{0}------------------------------------------------
Exhibit 6 

C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **28** 

## **Staff Report** 

## **June 11, 2024** 

## **Case A24-0287 642 W King LLC - Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Work** 

## Table of Contents 

Request ......................................................................................................................................................... 1 Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................... 2 History ........................................................................................................................................................... 2 Parcel Information ........................................................................................................................................ 3 Architectural Survey/Designation Report Information ................................................................................. 4 Inventory Classification ............................................................................................................................. 4 Designation Report/Architectural Survey Property Summary ................................................................. 6 Library of Congress - Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps ................................................................................... 11 Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook Analysis ................................. 15 Design Standards for Commercial Properties Within the District .......................................................... 15 Automatic Conditions of Approval .............................................................................................................. 19 Historic Preservation Commission Procedure ............................................................................................ 20 Historic Photos ............................................................................................................................................ 20 

## **Request** 

Chelsea Garrett of 642 West King, LLC has submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Work for 640-642 West King Street (WT0819 Boone Garage/Hodges Tire) located in the Downtown Boone Local Historic District to amend the previously-approved storefront with the addition of a light fixture on the primary façade, already installed, and reconfiguring the front courtyard area from patterned concrete to a combination of concrete and a mulched area with brick inlayed pavers. The subject property is outlined in green on the map on page 2. 

The Table of Minor Work and Major Work, located in both UDO Article 8, Subsection 8.05.03 and Appendix D, requires the applicant to obtain a (COA) for alterations of windows and/or doors on the primary elevations. 

_**Staff Notes**_ can be found throughout the report marked in _**bold green italicized text**_ . 

**Packet Pg. 107** [|
{1}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **2** 

## **Zoning Map** 

## **History** 

11/29/2022 

The Boone Historic Preservation Commission approved a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) to alter the primary elevation including renovating and replacing stucco and adding textured concrete to the front courtyard. 

**Packet Pg. 108** [
{2}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **3** 

**Parcel Information Address:** 642 W. King Street **Property Owner:** 642 W. King Street, LLC **Watauga County PIN:** 2900-89-3129-000 **Lot size (total):** .20 Acres **Jurisdiction:** Town of Boone **Access:** W. King Street (State maintained) and S. Depot Street (Town maintained) **SFHA:** Yes **Watershed District:** No **Corridor District:** No **NCD:** No **Viewshed:** No **Steep Slope:** No **Transitional Zone:** No **Current Zoning:** B1 Downtown Core, Downtown Historic District Overlay 

The B1 Downtown Core, together with the B1 Downtown Interface District encompass the Town of Boone’s downtown area and represent, in large measure, the remaining vestiges of the Town’s historic character. Regulations in these districts are intended to preserve and maintain a small town, high country atmosphere. Preservation and adaptive reuse of existing historic buildings are encouraged and new construction shall be appropriately scaled to be sympathetic to the existing built environment. Design and regulatory standards for these districts reinforce the character of the downtown as a pedestrian friendly area by encouraging architectural solutions that are visually interesting, and are compatible in scale and character to the surrounding area. To help accomplish this, the area is divided into two (2) districts, each with its own character and scale which contribute to the overall vitality of the downtown area. Identification of the districts is listed below: 

1. B1 Downtown Core District: The Downtown Core District is the center of the downtown area and contains the greatest concentration of historic commercial buildings. This district establishes a continuous building facade at the street frontage to strengthen the identity of downtown as a pedestrian destination where pedestrians feel comfortable through the careful selection of building materials, human scale design, and ground floor fenestration. Standards in this district reinforce the historic nature of the existing built environment through regulation of appearance, height, scale and mass. 

2. B1 Downtown Interface District: The Downtown Interface District serves as a gateway into the downtown area and as the transition between the B1 Downtown Core District and adjacent zoning districts. Development in this 

**Packet Pg. 109**
{3}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **4** 

district must be sensitive to issues of compatibility with the Downtown Core District as well as surrounding zoning districts, many which are low-density residential. 

_**Staff Note: The Downtown Boone Local Historic District is an overlay district, which is a district that overlaps, in this case, the general use B1 zoning districts and contains standards in addition to the underlying general use district zoning standards. Where requirements conflict, overlay district standards supersede.**_ 

||**Zoning & Use of Adjacent Properties**|**Zoning & Use of Adjacent Properties**|
|---|---|---|
||**Adjacent Zoning**|**Adjacent Land Use**|
|North|B1, Downtown Core, Downtown Boone Local<br>Historic District|Retail|
|East|B1, Downtown Core, Downtown Boone Local<br>Historic District|Retail|
|South|B1, Downtown Interface|Restaurant, Retail|
|West|B1, Downtown Core, Downtown Boone Local<br>Historic District|Restaurant|



## **Architectural Survey/Designation Report Information** 

The following three documents are central to the Downtown Boone Local Historic District: 

1. Comprehensive Architectural Survey of Downtown Boone, NC – Final Report 

2. Report and Recommendation for the Designation of the Downtown Boone Local Historic District, Boone, NC 

3. Downtown Boone Local Historic District Standards 

The designation report (#2 above), was created using the architectural survey of the downtown area (#1 above) and recommended the Downtown Boone Local Historic District area be designated as a historic overlay district; and the Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards, which are outlined in a separate document (#3 above), are to be applied by the HPC when it considers applications for Certificates of Appropriateness for proposed development within the historic district. 

## **INVENTORY CLASSIFICATION** 

The following information has been taken from the designation report starting on page 69.   The property inventory found within the report was specifically written to assess the contributing significance and integrity of the district’s resources. Integrity, as determined was based upon the following: 

1. design integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to its original appearance or altered appearance during the period of significance; 

**Packet Pg. 110**
{4}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **5** 

2. material integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to original materials during the period of significance or replacement materials that mimic the appearance of original materials during the period of significance; 

3. locational integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to its original location during the period of significance; 

4. integrity of association, meaning the building’s relationship to its original or adapted use, function, and purpose during the period of significance; and 

5. integrity of relationship to the district as a whole, meaning the building’s historical importance to the development of downtown Boone’s commercial district during the district’s four periods of growth within the period of significance (1918-1964). 

## **Inventory Classifications:** 

- **CA:** Contributes to the character of the district based on architectural significance 

- **CH:** Contributes to the character of the district based on historical significance related to events or individuals associated with the property 

- **NC:** Non-contributing property 

- **VL:** Vacant lot 

**Packet Pg. 111**
{5}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **6** 

## **DESIGNATION REPORT/ARCHITECTURAL SURVEY PROPERTY SUMMARY** 

The Designation Report summary is included on the right (in blue), and the full Architectural Survey summary is included below. The subject property is classified as “CH” meaning the property contributes to the district based on historical significance related to events or individuals associated with the property. The parcel has two entries in these reports for 642 W. King Street. 

## **1. WT0819 Boone Garage Circa (1922)** 

## **642 West King St.** 

This building, which is the east half of the current di Santi, Watson, Capua, and Wilson law firm, appears to have been built as a mechanic’s garage in 1922. Because of this tenancy, past surveys have mistakenly grouped this building with WT0894, a related property, as a singular complex. This survey update remedies that confusion. 

Walter Johnson acquired the property from J. W. and Mattie Jones (Deed Book 28, Page 477) in 1922, with a stipulation that a two-story, brick building would be built on the site, to which Jones would be permitted to attach his own building on his lot to the east (see also Watauga Democrat, April 27, 1922). Two years later, F. C. and Verta Ward bought the “Boone Garage” from Walter and Lillie Johnson. The Wards sold the “Boone Garage” in 1927 to A. G. Miller (Deed Book 35, Page 304), who appears to have operated as the “Miller Moretz Motor Company” in the late 1920s (Watauga Democrat, February 7, 1929). The building has been drastically altered numerous times in the years since. By January 1935, the building fell into default, at which time the Watauga Building & Loan Association sold the property to A. E. Hodges (Deed Book 43, Page 493). Hodges retained the building until July 1940, when he sold it to R. W. Colvard (Deed Book 52, Page 401). Colvard also obtained WT0894 that same year, at which point the two buildings became linked in the minds of members of the community. For details on the west building, see WT0894. 

This complex of two-story buildings (WT0819 and WT0894) on the south elevation now consists of a uniform, running bond, brick veneer that covers both buildings. This represents a significant change 

## _**WT0819 Boone Garage (1922)—CH**_ 

_642 West King Street (2900-89-3129-000, shared parcel with WT0894)_ 

_Originally built in 1922 as the Boone Garage, this twostory, brick building was constructed simultaneously with WT0591 to the east and originally had a south elevation that was flush with the sidewalk at King Street and featured an enclosed second floor with an open garage area underneath. After a string of automotive tenants, the Hodges Tire Company removed the second floor overhang about 1937, cladding the new façade in natural stone, with two double bays of one-over-one, doublehung sash windows on the second floor and a large, arched, garage bay set to the west side of the first floor. Substantial alterations followed again before 1963 and again after 1988 to the present configuration, which presents as a uniform brick veneer, which continues onto WT0894 to the west and onto the west wall of WT0591 to the east (although it is presently peeling away from the latter and in danger of collapse). Fenestration patterns of the second floor are radically altered from their earlier appearances, while the first floor offers three side-byside, plate glass windows that do not resemble earlier configurations. Despite these radical changes, the building is an important example of the adaptive changes wrought on the district’s oldest buildings as uses changed. Removal of the current veneer may reveal the natural stone façade dating to 1937 and offer an opportunity for historically intriguing façade rehabilitation._ 

from the appearance of the east building (WT0819) in 1936, as seen in the H. Lee Waters film of Boone (Cec-Gre-01-001), when the two-story structure extended all the way to the sidewalk on West King Street, flush with the south elevation of WT0591 to the east. This extension consisted of an enclosed second floor 

**Packet Pg. 112**
{6}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **7** 

with an open garage area underneath. Sometime after 1936 Waters film but before July 7, 1938, when a photo of the building ran with a Hodges Tire Company advertisement in the Watauga Democrat, Hodges removed the second floor overhang and trimmed back the building footprint to a position slightly forward of WT0894. He also appears to have clad the new façade in natural stone, with two double bays of oneover-one, double-hung sash, wooden windows on the second floor and a large, arched garage bay set to the west side of the first floor (the east side of the first floor was obscured in the image). This configuration was dramatically altered again before 1963 (His-Boo-1.43.5), when WT0819 included three sets of louvered awning windows on the second floor, the outer bays consisting of two four-light, vertical runs and the center bay consisting of one four-light, vertical run. Terracotta coping ran along the low parapet roof. Between the first and second floors was a pronounced flat awning that wrapped onto the modified west wall of WT0591 and the south elevation of the west building of this complex. The first floor of the WT0819 is more difficult to decipher from images from this period, but it appears to have included a large, aluminum-frame shop window configuration of two large, side-by-side, plate glass windows to the west and a single doorway with small transom immediately east of these windows, while a second aluminum frame plate glass window, perhaps one-over-one, was located in the east corner. This configuration appears to have survived until sometime before the 1988 survey (see WT0591), when images show that the second floor windows had been modified to a double bay of six-over-six, double-hung sash windows flanked by shutters to the west and a single six-over-six, double-hung sash window flanked by shutters at center. The east window bay is not visible, but presumably continued this alteration pattern. Parking was available in front of the south elevation. 

At an unknown date after 1988, the east building was further altered to its present configuration. The terracotta coping survives, and WT0819 still steps out slightly to the south from WT0894, but the second floor windows are now, single-light, fixed plate glass windows with aluminum frames. The flat awning between the first and second floors has been removed entirely and replaced with a run of corrugated metal paneling with a border. The first floor has two sets of three side-by-side, plate glass windows with aluminum frames. It should be noted that the brick veneer that wraps onto the west wall of WT0591 is separating from that building and is in danger of collapse. A large landscaped area is now located in front of WT0819. 

**Packet Pg. 113**
{7}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **8** 

## **2. WT0894 W. R. Winkler Tire Company Building (1929/addition circa 1947) 642 West King** 

This building, which is the west half of the current di Santi, Watson, Capua, and Wilson law firm, was built by W. R. Winkler as a tire store in 1929. Because of this current tenancy and various changes to the building in the distant past, previous surveys have mistakenly grouped this building with WT0819 as a singular complex. This survey update remedies that confusion. 

The W. R. Winkler Tire Company Building was completed in 1929 and was initially home to the Central Tire Company, one of W. R. Winkler’s several auto-related businesses in Boone at the time (Watauga Democrat, October 4, 1928, and February 7, 1929). W. R. Winkler purchased the west building property on August 15, 1927, from S. B. and Julia Sullivan (Deed Book 35, Page 403). A year later, the October 4, 1928, article described the construction of a new building with the precise dimensions of this lot. The first floor was intended to contain a salesroom for tires, while the second floor would “house a complete vulcanizing and battery rebuilding plant.” Winkler sold this property to R. W. Colvard in 1940 (Deed Book 52, Page 402), and Colvard purchased WT0819 that same year. Colvard then operated various garage and auto-related businesses in this property and WT0819 for decades, at which point the two buildings became linked in the minds of members of the community. 

The south elevation of this complex of two-story buildings now consists of a uniform, running bond, brick veneer that covers both buildings. This represents a significant change from the appearance of the west portion of the building in 1936, as seen in the H. Lee Waters film of Boone (Cec-Gre-01-001). At that time, the south elevation of WT0894 consisted of three slightly separated, one-over-one, doublehung sash wooden windows, all mounted on a brick face of unknown bond that was slightly recessed 

_**WT0894 W. R. Winkler Tire Company Building (1929/addition ca. 1947)—CH** 642 West King Street (2900-89-3129-000, shared parcel with WT0894)_ 

_W. R. “Ralph” Winkler had this two-story, brick, commercial block building constructed in 1929 to house the Central Tire Company, one of Winkler’s several automotive businesses of the early twentieth century, and the building remained a tire store under various owners for several decades thereafter. The current brick veneer, which continues onto WT0819 to the east, offers a substantially more uniform appearance than the original brick face that was slightly recessed from pronounced pilasters at each corner of the south elevation. The first floor originally featured a large storefront entrance with a leaded glass, clerestory window, three large, plate glass windows, and a single recessed entry, while the second floor offered three slightly separated, one-over-one, double hung sash wooden windows separated from the first floor by a decorative band of alternating soldiers and headers. This configuration survived perhaps as late as 1988, after which the second floor windows were converted to fixed, metal-framed lights and the first floor storefront was completely reworked to its present configuration. The west elevation, which fronts on North Depot Street, has also been radically altered from its original appearance. A one-story addition at the rear was completed in 1947 to serve as a recapping area for Colvard Chevrolet, occupying a former alleyway leading from North Depot Street to the Jones House property. It is unclear whether any of the original brick detailing survives under the present treatments on the south and west elevations. Despite these substantial changes, the building is significant as one of the several late-1920s commercial infill projects following the establishment of Boone’s revitalized commercial center._ 

_East side of Depot Street between West King Street and Queen Street_ 

**Packet Pg. 114**
{8}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **9** 

from flanking brick pilasters at the southwest and southeast corners of the building. Above these windows was corbelling that rose to the parapet roof. Between the first and second floors, a decorative band of one soldier to three headers ran the full length of the south elevation and wrapped onto the west elevation. The first floor was dominated by a large, storefront entrance consisting of a leaded glass, clerestory window, apparently surmounted by a soldier course run, underneath of which were three large, plate glass windows in a wooden frame, with a single, recessed entry between the first and second windows from the east. This configuration appears to have been essentially the same in 1963 (His-Boo1.43.5) and perhaps 1988 (survey images associated with adjacent buildings are not clear), except that the leaded glass, clerestory window had been paneled over, presumably for insulation purposes. 

Today, this west building has an appearance that resembles its original appearance, with notable changes. Roofline coping is now aluminum. The second floor windows have been replaced with single, metal-frame, fixed plate glass windows, while the original clerestory has been uncovered and replaced with a four-light, metal frame clerestory. The corrugated metal band from the east building (WT0819) continues onto this building between the clerestory windows and the entrance below. The decorative brick band and the soldier course band survive. The first floor portion of the south elevation consists of a centered, singledoor, recessed entrance flanked by inverted, plate glass windows, with single, plate glass windows on either of this entrance flush with the south elevation. Brick pavers and plantings fill the area in front of the west building, while a park bench with a seated statue of Doc Watson (installed 2011) sits on the southwest corner of the lot. 

The west elevation of the west building has also changed since 1936. At that time, existing photos suggest that the decorative brick band wrapped onto the west elevation, while the first floor had at least one large window of unknown specifics and at least one one-over-one, double-hung sash, wooden window near the southwest corner. By 1963, the flat awning treatment visible on the south elevation and the west elevation of WT0591 also wrapped onto the west elevation of this west building. At least four one-overone, double-hung sash windows with brick sills were visible at that time on the second floor of the west elevation, all of them probably original. The first floor possessed a single, wood-paneled door with four upper lights located at the northwest corner, with a one-over-one, metal frame window (apparently a replacement) occupying an opening just south of this door. At the southwest corner was an apparently complex window configuration that may have projected out onto the sidewalk underneath the awning. Two additional, small, fixed windows were visible to the north of this bizarre window configuration. 

Today, the second floor of this west elevation retains the four window openings, although they are now metal-frame, fixed, plate glass windows; they retain their brick sills and soldier course lintels. A decorative brick band identical to that found between the first and second floors is visible above the second floor windows and wraps partially onto the west pilaster of the south elevation. On the first floor, the doorway at the northwest corner has been replaced by a slightly recessed entrance, although the soldier course lintel remains intact above the original opening. To the right of this is a large, fixed, plate glass window with a concrete frame while what may have once been a doorway at the center of the elevation has been replaced with a single, aluminum-frame, plate glass window with a bulkhead made of the same corrugated metal found on the south elevation. The bizarre window configuration from the 1963 images has been 

**Packet Pg. 115**
{9}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **10** 

replaced by a large, three-light, aluminum-frame, plate glass window with the corrugated metal bulkhead. Metal coping caps this west wall, while the roof is flat and apparently of rubber. 

At the rear (north end) of this west building is a one-story addition that dates to sometime prior to 1947 (last Boone Sanborn), which by that time was serving as a re-capping area for Colvard Chevrolet. This addition appears to have been built sometime after the coal storage area to the immediate north, based on the overlap of its portico onto the roof of the coal storage area, which is historically associated with WT0817. As of 1963, the west elevation of this addition was comprised of concrete block with a recessed portico entrance paired with at least two plate glass windows. The west wall of this area under the portico appears to be angled from southwest to northeast—a common treatment found in Boone entrance configurations during the mid-1900s as a buffer against strong winter winds. Indeed, this 1963 configuration may be an alteration of the original configuration of this elevation. 

Today, the west elevation of this one-story addition reveals a dramatically altered appearance. Clad in board and batten panels (presumably of either wood or Hardie Board simulated to look like wood), the west elevation entrance is now raised, recessed, and reached by cultured stone steps (probably over concrete), with an oak door containing a large, central window serving as the entrance. This board and batten treatment continues onto the coal storage area to the north, suggesting that the buildings are linked, but they should be understood as distinct properties and buildings. A low, concrete stoop drops to the sidewalk in front of this elevation. A prominent, shed-style awning clad in standing seam metal covers the entire west elevation, above which is a short run of additional board and batten panels below the metal-coped, parapet roofline. To the south of the entrance and below the awning are two narrowlyspaced, plate glass windows. 

**Packet Pg. 116**
{10}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **11** 

## **Library of Congress - Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps** 

The Library of Congress has made Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps from 1928 and 1947 accessible. As these years fall within the historic district’s period of significance (1918-1964), these maps will be used when the property in question, or area of the property in question, can be viewed within these maps. The content of the Library of Congress online Sanborn Maps Collection is in the public domain and is free to use and reuse. 

**Packet Pg. 117**
{11}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **12** 

(1928) _Sanborn Fire Insurance Map from Boone, Watauga County, North Carolina_ . Sanborn Map Company, Jan. [Map] Retrieved from the Library of Congress, https://www.loc.gov/item/sanborn06383_001/. 

**Packet Pg. 118**
{12}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **13** 

**Packet Pg. 119**
{13}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **14** 

- (1947) _Sanborn Fire Insurance Map from Boone, Watauga County, North Carolina_ . Sanborn Map Company, Jun. [Map] Retrieved from the Library of Congress, https://www.loc.gov/item/sanborn06383_002/. 

**Packet Pg. 120**
{14}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **15** 

## **Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook Analysis** 

## _**Standards for Commercial Properties within the District**_ 

These Standards for commercial properties are intended to address many of the most common issues to arise during renovations, additions, and new construction in the District. Where the Standards are silent on a particular issue or concern, the HPC will rely upon the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation to guide their review of the proposed work under the COA process and any subsequent recommendations. 

## _**“Commercial Property” Defined**_ 

A commercial property within the District is any property whose purpose-built function at the time of construction was primarily to serve a commercial, institutional, or governmental purpose or use. More specifically, commercial properties include 1) any building whose original configuration included commercial, institutional, or governmental uses on the ground floor accessed via the entrance(s) located on the primary elevation, even if residential spaces were available elsewhere in the building (such as a commercial block building with stores on the first floor and apartments on the second floor), or 2) any building with a garage bay or bays on the ground floor accessed via the entrance(s) located on the primary elevation and commercial, institutional, or governmental spaces located elsewhere in the building (such as a garage building with an office or store located on an upper floor or in the basement). 

## **Design Standards for Commercial Properties Within the District** 

## **8. Entrances, Porches, and Balconies** 

One of the most significant and defining characteristics of all architecture is the main or front entrance, including any porches that surround or frame that entrance. While most of the commercial buildings in the District employed conventional storefront configurations (see Section 1 of these commercial standards), a handful of properties in the District do not employ traditional commercial entrance configurations. These properties include the Boone Post Office (WT0049), the Wade E. Brown Law Office Building (WT0586), the Watauga County Office Building (WT0607), and the Boone Recreation Parlor (WT0869). Retaining the original porch and entrance components of these buildings is especially important for understanding the building’s history in context with the District. Unfortunately, main or front entrances are also often the most altered elements of historic properties. Many historic entrances, porches, and balconies contain architectural elements that are essential to communicating the architectural style of the home. Machine-carved balustrades, spindles, brackets, entrance surrounds, and posts were common in many of the District’s buildings, but hand-worked elements were also not uncommon. Preserving these details is vital to preserving the appearance and integrity of the District’s historic architecture. 

8.1 Entrances, porches, and balconies, as used in this section, include front (primary elevation), side (secondary elevation), and rear (tertiary elevation) porches, mudrooms, porticos, sleeping porches, balconies, pergolas, terraces, widow’s walks, and entrances. Components of porches include steps, balustrades, columns, trellises, skirt boards, fascias, brackets, and various ornamental details. Most original porches and balconies were built with a slight pitch away from the residence to facilitate the runoff of rainwater. 

8.2 Because of their architectural significance, porches, balconies, and entrance configurations— especially those on the front or primary elevation—and all of their architectural details 

**Packet Pg. 121**
{15}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **16** 

(steps, balustrades, brackets, spindlework, columns, roofs, etc.) should be preserved in their original form and detail whenever possible. It is inappropriate to enclose porches and balconies on the front (primary) elevation for use as an interior space. In addition, the original pitch of porches and balconies should be maintained in order to facilitate the runoff of rainwater and snowmelt. Porches and balconies must be properly maintained and repaired as necessary, as they are exposed to the weather and will deteriorate if regular maintenance is not conducted. 

**Design Standards for Historic Streetscapes, Landscapes, Monuments, and Other Resources in the District, Streetscapes** 

## **1. Streetscapes** 

In contrast to the natural elements around which communities are often organized, historic streetscapes instead represent the built environment that defines the character, context, and components around which a community grows and evolves. Typically, buildings are the most obvious and dominant streetscape features, but this type of landscape includes other elements, including the spaces between buildings, private yards, alleyways and streets, sidewalks and other pedestrian elements, lighting, fences, public benches, retaining walls, monuments, public art, and street signage. 

With regard to all streetscapes in the District, the following standards should be observed: 

- 1.11 Historic street paving and sidewalk materials, as well as historic curbing, should be retained and preserved, using salvaged or historically compatible materials when repairs are necessary. If historic materials cannot be found, substitute materials may be used, provided they replicate the durability, color, texture, and appearance of the original historic materials. 

## **3. Landscapes and Ecologically Sensitive Areas** 

Regarding ecologically sensitive areas and natural areas, the Town of Boone has seen dramatic development over the past fifty years, much of which has adversely impacted Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards--106 the stream corridors flowing through the District as well as onceforested and open areas in the community. As a result, the remaining ecologically sensitive and natural environments within the Town’s limits are valuable resources, especially in the context of the Town’s urban environment. Contrary to the public perception when the occasional flooding rainstorm visits Boone, these areas actually help slow and filter rainwater and runoff, improve air and water quality, provide natural habitat, and offer aesthetic contributions to the community. In addition, some of these natural areas offer essential clues to the settlement history of Boone and the ways in which its natural resources have been utilized for the better part of two centuries. 

Accordingly, the following standards should be followed in an effort to maintain these vital resources: 

… 

- 3.2 Use plant materials that are indigenous to the District. New plant material should complement those found on the site and in the District. 

- 3.4 Keep the location of new landscape features consistent with the location of similar elements in the District. 

- 3.5 It is inappropriate to introduce contemporary plant edging materials such as exposed landscape timbers (e.g., rail ties) in primary and secondary elevations. 

- 3.6 Maintain the relationship between building mass and open space that exists on the block or streetscape. Property owners should preserve the historic spatial arrangements and landuse patterns within the District as they have changed over time, and they should strive to 

**Packet Pg. 122**
{16}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **17** 

protect character-defining elements of both constructed and natural landforms, including the topography and open spaces surrounding historic buildings and landscape features. 

- 3.7 Locate additions and new construction, if possible, in areas that do not necessitate the removal of mature plantings or cause the disruption of the established rhythm of building mass and open space. New construction should not interrupt or obstruct significant views and sight lines within the District, and existing intrusions within the District should either be removed or screened with plantings. 

## **7. Exterior Lighting** 

- 7.1 Select lighting that is compatible with the building, site, height and character of existing streetscape features, and the surrounding architecture, and that aligns with the historic context of the property in question, in terms of design, materials, use, size, scale, location, and level and angle of illumination. 

- 7.2 Avoid placing fixtures in areas that will obscure or damage character-defining architectural or landscape features. 

- 7.3 It is inappropriate to replace original light fixtures when they exist. If no evidence of fixtures is present, select unobtrusive light fixtures that are compatible with the building and site and do not disrupt adjacent properties. Use a white light source. 

- 7.4 Employ minimal lighting levels required for public safety while striving to eliminate light pollution. Whenever possible, lighting should be directed toward the ground, away from surrounding properties, and be shielded from direct view. 

- 7.5 Locate lighting sources in strategic locations on the building or landscape to create a subtle and inviting ambience. 

- … 

- 7.8 All entrances and exits in substantial buildings used for nonresidential purposes and in twofamily or multifamily developments containing more than four (4) dwelling units shall be adequately lighted to ensure the safety of persons and the security of the buildings. 

- 7.9 Lighting within any lot that unnecessarily illuminates any other lot and substantially interferes with the use or enjoyment of such other lot is prohibited. Lighting unnecessarily illuminates another lot if it clearly exceeds the standards set forth in the Town of Boone UDO. 

_**Staff Note:  To assist with your analysis, Staff visited other properties within the Historic District to find similar front façade light fixtures.  Although no fixtures of the exact size and design of that on the subject parcel were found, a few similar fixtures are shown below.  Photos were taken by Staff.**_ 

**Packet Pg. 123**
{17}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **18** 

605 West King (similar design but smaller scale fixtures) 

260 Howard Street (similar size and a somewhat similar but simpler design) 

**Packet Pg. 124**
{18}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **19** 

- 186 Howard Street (similar size and a somewhat similar but simpler design) 

_**Staff Note – As noted by the applicant in the Design Narrative, the light fixture is very similar in size and design to the Town of Boone street lights throughout the District**_ . 

## **Automatic Conditions of Approval** 

The following conditions are automatically included and a part of any approval. 

- Where there is a conflict between the application information and the plans (April 25, 2024), the plans control. Insignificant deviations may be permitted to comply with the requirements of the UDO. 

- Any commitments and representations concerning the proposed exterior modification made by the applicant or its representatives at the public hearing shall also become a condition of the permit, and a basis for a stop work order and/or permit revocation if violated. 

- The applicant shall submit the necessary applications, plans, details and specifications which meet the requirements of the Town Code, UDO, Building Code and any other applicable codes for review and approval necessary to issue Zoning and Building Permits. 

**Packet Pg. 125**
{19}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **20** 

## **Historic Preservation Commission Procedure** 

In considering this application for a COA the HPC shall base their decisions solely on the basis of competent, material and substantial evidence entered into the record via the application packet and sworn testimony at the public hearing. 

The question before the Historic Preservation Commission is whether or not the proposed development is congruous (i.e., in agreement, in harmony) with the special character of the historic district.  If the proposed exterior modification is congruous, the Commission shall issue the requested COA.  If the proposed exterior modification is incongruous (not in agreement, not in harmony) with the special character of the historic district, the Commission shall deny the requested COA.  The Commission shall approve, approve with conditions, or the deny the COA by majority vote. 

**Vote:** The proposed development  **is congruous  OR**  **is incongruous** with the special character of the Downtown Boone Local Historic District and is approved subject to the following conditions (as warranted): 

## 1. Conditions: 

_**Criteria for Conditions: The Commission may issue approval subject to reasonable conditions necessary to carry out the purposes served by the historic district (see G.S. 160D-940, 160D-947(a)).  The purposes of the historic district are to (i) safeguard the heritage of the town insofar as the Historic District embodies important elements of the town’s culture, history, architectural history, and/or prehistory, and (ii) to promote the use and conservation of the district for the education, pleasure, and enrichment of the residents of the town and/or the State as a whole, see North Carolina G.S. §160D-940, 944, 947(a).**_ 

## **Historic Photos** 

Below is a collection of historical photos of the subject property, obtained through a collaboration with Digital Watauga. The photos are displayed in their original size and resolution, as well as in a cropped version that highlights the main features of interest. For each photo, there is a citation for the photo. 

_**Staff Note: Planning Staff has provided images and cropped images of the property. Any commentary on the images is from the Digital Watauga technician(s) who found and sent the images to Planning Staff.**_ 

**Packet Pg. 126**
{20}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **21** 

W. M. Cline Co., “Downtown Boone Street Scene Postcard,” Digital Watauga, accessed October 26, 2022, https://digitalwatauga.org/items/show/20690. 

_**Planning Staff has cropped the image to show the property in question.**_ 

**Packet Pg. 127**
{21}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **22** 

W. M. Cline Co., “Downtown Boone Street Scene Postcard,” Digital Watauga, accessed October 26, 2022, https://digitalwatauga.org/items/show/20690. 

**Packet Pg. 128**
{22}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **23** 

John Ward, “Downtown Boone During the 1960 Blizzard,” Digital Watauga, accessed October 26, 2022, https://digitalwatauga.org/items/show/19917. 

**Packet Pg. 129**
{23}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **24** 

## _**Planning Staff has cropped the image to show the property in question.**_ 

John Ward, “Downtown Boone During the 1960 Blizzard,” Digital Watauga, accessed October 26, 2022, _https://digitalwatauga.org/items/show/19917._ 

**Packet Pg. 130**
{24}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **25** 

Unknown, “Children in 1952 Spring Clean Up Parade,” Digital Watauga, accessed October 26, 2022, https://digitalwatauga.org/items/show/6445. 

**Packet Pg. 131**
{25}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **26** 

## _**Planning Staff has cropped the image to show the property in question.**_ 

Unknown, “Children in 1952 Spring Clean Up Parade,” Digital Watauga, accessed October 26, 2022, https://digitalwatauga.org/items/show/6445. 

**Packet Pg. 132**
{26}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **27** 

Unknown, “Intersection at King Street and Depot Street, Downtown Boone, 1990s,” Digital Watauga, accessed October 26, 2022, _https://digitalwatauga.org/items/show/7072._ 

**Packet Pg. 133** [
{27}------------------------------------------------
**Packet Pg. 134**
{28}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **28** 

Unknown, “Wagon Train on King Street”, circa 1950-1955, Historic Boone Digital Exhibit, Watauga County Public Library, Digital NC, accessed March 31, 2022, _https://lib.digitalnc.org/record/5919#?c=0&m=0&s=0&cv=0&r=0&xywh=1783%2C323%2C3069%2C2210._ 

_**Planning Staff has cropped the image to show the property in question.**_ 

**Packet Pg. 135**
{29}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **30** 

Unknown, “Wagon Train on King Street”, circa 1950-1955, Historic Boone Digital Exhibit, Watauga County Public Library, Digital NC, accessed March 31, 2022, _https://lib.digitalnc.org/record/5919#?c=0&m=0&s=0&cv=0&r=0&xywh=1783%2C323%2C3069%2C2210._ 

Image from the Paul Armfield Coffey Collection, courtesy of the Digital Watauga Project 

**Packet Pg. 136**
{30}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **31** 

## _**Planning Staff has cropped the image to show the property in question.**_ 

Image from the Paul Armfield Coffey Collection, courtesy of the Digital Watauga Project 

**Packet Pg. 137** [|
{31}------------------------------------------------
C a s e  A 2 4 - 0 2 8 7  6 4 2  W .  K i n g  L L C  -  C O A | **32** 

Image from the Paul Armfield Coffey Collection, courtesy of the Digital Watauga Project 

**Packet Pg. 138**
