{0}------------------------------------------------
#### Asheville-Buncombe Air Quality Agency 

#### **APPLICATION REVIEW SUMMARY** 

|**S**|**ECTIONA:FACILITY 'INFORMATION**||
|---|---|---|
|**Company Name:**|Freudenberg Performance Materials (Freude|nberg)|
|**Site Name:**|Freudenberg - Enka Facility||
|**Mailing Address:**|1301Sand Hill Road, Enka, NC 28728||
|**Site Address:**|1301Sand Hill Road, Enka, NC 28728||
|**General Description of Business**|Non-woven and geosynthetic fiber manufactu<br>|ring facility<br>|
|**Facility Classification:**|Title V<br>ISITE STATUS:|IExisting|



##### **SECTION B: APPLICATION INFORMATION** 

|**DateOfApplication:**|May24,2024|**Application Tracking No.:**|**NA**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Date Complete Application**<br>**Received:**|January2,2025|**Board Meeting Date:**|May 14, 2026|
|**Confidentiality Requested?**|No|**Board Agenda Type:**|Title V Permit<br>Renewal|
|**Application Results:**|The purposeofthis<br>facility.|reviewisto renew the Title V opera|ting permit for the|
|**Permit No.**/**Date Issued by**<br>**Application:**|11-805-26 / May 14,|2026||
|**Permit No.**/**Date Voided by**<br>**Application:**|11-805-19A / March|14, 2024||



##### **SECTION C: REGULA TORY INFORMATION** 

|'|
|---|



AB A<sup>.</sup><sup>**Q**</sup> **l't R** I **t·** . , 4.0503, 4.0515, 4.0516, 4.0521, 4.0524, 4.0530, 4.0535, 4.0958, 4.1111, 4.1806 ir ua<sup>I</sup> **Y egu a ,ons.** 17.0504, 17.0317, 17.0700 

|**SECTION **<br>|**D:FACILITY-WIDE EMISSIONS I**|**NFORMATION**<br>||
|---|---|---|---|
|**Pollutants Reviewedasa Result**||**Potential Emiss**|**ions (TONS/YR)**|
|**ofthis Application or AB Air**<br>**Quality Action:**|**Actual 2023 Emissions (TONS/YR)**|**Prior to Review**|**New**|
|**PM-Total**|13.6*|91.4|91.1|
|**PM-10**/**PM-2.5**|13.6* / 13.6*|88.7_I_87.8|88.1/87.1|
|502|0.055|83.6|93.3|
|**NOx**|8.25|37.0|26.3|
|**co**|7.81|13.9|6.6|
|voe|62.0|249 (with limit)|249 (with limit)|
|**Greenhouse Gases, CO2e**|11,171.06|40,043|29,996|
|**AllHazardous Air Pollutants**<br>**(HAPs)**|0.175|0.227|0.226|
|**List all HAPs>10TPY of**<br>**potential emissions**|None|||



*Emission **numbers denoted with** an{*) **reflect** "controlled" emissions **{i.e. emissions** reduced **by a** pollution control **device).** 

##### **IN COMPIJANCE WITH EMISSION STANDARDS/ RECOMMEND APPROVAL** 

|**Preparedby:**|Alex Latta /|**Date Completed:**|03/20/2026|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Reviewedby:**||**Date Approved:**|03/25/2026|
|**Director:**|AshleyJ.Featherston|**Date Approved:**|03/25/2026|
{1}------------------------------------------------
#### **SECTION A DETAILS** 

##### **FACILITY INFORMATION** 

**[Detailed discussion of any items in Section A]** 

On March 4, 2013, the Agency received notification that Colbond, Inc. had merged with Bonar Technical Fabrics. The legal name of the new company is Bonar, Inc. (Bonar). The permit was amended in 2013 to reflect the change. On September 26, 2016, the Agency received notification that Bonar, Inc. had changed their corporate name to Low & Bonar, Inc. (Low & Bonar). The permit was amended in 2016 to reflect the name change. Low & Bonar manufactures non-woven and gee-synthetic fabrics for various end uses in construction, flooring, and automotive markets. 

In the nonwoven process line (M-1 through M-5), polyester (polyethylene terephthalate, PET} and nylon chips (Nylon 6 aka polycaprolactam, polyamide, PA6) are melted and extruded or spun to form a synthetic fiber. Bonar utilizes a two-step process: the yarn is spun and the fleece is then made from the yarn. In the fleecing operation, the fibers are bonded together in a nonwoven fashion to form a blanket. The blankets are trimmed and stored on large rolls. The finished product, called Colback, is used as a backing for carpeting and flat roofing products. 

Specifically, Nylon and PET chips are crystallized and dried in dedicated heated conversion processes prior to melting and being combined in the spinning process. A heated extrusion process melts and coextrudes nylon and PET through spinnerets to produce co-polymer fibers . Individual fibers are combined into a yarn that is collected onto spools. In this process, a VOC-containing lubricant is applied to the surface of individual yarn strands to facilitate movement of the yarn through the equipment. Further in the process, yarn is wound onto spools in the winding cabinets. Ultimately, yarn stored on spools is fed to the fleecing operation step and formed into a non-woven fabric, which is the final product. 

In the gee-synthetic process line (G-1 through G-6), nylon or polypropylene chips are melted and then extruded to form a loosely bonded blanket called Enkamat. No individual fibers are spun during this process. After cooling, the blankets are stored on large rolls. The gee-synthetic products or specialty gee-fabrics are used in various erosion control systems and building products, including ridge vents for roofing. 

In the application for the initial Title V permit, Bonar provided updated maximum production capacity figures for two of the gee-synthetic fabric extrusion lines (G-3 and G-5). They also requested that G-RES be classified as an insignificant activity. Emissions from G-RES are required to be calculated and reported in accordance with the PSD avoidance condition. For that reason, the source was be included in the permit so that it would be clear that emissions must be included in PSD avoidance calculations. 

Three 502(b)(10) changes occurred prior to the 2019 permit renewal. In a letter dated August 3, 2016, Bonar notified the agency of their intention to implement a 502(b)(10) change at their facility (which had been previously discussed with the Agency). Bonar was planning to reroute the M-1 line, which was routed to Filter House 1 (FH-1) to Filter House 2 (FH-2). The polypropylene was being utilized on this line was causing issues with the filter media on FH-1. FH-2 is a packed bed scrubber with a chevron style demister, it was expected to be able to process this material without causing media issues. The change occurred in late 2016. The table in the permit with the source and control device information was updated while the permit was open. 

In May of 2017, Low & Bonar contacted the agency regarding the addition of a geosynthetic process line, G-6. This line is the same configuration as G-3, with the same maximum rated capacity. It was determined that this line addition could be handled as a 502(b)(10) change. Low & Bonar submitted the notification letter and checklist in August of 2017. In August of 2018 during the compliance inspection, it was noted that the process was in operation running trials. It was not in full production yet at that time. 

In July of 2018, after consultation with the agency, Low & Bonar submitted a 502(b)(10) notification for the replacement of the smog hogs or electrostatic mist collection system that controls emissions from process line G-5. The goal of the project was to increase the capacity of the system in order to improve the collection efficiency of the hood inside the manufacturing area to improve indoor air quality for the
{2}------------------------------------------------
employees. The new system is the same brand, manufacturer, and electrostatic precipitator technology, the only difference is the replacement unit has more airflow capacity, 13,000 CFM compared to 7,600 CFM. The checklist and an updated C2 form were included with the notification. The replacement was completed in 2018. 

Additional insignificant activities were added as part of the 2019 renewal including one aerosol can recycling unit, two ink jet printers, and one diesel fired emergency generator. More details regarding those sources are included below. 

Facility Process Changes Since Last Renewal: 

In February of 2020, Low & Bonar submitted a 502(b)(10) notification for the replacement of two (2) dryers, DRY 1 and DRY 2, and one (1) crystallizer, CRST-2, with new units, CRST-6, CRST-7, DRY-6, and DRY-7. The current units are listed as insignificant activities and the new units will have similar heat input ratings to the units being replaced . This change occurred in March of 2020. 

In June of 2021, Low & Bonar submitted a 502(b)(10) notification to change the listed burner size of ESPB-1 and ESPB-2 from 18.8 MMBtu/hr to 21 .0 MM Btu/hr to reflect actual burner size of equipment. 

These changes were processed during this renewal. The emissions limits for the boilers were updated as part of this renewal since they are based on the heat input. 

###### 2024 Administrative Modification: 

In an email from Tom Buller on June 29, 2022, Mr. Buller notified the Agency that Freudenberg & Co. had acquired Low and Bonar in May 2020. Because of the pandemic nothing really changed about how they operated in the first year of the acquisition. In 2021 they began merging into the Freudenberg organization. In 2022 they changed the name out front of the business and begun corresponding with customers as Freudenberg Performance Materials. They continued to operate under the Low & Bonar, Inc. legal entity. It was noted that Low and Bonar had complicated financial entities and that it would take awhile to unwind those entities. The company is listed as Freudenberg Performance Materials LP on the NC Secretary of State website. 

The Agency received a letter from Tom Buller dated January 9, 2024, which included the ownership change notification and an off-permit change notification. The permit changes were for the insignificant activity list; they included a correction to the heat input rating of STEEL-1 from 0.62 MMBtu/hr to 0.5 MMBtu/hr and only being fired on natural gas and not including propane as a backup fuel source. They noted that the POLY-CHIP activity vented indoors and not outdoors, as they said the permit stated. The facility wants to add an additional STEEL-2, 0.5 MM Btu gas-fired burn off oven and an additional chip handling system - POLY-CHIP-2. Additionally, the facility noted the LIN-1 burn off oven was removed from the facility. An A 1 Form was attached that was signed by Donnie Phelps, the Site Executive Officer, as the responsible official, and dated 1 /24/24. The Agency responded with a letter and invoice for the $100 administrative fee change on February 14, 2024. Emissions calculations for the burn-off oven were included. 

The general c.onditions in the permit were also updated as part of this renewal. 

###### Facility Requested changes as part of this renewal: 

Freudenberg is requesting the following changes to the permit with this renewal: 

1. Remove all references to the use of propane at the facility, as the propane tank has been removed from operation. This includes removing propane as a backup fuel for F-1,F-2, DRY4,CRST-5, DRY-5, STEEL-1 and removing propane from the text of conditions 2.1.D.1 .c and 2.1.D.4.c 

2. Remove equipment PST, GLUE, and AEROSOL from the permit as the equipment has been removed from operation. 

3. Update the following insignificant activities emission source and/or control device descriptions: a. POLY-CHIP: change the control device description to read "Closed-loop pneumatic system comprised of numerous dust collectors and a cyclone" 

   - b. R&D LAB: change emission source description to read "One Research and Development Laboratory known as the 'Quality Lab"'
{3}------------------------------------------------
- c. FINISH: change emission source description to read "One finish oil storage area" d. TRANSFER: 

   - i. Change emission source description to read "Pneumatic nylon chip transfer operation" 

   - ii. Change control device description to read "Closed-loop pneumatic system with one (1) vacuum system dust collector" 

- e. ENKA-CHIP: Change emission source description to read "Closed-loop pneumatic Enkamat chip handling system" 

- f. INKJET: change emission source description to read "Two ink jet printers utilized for printing on the geo-synthetic lines" 

Additionally, Freudenberg identified inconsistencies between the emission calculations and the listed maximum process rates for the G-3 and G-6 process lines and has submitted updated emissions calculations with the renewal application to correctly reflect the maximum process rates listed in the permit. No changes to the permit are requested with the update to the emissions calculations. These changes are reflected on forms A2 and D4 of the renewal application. 

Freudenberg also requested that the condition for the emergency engines 40 CFR Part 63 Subpart ZZZZ be updated since rule changes occurred since the last permit was issued.
{4}------------------------------------------------
|[Listall e<br>associate<br>|**SECTION**<br>**APPLICATIO**<br>mission sources(permittedand exe<br>dcontroldevices andpollutants.P<br>Section B atbottomu<br>|**B DETAILS**<br>**N INFORMATIO**<br>mpt) reviewed as<br>rovide a detailedd<br>nder"Application|**N**<br>a resultofthisapplication,their<br>iscussionofanyotheritems in<br> Notes"]|
|---|---|---|---|
|**EMISSION**<br>**SOURCE**<br>**ID**|**Emission Source Description**<br>1.<br>**Type, manufacturer, capacity**<br>**2.**<br>**Control device with ID (if any)**|**Pollutant(s)**<br>**Emitted**|**Miscellaneous Notes**|
|M-1|Onesynthetic fiber extrusion and<br>winding process with emissions<br>controlledbyone packed bed<br>scrubber equipped with a chevron<br>style demister referred to by the<br>facilityasa filter house (FH-2)<br>'|PM,PM-10, PM-<br>2.5,voe|FH-2isa horizontally-oriented,<br>packed bed wet scrubber with a<br>chevron style demister<br>manufacturedbyHEE<br>Environmental Engineering, LLC,<br>Model No.ECH44-5LB.The<br>pressure drop rangeis0.2to2.0<br>inches water column. Packingis<br>polypropylene, total volume of<br>packingis4x4x5=80 cubic feet,<br>volumetric flow rateis7,200 cubic<br>feet per minute,andthe total<br>liquid injection rateis80gallons<br>per minute. The range of<br>operation listedinthe permit<br>application forms indicates that<br>the operating rangeisbetween 75<br>and80gallons per minute. For<br>more detailsonthe scrubber,<br>please see the notes below from<br>the 2012 permit reviewandthe<br>Title V permit application. Bonar<br>implemented a 502(b)(10) change<br>in2016toreroute theM-1line to<br>FH-2. It had previously been<br>exhaustedtoFH-1.<br>The maximum material<br>throughput data for this process<br>were revisited during the permit<br>modificationin2012. The<br>maximum process weight rate for<br>M1is1,693 pounds per hour; this<br>figure includes PET (polyester)<br>and PA (nylon), which are<br>processed together. Two different<br>scenarios or % throughput<br>combinations of raw materials<br>were provided. The combination<br>with the higher nylonorPA<br>contentisused for maximum<br>potential emissions, since nylon<br>resultsinhigherPMemissions.<br>(1,303pounds polyester or PET +<br>389 pounds nylon orPA=1,693<br>pounds per hour total throughput).<br>Data providedinemail<br>correspondence from Dan March<br>of Pisqah Environmentalon|
{5}------------------------------------------------
||||August20, 2012.<br>In2014, Bonar began making a<br>new product that utilizes<br>polypropylene and PET.<br>Please see note below for more<br>details regarding the modification<br>that occurredinMarch of 2014.|
|---|---|---|---|
|**M-2**|One synthetic fiber extrusion and<br>winding process with emissions<br>controlled by one monomer mist<br>elimination system referred toby<br>the facilityasthe filter house(FH-<br>1 )|PM, PM-10, PM-<br>2.5,voe|FH-1utilizes a KOCH flexifiber<br>mist eliminatorBOSRF TypeII<br>24120, which utilizes Brownian<br>diffusion and glass fiber filter<br>media. The dual system was<br>custom built and includesan<br>IndustrialAir, Inc. vacuum unit<br>and housing with two sets of<br>filtration units; only one operates<br>ata time. Facility operators<br>monitor the pressure drop across<br>the scrubber and when the<br>pressure drop falls below 4.75<br>inches of water, the exhaustis<br>routed to the second unit and a<br>water spray system flushes the<br>filtration media to cleanitand<br>prepareitfor reuse.<br>The maximum material<br>throughput data for this process<br>was revisited duringthe permit<br>modification in 2012. The<br>maximum process weight rate for<br>M2is1,058 pounds per hour; this<br>figure includes PET (polyester)<br>and PA (nylon), which are<br>processed together. Two different<br>scenarios or % throughput<br>combinations of raw materials are<br>provided. The combination with<br>the higher nylon or PA contentis<br>used for maximum potential<br>emissions, since nylon resultsin<br>PMemissions and polyester does<br>not. (815 pounds polyester or<br>PET+243 pounds nylon orPA=<br>1,058 pounds per hour total<br>throughput). Data providedin<br>email correspondence from Dan<br>March of Pisgah Environmental<br>onAuQust202012.|
{6}------------------------------------------------
|**M-3**|Onesynthetic fiber extrusionand<br>winding process with emissions<br>controlled by one monomer mist<br>elimination system referredtoby<br>the facilityasthe filter house (FH-<br>1)|**PM, PM-10, PM-**<br>2.5,voe|Please see note regarding the<br>control device above underM1.<br>The maximum material<br>throughput data for this process<br>was revisited during the permit<br>modificationin2012. The<br>maximum process weight rate for<br>M3is1,058 pounds per hour; this<br>figure includes PET (polyester)<br>andPA(nylon), which are<br>processed together. Two different<br>scenariosor% throughput<br>combinations of raw materials are<br>provided. The combination with<br>the higher nylonorPA contentis<br>used for maximum potential<br>emissions, since nylon resultsin<br>PMemissionsandpolyester does<br>not. (815 pounds polyesteror<br>PET+243 pounds nylon or PA =<br>1,058 pounds per hour total<br>throughput). Data providedin<br>email correspondence from Dan<br>March of Pisgah Environmental<br>onAugust20,2012.|
|---|---|---|---|
|**M-4**|Onesynthetic fiber extrusionand<br>winding process with emissions<br>controlled by one monomer mist<br>elimination system referredtoby<br>thefacilityasthe filter house (FH-<br>1)|**PM,PM-10, PM-**<br>2.5,voe|Please see note regarding the<br>control device above underM1.<br>The maximum material<br>throughput data for this process<br>was revisited during the permit<br>modificationin2012. The<br>maximum process weight rate for<br>M4is1,285 pounds per hour; this<br>figure includes PET (polyester)<br>andPA(nylon), which are<br>processed together. Unlike M1-<br>M3,only one combination of<br>materials was given {990 pounds<br>polyesterorPET + 296 pounds<br>nylonorPA=1,285 pounds per<br>hour total throughput). Data<br>providedinemail correspondence<br>from Dan March of Pisgah<br>EnvironmentalonAugust 20,<br>**2012.**|
{7}------------------------------------------------
|**M-5**|One synthetic fiber extrusionand<br>winding process with emissions<br>controlledbyone packed bed<br>scrubber equipped with a chevron<br>style demister referredtoby the<br>facilityasa filter house (FH-2)|**PM,PM-10, PM-**<br>2.s,voe|Solvent-based coatings are<br>utilizedinthis process. Bonar<br>estimates that similartoM1-M4,<br>96% of thevoesare emitted at<br>this stageinthe process. The<br>other 4% ofvoesare emittedin<br>the fleecing operation that follows<br>(F1andF2).<br>The maximum process weight<br>rate forMSis1,270 pounds per<br>hour; this figure includes PET<br>(polyester)andPA(nylon), which<br>are processed together. Several<br>different scenariosor%<br>throughput combinations of raw<br>materials were providedinthe<br>permit application. The<br>combination with the highest<br>nylon orPAcontentisused for<br>maximum potential emissions,<br>since nylon resultsinPM<br>emissions and polyester does not.<br>(979 pounds polyester or PET +<br>291pounds nylonorPA=1,270<br>pounds per hour total throughput).<br>In2014, Bonar began making a<br>new product that utilizes<br>polypropyleneandPETontheM1<br>line. During this permit review,<br>they indicated that they may also<br>wishtomake that productonMS.<br>Please see the note below for<br>more details regarding the<br>modification that occurredin<br>Marchof2014 and updated<br>information provided during this<br>review.<br>FH-2isa horizontally-oriented,<br>packed bed wet scrubber with a<br>chevron style demister<br>manufacturedbyHEE<br>Environmental Engineering, LLe,<br>Model No.EeH44-5LB.The<br>pressure drop rangeis0.2to2.0<br>inches water column. Packingis<br>polypropylene, total volume of<br>packingis4x4x5=80 cubic feet,<br>volumetric flow rateis7,200 cubic<br>feet per minute, and the total<br>liquid injection rateis80gallons<br>per minute. The range of<br>operation listedinthe permit<br>application forms indicates that<br>the operating rangeisbetween 75<br>and80gallons per minute. For<br>more detailsonthe scrubber,<br>please see the notes below from<br>the 2012 permit review and the<br>Title V permit application.|
|---|---|---|---|
{8}------------------------------------------------
|F-1|One Flamenco non-woven fleecing<br>unit (Unit 1) utilizing a 6.0**MM**<br>Btu/hr air heater firedonnatural<br>gas|**PM, PM-10,PM-**<br>**2.5, CO,NOx, **<br>s02,voe,<br>**HAPs/TAPs,**<br>**GHG**|The permit was modifiedin2014<br>toallow Bonartoincrease the<br>heat input capacity of this unit<br>from 5.6MMBTU per hourto6.0<br>millionBTUper hour.<br>The agency determined that this<br>action requireda permit<br>modification sinceF-1isa<br>permitted piece of equipment due<br>tothe fact thatina letter from<br>eolbond dated June3,2003,<br>eolbond estimated that 96% of<br>voesfrom the fiber finish are<br>emitted during the spinning<br>process,andthe remaining 4% of<br>voesare emitted during the<br>fleecinq process.|
|---|---|---|---|
|**F-2**|One Flamenco non-woven fleecing<br>unit (Unit 2) utilizing a10.4MM<br>Btu/hr air heater firedonnatural<br>gas|**PM, PM-10, PM-**<br>**2.5, CO,NOx,**<br>s02,voe,<br>**HAPs/TAPs,**<br>**GHG**|Bonar did not propose any<br>changestoF-2in2014. Updated<br>information about heat input<br>capacity was providedaspart of<br>that permit modification. The<br>previous permit listed the heat<br>input capacityas6.7MMBTUper<br>hour.|
|G-1|One geo-synthetic fabric extrusion<br>line|**PM, PM-10,PM-**<br>2.5,voe|The maximum design input rate<br>for this machineisapproximately<br>550pounds per hour when<br>utilizing nylonasthe raw material,<br>andapproximately451pounds<br>per hour when utilizing<br>polypropylene.|
|G-2|One geo-synthetic fabric extrusion<br>line|**PM,PM-10, PM-**<br>2.5,voe|The maximum design input rate<br>for this machineisapproximately<br>550pounds per hour when<br>utilizing nylonasthe raw material,<br>andapproximately451pounds<br>per hour when utilizing<br>polypropylene.|
{9}------------------------------------------------
|G-3|One geo-synthetic fabric extrusion<br>line|PM,PM-10, PM-<br>2.5,voe|The maximum design input rate<br>for this machineisapproximately<br>50pounds per hour when utilizing<br>nylonasthe raw material, and<br>approximately41pounds per hour<br>when utilizing polypropylene.In<br>this application for the Title V<br>permit, Bonar has indicated that<br>the maximum design input ratefor<br>this unitisactually60pounds per<br>hour when utilizing nylonasa raw<br>material.Anupdated figure for<br>polypropylene was not providedin<br>the application .Inemail<br>correspondence dated July3,<br>2014, Steve Jenkins of Bonar<br>indicated that the maximum<br>capacity when utilizing<br>polypropyleneis49 pounds per<br>hour. The maximum capacity<br>figures were not updated when<br>the Title V permit was issued .<br>They willbeupdatedaspart of<br>the current renewal .|
|---|---|---|---|
|G-4|One geo-synthetic fabric extrusion<br>line|PM,PM-10,PM-<br>2.5,VOC|The maximum designinput rate<br>for this machineisapproximately<br>550 pounds per hour when<br>utilizing nylonasthe raw material,<br>andapproximately451pounds<br>per hour when utilizing<br>polypropylene.|
{10}------------------------------------------------
|G-5|One geo-synthetic fabric extrusion<br>line|PM, PM-10, PM-<br>2.s,voe|G-5 mayruncontinuously; the<br>maximum design input ratewas<br>previously listedas2,500 pounds<br>per hour when utilizing nylonasa<br>raw material, and 2,050 pounds<br>per hour when utilizing<br>polypropylene.Inthe application<br>for the Title V permit, Bonar<br>indicated that the maximum<br>design input rate for this unitis<br>actually 1,800 pounds per hour<br>when utilizing nylon as a raw<br>material.Inemail<br>correspondence dated July3rd,<br>Steve Jenkins indicated that the<br>maximum capacity when utilizing<br>polypropyleneis1,476 pounds<br>per hour. This information was<br>updated when the Title V permit<br>was issued.<br>Emissions are routedtoa<br>separate exhaust stackand<br>controlled with two electrostatic<br>mist collectors. The manufacturer<br>isUnited Air Specialists, Inc.<br>Both are Model No. SHN-20-H-M<br>Electrostatic Mist Collectors. The<br>efficiency ratingis95%. The<br>control device description was<br>updated when the Title V permit<br>was issued.<br>InJuly of 2018, after consultation<br>with the agency, Low & Bonar<br>submitted a 502(b)(10) notification<br>for the replacement of the smog<br>hogsorelectrostatic mist<br>collection system that controls<br>emissions from process line G-5.<br>The goal of the project wasto<br>increase the capacity of the<br>systeminordertoimprovethe<br>collection efficiency of the hood<br>inside the manufacturing areato<br>improve indoor air quality for the<br>employees. The new systemis<br>the same brand, manufacturer,<br>electrostatic precipitator<br>technology, same 95% efficiency<br>rating (per application form), the<br>only differenceisthe replacement<br>unit has more airflow capacity,<br>13,000 CFM comparedto7,600<br>CFM, the combined capacity of<br>the two previous units. The<br>checklist andanupdatedC2form<br>were included with the<br>notification. The replacement was<br>completedin2018. The new unit<br>isa CLARCOR-UAS-SMOGHOG<br>Model No. PSG34-2. Total<br>collection plate areaislistedas<br>3,336 ft2 .|
|---|---|---|---|
{11}------------------------------------------------
|**G-6**|One geo-synthetic fabric extrusion<br>line|**PM, PM-10,PM-**<br>2.5,voe|This process was added as a<br>502(b)(10) changein2017and<br>added to the permit with the 2019<br>renewal.Inthe notification, it was<br>stated that the capacity was the<br>sameasG-3.Assuch, the<br>maximum design input rate for<br>this machineisapproximately60<br>pounds per hour when utilizing<br>nylonasthe raw material,and<br>approximately49pounds per hour<br>when utilizinqpolypropylene.<br>|
|---|---|---|---|
|**G-RES**|One geo-synthetic fabric extrusion<br>line|**PM, PM-10,PM-**<br>2.5,voe|This machineisoperated<br>intermittently for research<br>purposes only; maximum design<br>input rate for this machineis<br>approximately30pounds per hour<br>when utilizingnylonastheraw<br>material, and approximately25<br>pounds per hour when utilizing<br>polypropylene.Inadditionto<br>utilizing nylonandpolypropylene,<br>other raw materials are<br>occasionally testedonthis<br>machine for product development<br>purposes. Emissions are<br>exhaustedtoa separate stack.In<br>a previous permit, this machine<br>was referredtoasG-5.In2008<br>when Colbond added a<br>production line, they asked that<br>the new machine be referredtoas<br>G-5,and that this machinebe<br>renamed G-RES.<br>Inthe Title V permit application,<br>Bonar pointed out that potential<br>emissions are less than 5 tons per<br>year andassuch, this source can<br>be listedonthe insignificant<br>activity list.Emissions will still<br>needtobecalculated and<br>reportedinaccordance with the<br>PSD avoidance condition . For<br>that reason, the source willbe<br>includedinthe permitsothatit<br>willbeclear that emissions must<br>be includedinPSD avoidance<br>calculations.|
|ESPB-1|One21MMBtu/hr Hurst Series<br>500natural gas /No.2 fueloil<br>boiler with Industrial Combustion<br>Model DLG-210P Low NOx Burner|**PM, PM-10, PM-**<br>**2.5, CO, NOx,**<br>so2, voe,<br>HAPs/TAPs,<br>GHGs|Primary fuel is natural gas with<br>No. 2 fuel oil backup. The boilers<br>burn only natural gas, except<br>during periods of natural gas<br>curtailment and gas supply<br>emerqencies,andfor testinq.|
|**ESPB-2**|One21MMBtu/hrHurstSeries<br>500 natural gas /No.2 fueloil<br>boiler with Industrial Combustion<br>Model DLG-21OPLow NOx Burner|**PM,PM-10,PM-**<br>**2.5, CO, NOx,**<br>so2,voe,<br>**HAPs/TAPs,**<br>GHGs|<br>Primary fuelisnatural gas with<br>No. 2 fueloilbackup. Theboilers<br>burn only natural gas, except<br>during periods of natural gas<br>curtailment and gas supply<br>emergencies,andfor testinq.|
{12}------------------------------------------------
|**BER-1**|OneBerringer electric burn-off<br>oven with emissions controlledby<br>a wet scrubber|**PM, PM-10, PM-**<br>2.5,voe,<br>**HAP/TAP**|The ovenisused for cleaning the<br>spinnerets utilizedin**M1-M4.**The<br>spinnerets are disassembledand<br>placedinthe oven**to**melt and<br>bake-off polymer residue. The<br>wet scrubberisinherenttothe<br>process. More informationis<br>availableina memo to file dated<br>January9,2004. The ovenis<br>consideredaninsignificant activity<br>because of sizeorproduction rate<br>asdefinedinABAir Quality Code<br>17.0503 - "Definitions."|
|---|---|---|---|
|**DRY-4**|OneConair dryer (#4) with a<br>maximum heat input capacity of<br>0.64 MMBtu/hr, firedonnatural<br>gaswithpropane backup|**PM,PM-10,PM-**<br>**2.5, CO,NOx,**<br>sO2,voe,<br>**HAPs/TAPs,**<br>**GHGs**|This piece of equipmentisan<br>insignificant activity because of<br>sizeorproduction rateasdefined<br>inABAir Quality Code17.0503 -<br>"Definitions."|
|**DRY-5**|OneDryer (#5) with a maximum<br>heat input capacity of 0.5MM<br>Btu/hr, firedonnatural gas with<br>propane backup|**PM, PM-10, PM-**<br>2.5, CO, NOx,<br>sO2,voe,<br>**HAPs/TAPs,**<br>**GHGs**|The dryer, addedtoserveM5,is<br>similartothe two existing unitson<br>other production lines. This piece<br>of equipmentisexempt from<br>permittingasaninsignificant<br>activity because of sizeor<br>production rateasdefinedinAB<br>Air Quality Code 17.0503 -<br>"Definitions."|
|DRY 6 & 7|Two Novatec dryers with maximum<br>heat input capacities of 0.72MM<br>Btu/hr each, firedonnatural gas<br>withpropane backup (Replaced<br>Dryers # 1and2)|**PM, PM-10, PM-**<br>2.5,CO, NOx,<br>sO2,voe,<br>**HAPs/TAPs,**<br>**GHGs**|These pieces of equipment are<br>currently exempt from permitting<br>perABAir Quality<br>17.0102( c)(2)(B)(ii). These<br>sources are considered<br>insignificant activities because of<br>size or production rateasdefined<br>inABAir Quality Code 17 .0503 -<br>"Definitions."|
|**CRST-5**|OneCrystallizer (#5) with a<br>maximum heat input capacity of<br>0.35MMBtu/hr, firedonnatural<br>gaswith propcime backup|**PM, PM-10, PM-**<br>**2.5, CO, NOx,**<br>sO2,voe,<br>**HAPs/TAPs,**<br>**GHGs**|The crystallizer was addedto<br>serveM5andis similartothe two<br>existing unitsonother production<br>lines. This piece of equipmentis<br>consideredaninsignificant activity<br>because of sizeor production rate<br>asdefinedinABAirQuality Code<br>17.0503 - "Definitions."|
|**CRST-6**|OneNovatec crystallizer with a<br>maximum heat input capacity of<br>0.54MMBtu/hr, firedonnatural<br>gas(Crystallizer #6 Replaced<br>Crystallizer #2)|**PM,PM-10, PM-**<br>2.5, CO, NOx,<br>sO2,voe,<br>**HAPs/TAPs,**<br>GHGs|This piece of equipmentis<br>currently exempt from permitting<br>perABAir Quality<br>17.0102(c)(2)(B)(ii). This source<br>meets the definition ofan<br>insignificant activity because of<br>size or productionrateasdefined<br>inABAir Quality Code 17.0503 -<br>"Definitions."|
{13}------------------------------------------------
|**CRST-7**|One Novatec crystallizer with a<br>maximum heat input capacity of<br>0.54MM Btu/hr, firedonnatural<br>gas (Crystallizer #7 was added<br>when Crystallizer #2 was replaced)|**PM, PM-10, PM-**<br>**2.5, CO, NOx,**<br>sO2,voe,<br>**HAPs/TAPs,**<br>GHGs|This piece of equipmentis<br>currently exempt from permitting<br>per AB Air Quality<br>17.0102(c)(2)(B)(ii). This source<br>meets the definitionofan<br>insignificant activity because of<br>size or production rate as defined<br>inAB Air Quality Code 17 .0503 -<br>"Definitions."|
|---|---|---|---|
|**ETC-1**|One edge trim collection system<br>with emissions controlled by one<br>Flex-Kleen baghouse with 339<br>square feet of filter area|**PM,PM-10, PM-**<br>**2.5 **|The maximum material<br>throughput for the edge trim<br>collection systemis140 pounds<br>of materialper hour.<br>Maximum potential emissions<br>from this process were revisited<br>aspart of the Title V permit<br>review. Potential uncontrolledPM<br>emissions are now less than five<br>tons per year. Under the Title V<br>procedures, ETC-1 is considered<br>aninsignificant activity because of<br>size or production rate as defined<br>inAB Air Quality Code 17.0503 -<br>"Definitions."<br>Regarding the control device, the<br>Title V permit application states<br>that the minimum and maximum<br>pressure drop are 4.0 and 6.0<br>inches water column,<br>respectively. 2002 Model No.<br>**84WSBS64M32.**|
|**PST**|One 10,000 gallon aboveground<br>propane storage tank|voe|This unit has been removed and<br>the permit will updated with the<br>2024 renewal .|
|**POLY-**<br>**CHIP,**<br>**POLY-**<br>**CHIP-2**|Two polyester and nylon chip<br>handling system with emissions<br>controlled by numerous dust<br>collectors and a cyclone|**PM, PM-10, PM-**<br>**2.5**|POL Y-CHIP-2 was added as part<br>of this modification. The dust<br>collectors are located throughout<br>the facility, and are part of a dust<br>collection system that collects<br>dust moving through the pipes in<br>the winding process. The dustis<br>routedtoa cyclone that exhausts<br>indoors. None of the dust<br>collectorsisexhausted to the<br>outdoor atmosphere, so they are<br>consideredaninsignificant activity<br>because of size or production rate<br>as defined in AB Air Quality Code<br>17 .0503 - "Definitions."|
|GbY€|ORe§ll:le!=)Fess|VGG|+l=le§l1:1e!=)FessisG9RsiEleFeEIaR<br>iRSi§RifisaRtastivityeesa1:1seef<br>si2:e9F13rnEl1:1stieRFateasElefiReEI<br>iRABAiFQ1:1alityGeEle17.0503<br>"QefiRitieRs."+l=lis1:1Ritl=laseeeR<br>FemeveEIaREIwill1:113ElateEIw-itJ::Hl::le<br>**~0~4F9R9'N8I.**|
|**LIN-1**|One Lindberg electric burn-off<br>oven.|**PM,PM-10,PM-**<br>**2.5**|This unit has been removed and<br>the permit will updated with the<br>2024 renewal .|
{14}------------------------------------------------
|**TANKS1-2**|Two 15,000 gallon No. 2 fueloil<br>tanksandsupply systems|voe|Fueloiltanks are for backup for<br>the boilers. These storage tanks<br>are considered insignificant<br>activities because of size or<br>production rateasdefinedinAB<br>Air Quality Code 17.0503 -<br>"Definitions."|
|---|---|---|---|
|CHILL|Three (3) chillers with a total<br>capacity of approximately 1,500<br>tons|**PM, PM-10, PM-**<br>**2.5**|Refrigerant 134A. This equipment<br>isaninsignificant activity because<br>of categoryasdefinedinABAir<br>Quality Code17.0503 -<br>"Definitions."|
|**PYRO**<br>**OVEN**|One pyrolitic polymer cleaning<br>oven with emissions controlled by<br>a catalytic afterburner.|**PM, PM-10, PM-**<br>2.5, CO, NOx|Manufacturer: SCHWING Fluid<br>Technik GmbH. Model#:<br>VacuClean 454T. This piece of<br>equipment consideredan<br>insignificant activity because of<br>sizeorproduction rateasdefined<br>inABAir Quality Code 17 .0503 -<br>"Definitions."|
|**R&DLAB**|One ResearchandDevelopment<br>Laboratory knownasthe "Quality<br>Lab."|voes|This processisconsideredan<br>insignificant activity because of<br>sizeorproduction rateasdefined<br>inABAir Quality Code 17.0503 -<br>"Definitions".|
|**BOIL-3**|One natural gas fired Hurst model<br>cyclone hot water boiler with a<br>maximum rated input of 2.5MM<br>Btu/hr|**PM, PM-10, PM-**<br>**2.5, CO, NOx,**<br>so2,voe,<br>**HAPs/TAPs,**<br>**GHGs**|This boiler runs exclusivelyon<br>natural gas;No. 2 fueloilisnot<br>utilizedasa backup fuel. This<br>piece of equipmentisconsidered<br>aninsignificant activity because of<br>sizeorproduction rateasdefined<br>inABAir Quality Code 17.0503 -<br>"Definitions."|
|**FINISH**|Finishoilstorage area|voe|Sealed totes are storedinthis<br>area. This areaisnot ventedto<br>the atmosphere. The finishoil<br>storage areaisconsideredan<br>insignificant activity because of<br>sizeorproduction rateasdefined<br>inABAir Quality Code 17.0503 -<br>"Definitions."|
|TRANSFER|Pneumatic nylon chip transfer<br>operation with emissions controlled<br>bya closed-loop pneumatic<br>system with one (1) vacuum<br>system dust collector|**PM, PM-10, PM-**<br>**2.5**|The nylon chip transfer systemis<br>a closed loop system andis<br>consideredaninsignificant activity<br>because of size or production rate<br>asdefinedinABAir Quality Code<br>17.0503 - "Definitions."|
{15}------------------------------------------------
|ENKA-<br>CHIP|Closed-loop pneumatic Enkamat<br>chip handling system|PM,PM-10, PM-<br>2.5|This areaislocatedina room<br>adjacent to the geo-synthetic<br>process lines. Six storage<br>bunkers and 2 chip handlers are<br>utilized here to store raw material<br>(resin chips) for the geo-synthetic<br>process. The areaisnot vented<br>outdoors. Itisconsideredan<br>insignificant activity because of<br>size or production rateasdefined<br>inABAir Quality Code 17.0503 -<br>"Definitions."<br>There are 2 Conair dryersand2<br>Novatec dryersinthis area that<br>are used for drying nylon chips.<br>These dryers are electric andas<br>such, not expectedtohave air<br>pollution emissions.|
|---|---|---|---|
|STEEL-1 ,<br>STEEL-2|Two Steelman burn-off oven with a<br>maximum heat input capacity of<br>0.5 MMBtu/hr, firedonnatural gas|PM, PM-10, PM-<br>2.5, CO, NOx,<br>so2, voe,<br>HAPs/TAPs,<br>GHGs|<br>STEEL-2 was addedaspart of<br>the 2024 modification. They are<br>consideredaninsignificant activity<br>because of size or production rate<br>asdefinedinAB Air Quality Code<br>17.0503 - "Definitions."|
|AEROSOL|One aerosol can recycling unit|voe,<br>HAPs/TAPs|This unit has been removed and<br>the permit will updated with the<br>2024 renewal.|
|GEN-1|One diesel fired emergency<br>generator with a rated output<br>capacity of20kW<br>.|PM, PM-10, PM-<br>2.5,CO, NOx,<br>s02,voe,<br>HAPs/TAPs,<br>GHGs|Generac 20kW Model<br>2834080100. Manufacturedin<br>2002. This source was notedby<br>Low & Bonarinaninternal audit<br>in2017 and broughttothe<br>agency's attention at that time.<br>'<br>Generac engineisused for lift<br>station pumps to pump effluent<br>from plant to MSDinthe event of<br>a power failure. This engineis<br>classifiedasan insignificant<br>activity, butissubject to GACT<br>standard ZZZZ.Assuch itislisted<br>under permitted equipment to<br>include the requirements for<br>ZZZZ.|
{16}------------------------------------------------
|**GEN-2**|One diesel fired emergency<br>generatorwith a rated output<br>capacity of 200kW|**PM, PM-10, PM-**<br>**2.5, CO, NOx,**<br>s02,voe,<br>HAPs/TAPs,<br>GHGs|Olympian Generator Model<br>D200P4. Manufacturedin2001.<br>This source was added to the<br>permitin2019. This engineis<br>locatedonadjacent property<br>ownedbyFletcher Partners. Low<br>& Bonar operates and maintains<br>the generator for the flood pumps<br>that help control water during<br>stormandflood conditions. The<br>generatorisincludedinthe<br>definition of 'facility' sinceitison<br>adjoining property under common<br>control. This engineisclassified<br>asaninsignificant activity butis<br>subjecttoGACT standard ZZZZ.<br>Assuchitislisted under<br>permitted equipmenttoinclude<br>the requirements for ZZZZ.|
|---|---|---|---|
|**INKJET**|Two ink jet printers utilized for<br>printingonthe gee-synthetic lines|VOC/TAP|Ink jet printers utilizedto print<br>labels for products manufactured<br>onlines G-3andG-5.<br>Applicability determinations were<br>submittedin2017and2018.<br>Worst case emissions were<br>estimated at 0.52tons per year<br>and10pounds per year MEK for<br>lines G-3 and G-5 respectively.<br>The printers are considered<br>insignificant activities becauseof<br>sizeorproduction rate as defined<br>inAB Air Quality Code 17.0503 -<br>"Definitions."|



##### **APPLICATION NOTES** 

###### M-1 and M-5 : 

Prior to submitting the application for the burner tube replacement in 2014, Bonar notified the Agency of plans to produce a new product on one of their spinning machines (M -1 ). The new product will require the use of a different raw material, polypropylene, and a different finish material. EPA emission factors that this Agency was not previously aware of indicate that the use of polypropylene will result in additional PM and VOC emissions from the spinning process. The new finish material is water based, rather than solvent based, and as such, emissions from the finish will decrease. The modification to the M1 line resulting in a change in emissions was processed as part of that permit action. Bonar estimates that maximum material throughput is 85,000 pounds of polypropylene per month. The proportion of PET to polypropylene is estimated to be the same as that for nylon, as provided for the 2012 permit modification. Potential PM emissions from nylon are higher than those from polypropylene. \. As such, the PM emission limit and maximum potential hourly emission rates will be based on the product that utilizes nylon and polyester as raw materials. 

As part of the review for the initial Title V permit in 2014, Steve Jenkins provided updated information regarding maximum throughput rates for the polypropylene based product on M-1 . Email correspondence dated August 28, 2014 is attached to that review. Bonar estimates that maximum throughput for the M1 line for this product is 240 pounds of polypropylene and 760 pounds of PET per hour. Bonar may also wish to produce this product on the M-5 line in the future. The maximum throughput for the M-5 line for this product is estimated to be 229 pounds of polypropylene and 726 pounds of PET per hour. Potential PM emissions from nylon are higher than those from polypropylene. As such, the PM emission limit and maximum potential hourly emission rates will be based on the product that utilizes nylon and polyester as raw materials.
{17}------------------------------------------------
The production figures submitted by the facility in Appendix B.1 for the renewal in 2024 are outdated figures that were also submitted in the prior facility permit renewal application. As such, they do not match the figures used by the agency in our calculations which are more conservative. 

###### M5 Scrubber: 

The specifications from the manufacturer that were submitted in 2012 state that the scrubber is 99% efficient at removing particles greater than or equal to 5 microns in size. No data is available for efficiency for other particle sizes. No particle size data was provided for caprolactam (a component of Nylon 6) in the application. An inhalation study by the United Nations Environment Programme estimated particle size for caprolactam in the PM-2.5 range. An EPA fact sheet on packed bed scrubbers states that typical PM collection efficiencies range from 50 to 95% (http://www.epa.gov/ttn/catc/dir1/fpack.pdf). The fact sheet references another document, which states that collection efficiency for PM-2.5 and PM-10 in a packed bed scrubber is "poor," so it was determined that a value near the low end of the range may be most appropriate (http://www.epa.gov/ttn/catc/dir1/fpack.pdf; please see page 5.4-27 for the table and there is a discussion at the beginning of section 5.4). The control efficiency previously reported by Bonar for the scrubber that serves M-1-M-4 was reconsidered as part of the 2012 review. The original source test on which that figure was based has never been submitted to this agency. The summary available from the 2010 permit renewal review is not specific to particle size. The control efficiency used by this Agency has been updated to 50% as part of the 2012 review. If Bonar wishes to conduct source testing to establish more accurate control efficiencies for future emissions inventories and permit applications, they will need to submit source test protocols, notifications, and test data to this agency for review. A statement to this effect was included in the cover letter of the permit in 2012. 

In the 2014 Title V application, on page 3, there is a discussion regarding the particulate matter control efficiency associated with M5 and the fact that the Agency explained in the permit cover letter to Bonar dated September 11 , 2012 our rationale for using a conservative figure of 50% for FH1 and FH2. The application mentions th is and states that regarding FH-2, "This is a new control device installed in 2012. The manufacturer guarantees a control efficiency of 99 percent for particulate matter less than five microns; the range of aerodynamic diameters expected of caprolactam monomers in the Colback fiber process. This control efficiency is used in the calculations presented in table 7." No manufacturer data was provided. I contacted Steve Jenkins of Bonar via email and attached previous email correspondence between me, Dan March, and **HEE** Environmental Engineering from 2012. In that message, HEE indicated that they have no data for control efficiencies for particles less than 5 microns in diameter. On July 3, 2014, Mr. Jenkins indicated that he did not have any further supporting documentation to suggest a control device efficiency greater than 50%. As such, we will continue to use the 50% factor unless new information is provided or a source test is conducted. 

###### Insignificant Activities 

Updated information on the heat input capacities and status of the dryers and crystallizers was provided by Steve Jenkins of Bonar as part of the Title V permit review in 2014. That information was adjusted accordingly. Please see email correspondence from Steve Jenkins in the Title V permit review for more details. 

###### Current Renewal 

In the current application for this renewal in 2024, Appendix B, outdated production figures were submitted for M-1 , M-2, and G-3. G-6 was also affected since the production rate is the same as G-3. The updated more conservative figures will be used. This information will be passed on to the facility permit contact. Appendix B also listed the control efficiency of the filter house FH-2 as 99%. As discussed above, the agency will continue to use the 50% figure. These same incorrect figures were submitted in the 2019 permit renewal for this facility. The agency will plan to notify the facility and consultant that the production figures in the application (appendix B) do not match those in the permit, which were updated in 2012.
{18}------------------------------------------------
#### **SECTION C DETAILS** 

|**REGULA**<br>**(Identify theABAir Quality Regulations r**<br>**regulations already listed shouldbe**<br>**applicability. If a regulation has a stand**|**TORY INFO**<br>**eviewed becau**<br> **reviewed and**<br>**ard, list the sta**<br>**compliance.)**<br>**Emission**<br>|**RMATION**<br>**se of this application.Ata minimum, the**<br>**reason given for applicability or non-**<br>**ndard and indicate how the sourceisin**<br>|
|---|---|---|
|**AB Air Quality RegulationNumber/Title**|**SourceID**<br>**No(s).**<br>**Subject**|NotesonRegulation<br>(Compliance demonstration, applicability, etc.)|
|17 .0500 - Title V Procedures|Entire Facility|The facilityissubjecttoTitle V permitting<br>procedures because potential emissions<br>areinexcess of the 100-ton per year<br>applicability threshold forvoes.<br>Inaccordance with the current permit,<br>PPPI submittedanapplicationtorenew the<br>Title V permitonMay24, 2024 (application<br>was dueonJune30,2024). Since the<br>permit application was submitted 9 months<br>prior to permit expiration, the permit will not<br>expire until the renewal permit has been<br>issued or denied. All terms and conditions<br>of the existing permit shall remain in effect<br>until the renewal permithasbeen issued or<br>denied .|
|17.0700 - Toxic Air Pollutant Procedures|Entire Facility|The facility was reviewed for NC Air Toxics<br>when the permit was modifiedinMarch of<br>2014 to allowanincreaseinheat input<br>capacitytoF-1. The combustion<br>equipmentonthe fleecing unitsisbelow<br>permitting thresholdsandas such, would<br>normallynottrigger a toxics review. But,<br>since the equipmentispermitted due to<br>emissions associated with the finish oils,<br>the increase in the heat input capacitytoF-<br>1didresultinanincrease in potential<br>emissions from natural gas combustion<br>and did trigger a toxics review. Actual<br>emissions fromallcombustion sources<br>were below the TPERs.<br>For the current permit renewal,nonew<br>combustion sourcesorsources of TAPs<br>have been addedtothe facility since the<br>last review. GEN-1, a20KW diesel-fired<br>emergency engineandGEN-2, a 200 KW<br>diesel-fired emergency engine are<br>consideredaninsignificant activity under<br>17. 0503andwere added to the permitin<br>2019 so that the relevant requirements for<br>GACT ZZZZcanbeincluded. These<br>sources were manufacturedin2001and<br>2002 andassuch,isexempt from NC Air<br>Toxics under Chapter17. 0702(a)(18).<br>The toxics evaluation was not revisited as<br>part of this renewal.|
|4.0524 - New Source Performance<br>Standards|ESPB-1,<br>ESPB-2|The facilityissubjectto40CFR Part 60,<br>SubpartDe- "Standards of Performance<br>for Small Industrial-Commercial-|
{19}------------------------------------------------
|||Institutional Steam Generating Units." To<br>maintain compliance with theSO2<br>requirements of this regulation, the facility<br>will monitor the sulfur content of theNo. 2<br>fueloilcombustedinthe boilerstoensure<br>thatitdoes not exceed 0.5%byweight.<br>The facilityisalso required to maintain<br>monthly recordsofthe amountoffuel oil<br>andnatural gas burnedinthe boilers.In<br>lieu of tracking natural gas combustion for<br>each boiler, the facilitycanmonitor total<br>natural gas consumption forthefacility.<br>The facility reports the results of the<br>monitoringtothis Agencyona semi-annual<br>basis.|
|---|---|---|
|4.0530 - Prevention of Significant<br>Deteriorationand17.0317-Avoidance<br>Conditions|Entire Facility|<br>When the permit was modifiedin2012, the<br>maximum potential VOC emissions<br>increasedtoover 250 tons per year.In<br>ordertoavoid PSD applicability, a limit of<br>247 tons of VOCs per year was includedin<br>the permit. Low & Bonarisrequiredto<br>trackandreport 12 month rolling average<br>voeemissions for M-1-M-5 (including the<br>non-combustion portion emittedbyF-1and<br>F-2)toensure compliance with this<br>limitation. Potential VOC emissions from<br>combustion sources (permittedand<br>unpermitted) arenomore than 2 tons per<br>year regardless of fuel type. There areno<br>other significant VOC sources. A limit of<br>247 tons per yearvoesfor M-1-M-5, F-1-<br>F-2,andG-1-G6 and G-RES should be<br>sufficient to ensure the facility's emissions<br>remain below 250 tons per year.|
|4.1111- MACT (40CFR 63, Subpart<br>JJJJJJ)<br>'|ESPB-1,<br>ESPB-2|The permitted boilers are potentially<br>subjectto40CFR Part63,Subpart JJJJJJ<br>- "National Emission Standards for<br>Hazardous Air Pollutants for Area Sources:<br>Industrial, Commercial,andInstitutional<br>Boilers,"which was promulgatedbyEPA<br>onMarch21, 2011. The ruleisgenerally<br>applicabletosolidandliquid fuel-fired<br>boilers; however, boilers that are also gas-<br>firedandburn liquid fuel only during<br>periods of gas curtailment, gas supply<br>emergencies,orfor periodic testing notto<br>exceed48hours during any calendar year<br>are not subjecttothis subpart. Bonar<br>submitted the initial notificationinwhich<br>they stated that they were not subject to<br>the rule because the boilers burn only<br>natural gas, except during periods of<br>natural gas curtailmentandgas supply<br>emergencies, and for testing. If Bonar<br>indicates that they wishtohave the<br>flexibility to burn fueloilmore often than<br>just during periods of natural gas<br>curtailment, the requirements would<br>include a one-time energy assessmentand<br>biennial tune-ups. If the boilers are|
{20}------------------------------------------------
|4.1111- MACT (40 CFR63, Subpart<br>ZZZZ)<br>'|GEN-1,<br>GEN-2|equipped with oxygen trim systems, tune-<br>upscanbeconducted every five years.<br>When the permit was modifiedin2011,<br>relevant requirements of this subpart were<br>addedtothe permitincase the facility<br>wishestooperate the boilersonfueloilin<br>the future . Since that time, the<br>requirements were amended by EPA. This<br>conditioninthe permit was updated when<br>the permit was modifiedinMarch of 2014.<br>GEN-1 and GEN-2 are subject to40CFR<br>63, Subpart ZZZZ, "National Emissions<br>Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants for<br>Stationary Reciprocating Internal<br>Combustion Engines."Low & Bonaris<br>classifiedasanarea source of hazardous<br>air pollutants. Complianceisachieved<br>through work practice standards and<br>maintenance activities.<br>This conditionwasupdatedaspart ofthis<br>renewal since rule updates have been<br>made since the permit was last issued.|
|---|---|---|
|4.0503 - Particulates from Fuel Burning<br>Indirect Heat Exchangers|ESPB-1,<br>ESPB-2|<br>ESPB-1 and ESPB-2 burn natural gas with<br>No. 2 fueloilback-up; actual emission<br>ratesarewell below the standard.|
|4.0515 - Particulates from Miscellaneous<br>Industrial Processes|M-1, M-2,M-<br>3, M-4, M-5,<br>G-1, G-2, G-<br>3, G-4, G-5,<br>G-6, G-RES|M-1hasanhourly emissions limit of 3.67<br>pounds per hour; potential uncontrolled<br>emissions are4.71pounds per hourand<br>potential controlled emissions are 2.35<br>pounds per hour. M-2 andM3each have<br>anhourly emissions limit of 2.68 pounds<br>per hour; potential uncontrolled emissions<br>are 2.94 pounds per hour and potential<br>controlledemissions are 1 .47 pounds per<br>hour. M-4 hasanhourly emissions limit of<br>3.05 pounds per hour; potential<br>uncontrolled emissions are 3.58pounds<br>per hour and potential controlled emissions<br>are 1.79 pounds per hour. M-5 hasan<br>hourly emissions limit of 3.02 pounds per<br>hour; potential uncontrolled emissions are<br>3.52 pounds per hour and potential<br>controlled emissions are 1.76pounds per<br>hour. Complianceisexpected as longas<br>the control devices are operating properly.<br>Please see the notes section below for<br>additionaldetails.<br>G-1,G-2,and G-4 each haveanhourly<br>emissions limit of 1.73 pounds per hour<br>when utilizing nylon and 1.51pounds per<br>hour when utilizing polypropylene; potential<br>uncontrolledemissions are 0.050 pounds<br>per hour with nylonand0.311pounds per<br>hour with polypropylene for each machine.<br>G-3andG-6 have hourly emissions limits<br>of0.391pounds per hour when utilizing<br>nylonand0.342 pounds per hour when<br>utilizing polypropylene; potential<br>uncontrolled emissions are 0.0054 pounds<br>per hour with nylon and 0.034 pounds per|
{21}------------------------------------------------
|||hour with polypropylene. G-5hasan<br>hourly emissions limit of 3.82pounds per<br>hour when utilizing nylon and 3.34 pounds<br>per hour when utilizing polypropylene;<br>potential uncontrolled emissions are 0.162<br>pounds per hour with nylonand1 .02<br>pounds per hour with polypropylene. G-<br>REShasanhourly emissions limit of 0.246<br>pounds per hour when utilizing nylonand<br>0.218 pounds per hour when utilizing<br>polypropylene; potential uncontrolled<br>emissions are 0.0027 pounds per hour with<br>nylonand0.017 pounds per hour with<br>polypropylene.|
|---|---|---|
|4.0516 - Sulfur Dioxide Emissions from<br>Combustion Sources|**ESPB-1,**<br>ESPB-2,F-<br>1,F-2|This regulation limitsSO2 emissions from<br>these sourcesto2.3 lb/MMBtu. The AP-42<br>SO2emission factor for natural gas<br>combustion for each boiler (ESPB-1,<br>ESPB-2)is0.001lb/MMBtu. The boilers<br>are subject to theSO2 emission limit of<br>NSPS SubpartDewhen burningNo. 2 fuel<br>oil. Thus, the facilityisexpectedtobein<br>compliance.|
|4.0521- Control of Visible Emissions|**M-1,M-2,M-**<br>**3,M-4,M-5,**<br>F-1, F-2, G-1,<br>G-2, G-3,G-<br>4,G-5, G-6,<br>**G-RES,**<br>ESPB-1 ,<br>ESPB-2|This regulation limits visible emissions from<br>each of these emission sourcestono<br>greater than 20% opacity duetotheir post-<br>1971manufacture date. Compliance with<br>this regulation willbedetermined through<br>facility self-monitoringandAgency<br>inspections. This regulation does not apply<br>toemission sources subjecttoABAir<br>Quality Code 4.0524 - New Source<br>Performance Standards if the NSPShasa<br>visible emission standard. The boilers are<br>subjecttoNSPS SubpartDe,which does<br>not have a visible emission (opacity)<br>standard for boilers with a heat input<br>capacity under30MMBtu/hr.|
|4.1806 - ControlandProhibition of<br>Odorous Emissions|Entire Facility|<br>This regulation requires thatthefacility<br>prevent odorous emissions from causing or<br>contributingtoobjectionable odors beyond<br>their property line. Compliance with this<br>regulation will be determined through<br>Agency inspections.|



##### **REGULATORY NOTES** 

**4.0515 - Particulates from Miscellaneous Industrial Processes.** The particulate matter limits were calculated according to the appropriate equation in 4.0515 of the AB Air Quality code. Input parameters were as follows: 

- M-1 through M-5, G-1 through G-5: Please see process weight rates listed above in Section B Details. Limits and worst-case emissions were calculated for the two different raw materials that are utilized on the G lines. Please see the attached spreadsheet for more details on limits and potential emissions for the G lines. 

Inspection and maintenance requirements are included in the permit to address the control devices that reduce particulate matter emissions from M-1-M-5. Potential uncontrolled emissions from M-1-M-5 are higher than the particulate matter limit for those sources. Potential uncontrolled emissions for G-1 through G-6 are less than the emissions limits for those sources. Inspection and maintenance
{22}------------------------------------------------
requirements for the control devices serving M-1 through M-5 are included in the permit. Inspection and maintenance requirements for the control device that serves G-5 will not be included in the permit since maximum potential uncontrolled emissions are less than permitted limits. 

**4.0503 - Particulates from Fuel Burning Indirect Heat Exchangers.** The allowable emission limit for each boiler was calculated according to the following equation: 

Allowable PM Emission Limit= (1 .090) x (42.0)-<sup>02594</sup> = 0.413 lb/MMBtu heat input, 

where 42.0 is the total maximum heat input capacity of both permitted boilers (2 x 21 .0 MMBtu/hr). 

**4.0524 - New Source Performance Standards.** GEN-1 and GEN-2 are not subject to NSPS Subpart 1111 since they were manufactured prior to 2006.
{23}------------------------------------------------
|Calculation Method Codes<br>(List allthatapply)|**SECTION**<br>**EMISSION I**<br>1=Stack test result<br>2=Material (mass) b<br>3=**EPA**approved in<br>**4**=Other (specify in<br>|D**DETAIL**<br>**NFORMATIO**<br>alance<br>formation**(AP-42,**<br>table below)<br>|**S**<br>**N**<br> CTG,etc.)||
|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Calculation Rejection**<br>**Codes**<br>(List allthatapply)|1=Calculationerror<br>2=Wrong emission<br>3=Control efficiency<br>4=Other (specify in|<br>factor(s) used<br>(ies)notaccepte<br>table below)|d||
|**Emission Source (ID No.)**|Calculation<br>**Method Code**|**Accept or**<br>**Reject?**|**Calculation**<br>**Rejection Code**|**AB Air Quality**<br>**Calculations**<br>**Attached?**|
|M-1, M-2, M-3,M-4,M-5|2,3|NA|NA|Yes|
|F-1andF-2|2, 3|NA|NA|Yes|
|G-1, G-2, G-3, G-4, G-5, G-6,<br>G-RES|1|NA|NA|Yes|
|ESPB-1, ESPB-2, Unpermitted<br>DryersandCrystallizers|3|NA|NA|Yes|
|ETC-1|2|NA|NA|Yes|



##### **EMISSION NOTES** 

Potential emissions are based on back up fuels, which are No. 2 fuel oil for the 2 permitted boilers. The small natural gas boiler that was added in 2008 is included in the potential emissions calculations. Maximum potential VOC emissions are based on maximum material throughput submitted by Bonar in the revised permit application they submitted in July of 2012 and updates for G-3 and G-5 that were submitted in the Title V application and an application that was submitted to modify the burners on the fleecing unit in 2014. 2013 emissions and potential emissions associated with the M and G lines were revised during the March 2014 permit modification and the permit review for the Title V permit to incorporate additional emission factors for PM and VOCs from melt spinning of polyester (PET), nylon 6, and polypropylene from EPA's AP-42, Fifth Edition, Compilation of Air Pollution Emission Factors, Volume 1, Chapter 6.9, Synthetic Fibers. This Agency was not previously aware of these factors. The use of these additional factors resulted in a slight increase in actual and potential PM and VOC emissions from the main product line. 

Polypropylene is a polyolefin. AP-42 factors were used to calculate emissions from M-1 and M-5 when using that raw material. With the addition of the PM and VOC factors from AP-42 and then accounting for the very low VOC content of the spin finish for the product that will utilize polypropylene, it was determined that VOC and PM emissions would be significantly less compared to the product that utilizes nylon and the higher VOC content spin finish. The finish oil that is utilized when M-1 utilizes polypropylene has a volatile content of 0.05% as 2-(2-butoxyethoxy)ethanol (CAS # 112-34-5), which is a glycol ether. Glycol ethers are considered a HAP, but not a TAP. 

Material usage data from 2024 that were submitted by Bonar in the annual emissions inventory were utilized to calculate 2024 emissions. The production figures submitted by the facility in Appendix B.1 for the renewal in 2024 are outdated figures that were also submitted in the prior facility permit renewal application . The Agency is using the more conservative production figures from 2012 to calculate potential emissions. Also, potential emissions were updated to remove propane as a back-up fuel and to change the boiler heat input rating.
{24}------------------------------------------------
<!-- Start of picture text -->
u<br>SECTION E<br><!-- End of picture text -->

##### **SUPPORTING DOCUMENTATION** 

**(Provide brief description of any attachments)** 

1. Permit application 

2. Copy of 502(b)(10) notification for replacement of DRY 1, DRY-2, and CRST-2 with DRY-6, DRY-7, CRST-6, and CRST-7 

3. Draft permit 

4. Permit cover letter 

5. Emission calculations 6. Draft Public Notice
