{0}------------------------------------------------
Buncombe County Planning and Development Long Range Planning Division 46 Valley St. Asheville, NC 28801 

## **LIGHTING MEMORANDUM** 

**To: Buncombe County Planning Board From: Long Range Planning Division Date:    September 2, 2025** 

**Re: Text Amendments Addressing Exterior Lighting Standards** 

## **PURPOSE** 

The Exterior Lighting Memorandum provides an overview of the key issues and proposed Zoning Ordinance changes related to outdoor lighting. Lighting standards are intended to minimize light pollution, light trespass and glare, and work to promote energy efficient lighting practices. Reducing light pollution has important benefits for the natural environment, such as protecting migrating and nesting wildlife, and has been shown to positively impact human health. 

This document will summarize an analysis of Equity issues, relevant case law, current bills before the General Assembly, a consideration of regulations in other jurisdictions, proposed text amendments, and general recommendations. 

## **EQUITY ANALYSIS** 

When exterior lighting pervades the night sky and landscape in ways that negatively impact humans and the environment it is called light pollution. Exposure to light pollution has been found to have negative mental and physical impacts to humans, such as by disrupting the body’s circadian rhythm that regulates sleep, and increasing traffic accidents due to glare and night blindness (3). It also creates impacts that can harm wildlife, plants, and ecosystems that we rely on for a healthy and resilient environment (1). 

A study of outdoor lighting in the United States showed that non-white communities and renter-occupied areas were impacted by light pollution at a rate twice that of white communities, and that there was little difference in the inequity when studying rural vs. urban areas. Some of this can be attributed to development patterns that result in racial and ethnic minorities, and low-income households being situated near less desirable uses that are more likely to create light pollution (2). “Marginalized communities generally suffer from poor lighting, which is visually distressing, environmentally harmful and socially hostile” (4). As a result, light pollution is an environmental justice issue as it disproportionately impacts communities of color and lower socioeconomic households. 

As Buncombe County continues to grow, conflicts between residents and businesses will increase as more areas become developed and new exterior lighting is installed. Infill development, up-zoning, and redevelopment will contribute to a brighter nighttime environment unless protections are put in place to limit the negative impacts of light pollution.
{1}------------------------------------------------
## **CASE LAW & CURRENT BILLS** 

In North Carolina, local jurisdictions have the authority under Zoning law to regulate land uses and standards related to them, such as for exterior lighting. The NC General Assembly prohibits blinding, deceptive or distracting lights which could result in a motor vehicle accident or be confused for a traffic signal (G.S. 13632.2). Two Supreme Court cases related to the regulation of on vs. off-premise sign regulations include: Reed v. Town of Gilbert, and Austin v. Reagan National. 

## _**Current Bills in NC General Assembly**_ 

None identified. 

## **REGULATIONS IN OTHER JURISDICTIONS** 

This is a brief look at what other local governments are doing. _Examples from outside North Carolina may not be legal or otherwise desirable in North Carolina but are presented to illustrate alternative approaches._ 

## _**Common Language and Practices**_ 

Examples of standards from other jurisdictions include: 

|Light level|Regulates the maximum amount of light at property lines, roads, and for the entire<br>development site or withinparkinglots,often through footcandle measurements.|
|---|---|
|Color Temperature|Regulates the color of light on the kelvin scale. 1,000 to 4,500 kelvin is warm light<br>4,500 to 6,500 is white daylight. 6,500 to 10,000 is blue light. Typically warmer<br>colors are healthier and easier on human eyes,and less disruptive to wildlife.|
|Mounted height|Sets a maximum height for the mounting of lights or illuminated signage. Height is<br>one factor that impacts how much light is visible to surrounding properties, and<br>how much of an area is illuminated.|
|Internal illumination|Sets standards for the maximum face size of internallyilluminated signs.|
|Light direction|Light direction dictates where the light falls based on fixture design and placement.<br>Standards to minimize light trespass may include shielding, glare control, or cutoff<br>light fixtures.|
|Lumens|Sets standards for the maximum amount of visible light through limits on lumens.<br>Lumens is the brightness of the light.|
|Movement|Regulates orprohibits animation,movement,or change on a digital displaysign.|
|Automation|Lights can be automated to automatically dim after a certain time of night, turn off<br>during daylight, or adjust brightness during fog and rain. Typically utilized for traffic<br>safetyreasons.|



## _**Common Regulatory Obstacles**_ 

Enforcement of exterior lighting regulations can be difficult when applied to single-family residential developments. For example, when residents add new light fixtures or change old light fixtures they are not required to obtain a Zoning permit, so there is no process for a Zoning inspector to ensure that the light is compliant. Coordination with the Permits & Inspections Department through their electrical permitting process would be needed to enforce exterior lighting standards for single-family residential uses. Therefore, no standards are being proposed for detached single-family uses in these text amendments.
{2}------------------------------------------------
## _**Health & Safety Requirements:**_ 

Regulating a specific use through the Zoning Ordinance does not exempt that use from any other local, state, or federal regulation. As an example, lighting standards are subject to the following requirements: 

- NC State Building Code Requirements for health, safety, and emergency access lighting 

- NCDOT Street light requirements for public roads 

- FAA requirements for Airport lighting related to the airfield side of the property 

## _**Regulation and Enforcement**_ 

Regulation of lighting is through the normal permitting process of obtaining a Site Plan Review (SPR) permit for construction of a building, installation or replacement of lighting, or through a Change of Use permit if a residential structure were converted to commercial use. As is common with most of our regulations, Zoning enforcement for a violation of the lighting requirements would be initiated by receipt of a community complaint for non-compliant lighting. 

## _**Localities**_ 

The following is a list of notable lighting standards from other jurisdictions: 

|**LOCATION**|**REGULATORY EXAMPLES**|
|---|---|
|Asheville, NC|Regulates residential and commercial lighting, requiring full cutoff fixtures. Limits light at<br>property lines to 0.5 footcandles, mounted height to 25 feet, and flood lights less than<br>1,250 lumens and shielded. Requires BUG rating and 4,300 kelvin or less. 6,500 lumens or<br>less in residential districts and 20,000 lumens or less for non-residential. Additional<br>requirements for other uses. Prohibits blinking or changing displays and internally lit wall<br>panels. Exempts temporary seasonal lighting, historic landmark lighting, string lights for<br>residential or over diningareas,and ornamentalgas lights.|
|Henderson<br>County, NC|Requires exterior lighting be fully shielded with exceptions for flag poles and other uses.<br>Sets a maximum amount of light trespass at property lines, and prohibits flood lights.<br>Requires existing buildings to bring lighting into full compliance if they repair or replace<br>50% or more total existingexterior lightingwithin a 12 monthperiod.|
|Chatham<br>County, NC|Requires lighting in natural areas to be reduced after midnight. Requires lighting plans to<br>demonstrate how they will be energy efficient, reduce lighting, and utilize timers or other<br>methods to eliminate lights. Sets standards specific to type of use. Sets standards for light<br>measurement techniques forpermitting.|
|Guilford<br>County, NC|Requires commercial lighting adjacent to a residence be turned off by 10pm. All lights<br>must be full cutoff, mounted less than 35 feet, with footcandle limits based on type of use.<br>Specific standards for canopy lighting and outdoor recreation. Exempts single family<br>residential lighting, temporary lighting and holiday displays, security lighting with motion<br>activation that turns off after 15 minutes, gas lamps, street lights, and government flags.<br>Prohibits flashingor intermittent lighting.|
|Wendell, NC|Specifies a maximum light level of 0.5 footcandles at residential property lines, and up to 1<br>foot candle at all other property lines. Limits wall packs to building entrances only,<br>prohibiting them for general site lighting. Prohibits any light which shines directly into the<br>yard or window of an adjacent residence. Sets a maximum mounted height of 18 feet for<br>pedestrian lights and 37 feet for street orparkinglot lighting.|



## **EXISTING COUNTY ORDINANCES**
{3}------------------------------------------------
Buncombe County’s Zoning Ordinance currently regulates exterior lighting related to commercial uses, multifamily apartment complexes, and dusk-to-dawn security lighting. Standards require full cutoff lighting, or partial cutoff fixtures for lights less than 1,250 lumens. There are limits on the maximum average light level for the overall development, as well as for light levels at property lines, road rights-of-way, and in parking lots. 

Specific standards apply based on type of use, for example, wall accent lighting, gas station canopy lights, streetlights, and sports fields have additional requirements. LED lights are limited to a maximum color temperature of 4,300 kelvin, which is in the warmer yellow range. There is a 35 foot height limit, and glare control requirements. Exemptions exist for temporary seasonal lighting, emergency lighting, and single-family residential lighting (except not dusk-to-dawn lights). Search lights, laser lights, high intensity string lights, and up-lighting are all prohibited. 

## **PROPOSED TEXT AMENDMENTS** 

The following table summarizes the proposed Zoning Ordinance Text Amendments related to co-living. 

||**SUMMARY OF PROPOSED TEXT AMENDMENTS**<br>_(Sec. 78-668 Lighting Standards)_|
|---|---|
|1|Create a definition of accent lighting|
|2|Create a definition of electronic message display|
|3|Create a definition for facade lighting|
|4|Update the lighting standard Purpose statement.|
|5|Remove the assemblyreplacement standard(b)(2)as this is redundant.|
|6|Remove dusk to dawn 5-year conformity standard as these lights were already phased out years ago|
|7|EXEMPTIONS:<br>a) Add exemption for low-intensity ornamental gas flame lamps<br>b) Add exemption for low volt,low watt ornamental landscape lighting|
|8|PROHIBITIONS:<br>a) Clarify prohibition for outward lighting and any that is not full or partial cutoff<br>b) Clarify standards for lumen ratings of string lights<br>c) Prohibit animated or flashingsigns|
|9|Move all footcandle standards into 1 central table, and make the following changes:<br>a. Split the property line footcandle limit into a non-residential and residential option<br>b. Add a maximum footcandle for illumination of vertical surfaces<br>c. Add a maximum footcandle for electronic message displays|
|10|Move all Kelvin ratings into 1 central table, and make the following changes:<br>a. Reduce the maximum kelvin rating for commercial<br>b. Create separate kelvin standards for residential and rural areas<br>c. Create a higher kelvin rating for vehicular canopies, sports fields, and performance areas<br>d. Exempt internallylit signs,lettering,and electronic displays from kelvin standards|
|11|Add agraphic showingthe difference between full cutoff,partial cutoff, and non-cutoff fixtures|
|12|Require that lighting be aimed and shielded so the direct light falls on the property of the light and not<br>onto adjacentparcels except for sharedparkingareas or common developments|
|13|Move all maximum height standards into 1 central table, and make the following changes:<br>a. Reduce the maximum height of security lighting to 15 feet<br>b. Create a 10 foot height limit for electronic message displays<br>c. Reduce the maximum height for outdoor sports courts to 50 feet<br>d. Reduce sign lighting to 20 feet<br>e. Reduce the height ofgeneral site lightingto 30 feet|
{4}------------------------------------------------
||f. Clarifyindividual lights on apartment balconies have no height limit but must be full cutoff|
|---|---|
|14|Revise accent and facade lighting to clarify that it only applies to lights which are directly facing a<br>structure or sign that is beingilluminated.|
|15|Clarifythe wordingforplacement of low wattage fixtures close to buildings.|
|16|Allow non-compliant vehicular canopies to be updated without having to meet all lighting standards by<br>removingsome of the faces of the canopylighting.|
|17|Require that dusk to dawn, security, and flood lights be motion-activated and designed to turn off<br>within 20 minutes of activation.|
|18|Require that all street lightingbe full cutoff.|
|19|Clarifythat outdoor sports fields andperformance areas must be cutoff or full cutoff light fixtures|
|20|Limit lightingof sports fields to those in open for use or undergoingmaintenance.|
|21|Create standards for electronic message displays.|
|22|Create maximum size standards for backlit signs and letters based on mountingtype/location.|
|23|Clarifythephotometricplan requirements.|
|24|Create a table identifying commercial and multi-family lighting designs which will not require a<br>photometricplan based on meetingcertain standards.|
|25|Remove the requirement for an as-built drawingfor the lighting plan.|
|26|Remove the reference to the 10 business dayreviewprocess.|



## **COMPREHENSIVE PLAN REFERENCE** 

The following sections of the Comprehensive Plan were referenced when drafting these text amendments: 

## **Growth, Equity, Conservation** 

Action 6: Support the protection of agricultural and forest lands, environmentally sensitive areas, and rural communities. 

## **Farms, Forests, Env.** 

Policy 2: Preserve Buncombe County’s natural heritage. 

Policy 3: Promote ecosystem enhancement… 

## **Health & Recreation** 

Policy 5: Utilize environmental protection and land conservation to… promote health. 

## **Infrastructure & Energy** 

Action 2: Implement policies around new development and re-development that advance decarbonization and sustainability goals 

## **CITATIONS:** 

1. Chepesiuk R. Missing the dark: health effects of light pollution. Environ Health Perspect. 2009. 

2. Nadybal SM, Collins TW, Grineski SE. Light pollution inequities in the continental United States: A distributive environmental justice analysis. Environ Res. 2020. 

3. Task Force to Study Lighting Efficiency & Light Pollution in Maryland. State of Maryland. 2002. 

4. Bartholomew, Edward & Loeffler, Mark. With Good Lighting & Justice for All. 2021. Illuminating Engineering Society. **REFERENCES:** 

- (A) Model Lighting Ordinance. 2011. International Dark Sky Association. 

- (B) Innovative Land Use Planning Techniques. A Handbook for Sustainable Dev. 2008. New Hampshire Dept. of Environmental Svcs. 

- (C) Smart Codes: Model Land-Development Regulations. 2009. American Planning Association. Planning Advisory Service report 556. 

- (D) Finding Common Ground: Answers to Common Questions about Electronic Message Centers (EMCs). International Sign Association.
{5}------------------------------------------------
**ZPH2025-00024** 

## **VERSION 1** 

## **9-15-2025** 

~~**Strikethrough**~~ **– deletions** 

**Underline - additions** 

## **Sec. 78-581. Definitions.** 

Accent lightng means an exterior light directed at and for the purpose of illuminatng an object, sign, landscaping feature, or specifc architectural detail. 

Electronic message display (EMD) means a digital surface that uses light to display informaton, graphics, or images that can be changed electronically. 

Facade lightng means the illuminaton of the vertcal surface of a building through shielded light fxtures atached to and pointng at the structure. 

## **Sec. 78-668. - Lighting standards.** 

(a) _Purpose._ Lighting standards are established in order to permit ~~,~~ reasonable uses of outdoor lighting for night-time safety, utility, security, productivity, enjoyment and commerce. These standards will minimize light pollution, light trespass, and glare, ~~and will work to~~ promote energy efficient lighting practices and systems, and reduce adverse impacts of outdoor lightng on wildlife and human health. Lightng should be used only where needed, directed and shielded, no brighter than necessary, controlled during off-hours, and of warmer colors where possible. 

(b) _Applicability._ Lighting standards shall apply to all new uses including commercial, industrial, public and residential development, all new and pre-existng dusk-to-dawn utility/security lights, and all new street lighting. To the extent i regulated by this section, all existing outdoor lights or lighting systems nstalled prior to the adoption of this section, shall be treated as nonconforming uses pursuant to secton 78-657 with the following exceptions: 

(1) When a vehicular canopy is renovated at a cost which exceeds 50 percent of the value of the structure or is replaced in its entirety, all lighting attached to the new or renovated canopy must comply with subsection (e). 

~~(2) When all the light fxtures of an assembly or group (such as, all the fxtures lightng a loading area or all the fxtures lightng one facade of a building) are replaced, the new lightng must comply with subsecton (e).~~ 

(3) All pre-existing non-cutof metal halide or high pressure sodium dusk-to-dawn utility/security lights shall conform to the provisions of subsection (e) ~~within fve years from the date this secton was adopted.~~
{6}------------------------------------------------
_Figure X: Example of a prohibited metal halide dusk-to-dawn security light._ 

(c) _Exemptions._ The following are not regulated by the lighting standards set forth in this section: 

(1) Lighting for single-family residential ~~use s~~ tructures, with the exception of dusk-to-dawn utility/security lights which shall be regulated pursuant to subsection (e) ~~(5)~~ . 

(2) Lighting required by federal, state, or local laws or regulations; 

(3) Seasonal displays using multiple low-wattage bulbs; 

(4) Lighting used during an emergency or by emergency services personnel or at their direction; 

(5) Temporary lighting which does not utilize the lighting types described in subsection (d)(1); 

(6) Temporary lighting used for public purposes including but not limited to highway construction and public utility repairs ~~.;~~ 

- (7) Low intensity ornamental gas fame lamps which include a solid cover over the top of the light source; 

(8) Low voltage (twelve volts or less), low watage ornamental landscape lightng, where fxtures are directed downward, and where any single light bulb does not exceed 25 lumens. 

(d) _Prohibitions._ The following lighting types are specifically prohibited: 

(1) Search lights, laser source lights, or any other similar high intensity lights except for those permitted in advance as required in subsection (f)(5) to be used on a temporary basis; 

(2) Lighting that is oriented upward or outward, and any light which is not a cutof or full cutof light fxture, except as otherwise provided for in this sectio ~~n:;~~ 

(3) Lighting that could be confused for a traffic control device; 

(4) A suspended string of lights, consisting of individual lamps larger than 45 lumens for LED bulbs, or 25 lumens per incandescent bulb, unless used only for temporary seasonal decorations ~~.;~~ 

(5) Animated signs which use fashing or intermitent lights, sound, color changes, video, or other means to give moton to, or bring atenton to the sign or the message on it, except that electronic message signs shall be regulated under secton (e)(12). 

## (e) _Lighting specifications._ 

- (1) _Intensity._ 

   - ~~a.       Unless otherwise specifed, the maximum light level at any point shall be 0.75 footcandles at any property line, or 3.0 footcandles at any public street right-of-way.~~ 

   - ~~b. The maximum average light level for the developed area of the project to be permited shall be 4.5 footcandles.~~ 

   - ~~c. The maximum ratng for LED lights shall be 4.300 degrees Kelvin.~~ 

      - a. _Footcandles._ Footcandle light limits shall be as follows: 

**Table X. Maximum footcandles Locaton Max. footcandle** Non-residental property lines 0.75 Residental property lines 0.5
{7}------------------------------------------------
|Public street rights-of-way|3.0|
|---|---|
|Outdoor parking, loading and storage|6.0|
|Total Developed area<br>ii|4.5 max. avg.|
|Illumination of vertical surfaces|5.0 max. avg.|
|Outdoor sales/display areas<br>i|25 max. avg.|
|Outdoor sports fields, courts, performance areas|60 fc max. avg.|
|Electronic message displays (EMD)|0.3|



i ~~.c. b~~ . _Kelvin ratng._ The maximum color temperature rating for LED lights shall be as follows: 

|**Table X. Maximum Kelvin ratings**|**Table X. Maximum Kelvin ratings**|**Table X. Maximum Kelvin ratings**|
|---|---|---|
|All lights,<br>except those<br>listed below<br>|ZONING: OU, RLD, BDM, R1, R2, R3|**i**<br>3,000 degrees kelvin|
||ZONING: NS, CS, EMP, CR, PS<br>i|4,000 degrees kelvin|
|Beneath vehicular gas station canopies, outdoor sports<br>fields and courts, and performance areas||5,000 degrees kelvin|
|i<br>Internally-lit, backlit signs/lettering, and Electronic<br>Message Displays||Exempt from Kelvin limits when light<br>source is entirely within a non-<br>transparent enclosure|



(2) _Luminaire type._ All lighting luminaires to be installed on a permanent basis shall consist of full cutoff or ~~and~~ partal cutoff fixtures, unless otherwise stipulated by this section. Full cutoff fixtures shall be ~~utlized~~ required where the luminaire has more than a 1,250 lumen output, unless as otherwise stipulated by this section. Lighting fixtures to be utilized on a temporary basis and as permitted through subsection (f)(5) shall be exempt from this requirement. 

_Figure X. Lightng fxture cutof types_ a) All light fxtures shall be aimed and shielded so that the direct illuminaton shall be confned to the property boundaries of the light source. Lightng shall not be aimed onto adjacent propertes except in cases of shared parking or for communal infrastructure of phased or common developments on adjacent parcels.
{8}------------------------------------------------
(3) _Height_ . The maximum mounted height of light fxtures above lowest adjacent grade shall be as follows: 

|||**Table X: Maximum Mounted Exterior**|**Table X: Maximum Mounted Exterior**|**Light Fixture Height**|**Light Fixture Height**|**Light Fixture Height**|**Light Fixture Height**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
||||**Fixture type or use**||**Maximum mounted height**|||
||Dusk-to-dawn, security, and food lights||||||15 feet|
||Electronic message displays (EMD)||||||10 feet|
||Outdoor sports courts<br>||||||50 feet|
||Outdoor sports felds and performance areas<br>||||||80 feet|
||Parking lot and street lightng<br>||||||37 feet|
||<br>|||||||
||Sign lightng||||||20 feet|
||Site lightng||Individual apartment balconies|||Must|N/A<br>be full cutof|
||||All other types||||30 feet|



~~(3)~~ (5) _Accent and facade_ lighting _._ Accent or facade lighting shall meet the following standards ~~be directed toward at the face of the building or structure.~~ 

a. Lighting fixtures shall be directed downward ~~rather than upward~~ and shall be full cutoff fixtures, or shall be fully shielded and directly facing the structure or sign surface to be illuminated. ~~The zoning administrator or the board of adjustment may waive this requirement in cases where it is impractcal.~~ 

b. ~~Placement of low watage fxtures with shields (as needed) close to the building to graze the facade is required to minimize refected light from windows and other surfaces.~~ Fixtures placed close to windows and other refectve surfaces shall be low watage and include shields to minimize refectons. Lightng of any porton of a structure with a polished or glass exterior surface is prohibited. 

## ~~(4)~~ (6) _Vehicular canopies._ 

(a) ~~A~~ reas under a vehicular canopy shall have a maximum average horizontal illuminance of 30 footcandles. All lighting under the canopy, including but not limited to, luminaires mounted on the lower surface of the canopy and auxiliary lighting within signage or panels over the pumps, is to be included in the calculation. Lighting under vehicular canopies shall be designed so as not to create glare off-site. Acceptable methods include one or more of the following: 

~~a.~~ (i) Recessed fixture incorporating a lens cover that is either recessed or flush with the bottom surface (ceiling) of the vehicular canopy that provides a full cutoff or fully shielded light distribution. 

~~b.~~ (ii) Surface mounted fixture incorporating a flat glass that provides a full cutoff or fully shielded light distribution.
{9}------------------------------------------------
- (b) When replacing the internally lit signage lightng on a vehicular canopy that is on a property that has pre-existng, non-conforming lightng, signage lightng and canopy wrap lightng shall only be - - allowed to be replaced on one street facing side of the canopy. Internally lit signage shall be removed from all other sides of the canopy unless the entre site is brought into compliance. 

~~(5)~~ (7) _Dusk-to-dawn utilit_ ~~_y/,_~~ _security, and food lights._ Dusk-to-dawn utility ~~_/,_~~ _security and food_ lights shall ~~have a maximum ratng of 9,500 lumens, shall be mounted at a maximum height of 25 feet above the lowest adjacent grade, and must b~~ e full cutoff fixtures, and must be moton-actvated and designed to turn of afer no more than 20 minutes afer actvaton. The Zoning Administrator may waive the requirement for motonactvaton in cases where the type of use requires specifc security features on the property due to a demonstrable, signifcant public health or safety interest. 

~~(6)~~ (8) _Street_ lighting _._ ~~a.~~ ~~_Alignment._ S~~ treet lighting on newly constructed streets shall be alternately staggered on each side of the street. The zoning administrator or the board of adjustment may waive this requirement in cases where it is impractical. All street lightng must consist of full cutof fxtures. 

~~_b. Intensity._ Newly installed street lightng luminaires shall meet the following standards:~~ 

~~1. Individual luminaires erected in residental areas shall have a ratng which does not exceed 9,500 lumens.~~ 

~~2. Individual luminaires erected in commercial and industrial areas shall have a ratng which does not exceed 50,000 lumens.~~ 

~~c.~~ ~~_Luminaire type._ All street lightng must consist of full cutof fxtures. If the luminaire is a post mounted decoratve fxture mounted at a height of no more than 18 feet above the lowest adjacent grade, the luminare may consist of a cutof fxture if the zoning administrator or board of adjustment determines that appropriate glare reducton measures are taken.~~ 

~~(7)~~ ~~_Outdoor parking, loading and storage areas._ The mountng height of all outdoor parking, loading and storage area lightng shall not exceed 37 feet above the lowest adjacent grade. The lightng of outdoor parking areas shall have a maximum average horizontal illuminance of 6.0 footcandles.~~ 

~~(8)~~ ~~_Outdoor sales/display areas._ The mountng height of all outdoor sales/display area lightng shall not exceed 37 feet above the lowest adjacent grade. The lightng of outdoor sales/display areas shall have a maximum average horizontal illuminance of 25 footcandles.~~ 

## ~~(9)~~ (11) 

~~a. The mountng height of outdoor sports feld and outdoor performance area lightng fxtures shall not exceed 80 feet from the lowest adjacent grade.~~ 

b. _Glare Control._ All outdoor sports field and outdoor performance area lighting fixtures shall be cutof or full cutof fxtures which are equipped with a glare control package (louvers, shields, or similar devices). The fixtures must be aimed so that their beams are directed and fall within the primary playing or performance area. 

c. _Hours of Operaton_ . The hours of operation for the lighting system shall coincide with ~~actve o~~ pen use of the field or performance area and any necessary maintenance thereof. ~~Lightng the feld or performance area during periods of vacancy shall be prohibited. O~~ nly areas which are open for use, or undergoing maintenance, shall be lit. 

(12) _Electronic message displays (EMD)_ .
{10}------------------------------------------------
(a) _Applicability._ The following standards shall apply to all electronic message displays which are visible from or adjacent to a public or private road, with the following exceptons: 

- (i) Outdoor Sports Field displays which directly face the feld or bleachers are exempt; 

- (ii) Displays located along interior development roads which are not visible outside of the development are exempt; 

- (iii) Public schools displays shall be allowed in all zoning districts; (iv) Government Protectve Service displays shall be allowed in all zoning districts, and shall be exempt from the limit on rate of change. 

(b) _Locatons:_ EMD's are prohibited in the OU, R-LD, BDM, R-1, R-2, and R-3 zoning districts. 

(c) _Dimensions_ . A maximum of one (1) electronic message sign shall be allowed per property and the electronic display shall not exceed 15 square feet in size. 

(d) _Setbacks_ . Signs shall be located no closer to the edge of the public road than 20 feet, and shall not be located within 100 feet from any intersecton. 

## (e) _Display_ . 

(i) _Rate of change_ . Displays shall be programmed to change no more than once per 12 hours; 

(ii) _Moton_ . Only statc text and imagery may be displayed on the sign, and shall not include animaton, video, fashing or intermitent lights, sound, color changes, or other means to give moton to the sign or message on it. Any change of the message shall be completed immediately without pauses and all parts of the message shall change simultaneously; 

- (iii) _Brightness_ . The maximum light level shall be 20 nits during non daylight hours, and 1,000 nits during daylight hours. Displays shall be equipped with a feature which automatcally adjusts the brightness of the display based on ambient conditons; 

(13) _Backlit signs and internally-lit signs and leters_ . Backlit signs, or groupings of backlit leters, shall not exceed the following total cumulatve size for the area of the sign that includes lightng: 

- a. Signs mounted on structures: 50 square feet of lit area 

- b. Pole-mounted or pylon signs: 15 square feet of lit area 

- c. Monument signs: 20 square feet of total lit area, or 5 square feet of lit area per business sign. 

_Figure X. Maximum backlit sign sizes._
{11}------------------------------------------------
## (f) _Administration and enforcement._ 

(1) Lighting plan required. A lighting plan designed and sealed by a licensed engineer shall be submitted with the application for a zoning certificate of compliance. The plan shall indicate the following: 

a. Location and mounted height of all exterior lighting on the property. 

b. A photometric plan containing the following: 

- ~~i)~~ A point-by-point footcandle array photometric plan, ~~in a printout format~~ indicating the location and aiming of all pre-existng and proposed illuminating devices is required for all lightng except those indicated in the table below: 

||||**Table X: Exterior Lightng Designs Which Are Exempt**|**Table X: Exterior Lightng Designs Which Are Exempt**|**Table X: Exterior Lightng Designs Which Are Exempt**|**Table X: Exterior Lightng Designs Which Are Exempt**|**Table X: Exterior Lightng Designs Which Are Exempt**|**Table X: Exterior Lightng Designs Which Are Exempt**|**Table X: Exterior Lightng Designs Which Are Exempt**|**Table X: Exterior Lightng Designs Which Are Exempt**|**Table X: Exterior Lightng Designs Which Are Exempt**|**Table X: Exterior Lightng Designs Which Are Exempt**|**from Photometric Plan Requirements**|**from Photometric Plan Requirements**|**from Photometric Plan Requirements**|**from Photometric Plan Requirements**|**from Photometric Plan Requirements**|**from Photometric Plan Requirements**|**from Photometric Plan Requirements**|**from Photometric Plan Requirements**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
||||||**Cutof**||||||**Max. Number of**<br>**Fixtures**|||||||||**Conditons**|
||||||||||||||||||||||
||||||||||||||||||||||
|||**Type**|||||||||||||||||||
||||||||||||||||||||||
||||||||||||||||||||||
||||||||||||||||||||||
||||||||||||||||||||||
||Backlit sign||||N/A||N/A|||Up to 2|||20 feet|||5|feet||All other types of<br>lightng on the site<br>must be legally<br>conforming.||
||||||||||||||||||||||
||Wall pack||||Full<br>cutof||50 feet|||Up to 10 total wall packs<br>in the development|||20 feet|||25 feet from<br>residental<br>PL;<br>10 feet from<br>commercial<br>PL|||Located within a<br>development<br>containing no other<br>types of communal<br>lightng, except<br>backlit signs or entry<br>signs with up to 6<br>accent lights.||
||Street light||||Full<br>cutof||250 feet|||1 light per 4 subdivision<br>lots;<br>N/A to commercial<br>developments|||25 feet||||||||
||Parking lot<br>pole light||||Full<br>cutof||100 feet|||Up to 10 total parking<br>lot pole lights in the<br>development|||||||||||
||Any mix of<br>lightng types<br>listed above||||Full<br>cutof||As listed<br>above by<br>type|||Up to 10 total lights in<br>the development|||As listed<br>above by<br>type|||As listed<br>above by<br>type|||N/A||



c. The ~~printout~~ site lightng plan shall include a printed statement that the lightng plan is in compliance with the requirements of this secton. ~~indicate compliance with the lightng specifcatons required by this secton.~~ 

d. The plan shall be accompanied by a description of the illuminating devices, fixtures, lamps, supports, reflectors, poles, raised foundations and other devices including, but not limited to,
{12}------------------------------------------------
manufacturers or electric utility catalog specification sheets and/or drawings, and ~~photometric report~~ indicating fixture classification (cutoff fixture, full cutoff fixture, etc.) must be furnished. 

e. The zoning administrator may waive the requirements for a lighting plan set forth above, provided the applicant has provided all other required information and can sufficiently demonstrate compliance with this section. If the lighting plan requirements are waived, the requirements set forth in subsection (f)(2) ~~and (f)(3) s~~ hall also not apply. 

(2) A written statement signed and sealed by a licensed engineer, which indicates that the lighting plan complies with the standards set forth herein, shall be submitted with any application for a zoning certificate of compliance that proposes permanent outdoor lighting. 

~~(3) A signed and sealed as-built drawing which demonstrates that the lightng plan described in subsecton (f)(l) and submited with the zoning certfcate of compliance applicaton was followed shall be submited for review prior to the issuance of a zoning certfcate of occupancy for the project.~~ 

~~(4)~~ (3) Light measurement technique. When a lightng afdavit is allowed in lieu of a photometric plan by the Zoning Administrator, the ~~lL~~ ight level measurements of light trespass shall be made at the property line ~~of the property~~ upon which light to be measured is being generated. Measurements shall be made at finished grade (ground level) with the light registering portion of the meter held parallel to the ground pointing up. Measurements shall be taken with a light meter that has been calibrated within the previous two years. 

~~(5)~~ (4) Permit for temporary lighting required. Applicants who wish to utilize lighting on a temporary basis ~~The~~ or lighting described in subsection (d)(1) must submit a written request to the zoning administrator. ~~zoning administrator shall have ten business days to approve or deny the permit applicaton.~~ The application shall include: 

a. The purpose of the lighting; 

b. The hours of lighting operation; 

c. Where applicable, a plan showing the extent and intensity of light trespass upon adjacent properties; 

d. Signed certification that in no case shall such lighting be directed at roadways where such lighting could pose a public safety threat to vehicular traffic; and 

e. An application ~~fee f~~ or ~~the~~ a zoning certificate of compliance ~~which shall be issued by the zoning administrator.~~ 

A permit for temporary lighting, in the form of a zoning certificate of compliance, shall be issued for an operation period of no more than 30 days. Once the permit has been issued, it may be renewed in 30-day periods for up to a total of 90 days unless the permit is for lighting as described in subsection (d)(1). If operation is to continue past the close of the 90-day period, a new permit must be applied for and obtained. Temporary lighting of the type described in subsection (d)(1) shall be event-specific and shall not be permitted for a duration of more than five (5) days. In no case shall temporary lighting be permitted on a single property, in one or in multiple locations, for more than 180 days per calendar year.
