{0}------------------------------------------------
Exhibit 2 

## **Boone Historic Preservation Commission Local Landmark Designation Report** 

## **R. L. Clay House (Rivers House)** 

## Prepared by Ellie McCorkle with assistance from the 

Boone Historic Preservation Commission July 2023, Final Draft, February 2024, Final Revised 

**Packet Pg. 38**
{1}------------------------------------------------
## **R. L. Clay House (WT0530)** 

## **I. General Information** 

A. Common and Historical Property Names 1. R. L. Clay House (Ca. 1933-1945) 2. R. C. Rivers House (Ca. 1945-Present) B. Physical Address or Location 1. 150 Clay House Dr., Boone, NC 28607 a. North (primary) elevation faces Rivers Street C. Tax Parcel Identification Numbers (PIN) 1. PIN: 2900-78-3934-000 2.   PIN: 2900-69-9070-000 3.   PIN: 2900-79-0308-000 D. Current Owner Name 1. The current owner is the Town of Boone and has been since the donation of the house and related properties beginning in 1998. There was a life tenancy included with the house deed, but this person left the house permanently in 2011 and no longer survives. It has been uninhabited since and used for storage. E. Current Owner Mailing Address(es) 1. 567 West King Street, Boone, NC 28607 F. Appraised Value of the Property (2022) 1. PIN 2900-78-3934-000: Total value $682,200. Land value is $55,300 and building value is $626,900. 2.   PIN 2900-69-9070-000: Land value is $821,100. 3.   PIN 2900-79-0308-000: Land value is $108,600. G. Date of Construction 1. House: Circa 1933 2. Garage: Before 1940 (perhaps 1933) H. Historical Significance 1. Criterion B: Association with Significant Person(s), 1945-1998 2. Criterion C: Architectural Significance, 1933-1940 I. Statement of Property Designation: 1. The proposed boundaries of the designation follow the surveyed boundaries for all listed parcels: 2900-78-3934-000, 2900-69-9070-000, and 2900-79-0308000. These parcels include the house, the garage (interior not included for the house and garage), a portion of the drive leading to the house and garage (Clay House Drive), the Daniel Boone Monument/Rivers Park, land along the ridgeline to the north and northwest of the house, “Rachel’s meadow,” and “Baby,” the North Carolina state champion sugar maple. See pages 8 and 9 for further information. 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 2 **Packet Pg. 39**
{2}------------------------------------------------
_The original report drafted by Ellie McCorkle was substantially revised and edited into this final version by the following members of the Boone Historic Preservation Commission: Elizabeth Bond, Eric Plaag, James Sharp, Charles Watkins, and Riley Ziegler. January 2024 modifications were edited into this final version by the following members of the Boone Historic Preservation Commission: Elizabeth Bond, Vardell Smyth, Krystal Carter, and Jerry Williamson._ 

_The 1950 cover image of the R. L. Clay House, taken from the northeast, is used courtesy of the Palmer Blair Collection, Digital Watauga Project._ 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 3 **Packet Pg. 40**
{3}------------------------------------------------
## **II. Brief Statement of Significance** 

The R. L. Clay House is proposed for designation as a local historic landmark due to its high level of local significance for its association with several members of the Rivers family who were influential in the history of the Town of Boone. Members of the Rivers family resided in and owned the home for more than 50 years as they operated and published the local newspaper, the _Watauga Democrat_ . R. C. Rivers, Jr., ran the _Watauga Democrat_ for 42 years, 30 years of that while residing in this home. Rachel Rivers-Coffey, the granddaughter of R. C. Rivers, Sr., and daughter of R. C. Rivers, Jr., was raised in the home before she took over the _Watauga Democrat_ following her father’s death in 1975 and continued to run the paper until 1994. She and her husband Paul Armfield Coffey donated the property to the Town of Boone in 1998. 

The R. L. Clay House is also locally significant for its architecture. The one and a half-story R. L. Clay House with its subdued, Colonial Revival influences was constructed using native stone and completed circa 1933. Its use of native stone is an early local example of a popular trend that accelerated with the Works Progress Administration (WPA) funding of the construction of other Colonial Revival, native stone buildings during the mid to late 1930s. Also included as a contributing resource in this designation is the two-story, native stone garage to the southeast of the home, which was likely constructed simultaneous to the house and certainly before 1940. There is a prize sugar maple tree, “Baby,” that straddles two of the parcels within the boundary to the northwest of the R. L. Clay House. At the northeast end of the boundary is Rivers Park, a stone monument area built in 2005 containing a reconstruction of historic Daniel Boone Monument that originally stood several hundred yards to the southeast. The parcels proposed for designation continue to provide historic context for the close relationship the Rivers family had to the town and community of Boone. 

Three of seven legal parcels in this vicinity that are owned by the Town of Boone are proposed for designation, all three of which were associated with the Rivers family from at least the mid 1940s. The Town of Boone acquired all three parcels through donations by Rachel Rivers-Coffey and/or Paul Armfield Coffey. This is not all of the land once associated with the property, as some of the original Clay and Rivers holdings were either subdivided or sold off, then developed by private individuals and companies. The other four nearby parcels owned by the Town are either noncontiguous to the boundary parcels or not historically associated with the Rivers family. 

## **III. Architectural Description** 

The R. L. Clay House is a one and a half-story, side-gabled home with a native, cut stone exterior, and it features subdued, Colonial Revival influences. It is three bays wide and built to face north, toward present-day Rivers Street. The house sits perpendicular to another street historically known as South Water Street (recently renamed Burrell Street). Access to the property is via a long, circuitous driveway, known as Clay House Drive, located off of Moretz Drive to the southeast. The property retains a one and a half-story, two-bay garage that also features a native, cut stone exterior. This garage is located at the end of Clay House Drive and just southeast of the house. Walkways, outside stairwells, retaining walls, and curbing throughout the property are also of native, cut stone and are apparently part of the original 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 4 **Packet Pg. 41**
{4}------------------------------------------------
landscaping plan. The roof of the house, until recently, was composed of asbestos shingles designed to resemble slate, but these were probably not original. These shingles were removed in 2015 and replaced with more traditional asphalt shingles. 

The north (front) façade of the R. L. Clay House features an irregular, front-gabled porch entrance that is reached by stone steps with stone cheek walls. The entrance to the porch features a flat arch lintel with a gothic-style light above, and the interior of the porch includes a stone bench on the east side of the porch with two rectangular window openings on either side of the porch. Wood weatherboard was used for the interior porch ceiling. The main entrance features a twelve-light, wooden door that is protected by an aluminum screen door. This entrance, while intended as the front door to the home, is no longer used for interior access by the Town of Boone. Immediately to the east of the porch is a prominent, exterior chimney of native stone with alternating steps that narrow the chimney as it rises. There is a pale, stone diamond in the center of the chimney, an architectural detail that is continued throughout the design of the home, interior and exterior. The chimney includes a pronounced concrete cap with brick piers at its four corners. Further to the east of the chimney and porch on the first floor is a double set of six-oversix, double-hung sash windows with a wooden surround, aluminum storm windows, and stone sills. Beyond this to the east, the first floor of the north elevation opens to a square, interior porch with stone flooring and walls as well as a wooden weatherboard ceiling. This is all anchored to the footprint of the house by a stone column at the northeast corner of the porch. 

The porch includes one wooden doorway along the interior south wall at the southwest corner of the porch, with another similar door at the same corner along the west wall of the porch. This west wall entrance is currently used as the main entrance by the Town of Boone. Both doors are covered with aluminum screen doors. To the north of the second door, still on the west wall of the porch, is a single, six-over-six, double-hung sash, wooden window with a wooden surround, a stone sill, and an aluminum storm window protecting it. A gothic light fixture hangs at the center of this interior porch space; some of the glass panels in this fixture are broken and missing. 

Visible under each window grouping on the north elevation are two basement-level vents. The west side of the north elevation has a triple bay of six-over-six, double-hung sash, wooden windows with wooden surrounds and a stone sill. All three are covered with aluminum storm windows. The second floor of the north elevation features two projecting, symmetrically spaced, gabled dormers, each clad in weatherboard on their sides and what appear to be shingles on the gable fronts. This shingle material may be of asbestos that has since been painted. The dormers include prominent cornice returns with double sets of six-over-six, double-hung sash, wooden windows with wooden surrounds and aluminum storm windows over them. Small vents are visible just below the apexes of these dormer gables. 

The first floor of the west elevation, reading from north to south, is primarily of native stone and includes a single, six-over-six, double-hung sash, wooden window with an aluminum storm window covering. A short distance to the south is an identical window. Near the center of the elevation, but offset slightly to the south, is a smaller, double window group of six-over-six, double-hung sash, wooden windows with a wooden surround, stone sill, and aluminum storm window coverings. A short distance to the south of this is a single window that is otherwise 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 5 **Packet Pg. 42**
{5}------------------------------------------------
identical to those found in the double window grouping. Just above this window, the south end of the gable roofline abruptly evens out to accommodate an enclosed porch that includes another double set of windows identical to those at the center of the west elevation, with a small amount of the same asbestos shingle treatment visible between the tops of the windows and the roofline, while the bulkhead below the windows is parging over an unknown material (possibly concrete block). At ground level are three basement vents with stone lintels and stone window wells. The second floor of the west elevation includes a double set of the windows at an intermediate size between the small and large examples found elsewhere on the west elevation, but otherwise identical in their design and treatment. This set is centered underneath the west gable. The roofline of the west gable includes an aluminum, boxed soffit that sports an oddly shaped cornice return at the northwest corner of the house and at no other corner. 

The south elevation of the house is irregularly shaped. Reading from west to east, the first floor of the south elevation is dominated by the three-season enclosed porch that runs nearly to the center of the back of the house. This porch continues the previously described, parged bulkhead treatment, with a centered, four-light door with an aluminum storm door over it; this door is flanked by double sets of windows like those found on the west elevation of this porch. For reasons that are not clear, the roofline of this porch steps down near its junction with a secondfloor window, perhaps in an effort to not block that window. The east return wall of this rear porch repeats the asbestos shingling for a short distance below the roof slope, with the bulkhead treatment taking up the whole east return wall. At its base is a set of stone steps with a stone stairwell wall leading down to a basement door with an aluminum storm door. This door is not visible from the interior of the basement, indicating that it leads to a separate storage space under the home. Above this, along the main body of the house, is a double set of large, six-over-six, double-hung sash, wooden windows with a wooden surround, stone sill, and aluminum storm windows. Above this, the second floor of the main block of the house reads as a wide dormer. At its center is a medium-sized, double window grouping otherwise identical to those found elsewhere with a single window of similar size just to the west, over the stepped-down porch roof. A much smaller window, also otherwise identical, is visible to the east of this centered, double window group. This wide dormer features wooden weatherboard on the west and east sides of the dormer. A stone interior chimney rises from a high point of the south-facing roof at a junction with the west side of the south dormer, while another interior chimney rises from the east side of the south-facing roof, separated by a short distance from the south dormer. 

Back at the first floor level is another projection at the southeast corner of the house, with a small, single, one-over-one, horizontal light, wooden window with a stone sill and aluminum storm window over it on the west elevation of this projection. A large, single window like most of the others on the house is centered on the south elevation of this southeast projection. Along this south elevation of the house about ten feet from the back of the house is a long, stone retaining wall that runs parallel with the house to a set of stone steps with a stone cheek wall and an iron railing just beyond the southwest corner of the house. This retaining wall continues a short distance, parallel with the west elevation of the house. 

The first floor of the east elevation, moving from south to north, includes a large window like those found elsewhere, followed a short distance to the north by a large, double window group like those found elsewhere. A short distance to the north of this is a set of stone steps with stone 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 6 **Packet Pg. 43**
{6}------------------------------------------------
cheek walls on each side and an iron railing along the top of the north cheek wall. This set of steps leads to the aforementioned open, interior porch at the northeast corner of the house. The second floor of the east elevation features a medium-sized, double set of windows identical to those on the west elevation, centered just below the gable. A boxed, aluminum soffit terminates in prominent cornice returns at both ends of the roofline. Leading away from the porch steps is a cut stone pathway, with the iron railing continuing along its length. This terminates at a step down to the asphalt driveway of Clay House Drive, which is itself bounded on its west and south sides by a low, stone retaining wall. 

At the southeast end of this driveway is a detached, front-gabled, one and a half-story, two-car garage of cut stone. Its north elevation includes two symmetrically spaced, garage bay doors of vertical wood slats, with a large, six-over-six, double-hung sash, wooden window with wooden surround and stone lintel centered beneath the gable. The roofline includes an aluminum, boxed soffit that terminates in prominent cornice returns. The west and east walls of the garage are essentially featureless stone while the south elevation, which is built partially into the grade, includes a set of wooden steps rising to the upper level of the garage, which is accessed via a wooden door with a deep wooden surround. The roofline on this gable end also includes an aluminum, boxed soffit that terminates in prominent cornice returns.[1] 

There is a low, creekstone retaining wall along the sloping edge of the north portion of the property, facing Rivers Street. The wall was likely more prominent when first constructed but has since been obscured by overgrowth and has partially collapsed. It appears to have been placed to aid in landscaping for the rhododendrons that grow along its top. 

On the northeast corner of the larger parcel (2900-69-9070-000) being designated there is a monument and small park, Rivers Park, that is included in the proposed boundary. The monument feature, known as the Daniel Boone Monument (WT0567), is a stone obelisk with a pinnacle of either parged stone or concrete, capped by a rough stone finial; together, they stand approximately 25 feet tall. This monument is a replica of one built twice before and originally meant to denote where a cabin once stood that local legend alleges may have been inhabited seasonally by Daniel Boone in the late eighteenth century.[2 ] Commemorative tablets from the original monument are mounted within the base of the present iteration of the obelisk. Surrounding the monument is a native stone, circular wall, bisected by entries at the east and 

1 Almost the entirety of this architectural description is taken, with minor adjustments, from Eric W. Plaag, et al, “Comprehensive Architectural Survey of Downtown Boone, North Carolina,” (Boone, NC, February 2021), 97-101, http://www.townofboone.net/DocumentCenter/View/1334/Comprehensive-Architectural-Survey-of-DowntownBoone-North-Carolina-2021. 

2 The original version of this monument stood on the north side of the intersection of Stadium Drive and Rivers Street, near the present Daniel Boone and Dogs statue. This original version was composed of rough-cut, stone blocks with a pyramidal cap of concrete that tapered in a phallic, pyramidal spearpoint. In 1968, the monument was deconstructed and moved approximately 50 yards to the east to a point just northeast of the former location of Justice Hall dormitory, just southeast of Stadium Drive, where it was reconstructed in April 1969. This reconstruction used entirely different materials and was proportioned differently in terms of overall height and the proportions of its cap. This version was demolished in 1994. After rescuing the original engraved tablets from the original monument, the Town of Boone reconstructed the monument at Rivers Park in 2005. For more on this feature, see Plaag, “Comprehensive Architectural Survey,” 101-02, from which much of the description in this note is taken. 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 7 **Packet Pg. 44**
{7}------------------------------------------------
west ends. Portions of the south portion of the perimeter wall are stepped with the terrain, and all elements of the wall are capped by a concrete slab. Additional commemorative plaques are adhered to the south portion of the perimeter wall. 

No significant archaeological features are known to be on the property at this time. 

## _Integrity_ 

The association between this property and the Rivers family is undivided and uninterrupted during the period of significance and more broadly during their lifetimes until the property was transferred to the Town of Boone for its protection in the late 1990s. The house and garage have never been moved and are still associated with much of the original acreage the Rivers family would have enjoyed while residing at the property. The design of both the residence and the garage is original and still retains the original features that make both buildings architecturally significant. The alteration of the south porch of the residence from an open to an enclosed porch appears to have occurred during the 1970s, and while the materials used for this porch do not match the stonework of the rest of the house, this is a relatively minor change to the tertiary elevation of the house, so the impact on material and design integrity is minimal. The exterior cladding materials of both the home and the garage are original and in good condition, and they continue to reflect the workmanship of the home’s skilled mason, John L. Hickerson (see significance section). The roof was replaced recently on both the house and the garage, but the materials selected generally match the appearance of the original materials. The aluminum storm windows are not original to the home and are in fair condition; this reversible application serves to protect the original windows that are still in place. As far as setting, much of the property is still characterized by the thick forest that remains to the north and west of the home, and “Rachel’s Meadow,” a bowl-shaped feature to the west and southwest of the home, still retains its topography. Taken together, the landscape and building resources of the property continue to convey the historic feeling of the 1930s, when the home was first built, and the 1940s through the 1990s, when members of the Rivers family resided here. As the home, garage, and surrounding landscape have remained largely unchanged, excepting the south porch of the house, there is little that detracts from the integrity of the property and its building resources. 

## _Boundary Justification_ 

The proposed boundaries of the designation follow the surveyed boundaries for all listed parcels: 2900-78-3934-000, 2900-69-9070-000, and 2900-79-0308-000.[3 ] These parcels include the house, the garage, a portion of the drive leading to the house and garage (Clay House Drive), the Daniel Boone Monument/Rivers Park, land along the ridgeline to the north and northwest of the house, “Rachel’s meadow,” and “Baby,” the North Carolina state champion sugar maple. The combined acreage for the boundary amounts to 9.54 acres of the original 13 to 15 acres associated with the home under the Rivers’ ownership. While this does not include all of the property that was once associated with the Rivers family during the Rivers occupancy, it does include all pertinent 

3 Rachel Rivers-Coffey and Armfield Coffey to Town of Boone, 28 October 1998, Book of Record 480, Page 494; Rachel Rivers-Coffey and Armfield Coffey to Town of Boone, 28 October 1998, Book of Record 480, Page 496; and Armfield Coffey, personally and as Executor of the Estate of Rachel Rivers-Coffey, to Town of Boone, 26 January 2000, Book of Record 553, Page 297 (Tract III). All references are from the Watauga County Register of Deeds. 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 8 **Packet Pg. 45**
{8}------------------------------------------------
buildings associated with the home and its human inhabitants, and the associated parcels are contiguous, making for an uninterrupted boundary. The proposed boundary parcels surrounding the home and garage provide context for understanding the use of the property by those who lived in the home during its historically significant periods in the mid-twentieth century. 

The first of these parcels, 2900-78-3934-000, contains the R. L. Clay House, the garage, and part of Clay House Drive. It totals 0.26 acres. The second parcel, 2900-69-9070-000, is located to the northeast, north, west, and south of the house parcel and contains Rivers Park, the reconstructed Daniel Boone Monument, and what was once the horse pasture (“Rachel’s Meadow”) for the horses owned by Rachel Rivers-Coffey. It totals 8.15 acres. This parcel and/or the third parcel slightly to the northwest (2900-79-0308-000) contains “Baby,” a champion sugar maple registered with the North Carolina Register of Big Trees.[4 ] This last parcel contains 1.13 acres. 

In total, there were seven parcels historically associated with the Rivers family in this vicinity. The smaller parcel to the southeast (2900-78-3881-000) was donated to the Town of Boone by Paul Armfield Coffey in 2004. This parcel originally contained the small frame house that appears to have been the original R. L. Clay House that previously stood on the 1933 Clay House site but was moved in late 1932 to make way for construction of the newer stone residence.[5 ] This house was burned and then demolished by the Town of Boone on May 30, 2015, as part of a firefighting training exercise after attempts to sell or relocate the house failed.[6 ] Because the Rivers family did not control this parcel until 1984, it is not included in the designation boundary. Three other parcels (2900-69-6458-000, 2900-69-4353-000, and 2900-69-8483-000) to the west and northwest do not adjoin the parcels proposed for designation or were not originally part of the Rivers holdings; they are thus excluded from the proposed boundary. 

## **IV. Historical Background** 

## _John L. Hickerson (ca. 1889-1938)_ 

Completed in 1933, the R. L. Clay House was the work of a prominent, Black stonemason and contractor, John L. Hickerson (ca. 1889-1938), a Yadkin County native who relocated to Boone about 1920. He was married to Sallie Shearer Hickerson and had no children. In October 1930, Hickerson and his wife took out a deed of trust along with two of his wife’s family members on the lot at the northwest corner of present-day Church Street and North Street, although this property originally appears to have been purchased by the other three parties in 1924, without Hickerson’s participation, suggesting that this was the Shearer residence where Hickerson lived 

4 Direct access to “Baby” is prohibited by the presence of a tall, aluminum, decorative fence around the base of the tree, and aerial GIS maps with parcel lines place the fenced area around the tree on both parcels (9070 and 0308). 5 “Local Affairs,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 1 Jun 1933: 5. 6 Josiah Clark, “’Nearly Once-in-a-Lifetime Opportunity” for Public to Watch House Burning Last Saturday,” _High Country Press,_ 1 June 2015, online, https://www.hcpress.com/front-page/boone-fire-department-burns-down-oldwhite-house-at-rivers-park-to-demonstrate-the-dangers-of-house-fires-in-a-nearly-once-in-a-lifetimeopportunity.html. 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 9 **Packet Pg. 46**
{9}------------------------------------------------
with his wife and in-laws following their marriage.[7 ] Little else has been documented about Hickerson’s private life. 

Hickerson built the R. L. Clay House for Robert Luther “R. L.” Clay (1889-1945) in 1933, and it’s likely that his work also included the stone garage on the property, given that the stonework there closely resembles the stonework found on the house.[8 ] Hickerson was considered “renowned for his masonry work throughout Boone in the 1920s and 1930s.”[9 ] A single-family dwelling built of native stone by a local, Black mason was not unusually notable in North Carolina at the time, as there were many non-White laborers engaged in the building trades throughout the state during the early twentieth century. Hickerson, however, is the only Black brick mason listed in the 1930 US Census for Watauga County, North Carolina, suggesting that he possessed a unique set of skills among his Black peers for that time period.[10 ] In particular, the local press noted Hickerson for the quality of his work and for leading his own team of laborers, indicating that he would have been in high demand by those who could afford to create such homes during the Great Depression.[11 ] In June 1934, a year after Hickerson completed the R. L. Clay House, “Mr. Ed Luttrell of Shulls Mills [was] erecting a nine-room stone dwelling…. J. L. Hickerson [was] taking care of the masonry.” Hickerson also apparently teamed with a prolific local White contractor, Wiley Gordon “W. G.” Hartzog (1885-1976), as the primary brick or stone mason on a number of local projects during the 1920s and 1930s.[12 ] Hickerson was also credited with completing the masonry work on “almost all the newer brick structures of the town,” including the First Baptist Church auditorium (WT0611, 1936), the Rivers Printing Company Building (WT0585, 1937), the second Newland Hall dormitory on the Appalachian 

7 Etta Shearer and Lola Shearer, J. L. Hickerson and Sallie Hickerson, to John E. Brown and J. M. Hodges, 30 October 1930, Deed of Trust Book 39, Page 57; and A. E. South and Mae Bell South to Ella Shearer, Lola Shearer, and Sallie Shearer, 11 March 1924, Deed Book 31, Page 486. A frame house is visible at this location in a 1950 aerial image (Pal-Bla-02-002) by Palmer Blair but no longer stands today. This image is visible at http://digitalwatauga.org/items/show/6030. 8 “Real Estate Trade Active: Many Building Projects,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 29 June 1933: 1; “Local Affairs,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 1 June 1933: 5; and “John Hickerson Dies on Sunday,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 13 October 1938: 1. 9 Plaag, et al, “Comprehensive Architectural Survey,” 50. 10 See Ancestry.com, “Watauga County, North Carolina,” _1930 United States Federal Census,_ [database online], (Provo, UT: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2002). The 1930 Census listed dozens of Black laborers in Watauga County, most described as being odd jobbers of farmers. There was also a large contingent of Black laborers from the Watauga County State Prison Farm who were apparently leased out as construction workers. None of these other individuals, however, appear to have possessed sufficient training and experience to have been labeled as a skilled mason. 

11 The most prominent White masons working in Watauga County during the 1930s were probably Earl, Clarence, and Leslie Lyons, three contractors with deep roots in Watauga County. See Eric Plaag, “Watauga County Historical Society Announces the Lyon Brothers as Next Inductees to the WCHS Hall of Fame,” Watauga County Historical - - - Society, 30 June 2022, online, https://www.wataugacountyhistoricalsociety.org/blog 1/2022/7/1/watauga county historical-society-announces-the-lyons-brothers-as-next-inductees-to-the-wchs-hall-of-fame. For an account of a laborer who worked for Hickerson, see “Leroy Kirkpatrick, Sr., 1910-1993,” _Junaluska: Oral Histories of a Black Appalachian Community_ , Edited by Susan E. Keefe, (Jefferson, NC: McFarland and Company, 2020), 68. 12 “Much Building Now Going on in County,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 14 June 1934: 1. 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 10 **Packet Pg. 47**
{10}------------------------------------------------
State Teachers College campus (masonry in 1938, completed in 1939), and the Appalachian Theatre (WT0609, 1938).[13] 

_The R. L. Clay House in an Architectural Context_ 

The R. L. Clay House was built in 1933 of native stone, a material that was not readily available in Boone until after the arrival of the Linville River Railway in October 1918.[14 ] Before the mid1930s, few private homes were constructed using native, cut stone, and the few stone buildings that did exist in Boone prior to 1933 tended to be constructed from stacked fieldstone in mortar or roughly cut fieldstone. Two such Boone buildings were the Advent Christian Church (WT0577, 1926), constructed from native graystone, and the original Linney Law Office (WT0587, 1923), featuring stacked “surface rock.”[15 ] Institutional building schemes also occasionally incorporated stone construction, such as the 1928 project to build several cottages at the Grandfather Orphans Home in Banner Elk.[16 ] Another such project just outside Watauga County was a four-story, native stone hospital built in Banner Elk in 1930 by the same people who constructed stone buildings on the Lees McRae campus in 1926.[17 ] As a residential building material, however, native stone appears to have been used somewhat rarely in single-family dwellings before the mid 1930s. Among the few early examples were a handful of summer cottages built at Blowing Rock in 1913 and Ben Smith’s bungalow built near Appalachian State Teachers College in 1927, better known as the Bushnell Cabin (WT0522). Another example was Dr. R. C. Ellis’s summer home built on Orchard Street (WT0546) in 1927 by local contractor Will Hodges. Another such home was the Howard Miller House (WT0509) on Delmar Street, presumed to have been built about 1930. None of these examples rivals the R. L. Clay House in size or architectural sophistication.[18] 

The construction of the stone residence for R. L. Clay in 1933, however, marked the beginning of a new and popular trend that continued throughout the middle and late 1930s. In the summer of 1934, for example, single-family, stone dwellings were being built in the Boone area for Professor J. A. Williams near the Appalachian State campus, R. T. Greer on Boone Trail 

> 13 “David Horton,” _Junaluska_ , 107. B. G. Teams was the contractor on the Rivers Printing Company building, suggesting that Hickerson was subcontracted to lay the brick. See Plaag, et al, “Comprehensive Architectural Survey,” 110-11; and “John Hickerson Dies on Sunday,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 13 October 1938: 1. 

- 14 For a history of the Linville River Railway, see John R. Waite, _The Blue Ridge Stemwinder,_ (Johnson City, TN: Overmountain Press, 2003). 

15 The Advent Christian Church is frequently attributed incorrectly to 1920; it was actually completed in 1926. See 

“Advent Christian Church to Open,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 19 August 1926: 1. Regarding the Linney Law Office, see “Local Affairs, Town and County,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 6 December 1923: 5. For all survey-referenced properties, see the survey files listed by number, which are held by the NC State Historic Preservation Office in Asheville, NC. 16 “Banner Elk News,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 19 July 1928: 1. 

> 17 “New Hospital at Banner Elk Is Near Completion,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 24 July 1930: 1. 

> 18 “Blowing Rock in Brief,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 1 May 1913: 2; and “The Tattler,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 7 July 1927: 5. Smith built the Bushnell Cabin using stone quarried from a mountain a short distance away on Highway 105; no mortar is visible in the stonework. Regarding the Ellis summer house, see “Local Affairs,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 4 August 1927: 4. The Ellises spent just one summer in the house after its completion, then routinely rented it out and stayed at the W. H. Gragg House on Gragg Street as boarders in subsequent summers. See “Local Affairs,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 10 July 1930: 5. Regarding the Howard Miller House, the property was actually sold by J. E. and Nannie Edmisten to Charles and Bettie Lou Wilfong in 1951 (Deed Book 70, Page 161), with no predecessor deed listed or found, long before Miller’s ownership. Its construction date has not been independently verified. 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 11 **Packet Pg. 48**
{11}------------------------------------------------
Highway (now US 421), Charles T. Zimmerman in Daniel Boone Park (224 Grand Blvd.), James E. Holshouser, Sr., (WT0544) in Daniel Boone Park, Owen Wilson on the western end of King Street, and H. L. Lyons near the Lovill House at the west end of Boone.[19 ] Of these, the Holshouser house is probably most analogous to sophistication and size to the R. L. Clay House and was built a year later. It features stone quarried from Shulls Mill; this stone is not cut to provide a flat finish, as at the R. L. Clay House, and instead features boulders that provide a distinctly different appearance. The house also includes unusual Gothic-style features.[20 ] Ernest Banner of Banner Elk is credited as the mason for this home. 

Other stone homes quickly followed during the 1930s. The W. Ralph Winkler House (WT0515) on Blowing Rock Road also features stone masonry and is attributed to Midas Wheeler as stone mason in 1936. Unfortunately, numerous additions and alterations have destroyed the architectural integrity of this property. That same year, Wheeler was also reportedly the stone mason for the construction of the W. F. Miller House on Cherry Drive (WT0539). This home is smaller than the R. L. Clay House, and additions to the house in the late twentieth century have adversely impacted the integrity of the property. In 1937, Guy Hunt reportedly had his home built on Orchard Street (WT0547), with the masonry conjecturally attributed by the surveyor to the Lyons brothers. The Hunt house compares favorably with the R. L. Clay House but appears to postdate its construction. About 1938, yet another stone home with a rock garage was completed nearby for Herman W. Wilcox on present-day Wallace Circle (WT0548). Unfortunately, several late twentieth-century additions have marred the integrity of this property. 

The popularity of stone construction in domestic architecture aligns with the introduction of the Works Progress Administration programs of the mid-1930s, which were designed to ease the effects of the Great Depression. In Boone and Watauga County, four schools of stone construction were completed using WPA funding in 1937 alone, and at least six other stone buildings were completed for the local community, county government, and the Appalachian State Teachers College in Boone in 1938 and 1939.[21 ] Stone buildings were perceived as especially desirable during this period because they were “not only durable but absolutely fireproof.”[22 ] Institutional buildings, such as the United States Post Office in downtown Boone (WT0049, 1939), the Courthouse Annex building on North Water Street (WT0607, 1939), various school buildings throughout Watauga County, and about a dozen single-family, faculty homes constructed at Appalachian State Teachers College (WT0529, ca. 1938-1940), less than a mile east of the R. L. Clay House, were of stone construction, indicating a ready supply and relatively easy access to the material in large quantities in the later 1930s after government programs allowed for massive mining of stone for buildings.[23 ] All of those faculty homes were moved or destroyed as the Appalachian State University rapidly expanded after 1967, decreasing 

> 19 “Much Building Now Going on in County,” _Watauga Democrat,_ 14 June 1934: 1; and “Work on Dwelling to Start,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 9 August 1934: 8. Midas Wheeler was the stone mason on the Zimmerman property. 20 On construction of the Holshouser residence, see “Much Building Now Going on in County,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 14 June 1934: 1, 4. 

> 21 “Ellerbe Lauds School Projects,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 22 October 1936: 1; and “26,000 Allotted to Local College,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 24 February 1938: 1. 

> 22 “Lees-McRae Institute Opening at Banner Elk,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 16 September 1926: 1. 

> 23 “Faculty Homes are Completed,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 20 October 1938: 8. The homes were completed in stages from 1938 to 1940. 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 12 **Packet Pg. 49**
{12}------------------------------------------------
or otherwise destroying their architectural integrity as significance representations of stone, domestic architecture at Boone during the Depression era. 

Local lore has spread the belief that many of these stone buildings constructed from the early 1930s to 1940 were made using the stone moved to create the nearby Blue Ridge Parkway. Construction on the Parkway began in 1938, years after the construction of many of these buildings. Furthermore, the portion of the Blue Ridge Parkway nearby to Boone did not begin construction until after World War II and was not completed until the mid-1980s. Nevertheless, the mistaken belief that these stone homes were built using stone quarried from the construction of the historic scenic route persists. 

The 2021 Downtown Boone Historic Resources Survey listed several native stone buildings, all of which were commercial buildings except for the R. L. Clay House. The Cook-Nichols Motor Company Building (WT0603), which eventually burned in 1996, and the Duncan Motor Company Building (WT0887) were both completed in 1940.[24 ] The Boone Bus Station (WT0612) was also a W. G. Hartzog project, but its native stone façade was completed in 1946. Following demolition of the entire building in 2011 after its acquisition by Appalachian State University, ASU officials promised to “rebuild” the façade as a curtain wall, allegedly using the original stones in a pattern that mimicked the original design and door and window openings. Close analysis, however, supports recent contentions that there is considerable doubt that the extant stones are the original stonework that comprised the façade of the original bus station.[25 ] Beyond these later examples of stone construction in Boone, native stone can also be seen in various appurtenant structures and landscape objects around downtown Boone, mostly in retaining walls, sheds, and steps that lead to house sites, many of which no longer stand. 

_Additional Historic Context, R. L. Clay (1889-1945)_ 

Robert Luther “R. L.” Clay, for whom the R. L. Clay House was originally built in 1933, was a native of Avery County, having moved to Watauga County after the Linville River Railway was built in the late 1910s.[26 ] He worked at the Shulls Mill station as an agent until he moved to Boone in the 1920s, where he remained working with the railway. The Clays did have a home in Boone before the native stone house was built, as there are reports of Mrs. Clay entertaining the Friday Afternoon Club in her home in May of 1931.[27 ] This original home was a simple, woodframe farmhouse that was a commonplace type of residential construction in the early twentieth century in Boone. The first home was moved from the present R. L. Clay House site a short distance to the southeast in order to make space for the native stone building, possibly as part of an agreement between the Clays and Poly C. Wyke, who owned those lots. After a default by the Wykes, the former Clay house and the land surrounding its location were sold to Esther Boone, who was R. L. Clay’s sister-in-law, in 1940.[28 ] Boone remained in that home for more than four 

> 24 Plaag, et al, “Comprehensive Architectural Survey,” 165, 329. 

> 25 Plaag, et al, “Comprehensive Architectural Survey,” 190-92. 

> 26 “Brief Illness Proves Fatal to R. Luther Clay,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 29 March 1945: 1. 

> 27 “Friday Afternoon Club with Mrs. R. L. Clay,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 21 May 1931: 5. 

> 28 Watauga Building and Loan Association to Esther Boone, 27 July 1940, Deed Book 52, Page 518. 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 13 **Packet Pg. 50**
{13}------------------------------------------------
decades. The original Clay home was, unfortunately, destroyed by the Town of Boone in a fire exercise in 2015.[29] 

In 1933, Clay, his wife Annie Stansbury Clay, and his daughters moved to Greensboro so Clay could work with the Internal Revenue Department, now known as the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). As this move happened, the stone house was being completed by a local Black brick mason and contractor, John L. Hickerson (ca. 1889-1938).[30 ] It is likely that Clay also had the separate, two-car garage built at about the same time to the southeast of the home, given that the stonework closely resembles that found on the house.[31 ] Rather than residing full-time in the new home at Boone, the Clays maintained the house as a summer and weekend residence for the family. Mrs. Clay would entertain in the home regularly while she and her daughters were in town, based on multiple _Watauga Democrat_ articles regarding the Friday Afternoon Club during the 1930s and 1940s.[32 ] In 1943, Clay was promoted to the Field Division Chief in the Greensboro office of the IRS. When Clay was in residence in Boone, he was an active Free Mason and Shriner. He was a member of the Boone Methodist Church, where he served as the Sunday school superintendent for two years and as steward for many more. While in Greensboro, Clay was a member of the West Market Street Methodist Church.[33] 

The promotion in 1943 appears to have influenced the Clay family’s decision to abandon the house at Boone. In December 1944, Clay and his wife sold the house property and some of the surrounding land to Robert Campbell “R. C.” Rivers, Jr. (1899-1975), and his wife Bonnie Jean Lewis Rivers (1910-1991).[34 ] Shortly thereafter, Clay died from complications following an operation to remove his appendix in 1945. He was survived by his wife and five daughters.[35] 

_The R. L. Clay House in the Context of the R. C. Rivers, Jr., Family_ 

Robert Campbell Rivers, Sr. (1861-1933), was born in Tennessee and moved to Boone at some point before 1888, marrying Sarah Locke “Sallie” Jurney (1861-1924) in 1892. They had three children, R. C., Jr., being the eldest surviving son. In 1889, Rivers, Sr., purchased the _Watauga Democrat_ , the local paper that had flopped after its first fall edition in 1888, from Joseph Spainhour and John S. Williams. Rivers initially had a noteworthy partner in this purchase— Daniel B. Dougherty—but Rivers bought out his partner later that year. Rivers continued to print the paper as the mouthpiece of the local Democratic Party and run the printing business until his death in 1933.[36 ] Following his death, the business passed to R. C. Rivers, Jr., via inheritance. R. 

> 29 “Local Affairs,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 1 June 1933: 5; Plaag, et al, “Comprehensive Architectural Survey,” 97; and Clark, “Nearly.” 

> 30 “Brief Illness Proves Fatal to R. Luther Clay,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 29 March 1945: 1; and Plaag, et al, “Comprehensive Architectural Survey,” 50. 31 The garage is visible in a 1940 aerial image taken for the Department of Agriculture. This image is not yet published and available online but is held as part of the Watauga County Agricultural Extension Aerial Images Collection, Digital Watauga Project. 

> 32 For one example, see “Alice Stansbury Taylor Circle Holds Meeting,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 4 July 1935: 5. 

> 33 “Brief Illness Proves Fatal to R. Luther Clay,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 29 March 1945: 1. 34 R. L. Clay and Annie S. Clay to R. C. Rivers and Bonnie Jean Rivers, 22 December 1944, Deed Book 58, Page 308. 

> 35 “Brief Illness Proves Fatal to R. Luther Clay,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 29 March 1945: 1. 

> 36 “History of the Watauga Democrat,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 3 January 2012, updated 11 August 2014, online, https://www.wataugademocrat.com/aboutus/history-of-the-watauga-democrat/article. 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 14 **Packet Pg. 51**
{14}------------------------------------------------
C. Rivers, Jr., was responsible for the growth of the _Watauga Democrat_ during the middle twentieth century, and he acquired both the _Blowing Rocket_ and the _Avery Journal_ during his tenure as editor and publisher, significantly expanding the influence of the Rivers Printing Company, Inc. Rivers, Jr., was also a member of the Board of Directors of Northwestern Bank of Boone, Vice President of the Watauga Savings and Loan, a member of the Board of Directors of the North Carolina Press Association, and director of the Journalism Foundation at UNC Chapel Hill. He was also a very influential political operative, serving as a delegate to the 1944, 1952, 1956, and 1960 National Democratic Conventions. Politically, he is probably best known as one of the “Dirty Dozen” who stood for the Democratic Party nomination of John F. Kennedy. Rivers’ comments on the assassination of John F. Kennedy were published in the _Watauga Democrat_ and entered into the _Congressional Record_ by Senator Sam Ervin.[37] 

Rivers, Jr., and his wife Bonnie Jean Rivers had four children in total: Lucinda Jane Rivers (1935-2017), two children born between 1939 and 1940 who were unnamed and did not survive infancy, and Rachel Ann Rivers (1943-1999). Having lived in the apartment above the brick Rivers Printing Company shop located at what is today 747 West King Street since its construction in 1937, the Rivers family realized in 1945 that they could relocate to the R. L. Clay House just down the street and still be close to the business.[38 ] Following their purchase of the Clay House, the Riverses also purchased surrounding land that significantly increased their holdings. In 1968, Rivers then used the Rivers Printing Company to purchase additional lands to the northwest and west of the property, presumably as a buffer to their existing property, since he immediately flipped the land to himself. Then, in 1984, Bonnie Jean Rivers secured the Esther Boone lands that lay to the southeast of the house.[39 ] Bonnie Jean Rivers continued to live in the R. L. Clay House following the death of her husband in 1975, and it is believed that she stayed live there until her death in 1991.[40] 

From an early age, both Jane and Rachel Rivers showed a keen interest in journalism, but it was Rachel’s interest that survived into adulthood. Born at the Hagaman Clinic on King Street in downtown Boone in 1943, Rachel—initially named Bobbie Jean Rivers—was an accomplished equestrian from a young age. She was frequently seen riding her pony Patsy along King Street, typically feeding the parking meter in front of the Rivers Printing Company building or elsewhere along her journeys after tying up Patsy to the meter. She began writing for the _Watauga Democrat_ at the age of eleven and completed her high school education at Appalachian 

> 37 “Publisher R. C. Rivers, Jr., Dies; End Brought to Unique Career,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 24 April 1975; and 

“Watauga Newspaperman Is Dead,” _Winston-Salem Journal_ , 24 April 1975: 21. 

> 38 “Hands Across the State,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 21 July 1938: 4. 

39 See R. L. Clay, et al, to R. C. Rivers and Bonnie Jean Rivers, 1 January 1945, Deed Book 59, Page 214; Lala Clay Rolfe and Shelley R. Rolfe to R. C. Rivers and Bonnie Jean Rivers, 21 February 1945, Deed Book 58, Page 406; Luther Moretz and Maggie Moretz to R. C. Rivers, Jr., and Bonnie Jean Rivers, 20 August 1945, Deed Book 60, Page 127; P. 

W. Moretz and Alice Moretz to R. C. Rivers and Bonnie Jean Rivers, 1 May 1947, Deed Book 63, Page 334; P. W. Moretz to R. C. Rivers and Bonnie Jean Rivers, 28 April 1948, Deed Book 67, Page 41; Joe Williams and Laura Ruth Williams to Rivers Printing Company, Inc., 14 April 1962, Deed Book 89, Page 437; Joe Williams and Laura Ruth Williams to Rivers Printing Company, Inc., 5 August 1968; Deed Book 103, Page 419; Rivers Printing Company, Inc., to R. C. Rivers, Jr., 26 November 1968, Deed Book 110, Page 17; Esther S. Boone to Eddie A. Caudill, 10 April 1984, Deed Book 246, Page 724; and Eddie A. Caudill and Shirley N. Caudill to Jean L. Rivers, 27 April 1984, Deed Book 246, Page 727. 

> 40 “Publisher R. C. Rivers, Jr., Dies; End Brought to Unique Career,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 24 April 1975. 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 15 **Packet Pg. 52**
{15}------------------------------------------------
High School—now Chapell-Wilson Hall (WT0564)—before earning a journalism degree at the University of Missouri. Rachel returned to work for the _Watauga Democrat_ full-time in 1965, serving as both a writer and a photographer. Shortly thereafter, she married Paul Armfield Coffey (1934-2007), whom she probably knew from growing up in Boone, but with whom she also worked at the _Democrat_ , where Coffey served as a journalist and photographer. Rachel reportedly worked an average of 70 hours per week during this period, by which time the operations of the Rivers Printing Company included two other newspapers, the _Blowing Rocket_ and the _Avery Journal._ She also published two novels in the 1970s: _A Horse Like Mr. Ragman_ (1977) and _The City Man_ (1978).[41] 

Following the death of R. C. Rivers, Jr., in 1975, Rachel and Armfield inherited the _Watauga Democrat_ , the Rivers Publishing Company, and the other papers under its banner. They continued to run the company for the next two decades, eventually selling it to the owners of the _Bristol Herald-Courier_ in 1994. Rachel also served as president of the North Carolina Press Association in 1994 and 1995. Today, the various papers and other media operations are owned by Jones Media, who acquired those concerns in 2002, and the _Watauga Democrat_ remains the oldest continually operating business in Watauga County.[42 ] Outside of her journalistic and writing pursuits, Rachel was also an influential and active participant in numerous cultural programs and initiatives in Boone and Watauga County. She helped found the Doc and Merle Watson Mountain Folk Art Museum in Cove Creek and the first Firefly Festival in Boone, served on the Watauga County Hospital Board and its Foundation Board, helped found the Watauga Humane Society, and was a prominent leader in her service with the boards of Historic Boone and the Watauga County Community Foundation. One of her most lasting contributions was her vigilant and persistent efforts to preserve the historically Black and White sections of the Boone Cemetery (WT0055). She and her husband also sponsored a professorship in creative writing at Appalachian State University shortly before her untimely death in 1999. 

Following the death of her mother, Rachel Rivers-Coffey acquired most of the Rivers family land and held it for only a few years until she and her husband began conveying it to the Town of Boone in October 1998, along with the adjacent Esther Boone lands (not part of the designation boundary) acquired by Bonnie Jean Rivers in 1984 and bequeathed to Armfield Coffey in 1993.[43 ] As a condition of conveying these lands to the Town of Boone, Rachel and Armfield 

41 Eric Plaag, “Watauga County Historical Society Announces Rachel Rivers-Coffey as Next Inductee to the WCHS Hall of Fame,” 23 July 2022, Watauga County Historical Society, online, https://www.wataugacountyhistoricalsociety.org/blog-1/2022/7/23/watauga-county-historical-societyannounces-rachel-rivers-coffey-as-next-inductee-to-the-wchs-hall-of-fame. See also “Publisher R. C. Rivers, Jr., Dies; End Brought to Unique Career,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 24 April 1975. 42 “History of the Watauga Democrat,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 3 January 2012, updated 11 August 2014, online, https://www.wataugademocrat.com/aboutus/history-of-the-watauga-democrat/article ; and Brad Hodges, “Former Newspaper Publisher Dies after Falling from Horse: Rachel Rivers-Coffey Was Long-Time County Civic Leader,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 25 August 1999. 43 Executrix’s Deed in Distribution, Rachel A. Rivers-Coffey to Rachel A. Rivers-Coffey and Jane Rivers Krida, 23 December 1993, Book of Records 272, Page 585; and Executrix’s Deed in Distribution, Rachel A. Rivers-Coffey to Rachel A. Rivers-Coffey, 23 December 1993, Book of Record 272, Page 579. Rachel and Armfield briefly surrendered their interest in part of the land to Jane in 1993—see Rachel A. Rivers-Coffey and Paul Armfield Coffey to Janes Rivers Krida, 31 December 1993, Book of Record 273, Page 244. Jane then transferred the land to a trust in her name before selling (or donating) it to the Appalachian State University Foundation in 1997. ASU returned 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 16 **Packet Pg. 53**
{16}------------------------------------------------
included a life estate to Rachel Rivers-Coffey and to Jim Butler, a family friend, during their lifetimes, as well as restrictions to the property and its future use by the Town of Boone. These restrictions read, “The Grantee may use said property only for the following purposes:… 1. Recreational purposes. 2. Green space 3. The Installation of utility lines; provided however, that all lines must be installed underground, and in such a way as to cause a minimum disturbance to the natural environment. 4. Flood mitigation. 5. A wildlife sanctuary. 6. Historical Purposes.”[44 ] Jim Butler, who resided in the home at the time of its donation to the Town, passed away in 2011, leaving the home empty as it sits today.[45] 

The R. L. Clay House is probably the best surviving resource with the highest degree of integrity in Watauga County associated with the Rivers family. The original Rivers “Old Home Place,” located at the southeast corner of King Street and Water Street in downtown Boone, was demolished in 1959.[46 ] The Rivers Printing Company Building (WT0585) does still stand and was the workplace for R. C. Rivers, Jr., and Rachel Rivers-Coffey for several decades. Nevertheless, changes to the original windows (now metal, with different sash and light details) and dramatic changes to both the rear elevation and the interior of the building (where no signs of the original printing operations survive) have reduced the overall integrity of the Rivers Printing Company Building in comparison to the high level of integrity of the R. L. Clay House. 

## _Historical Significance_ 

The R. L. Clay House possesses special significance at the local level for its association with members of the Rivers family, specifically Robert Campbell “R. C.” Rivers, Jr., and Rachel Rivers-Coffey, who were prominent figures in the publishing industry in Boone throughout the twentieth century. As consecutive editors and publishers of the _Watauga Democrat,_ Boone’s 

the land to Rachel in 1999. For this convoluted deed history, see Jane Rivers to Jane Rivers, Trustee of the Jane Rivers Living Trust Agreement, 13 December 1995, Book of Record 354, Page 410; Jane Rivers, Trustee of the Jane Rivers Living Trust Agreement to Appalachian State University Foundation, Inc., 17 December 1997, Book of Record 438, Page 124; and Appalachian State University Foundation, Inc., to Rachel Rivers-Coffey, 25 February 1999, Book of Record 507, Page 170. For the transfer of the house and garage parcel, as well as the parcel containing Rachel’s Meadow, to the Town of Boone, see Rachel Rivers-Coffey and Armfield Coffey to Town of Boone, 28 October 1998, Book of Record 480, Page 494; and Rachel Rivers-Coffey and Armfield Coffey to Town of Boone, 28 October 1998, Book of Record 480, Page 496. For the parcel fronting on Poplar Grove Road, which Armfield conveyed to the Town after Rachel’s death, see Armfield Coffey, personally and as Executor of the Estate of Rachel-Rivers Coffey, to the Town of Boone, 26 January 2000, Book of Record 553, Page 297. Armfield also acquired the old Esther Boone lands to the southeast of the house, which are not part of the designation boundary, in 1993, and he later donated these lands to the Town of Boone in 2004. See Rachel A. Rivers-Coffey, Executrix under the Last Will and Testament of Bonnie Jean L. Rivers, to Paul Armfield Coffey, 23 December 1993, Book of Record 272, Page 591; and Paul Armfield Coffey to Town of Boone, 12 March 2004, Book of Record 980, Page 689. 

44 Rachel Rivers-Coffey and Armfield Coffey to Town of Boone, 28 October 1998, Book of Record 480, Page 494. Similar language appears in the Esther Boone property conveyance to the Town, with the exception that the old Boone house could be torn down, and the lot could be used for “free, unmetered parking for park users.” See Paul Armfield Coffey to Town of Boone, 12 March 2004, Book of Record 980, Page 689. 45 Anna Oakes, “Boone to Consider Uses for Property Near Rivers Street,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 12 March 2012, online, https://www.wataugademocrat.com/news/boone-to-consider-uses-for-property-near-riversstreet/article_ca471d55-6394-58b2-8a82-d68129b847bb.html. This article includes an image showing the proximity of the Boone house to the property proposed for designation. 46 Rob Rivers, “King Street,” _Watauga Democrat_ , 5 November 1959: 4. 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 17 **Packet Pg. 54**
{17}------------------------------------------------
primary local newspaper since 1888, and owners of the Rivers Publishing Company for 61 years from 1933 to 1994, they dominated and controlled Boone’s most significant news media outlet for generations. R. C. Rivers, Jr., was responsible for the growth of the Rivers Printing Company outside of Boone, with the acquisition of both the _Blowing Rocket_ and the _Avery Journal_ during his publishing tenure, and he transformed the _Watauga Democrat_ from an eight-page weekly publication to one that averaged 40 pages twice per week at the time of his death. His principal residence from 1945 to 1975 was the R. L. Clay House. Following his death in 1975, his daughter Rachel—who was raised in the R. L. Clay House—took over at the _Watauga Democrat_ as editor and publisher and continued to own and operate the Rivers Printing Company with her husband Armfield Coffey until 1994. Their donation of the house parcel and several parcels of surrounding land in 1998 and just after Rachel’s death was critically important to the property’s long-term, ongoing preservation. 

Built in 1933, the R. L. Clay House also possesses special significance in architecture at the local level as an unusually early, domestic example of architecturally sophisticated, native stone construction in Boone. This masonry work was completed by John L. Hickerson (ca. 18891938), a prominent Black mason and contractor in Boone and Watauga County from about 1920 until his death in 1938. He remains the only documented Black mason in Watauga County working during that period. The R. L. Clay House and its nearby garage remain intact and largely unchanged since their construction in 1933. The integrity and sophistication of the masonry work are exemplary when compared to other stone structures from the period of significance in downtown Boone. While not part of this proposed designation, even the interior floor plan of the R. L. Clay House appears to be largely unchanged from its original design. 

## **V. Supporting Documentation** 

Appendix A: Digital Photography 

Appendix B: Site Plan, Boundary Map, and Tax Map 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 18 **Packet Pg. 55**
{18}------------------------------------------------
## Works Cited 

Ancestry.com. “Watauga County, North Carolina.” _1930 United States Federal Census._ [Database online.] Provo, UT: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2002. _High Country Press._ Keefe, Susan E., editor. _Junaluska: Oral Histories of a Black Appalachian Community_ . Jefferson, NC: McFarland and Company, 2020. North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office. Palmer Blair Collection. Digital Watauga Project. Plaag, Eric W. “Watauga County Historical Society Announces Rachel Rivers-Coffey as Next Inductee to the WCHS Hall of Fame.” Watauga County Historical Society: 23 July 2022. Online. https://www.wataugacountyhistoricalsociety.org/blog-1/2022/7/23/wataugacounty-historical-society-announces-rachel-rivers-coffey-as-next-inductee-to-the-wchshall-of-fame. -----. “Watauga County Historical Society Announces the Lyon Brothers as Next Inductees to the WCHS Hall of Fame.” Watauga County Historical Society: 30 June 2022. Online. https://www.wataugacountyhistoricalsociety.org/blog-1/2022/7/1/wataugacounty-historical-society-announces-the-lyons-brothers-as-next-inductees-to-the-wchshall-of-fame. Plaag, Eric W., et al. “Comprehensive Architectural Survey of Downtown Boone, North Carolina.” Boone, NC: February 2021. Online. http://www.townofboone.net/DocumentCenter/View/1334/Comprehensive-ArchitecturalSurvey-of-Downtown-Boone-North-Carolina-2021. Waite, John R. _The Blue Ridge Stemwinder._ Johnson City, TN: Overmountain Press, 2003. Watauga County Agricultural Extension Aerial Images Collection, Digital Watauga Project. Watauga County Register of Deeds. _Watauga Democrat. Winston-Salem Journal._ 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 19 **Packet Pg. 56**
{19}------------------------------------------------
## **Appendix A: Digital Photography** 

All photographs were taken by Eric Plaag on July 25, 2023. 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 20 **Packet Pg. 57**
{20}------------------------------------------------
NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0001.JPG Clay House Drive, looking northwest 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0003.JPG Moretz Drive, looking north toward Rivers Park 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0002.JPG Moretz Drive, looking west toward Boone house site 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0004.JPG R. L. Clay House, looking west from Clay House Drive 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 21 **Packet Pg. 58**
{21}------------------------------------------------
NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0005.JPG 

R. L. Clay House and Garage, looking southwest from Clay House Drive 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0007.JPG 

R. L. Clay House and Garage, looking south 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0006.JPG 

R. L. Clay House, looking west 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0008.JPG R. L. Clay House entrance detail, looking southwest 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 22 **Packet Pg. 59**
{22}------------------------------------------------
NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0009.JPG 

R. L. Clay House entrance detail, looking south 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0011.JPG R. L. Clay House, looking south 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0010.JPG R. L. Clay House entrance detail, looking southwest 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0012.JPG R. L. Clay House, looking south 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 23 **Packet Pg. 60**
{23}------------------------------------------------
NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0013.JPG R. L. Clay House, looking southeast 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0015.JPG R. L. Clay House, looking east 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0014.JPG R. L. Clay House, looking east 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0016.JPG R. L. Clay House, looking east 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 24 **Packet Pg. 61**
{24}------------------------------------------------
NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0017.JPG R. L. Clay House, looking northeast 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0019.JPG 

R. L. Clay House, looking northeast 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0018.JPG R. L. Clay House, looking north 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0020.JPG R. L. Clay House, looking north 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 25 **Packet Pg. 62**
{25}------------------------------------------------
© 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0021.JPG 

R. L. Clay House, looking north 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0023.JPG R. L. Clay House, looking northwest 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0022.JPG R. L. Clay House, looking northwest 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0024.JPG R. L. Clay House, looking northwest 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 26 **Packet Pg. 63**
{26}------------------------------------------------
NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0025.JPG 

R. L. Clay House, east porch detail, looking northwest 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0027.JPG 

R. L. Clay House, east porch walkway with Clay House Drive, looking southeast 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0026.JPG R. L. Clay House, east porch detail, looking northwest 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0028.JPG R. L. Clay House, looking southwest 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 27 **Packet Pg. 64**
{27}------------------------------------------------
## NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0029.JPG 

R. L. Clay House Garage, looking southwest 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0031.JPG 

R. L. Clay House Garage, looking southeast 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0030.JPG R. L. Clay House Garage, looking south 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0032.JPG 

R. L. Clay House Garage, looking east 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 28 **Packet Pg. 65**
{28}------------------------------------------------
## NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0033.JPG 

R. L. Clay House Garage, looking northeast 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0035.JPG 

R. L. Clay House Garage, looking west 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0034.JPG R. L. Clay House Garage, looking north 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0036.JPG 

- "Rachel's Meadow," looking northwest 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 29 **Packet Pg. 66**
{29}------------------------------------------------
NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0037.JPG "Rachel's Meadow," looking west 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0039.JPG "Baby" with perimeter fence, looking southeast 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0038.JPG "Baby" with perimeter fence, looking northwest 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0040.JPG "Baby" interpretive signage, looking southeast 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 30 **Packet Pg. 67**
{30}------------------------------------------------
NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0041.JPG 

Southwest side of "Baby" perimeter fence, looking southeast toward house site (not visible) 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0043.JPG Daniel Boone Monument at Rivers Park, looking west 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0042.JPG Daniel Boone Monument at Rivers Park, looking northwest 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0044.JPG Northeast side of Rivers Park, looking northwest 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 31 **Packet Pg. 68**
{31}------------------------------------------------
NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0045.JPG Daniel Boone Monument at Rivers Park, looking southeast 

NC_WataugaCounty_RLClayHouse_0046.JPG Daniel Boone Monument at Rivers Park, looking east 

R. L. Clay House Local Landmark Designation Report 

Page 32 **Packet Pg. 69**
{32}------------------------------------------------
**Packet Pg. 70**
{33}------------------------------------------------
**Packet Pg. 71**
{34}------------------------------------------------
**PARID: 2900699070000 BOONE TOWN OF,** 

## **Parcel** 

ParID Tax Year SITUS Addess City, State, Zip Unit # Unit Description NBHD Class Land Use Code Living Units CAMA Acres Zoning Map # 

**==> picture [270 x 181] intentionally omitted <==**

## **Jan 1 Values** 

|Land Value.<br>Building Value<br>==================<br>Appraisal Total<br>Exemptions or Exclusions<br>Land Deferred Value<br>Taxable Total<br>**Owner Mailing**<br>Tax Year<br>Sequence Number<br>Owner Number<br>Owner<br>Mailing Address<br>City, State, Zip<br>**Legal Description**<br>Township<br>City Code<br>Jurisdiction (Tax Code District)<br>Unit Desc<br>Unit #<br>Book<br>Page<br>Legal Desc 1<br>Deeded Acres|821,100<br>0<br>========<br>821,100<br>821,100<br>========<br>0<br>2023<br>0<br>1161496<br>BOONE TOWN OF<br>567 W KING ST<br>BOONE NC 28607<br>05 - BOONE<br>MS1 - MUNICIPAL SERVICE DIST<br>480<br>496<br>RIVERS HOME<br>8.15|
|---|---|



**Packet Pg. 72**
{35}------------------------------------------------
||||||**Grantee**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|||||||
|||||||
|**Sale Date**|**Book**|**Page**|**Sale Price**|**Grantor**|**Grantee**|
|29-OCT-98|480|496|0|||
|||||||
|||||||



**Packet Pg. 73**
{36}------------------------------------------------
## Watauga County Auditor 

December 1, 2023 

**R. L. Clay House (WT0530), Boone, Watauga County, North Carolina Tax Map for Parcel 2900-69-9070-000** 

1:4,442 

0 0.04 0.07 0.15 mi ~~#1 > 1 tt oH~~ 0 0.05 0.1 0.2 km 

Watauga County Auditor **Packet Pg. 74**
{37}------------------------------------------------
**PARID: 2900783934000 BOONE TOWN OF,** 

**150 CLAY HOUSE DR** 

## **Parcel** 

ParID Tax Year SITUS Addess City, State, Zip Unit # Unit Description NBHD Class Land Use Code Living Units CAMA Acres Zoning Map # 

**==> picture [270 x 181] intentionally omitted <==**

## **Jan 1 Values** 

|Land Value.<br>Building Value<br>==================<br>Appraisal Total<br>Exemptions or Exclusions<br>Land Deferred Value<br>Taxable Total<br>**Owner Mailing**<br>Tax Year<br>Sequence Number<br>Owner Number<br>Owner<br>Mailing Address<br>City, State, Zip<br>**Legal Description**<br>Township<br>City Code<br>Jurisdiction (Tax Code District)<br>Unit Desc<br>Unit #<br>Book<br>Page<br>Legal Desc 1<br>Deeded Acres|55,300<br>626,900<br>========<br>682,200<br>682,200<br>========<br>0<br>2023<br>0<br>1161496<br>BOONE TOWN OF<br>567 W KING ST<br>BOONE NC 28607<br>05 - BOONE<br>MS1 - MUNICIPAL SERVICE DIST<br>RIVERS HOME<br>0.26|
|---|---|



**Packet Pg. 75**
{38}------------------------------------------------
||||||**Grantee**<br>JIM BUTLER LIFE<br>ESTATE|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|||||||
|||||||
|**Sale Date**|**Book **|**Page **|**Sale**<br>**Price**|**Grantor**|**Grantee**|
|29-OCT-98|480|494|0|COFFEY, RACHEL RIVERS AND<br>ARMFIELD||
|||||||
|||||||



**Packet Pg. 76**
{39}------------------------------------------------
## Watauga County Auditor 

December 1, 2023 

**R. L. Clay House (WT0530), Boone, Watauga County, North Carolina Tax Map for Parcel 2900-78-3934-000** 

1:1,026 

0 0.01 0.01 0.03 mi ~~K+ —_,—_,—_ +, +,_~~ 0 0.01 0.03 0.05 km 

Watauga County Auditor **Packet Pg. 77**
{40}------------------------------------------------
**PARID: 2900790308000 BOONE TOWN OF,** 

## **Parcel** 

ParID Tax Year SITUS Addess City, State, Zip Unit # Unit Description NBHD Class Land Use Code Living Units CAMA Acres Zoning Map # 

**==> picture [270 x 181] intentionally omitted <==**

## **Jan 1 Values** 

|Land Value.<br>Building Value<br>==================<br>Appraisal Total<br>Exemptions or Exclusions<br>Land Deferred Value<br>Taxable Total|108,600<br>0<br>========<br>108,600<br>108,600<br>========<br>0|
|---|---|



## **Owner Mailing** 

|Tax Year<br>Sequence Number<br>Owner Number<br>Owner<br>Mailing Address<br>City, State, Zip<br>**Legal Description**<br>Township<br>City Code<br>Jurisdiction (Tax Code District)<br>Unit Desc<br>Unit #<br>Book<br>Page<br>Legal Desc 1<br>Deeded Acres|2023<br>0<br>1161496<br>BOONE TOWN OF<br>567 W KING ST<br>BOONE NC 28607<br>05 - BOONE<br>C02 - BOONE<br>553<br>297<br>LOTS 167-173\R F GREENE SUB<br>1.13|
|---|---|



**Packet Pg. 78**
{41}------------------------------------------------
||||||**Grantee**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|||||||
|||||||
|**Sale Date**|**Book**|**Page**|**Sale Price**|**Grantor**|**Grantee**|
|26-JAN-00|553|297|0|||
|||||||
|||||||



**Packet Pg. 79**
{42}------------------------------------------------
## Watauga County Auditor 

December 1, 2023 

**R. L. Clay House (WT0530), Boone, Watauga County, North Carolina Tax Map for Parcel 2900-79-0308-000** 

1:2,123 0 0.02 0.04 0.07 mi 0 0.03 0.06 0.11 km 

Watauga County Auditor **Packet Pg. 80**
{43}------------------------------------------------
WT0530 R. L. Clay House 150 Clay House Dr. Boone, Watauga County, NC 

**Packet Pg. 81**
{44}------------------------------------------------
WT0530 R. L. Clay House 150 Clay House Dr. Boone, Watauga County, NC 

**Packet Pg. 82**
{45}------------------------------------------------
WT0530 R. L. Clay House 150 Clay House Dr. Boone, Watauga County, NC 

**Packet Pg. 83**
