{0}------------------------------------------------
## **ZONING MAP AMENDMENT** _**STAFF ANALYSIS Legislative Hearing**_ 

## **A. CASE** 

## ZPH2025-00022 Ramsey Rezoning 

**B. LOCATION MAP C. PROPERTY INFORMATION** 

PIN: 9639-31-9355 ADDRESS: Unaddressed on Emma Rd OWNER: Emmett Ramsey Trust ACREAGE: 1.32 acres UTILITIES: Public water, MSD Sewer ACCESS ROAD: Emma Rd. 

## **D. REZONING REQUEST** 

|**Summary:**Quinlan Matthews of Penny Cup<br>Pit Stop, on behalf of Lynne and Patsy|**Existing:**R-3 Residential|||
|---|---|---|---|
|Ramsey, has applied to rezone one (1) parcel||||
|of land further identified as PIN 9639-31-||||
|9355, from R-3 Residential to CS-|**Proposed:**CS Commercial Services|CS Commercial Services||
|Commercial Service.||||
|E. **PUBLIC NOTICE**|**Planning Board**||**Board of Commissioners**|
|Newspaper and BC website:<br>Mailed to owners within 1,000 ft:<br>Physical posting on site:<br>Hearing Date:|8-6-25<br>8-5-25<br>8-8-25<br>8-18-25||TBD|
|**F. RECOMMENDATION & SUMMARY OF CONSISTENCY REVIEW**||||



Staff recommends that the rezoning of the parcels be approved as it is **STAFF:  APPROVAL** consistent with the G.E.C recommendations from the 2043 Comprehensive Plan. 

Page **1** of **7**
{1}------------------------------------------------
## **G. SPOT ZONING & STATEMENT OF REASONABLENESS** 

|**G. SPOT ZONING & STATEMENT OF REASONABLENESS**|**G. SPOT ZONING & STATEMENT OF REASONABLENESS**|**G. SPOT ZONING & STATEMENT OF REASONABLENESS**|**G. SPOT ZONING & STATEMENT OF REASONABLENESS**|**G. SPOT ZONING & STATEMENT OF REASONABLENESS**|**G. SPOT ZONING & STATEMENT OF REASONABLENESS**|**G. SPOT ZONING & STATEMENT OF REASONABLENESS**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
||**_Spot Zoning:_ **_A zoning ordinance, or amendment, which singles out and_<br>_reclassifies a relatively small tract owned by a single person and surrounded by a_<br>_much larger area uniformly zoned, so as to impose upon the smaller tract_<br>_greater restrictions than those imposed upon the larger area, or so as to relieve_<br>_the small tract from restrictions to which the rest of the area is subjected, is_<br>_called “spot zoning.”Spot Zoning, David W. Owens, April, 2020, quotingBlades v._<br>_City of Raleigh, 280 N.C. 531, 547, 187 S.E.2d 35, 45 (1972)._||**CONSISTENT**||**POTENTIAL**<br>**SPOT**<br>**ZONING**||
||||||||
||||||||
||<br>_called “spot zoning.”Spot Zoning, David W. Owens, April, 2020, quoting_||||||
||_City of Raleigh, 280 N.C. 531, 547, 187 S.E.2d 35, 45 (1972)._||||||
||**1. Staff Analysis of spot zoning:**<br>The subject parcel is approximately 1.32 acres in size. It is adjacent to CS<br>zoning to the west, R-3 zoning to the north and east, and the City of<br>Asheville across the train tracks to the south. The parcel adjoins other R-2<br>parcels to the east that the owner also owns, and to the south. Most of the<br>nearby parcels along Emma Rd to the west and centered around the<br>intersection of Emma Rd and N Louisiana Ave are zoned CS. Staff does not<br>consider this request a spot zoning.||**X**||||
||**_Statement of Reasonableness:_**_When adopting or rejecting any petition for a_<br>_zoning map amendment, a statement analyzing the reasonableness of the_<br>_proposed rezoning shall be approved by the governing board. This statement of_<br>_reasonableness may consider, among otherfactors:_||**CONSISTENT**||||
||1. The size, physical conditions, and other attributes of the area proposed to be<br>rezoned||**X**||||
||2. The benefits and detriments to the landowners, the neighbors, and the<br>surroundingcommunity||**X**||||
||3. The relationship between the current actual and permissible development<br>on the tract and adjoining areas and the development that would be<br>permissible under theproposed amendment||**X**||||
||4. The action taken is in the public interest||**X**||||
||5. Any changed conditions warranting the amendment||**X**||||



## **H. 2043 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN CONSISTENCY** 

**PLEASE NOTE:** If a rezoning request is approved that is not consistent with the adopted comprehensive plan, the zoning amendment shall have the effect of also amending any future land use map (e.g., the Growth, Equity, and Conservation Map) in the approved plan. No additional request or application for a plan amendment shall be required per the statute. 

|**GEC CHARACTER FRAMEWORK (FUTURE LAND USE MAP):**||**CONSISTENT**|||**NOT**<br>**CONSISTENT**|**NOT**<br>**CONSISTENT**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|1. **FLUM CATEGORY DESCRIPTION**|||||||
|The proposed rezoning is consistent with the Character area description of||**X**|||||
|‘Mixed Use Neighborhood” where thisparcel is located.|||||||
|2. **WASTEWATER & POTABLE WATER TYPE**||**X**|||||



Page **2** of **7**
{2}------------------------------------------------
|The parcels are intended to be served by public water and MSD.|||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
|3. **DENSITY**<br>The proposed zoning district has a maximum density of up to 12 units an<br>acre, which is the same as the current R-3 zoning also allows 12 units per<br>acre.||**X**|||
|4. **PRIMARY AND SECONDARY LAND USES**<br>The uses allowed in the proposed zoning district include additional uses<br>which are recommended in the Character Framework for this area.||**X**|||
|**PLAN POLICIES AND ACTIONS:**||**CONSISTENT**||**NOT**<br>**CONSISTENT**|
|5. **Proximity to Transportation Corridor** _(Transportation Action 4)_<br>The parcel is located near Patton Ave, which is part of a major<br>transportation corridor running through the City of Asheville the larger<br>County.||**X**|||
|6. **Support higher density residential development near job centers and**<br>**amenities** _(Transportation Action 4)_<br>The density will not change since the allowable density is the same in R-3<br>and CS.||**N/A**|||
|7. **Prioritize environmental conservation of other natural lands (such as**<br>**intact forest lands, wetlands, and other unique habitats) to protect and**<br>**increase the capacity to sustain the county’s existing biodiversity** _(Env._<br>_Conserv. Action 3)_<br>This parcel is in the Mixed Use Neighborhood area on the GEC map which is<br>designated as a growth area. There are no intact forest lands, wetlands, or<br>other unique habitat that we know of.||**N/A**|||
|8. **Prioritize the conservation of physical connections between natural**<br>**landscapes to avoid fragmentation of large forest blocks in order to**<br>**benefit wildlife migration** _(Env. Conserv. Action 3)_<br>This does not apply to this parcel.||**N/A**|||
|9. **Using the guidance of the GEC Map, work with private development**<br>**partners to bring new sites to market that have promising transportation**<br>**access, proximity to current and future economic corridors, a robust utility**<br>**service, labor draw, community synergies, etc.** _(Economic Dev. Action 2)_<br>This property has the potential to attract a larger variety of commercial,<br>mixed-use, and residential developments with the change from R-3 to CS.||**X**|||
|10. **Support the creation of place-based community gathering destinations at**<br>**Walkable Destination Centers, Mixed Use Areas, and Rural Centers**<br>**identified on the GEC Map** _(Economic Dev. Action 3)_<br>This parcel is designated as a Mixed Use Neighborhood on the GEC map. CS<br>could allow for commercial opportunities that can be accessed from the<br>surroundingneighborhood.||**X**|||



Page **3** of **7**
{3}------------------------------------------------
|11. **Integrate equity considerations into projects that improve air, water, and**<br>**land quality by utilizing tools including redlining maps of Asheville and**<br>**other municipalities and EPA’s Environmental Justice Screening Tool**<br>_(Health Action 7)_<br>The parcel is not in an area identified on the red lining map of Asheville<br>however it has a high score on the Buncombe Community Index Map<br>indicating that there may be vulnerable populations in the area of the<br>rezoning.|11. **Integrate equity considerations into projects that improve air, water, and**<br>**land quality by utilizing tools including redlining maps of Asheville and**<br>**other municipalities and EPA’s Environmental Justice Screening Tool**<br>_(Health Action 7)_<br>The parcel is not in an area identified on the red lining map of Asheville<br>however it has a high score on the Buncombe Community Index Map<br>indicating that there may be vulnerable populations in the area of the<br>rezoning.|11. **Integrate equity considerations into projects that improve air, water, and**<br>**land quality by utilizing tools including redlining maps of Asheville and**<br>**other municipalities and EPA’s Environmental Justice Screening Tool**<br>_(Health Action 7)_<br>The parcel is not in an area identified on the red lining map of Asheville<br>however it has a high score on the Buncombe Community Index Map<br>indicating that there may be vulnerable populations in the area of the<br>rezoning.|11. **Integrate equity considerations into projects that improve air, water, and**<br>**land quality by utilizing tools including redlining maps of Asheville and**<br>**other municipalities and EPA’s Environmental Justice Screening Tool**<br>_(Health Action 7)_<br>The parcel is not in an area identified on the red lining map of Asheville<br>however it has a high score on the Buncombe Community Index Map<br>indicating that there may be vulnerable populations in the area of the<br>rezoning.|11. **Integrate equity considerations into projects that improve air, water, and**<br>**land quality by utilizing tools including redlining maps of Asheville and**<br>**other municipalities and EPA’s Environmental Justice Screening Tool**<br>_(Health Action 7)_<br>The parcel is not in an area identified on the red lining map of Asheville<br>however it has a high score on the Buncombe Community Index Map<br>indicating that there may be vulnerable populations in the area of the<br>rezoning.||**Equity Analysis is**<br>**suggested for this**<br>**parcel.**|**Equity Analysis is**<br>**suggested for this**<br>**parcel.**|**Equity Analysis is**<br>**suggested for this**<br>**parcel.**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
||||||||||
|**ENVIRONMENTAL:**||||||**CONSISTENT**||**NOT**<br>**CONSISTENT**|
|**12. Steep Slope/High Elevation and Protected Ridge Overlay Districts**<br>The parcel is not within an Overlay District.||||||**X**|||
|**13. Regulated Flood Hazard Areas**<br>The parcel is not within a regulated flood hazard area.||||||**X**|||
|**14. High or Moderate Hazard Stability Areas**<br>The parcel contains an insignificant amount of moderate and high hazard<br>stabilityareas to the rear of theparcel.||||||**X**|||
||||||||||
||||||||||
|**I. NEIGHBORHOOD CONSISTENCY**||||||||**NOT**<br>**CONSISTENT**|
|**1. CURRENT DEVELOPMENT TYPES:**<br>Subject acreage has the followingadjacent zonings and uses:||||**X**|||||
|**DIRECTION**|**ZONING**|**ADJACENT USES**|||||||
|NORTH|R-3|Medium densityMHP|||||||
|EAST|R-3|Low densityresidential|||||||
|SOUTH|COA|Crowne Plaza Resort & Hotel|||||||
|WEST|CS|Commercial Vacant|||||||
|**2. Does the proposed rezoning allow for any transition between**<br>**higher density or intensity uses and lower density or intensity uses?**<br>_(Examples include medium intensity zoning between a low and high_<br>_intensity district, topographic separations, other natural features to ensure_<br>_a transition or buffer.)_<br>The rezoning of the properties from R-3 to CS could cause a increase<br>in the types and intensity of uses allowed on the property compared<br>to the current zoning. R-3 zoning is intended for low to medium<br>density housing. CS allows for higher intensity commercial uses. The<br>public rights-of-way provide transitions between proposed CS and<br>neighboring R-3.||||**X**|||||



Page **4** of **7**
{4}------------------------------------------------
## **3. Are the uses allowed in the proposed zoning district compatible with the existing uses in the area?** 

Much of the land along the road outside the intersection of Emma Road and N Louisiana Ave is already zoned CS and the majority of the uses are commercial as well. The uses in the CS zoning district are compatible with the current uses in the area and in promixity to both residential and commercial uses inside the adjacent municipality. 

**X** 

## **4. ALLOWED DEVELOPMENT TYPES AFTER CHANGE:** 

The proposed rezoning would allow additional uses in the district that are not currently allowed. Examples of new uses: Veterinarian Clinics, Banks, Greenhouses, Kennels,  Dry cleaners, Medical clinics, Retail, Gas stations, Nightclubs/Bars, Gyms, Post Office, PUD II, Schools, Storage and Warehousing, Theaters, etc. 

## **5. DENSITY & DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS COMPARISON:** 

|**3. Are the uses allowed in the proposed zoning district compatible**<br>**with the existing uses in the area?**<br>Much of the land along the road outside the intersection of Emma<br>Road and N Louisiana Ave is already zoned CS and the majority of the<br>uses are commercial as well. The uses in the CS zoning district are<br>compatible with the current uses in the area and in promixity to both<br>residential and commercial uses inside the adjacent municipality.|**3. Are the uses allowed in the proposed zoning district compatible**<br>**with the existing uses in the area?**<br>Much of the land along the road outside the intersection of Emma<br>Road and N Louisiana Ave is already zoned CS and the majority of the<br>uses are commercial as well. The uses in the CS zoning district are<br>compatible with the current uses in the area and in promixity to both<br>residential and commercial uses inside the adjacent municipality.|**3. Are the uses allowed in the proposed zoning district compatible**<br>**with the existing uses in the area?**<br>Much of the land along the road outside the intersection of Emma<br>Road and N Louisiana Ave is already zoned CS and the majority of the<br>uses are commercial as well. The uses in the CS zoning district are<br>compatible with the current uses in the area and in promixity to both<br>residential and commercial uses inside the adjacent municipality.|**3. Are the uses allowed in the proposed zoning district compatible**<br>**with the existing uses in the area?**<br>Much of the land along the road outside the intersection of Emma<br>Road and N Louisiana Ave is already zoned CS and the majority of the<br>uses are commercial as well. The uses in the CS zoning district are<br>compatible with the current uses in the area and in promixity to both<br>residential and commercial uses inside the adjacent municipality.|**3. Are the uses allowed in the proposed zoning district compatible**<br>**with the existing uses in the area?**<br>Much of the land along the road outside the intersection of Emma<br>Road and N Louisiana Ave is already zoned CS and the majority of the<br>uses are commercial as well. The uses in the CS zoning district are<br>compatible with the current uses in the area and in promixity to both<br>residential and commercial uses inside the adjacent municipality.|**3. Are the uses allowed in the proposed zoning district compatible**<br>**with the existing uses in the area?**<br>Much of the land along the road outside the intersection of Emma<br>Road and N Louisiana Ave is already zoned CS and the majority of the<br>uses are commercial as well. The uses in the CS zoning district are<br>compatible with the current uses in the area and in promixity to both<br>residential and commercial uses inside the adjacent municipality.|**X**||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**4. ALLOWED DEVELOPMENT TYPES AFTER CHANGE:**<br>The proposed rezoning would allow additional uses in the district that are not currently allowed.<br>Examples of new uses: Veterinarian Clinics, Banks, Greenhouses, Kennels,  Dry cleaners, Medical<br>clinics, Retail, Gas stations, Nightclubs/Bars, Gyms, Post Office, PUD II, Schools, Storage and<br>Warehousing, Theaters, etc.||||||||
|**5. DENSITY & DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS COMPARISON:**||||||||
||||**Existing District:**|||**Proposed District:**||
||||**R-3 Residential**|||**CS Commercial**||
||**Min. Lot**<br>**Size**|No Public Sewer<br>Public Sewer/No<br>Water<br>Public Water & Sewer|30,000 SF<br>10,000 SF<br>6,000 SF|||30,000 SF<br>10,000 SF<br>5,000 SF||
||**Max. dwelling units per acre**||12|||12||
||**Setbacks (Front/Side/Rear)**||10/7/15 with public sewer<br>20/10/20 septic system|||10/10/10 with public sewer<br>10/10/10 septic system||
||**Max. height**||35 feet|||50 feet||
||**6. PREVIOUS ZONING ACTIONS & RELEVANT SITE HISTORY:**<br>The parcel is undeveloped, and was formerly part of City of Asheville’s ETJ.|||||||
||**J. COMPARISON OF ZONING ORDINANCE DISTRICT STATEMENT OF INTENT**|||||||
||**EXISTING ZONING DISTRICT– R-3 **<br>The R-3 Residential District is primarily intended<br>to provide locations for a variety of residential<br>development depending upon the availability of<br>public water and sewer services. Some areas<br>within the R-3 Residential District will have no<br>public water and sewer services available and<br>will thus be suitable primarily for single-family<br>residential units on individual lots and mobile<br>homes on individual lots. Other areas within the<br>district will have public water and/or sewer<br>service available and will thus be suitable for<br>higher density uses such as multifamily<br>residential units, planned unit developments,<br>and mobile homeparks. The R-3 district also||||**PROPOSED ZONING DISTRICT– CS**<br>The CS Commercial Service District is primarily<br>intended to provide suitable locations for clustered<br>commercial development to encourage the<br>concentration of commercial activity in those<br>specified areas with access to major traffic arteries, to<br>discourage strip commercial development, and to<br>allow for suitable noncommercial land uses. Such<br>locations should currently have water and sewer<br>services or be expected to have such services<br>available in the future. This CS Commercial Service<br>District may be applied to suitable areas adjacent to<br>existing commercial concentration to allow for their<br>expansion.|||



Page **5** of **7**
{5}------------------------------------------------
provides for various recreational, community service and educational uses that will complement the residential development. 

## **K. EQUITY ANALYSIS** 

**1. Buncombe County Government is utilizing an Equity Analysis Tool for certain types of planningrelated development decisions. The following is Staff’s Equity Analysis for this rezoning:** 

Based on this parcel’s ranking on the Community Index Map, this parcel is located in an equity opportunity area. This parcel is in a Census Tract that ranks at 120 out of 153. The higher the number on the index, means that that the area faces more equity challenges. Equity Opportunity Areas fall between rankings of 94-153. Here are some factors to consider that contribute to the high ranking on the Equity Index: 

- **34.7% identifying as Hispanic or Latino** 

- **26.35% Spanish spoken at home** 

- **22.42% limited English-speaking HH** 

- **$48,073 median HH income** 

The Planning Board and Board of Adjustment should take into consideration how the proposed rezoning may affect the vulnerable populations in the area. 

## **L. PLANNING BOARD RECOMMENDATION** 

## 1. BOARD BASIS FOR DECISION MAKING 

The Board must determine if there is a reasonable basis for the requested change in light of its effect on all involved including the following considerations: 

- The requested change does not directly or indirectly result in the creation of spot zoning 

- Size of the tract in question 

- Compatibility of the change with the adopted 2043 Comprehensive Plan 

- Benefits and detriments resulting from the change for the owner of the newly zoned property, their neighbors, and the surrounding community 

• Relationship between the uses envisioned under the new zoning and the uses currently present in adjacent tracts _References: Good Neighbors of South Davidson v. Town of Denton, 355 N.C. 254, 559 S.E.2d 768 (2002) Chrismon v. Guilford County, 322 N.C. 611, 370 S.E.2d 579 (1988)_ 

## **M. BOARD OPTIONS** 

The following options are available to the Board: 

   - a. Recommend approval of the proposed rezoning as it is consistent with the Buncombe County 2043 Comprehensive Plan, as presented. 

   - b. Recommend approval of a portion of the proposed rezoning as it is consitent with the Buncombe County 2043 Comprenhensive Plan. 

   - c. Recommend denial of the proposed rezoning, as presented as it is inconsistent with the Buncombe County 2043 Comprehensive Plan. 

- **N. ATTACHMENTS** 

Page **6** of **7**
{6}------------------------------------------------
• Application • Maps 

Page **7** of **7**
