-0109, and A24-0110 amended the Town of Boone’s zoning map to adopt the Local Historic Landmark overlay on three parcels, 2900-78-3934-000, 290079-0308-000, and 2900-69-9070-000, located at 150 Clay House Drive. 

- **06-10-2025** Approval for a Certificate of Appropriateness Case A25-0169 – Rivers House Trail on adjacent parcels that are part of the landmark designation for the addition of trailhead signage and construction of an aggregate surfaced trail. 

## Zoning Analysis (B1 Downtown Interface) 

The following UDO requirements must be met for the proposed project, unless superseded by any requirements of the Downtown Boone Local Historic District overlay. A zoning and building permit will be required prior to the commencement of the project to show compliance with all regulations. 

4 | P a g e 

**5**
{4}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **5** 

The proposed use, 5.01 Government Culture Facility, is permissible by right in the B1 Downtown Interface district. 

## **UDO References to Appearance Standards:** 

Per UDO Subsection 14.19.06(A) the B1 Downtown Core and the B1 Downtown Interface Zoning districts are located within the Central Fire District which is regulated by the most recent edition of the NC Building Code. Applicants will be required to submit sufficient information during the zoning permit process for Staff to determine compliance of the proposed development with the requirements of the Central Fire District. 

Per UDO Subsection 14.19.06(I)(3) distinctive or historic materials, features, finishes, construction techniques or examples of building craftsmanship of a building shall be retained and preserved. The removal of distinctive materials or alteration of features, spaces and spatial relationships that characterize a property shall be prohibited. 

Per UDO Subsection 14.19.06(I)(5) applicants shall identify, retain and preserve wood features that are important in defining the overall historic character of the building (such as, but not limited to: siding, cornices, brackets, window and door surrounds, and steps) and their paints, finishes and colors. 

Per UDO Subsection 14.19.06(I)(7) deteriorated historic features shall be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement of a distinct feature, the new feature will match the old in design, color, texture, and where possible, materials. Missing features will be substantiated by documentary and physical evidence and shall only be replaced with new materials that match the existing historic material in composition, size, shape, texture, pattern, color and detail. 

Per UDO Subsection 14.19.06(I)(8) materials that are not visually compatible with the original façade, such as shiny metals, mirror glass, plastic panels, and vinyl windows or doors are prohibited, unless they can be documented through historic images or similar documentation. 

Per UDO Subsection 14.19.06(I)(13)(a-d) for Exterior Doors when renovating an existing building the original exterior doors historic to the building shall be repaired and retained and the reuse of historic hardware and locks is encouraged. The renovations to facades shall retain recessed door areas or recreate recessed door areas, if historically appropriate, to the extent practicable. Renovations which require new doors or replacement of doors on the primary or secondary facades shall meet the standards set forth in UDO Subsection 14.19.06(H)(3)(e) which for the Downtown Core states all entrance doors on the primary and secondary facades shall be made of a solid wood frame and must be architecturally compatible/sympathetic with the storefront of the building. 

Per UDO Subsection 25.06.04(B)(1) acceptable exterior materials are brick, stone, or wood and per UDO Subsection 25.06.04(D)(2) asphalt shingles are acceptable roof materials. 

_**Staff Note: The repair and replacements suggested in the scope of work is compliant with these standards in that all material is to be similar to existing, a zoning permit would be required prior to work beginning to verify all details in relation to material, colors, and landscape. The Fire Marshal has reviewed the application and approved with no comments. Public Works has reviewed the application and the noted requirement is that a double check backflow will need to be installed, verification of this installation would be required by the permit and must be complete prior to receiving a Certificate of Occupancy.**_ 

5 | P a g e 

**6**
{5}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **6** 

Architectural Survey/Designation Report Information 

The following three documents are central to the Downtown Boone Local Historic District: 

1. Comprehensive Architectural Survey of Downtown Boone, NC – Final Report 

2. Report and Recommendation for the Designation of the Downtown Boone Local Historic District, Boone, NC 

3. Downtown Boone Local Historic District Standards 

The designation report (#2 above), was created using the architectural survey of the downtown area (#1 above) and recommended the Downtown Boone Local Historic District area be designated as a historic overlay district; and the Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards, which are outlined in a separate document (#3 above), are to be applied by the HPC when it considers applications for Certificates of Appropriateness for proposed development within the historic district. 

## **Inventory Classification** 

The following information has been taken from the designation report starting on page 69.   The property inventory found within the report was specifically written to assess the contributing significance and integrity of the district’s resources. Integrity, as determined was based upon the following: 

1. design integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to its original appearance or altered appearance during the period of significance; 

2. material integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to original materials during the period of significance or replacement materials that mimic the appearance of original materials during the period of significance; 

3. locational integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to its original location during the period of significance; 

4. integrity of association, meaning the building’s relationship to its original or adapted use, function, and purpose during the period of significance; and 

5. integrity of relationship to the district as a whole, meaning the building’s historical importance to the development of downtown Boone’s commercial district during the district’s four periods of growth within the period of significance (1918-1964). 

## **Inventory Classifications:** 

- **CA:** Contributes to the character of the district based on architectural significance 

- **CH:** Contributes to the character of the district based on historical significance related to events or individuals associated with the property 

- **NC:** Non-contributing property 

- **VL:** Vacant lot 

Designation Report 

The full Architectural Survey summary is included below. 

_**Staff Note: The subject property was designated as a Historic Landmark and is not part of the Historical District Overlay thereby the parcel is not classified in the Designation Report.**_ 

6 | P a g e 

**7**
{6}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **7** 

Architectural Survey 

## **WT0530 R.L. Clay House (1933)** 

150 Clay House Dr. 

This is an update to the 1988 survey of this property and the 2002 survey update. Please note that the 2002 survey update incorrectly states that the house is no longer standing, and the 1988 survey incorrectly identified it as the Rob Rivers House (Rivers was a later owner). Because the original architectural description is quite brief and lacking in essential details, this resurvey provides a more exhaustive account of the house and its significance. 

According to past surveys, an African-American contractor, “Mr. Simpson,” built the house in the late 1930s for Robert Luther (R. L.) Clay (1889-1945), the former Linville River Railway station agent (early 1930s) and deputy tax collector (mid to late 1930s) at Boone. Clay had moved his prior home—a frame structure demolished in 2015—down the hill toward Moretz Drive to accommodate the new construction. Newspaper accounts actually confirm a construction date of 1933 for the R. L. Clay House, with the June 29, 1933, issue of the Watauga Democrat reporting that Clay “is engaged in the construction of a native stone house.” Frequent newspaper updates occurred throughout the year, with the Democrat reporting in December 1933 that the house was complete. Past attributions to Simpson have never been sourced, however, and African-American members of the local Junaluska community insist that John L. (“J. L.”) Hickerson (circa 1889-1938), who was listed in the 1930 Census as a brick mason working and living in Boone Township, completed the stonework at the R. L. Clay House. Indeed, Hickerson was credited in the June 14, 1934, issue of the Watauga Democrat with completing the masonry work on a stone dwelling being erected for Ed Luttrell in Shulls Mills, with W. G. Hartzog as the general contractor. Hickerson’s obituary indicated that he “had resided in Boone for the past 17 years, where he had the highest respect of the white population. He and his crew of workmen had erected the walls of almost all the newer brick structures of the town” (“John Hickerson Dies on Sunday,” Watauga Democrat, October 13, 1938, 1). 

R. L. Clay sold the house in early 1945 to R. C. Rivers, the editor and publisher of the Watauga Democrat and owner of the Rivers Publishing Company. The house remained in the Rivers family until October 1998, when Rachel Rivers-Coffey and her husband Paul Armfield Coffey donated the house and related, adjacent family lands to the Town of Boone. A tenant, Jim Butler, remained in the house under a life estate until his death in November 2011, but the house has been vacant for the past several years. Deed restrictions limit future uses of the property and the house to “recreational purposes, green space, [underground utility line easements], flood mitigation, a wildlife sanctuary, and historical purposes.” The Boone Historic Preservation Commission has already identified the site for potential local historic landmark designation. 

The R. L. Clay House is a one and a half-story, side-gabled, natural cut stone home that is three bays wide and built to face present-day Rivers Street. Access to the property is via a long, circuitous driveway, known as Clay House Drive, off of Moretz Drive to the southeast. The property retains a one and a half-story, two bay garage, also of natural cut stone, that is located at the end of Clay House Drive and just to the southeast of the house. Walkways, outside stairwells, retaining walls, and curbing throughout the property are also of natural cut stone and apparently part of the original landscaping plan. The roof of the house until recently was composed of asbestos shingles designed to resemble slate, but these were probably not original. They were removed in 2015 and replaced with more traditional asphalt shingles. 

7 | P a g e 

**8**
{7}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **8** 

The house and garage are encircled in all directions by two parcels that are historically associated with the Rivers and Clay families. The smaller parcel located to the southeast (2900-78-3881-000) was donated to the Town of Boone by Paul Armfield Coffey in 2004. This parcel originally contained the small frame house that appears to have been the R. L. Clay house that previously stood on the 1933 R. L. Clay house site, but was moved in 1933 to make way for construction of the newer stone building (Watauga Democrat, June 1, 1933). This house was burned, then demolished by the Town of Boone on May 30, 2015, as part of a firefighting training exercise after attempts to sell or relocate the house failed. 

The second, larger parcel (2900-69-9070-000) is located to the north, west, and south of the house and contains what was once the horse pasture (now overgrown) for Rachel Rivers-Coffey’s horses. This land appears to have also been in the Clay family’s ownership for a number of years. This parcel contains Baby, a gargantuan sugar maple that is on the North Carolina Register of Big Trees. There is a wrought iron fence surrounding the tree and a large plaque on the southwest fence that states that Baby is a North Carolina Champion Big Tree. Also on this parcel, at the northeast corner, is the Daniel Boone Monument (WT0971), which was reconstructed at this location in the early 2000s. The Town of Boone owns three additional, adjacent parcels to the northwest along Poplar Grove Road, two of which were also donated by Paul Armfield Coffey with similar deed restrictions as those attached to the main house property. 

The north (front) façade of the R. L. Clay features an irregular, front-gabled porch entrance that is reached by stone steps with stone cheek walls. The entrance to the porch features a flat arch lintel with a gothicstyle light above, and the interior of the porch includes a stone bench on the east side of the porch with two rectangular window openings on either side of the porch and wood weatherboard for the interior porch ceiling. The main entrance features a twelve-light, wooden door, which is covered by an aluminum screen door. Immediately to the east of the porch is a prominent, exterior, stone chimney with alternating steps that narrow the chimney as it rises. The chimney includes a pronounced concrete cap with brick piers at its four corners. Further to the east of the chimney and porch on the first floor is a double set of six-over-six, double-hung sash windows with a wooden surround, aluminum storm windows, and stone sills. Beyond this to the east, the first floor of the north elevation opens to a square, interior porch with stone flooring and walls and a wooden weatherboard ceiling, with all of it anchored to the footprint of the house by a stone column at the northeast corner of the porch. The porch includes one wooden doorway along the interior south wall at the southwest corner of the porch, with another similar door at the same corner along the west wall of the porch. Both are covered with aluminum screen doors. To the north of the second door, still on the west wall of the porch, is a single, six-over-six, double-hung sash, wooden window with a wooden surround, a stone sill, and an aluminum storm window covering it. Another gothic light fixture hangs at the center of this interior porch space. Two basement-level vents are visible under each window grouping of the north elevation. 

The west side of the north elevation has a triple bay of six-over-six, double-hung sash, wooden windows with a wooden surround and a stone sill. All three are covered with aluminum storm windows. The second floor of the north elevation, meanwhile, features two projecting, symmetrically spaced, gabled dormers, each clad in weatherboard on their sides and what appear to be shingles on the gable fronts; this shingle material may be of asbestos that has since been painted. The dormers themselves, meanwhile, include prominent cornice returns, with double sets of six-over-six, double-hung sash, wooden windows with wooden surrounds and aluminum storm windows over them. Small vents are visible just below the apexes of these dormer gables. 

The first floor of the west elevation, reading from north to south, is primarily of native stone and includes a single, six-over-six, double-hung sash, wooden window with a wooden surround, a stone sill, and an 

8 | P a g e 

**9**
{8}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **9** 

aluminum storm window covering, followed a short distance to the south by an identical window. Near the center of the elevation, but offset slightly to the south, is a smaller, double window group of six-oversix, double-hung sash, wooden windows with a wooden surround, stone sill, and aluminum storm window coverings. A short distance to the south of this is a single window that is otherwise identical to those found in the double window grouping. Just above this window, the south end of the gable roofline abruptly evens out to accommodate an enclosed porch along the south elevation. The small, west portion of this porch includes another double set of windows identical to those at the center of the west elevation, with a small amount of the same asbestos shingle treatment visible between the tops of the windows and the roofline, while the bulkhead below the windows is parging over an unknown material (possibly concrete block). At ground level are three basement vents with stone lintels and stone window wells. The second floor of the west elevation, meanwhile, includes a double set of windows at an intermediate size between the small and large examples found elsewhere on the west elevation, but otherwise identical in their design and treatment. This set is centered underneath the west gable. The roofline of the west gable, meanwhile, includes an aluminum, boxed soffit that sports an oddly shaped cornice return only at the northwest corner of the house. 

The south elevation of the house, meanwhile, is irregularly shaped. Reading from west to east, the first floor of the south elevation is dominated by the three-season porch that runs nearly to the center of the back of the house. This porch continues the parged bulkhead treatment, with a centered, four-light door with an aluminum storm door over it, flanked by double sets of windows like those found on the west elevation of this porch. For reasons that are not clear, the roofline of this porch steps down near its junction with a second floor window, perhaps in an effort to prevent blocking that window. The east return wall of this rear porch, meanwhile, repeats the asbestos shingling for a short distance below the roof slope, with the bulkhead treatment taking up the whole east return wall. At its base is a set of stone steps with a stone stairwell wall leading down to a basement door with an aluminum storm door. Above this, along the main body of the house is a double set of large, six-over-six, double-hung sash, wooden windows with a wooden surround, stone sill, and aluminum storm windows. Above this, the second floor of the main block of the house reads as a wide dormer. At its center is a medium-sized, double window grouping otherwise identical to those found elsewhere, with a single window of similar size just to the west, over the aforementioned, stepped-down porch roof. A much smaller window, also otherwise identical, is visible to the east of this centered, double window group. This wide dormer features wooden weatherboard on the west and east sides of the dormer. A stone, interior chimney rises from a high point of the south-facing roof at a junction with the west side of the south dormer, while another interior chimney rises from the east side of the south-facing roof, separated by a short distance from the south dormer. Back at the first floor level is another projection at the southeast corner of the house, with a small, single, one-over-one, horizontal light, wooden window with a stone sill and aluminum storm window over it on the west elevation of this projection, while a large, single window like most of the others on the house is centered on the south elevation of this southeast projection. Along this south elevation of the house, about ten feet from the back of the house, is a long, stone retaining wall that runs parallel with the house to a set of stone steps with a stone cheek wall and an iron railing just beyond the southwest corner of the house. This retaining wall continues a short distance, parallel with the west elevation of the house. 

The first floor of the east elevation, moving from south to north, includes a large window like those found elsewhere, followed a short distance to the north by a large, double window group like those found elsewhere. A short distance to the north of this is a set of stone steps with stone cheek walls on each side and an iron railing along the top of the north cheek wall. This set of steps leads to the aforementioned open, interior porch at the northeast corner of the house. The second floor of the east elevation, 

9 | P a g e 

**10**
{9}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **10** 

meanwhile, features a medium-sized, double set of windows identical to those on the west elevation, centered below the gable. A boxed, aluminum soffitt terminates in prominent cornice returns at both ends of the roofline. Leading away from the porch steps, meanwhile, is a cut stone pathway, with the iron railing continuing along its length. This terminates at a step down to the asphalt driveway, which is itself bounded on its west and south sides by a low, stone retaining wall. 

At the southeast end of this driveway is a detached, front-gabled, one and a half-story, two car garage of cut stone. Its north elevation includes the two symmetrically spaced, garage bay doors of vertical wood slats, with a large, six-over-six, double-hung sash, wooden window with wooden surround and stone lintel centered beneath the gable. The roofline includes an aluminum, boxed soffitt that terminates in prominent cornice returns. The west and east walls of the garage are essentially featureless stone, while the south elevation, which is built partially into the grade, includes a set of wooden steps rising to the upper level of the garage, which is accessed via a wooden door with a deep wooden surround. The roofline on this gable end also includes an aluminum, boxed soffitt that terminates in prominent cornice returns. 

## Library of Congress - Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps 

The Library of Congress has made Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps from 1928 and 1947 accessible. As these years fall within the historic district’s period of significance (1918-1964), these maps will be used when the property in question, or area of the property in question, can be viewed within these maps. The content of the Library of Congress online Sanborn Maps Collection is in the public domain and is free to use and reuse. 

_**Staff Note:  The R. L. Clay House is located southwest of Rivers Street and is outside of the viewable areas detailed on the Sanborn Fire Insurance Map, thus it is not included on the Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps.**_ 

Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook Analysis 

## Narrative 

Relevant design standards from UDO Appendix D, Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook, Design Standards for COMMERCIAL/RESIDENTIAL Properties within the District, are outlined below.   These Standards for COMMERCIAL/RESIDENTIAL properties are intended to address many of the most common issues to arise during renovations, additions, and new construction in the District. Where the Standards are silent on a particular issue or concern, the HPC will rely upon the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation to guide their review of the proposed work under the COA process and any subsequent recommendations. 

Design Standards for Residential Properties 

“Residential Property” Defined 

A **residential property** within the District is any property whose purpose-built function at the time of construction was to serve solely as a residence for long-term (greater than 30 days) occupants. Such properties may include single-family homes, single-family residences with an accessory purpose, apartment homes, condominiums, or apartment complexes that were built strictly for apartment living without a mixed-use component in any other part of the building. 

10 | P a g e 

**11**
{10}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **11** 

Buildings within the District that meet this definition include, but may not be limited to, the John Walter Jones House (WT0008), the Watauga County Jail (WT0067), the Frank A. Linney House (WT0582), the Stanley A. Harris Apartment House (WT0805), the Terrace Apartments (WT0809), the J. M. and Ida Moretz House (WT0810), the A. E. and Roberta Hodges House (WT0818), the Dr. H. B. Perry Building (WT0844), the Chapell Wilson/B. G. Teams House (WT0845), and the G. F. and Josie Critcher House (WT0876). 

## **1. Architectural Components and Details** 

Exterior architectural components, including door and window casings, columns, brackets, porch railings, soffits, fascias, roof configurations, trim details, architectural flourishes, and various joinery and surface patterns, all contribute significantly to the character and historical integrity of properties located within the District. Because many of these components are either irreplaceable or very expensive to reproduce, they should be maintained and valued in the same way that one might consider an important family heirloom or expensive antique furniture. In many cases, missing or damaged architectural details can be replaced with like items from salvage yards, antique shops, or mail order companies that specialize in replacement of historic architectural components. If such items cannot be replaced, many construction supply companies stock simulations of period architectural components that are approved by the Secretary of the Interior and the National Park Service as suitable historic replacements. In any event, before replacing any exterior architectural component, property owners should familiarize themselves with the architectural style and historic characteristics of their building to avoid introduction of inappropriate elements. 

- 1.1 It is important to preserve historical architectural features of exterior walls, such as cornices, friezes, medallions, sunbursts, brackets, bays, turrets, fascias, and decorative moldings. Original architectural details should always be retained if structurally feasible, even if portions of the original material are damaged or deteriorated to a point requiring replacement. 

- 1.2 It is NOT appropriate to remove rather than repair or replace in kind such features when they are deteriorated. If replacement is necessary, the new materials should match the materials being replaced in composition, design, texture, color, and other visual qualities. 

- 1.3 It is NOT appropriate to cover or replace historic materials with substitute materials, such as aluminum, vinyl, fiber cement board siding (or similar materials simulating the appearance of wood), or plywood panels. Architectural details that are not appropriate to the historic context and character of a building should never be added. At the same time, property owners should never use details from an earlier period to try to make a building look older than it is. 

## **2. Foundations** 

For most property owners, the foundation of their historic residential property will consist of either piers of masonry or a complete masonry wall on the perimeter of the structure as well as interior piers for support and a sill plate connecting the perimeter wall with the rest of the house. In some cases, masonry walls have been added between original masonry piers on the perimeter of the foundation. 

Settling—sometimes of an inch or more—is quite common and should be expected in a historic property, often in an uneven or disproportionate manner along the entirety of the foundation. Settling also typically cracks mortar joints. For this reason, it is part of routine maintenance to periodically repoint mortar joints and inspect for more severe settling problems. In some cases, property owners will need to consult with a masonry contractor or civil engineer to correct serious settling problems. A number of less expensive 

11 | P a g e 

**12**
{11}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **12** 

and fairly common repair tricks are inappropriate for historic properties and can actually cause further damage to the historic fabric and integrity of the property. 

- 2.1 Whenever a foundation requires repairs, always use the original bricks or stones if possible. If these materials are damaged beyond repair, replace them with bricks or stones similar in size, color, and surface texture to the originals. If using recycled bricks, always put the weathered side to the exterior in order to maintain the historic appearance of the foundation walls and/or piers. 

- 2.2 In repairing or reconstructing a foundation, the historic bond patterns and mortar treatments should always be replicated. Brick header or rowlock rows, soldier or sailor courses, bandboards, water tables, driplines, and other horizontal design elements should match and align with the existing historic elements. 

- 2.3 Sandblasting, painting, waterproofing, and parging—a technique of applying a cement-like coating to a deteriorating foundation in order to avoid repairs—should never be employed on the exposed portions of foundation exteriors, as all of these treatments damage original masonry and mortar treatments. In addition, non-porous applications trap moisture that can freeze, cause further damage to masonry, and result in damage to the interior of the home. 

- 2.4 Exposed concrete block and cast concrete are strongly discouraged, unless these components are already part of the historic context of the property in question. Such treatments are somewhat common in the District and should be left intact if original, rather than covered over. 

- 2.5 If closing in the openings between brick piers, use matching masonry materials or lattice that is slightly recessed from the façade plain of the historic masonry. Note that foundations need to be vented. Vents should be painted a color that blends with the existing foundation color. 

- 2.6 Access doors to basements or foundation crawlspaces should always be located in an area not visible from the street unless a different historic configuration that aligns with the building’s historic context already exists. 

## **3. Masonry** 

Many residences in the District are composed of brick or stone masonry, and it is imperative that original masonry materials—many of which have a weathered appearance reflecting the history of the building— remain preserved whenever possible. For this reason, masonry should never be cleaned unless it is determined that perceived “dirt” is actually accumulated deposits and not the effects of weathering. If cleaning is pursued, always use the gentlest method available, preferably with low-pressure water, a mild, non-caustic detergent, and a natural bristle brush where needed. In addition, while repointing is sometimes necessary when mortar is missing or moisture problems have developed, it should only be completed in a manner that avoids smearing the mortar onto the surface of the masonry. 

- 3.1 It is NEVER appropriate to paint masonry materials, such as brick, concrete block, cast concrete, or stone, that were historically unpainted, including masonry associated with foundations. If there is historic precedent for painting of masonry in the building’s original historic context, it should be 3completed using colors that can be documented with original historic photographic evidence or analysis of original paint samples. 

Removal of non-historic paint from masonry can be challenging and problematic, and doing so requires strict adherence to preservation guidance published by the National Park Service. 

12 | P a g e 

**13**
{12}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **13** 

Generally speaking, such work should be completed by a professional trained in historic preservation methods and using a chemical paint remover specifically intended for masonry and the gentlest application means possible. In some instances, inappropriately applied paints may not be removable without damaging the underlying masonry, so it is always advisable to test removal techniques in an area that is not easily visible to the public. The HPC will provide guidance in such instances on the best approach to addressing unusual paint removal challenges. 

- 3.2 Whenever feasible, historic masonry should be repaired rather than replaced or covered. When replacement is necessary, it should always be completed using traditional materials of like kind and quality to the originals that are being replaced. 

- 3.3 Repointing of masonry should also be completed using materials that duplicate the existing mortar in appearance, texture, and color. Colored sands or mineral pigmented mortar can be used to achieve a match with the existing mortar. Portland cement should be avoided in mortar, as it may produce a mortar that is stronger than the surrounding masonry, potentially causing the masonry to crumble. 

- 3.4 Unless there is a specific reason for using waterproof or water-repellent coatings (e.g., brick that has previously been sandblasted, creating a porosity problem), these treatments should be avoided, as they can accelerate deterioration of historic masonry. 

- 3.5 When repairing or replacing masonry or mortar, take care to maintain the alignment, bond pattern, joint spacing, color, texture, and size of the original masonry. 

- 3.6 Unless there is historic precedent for its use on the building in question, stucco should never be applied to existing masonry walls, as it can trap moisture that accelerates the deterioration of the masonry. If existing stucco is being repaired, the stucco mixture should duplicate the original appearance, color, and texture as closely as possible. 

- 3.7 Masonry should never be treated with abrasive stripping methods, sandblasting, or highpressure water cleaning, as these methods almost always immediately damage the “skin” of the brick and the mortar joints, and they can make the masonry more susceptible to spalling, or flaking of the masonry surface as a result of the introduction of moisture. Masonry should only be cleaned using the gentlest method available, including low pressure water, soft natural brushes, and, if necessary, non-abrasive, non toxic chemicals that will not damage the masonry being treated. 

- 3.8 Spalled masonry should never be repaired using cement infills or other patchwork repairs that will only further degrade the historic materials and alter the historic appearance of the building. Instead, spalled or delaminated bricks should be replaced with a similar brick stock or salvaged historic brick that matches the original in color, size, and appearance. New mortar joints should match the originals in color, composition, texture, and method of application. 

- 3.9 All historic masonry architectural features, including cornices, moldings, chimneys, and other decorative flourishes, should be retained as they are integral to the architectural character and integrity of the building. 

13 | P a g e 

**14**
{13}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **14** 

- 3.11 Proper maintenance of masonry is essential to its long-term survival. Property owners should conduct periodic checks for moisture problems and cracking, and they should remove any vegetation that adheres to masonry (such as ivy and other vine plants) or that hinders ventilation and drainage around masonry elements. Vegetation should never be sprayed with defoliants, pesticides, or other harsh chemicals. Please consult with the Planning and Inspections Department for guidance on removal of vegetation on masonry. 

## **4. Siding and Trim** 

Wooden siding is probably the most commonly found material on residential properties in the District. Traditional historic forms of siding include clapboards, weatherboard, shiplap, drop siding, flush siding, and board-and-batten siding. In some rare cases, wood shingles may also be found. 

Maintaining wood siding is essential to the preservation of the historic property on which it appears. In addition to repairing and/or replacing damaged siding members, it is imperative that a regular maintenance program be in place in order to protect the integrity of historic properties that feature siding. This program should include routine caulking and sealing, cleaning, and painting. 

- 4.1 The use of artificial siding (vinyl, aluminum, asphalt, asbestos, Masonite, pressboard, etc.) to cover original siding is not permitted in the District because it destroys the integrity of historic properties. Beyond covering up original architectural details, its installation damages the historic materials underneath, and the artificial siding itself often traps moisture that can lead to further damage of the historic materials. Because it covers historic natural materials, it can also hide the natural critters—termites, carpenter ants, mold, and fungus—that can damage those historic natural materials. In some very rare instances, some forms of artificial siding may be original to the property. Where this does occur, the original siding material should be maintained and repaired whenever possible. 

- 4.2 The original form, details, and materials of exterior walls and trim should be preserved whenever feasible. If damage is present, repair using existing historic materials is always preferable over replacement. If replacement is necessary, replacement materials should duplicate the form, details, texture, size, shape, color, pattern, and composition of the historic wall surface and should be obtained from salvage or antique suppliers. Only the portion that requires replacement should be replaced. The HPC will consider the use of substitute materials ONLY if the historical material is not technically feasible or is no longer available. 

- 4.3 Because its use is not historic to Boone’s residential historic districts, artificial bark siding is not permitted. 

- 4.4 Wood elements that were traditionally stained, such as cedar shingles, should never be painted, as this destroys the historic appearance and integrity of the building. 

- 4.5 Whenever possible, the removal of non-historic artificial siding and trim materials to uncover or facilitate the restoration of original historic siding and trim details is strongly encouraged. 

- 4.6 Historic architectural metals, such as pressed tin, aluminum, and cast or wrought iron, should always be retained. If these items are not repairable due to rust or other deterioration, replacement materials should duplicate the form, details, texture, material, size, shape, color, pattern, and composition of the original. When cleaning of architectural materials is 

14 | P a g e 

**15**
{14}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **15** 

necessary, use the gentlest methods possible, such as water, a gentle, non-caustic soap, and soft bristle brushes. 

## **5. Windows, Doors, and Awnings** 

The arrangement of doors and windows on an historic property is one of the most important elements of building design. It is imperative that these arrangements be preserved in order to maintain the integrity of individual historic properties and the integrity of the District. Because older windows and doors were not always designed with heating and cooling efficiency in mind, it is often tempting to property owners to replace these features with modern doors and windows. Despite the apparent advantages of doing so, replacement with modern doors and windows is often far more expensive than repairing existing historic doors and windows, and their use often completely destroys the integrity of the historic property in question. Furthermore, many companies are now producing “modern” wood replacement windows that replicate the appearance of their historic antecedents with fixed muntins but feature double-pane glass to assist with heating and cooling efficiency. The HPC reviews proposals for the use of modern wood replacement windows carefully to insure that muntin thickness aligns with the muntin dimensions of historic windows. 

- 5.1 The pattern, arrangement, location, size, and shape of windows and doors contribute significantly to a building’s historic character, and their consistency within the district helps unify the buildings in context to one another. For this reason, it is always preferable to repair damaged windows and doors rather than replacing them. Furthermore, it is imperative that the fenestration pattern of the door and window openings on the building and of the doors and windows themselves (muntin width, number of lights per sash, etc.) be maintained when repairs to or replacement of elements is underway. It is never appropriate to introduce new features, such as vents, bays, windows, or door openings, in exterior walls if they diminish the historic character of the wall or damage historic materials. 

- 5.2 Whenever possible, the original window and door hardware should be preserved and maintained, as these components are also vital elements of historic properties. 

- 5.3 Whenever possible, other original window and door elements, such as sashes, glass, sills, frames, casings, weather-stripping, lintels, architraves, and shutters, should be repaired rather than replaced. This includes sidelights and fanlights on both doors and windows, which are vital architectural elements that help identify the style and period of a particular property. Snap-in muntins are not historically accurate and should always be avoided. 

- 5.4 Unless restoring the appearance of a building to its original, historic context, the pattern, arrangements, and dimensions of doors and windows on principal elevations should be retained. On tertiary elevations not visible from the street, new door or window openings should be proportionate to existing ones and include matching design elements. 

- 5.5 Reflective or tinted glass is not historically accurate to the District or its historic properties and should never be used. 

- 5.10 Raw metal storm windows and doors are not appropriate. When possible, interior storm windows are encouraged. Avoid poorly designed interior storm windows that can trap moisture between the storm window and the original window, causing damage to historic materials. If exterior storm windows and/or doors are installed, frames should be painted wood or painted or baked enamel finish aluminum. 

15 | P a g e 

**16**
{15}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **16** 

## **7. Entrances, Porches, and Balconies** 

One of the most significant and defining characteristics of residential architecture is the main or front entrance, including any porches that surround or frame that entrance. In Boone, the front porch was also often one of the most socially important areas of a home—a place where hosts greeted their guests and where neighbors often exchanged news and stories with one another. Unfortunately, main or front entrances are also often the most altered elements of historic properties. 

Many historic entrances, porches, and balconies contain architectural elements that are essential to communicating the architectural style of the home. Machine-carved balustrades, spindles, brackets, and posts were common in many of the District’s historic homes, but hand-worked elements were also not uncommon. Preserving these details is vital to preserving the appearance and integrity of the District’s historic domestic architecture. 

- 7.1 Entrances, porches, and balconies, as used in this section, include front (primary elevation), side (secondary elevation), and rear (tertiary elevation) porches, mudrooms, porticos, sleeping porches, balconies, pergolas, terraces, widow’s walks, and entrances. Components of porches include steps, balustrades, columns, trellises, skirt boards, fascias, brackets, and various ornamental details. Most original porches and balconies were built with a slight pitch away from the residence to facilitate the runoff of rainwater. 

- 7.2 Because of their architectural significance, porches, balconies, and entrance configurations— especially those on the front or main elevation— and all of their architectural details (steps, balustrades, brackets, spindlework, columns, roofs, etc.) should be preserved in their original form and detail whenever possible. It is inappropriate to enclose porches and balconies on the front or main elevation for use as an interior space. In addition, the original pitch of porches and balconies should be maintained in order to facilitate the runoff of rainwater and snowmelt. Porches and balconies must be properly maintained and repaired as necessary, as they are exposed to the weather and will deteriorate if regular maintenance is not conducted. 

- 7.3 If an historic porch or balcony is completely missing (or if architectural elements associated with the porch or balcony are missing), it should be replaced with a reconstruction based on accurate historic documentation or a new design that is appropriate for the building in terms of architectural style, materials, roof form, details, scale, size, and ornamentation. Adding details that are not historical to create a false historical appearance is never appropriate. 

- 7.4 If an historic porch or balcony requires repair or replacement of original materials, use only materials that are compatible with the original materials associated with the porch or balcony. These replacement materials should match the previously existing historic materials in composition, size, shape, texture, pattern, color, and detail. 

- 7.5 Whenever possible, existing, non-historical enclosures of and additions to historic porches and balconies should be removed and the original appearance of the porch or balcony restored. 

- 7.6 Side and rear porches (i.e., not located on the primary elevation) may be enclosed for interior space, provided that the proposed design of the enclosure is compatible with the architecture of the historic property and the enclosure is reversible. Side porches and rear porches not located on the main elevation may also be screened, provided that framing for 

16 | P a g e 

**17**
{16}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **17** 

the screening and the screening itself is placed behind columns or balustrades. Any such enclosures or screening should be designed so that they can later be removed without damage to the integrity of the historic structure. 

- 7.7 Original porch steps should always be retained. If repair or replacement of porch step materials is necessary, the design, configuration, dimensions, and materials should match the original as closely as possible. In addition, historic stairways and walkways that are part of the landscape around a building—even though not technically part of the building’s architecture— are nevertheless an important part of the landscape that accompanies the property and often informs the architectural style and patterns of the property. These elements should always be retained and repaired with appropriate materials whenever possible. 

- 7.8 Decks may be added on the rear (tertiary) elevation of a historic property, provided their addition does not require the removal of large, healthy trees, and their design is compatible in scale with the historic property. They should always be designed and installed in such a manner that they may be removed without damage to the historic building. Removal of historic building materials to facilitate the installation of a deck is never acceptable. 

- 7.9 Vegetative screening should be employed to obscure the visibility of decks from the street. The underside of decks should also employ latticework or vegetative screening to incorporate the deck element into the general whole of the building in question. 

- 7.10 Floor coverings, such as artificial turf, indoor/outdoor carpeting, linoleum, and other similar materials (aside from a small doormat near an entrance) should never be installed on porch, balcony, or deck floors, as these materials can trap water and damage the historic architectural elements below. 

## **9. Utilities and Energy Retrofit** 

Updating utilities and energy systems in historic homes is a common and natural event in the life of a house. As technology improves and environmentally friendly mechanical systems become more readily available, many homeowners will desire to improve the efficiency of their historic homes. The HPC encourages the installation, rehabilitation, or replacement of mechanical systems—in compliance with local building codes and utility company standards—with systems that will improve the overall efficiency of those properties. That said, these mechanical systems, when installed in or on an historic property, must comply with certain essential standards. 

- 9.1 Install utilities and mechanical equipment in areas and spaces that will require the least possible alteration to the plan, materials, and appearance of the building. Installation at the rear (tertiary elevation) of the building, if feasible, is preferred. 

- 9.2 It is NOT appropriate to locate mechanical equipment farther forward on the property (i.e., toward the street facing the primary elevation) than the midpoint of the primary building. 

- 9.3 Ductwork, piping, fuel tanks, plumbing vents, solar collectors, and satellite dishes should not be visible from the street. Equipment that can be seen from the street should be screened with shrubbery or fencing. 

- 9.4 If an interior location is not feasible, place utilities and mechanical equipment and conduit in inconspicuous locations and/or conceal with architectural elements such as downspouts. 

17 | P a g e 

**18**
{17}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **18** 

- 9.5 The location of solar collectors or solar panels should be aligned on the building’s roof in the direction of greatest effectiveness with a minimized view of such equipment from the primary elevation of the structure. 

## **10. Accessibility, Health, and Safety Considerations** 

Modern building codes and/or the needs of the families who own and live in historic properties often mean that a variety of accessibility and safety elements must be installed in those properties. Careful planning ensures that the integrity of historic properties can be maintained in spite of the addition of these non-historic elements. 

- 10.1 New exterior fire escapes are not permitted on historic properties unless more adequate exit facilities cannot be provided. If they must be installed, fire escapes generally should be located at the rear (tertiary elevation) of the building and never along an elevation visible from an adjacent street. 

- 10.2 Introducing items such as wheelchair ramps, fire exits, and fire stairs without damaging the character of a historic structure requires careful planning. Owners should introduce fire exits, stairs, landings, and ramps on rear (tertiary elevation) or inconspicuous side (secondary elevation) locations. If access ramps must be installed in a manner that makes them visible from the public right-of-way, they should be constructed in a manner that makes them as simple and compact as possible and limits their projection from the building. 

- 10.3 Construct fire exits, stairs, landings, and ramps in such a manner that they do not damage or significantly obscure historical materials and features. Such additions should be designed to be complementary to the architectural style, materials, scale, and function of the historic property. 

- 10.4 Whenever possible, existing exterior fire escapes and stairways that are not original to historic properties should be relocated from front or exposed elevations to a rear or unexposed elevation. 

Design Standards for Historic Streetscapes, Landscapes, Monuments, and Other Resources in the District 

## **1. Streetscapes** 

In contrast to the natural elements around which communities are often organized, historic streetscapes instead represent the built environment that defines the character, context, and components around which a community grows and evolves. Typically, buildings are the most obvious and dominant streetscape features, but this type of landscape includes other elements, including the spaces between buildings, private yards, alleyways and streets, sidewalks and other pedestrian elements, lighting, fences, public benches, retaining walls, monuments, public art, and street signage. 

With regard to all streetscapes in the District, the following standards should be observed: 

- 1.9 Existing historic block patterns, setbacks, and other land divisions—both natural and created—should be maintained. 

- 1.10 When necessary, prune or remove and replace trees that threaten public safety, utilities, or property. When considering new plantings near existing utilities, select historically appropriate, native species that will not interfere with the utility when they reach mature height. 

18 | P a g e 

**19**
{18}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **19** 

- 1.15 Materials, architectural features, and entrance orientations of all historic buildings associated with historic streetscapes should be preserved and maintained. Non-historic architectural features, including promenades, porches, and other additions to buildings intended to create an imagined “mountain village” appearance that is not an accurate reflection of the District’s historic buildings and streetscapes, should be removed and/or altered to more accurately reflect the context and history of Boone’s streetscapes. When possible, public-private partnerships, including programs like the Main Street Façade Grant program, should be utilized to restore historic streetscape features. 

- 1.16 Historic accessory structures, such as garages, sheds, and other outbuildings, should be preserved and maintained in situ. Deteriorating buildings should be repaired using salvaged materials that match existing ones. When repair of accessory structures is not possible, only those accessory structures for which there is sufficient historic documentation should be reconstructed using materials and configurations similar to the original structure. 

## **3. Landscapes and Ecologically Sensitive Areas** 

Boone has a number of inconspicuous but nevertheless historic landscape features in the District, ranging from the open land surrounding the Frank A. Linney House on King Street to the ancient sugar maple trees located on the Jones House property. Because the proponents of expanding development rarely stop to consider the importance of these kinds of landscape features and their links to Boone’s history, it is essential that the Town of Boone have a comprehensive set of standards for the treatment of these valuable historic resources. 

Landscape features, regardless of whether they consist of formally planned, human-constructed gardens or naturally evolving woodlands and meadows in the community, are essential to maintaining and preserving the character, aesthetic appeal, and history of the District. Evaluating and preserving the integrity of such existing features and their historical significance requires documentation with historic images, maps, and other data. As with architecture, the preservation and restoration of historic landscape features is always preferred over elimination or replacement, but when the integrity of an existing feature is seriously compromised, new features should be designed to be compatible with the historic context of the District and simultaneously identifiable as a new feature rather than as an attempt to recreate the old. 

Some of these historic landscapes are essential to understanding the settlement patterns of our community. As the Town of Boone and the educational institution now known as Appalachian State University grew rapidly during the early twentieth century, for example, the landscape along Boone Creek evolved rapidly from its pastoral origins. While much of this historic landscape to the north of Rivers Street has been compromised by modern development, especially in relationship to the University, pockets in the District still remain. Among these are the warehouse areas positioned directly along the north side of the creek, south of Howard Street from just west of Burrell Street to the vicinity of Appalachian Street While this may seem an unlikely example of an historic landscape, the wholesale removal of these buildings and the burial of Boone Creek underground—which has occurred in many other areas of Boone along Boone Creek and other tributaries—would erase this natural resource and the settlement patterns associated with it from Boone’s tangible past. 

It is important to maintain landscaping details that enhance the character of the District. Additions to landscaping such as fences, lighting, garden art, and streetscape furniture should be in accordance with the surrounding environment. The purpose of the landscaping standards is to regulate the planting and preservation of landscape material; to promote the general health, safety, and welfare of the community; 

19 | P a g e 

**20**
{19}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **20** 

to facilitate the creation of an attractive environment; to protect property values; to further the urban design and economic development of the community; and to encourage skilled installation and continued maintenance of all plant materials. 

Regarding ecologically sensitive areas and natural areas, the Town of Boone has seen dramatic development over the past fifty years, much of which has adversely impacted the stream corridors flowing through the District as well as once-forested and open areas in the community. As a result, the remaining ecologically sensitive and natural environments within the Town’s limits are valuable resources, especially in the context of the Town’s urban environment. Contrary to the public perception when the occasional flooding rainstorm visits Boone, these areas actually help slow and filter rainwater and runoff, improve air and water quality, provide natural habitat, and offer aesthetic contributions to the community. In addition, some of these natural areas offer essential clues to the settlement history of Boone and the ways in which its natural resources have been utilized for the better part of two centuries. 

Accordingly, the following standards should be followed in an effort to maintain these vital resources: 

- 3.1 Maintain mature street trees. When removal or replacement is warranted, replace with historically appropriate, indigenous cultivars that will thrive at the site and that will achieve a similar canopy and street edge definition at maturity. 

- 3.2 Use plant materials that are indigenous to the District. New plant material should complement those found on the site and in the District. 

- 3.3 Retain and maintain landscape elements that contribute to the character of the District such as mature trees and hedge rows, grassy lawns, foundation plantings, paver materials, ground covers, fountains, outbuildings, and gardens. 

- 3.6 Maintain the relationship between building mass and open space that exists on the block or streetscape. Property owners should preserve the historic spatial arrangements and landuse patterns within the District as they have changed over time, and they should strive to protect character-defining elements of both constructed and natural landforms, including the topography and open spaces surrounding historic buildings and landscape features. 

- 3.13 In cooperation with property owners within and bordering historic landscapes and ecologically sensitive areas, the Town of Boone will encourage historically appropriate tree plantings of indigenous species, especially within parks and along stream corridors; maintain appropriate recreational trails through ecologically sensitive areas and public parks in order to increase public awareness of and participation in the preservation of these areas and to discourage the misuse of these areas; and monitor the condition of trees and other plantings within natural areas, public parks, and along streetscapes to track and prevent the encroachment of diseases and pests. 

## **4. Fences and Garden Walls** 

- 4.1 Required street trees shall be planted outside of the sight triangle area, as regulated by UDO Subsection 31.02.02. For detailed descriptions of screening regulations, see the Town of Boone UDO. 

- 4.2 Preserve historic fences and garden walls. Preservation requires continual maintenance and repair. A sound paint surface is essential to maintaining and protecting wooden and iron fences. On wooden fences, seal all joinery to avoid moisture damage. To prevent rust and corrosion on iron fences, clean surfaces with a wire brush to remove all loose paint and rust, 

20 | P a g e 

**21**
{20}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **21** 

   - then prime immediately with high quality metal primer before the finish coat is applied. Corrosion will occur whenever metal is left unpainted. Brick and masonry walls are vulnerable to uneven ground settling and mortar failure due to weather exposure and vegetation. Resist the tendency to allow plants such as ivy to grow on brick walls as the plants will trap moisture and cause deterioration. 

- 4.4 Retain and preserve all character-defining features of historic fences and walls including gates, decorative pickets, finials, and hardware. 

- 4.5 Repair rather than replace historic fence and wall materials. If replacement is necessary, replace only those sections in need of replacement. Match the original in composition, height, scale, proportion, color, texture, material and design. 

- 4.6 Design new fences that are compatible with the associated building, site, and streetscape in terms of composition, height, scale, proportion, color texture, material and design. Fences and walls based on historic designs are encouraged. New designs that meet the aforementioned criteria are also acceptable. 

- 4.7 Use fences or walls in a manner that is historically appropriate such as for demarcating property lines and screening private areas from the public right-of-way. 

- 4.8 Use walls and hedgerows in the District to screen parking lots. A masonry wall or single species evergreen hedge will maintain the sense of an “edge” to the streetscape in a similar manner as a building. The peripheral screen will also hide wheels, bumpers, and paving, thereby eliminating the undesirable aspects of the automobile while at the same time not jeopardizing safety. 

- 4.9 Avoid the use of utilitarian fences along primary elevations of buildings. 

## **5. Garages and Accessory Buildings:** 

- 5.1 Original structures should be retained and preserved if at all possible. 

- 5.6 It is inappropriate to introduce features and details to an outbuilding that will create a false sense of historic development. For example, it would be inappropriate to add Art Deco features using historic materials to a newly constructed accessory building, as doing so might inappropriately suggest that the accessory building was constructed during the 1930s. 

## **10. Parks and Public Spaces:** 

The District is also home to several parks and public spaces frequently utilized for community events in addition to their intrinsic pastoral and aesthetic purposes. Such locations include the Jones House property and Jimmy Smith Park, among others. Because these areas see a high volume of public traffic, they create a special challenge for protection, preservation, and maintenance by the Town and, in some cases, their private owners. 

The Town of Boone and its residents should observe the following standards in managing these important cultural landscapes: 

- 10.1 Preserve historic landscape features that are critical to site identity and form, including landforms, topography, roadways, pathways, trails, trees and other plantings (both natural and planned), fences, and other resources. 

21 | P a g e 

**22**
{21}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **22** 

- 10.2 Preserve and protect significant views into, out of, and within parks and public spaces. Carefully weigh the impact on both visitors and nearby residents and businesses when adding or removing landscape features, trails, walkways, and roadways. 

- 10.3 Preserve, protect, and maintain significant primary and accessory structures, including pavilions and fountains, that are essential to the identity of the cultural landscape. When planning new accessory structures, including monuments, public art, interpretive signage, memorials, and similar features, weigh their potential impact on historic views associated with the park and the general character and aesthetics of the public space in its historic context. Necessary accessory structures used for service purposes (maintenance sheds, restrooms) should be as unobtrusive as possible and designed to blend into the park’s historic landscape. 

22 | P a g e 

**23**
{22}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **23** 

Automatic Conditions of Approval 

The following conditions are automatically included and a part of any approval. 

- Where there is a conflict between the application information and the plans submitted March 28, 2025, and the revisions submitted July 3, 2025, the plans control. Insignificant deviations may be permitted to comply with the requirements of the UDO. 

- Any commitments and representations concerning the proposed exterior modification made by the applicant or its representatives at the public hearing shall also become a condition of the permit, and a basis for a stop work order and/or permit revocation if violated. 

- The applicant shall submit the necessary applications, plans, details and specifications which meet the requirements of the Town Code, UDO, Building Code and any other applicable codes for review and approval necessary to issue Zoning and Building Permits. 

Historic Preservation Commission Procedure 

In considering this application for a COA the HPC shall base their decisions solely on the basis of competent, material and substantial evidence entered into the record via the application packet and sworn testimony at the public hearing. 

When making the motion for approval, the Commission should consider that unless the Commission explicitly orders otherwise, every approval is conditioned upon the development being completed in accordance with the plans submitted by the applicant, the commitments and representations concerning the proposed development made by the applicant and representatives at the public hearing, and final conformity with all requirements of the UDO. 

The question before the Historic Preservation Commission is whether or not the proposed development is congruous (i.e., in agreement, in harmony) with the special character of the historic district.  If the proposed exterior modification is congruous, the Commission shall issue the requested COA.  If the proposed exterior modification is incongruous (not in agreement, not in harmony) with the special character of the historic district, the Commission shall deny the requested COA.  The Commission shall approve, approve with conditions, or the deny the COA by majority vote. 

**Vote:** The proposed development  **is congruous  OR**  **is incongruous** with the special character of the Downtown Boone Local Historic District and is approved subject to the following conditions (as warranted): 

## 1. Conditions: 

_**Criteria for Conditions: The Commission may issue approval subject to reasonable conditions necessary to carry out the purposes served by the historic district (see G.S. 160D-940, 160D-947(a)).  The purposes of the historic district are to (i) safeguard the heritage of the town insofar as the Historic District embodies important elements of the town’s culture, history, architectural history, and/or prehistory, and (ii) to promote the use and conservation of the district for the education, pleasure, and enrichment of the residents of the town and/or the State as a whole, see North Carolina G.S. §160D-940, 944, 947(a).**_ 

23 | P a g e 

**24**
{23}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **24** 

## Historic Photos 

Below is a collection of historical photos of the subject property, obtained through a collaboration with Digital Watauga. The photos are displayed in their original size and resolution, as well as in a cropped version that highlights the main features of interest. For each photo, there is a citation. 

_**Staff Note: Planning Staff did not alter or edit the photos in any way, but only arranged them in this document for presentation purposes. Photos attached here are the best available with the clearest and most complete images of the subject property.  Any commentary on the images is from the Digital Watauga technician(s) who found and sent the images to Planning Staff.**_ 

Image courtesy of the Crayte Teague Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

24 | P a g e 

**25**
{24}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **25** 

Image courtesy of the Crayte Teague Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

25 | P a g e 

**26**
{25}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **26** 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

26 | P a g e 

**27**
{26}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0195 Rivers House Bathroom Renovation - COA| **27** 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

27 | P a g e 

**28**
