{0}------------------------------------------------
## Exhibit 5 

|**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA**|**1**<br>A|
|---|
|**Staff Report**<br>**January 9, 2024**<br>**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel –Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Work - Modification of**<br>**Previous COA**<br>Table of Contents<br>Request ......................................................................................................................................................... 1<br>Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................... 3<br>Parcel Information ........................................................................................................................................ 3<br>Recent Zoning History for 970 Rivers Street ................................................................................................. 5<br>Architectural Survey/Designation Report Information ................................................................................. 6<br>Inventory Classification ............................................................................................................................. 7<br>Designation Report ................................................................................................................................... 8<br>Architectural Survey .................................................................................................................................. 8<br>Library of Congress - Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps ................................................................................... 11<br>Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook Analysis ................................. 15<br>Narrative ................................................................................................................................................. 15<br>Design Standards for Commercial Properties ......................................................................................... 15<br>Zoning Analysis (B1 Downtown Core) ......................................................................................................... 18<br>Conformity to Adopted Plans ..................................................................................................................... 19<br>Comprehensive Plan Update................................................................................................................ 19<br>Automatic Conditions of Approval .............................................................................................................. 23<br>Historic Preservation Commission Procedure ............................................................................................ 23<br>Historic Photos ............................................................................................................................................ 25<br>**Request**<br>John Winkler, on behalf of Rivers Street Ventures, LLC, is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness<br>(COA) for Major Work for the alteration of previously issued Certificate of Appropriateness for the<br>construction of a new hotel at 970 Rivers Street (Watauga County PIN: 2900-78-7965-000) in the<br>Downtown Boone Local Historic District.  The proposed alterations from the previously approved plan<br>include replacing double windows with either French doors or larger single windows in the second story<br>guest rooms.  The total heated square footage of the building would increase from 11,421 to 12,036 and<br>the building height would increase from 20 feet to 21 feet, 1 ½ inches.<br>The subject property is outlined in green on the map below.<br>**Communication: Exhibit 5:  Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel Modification of Previous COA - Staff Report  (Case A23-0547 Portfino Hotel COA -**|



**Packet Pg. 15** [
{1}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **2** 

The Table of Minor Work and Major Work, located in both UDO Article 8, Subsection 8.05.03 and Appendix D, requires the applicant to obtain a COA for the proposed new construction and building changes from the previously approved COA. _**Staff Notes**_ can be found throughout the report marked in _**bold green italicized text**_ . 

**Packet Pg. 16**
{2}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **3** 

## **Zoning Map** 

**==> picture [229 x 45] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Parcel Information<br>Address:  970 Rivers Street<br>Property Owner:  Rivers Street Ventures, LLC<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Packet Pg. 17**
{3}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **4** 

**Watauga County PIN:** 2900-78-7965-000 **Lot size (total):** .293 Acres **Jurisdiction:** Town of Boone **Access:** Rivers Street (State maintained) **SFHA:** Yes **Watershed District:** No **Corridor District:** No **NCD:** No **Viewshed:** No **Steep Slope:** No **Transitional Zone:** No **Current Zoning:** B1 Downtown Core, Downtown Boone Local Historic District Overlay The B1 Downtown Core, together with the B1 Downtown Interface District encompass the Town of Boone’s downtown area and represent, in large measure, the remaining vestiges of the Town’s historic character. Regulations in these districts are intended to preserve and maintain a small town, high country atmosphere. Preservation and adaptive reuse of existing historic buildings are encouraged and new construction shall be appropriately scaled to be sympathetic to the existing built environment. Design and regulatory standards for these districts reinforce the character of the downtown as a pedestrian friendly area by encouraging architectural solutions that are visually interesting, and are compatible in scale and character to the surrounding area. To help accomplish this, the area is divided into two (2) districts, each with its own character and scale which contribute to the overall vitality of the downtown area. Identification of the districts is listed below: 

1. B1 Downtown Core District: The Downtown Core District is the center of the downtown area and contains the greatest concentration of historic commercial buildings. This district establishes a continuous building facade at the street frontage to strengthen the identity of downtown as a pedestrian destination where pedestrians feel comfortable through the careful selection of building materials, human scale design, and ground floor fenestration. Standards in this district reinforce the historic nature of the existing built environment through regulation of appearance, height, scale and mass. 

2. B1 Downtown Interface District: The Downtown Interface District serves as a gateway into the downtown area and as the transition between the B1 Downtown Core District and adjacent zoning districts. Development in this district must be sensitive to issues of compatibility with the Downtown Core District as well as surrounding zoning districts, many which are low-density residential. 

**Packet Pg. 18**
{4}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **5** 

_**Staff Note: The Downtown Boone Local Historic District is an overlay district, which is a district that overlaps, in this case, the general use B1 zoning districts and contains standards in addition to the underlying general use district zoning standards. Where requirements conflict, overlay district standards supersede.**_ 

||**Zoning & Use of Adjacent Properties**|**Zoning & Use of Adjacent Properties**|
|---|---|---|
||**Adjacent Zoning**|**Adjacent Land Use**|
|North|B1, Downtown Core, Downtown Boone Local Historic<br>District|Single Family Dwelling Unit,<br>Other Business or Professional Office|
|East|U1, University|Public College and University|
|South|B1, Downtown Interface|Restaurant, Retail|
|West|B1, Downtown Core, Downtown Boone Local Historic<br>District|Parking Lot|



## **Recent Zoning History for 970 Rivers Street** 

**02-03-2022** The Boone Board of Adjustment granted a variance to UDO Subsection 20.04.03(B) to allow more than 10% disturbance within the stream buffer zone and, specifically, for 129.5 linear feet of temporary disturbance within the 129.5 linear feet of stream buffer zone (100%).     The variance was granted subject to specific conditions as set forth below. 

   1. Where there is a conflict between the application information and the plans (site plan received December, 14 2021), the plans control.  Insignificant deviations may be permitted to comply with the requirements of the UDO. 

   2. Any commitments and representations concerning the proposed development made by the applicant or its (his or her) representatives at the public hearing shall also become a condition of the permit, and a basis for a stop work order and/or permit revocation if violated. 

   3. The applicant shall submit the necessary applications, plans, details and specifications which meet the requirements of the Town Code, UDO, Building Code and any other applicable codes for review and approval necessary to issue Zoning and Building Permits. 

   4. The applicant cannot proceed with any land disturbance on the property in absence of a final approved development plan authorizing demolition of the building and new development. 

   5. The variance shall expire following completion of demolition, remediation of the stream buffer, and construction activities undertaken consistent with an approved redevelopment project, should all required zoning and building permit(s) for the demolition of the existing building and re-development of the property be approved. 

- **05-10-2022** The Town of Boone Historic Preservation Commission granted a Certificate of Appropriateness for the demolition of the building with the following conditions: 

**Packet Pg. 19**
{5}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **6** 

   1. Where there is conflict between the application information and the plans (February 28, 2021), the plans control. Insignificant deviations may be permitted to comply with the requirements of the UDO. 

   2. Any commitments and representations concerning the proposed exterior modification made by the applicant or its (their) representatives at the Public Hearing shall also become a condition of the permit, and a basis for a stop work order and/or permit revocation if violated. 

   3. The applicant shall submit the necessary applications, plans, details and specifications which meet the requirements of the Town Code, UDO, Building Code and other applicable codes for review and approval necessary to issue Zoning and Building Permits. 

   4. The applicant agreed to a 90-day waiting period: to hire and pay for a professional from a list provided by the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) to document the interior and exterior of the building. 

5. The applicant shall explore alternative options to save or salvage the building. 

**07-13-2022** The Town of Boone Historic Preservation Commission granted a Certificate of Appropriateness for the demolition of the building and construction of a new one-story hotel with the following conditions: 

   1. New construction: Where there is a conflict between the application information (March 24, 2022) and the plans (June 24, 2022), the plans control. Insignificant deviations may be permitted to comply with the requirements of the UDO. 

   2. Any commitments and representations made by the applicant or its (his or her) representatives at the public hearing shall also become a condition of the permit, and a basis for a stop work order and/or permit revocation if violated. 

   3. The applicant shall submit the necessary applications, plans, details and specifications which meet the requirements of the Town Code, UDO, Building Code and any other applicable codes for review and approval necessary to issue Zoning and Building Permits 

   4. The applicant agreed to work with the Public Works Department to locate and to construct a pedestrian access between the hotel parking. 

_**Staff Note: Staff has included in the Quasi-Judicial Meeting Packet the previous previously approved project information for reference for Commission members.**_ 

## **Architectural Survey/Designation Report Information** 

The following three documents are central to the Downtown Boone Local Historic District: 

1. Comprehensive Architectural Survey of Downtown Boone, NC – Final Report 

2. Report and Recommendation for the Designation of the Downtown Boone Local Historic District, Boone, NC 

3. Downtown Boone Local Historic District Standards 

**Packet Pg. 20**
{6}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **7** 

The designation report (#2 above), was created using the architectural survey of the downtown area (#1 above) and recommended the Downtown Boone Local Historic District area be designated as a historic overlay district; and the Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards, which are outlined in a separate document (#3 above), are to be applied by the HPC when it considers applications for Certificates of Appropriateness for proposed development within the historic district. 

## **Inventory Classification** 

The following information has been taken from the designation report starting on page 69.   The property inventory found within the report was specifically written to assess the contributing significance and integrity of the district’s resources. Integrity, as determined was based upon the following: 

1. design integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to its original appearance or altered appearance during the period of significance; 

2. material integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to original materials during the period of significance or replacement materials that mimic the appearance of original materials during the period of significance; 

3. locational integrity, meaning the building’s relationship to its original location during the period of significance; 

4. integrity of association, meaning the building’s relationship to its original or adapted use, function, and purpose during the period of significance; and 

5. integrity of relationship to the district as a whole, meaning the building’s historical importance to the development of downtown Boone’s commercial district during the district’s four periods of growth within the period of significance (1918-1964). 

## **Inventory Classifications:** 

**CA:** Contributes to the character of the district based on architectural significance 

**CH:** Contributes to the character of the district based on historical significance related to events or individuals associated with the property 

**NC:** Non-contributing property 

**VL:** Vacant lot 

**Packet Pg. 21**
{7}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **8** 

## _**Staff Note:  The former structure(s) on the parcel have been demolished as of June 21, 2023.**_ 

## **Designation Report** 

The Designation Report summary is included on the right, and the full Architectural Survey summary is included below. 

_**The subject property is classified as “CH” meaning the property contributes to the district based on historical significance related to events or individuals associated with the property.**_ 

## **Architectural Survey** 

## **WT0877 Austin Tobacco Company Prize Room (1939) 970 Rivers Street** 

This two-story, wood-clad, warehouse building with a concrete block foundation has long been rumored to be a surviving building of the operations of the East Tennessee and Western North Carolina Railroad (“Tweetsie”), and a sign on the building attributes it as the “original maintenance building for the railroad line which ran from Johnson City, Tennessee, to Boone, North Carolina, circa 1911.” Put plainly, neither of these claims is even remotely true. 

The 1928 Sanborn Fire Insurance Company map of Boone shows two one-story, frame buildings at this site, both associated at the time with the Watauga Lumber Company. The west building of that complex, located in the same spot as the current building, had a somewhat flattened, rectangular footprint that was less deep on the lot than the east building. A circa 1939 photo of Boone taken from the southwest (Cy Crumley Scrapbook) shows the west building as having a front-facing gable at the east end of its south elevation. In 1935, the Watauga Building and Loan Association acquired this property (Deed Book 44, Page 279) after Blanche and E. N. Hahn defaulted on it. By early 1936, C. M. Critcher occupied the east Watauga Lumber Company/Boone Ice Plant building (Watauga Democrat, February 13, 1936), remaining there well into the 1940s, but W. H. Gragg, secretary of the Watauga Building and Loan, had different plans 

_**WT0877 Austin Tobacco Company Prize Room (1939)—CH 970 Rivers Street (2900-78-7965-000)** This two-story, wood-clad warehouse building with a partial concrete block foundation is one of the oldest surviving buildings from the warehouse area along Howard and Depot Streets, dating to the end of the period when wooden warehouses were common in this part of the district. Like many similar buildings of the period, it extends partially over Boone Creek, where concrete columns that were likely wooden piers when the building was first constructed support the structure above. Built in 1939 as the Austin Tobacco Company Prize Room, it is also the only surviving building in the district that was ever associated with Boone’s once vigorous tobacco trade. After the August 1940 flood ended train service to Boone, various entities used the building for decades for fertilizer and pesticide storage and other similar purposes. It housed a country store in the late 1990s, then a restaurant beginning in 2000. Although the building is mostly unchanged from its original form, a rectangular, wooden addition was affixed to the southwest corner of the building in relatively recent years. Exterior wooden treatments have also been replaced in some cases by parging over an unknown material arranged in panels. Nevertheless, the building remains an excellent example of transitional construction between the pre-Depression era and the 1940s and 1950s Howard Street boom._ 

**Packet Pg. 22**
{8}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **9** 

for the old west building of Watauga Lumber. Finally, in November 1939, Gragg demolished the west building—which Hahn had used to store fertilizers during the early 1930s—and erected a new, 70’ by 70’ warehouse to be used as a prize room by the Austin Tobacco Company during market season (Watauga Democrat, November 23, 1939). Like the other tobacco warehouses in town, Gragg’s new building also served as a venue for dances from time to time (Watauga Democrat, February 1, 1940). This new building is visible on the September 27, 1940, high aerial image of Boone (Agr-Ext-1940-9B76), well after the Tweetsie line to Boone had shut down permanently following the mid-August 1940 floods. This new building, which clearly displayed skylights in its roof, was deeper than the old east building of the Watauga Lumber Company and had an unusual addition at its northeast corner that wrapped behind the old east building of Watauga Lumber. Meanwhile, by February 1941, it became clear that Austin Tobacco was no longer using the building as a prize room. That month, W. H. Gragg began advertising the availability of a “large and strong” building specifically described as a “good warehouse, suitable for fertilizer or storage” (Watauga Democrat, February 6, 1941). 

Ultimately, Southern Agricultural Insecticides purchased the warehouse from the Building and Loan in August 1944 (Deed Book 59, Page 54, and Watauga Democrat, June 14, 1945), and a few months later in 1945, Southern Agricultural Insecticides had to secure a corrective deed because the Watauga Building and Loan had constructed WT0877 partially encroaching on a neighbor’s land (Deed Book 60, Page 298). Indeed, when the 1947 Sanborn map of Boone was published, it showed WT0877 as a concrete block and wood structure, labeled as an insecticide warehouse, with an odd hook of an addition at its northeast corner behind the old east building of Watauga Lumber (at that point also used as a fertilizer warehouse). The building footprint remained essentially unchanged until recent years, when an addition was located at the southwest corner. Some locals have speculated that this addition is part of the old train depot, but detailed analysis of historic images and other sources has determined that the Tweetsie-related building (perhaps part 4 In addition to the information that follows about the building itself, the Linville River Railway—the correct name for the line that came to Boone—did not reach Boone until very late 1918. 

of the depot) that sat for a time in front of the C. M. Critcher warehouse to the east was demolished in the mid-1960s, while the known half of the depot that sat behind the Boone Bus Station for many years was demolished in 1976. Southern Agricultural Insecticides sold the warehouse building in 1977 (Deed Book 172, Page 430), and it was briefly home to the Greeneville Sign Company in the late 1970s. The Whistle Stop Country Store occupied the space briefly in the late 1990s, which may be the origin of the myth that the building was related to Tweetsie, since this claim was made in their promotional materials (Watauga Democrat, July 31, 1998). Café Portofino has occupied the site since 2000. 

Today, the building appears from the exterior to be two stories in height, built partially over Boone Creek, which flows under the north edge of the building. The south elevation is clad in board and batten lumber with a large, shed-style awning supported by posts with Y brackets that rest on a narrow, wooden deck that provides outdoor seating. This awning is clad in raised seam metal. The first floor of the original, south face of the building, reading west to east, has a single, nine-light, vinyl replacement door located at the junction between the southwest addition and the main block. To the east of this entrance is a single, one- over-one, double-hung sash, vinyl window, followed by the 

**Packet Pg. 23**
{9}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **10** 

inaccurate historical sign, followed again to the east by a double bay of one-over-one, double-hung sash, vinyl replacement windows. A double set of fifteen-light, vinyl replacement doors is located at the east end of the first floor. The second floor of the south elevation has six irregularly spaced, oneover-one, double-hung sash, vinyl replacement windows. The southwest corner of the first floor of the south elevation is obscured by a one-story, shed-roofed addition clad in board and batten finish that juts out toward Rivers Street. This addition has a low, cultured stone wall at its base. The east wall of this addition, which is apparently used as a bar area, has a single piercing with sliding, divided sashes that open to either side. 

The east elevation appears to be parging over an unknown material—possibly large, wooden panels like those on the west elevation—and has a metal staircase rising from the middle of the elevation to the southeast corner, where a shed-style porch covering shields the landing outside a single, wooden, second floor door. A smaller, wooden staircase rises from the base of the first staircase to a mid-level landing and a vinyl replacement door at the center of the elevation. Two symmetrically spaced, oneover-one, double-hung sash windows with screens are visible at the northeast corner of the second floor. None of these piercings was visible in the 1963 aerial image of the building (Appalachian Collection). The roofline, meanwhile, descends in height from the south elevation to the north, and most of the skylights originally evident on the sloping but otherwise flat, rubber roof appear to have been filled in. The odd, northeast corner addition from early images of the building also appears to have been removed. 

The north elevation, meanwhile, is clad in the same parged material as the east elevation, with the western two thirds of the first floor open below to allow for the passage of the Boone Creek under the building. At the east end is a single, one-over-one, double-hung sash, wooden window with a metal storm window and a surrounding wood frame. Most of the posts supporting the north wall of the building appear to be wooden. The second floor, reading from east to west, has a small, one-overone, double-hung sash, wooden window with storms and a wooden frame, followed by a large, oneover-one, double-hung sash, vinyl replacement window and a repeated small window like the first one. A bit west of this is a single, one-over-one, double-hung sash, wooden window with a storm window and wooden frame. Well to the west of this is a four-light, fixed, vinyl replacement window with a wooden frame. As on the east elevation, trim elements are used to suggest a division between floors. 

The west elevation appears to be clad in large panels like those found on the east and north elevations, although the applied treatment/parging appears to be substantially thinner here. A large, side-byside, fixed, double-light window with a wooden frame is located at the center of the elevation, with much of the northern two-thirds undercut by the passage of Boone Creek under the building. Here, concrete columns support the building, with wood latticework screening part of the lower section of this elevation. A large, metal staircase rises to a porch shielding a doorway at the second floor level of the southwest corner, mimicking the feature at the southeast corner. Another door at the first floor level is visible under the second floor door. The sloped roof of the southwest corner addition, meanwhile, extends as an awning over the west elevation of the addition, resting on posts with Y brackets. A double, nine-light entrance is visible under the awning, as well as a large, single-light 

**Packet Pg. 24**
{10}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **11** 

window with a seating bar under it. A large, wooden deck located to the west of the building serves as an outdoor seating area. 

**Library of Congress - Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps** The Library of Congress has made Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps from 1928 and 1947 accessible. As these years fall within the historic district’s period of significance (1918-1964), these maps will be used when the property in question, or area of the property in question, can be viewed within these maps. The content of the Library of Congress online Sanborn Maps Collection is in the public domain and is free to use and reuse. 

**1928 Sanborn Fire Insurance Map – E. King Street, W. King Street, and Howard Street** _**Staff Note: Staff has included the 1928 Sanborn Fire Insurance Map as a full-sized image and cropped.**_ 

**Packet Pg. 25**
{11}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **12** 

**Packet Pg. 26**
{12}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **13** 

Image Credit: Sanborn Fire Insurance Map from Boone, Watauga County, North Carolina. Sanborn Map Company, Jan, 1928. Map. https://www.loc.gov/item/sanborn06383_001/. Digital Id http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.gmd/g3904bm.g3904bm_g063831928. 

## **1947 Sanborn Fire Insurance Map – Depot Street, Water Street, Howard Street, W. King Street, and Queen Street** 

_**Staff Note: Staff has included the 1947 Sanborn Fire Insurance Map as a full-sized image and cropped.**_ 

**Packet Pg. 27**
{13}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **14** 

**Packet Pg. 28**
{14}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **15** 

Image Credit: Sanborn Fire Insurance Map from Boone, Watauga County, North Carolina. Sanborn Map Company, Jun, 1947. Map. <www.loc.gov/item/sanborn06383_002/>. Digital Id http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.gmd/g3904bm.g3904bm_g063831947. 

## **Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook Analysis** 

## **Narrative** 

Applicable/relevant narrative from UDO Appendix D, Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook, is outlined below. 

## **Design Standards for Commercial Properties** 

Relevant design standards from UDO Appendix D, Downtown Boone Local Historic District Design Standards and Handbook, Design Standards for Commercial Properties within the District, are outlined below.   These standards for commercial properties are intended to address many of the most common issues to arise during renovations, additions, and new construction in the District. Where the standards are silent on a particular issue or concern, the HPC will rely upon the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation to guide their review of the proposed work under the COA process and any subsequent recommendations. 

These Standards for commercial properties are intended to address many of the most common issues to arise during renovations, additions, and new construction in the District. Where the Standards are silent on a particular issue or concern, the HPC will rely upon the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation to guide their review of the proposed work under the COA process and any subsequent recommendations. 

## _“Commercial Property” Defined_ 

A commercial property within the District is any property whose purpose-built function at the time of construction was primarily to serve a commercial, institutional, or governmental purpose or use. More 

**Packet Pg. 29**
{15}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **16** 

specifically, commercial properties include 1) any building whose original configuration included commercial, institutional, or governmental uses on the ground floor accessed via the entrance(s) located on the primary elevation, even if residential spaces were available elsewhere in the building (such as a commercial block building with stores on the first floor and apartments on the second floor), or 2) any building with a garage bay or bays on the ground floor accessed via the entrance(s) located on the primary elevation and commercial, institutional, or governmental spaces located elsewhere in the building (such as a garage building with an office or store located on an upper floor or in the basement). 

Any property within the District whose purpose-built function at the time of construction was to serve solely as a residence for long-term (greater than 30 days) occupants, even if the property currently serves a commercial use, is still considered a residential property. For standards for residential properties, please see the “Standards for Residential Properties within the District” section elsewhere in this publication. 

## **6.** _**Windows, Doors, and Awnings**_ 

The arrangement of doors and windows on an historic property is one of the most important elements of building design. It is imperative that these arrangements be preserved in order to maintain the integrity of individual historic properties and the integrity of the District.  Because older windows and doors were not always designed with heating and cooling efficiency in mind, it is often tempting to property owners to replace these features with modern doors and windows. Despite the apparent advantages of doing so, replacement with modern doors and windows is often far more expensive than repairing existing historic doors and windows, and their use often completely destroys the integrity of the historic property in question. Furthermore, many companies are now producing “modern” wood replacement windows that replicate the appearance of their historic antecedents with fixed muntins but feature double-pane glass to assist with heating and cooling efficiency. The HPC reviews proposals for the use of modern wood replacement windows carefully to insure that muntin thickness aligns with the muntin dimensions of historic windows. 

Boone’s downtown commercial historic district has also suffered from the installation of various architectural elements designed to simulate a “mountain village” appearance. These typically consist of large, wooden porch attachments or awnings that are not historically appropriate to the downtown area and its historic context. Metal and modern vinyl awnings have also appeared on some properties, disrupting the integrity of many of Boone’s historic commercial properties. 

- 6.1 The pattern, arrangement, location, size, and shape of windows and doors contribute significantly to a building’s historic character, and their consistency within the district helps unify the buildings in context to one another. For this reason, it is always preferable to repair damaged windows and doors rather than replacing them. Furthermore, it is imperative that the fenestration pattern of the door and window openings on the building and of the doors and windows themselves (muntin width, number of lights per sash, etc.) be maintained when repairs to or replacement of elements is underway. It is never appropriate to introduce new features, such as vents, bays, windows, or door openings, in exterior walls if they diminish the historic character of the wall or damage historic materials. 

_**Staff Note: The applicant proposes changes to previously approved plans by altering double windows on the secondary façade to either French doors or single, larger windows.**_ 

_**…**_ 

**Packet Pg. 30**
{16}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **17** 

- 6.16 New construction, additions, and renovations to existing historic buildings or properties within historic districts should maintain established proportions and spacing of window and door openings. 

## _**Staff Note: Requested changes appear to maintain established proportions.**_ 

## **14.** _**New Construction of Commercial Buildings within the District**_ 

It is inevitable that new commercial buildings will be constructed within the District. The intention of these design standards is not to prevent such changes but to ensure that new construction is compatible with and complementary to the integrity and architectural character of the District. While new commercial buildings should not attempt to replicate existing historic properties, they should mesh with and support the historic design principles of the other commercial properties in the District. These standards are intended to preserve the integrity of the District while also encouraging sensitive and appropriate new construction. 

- 14.1 New commercial construction within the District should not seek to duplicate historic buildings in the District or mimic their appearance. That said, new construction should strive to be sensitive to and compatible with the character-defining features of the commercial properties in the District. Thus, new construction should employ architectural design that reflects its current time, place, use, and culture, provided that this design is compatible with the character of the District. 

- _**Staff Note: Construction of the new building was previously approved and the overall design style is unchanged.**_ 

- 14.2 New construction should incorporate the predominant historic materials typical in surrounding historic buildings when possible—usually brick, native stone, structural glass, wooden trim, and similar historic materials. Synthetic, non-traditional materials, such as vinyl, synthetic stone, fiber cement board, aluminum, plywood, parging, and pre-formed concrete panels, are not permitted in new construction. It is NOT appropriate in new construction to use contemporary substitute materials in place of traditional materials. The use of the highest-quality, historically appropriate, exterior facing materials is encouraged. 

- _**Staff Note: Construction of the new building was previously approved and the materials being used have not changed other than the requested windows and/or doors.**_ 

- 14.3 Design, height, massing, and proportions of new buildings should complement and be compatible with the dimensions of neighboring buildings with similar character and style. New buildings should not overpower adjacent buildings or the District as a whole as a result of out-of-scale massing, footprint, height, or overhang. Roofs, fenestration, and materials should be compatible with surrounding buildings. Traditional separations between storefronts and upper facades should be maintained and consistent with those existing in adjacent or nearby buildings. Vertical divisions maintain the feeling of traditional building widths and should be maintained. New buildings generally should align with adjacent buildings facing on the same street and conform to existing setbacks from the street. The primary façade and main building entry shall face the primary public way. 

- _**Staff Note: Construction of the new building was previously approved and the overall building massing is nearly identical.  The height of the building has increased by 13.5 inches.**_ 

**…** 

**Packet Pg. 31**
{17}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **18** 

- 14.7 The appropriateness of a proposed new commercial building will be evaluated based on compatibility in terms of scale, height, form, massing, materials, openings, roof pitch, roof type, and other details with the District context. 

- _**Staff Note: Construction of the new building was previously approved and the overall design style and compatibility are unchanged.**_ 

- 14.8 New commercial construction should incorporate architectural elements and details into new construction that provide human scale. Do not add fanciful decorative elements and colors that are out of place or not in keeping with the historic context of the District and/or adjacent historic properties. 

- _**Staff Note: Construction of the new building was previously approved and the overall design style is unchanged.**_ 

## **…** 

- 14.10 Historically, most of Boone’s downtown commercial buildings had flat roofs. Residential roof types are not permitted in new commercial buildings. Roof planes should be hidden from view on the façade, and rooflines should be decorated using historic decorative details, using historic photographs and/or neighboring buildings as a guide. Walls should not appear to terminate at flat roofs, except along the tertiary elevation. Instead, flat roofs should be concealed from view by using historically appropriate pitched roof features, parapets, or a mixture thereof. Where only one elevation has this condition, the parapet or other feature will continue four feet along the adjacent elevation. The minimum slope for pitched roofs is four feet vertically to every twelve feet horizontally. Where a parapet intersects with a pitched roof element, there shall be no apparent breaks in the parapet wall. 

- _**Staff Note: Construction of the new building was previously approved and the roof design is unchanged except for a 1.5-inch reduction in parapet height.**_ 

## **Zoning Analysis (B1 Downtown Core)** 

The following UDO requirements are required to be met for the proposed façade renovation unless superseded by any requirements of the Downtown Boone Local Historic District overlay. 

## **Building Height:** 

UDO Subsection 14.19.04(F)(5) states “Buildings fronting streets in the B1 Districts, outside of the area governed by Subsection 14.19.03(G)(1) above, are limited to thirty-three feet (33’), as measured from the average elevation of the existing or proposed public sidewalk facing the street to the highest point of the building or structure containing the primary entrance.” 

_**Staff Note:  UDO Section 14.09.03(G)(1) is an invalid reference.  The proposed structure does not front King, Queen or Howard Streets, so 14.19.04(F)(5) applies to govern building height.  The proposed height of the building has changed from 20’0” to 21’1.5”.**_ 

## **Window to Wall Ratio:** 

UDO Subsection 14.19.06 (H)(3)(c) states “The window to wall ratio of an upper story shall meet the percentages outlined below. Parapets should not be included in the window to wall ratio for upper stories:” 

**Packet Pg. 32**
{18}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **19** 

|**District**|**Upper Floor Window Coverage**|
|---|---|
|B1 Downtown Core|20-40%|
|B1 Downtown Interface|20-60%|



_**Staff Note:  The window to wall ratio will vary depending on which alternative (if either) the Commission approves for this development.  The window to wall ratios for the two proposed options have not been provided to staff.**_ 

## **Conformity to Adopted Plans** 

**Comprehensive Plan Update** 

## **1.1 Overall Objectives for the Boone Comprehensive Plan (p. 15):** 

The following objectives, which have not been listed in any particular order of importance, are deliberately broad in scope and less specific than either a policy statement or an implementation action. 

**Economic Development:** Acknowledge the area’s natural beauty, university, and medical center presence as the Town’s greatest assets for economic development and jobs creation. Treat them accordingly. 

**Community Appearance and Community Character:** Blend the built environment with the natural, scenic, and historic character of a High Country small town. Especially discourage commercial strip development, cluttered signage, and “cheap” apartment buildings. 

**Open Space:** Integrate open space and greenways into the urban fabric of the Town. Preserve the countryside by discouraging suburban sprawl. Avoid development in floodplains, on ridgetops, and on steep slopes. 

**Environmental Quality:** Address and monitor growth factors and activities that contribute to water, air, light, and noise pollution. 

**Trees:** Conserve existing trees and plant new trees, especially hardwoods. 

**Automobile Transportation:** Maximize the efficiency of existing facilities, but not at the expense town and neighborhood character and livability. Build or expand transportation facilities and parking areas as needed, but with care. Work to reduce auto dependency, use, and congestion. 

**Bikeways:** Implement the planned system of bikeways as a legitimate transportation alternative. Unify with greenways and other pedestrian facilities where possible. 

**Mass Transit:** Enhance and support the mass transit system as an effective alternative to the congestion created by the individual automobile. 

**Pedestrian Movement:** Encourage a system of sidewalks, paths, crosswalks and compact development patterns which make it easy to get around Boone on foot. 

**Infrastructure:** Engage in long range planning for water and sewer systems, stormwater runoff, natural gas, and other utility systems. Place overhead utilities underground whenever feasible. 

**Packet Pg. 33**
{19}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **20** 

**Public Safety:** Maintain a high level of policing and fire protection and plan the expansion of public safety services to coincide with projected population increases and identified needs. 

**Energy and Waste:** Reduce waste generation, and the consumption of energy and water. Develop area recycling programs to the fullest. Encourage an anti-litter consciousness among residents and visitors. 

**University:** Emphasize cooperative planning among the Town, County, and University. 

**Downtown:** Support and enhance the cultural and historic significance of downtown Boone, and affirm its appealing, pedestrian orientation. 

**Recreation:** Strive for additional public recreation facilities, especially sports fields, greenways and indoor recreation centers. 

**Neighborhoods:** Ensure the livability of neighborhoods, especially through land use and traffic planning. **Public Involvement:** Encourage active public involvement and volunteerism to expand the effectiveness of community planning and action. 

**1.2 Growth Strategy Map (p. 17):** This development is located within the Primary Growth Area as shown on the Growth Strategy Map.  The Primary Growth Area is that portion of the urban growth area where urban levels of facilities are already in place or can be provided most cost effectively. This is the area where near term growth and development is to be especially encouraged. See Growth Strategy Map below: 

## **2.0 Policies for Growth and Development (P. 18-77)** 

Staff has reviewed land use and comprehensive plan policies, and listed those policies which in staff’s opinion have a bearing on the request. The Board should review these policies carefully. Each member 

**Packet Pg. 34**
{20}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **21** 

may make his or her own interpretation as to the relevance of each and which carry the most weight thereby shaping their overall recommendation. 

## **2.1 THE ECONOMY (p. 19)** 

- A. The Town shall protect and enhance a high quality of life, image, cultural amenities, and natural beauty as the most effective, long-term component of an economic development strategy. 

- B. New and expanding industries and businesses shall be encouraged which: 1) diversify the local economy, 2) train and use a skilled labor force and 3) increase area residents’ incomes. 

- C. The Town shall encourage the development of a well-balanced tourism trade as a primary element of the area’s economic future. Investments in services, facilities, and proper growth management shall be employed in furtherance of this objective. 

- D. Economic development efforts shall encourage the revitalization and reuse of currently unused or underutilized structures, sites and infrastructure in appropriately located areas. 

- E. The Town shall encourage a public service and regulatory environment conducive to business recruitment and expansion, while at the same time enhancing the area’s physical and human resources. 

- F. New firms and expanding businesses that complement the natural resources and beauty of the region shall be especially recruited and encouraged. 

- G. The Town shall support the development of new business parks. 

- H. The Town shall promote coordination of economic development resources with the appropriate institutions and agencies. Regional coordination and interaction among areas with a shared economic interest shall be encouraged. 

- I. Small business start-ups, expansions and spin-offs shall be encouraged. The presence of ASU and Caldwell Community College and Technical Institute shall be recognized as a necessary and important resource for area businesses. 

- J. Appropriate educational and training programs shall be encouraged to help local residents, especially those unemployed and underemployed, take advantage of business expansion and to develop new skills. 

- K. Boone shall identify and provide services consistent with the needs of the area’s growing retiree population _._ 

## **2.1.5 Downtown** 

- A. A compatible design character for the downtown area, drawing upon the locality’s original HighCountry small-town features, shall be identified, reinforced and supported to put forth a quality image and sense of place. 

- B. The Town, in concert with the downtown property owners and merchants, shall encourage public and private efforts to develop and publicize adequate and appropriately designed off-street parking lots in the downtown area. 

- C. A variety of mutually compatible and supportive mixed uses shall be encouraged in the downtown area. 

**Packet Pg. 35**
{21}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **22** 

- D. Public and private developments shall be encouraged to incorporate local artistry into public and semi-public spaces downtown. 

- E. Public and private development decisions in the downtown area shall exhibit a special concern for maintaining the intensive, pedestrian oriented character of the district. 

- F. The maintenance and revitalization of downtown Boone, as well as planning for its future development, will reflect the realities and qualities befitting its geographical setting and function as a center of (1) commercial and service activities, (2) educational and cultural activities, events and (3) public services. 

## **2.3 THE COMMUNITY (p. 60).** 

- A. Urban type development within the Urban Growth Area shall meet appropriate Town standards. 

- B. Properly planned, mixed use developments that promote efficient provision of public services shall be encouraged within the Urban Growth Area. 

- C. Funding for outside agencies and organizations serving the citizens of Boone shall continue to receive support consistent with area service needs and Town budget constraints. 

- D. Coordinated inter-governmental and university-town planning for urban area land use and development, transportation, utilities, recycling, environmental management, law enforcement, education, recreation, tourism and economic development shall be encouraged. 

## **2.3.2 Community Character (p. 67)** 

- A. The identification, restoration and active use of structures, buildings, monuments, and neighborhoods of historic or architectural significance shall be encouraged as a means of enhancing their economic and cultural value to the planning area. 

- B. Multiple and appropriate adaptive reuse of historic resources shall be encouraged. 

- C. Wise development of the tourism potential of the area’s architectural, historic, scenic and natural resources shall be encouraged. 

- D. The destruction of significant architectural, historic, scenic, natural and archaeological resources in the planning area shall be discouraged. 

- E. New development, redevelopment and rehabilitation of structures and sites shall occur in a manner which is consistent with the neighborhood and architectural context of the immediate area, and supportive, whenever possible, of Boone’s original community character as a High-Country small town. 

## **2.3.4 Public Involvement** 

- A. Public involvement shall be encouraged in decisions concerning land use and development by making the public aware of proposed developments at the earliest opportunity, as well as fostering communication among developers, the Town, the County, the University, and the general public. ******** 

- B. Neighborhood and special area planning shall be encouraged to foster public involvement in the production of closely tailored, action oriented special area plans and programs. 

**Packet Pg. 36**
{22}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **23** 

- C. Specific functional plans and implementation tools shall be supported as part of the comprehensive planning program for the Town and County. 

- D. Special committees, advisory panels, educational forums, public workshops, leadership seminars, town meetings and media contacts shall be encouraged and fostered to enhance the effectiveness of citizen involvement in community planning and action. 

## **Automatic Conditions of Approval** 

The following conditions are automatically included and a part of any approval. 

- Where there is a conflict between the application information and the plans (November 21, 2023), the plans control. Insignificant deviations may be permitted to comply with the requirements of the UDO. 

- Any commitments and representations concerning the proposed exterior modification made by the applicant or its representatives at the public hearing shall also become a condition of the permit, and a basis for a stop work order and/or permit revocation if violated. 

- The applicant shall submit the necessary applications, plans, details and specifications which meet the requirements of the Town Code, UDO, Building Code and any other applicable codes for review and approval necessary to issue Zoning and Building Permits. 

## **Historic Preservation Commission Procedure** 

In considering this application for a COA the HPC shall base their decisions solely on the basis of competent, material and substantial evidence entered into the record via the application packet and sworn testimony at the public hearing. 

The question before the Historic Preservation Commission is whether or not the proposed development is congruous (i.e., in agreement, in harmony) with the special character of the historic district.  If the proposed exterior modification is congruous, the Commission shall issue the requested COA.  If the proposed exterior modification is incongruous (not in agreement, not in harmony) with the special character of the historic district, the Commission shall deny the requested COA.  The Commission shall approve, approve with conditions, or the deny the COA by majority vote. 

**Vote:** The proposed development  **is congruous  OR**  **is incongruous** with the special character of the Downtown Boone Local Historic District and is approved subject to the following conditions (as warranted): 

## 1. Conditions: 

_**Criteria for Conditions: The Commission may issue approval subject to reasonable conditions necessary to carry out the purposes served by the historic district (see G.S. 160D-940, 160D-947(a)).  The purposes of the historic district are to (i) safeguard the heritage of the town insofar as the Historic District embodies important elements of the town’s culture, history, architectural history, and/or prehistory, and (ii) to promote the use and conservation of the district for the education, pleasure, and enrichment of the residents of the town and/or the State as a whole, see North Carolina G.S. §160D-940, 944, 947(a).**_ 

**Packet Pg. 37**
{23}------------------------------------------------
**Packet Pg. 38**
{24}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **25** 

**Historic Photos** Below is a collection of historical photos of the subject property, obtained through a collaboration with Digital Watauga. The photos are displayed in their original size and resolution. For each photo, there is a citation for the photo. _**Staff Note: Planning Staff did not alter or edit the photos in any way, but only arranged them in this document for presentation purposes. Any commentary on the images is from the Digital Watauga technician(s) who found and sent the images to Planning Staff.**_ 

**Packet Pg. 39**
{25}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **26** 

Image courtesy: Unknown, “Town of Boone from the Southwest, April 1939,” Digital Watauga, htps://digitalwatauga.org/items/show/7973. 

**Packet Pg. 40**
{26}------------------------------------------------
**Case A23-0547 Portofino Hotel – COA for Major Work – Modification of Previous COA** | **27** 

Image courtesy: Palmer Blair, “The Town of Boone in 1950,” Digital Watauga, accessed April 29, 2022, htp://digitalwatauga.org/items/show/3566. 

**Packet Pg. 41**
