{0}------------------------------------------------
Exhibit 11 HPC Meeting Minutes Excerpts 

## **TOWN OF BOONE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES JULY 12, 2022, 3:00 p.m. WebEx Video Conferencing** 

## **______________________________________________________________________________________** 

## **Historic Preservation Commission Members in Attendance:** 

Chair Eric Plaag, Vice-Chair Bettie Bond, and Chuck Watkins 

**Council Liaisons:** Virginia Roseman 

## **Town Staff in Attendance:** 

Jane Shook-Director of Planning & Inspections, Christy Turner-Senior Planner, and Marlene Crosby-Board Secretary 

**Others in Attendance:** Tim Futrelle-Mayor, Amy Davis-Interim Town Manager, Allison Meade-Town Attorney, Jim Deal-Attorney at Deal, Moseley and Smith, John Winkler-Winkler Organization, Judah Goheen-Winkler Organization, Brent Davis-Brent Davis Architecture, Bill Dixon-Appalachian Architecture, Alan Crees-Municipal Engineering, Deron Geouque-County Manager and Chelsea Garrett-Attorney at di Santi, Capua and Garrett, PLLC 

## **_______________________________________________________________________________________** 

## **Call to Reconvene** 

Chair Eric Plaag reconvened the Boone Historic Preservation Commission hearing from June 14, 2022, held via WebEx, at 3:00 p.m. 

Discussion ensued on a possible modification to the agenda. Chair Plaag explained that the Council had asked the HPC to weigh in on the property involved in Case Z05606-032422 River Street Ventures – COA as to its historical value concerning the possibility of salvaging or moving the building. He asked Ms. Meade, because of the timesensitive nature of the request would it be appropriate for the HPC to make a formal recommendation in this hearing. Ms. Meade said yes if it is a time-sensitive topic. She generally said her preference would be for the HPC to consider their discussion on the said topic at their advisory meeting to prevent confusion. Ms. Shook noted that the applicant still has to go through the conditional district and then a zoning permit process. She said some time could be made for this discussion at the HPC’s next advisory meeting. Chair Plaag voiced his concern that the clock is already ticking on the 90 days for the materials to be submitted that were required to meet the conditions for the 90 days on the demolition. Ms. Meade pointed out that it should have been made clear at the last hearing that even though the HPC set the 90-day timetable, the Unified Development Ordinance has a standard requirement that no demolition is allowed until a final zoning permit is issued. Chair Plaag asked that this topic be placed on the next HPC advisory meeting agenda. He withdrew his suggestion to include the discussion and possible recommendation of the historical value and possible salvaging of the Café Portofino building. 

## **Case Z05606-032422 Rivers Street Ventures – Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Work** 

John Winkler, on behalf of Rivers Street Ventures, LLC, is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) for Major Work for the demolition of the existing building (currently Café Portofino) at 970 Rivers Street (Watauga County PIN: 2900-78-7965-000) at the Downtown Boone Local Historic District and proposed new construction of a one-story hotel. 

Chair Plaag announced that the case is being continued from May 10, 2022 till July 12, 2022. 

Chair Plaag reopened this case and Ms. Jane Shook, Director of Planning and Inspections, and Ms. Christy Turner, Senior Planner were sworn in. 

Ms. Meade confirmed with Planning Staff that there was no one from the public that had asked to speak on this case. 

- 1 - 

**Packet Pg. 64**
{1}------------------------------------------------
Chair Plaag asked the HPC the following questions: does anyone have a fixed opinion about the case that is not susceptible to change; have a conflict of interest regarding the case, including any financial interest in the outcome of the case; have a close familial relationship with any person affected by the outcome of the case; or engaged in any undisclosed ex-parte communication regarding this particular application. There were no answers in the affirmative to these questions. 

Chair Plaag confirmed with Mr. Jim Deal from Deal, Moseley, and Smith that he is the attorney for the applicant. Chair Plaag asked Mr. Deal if he had any objections to the materials submitted with the updated meeting packet. Mr. Deal said he had no objections. 

Chair Plaag asked if the Acme Historical Documentation Survey Report included other photographs than those within the report. Chair Plaag affirmed Mr. Judah Goheen from the Winkler Organization. Mr. Goheen responded that the consultant only gave them the photos in the report. Chair Plaag asked Mr. Deal if the consultant they hired provided a floor plan or a photo key to the building's exterior and interior. Chair Plaag said these things are often included in these kinds of reports. 

Ms. Meade pointed out that the HPC did not outline a particular sort of explicit requirements or expectations for the requested report. She said if the HPC feels like they did not receive enough information, it would be helpful for the HPC to discuss it so that future applicants and staff could be given better directions. Ms. Meade pointed out that the HPC could request that the applicant ask their consultant to provide the additional photos. She asked Chair Plaag the intent of the report. Chair Plaag said the goal is to document the building that had been designated as a historic building, even though that building is potentially demolished. He further explained that it is a mitigating measure in terms of preservation. Ms. Meade noted that we could be more explicit with applicants and staff moving forward with these details. 

Chair Plaag asked Mr. Deal if his applicant could ask their consultant to provide the following things: all photographs so they can be appropriately stored, and a floorplan with a photo key that documents various numbered photos taken inside and outside of the building. Mr. Deal said the applicant is willing to ask the consultant to provide these things, provided they will do it without an additional charge. Mr. Goheen asked if they could hand draw a floor plan. Chair Plaag agreed to accept a hand-drawn floor plan with the photo key. Ms. Meade suggested that the HPC accept the report that has been submitted and published in the meeting packet. There were no objections to the report in the meeting packet. 

Discussion ensued on the new proposed building elevations. Mr. Deal said that based on comments at the last hearing, the applicant had redesigned the building. Mr. Deal called on Mr. Brent Davis from Brent Davis Architecture as a witness to present the changes from the written description of the proposed work. After Mr. Davis was sworn in by Chair Plaag, Mr. Davis began his review of the proposed building changes from the packet between the April 28, 2022 submittal and the June 23, 2002, submittal. 

Mr. Deal asked Mr. Davis to speak to the comments in the meeting packet by Ms. Amy Flieg, Town of Boone Fire Marshal. Mr. Davis explained that a sprinkler room on the first floor of the proposed building would accommodate a backflow device. 

Discussion ensued on a revised site plan. Ms. Meade pointed out that a revised site plan was offered but inadvertently omitted from the meeting packet, but it has been added and can be viewed online. 

After Mr. Gaston was sworn in, he began explaining that he had met with Mr. Justin Stines, Facilities Maintenance Supervisor, and Ms. Flieg and discussed relocating the dumpster and changing the access by closing some of the entrances. Mr. Gaston said these proposed changes are not shown on the revised site plan currently shown but that he did have an updated one that he could email to Ms. Shook so that she could share. Once Ms. Shook 

- 2 - 

**Packet Pg. 65**
{2}------------------------------------------------
received the email she shared the revised site plan on the screen where Mr. Gaston explained that there was also a discussion about a fire apparatus, but since they are taking down two power lines directly in front of this building for this project, the fire department can use ladder trucks when needed. He added that the proposed parking spaces are now 45 as opposed to 47 spaces. He said that one significant change is that there is no longer any vehicular access to Howard Street from the proposed hotel parking lot. 

Chair Plaag asked Mr. Gaston about a fencing component at the northeast end of the parking lot. Chair Plaag asked if the current design would provide pedestrian egress from the parking lot for the proposed hotel to Howard Street. Mr. Gaston said that as the plans are currently drawn, there would not be pedestrian access. 

Chair Plaag asked the Planning Staff if they had any questions about the revised site plan. Ms. Turner said no and confirmed that the proposed parking spaces were adequate for the buildings. Ms. Meade asked the Planning Staff if they felt the submitted materials and design details were specific enough and met the requirements of the Unified Development Ordinance. Ms. Turner said yes at this time, unless the applicant makes other proposed changes or if something arises during the conditional district zoning map amendment process. 

Chair Plaag expressed his concern for the lack of pedestrian access to Howard Street from the parking lot and the potential impacts on neighboring properties. He said if there is no access given, there is a potential for pedestrians to walk through other areas to get from the hotel to Howard Street. He asked the Planning Staff if there was a mechanism in the UDO to allow pedestrian access. Ms. Turner said yes, the access could be by a sidewalk or walkway. She suggested that the Planning Staff review the Howard Street Plan to see if it is feasible to have an access point there. Ms. Meade asked if the applicant would be willing to agree to provide a pedestrian access with hardscape, subject to the condition of working with Mr. Stines and Mr. Todd Moody at the Public Works Department, and to be consistent with the Howard Street Plan. After being sworn in by Chair Plaag, Mr. John Winkler, the property owner, agreed to the proposed condition. 

Discussion ensued on the standard for new commercial construction projects. Chair Plaag asked for clarification on building height. Ms. Shook noted that as proposed the applicant had met the height requirements and due to ordinance requirements the applicant was required to do an additional process because the height of the proposed building exceeded the height of the original building. 

Discussion ensued on the appropriateness of a proposed new commercial building. Chair Plaag read Section 14.7 and pointed out that the proposed building is longer and higher than the existing building. He voiced his concerns from a mass, scale, and height perspective as to whether this building, for this particular part of the district, is appropriate in scale and massing. He said he is raising this issue because it is a change from what historically has been there. He said he wanted to be sure that the Planning Staff was not saying that the proposed project meets the district standard and only addresses the required standards of the UDO. Ms. Meade responded that this was correct. She suggested that the Planning Staff revise this section to clarify that they were speaking to general UDO standards. She said that otherwise, they would be pre-judging the work of the HPC. 

Discussion ensued on the staff comment under Section 14.10. Chair Plaag pointed out that this staff comment is incorrect in the staff report. Ms. Turner agreed that the staff comment was incorrect. 

Discussion ensued on the staff comment under Section 3.6 on packet page 161. Chair Plaag read this section and pointed out that the staff comment states that the applicant meets the UDO setback requirements. He asked if the setbacks are relevant to this particular standard, since this is a standard that addresses building mass and open space and the relationship between those two things, and not a UDO requirement regarding setbacks. In response to the staff comment, Ms. Meade noted that Ms. Turner might have been speaking to the underlying general UDO standards. She said it is up to the HPC to apply the historic standards. 

Chair Plaag opened the public comment session of the meeting. There was no public comment presented. 

- 3 - 

**Packet Pg. 66**
{3}------------------------------------------------
Chair Plaag asked Mr. Deal if he would like to rebut any evidence or discussion presented at this hearing. Mr. Deal said no. 

Chair Plaag asked Mr. Deal if he would like to give a closing summary or argument or defer that until after the staff has any interest in making additional statements. Mr. Deal said he would wait for Staff to comment. Ms. Turner said the Staff had no further comments. 

In summary, Mr. Deal pointed out that the revised site plan included everything the HPC requested. He reiterated that the proposed building is out of the floodway. He noted that inserting the set back in the center of the new proposed building changes the massing along the street. Mr. Deal noted that the applicant thought it was important to have a hotel support the downtown area. He said the applicant does recognize that a conditional district rezoning map amendment is required for the proposed hotel. He said opening up the stream, creating a pedestrian walkway, and closing the vehicular traffic to Howard Street all benefit the downtown area. 

Chair Plaag opened the floor to the HPC for discussion on the proposal of the new building design and its relationship to the applicable standards. Member Watkins confirmed that all the staff comments on packet page 151 had been met. Ms. Turner explained that certifications for the stream bank restoration would be required later. Member Watkins asked Chair Plaag if any wire-cut brick exists in the Downtown area. Chair Plaag said there is a mix of brick types and some buildings that fall into the period of significance have wire-cut bricks. Chair Plaag said he thought wire-cut brick was appropriate for the historic district. Member Watkins agreed with the proposed color of the brick. 

Chair Plaag explained that the HPC does not want to create a sense of false historicity in existing architecture or new construction because that would not be appropriate. 

Discussion ensued on scale and massing of buildings. Chair Plaag voiced his concern about controlling scale and massing so that it is appropriate for the historic district. 

Vice-Chair Bond noted that it is important to be careful about handling the first new construction due to the Howard Street project. She noted her concern for any precedence set that would influence projects in the historic district. 

Member Watkins congratulated the applicant and his team for the significant improvement in the proposed new building design; he thought it would fit well in the historic district. 

## **Motion and Vote:** 

Member Watkins made a motion, seconded by Vice-Chair Bond, to accept the proposed exterior modification of the proposed hotel because it is congruous with the special character of the historic district. 

Chair Plaag asked Member Watkins to accept a friendly amendment to add the condition for the pedestrian access from the proposed hotel parking lot to Howard Street. Member Watkins accepted the friendly amendment. 

Member Watkins also included the conditions of approval that are automatically included as a part of the approval. Vice-Chair Bond accepted this friendly amendment and to include the following conditions. 

1. New construction: Where there is a conflict between the application information (March 24, 2022) and the plans (June 24, 2022), the plans control. Insignificant deviations may be permitted to comply with the requirements of the UDO. 

2. Any commitments and representations made by the applicant or its (his or her) representatives at the public hearing shall also become a condition of the permit, and a basis for a stop work order and/or permit revocation if violated. 

- 4 - 

**Packet Pg. 67**
{4}------------------------------------------------
3. The applicant shall submit the necessary applications, plans, details and specifications which meet the requirements of the Town Code, UDO, Building Code and any other applicable codes for review and approval necessary to issue Zoning and Building Permits 

4. The applicant agreed to work with the Public Works Department to locate and to construct a pedestrian access between the hotel parking lot and the streetscape improvements for Howard Street. 

## **Vote:** Aye – all 

Nay – None **The motion passed.** 

___________________________________________________________________________________________ 

- 5 - 

**Packet Pg. 68**
