{0}------------------------------------------------
###### **Staff Report March 25, 2024 Case A24-0095 Flag Lots/Cluster Subdivisions -UDO Text Amendment** 



<!-- Start of picture text -->
Northff.Carolina ;<br><!-- End of picture text -->

###### **<mark>Request</mark>** 

Modify language in the Town of Boone Unified Development Ordinance to allow “flag lots” in certain circumstances and to revise and modernize related standards for architecturally integrated (cluster) subdivisions. 

The Town of Boone is interested in the identification, evaluation, and implementation of effective and efficient land planning tools that support responsible residential development.  The purpose of this report is to evaluate and propose two options that are attended to address the area’s housing needs. 

###### **Flag Lots** 

The first option covered in this report is the creation and allowance of “flag lots”.  Currently, each lot created through the subdivision process must meet the dimensional requirements set forth for the zoning district in which the lot is located, including street frontage.  Street frontage for all new lots is set at 80% of the minimum lot width, with residential street frontage requirements ranging from 28’-56’.  One way to allow an increase in dwelling units in existing developed areas is to allow flag lots.  A flag lot is a lot that meets all other dimensional requirements except for street frontage.  Access to the lot/street frontage (flag section) is provided by either an easement or narrow strip of land (flagpole section) from either a publicly maintained or private street.   See example below: 



<!-- Start of picture text -->
Flag Lot Example<br>H Option A-Easement : Option B - Ownership i<br>| rca) eas | eis |<br>3 H a H H<br>a \ ry } 1a<br>a 1 popmersenes a | l°<br>a<br>wo) 9 (ar ResidualLot<br>S|<br>3)5 r HIie| ResidualLot Byie<br>|ia7 f<br>S| in iS.<br>2 8<br>rim | i<br>2|<br>2] pilot & Street Frontage Widths Min Wiats<br>q ——— a: ><br><!-- End of picture text -->

**Packet Pg. 166**
{1}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **2** 

While existing standards do not allow flagpole lots have the benefit of creating uniformity in neighborhoods in terms of lot size and shape, these standards also limit infill housing opportunities.  In this case, Staff uses the term “infill housing” to refer to increasing housing supply in existing residential areas by means of the creation of new lots similar in size to existing housing and served by expensive infrastructure (streets, water, sewer, police and fire protection, etc.) that is already in place. The draft text in Exhibit A sets forth the standards and limited instances where flag lots may be utilized and suggests restricting the use of flag lots, at least at this time, to only residentially zoned properties. 

###### **Cluster Subdivisions** 

In the process of revising text for flag lots, which necessitates a thorough review of current standards to rectify discrepancies, it became apparent to Staff that the “architecturally integrated subdivision” concept, a variant of a cluster subdivision, warranted reevaluation.  This is due to the introduction of new standards for flag lots that ought to be applied uniformly across any lot assessed during the cluster subdivision review, guaranteeing that these lots meet adequacy and safety requirements. 

Consequently, Staff advocates for the rebranding of the architecturally integrated subdivision to the more conventional and explicative term “cluster subdivision”.  Additionally, this presents an opportunity for Staff to align the cluster subdivision standards with the new standards proposed for flag lots and bring them up-to-date. 

Staff has coordinated with both the Fire Department and Public Works to ensure that any newly created lots created under the flag lot or residential cluster subdivision can still be adequately and safely served based upon NC Fire Prevention Code/Town Code and other operational standards. 

###### **<mark>CONFORMITY TO ADOPTED PLANS</mark>** 

###### **<u>COMPREHENSIVE PLAN UPDATE</u>** 

###### **1.1 Overall Objectives for the Boone Comprehensive Plan** 

The following objectives, which have not been listed in any particular order of importance, are deliberately broad in scope and less specific than either a policy statement or an implementation action. 

**Community Appearance and Community Character:** Blend the built environment with the natural, scenic, and historic character of a High Country small town. Especially discourage commercial strip development, cluttered signage, and “cheap” apartment buildings. 

###### **Automobile Transportation** 

Maximize the efficiency of existing facilities, but not at the expense town and neighborhood character and livability. Build or expand transportation facilities and parking areas as needed, but with care. Work to reduce auto dependency, use, and congestion. 

**Neighborhoods:** Ensure the livability of neighborhoods, especially through land use and traffic planning. **Public Involvement:** Encourage active public involvement and volunteerism to expand the effectiveness of community planning and action. 

**Comprehensive Plan Policies:** Staff has reviewed land use and comprehensive plan policies, and listed those policies which in staff’s opinion have a bearing on the request.  The Commission and Council should 

**Packet Pg. 167**
{2}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **3** 

review these policies carefully.  Each member may make his or her own interpretation as to the relevance of each and which carry the most weight thereby shaping their overall recommendation. 

###### **<u>COMPREHENSIVE PLAN POLICIES</u>** 

###### **2.2 Infrastructure** 

###### **2.2.1 Transportation** 

- **I.** Driveway cuts along major streets and roads shall be limited to allow these streets to serve primarily as safe traffic movement corridors or, alternatively, to maximize curb frontage for on-street parking. 

   - **I.1** Periodically evaluate the Town’s driveway regulations to minimize driveway cuts onto  area streets. 

###### **2.3 The Community** 

###### **2.3.2 Community Character** 

- A. The identification, restoration and active use of structures, buildings, monuments, and neighborhoods of historic or architectural significance shall be encouraged as a means of enhancing their economic and cultural value to the planning area. 

- E. New development, redevelopment and rehabilitation of structures and sites shall occur in a manner which is consistent with the neighborhood and architectural context of the immediate area, and supportive, whenever possible, of Boone’s original community character as a High Country small town. 

###### **2.3.3 Housing and Neighborhoods** 

- A.  The protection and rehabilitation of viable neighborhoods shall be encouraged to insure their continued existence as a major housing source and as a reflection of the area’s image as an attractive, highly livable community. 

- C.  Proposed residential development which would expose residents to harmful effects of incompatible development or to environmental hazards shall be prohibited. 

- D.  Innovative and flexible land planning and development practices shall be encouraged to create livable developments which better safeguard land, water, energy and historic resources. 

- F.  Factors in determining preferred locations for high density residential development shall include: close proximity to the university, employment or shopping centers; access to major thoroughfares and the transit system; the availability of public services and facilities; and compatibility with adjacent land uses. 

- G.  Compact, full service neighborhoods, offering opportunities for living, working, shopping, and gathering places, shall be encouraged in newly planned developments, as well as for redeveloping areas. 

- H. The overall housing unit density for proposed infill residential development or redevelopment should be compatible with the average density of existing areas. 

###### **2.3.4 Public Involvement** 

**Packet Pg. 168**
{3}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **4** 

- A. Public involvement shall be encouraged in decisions concerning land use and development by making the public aware of proposed developments at the earliest opportunity, as well as fostering communication among developers, the Town, the County, the University, and the general public. 

- C. Specific functional plans and implementation tools shall be supported as part of the comprehensive planning program for the Town and County. 

###### **<mark>PLANNING BOARD REPORT/RECOMMENDATIONS</mark>** 

Per NCGS 160D-604(b), subsequent to initial adoption of a zoning regulation, all proposed amendments to the zoning regulation or zoning map shall be submitted to the Planning Commission for review and comment. If no written report is received from the Planning Commission within 30 days of referral of the amendment to that board, the Town Council may act on the amendment without the Planning Commission report. The Town Council is not bound by the recommendations, if any, of the Planning Commission.  Per NCGS 160D-604(d), when conducting a review of proposed zoning text or map, the Planning Commission shall advise and comment on whether the proposed action is consistent with any comprehensive plan that has been adopted and any other officially adopted plan that is applicable. The Planning Commission shall provide a written recommendation to the governing board that addresses plan consistency and other matters as deemed appropriate by the Planning Commission, but a comment by the Planning Commission that a proposed amendment is inconsistent with the comprehensive plan shall not preclude consideration or approval of the proposed amendment by the governing board. 

**Vote 1:** The proposed amendment to the Town’s zoning ordinance  **is** OR  **is not** consistent with the Town’s comprehensive plan and any other adopted plan(s) of the Town that are applicable because: 

**_Note 1_** _: describe elements of controlling land use plans and how the amendment is or is not consistent._ 

_Note 1_ 

**Vote 2:** The Planning Commission recommends  **approval** OR  **denial** of Ordinance #A24-0095 within Exhibit A and  **approval** OR  **denial** is reasonable and in the public interest because: 

###### _Note 2_ 

**_Note 2_** _: briefly explain why, factors may include (i) the size, physical conditions, and other attributes of the area proposed to be rezoned, (ii) the benefits and detriments to the landowners, the neighbors, and the surrounding community, (iii) the relationship between the current actual and permissible development on the tract and adjoining areas and the development that would be permissible under the proposed amendment; (iv) why the action taken is in the public interest; and (v) any changed conditions warranting the amendment._ 

**Packet Pg. 169**
{4}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **5** 

###### **<mark>TOWN COUNCIL ACTION – Adoption of Ordinance</mark>** 

Per NCGS 160D-605, when adopting or rejecting any zoning text or map amendment, the Town Council shall approve a brief statement describing whether its action is consistent or inconsistent with an adopted comprehensive plan. The requirement for a plan consistency statement may also be met by a clear indication in the minutes of the governing board that at the time of action on the amendment the governing board was aware of and considered the planning board's recommendations and any relevant portions of an adopted comprehensive plan. 

**Vote 1:** The proposed amendment to the Town’s zoning ordinance  **is** OR   **is not** consistent with the Town’s comprehensive plan and any other adopted plan(s) of the Town: **_Note 1_** _: describe elements of controlling land_ 

**_Note 1_** _: describe elements of controlling land use plans and how the amendment is or is not consistent. Town Council members may reference the comprehensive plan policies in the Planning Commission’s recommendations, or use the other comprehensive plan policies as the Council member see relevant and pertinent to the_ 

_Note 1_ 

**Vote 2:** The Town Council  **approves** OR  **denies** Ordinance #A24-0095 to the Town’s zoning ordinance and believes  **approval** OR  **denial** is reasonable and in the public interest because: 

_case._ **_Note 2_** _: briefly explain why, factors may include (i) the size, physical conditions, and other attributes of the area proposed to be rezoned, (ii) the benefits and detriments to the landowners, the neighbors, and the surrounding community, (iii) the relationship between the current actual and permissible development on the tract and adjoining areas and the development that would be permissible under the proposed amendment; (iv) why the action taken is in the public interest; and (v) any changed conditions warranting the amendment._ 

_Note 2_ 

**Packet Pg. 170**
{5}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **6** 

###### **ORDINANCE # A24-0095** 

###### **AN ORDINANCE TO REVISE THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE TO REVISE THE STANDARDS FOR CLUSTER SUBDIVISIONS AND TO ALLOW FLAG LOTS IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES** 

WHEREAS **,** the Boone Town Council desires to modify the Unified Development Ordinance to allow flag lots in certain circumstances to promote appropriate infill residential to address the housing needs of the Town of Boone, and 

WHEREAS, the Boone Town Council held a duly-noticed public hearing on March 25, 2024 with respect to this ordinance; and 

WHEREAS, the Boone Town Council has taken into full consideration any information offered at the public hearing; and 

WHEREAS, this Town Council has reviewed the written recommendations of the Town of Boone Planning Commission; and 

WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that it is in the best interest of the Town and its citizens that Town Council directly consider and, with input from the public as deemed appropriate by Council; and 

WHEREAS, the Boone Town Council is authorized to enact this Ordinance pursuant to its zoning authority under G.S. Chapter 160D, Article 6; 

###### **NOW THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOONE TOWN COUNCIL THAT:** 

- **SECTION 1** . The Town of Boone Unified Development Ordinance (“UDO”) is hereby revised as set forth in the attached **Exhibit A** to this Ordinance, which is incorporated by reference, with deletions and additions shown in ~~red~~ and blue respectively: 

- **SECTION 2** . All provisions of any Town ordinance in conflict with this ordinance are hereby repealed to the extent of such conflict. 

- **SECTION 3** . In the event any section, subsection, subdivision, paragraph, subparagraph, item, sentence, clause, phrase or word of this ordinance is declared or adjudged to be invalid or unconstitutional, such declaration or adjudication shall not affect the remaining provisions of this ordinance, which shall remain in full force and effect as if the portion so declared or adjudged invalid or unconstitutional was not originally a part of this ordinance. 

**SECTION 4** . This Ordinance shall be effective immediately upon its adoption by Town Council. 

Adopted this the 24th day of April, 2024. 

###### **The Honorable Tim Futrelle, Mayor** 

**Attest:** 

**Nicole Harmon-Church, Town Clerk** 

**Packet Pg. 171**
{6}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **7** 

###### **<mark>Exhibit A</mark>** 

###### **Article 34 Definitions** 

###### **~~Architecturally Integrated Subdivision~~** 

~~A subdivision in which approval is obtained not only for the division of land into lots but also for a configuration of principal buildings to be located on such lots.  The plans for an architecturally integrated subdivision shall show the dimensions, height, and location of all such buildings to the extent necessary~~ 

~~to comply with the purpose and intent of architecturally integrated subdivisions as set forth in Section 5.10.~~ 

###### **Gross Land Area** 

All the area within the boundaries of a lot as described in a fee simple deed. 

###### **Interior Setback** 

The land area between the interior lot line and the closest wall of a building located on the property. 

###### **<u>Flag Lot</u>** 

<u>A lot meeting all dimensional requirements except street frontage and where access to the lot and street frontage is provided by either an easement or narrow strip of land to a publicly-maintained or private street.</u> 

###### **Lot** 

A parcel of land whose boundaries have been established by a legal instrument for purposes of transfer of title. 

###### **Lot of Record** 

A lot, parcel, or tract which has been recorded in the Watauga County Register of Deeds’ Office and which was in conformance with land development ordinances in effect at the time it was created. 

###### **Lot Area** 

The total area circumscribed by the boundaries of a lot, except that: [i] when the legal instrument creating a lot shows the boundary of the lot extending into a public street right-of-way, then the lot boundary for purposes of computing the lot area shall be the street right-of-way line, or if the right-of-way line cannot be determined, a line running parallel to and thirty feet (30’) from the traveled portion of the street, and [ii] in a residential district, when a private road that serves more than three (3) dwelling units is located along any lot boundary, then the lot boundary for purposes of computing the lot area shall be the inside boundary of the traveled portion of that road. 

###### **Lot Line** 

A line that marks the boundary of a lot. 

**Packet Pg. 172**
{7}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **8** 

###### **Lot Front** 

The lot line and yard area where the primary access is located.  In the case of additional equally significant access points located on other lot lines, the lot line and yard area for that access shall also be deemed a front. 

###### **Lot Line, Interior** 

Any lot line that is not a street lot line; a lot line separating a lot from another lot. 

###### **Lot Width** 

The horizontal distance between the side lot lines at the front building line measured parallel with the front lot line; or in the case of a lot fronting on a curved street, the straight-line distance between the side lot lines measured from the building line. 

###### **<u>Residential Cluster Subdivision</u>** 

<u>A residential subdivision within which lots do not meet minimum lot size or other minimum dimensional lot requirements (lot width, street setback, building spacing, etc.) generally required within the zoning district but the subdivision is designed so that (1) the overall density of the subdivision does not exceed the density set forth for the underlying zoning districts and (2) the amount of land saved with the creation of smaller lots is reserved as common open space for use by the property owners and residents.</u> 

###### **Setback** 

The land area located between a property line or the established edge of a right-of-way, whichever is closer, and the closest wall of a building located on the property. 

###### **Setback, Street** 

The land area between the established street right-of-way and the closest wall of a building located on the property. 

###### **Street Frontage Width** 

The horizontal distance measured along a straight line connecting the points at which the street lot line abuts such street with interior lot lines and or street lot lines. 

###### **5.10** **~~Architecturally Integrated~~** **<u>Residential Cluster</u> Subdivisions** 

**5.10.01** <u>A residential subdivision within which lots do not meet minimum lot size or other minimum dimensional lot requirements (lot width, street setback, building spacing, etc.) generally required within the zoning district but the subdivision is designed so that (1) the overall density of the subdivision does not exceed the density set forth for the underlying zoning districts and (2) the amount of land saved with the creation of smaller lots is reserved as common open space for use by the property owners and residents.</u> 

**Packet Pg. 173**
{8}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **9** 



<!-- Start of picture text -->
Residential Cluster Subdivision Example<br>y vw Al<br>Lot 1 t bed w Of { ‘we‘wfbd<br>‘<br>(flag Lot) \ iS ‘e<br>Yow ow<br>‘ ‘we ‘Common Area<br>S. Reserved Due to Stream Buffer ?<br>~. & Wetlands ?<br>Sweeney -*<br>Lot3 Lot 5<br>(flag lot) (flag tot)<br>Lot 2<br>Lot 4<br>name eee SS Ss = =<br>Total Area: 1 acre /43,560 safe fet 5000 square feet.<br>Zoned: R1 Single-Family Lot 2: 6,000 square feet<br>Min, Lot Size: 8,000 sq.ft Lot 3: 5,500 square feet<br>Maximum(43,560/8,000=5.45)Number of Lots: 5 4 7000 square feet<br>Note: All Lots have access to Lats 5.000 square feet<br>common eres Common Area: 15,060 square fet<br><!-- End of picture text -->

###### **<u>5.10.02</u>** <u>The residential cluster subdivision standards are established for the following purposes:</u> 

- **<u>A.</u>** <u>To provide flexibility in design in order to promote an efficient use of land and to protect environmentally sensitive areas (wetlands, riparian buffers, streams, steep slopes, wooded areas, special flood hazard areas, wildlife habitats, etc.).</u> 

**<u>B.</u>** <u>To provide flexibility in certain dimensional requirements without increasing overall</u> 

   - <u>density in order to allow a more flexible design than is permissible under the conventional subdivision process.</u> 

- **<u>5.10.03</u>** <u>Overall subdivision approval is outlined in Article 5 Subdivisions, with the exception of Uses 1.08-1.10 Townhouse, in which the subdivision approval is tied to the approval process set forth for the use.</u> 

- **<u>5.10.04</u>** <u>The tract of land to be subdivided may be held in single, multiple, or separate ownership, however the site shall be developed in accordance with a unified plan with common authority and common responsibility.</u> 

**<u>5.10.05</u>** <u>The use of the residential cluster subdivision process is limited to the following principal uses:</u> 

**Packet Pg. 174**
{9}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **10** 

- **<u>A.</u>** <u>1.01 Single-Family Dwelling</u> 

- **<u>B.</u>** <u>1.02 Manufactured Home Class A</u> 

**<u>C.</u>** <u>1.03 Manufactured Home Class B</u> 

   - **<u>D.</u>** <u>1.06-1.07 Duplex</u> 

   - **<u>E.</u>** <u>1.08-1.10 Townhouse</u> 

- **<u>5.10.06</u>** <u>Dimensional requirements: In</u> ~~an architecturally integrated~~ <u>residential cluster subdivision, the</u> applicant may create lots ~~and construct buildings without regard to any minimum lot size, lot width or setback restrictions except that~~ <u>pursuant to the following standards:</u> 

###### **<u>A.</u>** <u>Density</u> 

   <u>1. Townhouse Uses: The number of allowable lots for any townhouse use shall be limited by the minimum livability space and other development requirements (landscaping, parking, etc.) required for the development. For a townhouse subdivision that is composed of areas with different zoning designations, the number of lots shall be determined for each zoning district. The maximum number of lots for the project shall be the sum of the densities for each district.</u> 

   <u>2. The density (number of lots) for all other residential uses shall be calculated by dividing the total area by the minimum gross land area set forth for the underlying zoning district. For a subdivision that is composed of areas with different zoning designations, the number of lots shall be determined for each zoning district. The maximum number of lots for the project shall be the sum of the densities for each district.</u> _<u>See cluster subdivision example below.</u>_ 

- **<u>B.</u>** <u>Lot Width and Depth:  Each lot shall be of sufficient width and depth to accommodate the proposed dwelling and any required off-street parking.</u> 

###### **<u>C.</u>** <u>Setbacks</u> 

   <u>1. Interior setback requirements shall apply where and to the extent the subdivision abuts land that is not part of the subdivision. However, interior setbacks between lots within the subdivision may be reduced to no less than seven feet (7’).</u> 

   <u>2. Any flag lot in a residential cluster subdivision is not eligible for a reduction in setback and shall meet the minimum interior setback based upon the underlying zoning district.</u> 

   <u>3. Street: All lots, except flag lots as authorized in Subsection 14.03.06, shall meet the minimum street setback set forth for the underlying zoning district.</u> 

- **~~A.D~~** **<u>.</u>** <u>Livability Space Ratio:  Each cluster subdivision shall clearly indicate the maximum building footprint for each lot to determine that the development overall meets the minimum livability space ratio based upon the underlying zoning district.  For a</u> 

**Packet Pg. 175**
{10}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **11** 

<u>subdivision that is composed of areas with different zoning designations, livability space shall be determined and met for each zoning district.</u> 

- **~~B.E~~** **<u>.</u>** <u>Common Area: Residential cluster subdivisions shall provide to the owners and residents of the cluster subdivision an amount of common area equal to the land saved by creating lots smaller than normally required.</u> _<u>See cluster subdivision example below.</u>_ 

   ~~1. Lot boundary setback requirements shall apply where and to the extent that the subdivided tract abuts land that is not part of the subdivision, and~~ 

~~Each lot must be of sufficient size and dimensions that it can support the structure proposed to be located on it, consistent with all other applicable requirements of this Ordinance.~~ 

- **~~5.10.02~~** ~~The number of dwelling units in an architecturally integrated subdivision may not exceed the maximum density authorized for the tract. The number of lots allowed in an architecturally integrated subdivision shall be calculated by dividing the project area by the minimum gross land area set forth for the zoning district. For an architecturally integrated subdivision project that is composed of areas with different zoning designations, the number of lots shall be determined for each zoning district. The maximum number of lots for the project shall be the sum of the densities for each district. Further, only authorized uses shall be permitted in each zoning district.~~ 

- **~~5.10.03~~** ~~In architecturally integrated subdivisions the amount of land saved by creating lots that are smaller than the standards set forth in B1.04 Complete Intensity Table, shall be set aside as open space.~~ 

- **~~5.10.04~~** ~~The purpose of this Section is to provide flexibility, consistent with the public health and safety and without increasing overall density, to the applicant who subdivides property and constructs buildings on the lots created in accordance with a unified and coherent plan of development.~~ 

###### **Article 14 Zoning District Standards** 

- **14.03.01** Unless otherwise provided in this Ordinance, development shall comply with the intensity regulations set forth for the district.  Review Appendix B to view comparative tables that comprehensively list the intensity regulations set forth for the zoning districts enumerated in Section 14.01. 

   - **A.** Subject to the other provisions of this Ordinance, if (i) any portion of a tract lies within an area that is part of a proposed public park, sidewalk, greenway, bikeway, or other public improvement proposed by the Town and (ii) the owner of the tract, with the concurrence of the Town, dedicates to the Town that portion of the tract  then, when the remainder of the tract is developed, the permissible density at which the remainder 

**Packet Pg. 176**
{11}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **12** 

may be developed shall be calculated by regarding the dedicated portion of the original lot as if it were still part of the lot proposed for development. 

###### **14.03.02 Minimum Gross Land Area** 

- **A.** When a lot is located in more than one zoning district, the minimum square footage of the lot shall be the sum of the square footage derived by multiplying the minimum square footage required for each represented district by the proportion of the lot located within that district. 

- **B.** The area within the street right-of-way may not be used to satisfy lot area requirements. 

###### **14.03.03 Minimum Lot Width** 

- **A.** No lot may be created that is so narrow or otherwise so irregularly shaped that it would be impracticable to construct on it a building that: 

   1. Could be used for purposes that are permissible in that zoning district, and 

   2. Could satisfy any applicable setback requirements for that district. 

- **B.** Where a lot of fronts two (2) or more streets, the minimum lot width requirement shall be considered met if the lot width at the street setback from any one of such streets meets the minimum lot width requirement. 

- **C.** No lot created after the effective date of this Ordinance that is less than the required width shall be entitled to a variance from any building setback requirement. 

###### **14.03.04 Minimum Street Frontage Width** 

- **A.** The minimum width of the frontage of a lot on a street shall be eighty percent (80%) of the minimum lot width required for the lot. Easement areas shall be excluded from this requirement. 

- **B.** Where a lot fronts on two (2) or more streets, the minimum street frontage width requirements shall be considered met if the frontage along any one of such streets meets the minimum street frontage width requirements. 

- **C.** Where a lot fronts on a turning circle of a cul-de-sac or at a point of a street where the radius of the curvature of the right-of-way is less than ninety feet (90’), the minimum street frontage width requirement shall not apply. 

###### **14.03.05 Livability Space Ratio** 

- **A.** Livability space includes natural areas, lawns and other landscaped areas, walkways, terraces, sitting areas, outdoor recreational areas, and the pervious, landscaped portion of street rights-of-way. Livability space does not include paved pedestrian sidewalks or vehicular areas 

**Packet Pg. 177**
{12}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **13** 

- **B.** A maximum of one-third of the livability space required for a development may be impervious (e.g., paved terraces or sitting areas). 

- **C.** Livability space ratio is a ratio where the numerator is the square footage of Livability Space and the denominator is the square footage of the entire parcel. 

###### **<u>14.03.06 Residential Flag Lots</u>** 

- **A.** <u>Residential flag lots are permissible where there is adequate lot area to divide the property into two (2) or more lots but not enough street frontage to meet the minimum street frontage requirement.  The intent is to promote the efficient use of land to provide additional housing opportunities while meeting standards for both fire protection and solid waste, recycling, and similar services to the newly created lot(s).</u> 

- **<u>B.</u>** <u>Flag lots are only allowed in residential zoning districts for Use 1.01 Single-Family Dwelling with permissible accessory uses.</u> <u><mark>Due to limited access, accessory dwellings are prohibited on any flag lot.</mark></u> _<u><mark>Staff Note:  FOR DISCUSSION</mark></u>_ 

- **<u>C.</u>** <u>Flag lots must comply with the standards of the underlying zoning district unless otherwise specified herein.</u> 

- **<u>D.</u>** <u>Minimum Gross Land Area: Each flag lot shall meet the minimum gross land area based on the underlying zoning district.</u> 

- **<u>E.</u>** <u>Minimum Lot Width: Each flag lot shall meet the minimum lot width based on the underlying zoning district at the point the “pole section” meets the “flag portion” of the flag lot. Residual lots giving an easement to the flag lot may count the area within the easement as part of the residual lots required lot width.</u> 

**Packet Pg. 178**
{13}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **14** 

5<sup>z</sup> f 

- **<u>F.</u>** <u>Flag Lot Setbacks:  No structure, other than a solid waste enclosure just large enough to satisfy the requirements of Town Code Section 91.05, shall be built in the “pole portion” of a flag lot.  The flag section of the lot shall meet interior setbacks unless a street setback</u> 

   - <u>is applicable:</u> 

**Packet Pg. 179**
{14}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **15** 

'H'1 

- **<u>G.</u>** <u>Flag Lot Access:  Flag lots are encouraged to utilize the same driveway as the residual lot, however:</u> 

   <u>1. All driveways shall meet the driveway requirements set forth in UDO Section 23.03 and Section 24.03.</u> 

   <u>2. In no case may a driveway serving a flag lot exceed 200’ in length from the street to the parking area without permission of the Fire Chief.</u> 

   ~~<mark>1. All driveways serving a flag lot shall have a travel lane at least twelve foot (12’) in width.  This twelve foot (12’) travel lane shall be kept free of any overhanging</mark>~~ ~~<u>p</u>~~ ~~<mark>branches or landscape material to a height of thirteen feet six inches (13’6”) to allow</mark> C~~ ~~<mark>access by responding fire apparatus.</mark>~~ 

**Packet Pg. 180**
{15}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **16** 

2S 

**~~B.H~~** **<u>.</u>** <u>Flag Lot Building Height:   To maintain continuity of mass and scale within neighborhoods, all dwelling units on flag lots, except for those located in the R1S zoning district, may be one-story greater than the tallest dwelling unit on lots immediately adjacent to the flag lot, so long as the flag lot dwelling unit meets the maximum stories/maximum height set forth for the underlying zoning district.</u> 

**Packet Pg. 181**
{16}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **17** 



<!-- Start of picture text -->
Flag Lot Example - Height<br>i Option A-Easement i Option B - Ownership i<br>5z<br>if<br>5<br>F Residual Lot<br>! Io<br>ae 1 fel<br>5 | bed<br>col i 5 Ss"<br>2] e<br>uw !<br>3|<br>Communication: Case A24-0095 Staff Report  (Case A24-0095 Flag Lots & Architecturally Integrated Subdivisions - UDO Text Amendment)<br><!-- End of picture text -->

## <mark>For Discussion:  Some ordinances require dwelling units built on flag lots to be the same</mark> ~~<u>pT</u>~~ <mark>number of stories of the residual lot or adjacent lots.  Staff believes that this may be too</mark> ~~<u>pT</u>~~ <mark>limiting based upon topography and steep slope issues. However, height of new</mark> ~~<u>ee</u>~~ <mark>construction may have an impact on the overall character of existing neighborhoods.</mark> ~~ee~~ 

- **<u>I.</u>** <u>Solid Waste, Recycling, & Special Collections: All applicants seeking approval of a flag lot shall demonstrate that the owners have a plan to meet the requirements of Town Code Sections 91.05 and 91.06 for both the storage and collection of solid waste, recycling, and other special collections.  This plan shall be presented to the Public Works Department for review and approval and may require additional easements with notation on the final plat.</u> 

**Packet Pg. 182**
{17}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **18** 

> ais} £ 

###### **Article 24 Parking** 

###### **24.02 Parking Space Dimensions and Required Widths of Parking Area Aisles and Driveways** 

**24.02.01** Subject to Subsections 24.02.02, 24.02.03 and 24.02.06, each parking space shall contain a rectangular area at least seventeen- and one-half feet long (17.5’) and nine feet (9’) wide. Lines demarcating parking spaces may be drawn at various angles in relation to curbs or aisles, so long as the parking spaces so created contain within them the rectangular area required by this Section. 

**24.02.02** In parking areas containing ten (10) or more parking spaces, a rectangular area of only sevenand one-half feet (7.5’) in width by fifteen feet (15’) in length, may be conspicuously designated as reserved for compact cars in the following situations: 

- **A.** Multi-family uses may provide up to fifty percent (50%) of the parking spaces for compact cars. 

**Packet Pg. 183**
{18}------------------------------------------------
Case A24-0095 Flag Lots – UDO Text Amendment | **19** 

   - **B.** All other uses may provide up to thirty-five percent (35%) of the parking spaces for compact cars. 

   - **C.** Compact spaces must be signed as “compact”. 

- **24.02.03** Wherever parking areas consist of spaces set aside for parallel parking, the dimensions of such parking spaces shall be not less than twenty-three feet (23’) by nine- and one-half feet (9.5’). 

- **24.02.04** Parking area aisle widths shall conform to the Table 24.02 Geometric Design Standards for Parking Table, which varies the width requirement according to the angle of parking. 

###### **<u>24.02.05</u>** **~~<u>24.02.05</u>~~** **<u>Driveway Width</u>** 

- **A.** <u>Driveways, including a shared driveway to no more than two lots, serving a single-family or a two-family dwelling shall be at least 12’ in width.  This 12’ travel lane shall be kept free of any overhanging branches or landscape material to a height of 13’6” to allow access by responding fire apparatus. However, wider widths or a vehicle turnaround for larger vehicles may be required to satisfy fire protection requirements when a driveway exceeds 200’.</u> 

- **B.** <u>Unless required differently under the NC Fire Prevention Code, all other</u> ~~Dd~~ <u>riveways for</u> shall not be less than ~~eleven~~ ~~<u>t</u>~~ <u>welve feet (</u> ~~112~~ ’) in width for one-way traffic and eighteen feet (18’) in width for two-way traffic, except that ~~elevent~~ <u>welve</u> feet ( ~~112~~ ’) wide driveways are permissible for two-way traffic when: 

   1. The driveway is no longer than fifty feet (50’), and 

   2. The driveway provides access to not more than six (6) spaces, and 

   <u>3. Sufficient turning space is provided so that vehicles need not back into a public</u> street. 

**Packet Pg. 184**
