{0}------------------------------------------------
Exhibit 1 

## **Staff Report** 

## **August 12, 2025 Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Work** 

Table of Contents Request ......................................................................................................................................................... 1 Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................... 2 Parcel Information ........................................................................................................................................ 3 Recent Zoning History ................................................................................................................................... 4 Recent Building History ................................................................................................................................. 4 Zoning Analysis (B1 Downtown Core) ........................................................................................................... 5 Architectural Survey/Designation Report Information ................................................................................. 5 Inventory Classification ............................................................................................................................. 5 Designation Report ....................................................................................................................................... 7 Architectural Survey ...................................................................................................................................... 7 Library of Congress - Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps ................................................................................... 12 Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook Analysis ................................. 16 Narrative ................................................................................................................................................. 16 Design Standards for Commercial Properties ......................................................................................... 16 “Commercial Property” Defined ............................................................................................................. 16 Automatic Conditions of Approval .............................................................................................................. 21 Historic Preservation Commission Procedure ............................................................................................ 21 Historic Photos ............................................................................................................................................ 22 

## **Request** 

Trade Land Company, LLC has submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Work for 605 W King St located in the Downtown Boone Local Historic District. The request is for mortar joint repairs along the east, west, and south elevations of the building. The scope of work states repointing and tuckpointing of the mortar joints and the proposed material includes a water-based natural look sealant. The subject property is outlined in green on the Zoning Map included below. 

Pursuant to UDO Article 8, required by Subsection 8.03.01 and the Table of Minor Work and Major Work located in Subsection 8.05.03 and Appendix D, an applicant is required to obtain a (COA) for any alteration of the exterior surface material of a building outside of in-kind repair or replacement. 

_**Staff Notes**_ can be found throughout the report marked in _**bold green italicized text**_ . 

**75**
{1}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **2** 

## **Zoning Map** 

2 | P a g e 

**76**
{2}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **3** 

## **Parcel Information** 

**Address:** 595 -/605 W King St **Property Owner:** Trade Land Company, LLC **Watauga County Pin:** 2900-88-4900-000 **Lot Size (Total):** 0.215 ac **Jurisdiction:** Town Of Boone **Access:** W King St (State maintained) **SFHA:** No **Watershed District:** No **Corridor District:** No **NCD:** No **Viewshed:** No **Steep Slope:** No **Current Zoning:** B1 Downtown Core with Downtown Boone Local Historic District Overlay The B1 Downtown Core and the B1 Downtown Interface Districts encompass the Town of Boone’s downtown area and represent, in large measure, the remaining vestiges of the Town’s historic character. Regulations in these districts are intended to preserve and maintain a small town, high country atmosphere. Preservation and adaptive reuse of existing historic buildings are encouraged and new construction shall be appropriately scaled to be sympathetic to the existing built environment. Design and regulatory standards for these districts reinforce the character of the downtown as a pedestrian friendly area by encouraging architectural solutions that are visually interesting, and are compatible in scale and character to the surrounding area. To help accomplish this, the area is divided into two (2) districts, each with its own character and scale which contribute to the overall vitality of the downtown area. Identification of the districts is listed below: 

A. B1 Downtown Core District: The Downtown Core District is the center of the downtown area and contains the greatest concentration of historic commercial buildings. This district establishes a continuous building facade at the street frontage to strengthen the identity of downtown as a pedestrian destination where pedestrians feel comfortable through the careful selection of building materials, human scale design, and ground floor fenestration. Standards in this district reinforce the historic nature of the existing built environment through regulation of appearance, height, scale and mass. 

B. B1 Downtown Interface District: The Downtown Interface District serves as a gateway into the downtown area and as the transition between the B1 Downtown Core District and adjacent zoning districts. Development in this district must be sensitive to issues of compatibility with the Downtown Core District as well as surrounding zoning districts, many which are low-density residential. 

3 | P a g e 

**77**
{3}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **4** 

Historic districts are established as overlay districts intended to preserve historic landmarks and districts within the Town pursuant to Article 8 Historic Preservation. 

_**Staff Note: After the designation of a historic district, no exterior portion of any building shall be erected, altered, restored, moved, or demolished within such district until after an application for a Statement of Conformity (SOC) for minor work or a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) for major work has been approved. A COA may be issued subject to any reasonable conditions necessary to carry out the purposes of Article 8 and is required whether or not a building or other permit is necessary. Where requirements conflict, overlay district standards supersede.**_ 

**Zoning & Use of Adjacent Properties** 

|**Zoning & Use of Adjacent Properties**|**Zoning & Use of Adjacent Properties**|**Zoning & Use of Adjacent Properties**|
|---|---|---|
||**Adjacent Zoning**|**Adjacent Land Use**|
|North|B1 Downtown Core with Historic District<br>Overlay|Cultural Facility|
|East|B1 Downtown Core with Historic District<br>Overlay|Restaurant / Hotel|
|South|B1 Downtown Core with Historic District and<br>SFHA Overlay|Professional Office|
|West|B1 Downtown Core with Historic District<br>Overlay|Retail/Hotel|



## **Recent Zoning History** 

- **6-12-2025** A Statement of Conformity was issued to Maling Plumbing LLC to install a gas line for Venture Chocolate & Wine. 

- **8-06-2024** Zoning Permit issued for a Change of Use. The former creamery has been changed to a retail store, Appalachian Sportswear. 

- **8-06-2024** Certificate of Appropriateness under Case A24-0285 issued for a revision to the previously approved alterations to the entry door and storefront window on the primary elevation. 

- **4-02-2024** Certificate of Appropriateness under Case A24-0128 issued for alterations to the primary and tertiary elevations including removal of the current awning, reconfiguring the store front, replacement of mismatched brick, and adding a door and exit stairs. 

_**Staff Note: Elevations submitted under Cases A24-0128 and A24-0285 noted brickwork on the primary and rear elevation with statement clean and repoint mortar as needed.**_ 

## **Recent Building History** 

**5-09-2025** A building permit was issued for installation of gas services for a new coffee roaster for Venture Chocolate & Wine. 

4 | P a g e 

**78**
{4}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **5** 

- **3-04-2025** A building permit was issued for interior renovation for an expansion project for Venture Chocolate & Wine; the project is still on-going. 

- **2-03-2025** A building permit was issued for interior demo work for Venture Chocolate & Wine; the project is still on-going. 

- **6-11-2024** Building permit issued for interior renovations to convert the former creamer to retail space for Appalachian Sportswear. Project was completed and a Certificate of Compliance was issued 1-29-2025. 

## **Zoning Analysis (B1 Downtown Core)** 

The following UDO requirements are required to be met for the proposed project, unless superseded by any requirements of the Downtown Boone Local Historic District overlay. 

The proposed exterior would not require a zoning permit as there are no changes to the number or type of features, only repairs to the current façade, nor any changes to the color of the painted brick. 

_**Staff Note: The current work being performed has been permitted and is conforming to UDO requirements. The repairs to the brick façade would be permissible as maintenance outside decisions regarding the historic nature of the property.**_ 

## **Architectural Survey/Designation Report Information** 

The following three documents are central to the Downtown Boone Local Historic District: 

1. Comprehensive Architectural Survey of Downtown Boone, NC – Final Report 

2. Report and Recommendation for the Designation of the Downtown Boone Local Historic District, Boone, NC 

3. Downtown Boone Local Historic District Standards 

The designation report (#2 above), was created using the architectural survey of the downtown area (#1 above) and recommended the Downtown Boone Local Historic District area be designated as a historic overlay district; and the Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards, which are outlined in a separate document (#3 above), are to be applied by the HPC when it considers applications for Certificates of Appropriateness for proposed development within the historic district. 

## **Inventory Classification** 

The following information has been taken from the designation report starting on page 69.   The property inventory found within the report was specifically written to assess the contributing significance and integrity of the district’s resources. Integrity, as determined was based upon the following: 

1. design integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to its original appearance or altered appearance during the period of significance; 

2. material integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to original materials during the period of significance or replacement materials that mimic the appearance of original materials during the period of significance; 

3. locational integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to its original location during the period of significance; 

5 | P a g e 

**79**
{5}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **6** 

4. integrity of association, meaning the building’s relationship to its original or adapted use, function, and purpose during the period of significance; and 

5. integrity of relationship to the district as a whole, meaning the building’s historical importance to the development of downtown Boone’s commercial district during the district’s four periods of growth within the period of significance (1918-1964). 

6 | P a g e 

**80**
{6}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **7** 

## **Inventory Classifications:** 

**CA:** Contributes to the character of the district based on architectural significance 

- **CH:** Contributes to the character of the district based on historical significance related to events or individuals associated with the property 

- **NC:** Non-contributing property **VL:** Vacant lot 

## **Designation Report** 

The Designation Report summary is included on the right (in blue), and the full Architectural Survey summary is included below. 

_**Staff Note: The subject property is classified as CH,CA.**_ 

_**CH means the property contributes to the district based on historical significance related to events or individuals associated with the property.**_ 

_**CA means the property contributes to the character of the district based on architectural significance.**_ 

## **Architectural Survey** 

**WT0595 J.L. Qualls Block (1922)** 603 West King Street 

An especially auspicious year for Downtown Boone’s development was 1922, when local business leaders and the Watauga Democrat continued to promote the local development boom with the slogan, “Watch Boone Grow” (see, for example, the March 2, 1922, issue). One of the first buildings to actually break ground that year was the J. L. Qualls block, a two story, brick, commercial block building with basement, which already had its construction materials on site in March 1922. Built on what appears to have been the old D. J. Cottrell storehouse lot, by July, the brickwork was complete, with the masons shifting to the Jones Block (WT0969) job site just down the street (Deed Book 24, Page 337, and Watauga Democrat, July 20, 1922). This fact, coupled with the remarkable similarity in appearance among the Boone Drug 

_**WT0595 J.L. Qualls Block (1922)—CH,CA** 603 West King Street (2900-88-4900000)_ 

_Built in 1922 as one of three similarly designed, mixed-use properties constructed by the Poe and Triplett firm out of Lenoir as part of the “Watch Boone Grow” campaign, this two-story, commercial block building with basement features a central entrance to a staircase leading to the second-floor apartments, flanked by two storefront on either side, with pilaster divisions highlighting this central entrance. Raised stretchers serve as an unusual jigsaw trim around each of the second floor windows on this north elevation, giving them a pronounced appearance against the recessed plane of the much of the second floor façade. Early tenants included a hardware store and a restaurant, both run by J. L. Qualls, and a grocery store. The building also features a sidewalk staircase descending to basement shops below the west end of the building. From 1923 to 1952, the second floor was home to a hotel operation known mostly as the Carolina Hotel. A fire on Christmas Day 1952 gutted much of the building, after which the second floor was used for apartments and the upper façade of the north elevation was painted._ 

Building (WT0849), the Jones Block, and the Qualls Block suggests that the contractor on all three may have been Poe and Triplett of Lenoir, who are documented as having completed the Boone Drug Building. The most obvious similarity is the central, second floor entrance flanked on either side by 

7 | P a g e 

**81**
{7}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **8** 

storefronts, with pilaster divisions used to segment the central portion of the building. We know that Poe and Triplett was operating in Boone for several years during the early 1920s; both the Administration Building and the Science Building at the Appalachian Training School were their handiwork, and they later completed the Appalachian High School building and the first Cove Creek High School. 

There is some evidence to suggest the Qualls Block was built in stages; newspaper accounts mentioned that construction on the west section, with its exterior access to apartments and space for a “modern café” on the first floor, quickly followed completion of the east section, built for Qualls’s hardware store (Watauga Democrat, October 5, 1922). This may explain the long delay between the announced completion of the brickwork in July 1922 (Watauga Democrat, July 27, 1922) and the eventual completion of the entire commercial block, which was announced in March 1923. The final stages of this work on the west half of the building are visible in a 1923 image in the Historic Boone Collection (HisBoo-1.19.6). When the Qualls Block first opened, it was home to the Qualls Hardware Store, the Qualls and Company Restaurant, and the Cash Grocery Store, operated by H. H. McDougald (Watauga Democrat, March 22, 1923). This grocery store most likely functioned either out of the back of the hardware store or as part of a partitioned store space on the east side of the building, as the 1923 Historic Boone image clearly shows only two storefronts along King Street and no basement access from the sidewalk. Qualls apparently tired of the hardware business rather quickly. In late 1923, Qualls sold out the hardware stock to his son, Ed Qualls, and A. F. Dixon, then converted the second story of the building into the Commercial Hotel, later known as the Carolina Hotel after 1936 (Watauga Democrat, October 4, 1923, and July 16, 1936). 

In 1927, the restaurant space on the first floor of the west portion of the building took on the name of the Princess Café, a popular eatery in Boone through about 1937, even though management of the restaurant changed hands just about every year (Watauga Democrat, October 4, 1928). In February 1931, Ed Qualls, the son of J. L. Qualls, took over management of the Princess (Watauga Democrat, February 12, 1931). Shortly thereafter, the Princess Café also became the base of operations for the Union Bus Terminal until the bus operation moved to the Linville River Railway depot in October 1933 (Watauga Democrat, October 12, 1933). Tenants in the east storefront of the first floor are more difficult to track, as it is not known when either the grocery store or the hardware store closed. By early 1926, references to a store known as The Fashion Shop, operated by Ed Qualls, began appearing in the local paper (for first reference to this business being in the Qualls Building, see Watauga Democrat, November 18, 1926). In October 1929, Ed Qualls sold the business to his father, who then spent the next two years closing out the inventory (Watauga Democrat, October 17, 1929). In 1931, J. B. Brewer opened the Five to Five Store in the same space, which appears to have been partitioned from a selfservice grocery known as the J. & E. Self-Service Store, which had operated in the space since late 1927; later in 1931, the Five to Five took over this space to sell shoes and thus doubled its square footage (Watauga Democrat, May 21, 1931, and October 22, 1931). 

In May 1935, Qualls appears to have created an east side entrance in the alley now occupied by WT0848 to provide egress to a new “Basement Bargain Store” (Watauga Democrat, May 2, 1935). Also occupying the building after 1935 was the Ruth and Louise Shoppe (Watauga Democrat, October 31, 1935), which appears to have taken over part of the old Five to Five Store space (Watauga Democrat, May 2, 1935). That same year, Qualls appears to have opened the Qualls Furniture Store toward the east end of the block, suggesting that Qualls had essentially divided the original storefronts into a total of four storefronts, each with independent access. The following year, Qualls sold the Commercial Hotel business, apparently in conjunction with these renovations to the building, and the name was changed 

8 | P a g e 

**82**
{8}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **9** 

to the Carolina Hotel (Watauga Democrat, July 16, 1936). These renovations are evident in a circa 1936 postcard image (Bob-Bre-02-115), which shows major changes to the west half of the building (the east half is not visible). The most obvious change was the addition of a wooden porch spanning the middle section of the building, with a spindled balustrade around the porch roof. This porch rested on rounded columns with squared pedestals and caps, while the entablature of the porch roof was unusually ornate for the prevailing architecture of Boone at the time. Indeed, its similarities to the appearance of the porch roof of the Daniel Boone Hotel, then located diagonally across King Street, may be a reflection of the competition between the two properties. In any case, the porch was a short-lived feature, as it was no longer present by the time of the 1949 Watauga Centennial Parade (Pal-Bla-04-236). 

A more lasting change was the addition of a basement entrance accessed via a concrete staircase below sidewalk grade at the west end of the Qualls Block. It appears likely that this led to a barbershop, as evinced by a barber pole evident at the top of the staircase in the 1936 postcard image, although two separate shops are now present below grade in this space. By this point in time, the Princess Café appears to have changed names to the Carolina Café, occupying the same space under management by the hotel’s new operator, Milton Young (Watauga Democrat, July 16, 1936). Five years later, Qualls appears to have moved his furniture store out of the east storefront and into the two middle storefronts, with the Elite Shop occupying the east storefront (Watauga Democrat, February 13, 1941, and March 13, 1941). Three years later, Qualls sold the entire building outright to J. R. Craven (Deed Book 59, Page 59, and Watauga Democrat, September 7, 1944), where he opened the Edmisten-Craven Furniture Store. By 1949, Craven Furniture Company still occupied the east half of the first floor of the building, while the Skyline Restaurant was present in the center portion, as seen in a 1949 Watauga County Centennial Parade image (Pal-Bla-04-236), even though Craven had sold the building in 1945. After a succession of owners, the Greene and Wilcox families finally acquired joint ownership in 1948 (Deed Book 64, Page 529), an arrangement that continued until the recent sale of the building to a developer. 

In 1952, a Christmas Day fire gutted much of the building, causing serious damage to Craven Furniture, the Carolina Hotel, the Skyline Café, the City Meat Market (which occupied the western storefront), the Central Barber, and Earl Miller’s watch repair business; the latter two businesses were in the basement area accessed from the street level staircase (Watauga Democrat, January 1, 1953). The level of damage essentially resulted in a complete re-working of the tenants in the building as well as the exterior appearance. The most obvious change was the painting of the exterior brick white, apparently to hide fire damage to the brick. More noteworthy was that the fire appears to have killed Fred Church’s Carolina Hotel business; no evidence of the hotel reopening has been found, and Church was managing Bare’s Department Store by 1954. Presumably, the occupancy of the second floor shifted to apartments thereafter. In 1953, Bill’s Shoe Store moved into the renovated, easternmost storefront, while Palmer’s Photo Shop moved into the second shop from the east (Watauga Democrat, April 16, 1953, and May 7, 1953). Caudill’s, a department store, occupied the third storefront from the east, while the meat market reopened in the west storefront as the City Market and Grocery (Watauga Democrat, May 14, 1953, and September 10, 1953, and 1959 Rhododendron). 

These arrangements appear to have continued for a number of years, excepting a name change from Palmer’s Photo Shop to the Flowers Photo Shop following Palmer Blair’s death in 1957 and the purchase of the business by George Flowers in early 1958. By 1965, however, a number of exterior changes began occurring with the storefronts, as was common throughout Boone during this time, mostly featuring the addition of “modern” treatments such as wood paneling, cedar shake roof overhangs, and other illadvised treatments. By 1965, the former Caudill’s space had become the Fashion Shoppe, while the 

9 | P a g e 

**83**
{9}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **10** 

former City Market space was briefly a McClung’s before becoming a jewelry store known as The Stone (ASU Digital Collection). At the time of the survey in 1988, Jerry Wilson was still operating what was by then known as the Dixie Barber Shop in the basement area off King Street, although he had operated there under several different names over several decades. Shorty’s, a popular local restaurant, was in the former City Market space. By 1992, the City Market space was home to Rochelle’s Deli Restaurant, while the Fashion Shoppe space was the Curiosity Shop. Kelly and Green, a regional photo chain, also operated in the former Flowers space, having bought out Flowers, who then operated his studio out of the rear-accessed basement of the Qualls block until his retirement in 1998. By 1992, the former Bill’s Shoe Store space had become Dancey’s Shoe Store (Watauga Democrat, July 1, 1992). 

Physical changes to the north elevation storefront treatments are too numerous to recount here, aside from what is listed above. At the time of the survey, though, the north elevation generally retained the original appearance of its second floor configuration. Brick appears to be running bond, painted over following the 1952 fire. A continuous rowlock band divides the second floor from the first floor storefronts and essentially functions as a window sill for the six pairs of double, one-over-one, doublehung sash, wooden windows with aluminum storms—features certainly dating no earlier than the 1953 post-fire renovation but set in the original piercings. These six window groups are divided into two sets of three bays by a single, central, one-over-one, double-hung sash, wooden window. Raised stretchers serve as a sort of jigsaw trim around each of the windows, creating a recessed frieze treatment with two narrow pilasters framing the central, single window and rising to the five-course cornice treatment, which has a rowlock band in the center course. Attic vents are visible at the center of each frieze. The roofline is coped with terracotta tiles. 

At the time of the survey, the first floor of the north elevation, reading from east to west, offered a double storefront at its east end, with a recessed, double entry with transomed doors leading into the two shops (King Street Creamery and A Piece of the Past). A metal pole, which dated to at least the 1960s, provided additional support at the sidewalk for the wide, recessed entry, while a projecting, hip roof awning clad in wood shingles hung over these two storefronts. Shop windows appeared to date to the post-fire renovation. Slightly offset to the east of the central, second floor window was a single, first floor door that appeared to provide access to the second floor apartments. The east hip roof awning also covered this doorway. To the west of this door was the third storefront configuration, drastically altered from its post-fire configuration when Caudill’s occupied the space. It consisted of a single, aluminum framed, slightly recessed doorway with narrow, aluminum framed sidelights and a narrow transom light spanning the lower configuration. Aluminum framed shop windows were located just west of the doorway, rejoining the façade plane with a two-light configuration with a brick bulkhead. Wood paneling, apparently dating to the mid-1960s, covered the first floor brick around the storefront. A hip roof awning clad with wood shingles spanned this storefront. To the west of this was the west storefront, also radically altered from the post-fire configuration and entirely clad in wood paneling, with a single, recessed entrance located to the east side of the storefront and a large, single light window at the center. An asphalt-shingled, hip roof awning spanned this storefront. The wood paneling appeared to date to the 1960s as well, although the date of the awning is unknown. 

In early 2019, the present owner began a massive rehabilitation of this building, beginning with the removal of much of the fabric from the north elevation. This work revealed, in part, some portions of earlier façade configurations, including the old Caudill’s sign. While photographs have been taken showing this work, it is not described in detail here, as the façade appearance is likely to change in the coming months. 

10 | P a g e 

**84**
{10}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **11** 

In its original configuration, as seen in the 1928 Sanborn and in a circa 1938 image from the Cy Crumley Scrapbook, the west half of the building appears to have been brick in front (north) but of wood construction with multiple elevations toward the rear (south). The east portion was all brick and two stories in height. At some point before the 1947 Sanborn was completed, the west half of the building was expanded toward the south with one-story brick additions that extended considerably beyond the south elevation of the east half of the building. This configuration is partially visible in the Palmer Blair aerials from 1950 (Pal-Bla-02-002 and Pal-Bla-02-004), showing a garage bay set to the west side of the basement level of the south elevation of the west extension, with three evenly spaced, single windows on the first floor level. The south elevation of the east half was mostly obscured in those images. 

Today, the south elevation of the east section sits on a formed concrete foundation, with what appears to be a former garage bay set to the west side of the basement level now enclosed with a wood panel insert that frames a single wooden door and a one-over-one, double-hung sash, vinyl replacement window set just to the east. Another window at the basement level, visible in a circa 1950 image from the south (Pal-Bla-04-104), has apparently been concreted over. Brickwork on the first floor level begins with a rowlock course functioning as a sill resting on the concrete foundation. The rest of the brickwork on this elevation is generally six-course common bond. The first floor offers, left to right (west to east), a former doorway with surviving deep surround that has been filled in with a wooden panel and a hood vent, presumably kitchen ventilation. Just east of this is a former window opening with a rowlock sill now filled with running bond brick, aside from a single row of headers near the bottom. At the far, east end of the elevation is another doorway, this time retaining what appears to be an original, paneled door with an upper light that has been boarded over. The first floor is divided from the second floor with a projecting, rowlock course. Reading left to right (west to east), there are three proportionately spaced window openings. The first two to the west appear to occupy the original piercings and likely date to the 1953 post-fire renovation. They are one-over-one, double-hung sash, wooden windows with aluminum storms. The east window is smaller, with the lower portion of the original piercing bricked in with common bond brick and a rowlock sill. It is a one-over-one, double-hung sash, wooden window with an aluminum storm. The east elevation of the east section is difficult to see, but it features a stepped parapet roof capped with terracotta coping. At least two, widely-set, second floor window piercings are visible along this elevation over the roof of WT0848 to the east. The west elevation of the east section that rises slightly above the south portion of the west section also features a stepped parapet but is otherwise not visible. 

Photographs from the 1950s and 1960s of the west portion of the building from the south and southeast (Pal-Bla-02-002, Pal-Bla-04-104, and 5015_096_03) clearly show that the southern half of the west portion of the building was again dramatically altered sometime after 1963, when a third level (second floor) was added to the rear portion of the building, effectively bringing the entire height of the west section in line with the front (north elevation) of the building. The east elevation of the west extension offers a mostly featureless brick wall of six-course common bond, although there is a bizarre feature apparently intended to demarcate the basement level from the upper levels. Here is a repeating brick design consisting of single soldiers interrupting the normal flow of the brick pattern approximately every foot or so, with a rowlock resting on top of the soldier and creating a modified Flemish bond in just that one course with the rowlocks in it. Also, near the southwest corner of the east section of the building is a window opening with a soldier course lintel that has been bricked in. A stepped parapet with terracotta coping is evident along the east side of the west section. The west elevation of the west section offers similar details, except that the bizarre feature at the top of the basement level consists of soldiers interrupting one of the header courses. Another window opening on this side with a soldier 

11 | P a g e 

**85**
{11}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **12** 

course lintel has been bricked in. Spalling is evident on the upper reaches of the west elevation of the west section, and this wall is capped with a stepped parapet coped in terracotta tiles. 

The south elevation of the west section has clearly been altered over time, beyond the addition of the third level. The entire elevation is clad in six-course common bond brick, with no seam or break in the masonry pattern apparent from the addition of the third level. While the soldier course lintel of the basement-level garage bay is still evident, the bay itself has been bricked in, with openings for a steel door at the west end of the bay and a steel, double casement window at the east end of the bay similar to those on the third level. At the east end of the basement level is a double metal door covered by by a shed-roof awning clad in asphalt or possibly asbestos shingles. The first floor level has also been dramatically altered. Originally consisting of three, equally spaced, one-over-one, wooden windows, all three window piercings have been altered. The west piercing has been altered to a metal doorway reached via a rickety wooden staircase descending to the south alley. The middle window has been bricked in, and the east window has been partially filled in at bottom with an ill-fitting rowlock sill and a one-over-one, double-hung sash wooden window in an awkward wooden frame, behind which there appear to be metal bars in a crosshatch pattern. The third level features three, equally spaced, steel, double casement windows of three lights with fixed upper lights essentially serving as a transom. Each window offers a rowlock sill. 

_**Staff Note: Most of the images referenced above have been included within the historical photo section of the report. Bob-Bre-02-115: images 9 & 10, Pal-Bla-04-236: images 7 & 8, Pal-Bla-02-002: images 31 & 32; and Pal-Bla-04-104: images 5 & 6.**_ 

## **Library of Congress - Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps** 

The Library of Congress has made Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps from 1928 and 1947 accessible. As these years fall within the historic district’s period of significance (1918-1964), these maps will be used when the property in question, or area of the property in question, can be viewed within these maps. The content of the Library of Congress online Sanborn Maps Collection is in the public domain and is free to use and reuse. 

12 | P a g e 

**86**
{12}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **13** 

_Sanborn Fire Insurance Map from Boone, Watauga County, North Carolina_ . Sanborn Map Company, Jan, 1928. Map. https://www.loc.gov/item/sanborn06383_001/. 

13 | P a g e 

**87**
{13}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **14** 

_Sanborn Fire Insurance Map from Boone, Watauga County, North Carolina_ . Sanborn Map Company, Jun, 1947. Map. https://www.loc.gov/item/sanborn06383_002/. 

14 | P a g e 

**88**
{14}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **15** 

_Sanborn Fire Insurance Map from Boone, Watauga County, North Carolina_ . Sanborn Map Company, Jun, 1947. Map. https://www.loc.gov/item/sanborn06383_002/. 

15 | P a g e 

**89**
{15}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **16** 

## **Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook Analysis** 

## **Narrative** 

Relevant design standards from UDO Appendix D, Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook, Design Standards for COMMERCIAL/RESIDENTIAL Properties within the District, are outlined below.   These Standards for COMMERCIAL/RESIDENTIAL properties are intended to address many of the most common issues to arise during renovations, additions, and new construction in the District. Where the Standards are silent on a particular issue or concern, the HPC will rely upon the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation to guide their review of the proposed work under the COA process and any subsequent recommendations. 

## **Design Standards for Commercial Properties** 

## **“Commercial Property” Defined** 

A **commercial property** within the District is any property whose purpose-built function at the time of construction was primarily to serve a commercial, institutional, or governmental purpose or use. More specifically, commercial properties include 1) any building whose original configuration included commercial, institutional, or governmental uses on the ground floor accessed via the entrance(s) located on the primary elevation, even if residential spaces were available elsewhere in the building (such as a commercial block building with stores on the first floor and apartments on the second floor), or 2) any building with a garage bay or bays on the ground floor accessed via the entrance(s) located on the primary elevation and commercial, institutional, or governmental spaces located elsewhere in the building (such as a garage building with an office or store located on an upper floor or in the basement). 

Any property within the District whose purpose-built function at the time of construction was to serve solely as a residence for long-term (greater than 30 days) occupants, even if the property currently serves a commercial use, is still considered a residential property. For standards for residential properties, please see the “Standards for Residential Properties within the District” section elsewhere in this publication. 

## **1. Storefronts, Upper Facades, Side Elevations, and Rear Elevations** 

Downtown Boone is dominated by historic properties that reflect the commercial block architecture that was so common and influential during the period from 1910 to 1960 in many American towns and cities. In the case of the District, commercial block development began around 1919 and continued to the early 1960s. Central to this architecture is the importance of the storefront itself, whose familiar architectural details—large display windows, transom bars and windows, clerestory recessed entries, and prominent cornice and corbelling work—frequently signaled to customers not only the function of a business but also the quality of its wares. Many other elements—including projecting, flat awnings anchored to the façade with cables or steel rods, or fabric awnings amounted on metal frames, hinged or unhinged— provided customers with shelter from the elements while window shopping or otherwise enhanced the shopping experience. After 1950, many of these architectural details were removed, either in response to decay of these features or in an effort to “update” a building to the stylistic preferences of a later time. One such example is the Appalachian Theatre on West King Street, whose original Art Deco marquee and structural glass were removed during the late 1970s in response to safety concerns. Other elements— most notably transoms and clerestory windows, as well as the details of upper facades—were simply covered over and may still survive today underneath modern additions to the facades of many of Boone’s historic downtown properties in the District. 

Similarly, secondary and tertiary elevations of many of Boone’s historic commercial properties are vital to the character and integrity of its downtown commercial district. Often, significant side (secondary) elevations are located on corner buildings adjacent to two or even three streets, but sometimes such 

16 | P a g e 

**90**
{16}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **17** 

details are visible on mid-block buildings separated from nearby buildings by an alleyway or a vacant lot. Many of these buildings retain original fenestration, entrances, brickwork, and/or advertisements (some of the “ghost ad” variety) that contribute in their own significant way to the architectural character of the downtown historic district. Similarly, rear (tertiary) elevations can possess many of these same characteristics and also reveal much about the history of a property because of their frequently utilitarian design intended for the workers, owners, and residents who most often saw these rear elevations. 

In an effort to preserve what remains of the District’s historic commercial architecture and encourage the reconstruction or rehabilitation of elements that have been removed or covered over, the standards for storefronts, upper facades, and other elevations are intended to facilitate preservation and reconstruction wherever possible while also addressing new construction and its compatibility with the rest of the District. 

- 1.1 Whenever possible, historic storefronts and storefront features such as entrance configurations, display windows, doors, clerestory windows, transom bars and windows, bulkheads, corbelling, cornice work, windows, stonework, stringcourses, structural glass, and other architectural flourishes should be retained and preserved. When repairing these features, retain and preserve in place original elements as much as possible. If repair is not possible, replace damaged elements with materials that match the originals in composition, design, texture, color, and other visual qualities. 

- 1.2 When reconstructing an historic storefront, upper façade, or other elevation, use historical research and evidence as the basis for the design. Reconstructed storefronts should incorporate original dimensions, proportions, and architectural elements. 

- 1.3 In making changes to storefronts or other elevations to comply with code or accessibility requirements, avoid destroying historic materials and features and select configurations that have minimal intrusion or impact on the character-defining aspects of the property in question. 

- 1.4 When original or early storefronts or upper facades no longer exist, are too deteriorated to save, or cannot be reconstructed based on the available documentary evidence, retain the commercial character and any salvageable architectural details through a contemporary design that is compatible with the scale, materials, color, style, design, and texture of the surviving and surrounding historic buildings. 

- 1.5 Original upper facade windows should not be removed and replaced with modern materials, nor is the enclosing or bricking in of upper facade windows appropriate. When upper floor windows must be replaced, use new windows that match the original windows in configuration, appearance, and materials. 

- 1.6 It is never appropriate to cover an historic upper facade. Whenever possible, non-historic coverings of upper facades, including metal, stucco, or faux mountain village fronts and porches, should be removed and underlying original architectural elements repaired and restored. 

- 1.7 Historic painted advertisements are a significant element of the architectural and commercial history of downtown Boone, and their preservation and restoration are recommended whenever feasible, even if the product or store advertised is no longer available or in business. 

17 | P a g e 

**91**
{17}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **18** 

- 1.8 Facade details of side (secondary) and rear (tertiary) elevations should always be retained and preserved if possible. When repairing these features, retain and preserve in place original elements as much as possible. If repair is not possible, replace damaged elements with materials that match the originals in composition, design, texture, color, and other visual qualities. If there is evidence of a rear public entrance that is no longer extant, use historical research and other evidence to reconstruct or provide an equivalent rear entrance whenever possible. 

- 1.9 Utility lines, mechanical equipment, pipes, garbage receptacles, and other service items on side (secondary) and rear (tertiary) elevations—whether old or new—should be screened from public view whenever possible. Unnecessary or out-of-service elements should be removed unless they are essential to the historic character of the property. 

## **4. Masonry** 

Many commercial properties in the District are composed of brick or stone masonry, and it is imperative that original masonry materials—many of which have a weathered appearance reflecting the history of the building—remain preserved whenever possible. For this reason, masonry should never be cleaned unless it is determined that perceived “dirt” is actually accumulated deposits and not the effects of weathering. If cleaning is pursued, always use the gentlest method available, preferably with low-pressure water, a mild, non-caustic detergent, and a natural bristle brush where needed. In addition, while repointing is sometimes necessary when mortar is missing or moisture problems have developed, it should only be completed in a manner that avoids smearing the mortar onto the surface of the masonry. 

Terracotta, stucco, and concrete are other masonry elements that are occasionally found on historic commercial properties in Boone. In addition, many historic commercial properties feature chimneys, arches, quoins, lintels, sills, cornices, corbelling, and pediments that are all essential to the historic character of the building in question. 

- 4.1 It is NEVER appropriate to paint masonry materials, such as brick, concrete block, cast concrete, or stone, that were historically unpainted, including masonry associated with foundations. If there is historic precedent for painting of masonry in the building’s original historic context, it should be completed using colors that can be documented with original historic photographic evidence or analysis of original paint samples. 

   - Removal of non-historic paint from masonry can be challenging and problematic, and doing so requires strict adherence to preservation guidance published by the National Park Service. Generally speaking, such work should be completed by a professional trained in historic preservation methods and using a chemical paint remover specifically intended for masonry and the gentlest application means possible. In some instances, inappropriately applied paints may not be removable without damaging the underlying masonry, so it is always advisable to test removal techniques in an area that is not easily visible to the public. The HPC will provide guidance in such instances on the best approach to addressing unusual paint removal challenges. 

- 4.2 Whenever feasible, historic masonry, including decorative masonry features, should be repaired rather than replaced or covered. When replacement is necessary, it should always be completed using traditional materials of like composition, size, color, shape, pattern, texture, and quality to the originals that are being replaced. 

18 | P a g e 

**92**
{18}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **19** 

- 4.3 Re-pointing of masonry should also be completed using materials that duplicate the existing mortar in appearance, texture, and color. Colored sands or mineral-pigmented mortar can be used to achieve a match with the existing mortar. Portland cement should be avoided in mortar, as it may produce a mortar that is stronger than the surrounding masonry, potentially causing the masonry to crumble. 

- 4.4 Unless there is a specific reason for using waterproof or water-repellent coatings (e.g., brick that has previously been sandblasted, creating a porosity problem), these treatments should be avoided, as they can accelerate deterioration of historic masonry. 

- 4.5 When repairing or replacing masonry or mortar, take care to maintain the alignment, bond pattern, joint spacing, color, texture, and size of the original masonry. 

- 4.6 Unless there is historic precedent for its use on the building in question, stucco should never be applied to existing masonry walls, as it can trap moisture that accelerates the deterioration of the masonry. If historic stucco is being repaired, the stucco mixture should duplicate the original appearance, color, and texture as closely as possible. 

- 4.7 Masonry should never be treated with abrasive stripping methods, sandblasting, or highpressure water cleaning, as these methods almost always immediately damage the “skin” of the brick and the mortar joints, and they can make the masonry more susceptible to spalling, or flaking of the masonry surface as a result of the introduction of moisture. Masonry should only be cleaned using the gentlest method available, including low-pressure water, soft natural brushes, and, if necessary, non-abrasive, non-toxic chemicals that will not damage the masonry being treated. 

- 4.8 All historic masonry architectural features, including cornices, moldings, chimneys, and other decorative flourishes, should be retained as they are essential to the architectural character and integrity of the building. 

- 4.9 Deteriorated masonry chimneys and boiler stacks should never be shortened or covered with parging. Instead, the original chimney configuration should be restored on historic properties using historically appropriate masonry and mortar materials. In addition, the design of the original chimney should be maintained, including corbelling, clay chimney pots, and other original decorative features. Metal chimney caps may be added if they are unobtrusive and do not alter the design of the chimney, but metal vent pipes that protrude through the top of the chimney are not appropriate. Wooden box chimneys and chimneys made of simulated brick or stone are also inappropriate. 

- 4.10 Proper maintenance of masonry is essential to its long-term survival. Property owners should conduct periodic checks for moisture problems and cracking, and they should remove any vegetation that adheres to masonry (such as ivy and other vine plants) or that hinders ventilation and drainage around masonry elements. Vegetation should never be sprayed with defoliants, pesticides, or other harsh chemicals.  Please consult with the Planning and Inspections Department for guidance on removal of vegetation on masonry. 

- 4.11 Spalled masonry should never be repaired using cement infills or other patchwork repairs that will only further degrade the historic materials and alter the historic appearance of the building. Instead, spalled or delaminated bricks should be replaced with a similar brick stock or salvaged historic brick that matches the original in color, size, and appearance. New 

19 | P a g e 

**93**
{19}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **20** 

mortar joints should match the originals in color, composition, texture, and method of application. 

20 | P a g e 

**94**
{20}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **21** 

## **Automatic Conditions of Approval** 

The following conditions are automatically included and a part of any approval. 

- Where there is a conflict between the application information and the plans submitted June 26, 2025, the plans control. Insignificant deviations may be permitted to comply with the requirements of the UDO. 

- Any commitments and representations concerning the proposed exterior modification made by the applicant or its representatives at the public hearing shall also become a condition of the permit, and a basis for a stop work order and/or permit revocation if violated. 

- The applicant shall submit the necessary applications, plans, details and specifications which meet the requirements of the Town Code, UDO, Building Code and any other applicable codes for review and approval necessary to issue Zoning and Building Permits. 

## **Historic Preservation Commission Procedure** 

In considering this application for a COA the HPC shall base their decisions solely on the basis of competent, material and substantial evidence entered into the record via the application packet and sworn testimony at the public hearing. 

When making the motion for approval, the Commission should consider that unless the Commission explicitly orders otherwise, every approval is conditioned upon the development being completed in accordance with the plans submitted by the applicant, the commitments and representations concerning the proposed development made by the applicant and representatives at the public hearing, and final conformity with all requirements of the UDO. 

The question before the Historic Preservation Commission is whether or not the proposed development is congruous (i.e., in agreement, in harmony) with the special character of the historic district.  If the proposed exterior modification is congruous, the Commission shall issue the requested COA.  If the proposed exterior modification is incongruous (not in agreement, not in harmony) with the special character of the historic district, the Commission shall deny the requested COA.  The Commission shall approve, approve with conditions, or the deny the COA by majority vote. 

**Vote:** The proposed development  **is congruous  OR**  **is incongruous** with the special character of the Downtown Boone Local Historic District and is approved subject to the following conditions (as warranted): 

## 1. Conditions: 

_**Criteria for Conditions: The Commission may issue approval subject to reasonable conditions necessary to carry out the purposes served by the historic district (see G.S. 160D-940, 160D-947(a)).  The purposes of the historic district are to (i) safeguard the heritage of the town insofar as the Historic District embodies important elements of the town’s culture, history, architectural history, and/or prehistory, and (ii) to promote the use and conservation of the district for the education, pleasure, and enrichment of the residents of the town and/or the State as a whole, see North Carolina G.S. §160D-940, 944, 947(a).**_ 

21 | P a g e 

**95**
{21}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **22** 

## **Historic Photos** 

Below is a collection of historical photos of the subject property, obtained through a collaboration with Digital Watauga. The photos are displayed in their original size and resolution, as well as in a cropped version that highlights the main features of interest. For each photo, there is a citation. 

_**Staff Note: Planning Staff did not alter or edit the photos in any way, but only arranged them in this document for presentation purposes. Photos attached here are the best available with the clearest and most complete images of the subject property.  Any commentary on the images is from the Digital Watauga technician(s) who found and sent the images to Planning Staff.**_ 

Image courtesy of the Downtown Boone Development Association Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Downtown Boone Development Association Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

22 | P a g e 

**96**
{22}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **23** 

Image courtesy of the Alfred and Daisy Adams Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Alfred and Daisy Adams Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

23 | P a g e 

**97**
{23}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **24** 

Image courtesy of the Palmar Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Palmar Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

24 | P a g e 

**98**
{24}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **25** 

Image courtesy of the Palmar Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

25 | P a g e 

**99**
{25}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **26** 

Image courtesy of the Bobby Brendell Postcard Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Bobby Brendell Postcard Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

26 | P a g e 

**100**
{26}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **27** 

Image courtesy of the Rosalea Dorsey Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Rosalea Dorsey Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

27 | P a g e 

**101**
{27}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **28** 

Image courtesy of the Von and Vickey Hagaman Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Von and Vickey Hagaman Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

28 | P a g e 

**102**
{28}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **29** 

Image courtesy of the Historic Boone Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

29 | P a g e 

**103**
{29}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **30** 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

30 | P a g e 

**104**
{30}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **31** 

Image courtesy of the Linda H. Miller Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Linda H. Miller Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

31 | P a g e 

**105**
{31}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **32** 

Image courtesy of the John Ward Family Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the John Ward Family Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

32 | P a g e 

**106**
{32}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **33** 

Image courtesy of the John Ward Family Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the John Ward Family Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

33 | P a g e 

**107**
{33}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **34** 

Image courtesy of the George Flowers Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the George Flowers Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

34 | P a g e 

**108**
{34}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **35** 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

35 | P a g e 

**109**
{35}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **36** 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

36 | P a g e 

**110**
{36}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **37** 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

37 | P a g e 

**111**
{37}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **38** 

Image courtesy of the Downtown Boone Development Association Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

Image courtesy of the Downtown Boone Development Association Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

38 | P a g e 

**112**
{38}------------------------------------------------
Case A25-0482 Qualls Building - COA| **39** 

Image courtesy of the George Flowers Collection, Digital Watauga Project 

39 | P a g e 

**113**
