{0}------------------------------------------------
Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OAR-2025-0068 Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OAR-2003-0119 May 4, 2026 Page 5 of 10 

and accessible by agencies and regulated entities. Though we do have some concerns and suggested revisions that are discussed further in our comments, the DAQ generally supports the EPA’s proposal. 

#### **II. Comments on EPA’s Proposal** 

This section provides the DAQ’s comments on the EPA’s proposed actions, including comments related to specific topics on which the EPA has solicited comment (with the identifying comment number as listed in the preamble), and comments on additional aspects of the EPA’s proposed rulemaking. 

##### **A. Disaster Debris Cleanup and Management (Comments Emergency-1, Emergency-2, and Emergency-3)** 

As described in Section I.B of this letter, Hurricane Helene caused widespread destruction in Western North Carolina and resulted in an unprecedented magnitude of disaster debris, which increases the risk of wildfires and post-fire erosion that can degrade water quality. On December 13, 2024, North Carolina's former Governor Cooper and the Office of State Budget and Management (OSBM) released a Revised Damage and Needs Assessment on North Carolina’s recovery from Hurricane Helene,<sup>4</sup> which estimated that the storm resulted in approximately 6.8 million tons of vegetative debris. On March 19, 2025, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s (NOAA) National Hurricane Center issued a report on Hurricane Helene, stating, “The North Carolina Forest Service estimated 822,000 acres of damaged timberland, which resulted in $214 million in damages to North Carolina forests.<sup>16</sup> ” As the state and local governments of North Carolina were faced with the enormous task of managing this debris, the DAQ collaborated with state and federal partners to coordinate debris cleanup, including issuance of guidance on debris removal for contractors, local governments, and nonprofits. By December 13, 2024, the State had organized 108 active Temporary Debris Storage and Reduction Sites across 20 counties, and 10,445,000 cubic yards of debris had been cleared from 27 counties. 

As also described in Section I.B of this letter, state and local governments made many efforts to minimize the health impacts of debris cleanup following Hurricane Helene,  The NCDEQ issued extensive guidance on debris removal, collection, and burning, and offered technical assistance.<sup>17</sup> Landowners, contractors, and municipalities were encouraged to grind vegetative debris into wood chips when possible. The State also created the North Carolina State Mission Assigned Recovery Task (SMART) Program to assist counties in removing disaster debris after a federally declared disaster.<sup>18</sup> The SMART Program allows property owners in participating counties to request free debris removal services. 

If burning was the only viable option, the DAQ advocated for using ACIs to remove vegetative debris and limiting the use of open burning. When operated properly, ACIs emit less smoke and harmful pollution than open burning, making these units an essential component of North 

> 16 NOAA, National Hurricane Center Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Helene, March 19, 2025. 

> <u>https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/data/tcr/AL092024_Helene.pdf</u> 

> 17 NCDEQ, Environmental Guidance for Helene-Impacted Areas, Accessed April 14, 2026. <u>https://www.deq.nc.gov/news/key-issues/storm-season/hurricane-helene-response/environmental-guidance-heleneimpacted-areas#DebrisRemovalCollectionBurning-17021</u> 

> 18 North Carolina SMART Program, Disaster Debris Removal Assistance For Your Community, Accessed April 15, 2026. https://ncdebriscleanup.com/
{1}------------------------------------------------
Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OAR-2025-0068 Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OAR-2003-0119 May 4, 2026 Page 6 of 10 

Carolina’s path towards recovery. The state saw an influx of numerous temporary ACIs relocating from out of state to deal with the estimated 6.8 million tons of vegetative debris. While these temporary ACIs with capacities to burn less than 35 tons per day are not currently required to obtain Title V permits, units larger than this size were still subject to this onerous requirement, presenting a hurdle in the way of efficiently processing this disaster debris. When open burning was necessary, the DAQ emphasized that it is always illegal to burn trash or any man-made materials.<sup>17</sup> Along with the Asheville-Buncombe Air Quality Agency, the DAQ deployed 15 temporary air quality monitors and sensors to observe air quality in the aftermath in the storm. 

##### **B. Consolidation and Alignment of ACI Provisions** 

The DAQ generally supports the consolidation of regulations for ACIs that only burn wood waste, clean lumber, and yard waste in a new Subpart and the alignment of requirements for these ACIs. Combining requirements for ACIs of this type into a single set of rules regardless of the amount of vegetative debris burned would make the rules clearer for all stakeholders, including the regulated community, states, local governments, and the public. The regulated community will benefit from only having one set of regulations to reference for these ACIs’ requirements and not needing to cite different requirements depending on the amount burned. Additionally, ACIs that only burn wood waste, clean lumber, and yard waste are not solid waste incineration units, as described in Section I.B of this letter and defined in the Clean Air Act, and thus should not be regulated under the other numerous federal rules for solid waste incinerators. Separating requirements for ACIs of this type from those of solid waste incinerators will correct this error and reduce confusion. 

The DAQ agrees with most of the proposed requirements for ACIs that only burn wood waste, clean lumber, and yard waste but has some concerns about the specific text of the proposed rules, as shown in the EPA’s Redline/Strikeout (RLSO) markup of the rule language included with the docket.<sup>19</sup> Our specific comments are outlined below: 

###### **_<u>Definitions, Opacity Measurement, Performance Testing, Recordkeeping, and Reporting Requirements (Comments ACI-1, ACI-2, ACI-3, ACI-4, and ACI-6)</u>_** 

The DAQ agrees with the EPA’s proposal to align the definition of an ACI in the new proposed Subpart Ca with the existing definition of an ACI in the OSWI Rules (Comment ACI-1). The DAQ also agrees with the EPA’s proposal to require 6-minute averages as the basis of opacity compliance across all of the rules, as this ensures consistency across ACIs (Comment ACI-2). 

Additionally, the DAQ agrees with the approach EPA has taken in aligning and clarifying the annual performance testing frequencies (Comment ACI-3), including the allowance for delaying an annual performance test of a unit not operating until the next day that the ACI operates (Comment ACI-4). 

Finally, the DAQ supports aligning the recordkeeping and reporting requirements among ACIs, to require records for 5 years, with the records stored onsite for two years, and an 

> 19 EPA, Redline/Strikeout for amendments to Subparts across 40 CFR 60 and 62 and the addition of a new part 60 subpart for Consolidated Air Curtain Incinerators that Only Burn Wood Wastes, Yard Wastes, and Clean Lumber, Docket Document ID No. EPA-HQ-2025-0068-0013, March 20, 2026. https://www.regulations.gov/document/EPA- <u>HQ-OAR-2025-0068-0013</u>
{2}------------------------------------------------
Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OAR-2025-0068 Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OAR-2003-0119 May 4, 2026 Page 7 of 10 

option for offsite storage for the remaining 3 years that the record is required (Comment ACI6). 

###### **_<u>Initial Notification Requirements (Comment ACI-5)</u>_** 

While the DAQ agrees with the EPA’s proposal to require ACI operators to provide notification of startup, we recommend EPA revise the provisions to provide a more reasonable timeframe of these initial notification requirements. In the RLSO document, § 60.37a in 40 CFR Part 60 Subpart Ca specifies that the ACI operator “ _(a) Prior to the date of the initial startup or by [INSERT DATE OF PUBLICATION IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER], whichever is later, submit to the Administrator a Notification that includes the three items described in paragraphs (a)(1) through (3) of this section._ ” Requiring this notification on the same date as the final rule is published in the Federal Register does not provide adequate notice to regulated entities of this deadline, as the future date of publication would likely be unknown by regulated entities until the date that it appears in the Federal Register. The DAQ recommends allowing at least 60 days from the publication for entities to provide this notification. 

###### **_<u>CISWI Federal Plan Applicability</u>_** 

The DAQ notes that (according to the RLSO of the proposed rule language) EPA did not propose to remove the requirements for ACIs that only burn wood waste, clean lumber, and yard waste from the CISWI Federal Plan in 40 CFR Part 62 Subpart IIIa. Attachment 24 in the RLSO document does not amend or repeal any of the citations in this Subpart related to ACIs of this type, including §§ 62.14510a, 62.14530a, and 62.14740a through 62.14765a.<sup>19</sup> To achieve the EPA’s stated goals of consolidating requirements for ACIs that burn only wood waste, clean lumber, and yard waste in 40 CFR Part 60 Subpart Ca and removing all requirements for these ACIs from other federal rules, the DAQ believes that the CISWI Federal Plan in 40 CFR Part 62 Subpart IIIa should be amended in a manner consistent with the other rules in this proposed action. 

##### **C. Proposed Temporary-Use and Disaster Recovery Provisions** 

In the wake of Hurricane Helene, North Carolina urgently needed ACIs to burn vegetative debris as quickly and cleanly as possible; however, only OSWI ACIs had temporary-use disaster provisions that allowed them to be used without delay. In the immediate aftermath of the storm and prior to the EPA’s issuance of a NAA for North Carolina, CISWI ACIs were required to obtain a Title V permit and comply with 40 CFR Part 60 Subparts CCCC or DDDD. Consequently, fewer ACIs were able to be used to replace open burning. CISWI ACIs are larger and can burn more debris at once, making them safer and more effective for processing a large volume of debris. The DAQ recognized the potential benefits of using CISWI ACIs and asked the EPA for regulatory relief. After the EPA issued the NAA, these larger ACIs allowed more vegetative debris to be cleared and lessened the need for open burning. 

The use of both OSWI and CISWI ACIs continues to play an important role in Western North Carolina’s recovery from Hurricane Helene, as these units have allowed for quicker disposal of disaster debris while minimizing particle pollution and reducing the risk of wildfires. The DAQ generally supports adding temporary-use disaster provisions for CISWI units, which will relieve the need for future NAAs (upon the proposed rule becoming final). However, the DAQ
{3}------------------------------------------------
Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OAR-2025-0068 Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OAR-2003-0119 May 4, 2026 Page 8 of 10 

requests that §§ 60.2030 and 60.2542 in the CISWI Rules and § 62.14775a in the CISWI Federal Plan be amended to allow states to approve temporary use of a CISWI unit beyond 16 weeks.<sup>19</sup> The RLSO text specifically retains this authority with the EPA, but we believe that States are well equipped to handle these numerous requests when State personnel are already very involved in the many various efforts towards disaster recovery in their areas. Additionally, we request that the opacity limitations continue to apply for ACIs operating under the temporary-use disaster requirements. ACIs produce less pollution than open burning, but only if they are operated properly. Requiring ACIs used in disaster recovery to continue to meet the specified opacity limitations ensures that they are combusting waste efficiently and are not producing excessive pollution. The DAQ believes that the addition of temporary-use disaster provisions with opacity limitations for CISWI ACIs will allow states to respond more quickly and effectively to disasters while minimizing emissions. As a result, operators and state agencies will be able to focus on the most crucial and impactful pathways towards recovery. 

##### **D. Removal of Categorical Title V Permitting Provisions (Comment ACI-0)** 

On October 10, 2024, the North Carolina General Assembly (NCGA) passed House Bill 149, also known as the Disaster Recovery Act of 2024, in response to Hurricane Helene.<sup>20</sup> Section 10.5.(c) of the Act stated that owners and operators of permanent and temporary ACIs subject to 40 CFR Part 60, Subparts EEEE and FFFF were not required to obtain a General Title V Operating Permit, consistent with the EPA’s commensurate action to the federal OSWI Rules earlier that year. As a result, the Title V permitting requirement for OSWI ACIs in North Carolina was lifted sooner than it would have been through the state’s administrative rulemaking process alone, providing permitting relief for OSWI ACIs while the DAQ worked on amending the state’s ACI rule. This change further facilitated the use of ACIs during this critical time. 

The DAQ supports the EPA’s proposal to remove the categorical Title V permitting requirement for CISWI and SMWC ACIs that burn only wood wastes, yard wastes, and clean lumber (Comment ACI-0). This will align the requirements for these units with those for ACIs of other sizes (i.e., OSWI and LMWC ACIs). Further, as explained in Section I of this letter and in EPA’s preamble, ACIs that burn only these materials are not solid waste incineration units under the CAA, and therefore, should not be regulated as such with respect to Title V permitting. 

While the EPA’s preamble indicates its intent to remove categorical Title V permitting for ACIs of this type, the RLSO text for Subpart IIIa appears to continue requiring ACIs of this type to obtain a Title V permit, as Attachment 24 does not include any amendments or repeals of §§ 62.14510a, 62.14530a, and 62.14740a through 62.14765a.<sup>19</sup> The DAQ recommends EPA review this language closely and revise the CISWI Federal Plan text to remove requirements for ACIs burning only wood wastes, yard wastes, and clean lumber, as well as any erroneous cross references. 

##### **E. Pyrolysis Exclusion (Comment OSWI-1)** 

North Carolina is still recovering from the devastating impacts of Hurricane Helene. Though a significant amount of work has been done to process debris, there is still an enormous amount that needs to be removed. Removing the Title V permitting requirement for ACIs that only burn 

20 NCGA, The Disaster Recovery Act of 2024, October 10, 2024. <u>https://www.ncleg.gov/Sessions/2023/Bills/House/PDF/H149v5.pdf</u>
{4}------------------------------------------------
Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OAR-2025-0068 Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OAR-2003-0119 May 4, 2026 Page 9 of 10 

wood waste, clean lumber, and yard waste, streamlining requirements for these ACIs, and adding temporary-use disaster provisions for CISWI units will make the removal of vegetative debris easier and faster. It is imperative that North Carolina be able to take advantage of these benefits as soon as possible; however, they were proposed along with EPA’s request for comment on removing the reference to “pyrolysis/combustion units” from the definition of “municipal waste combustion unit” in the OSWI Rules. While we generally agree that pyrolysis units are distinct and separate from OSWI units, the DAQ does not want the necessary changes to ACI requirements needed to aid in disaster recovery to be delayed due to comments EPA receives on this definition (Comment OSWI-1). The DAQ urges EPA to separate the changes to ACI requirements and CISWI Rules from the request for comment on the pyrolysis exclusion so North Carolina can implement these crucial and timely actions without impediment. 

##### **F. Miscellaneous Comments** 

As outlined in this Subsection, the DAQ has identified several aspects of the text of the proposed rules, as included in the RLSO document posted to the docket,<sup>19</sup> that we believe require correction or clarification. 

###### **_<u>CISWI Rules and Federal Plan (40 CFR Part 60, Subparts CCCC and DDDD, and 40 CFR Part 62, Subpart IIIa)</u>_** 

The EPA states at 91 FR 13543, 13555 (Mar. 20, 2026) that CISWI units temporarily used in disaster recovery must continue operating control devices installed to comply with CISWI New Source Performance Standards, a CISWI Federal plan, or a State plan implementing CISWI Emission Guidelines, unless doing so is not technically feasible due to conditions in the disaster recovery area.<sup>21</sup> This provision is consistent with the (now rescinded) IFR, which included the same exception. However, unlike the IFR, the proposed text of 40 CFR Part 60 Subpart Ca, as listed in the RLSO document, requires control devices to remain in operation but does not include any reference to feasibility.<sup>19</sup> The DAQ supports the inclusion of the exception for feasibility and recommends that the rule text be amended to align with the IFR. 

###### **_<u>OSWI Rules (40 CFR Part 60, Subparts EEEE and FFFF)</u>_** 

In the RLSO of the proposed rules, the text appearing at § 60.3059(b) in 40 CFR Part 60 Subpart FFFF contains a cross reference to “§§ 60.3062 through 60.3068”, but the EPA is proposing to remove these sections. Additionally, § 60.2966(b), the section in 40 CFR Part 60 Subpart FFFF that corresponds to § 60.3059(b), is proposed to be removed.<sup>19</sup> The DAQ believes that § 60.3059(b) is no longer necessary and should also be removed. 

###### **_<u>Other Miscellaneous Rule Text</u>_** 

In our inspection of the RLSO document,<sup>**1**9</sup> the DAQ also identified some minor errors in the proposed rule text, as outlined below: 

- The RLSO markup of the proposed rules appears to contain an erroneous Subpart citation and title, where the text “PART 60—STANDARDS OF PERFORMANCE FOR LARGE MUNICIPAL WASTE COMBUSTORS” appears instead of “PART 

21 EPA, 91 FR 13543 and 13555, March 20, 2026.
