{0}------------------------------------------------
Exhibit 1 

## **Staff Report August 12, 2025 Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Work** 

Table of Contents Request ......................................................................................................................................................... 1 Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................... 2 Parcel Information ........................................................................................................................................ 3 Recent Zoning History ................................................................................................................................... 4 Zoning Analysis (B1 Downtown Core) ........................................................................................................... 4 Architectural Survey/Designation Report Information ................................................................................. 6 Inventory Classification ............................................................................................................................. 6 Designation Report ....................................................................................................................................... 7 Architectural Survey ...................................................................................................................................... 7 Library of Congress - Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps ................................................................................... 10 Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook Analysis ................................. 13 Narrative ................................................................................................................................................. 13 Design Standards for Commercial Properties ......................................................................................... 13 “Commercial Property” Defined ............................................................................................................. 13 Automatic Conditions of Approval .............................................................................................................. 20 Historic Preservation Commission Procedure ............................................................................................ 20 Historic Photos ............................................................................................................................................ 21 

## **Request** 

Farmer’s Ski Shop, Inc has submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Work for 140 S Depot St (WT0605 Watauga Motor Company Building), located in the Downtown Boone Local Historic District. The request is to add a staircase as an entryway to an existing loading dock door on the western side of the northern elevation. The subject property is outlined in green on the Zoning Map included below. 

Pursuant to UDO Article 8, required by Subsection 8.03.01 and the Table of Minor Work and Major Work located in Subsection 8.05.03 and Appendix D, an applicant is required to obtain a (COA) for an alteration or addition of a deck, patio, or sidewalk and for the modification of existing openings when not on the tertiary elevation. 

_**Staff Notes**_ can be found throughout the report marked in _**bold green italicized text**_ . 

**36**
{1}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **2** 

## **Zoning Map** 

2 | P a g e 

**37**
{2}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **3** 

## **Parcel Information** 

**Address:** 140 S Depot St **Property Owner:** Farmer’s Ski Shop, Inc **Watauga County Pin:** 2900-89-0070-000 **Lot Size (Total):** 0.19 ac **Jurisdiction:** Town Of Boone **Access:** S Depot St (Town maintained) **SFHA:** No **Watershed District:** No **Corridor District:** No **NCD:** No **Viewshed:** No **Steep Slope:** No **Current Zoning:** B1 Downtown Core with Downtown Boone Local Historic District Overlay 

The B1 Downtown Core and the B1 Downtown Interface Districts encompass the Town of Boone’s downtown area and represent, in large measure, the remaining vestiges of the Town’s historic character. Regulations in these districts are intended to preserve and maintain a small town, high country atmosphere. Preservation and adaptive reuse of existing historic buildings are encouraged and new construction shall be appropriately scaled to be sympathetic to the existing built environment. Design and regulatory standards for these districts reinforce the character of the downtown as a pedestrian friendly area by encouraging architectural solutions that are visually interesting, and are compatible in scale and character to the surrounding area. To help accomplish this, the area is divided into two (2) districts, each with its own character and scale which contribute to the overall vitality of the downtown area. Identification of the districts is listed below: 

A. B1 Downtown Core District: The Downtown Core District is the center of the downtown area and contains the greatest concentration of historic commercial buildings. This district establishes a continuous building facade at the street frontage to strengthen the identity of downtown as a pedestrian destination where pedestrians feel comfortable through the careful selection of building materials, human scale design, and ground floor fenestration. Standards in this district reinforce the historic nature of the existing built environment through regulation of appearance, height, scale and mass. 

B. B1 Downtown Interface District: The Downtown Interface District serves as a gateway into the downtown area and as the transition between the B1 Downtown Core District and adjacent zoning districts. Development in this district must be sensitive to issues of compatibility with the Downtown Core District as well as surrounding zoning districts, many which are low-density residential. 

3 | P a g e 

**38**
{3}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **4** 

Historic districts are established as overlay districts intended to preserve historic landmarks and districts within the Town pursuant to Article 8 Historic Preservation. 

_**Staff Note: After the designation of a historic district, no exterior portion of any building shall be erected, altered, restored, moved, or demolished within such district until after an application for a Statement of Conformity (SOC) for minor work or a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) for major work has been approved. A COA may be issued subject to any reasonable conditions necessary to carry out the purposes of Article 8 and is required whether or not a building or other permit is necessary. Where requirements conflict, overlay district standards supersede.**_ 

**Zoning & Use of Adjacent Properties** 

|**Zoning & Use of Adjacent Properties**|**Zoning & Use of Adjacent Properties**|**Zoning & Use of Adjacent Properties**|
|---|---|---|
||**Adjacent Zoning**|**Adjacent Land Use**|
|North|B1 Downtown Core with Historic District<br>Overlay|Retail / Apartments|
|East|B1 Downtown Core with Historic District<br>Overlay|Restaurant / Retail|
|South|B1 Downtown Core with Historic District and<br>SFHA Overlay|Retail / Offices|
|West|B1 Downtown Core with Historic District<br>Overlay|Retail / Apartments|



## **Recent Zoning History** 

**06-30-2025** Change of Use permit issued to change existing use of retail to 11.11 Retail Store Up to 5,000 ft[2] and 11.06 Restaurant ≤ 3,500 ft[2] . 

## **Zoning Analysis (B1 Downtown Core)** 

The following UDO requirements are required to be met for the proposed project, unless superseded by any requirements of the Downtown Boone Local Historic District overlay. 

The new occupant, Speckled Trout Outfitters, has renovated the interior space of the building into a combination of retail and restaurant space with the addition of a bar area. The building has a co-tenant, The Happy Persimmon, that previously shared the entrance with the former tenant, Orvis Fly Shop and Guide Service, that would now like to create a separate entryway by utilizing the loading dock area which has an existing door by adding steps that are the same design as the primary deck on the northern elevation. The applicant will be required to meet all applicable building code standards. 

4 | P a g e 

**39**
{4}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **5** 

## **UDO References to Appearance Standards:** 

Per UDO Subsection 14.19.06(A) the B1 Downtown Core and the B1 Downtown Interface Zoning districts are located within the Central Fire District which is regulated by the most recent edition of the NC Building Code. Applicants will be required to submit sufficient information during the zoning permit process for Staff to determine compliance of the proposed development with the requirements of the Central Fire District. 

Per UDO Subsection 14.19.06(I)(6) applicants shall identify, retain and preserve storefronts and their functional and decorative features that are important in defining the overall historic character of the building. The storefront materials (including wood, masonry, metals, ceramic tile, clear glass, and pigmented structural glass) and the configuration of the storefront are significant, as are features, such as, but not limited to: display windows, base panels, bulkheads, signs, doors, transoms, clerestory windows, kick plates, corner posts, piers, and entablatures. The removal of inappropriate, non historic cladding, false mansard roofs, and other more recent, non-historic or insignificant alterations can help reveal the historic character of the storefront. If the original façade has been covered, then it should be uncovered if structurally feasible. 

Per UDO Subsection 14.19.06(I)(8) materials that are not visually compatible with the original façade, such as shiny metals, mirror glass, plastic panels, and vinyl windows or doors are prohibited, unless they can be documented through historic images or similar documentation. 

Per UDO Subsection 14.19.06(I)(13)(a-d) for Exterior Doors when renovating an existing building the original exterior doors historic to the building shall be repaired and retained and the reuse of historic hardware and locks is encouraged. The renovations to facades shall retain recessed door areas or recreate recessed door areas, if historically appropriate, to the extent practicable. Renovations which require new doors or replacement of doors on the primary or secondary facades shall meet the standards set forth in UDO Subsection 14.19.06(H)(3)(e) which for the Downtown Core states all entrance doors on the primary and secondary facades shall be made of a solid wood frame and must be architecturally compatible/sympathetic with the storefront of the building. 

Per UDO Subsection 14.19.06(I)(11)(a)(iii) for Field Materials paint color should be similar to the original color of the field material, the existing painted color of the field material, or a color from the Benjamin Moore Historical Collection series or equivalent. Further, 14.19.06(I)(11)(b)(iv) for Trim Materials all other cornices, doors, door and window trim, awnings, canopies, and kickplates can be any color. 

Per UDO Subsection 25.06.04(B)(1) acceptable exterior materials are brick, stone, or wood. 

_**Staff note: The proposed work is compliant with these standards, no changes to the current door is proposed, only the addition of stairs for access. The entrance was not original to the property and the proposed stairs are matching to the existing desk along the northern elevation. The Fire Marshal has reviewed the application and approved with no comments. The steps will be required to meet NC building code.**_ 

5 | P a g e 

**40**
{5}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **6** 

## **Architectural Survey/Designation Report Information** 

The following three documents are central to the Downtown Boone Local Historic District: 

1. Comprehensive Architectural Survey of Downtown Boone, NC – Final Report 

2. Report and Recommendation for the Designation of the Downtown Boone Local Historic District, Boone, NC 

3. Downtown Boone Local Historic District Standards 

The designation report (#2 above), was created using the architectural survey of the downtown area (#1 above) and recommended the Downtown Boone Local Historic District area be designated as a historic overlay district; and the Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards, which are outlined in a separate document (#3 above), are to be applied by the HPC when it considers applications for Certificates of Appropriateness for proposed development within the historic district. 

## **Inventory Classification** 

The following information has been taken from the designation report starting on page 69.   The property inventory found within the report was specifically written to assess the contributing significance and integrity of the district’s resources. Integrity, as determined was based upon the following: 

1. design integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to its original appearance or altered appearance during the period of significance; 

2. material integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to original materials during the period of significance or replacement materials that mimic the appearance of original materials during the period of significance; 

3. locational integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to its original location during the period of significance; 

4. integrity of association, meaning the building’s relationship to its original or adapted use, function, and purpose during the period of significance; and 

5. integrity of relationship to the district as a whole, meaning the building’s historical importance to the development of downtown Boone’s commercial district during the district’s four periods of growth within the period of significance (1918-1964). 

## **Inventory Classifications:** 

- **CA:** Contributes to the character of the district based on architectural significance 

- **CH:** Contributes to the character of the district based on historical significance related to events or individuals associated with the property 

- **NC:** Non-contributing property 

- **VL:** Vacant lot 

6 | P a g e 

**41**
{6}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **7** 

## **Designation Report** 

The Designation Report summary is included on the right (in blue), and the full Architectural Survey summary is included below. 

_**Staff Note: The subject property is classified as CH.**_ 

_**CH means the property contributes to the district based on historical significance related to events or individuals associated with the property.**_ 

## **Architectural Survey** 

**WT0605 Watauga Motor Company Building (1920)** 140 South Depot Street 

This large, gable-roofed, brick building is one of the first brick buildings constructed in Boone using bricks imported via the East Tennessee and Western North Carolina Railroad, which began freight runs in December 1918. In April 1919, the local paper carried the news that “the brick are coming in and being unloaded for the Watauga Motor Co’s new garage,” which was to be built by the McGhee Brothers (Watauga Democrat, April 3, 1919). W. E. “Ed” Shipley, the owner (who may have been in business with J. B. Taylor), appears to have struggled to complete the building, however. In June 1919, he asked for changes to the building, which had been designed by Ford Motor Company’s architects to meet their standards (Watauga Democrat, June 12, 1919), prompting references to the building for years thereafter as the “Ford Building.” Walter Shore of Elk Park completed the carpentry work in the building (Watauga Democrat, July 3, 1919). After another year of delay, the Watauga Motor Company finally opened its repair department, even though the building was still not complete (Watauga Democrat, June 24, 1920). The stay was apparently brief. By April 1921, Shipley had sold the building to F. C. Ward (Deed Book 27, Page 230), and by the end of the year, Watauga Motor Company appears to 

## _**WT0605 Watauga Motor Company Building (1920)—CH**_ 

_140 South Depot Street (2900-89-0070000)_ 

_Completed by 1920 by the McGhee Brothers, this two-story, gable-roofed, brick building with a prominent, stepped east parapet is one of the first constructed in downtown Boone using bricks and other construction materials imported via the East Tennessee and Western North Carolina Railroad, which served Boone from late 1918 until August 1940. Purpose built as a garage, it housed a parade of various automotive concerns until the mid1930s, when the building officially became home to Boone’s Town (sometimes City) Hall, serving in that role until 1962. It has housed various commercial uses since then. A large, two-story addition joined the west elevation about 1977, at which time several salvaged architectural elements from other buildings were appended to the second floor exterior. Original piercings remain evident, although some have been either bricked in or altered using modern materials._ 

have left the site. By early 1924, Teague Brothers Garage may have been operating out of the space (Watauga Democrat, April 3, 1924), but this too seems to have been short-lived. The building was again sold in 1924 to former Sheriff W. P. Moody and A. P. Moody, but their ownership ended in 1925, when the property was sold at auction to the People’s Bank and Trust Company (Deed Book 36, Page 626, and Watauga Democrat, August 20, 1925). It’s not clear what operated there in the next few years, but in 1928, W. R. Winkler moved his garage operation to the old Ford building in the wake of his operation on King Street being demolished for construction of the H. W. Horton Building (WT0593) (Watauga Democrat, October 25, 1928). Contrary to previous survey reports, Winkler’s stay was short-lived as 

7 | P a g e 

**42**
{7}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **8** 

well; less than a year later, Winkler sold his garage operation to J. D. Horton, (Watauga Democrat, July 4, 1929). That same year, notice appeared that the American Legion would be holding a special meeting “at their regular meeting place over the Winkler Garage” (Watauga Democrat, October 17, 1929), thus indicating that the second floor was being used for community meetings. During this same general period, the building appears to have been used for town government meetings while efforts were underway to build a new town hall on King Street near Water Street in 1928. Horton’s operation, meanwhile, remained in the building until 1931, when it moved to West Boone (Watauga Democrat, June 18, 1931). Later that year, at least a portion of the second floor was apparently being used for apartments (Watauga Democrat, October 1, 1931). In 1932, the People’s Industrial Bank sold the property to the Town of Boone (Deed Book 40, Page 627), some time after which the Town of Boone began using the property as a formal city hall. The earliest formal reference to the building as “city hall” in local papers occurred in April 1935, when news was announced that the Daniel Boone Motor Company would be moving into the first floor of the building (Watauga Democrat, April 4, 1935). Boone Motor Sales, the successor to Daniel Boone Motor Company, vacated the property to move to the Sebastian Building (WT0878) in December 1936 (Watauga Democrat, December 10, 1936). The building continued to operate as Boone’s city hall until 1962, when it was abandoned for the old Sinclair gas station property located where WT0862 is today (Watauga Democrat, March 1, 1962). The Town of Boone sold the property to the Farmer’s Hardware and Supply Company in 1967 (Deed Book 100, Page 264), after which it served as a storage facility and a lawnmower and chainsaw repair shop. In 1977, Farmer’s Ski Shop opened in the building (Watauga Democrat, January 13, 1977). At the time of the survey, Magic Cycles occupied the first floor, while the Farmer’s Hardware Ski Shop was in the second floor space. Several early images of the building survive, and they show the building occupying a substantially smaller footprint than its present iteration. A circa 1938/39 image (Cy Crumley Scrapbook) taken from the southwest shows a two-story brick building with a gabled roof and a jerkinhead clip in the gable at the west end of the building. The east end was not clipped, instead offering a prominent, stepped parapet on its east elevation. The west elevation was perhaps most noteworthy for the long ramp extending from a large loading door at the center of the second floor out to the alley running from the old post office to the ice house. Flanking this loading door were two long window piercings, which were mirrored by similar openings on the first floor. The south elevation, meanwhile, offered five irregularly spaced window openings along the second floor (four of them oriented from center toward the west elevation), while the first floor had four piercings, three of them clustered near the center of the south elevation (the easternmost possibly a door) and a fourth located near the southwest corner. A circa 1950 image from the south by Palmer Blair (Pal-Bla-04-104) and a circa 1952 parade image from the southeast (His Boo-1.54.2) offer a little bit more detail. At that point, the west ramp to the alley was still intact, while the five windows of the second floor, south elevation all appeared to have been twoover-two, double-hung sash, wooden windows. The south elevation first floor piercings also appear to have been two-over-two, double-hung sash, wooden windows, with the exception of the easternmost piercing, which still appeared to be a doorway. The east elevation, meanwhile, offered three symmetrically spaced, two-over-two, double-hung sash window piercings on the second floor. Reading left to right (south to north), the first floor had a wooden, paneled door with a large transom, followed by a large shop window with a prominent, single-panel clerestory window, followed thereafter by another doorway set in an unusual, arched opening with a four-light transom, followed by another large shop window with a two-light clerestory window, followed to the north by a large garage bay in a wood frame. The first floor openings were capped with a spanning, soldier course lintel, and the second floor brick was set back slightly, creating the appearance of a panel inset with pilasters at the south and north ends. The entire building was clad in six-course common bond brick. This same general appearance remained until sometime between 1972 and 1984, when a large, two-story addition was built on the west side of the building and a wooden awning installed on the east elevation over the first floor. These 

8 | P a g e 

**43**
{8}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **9** 

changes may have occurred as a result of renovations by Farmer’s Ski Shop in 1977, when architectural remnants from other buildings were added to this site. These included several doors salvaged from a 1780s house in Troy, North Carolina, and a stained glass window with a mountain scene. The carved doors that now serve as the main entrance to the second-floor shop are from the Troy house (Watauga Democrat, January 13, 1977). Today, the east elevation retains the original piercings, but the original windows have been replaced with metal-framed plate glass and the original doors replaced by metalframe alternatives. A garage door is still present in the bay at the north end of the first floor of the east elevation, but it is clearly a modern replacement. Along the sidewalk on Depot Street, a stone retaining wall capped with stone slabs serves as the support for an asphalt-shingled irregularly cut, wooden awning resting on posts. Perhaps the most intriguing detail that survives from the original east elevation is the floating pilasters with stepped bases that are used to demarcate each of the steps in the prominent east parapet. The brick of the entire building has also been painted, although the second floor windows of the east elevation (which have soldier course lintels and brick, double-tier sills) appear to have had flanking shutters at some point whose absence today has left its mark on the painted brick. Coping on the east elevation parapet appears to be of metal. The original piercings of the second floor of the south elevation of the original building are still evident, although all of them have been filled in with brick. A new window piercing has been cut in the brick between the second and third piercings from the west on the second floor, within which is set the aforementioned, stained glass, mountain scene window. The original openings of the first floor of the south elevation are also evident, but these, too, have been bricked in and replaced with new openings. At the west end is a wooden-framed doorway with a large transom, to the east of which is a wooden-framed, plate glass window. This pattern is repeated near the east end of the original south elevation. The roof of the original building is clad in asphalt shingle and has been punctured on its south face by three skylights. A small, interior, furnace stack is also evident near the southwest corner of the original building. Curiously, the jerkinhead at the west end of the roof still survives, although it is partially obscured by the manner in which it ties into the gabled roof of the west addition. The west elevation of the original building is now obscured by the west addition. The north elevation of the original building reveals several piercings that have been bricked in. Toward the west end of the original building is a large, seven-light, projecting bay window that appears to be clad in metal. Just to the east of this is an elaborate, wooden porch, with a short run of stairs coming up from the parking lot on the north side of the building and another, much longer run descending to Depot Street. Accessible from this porch are two sets of elegant, wooden, doors that were sourced from the 1780s home in Troy and do not match this building architecturally. The center set is arched in its frame and hosts double doors with arched lights and eyebrow lights. The east door is a single doorway with arched lights. The west addition appears to be of running bond brick and is painted on its south and west elevations with an elaborate, somewhat psychedelic mural design, although both elevations have been marred by additional graffiti spray-painted over the murals. No piercings are present on the south or west elevations of the addition. The roof of the addition has a clipped gable at its west end and offers prominent eaves with boxed soffits. The roof is clad in asphalt shingles. A series of six skylights is evident on the south face of the addition’s roof. The north elevation of the west addition is also painted and featureless, save for a large, double-door opening inset with paneled doors sourced from elsewhere. 

_**Staff Note: The images referenced above have been included within the historical photo section of the report. Pal-Bla-04-104: image 7 and His Boo 1.54.2: image 13.**_ 

9 | P a g e 

**44**
{9}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **10** 

## **Library of Congress - Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps** 

The Library of Congress has made Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps from 1928 and 1947 accessible. As these years fall within the historic district’s period of significance (1918-1964), these maps will be used when the property in question, or area of the property in question, can be viewed within these maps. The content of the Library of Congress online Sanborn Maps Collection is in the public domain and is free to use and reuse. 

_Sanborn Fire Insurance Map from Boone, Watauga County, North Carolina_ . Sanborn Map Company, Jan, 1928. Map. https://www.loc.gov/item/sanborn06383_001/. 

10 | P a g e 

**45**
{10}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **11** 

_Sanborn Fire Insurance Map from Boone, Watauga County, North Carolina_ . Sanborn Map Company, Jun, 1947. Map. https://www.loc.gov/item/sanborn06383_002/. 

11 | P a g e 

**46**
{11}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **12** 

_Sanborn Fire Insurance Map from Boone, Watauga County, North Carolina_ . Sanborn Map Company, Jun, 1947. Map. https://www.loc.gov/item/sanborn06383_002/. 

12 | P a g e 

**47**
{12}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **13** 

## **Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook Analysis** 

## **Narrative** 

Relevant design standards from UDO Appendix D, Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook, Design Standards for COMMERCIAL/RESIDENTIAL Properties within the District, are outlined below.   These Standards for COMMERCIAL/RESIDENTIAL properties are intended to address many of the most common issues to arise during renovations, additions, and new construction in the District. Where the Standards are silent on a particular issue or concern, the HPC will rely upon the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation to guide their review of the proposed work under the COA process and any subsequent recommendations. 

## **Design Standards for Commercial Properties** 

## **“Commercial Property” Defined** 

A **commercial property** within the District is any property whose purpose-built function at the time of construction was primarily to serve a commercial, institutional, or governmental purpose or use. More specifically, commercial properties include 1) any building whose original configuration included commercial, institutional, or governmental uses on the ground floor accessed via the entrance(s) located on the primary elevation, even if residential spaces were available elsewhere in the building (such as a commercial block building with stores on the first floor and apartments on the second floor), or 2) any building with a garage bay or bays on the ground floor accessed via the entrance(s) located on the primary elevation and commercial, institutional, or governmental spaces located elsewhere in the building (such as a garage building with an office or store located on an upper floor or in the basement). 

Any property within the District whose purpose-built function at the time of construction was to serve solely as a residence for long-term (greater than 30 days) occupants, even if the property currently serves a commercial use, is still considered a residential property. For standards for residential properties, please see the “Standards for Residential Properties within the District” section elsewhere in this publication. 

## **1. Storefronts, Upper Facades, Side Elevations, and Rear Elevations** 

Downtown Boone is dominated by historic properties that reflect the commercial block architecture that was so common and influential during the period from 1910 to 1960 in many American towns and cities. In the case of the District, commercial block development began around 1919 and continued to the early 1960s. Central to this architecture is the importance of the storefront itself, whose familiar architectural details—large display windows, transom bars and windows, clerestory recessed entries, and prominent cornice and corbelling work—frequently signaled to customers not only the function of a business but also the quality of its wares. Many other elements—including projecting, flat awnings anchored to the façade with cables or steel rods, or fabric awnings amounted on metal frames, hinged or unhinged— provided customers with shelter from the elements while window shopping or otherwise enhanced the shopping experience. After 1950, many of these architectural details were removed, either in response to decay of these features or in an effort to “update” a building to the stylistic preferences of a later time. One such example is the Appalachian Theatre on West King Street, whose original Art Deco marquee and structural glass were removed during the late 1970s in response to safety concerns. Other elements— most notably transoms and clerestory windows, as well as the details of upper facades—were simply covered over and may still survive today underneath modern additions to the facades of many of Boone’s historic downtown properties in the District. 

Similarly, secondary and tertiary elevations of many of Boone’s historic commercial properties are vital to the character and integrity of its downtown commercial district. Often, significant side (secondary) elevations are located on corner buildings adjacent to two or even three streets, but sometimes such 

13 | P a g e 

**48**
{13}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **14** 

details are visible on mid-block buildings separated from nearby buildings by an alleyway or a vacant lot. Many of these buildings retain original fenestration, entrances, brickwork, and/or advertisements (some of the “ghost ad” variety) that contribute in their own significant way to the architectural character of the downtown historic district. Similarly, rear (tertiary) elevations can possess many of these same characteristics and also reveal much about the history of a property because of their frequently utilitarian design intended for the workers, owners, and residents who most often saw these rear elevations. 

In an effort to preserve what remains of the District’s historic commercial architecture and encourage the reconstruction or rehabilitation of elements that have been removed or covered over, the standards for storefronts, upper facades, and other elevations are intended to facilitate preservation and reconstruction wherever possible while also addressing new construction and its compatibility with the rest of the District. 

- 1.1 Whenever possible, historic storefronts and storefront features such as entrance configurations, display windows, doors, clerestory windows, transom bars and windows, bulkheads, corbelling, cornice work, windows, stonework, stringcourses, structural glass, and other architectural flourishes should be retained and preserved. When repairing these features, retain and preserve in place original elements as much as possible. If repair is not possible, replace damaged elements with materials that match the originals in composition, design, texture, color, and other visual qualities. 

- 1.2 When reconstructing an historic storefront, upper façade, or other elevation, use historical research and evidence as the basis for the design. Reconstructed storefronts should incorporate original dimensions, proportions, and architectural elements. 

- 1.3 In making changes to storefronts or other elevations to comply with code or accessibility requirements, avoid destroying historic materials and features and select configurations that have minimal intrusion or impact on the character-defining aspects of the property in question. 

- 1.4 When original or early storefronts or upper facades no longer exist, are too deteriorated to save, or cannot be reconstructed based on the available documentary evidence, retain the commercial character and any salvageable architectural details through a contemporary design that is compatible with the scale, materials, color, style, design, and texture of the surviving and surrounding historic buildings. 

- 1.5 Original upper facade windows should not be removed and replaced with modern materials, nor is the enclosing or bricking in of upper facade windows appropriate. When upper floor windows must be replaced, use new windows that match the original windows in configuration, appearance, and materials. 

- 1.6 It is never appropriate to cover an historic upper facade. Whenever possible, non-historic coverings of upper facades, including metal, stucco, or faux mountain village fronts and porches, should be removed and underlying original architectural elements repaired and restored. 

- 1.7 Historic painted advertisements are a significant element of the architectural and commercial history of downtown Boone, and their preservation and restoration are recommended whenever feasible, even if the product or store advertised is no longer available or in business. 

14 | P a g e 

**49**
{14}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **15** 

- 1.8 Facade details of side (secondary) and rear (tertiary) elevations should always be retained and preserved if possible. When repairing these features, retain and preserve in place original elements as much as possible. If repair is not possible, replace damaged elements with materials that match the originals in composition, design, texture, color, and other visual qualities. If there is evidence of a rear public entrance that is no longer extant, use historical research and other evidence to reconstruct or provide an equivalent rear entrance whenever possible. 

- 1.9 Utility lines, mechanical equipment, pipes, garbage receptacles, and other service items on side (secondary) and rear (tertiary) elevations—whether old or new—should be screened from public view whenever possible. Unnecessary or out-of-service elements should be removed unless they are essential to the historic character of the property. 

## **2. Architectural Components and Details** 

Exterior architectural components, including door and window casings, storefront configurations, cast iron ornamentation, stone relief, cornices, columns, brackets, porch railings, soffits, fascias, roof configurations, trim details, architectural flourishes, and various joinery and surface patterns all contribute significantly to the character and historical integrity of properties located within the District. 

Because many of these components are either irreplaceable or very expensive to reproduce, they should be maintained and valued in the same way that one might consider an important family heirloom or expensive antique furniture. In many cases, missing or damaged architectural details can be replaced with like items from salvage yards, antique shops, or mail order companies that specialize in replacement of historic architectural components. If such items cannot be replaced, many construction supply companies stock simulations of period architectural components that are approved by the Secretary of the Interior and the National Park Service as suitable historic replacements. In any event, before replacing any exterior architectural component, property owners should familiarize themselves with the architectural style and historic characteristics of their building to avoid introduction of inappropriate elements. 

- 2.1 It is important to preserve character-defining, historical, architectural features of exterior walls, such as cornices, friezes, medallions, sunbursts, brackets, bays, turrets, fascias, quoins, columns, brickwork, string courses, and decorative moldings. Original architectural details should always be retained if structurally feasible, even if portions of the original material are damaged or deteriorated to a point requiring replacement. If original details are missing, design replacement features based on historic photos and other documentation. 

- 2.2 It is NOT appropriate to cover or remove rather than repair or replace in kind such features when they are deteriorated. If replacement is necessary, the new materials should match the materials being replaced in composition, design, texture, color, and other visual qualities. Original architectural features that are covered should be uncovered, exposed, repaired and/or restored, and maintained. 

- 2.3 It is NOT appropriate to cover or replace historic materials with substitute materials, such as aluminum, vinyl, fiber cement board siding (or similar materials simulating the appearance of wood), or plywood panels. Architectural details that are not appropriate to the historic context and character of a building should never be added. At the same time, property owners should never use details from an earlier period to try to make a building look older than it is. 

15 | P a g e 

**50**
{15}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **16** 

- 2.4 Historic architectural metals, such as pressed tin, aluminum, and cast or wrought iron, should always be retained. If these items are not repairable due to rust or other deterioration, replacement materials should duplicate the form, details, texture, material, size, shape, color, pattern, and composition of the original. When cleaning of architectural metals is necessary, use the gentlest methods possible, such as water, a gentle, non-caustic soap, and soft bristle brushes. 

## **6. Windows, Doors, and Awnings** 

The arrangement of doors and windows on an historic property is one of the most important elements of building design. It is imperative that these arrangements be preserved in order to maintain the integrity of individual historic properties and the integrity of the District.  Because older windows and doors were not always designed with heating and cooling efficiency in mind, it is often tempting to property owners to replace these features with modern doors and windows. Despite the apparent advantages of doing so, replacement with modern doors and windows is often far more expensive than repairing existing historic doors and windows, and their use often completely destroys the integrity of the historic property in question. Furthermore, many companies are now producing “modern” wood replacement windows that replicate the appearance of their historic antecedents with fixed muntins but feature double-pane glass to assist with heating and cooling efficiency. The HPC reviews proposals for the use of modern wood replacement windows carefully to insure that muntin thickness aligns with the muntin dimensions of historic windows. 

Boone’s downtown commercial historic district has also suffered from the installation of various architectural elements designed to simulate a “mountain village” appearance. These typically consist of large, wooden porch attachments or awnings that are not historically appropriate to the downtown area and its historic context. Metal and modern vinyl awnings have also appeared on some properties, disrupting the integrity of many of Boone’s historic commercial properties. 

- 6.1 The pattern, arrangement, location, size, and shape of windows and doors contribute significantly to a building’s historic character, and their consistency within the district helps unify the buildings in context to one another. For this reason, it is always preferable to repair damaged windows and doors rather than replacing them. Furthermore, it is imperative that the fenestration pattern of the door and window openings on the building and of the doors and windows themselves (muntin width, number of lights per sash, etc.) be maintained when repairs to or replacement of elements is underway. It is never appropriate to introduce new features, such as vents, bays, windows, or door openings, in exterior walls if they diminish the historic character of the wall or damage historic materials. 

- 6.2 Whenever possible, the original window and door hardware should be preserved and maintained, as these components are also vital elements of historic properties. 

- 6.3 Whenever possible, other original window and door elements, such as sashes, glass, sills, frames, casings, weather-stripping, lintels, architraves, surrounds, and shutters, should be repaired rather than replaced. This includes sidelights and fanlights on both doors and windows, which are vital architectural elements that help identify the style and period of a particular property. Snap-in muntins are not historically accurate and should always be avoided. 

- 6.4 Unless restoring the appearance of a building to its original, historic context, the pattern, arrangements, and dimensions of doors and windows on principal elevations should be 

16 | P a g e 

**51**
{16}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **17** 

retained. On tertiary elevations not visible from the street, new door or window openings should be proportionate to existing ones and include matching design elements. 

- 6.11 Awnings, porches, shed roof porticoes, and arcades that attempt to create a “mountain village” appearance or that are not historically accurate to the District’s historic context only work to damage the integrity and appearance of the District. Property owners whose buildings possess such features should endeavor to remove them and restore the facade of their property to its historic appearance. Such “mountain village” treatments should never be incorporated into additions or new construction within the District. 

- 6.16 New construction, additions, and renovations to existing historic buildings or properties within historic districts should maintain established proportions and spacing of window and door openings. 

## **8. Entrances, Porches, and Balconies** 

One of the most significant and defining characteristics of all architecture is the main or front entrance, including any porches that surround or frame that entrance. While most of the commercial buildings in the District employed conventional storefront configurations (see Section 1 of these commercial standards), a handful of properties in the District do not employ traditional commercial entrance configurations. These properties include the Boone Post Office (WT0049), the Wade E. Brown Law Office Building (WT0586), the Watauga County Office Building (WT0607), and the Boone Recreation Parlor (WT0869). Retaining the original porch and entrance components of these buildings is especially important for understanding the building’s history in context with the District. Unfortunately, main or front entrances are also often the most altered elements of historic properties. 

Many historic entrances, porches, and balconies contain architectural elements that are essential to communicating the architectural style of the home. Machine-carved balustrades, spindles, brackets, entrance surrounds, and posts were common in many of the District’s buildings, but hand-worked elements were also not uncommon. Preserving these details is vital to preserving the appearance and integrity of the District’s historic architecture. 

8. 1 Entrances, porches, and balconies, as used in this section, include front (primary elevation), side (secondary elevation), and rear (tertiary elevation) porches, mudrooms, porticos, sleeping porches, balconies, pergolas, terraces, widow’s walks, and entrances. Components of porches include steps, balustrades, columns, trellises, skirt boards, fascias, brackets, and various ornamental details. Most original porches and balconies were built with a slight pitch away from the residence to facilitate the runoff of rainwater. 

- 8.2 Because of their architectural significance, porches, balconies, and entrance configurations— especially those on the front or primary elevation—and all of their architectural details (steps, balustrades, brackets, spindlework, columns, roofs, etc.) should be preserved in their original form and detail whenever possible. It is inappropriate to enclose porches and balconies on the front (primary) elevation for use as an interior space. In addition, the original pitch of porches and balconies should be maintained in order to facilitate the runoff of rainwater and snowmelt. Porches and balconies must be properly maintained and repaired as necessary, as they are exposed to the weather and will deteriorate if regular maintenance is not conducted. 

17 | P a g e 

**52**
{17}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **18** 

- 8.7 Original porch steps should always be retained. If repair or replacement of porch step materials is necessary, the design, configuration, dimensions, and materials should match the original as closely as possible. In addition, historic stairways and walkways in front of a building—even though not technically part of the building’s architecture—are nevertheless an important part of the landscape that accompanies the property and often inform the architectural style and patterns of the property. These elements should always be retained and repaired with appropriate materials whenever possible. 

- 8.8 Decks may be added on the rear elevation of a historic property, provided their addition does not require the removal of large, healthy trees, and their design is compatible in scale with the historic property and district. They should always be designed and installed in such a manner that they may be removed without damage to the historic building. Removal of historic building materials to facilitate the installation of a deck is never acceptable. 

- 8.9 Vegetative screening should be employed to obscure the visibility of decks from the street. The underside of decks should also employ latticework or vegetative screening to incorporate the deck element into the general whole of the property in question. 

- 8.10 Floor coverings, such as artificial turf, indoor/outdoor carpeting, linoleum, and other similar materials (aside from a small doormat near an entrance) should never be installed on porch, balcony, or deck floors, as these materials can trap water and damage the historic architectural elements below. 

## **9. Paint and Paint Color** 

For most of the District’s historic commercial properties, which typically were made of masonry and rarely painted, determining historic paint colors, except on trim, ornamentation, windows, original stucco walls, or other architectural details, is usually not a problem. While color chronology tests can help to determine original paint colors (contact the State Historic Preservation Office for assistance), this process is difficult, sometimes inconclusive, and often expensive. 

While the HPC does not regulate paint colors in the District per se, property owners are required to submit proposed paint samples as part of any COA application and seek guidance from the HPC and/or the State Historic Preservation Office when considering paint schemes for historic properties. Nevertheless, paint colors and applications must comply with all other general requirements outlined in the Town of Boone UDO. Beyond this, some general standards are applied by the HPC when considering paint in relation to historic properties. 

- 9.1 It is NOT appropriate to apply paint or other coatings to unpainted wall materials and surfaces/finishes that were historically left unpainted, including masonry, stonework, wood shingles, stained wood surfaces, and metal. 

- 9.2 It is NOT appropriate to use abrasive techniques for cleaning or removing paint from exterior walls and trim, such as sandblasting, high-pressure waterblasting, blowtorching, or other methods that may damage the exterior materials. In general, old paint should not be removed unless there is a compelling reason to do so, such as revealing an obscured architectural detail or correcting a severe peeling or cracking problem in existing paint. Removal of non-historic paint from masonry can be challenging and problematic, and doing so requires strict adherence to preservation guidance published by the National Park Service. Generally speaking, such work should be completed by a professional trained in historic 

18 | P a g e 

**53**
{18}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **19** 

   - preservation methods and using a chemical paint remover specifically intended for masonry and the gentlest application means possible. In some instances, inappropriately applied paints may not be removable without damaging the underlying masonry, so it is always advisable to test removal techniques in an area that is not easily visible to the public. The HPC will provide guidance in such instances on the best approach to addressing unusual paint removal challenges. 

- 9.3 Select paint colors that are appropriate for the building’s architectural style and that are complementary to neighboring buildings. In general, color should function as a method of contrasting among different materials and architectural elements that make up the building. Contrasting colors that accent architectural details and entrances are discouraged, however, except in those cases where this design element was common to the historic architectural style of an existing historic property and there is historic precedent for such accenting. 

- 9.4 Wooden porch steps should always be painted to match the color of a wooden porch floor. 

## **11. Accessibility, Health, and Safety Considerations** 

Modern building codes and/or the needs of the people who own, shop, work, and live in historic properties often mean that a variety of accessibility and safety elements must be installed in those properties. Careful planning insures that the integrity of historic properties can be maintained in spite of the addition of these non-historic elements. 

- 11.1 New exterior fire escapes are not permitted on historic properties unless more adequate exit facilities cannot be provided. If they must be installed, fire escapes generally should be located at the rear (tertiary elevation) of the building and never along an elevation visible from an adjacent street. 

- 11.2 Introducing items such as wheelchair ramps, fire exits, and fire stairs without damaging the character of a historic structure requires careful planning. Owners should introduce fire exits, stairs, landings, and ramps on rear (tertiary elevation) or inconspicuous side (secondary elevation) locations. If access ramps must be installed in a manner that makes them visible from the public right-of-way, they should be constructed in a manner that makes them as simple and compact as possible and limits their projection from the building. 

- 11.3 Construct fire exits, stairs, landings, and ramps in such a manner that they do not damage or significantly obscure historical materials and features. Such additions should be designed to be complementary to the architectural style, materials, scale, and function of the historic property. 

- 11.4 Whenever possible, existing exterior fire escapes and stairways that are not original to historic properties should be relocated from front or exposed elevations to a rear or unexposed elevation. 

19 | P a g e 

**54**
{19}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **20** 

## **Automatic Conditions of Approval** 

The following conditions are automatically included and a part of any approval. 

- Where there is a conflict between the application information and the plans submitted June 26, 2025, the plans control. Insignificant deviations may be permitted to comply with the requirements of the UDO. 

- Any commitments and representations concerning the proposed exterior modification made by the applicant or its representatives at the public hearing shall also become a condition of the permit, and a basis for a stop work order and/or permit revocation if violated. 

- The applicant shall submit the necessary applications, plans, details and specifications which meet the requirements of the Town Code, UDO, Building Code and any other applicable codes for review and approval necessary to issue Zoning and Building Permits. 

## **Historic Preservation Commission Procedure** 

In considering this application for a COA the HPC shall base their decisions solely on the basis of competent, material and substantial evidence entered into the record via the application packet and sworn testimony at the public hearing. 

When making the motion for approval, the Commission should consider that unless the Commission explicitly orders otherwise, every approval is conditioned upon the development being completed in accordance with the plans submitted by the applicant, the commitments and representations concerning the proposed development made by the applicant and representatives at the public hearing, and final conformity with all requirements of the UDO. 

The question before the Historic Preservation Commission is whether or not the proposed development is congruous (i.e., in agreement, in harmony) with the special character of the historic district.  If the proposed exterior modification is congruous, the Commission shall issue the requested COA.  If the proposed exterior modification is incongruous (not in agreement, not in harmony) with the special character of the historic district, the Commission shall deny the requested COA.  The Commission shall approve, approve with conditions, or the deny the COA by majority vote. 

**Vote:** The proposed development  **is congruous  OR**  **is incongruous** with the special character of the Downtown Boone Local Historic District and is approved subject to the following conditions (as warranted): 

## 1. Conditions: 

_**Criteria for Conditions: The Commission may issue approval subject to reasonable conditions necessary to carry out the purposes served by the historic district (see G.S. 160D-940, 160D-947(a)).  The purposes of the historic district are to (i) safeguard the heritage of the town insofar as the Historic District embodies important elements of the town’s culture, history, architectural history, and/or prehistory, and (ii) to promote the use and conservation of the district for the education, pleasure, and enrichment of the residents of the town and/or the State as a whole, see North Carolina G.S. §160D-940, 944, 947(a).**_ 

20 | P a g e 

**55**
{20}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **21** 

## **Historic Photos** 

Below is a collection of historical photos of the subject property, obtained through a collaboration with Digital Watauga. The photos are displayed in their original size and resolution, as well as in a cropped version that highlights the main features of interest. For each photo, there is a citation. 

_**Staff Note: Planning Staff did not alter or edit the photos in any way, but only arranged them in this document for presentation purposes. Photos attached here are the best available with the clearest and most complete images of the subject property.  Any commentary on the images is from the Digital Watauga technician(s) who found and sent the images to Planning Staff.**_ 

**==> picture [66 x 28] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
. [Miia]<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Image courtesy of the Palmar Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

21 | P a g e 

**56**
{21}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **22** 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

22 | P a g e 

**57**
{22}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **23** 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

23 | P a g e 

**58**
{23}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **24** 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

24 | P a g e 

**59**
{24}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **25** 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

25 | P a g e 

**60**
{25}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **26** 

Image courtesy of the Alfred and Daisy Adams Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Alfred and Daisy Adams Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

26 | P a g e 

**61**
{26}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **27** 

Image courtesy of the Crayte Teague Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Crayte Teague Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

27 | P a g e 

**62**
{27}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **28** 

Image courtesy of the Historic Boone Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Downtown Boone Development Association Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

28 | P a g e 

**63**
{28}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0466 Speckled Trout Outfitters - COA| **29** 

Image courtesy of the Watauga County Historical Society Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Watauga County Historical Society Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

29 | P a g e 

**64**
