{0}------------------------------------------------
## Town of Boone 

## Planning and Inspections Department 

## Memorandum 

To: Historic Preservation Commission From: Jessica Mitchell Date: 7/29/2025 Subject: Feedback on Stoneman’s Raid Interpretative Panel to Consider for Further Revisions 

## Feedback on Stoneman’s Raid Interpretative Panel 

In communicating the revised draft text (as of June 10, 2025) with funding partners, there are comments that require further review by the Commission before the text is presented to Town Council for consideration. 

The feedback includes the following suggestions/revisions: 

1. Suggesting changes to the title : To not use the term “battle,” but rather “raid,” “skirmish,” or “occupation.” With a reference to this resource: 

https://encyclopediaofarkansas.net/entries/civil-war-military-event-terminology-18739/. 

2. Revision to paragraph one to make it more clear in regards to the former courthouse location where the Linney House is now. 

The suggestion is (shown in blue): 

On the morning of March 28, 1865, Union cavalry under Maj. Myles Keogh rode into 

Boone on the road to your left, surprising about 100 Confederate Home Guard members who had gathered to drill near the courthouse, then located a short distance north of here. 

3. Paragraph two is suggested to be revised for grammatical reasons. (Suggested revisions are included after this list of items.) 

4. Factual errors in paragraph six regarding the detachment led by Maj. Myles Keogh, which was a detachment of the Twelfth Kentucky Union Volunteer Cavalry and not the entire occupying force. The current language implies that there were 13 Union loyalists from Watauga in the Twelfth Kentucky; this is not accurate, as that count is representative of the entire Second and Third North Carolina Mounted Infantry. 

680 West King Street, Suite C, Boone, NC 28607 828.268.6960 

www.townofboone.net 

**10**
{1}------------------------------------------------
_For reference, the December 2023 draft of the text included the following text:_ At least thirteen of the volunteer Union troops who occupied Boone were Watauga County natives, one of whom, William Riley Horton, was Black. Union forces recruited another five residents at Boone before moving on. 

5. Another comment for the same paragraph is to the revise the reference of “Col. George Kirk’s North Carolina Mounted Infantry” to “Col. George Kirk’s Second and Third North Carolina Mounted Infantry” – as the accurate way to describe the troops. 

6. Requested change to the reference of the courthouse being burned in 1865. Accounts indicate that Stoneman’s men fortified the courthouse; such references as: Arthur's account, p. 178, and Spencer's account, 192-96, here: 

https://docsouth.unc.edu/true/spencer/spencer.html. It is accurate that the courthouse burned, but it was not during Stoneman’s Raid; the text is also accurate to mention that the jail burned. 

The suggestion between comments in items 3-6 for revisions are as follows (additions are shown in blue, deletions shown in ~~red,~~ areas for discussion are highlighted yellow): 

**(Paragraph 2)** ~~Keogh’s command, which included at least 13 Union loyalists from Watauga and surrounding counties, was the vanguard of Union Gen. George Stoneman 6,000-man cavalry command advancing into Virginia and North Carolina  with orders to avoid battles  and to “dismantle the country” – to destroy rail lines and materials that could be used by the then retreating Confederate Army.~~ Keogh’s detachment was the vanguard of Union Gen. George Stoneman’s 6,000-man cavalry command tasked with “dismantling the country” of Virginia and North Carolina. Priority was placed on avoiding battles while also destroying rail line and material that could be used by the retreating Confederate Army. 

**(Paragraph 6)** Beginning April 6, Col. George W. Kirk's ~~North CarolinaS~~ econd and Third Mounted Infantry (“Kirk’s Raiders”) occupied Boone for several weeks, blockading major routes through the mountains. At least 13 Union loyalists from Watauga County served in the regiments that occupied Boone, and another 5 volunteered with Union forces after Boone’s occupation. The 

jail was ~~and courthouse were~~ burned. 

If the changes above are accepted, the text word count would be 271, which is still under the 275-word limit, including the assistance from the Civil War Trails program to stay within the maximum word limit. 

2 

**11**
