{0}------------------------------------------------
**11.1.g** 

Regular Burke County Animal Advisory Board Meeting Burke County Services Building Commissioners Meeting Room 110 N. Green Street Morganton, NC 28655 April 10, 2024 5:30 pm 

## **Board Members Present:** 

- Debbie Hawkins (Chair) 

- Gwen Hood (Vice-Chair) 

- Jeff Robinson 

- Liz Boyd-Oliver 

- Denise Smith 

## **Board Members Absent:** 

- Jennifer McGrady (Secretary) 

- Gwen Stephens 

- Adam Abernathy 

## **Minutes** 

**Also Present:** Kaitlin Settlemeyer, BCAS 

## **Citizens Present:** None 

## **Call to Order** 

- At 5:31 PM Gwen Hood called the meeting to order. 

**Welcome – Mission Statement:** _The Burke County Animal Advisory Board’s primary mission is to advocate for the humane treatment of companion animals. This will be accomplished through: 1. Encouraging responsible pet ownership by promoting and protecting the health, safety and welfare of companion animals and citizens of Burke County, 2. Monitoring animal welfare groups providing care for the animals, 3. Providing support to Animal Services, 4. Partnering with rescue organizations to promote owner retention and adoptions, 5. Advising County Commissioners on best practice for improvement to the Animal Ordinance, ensuring compliance with statutes pertaining to the care and treatment of animals._ 

## **Approval of Agenda** 

Agenda was approved: Liz motioned to approve the agenda; Jeff seconded. 

## **Approval of Minutes** (March) 

March minutes were reviewed and approved; Liz made motion to approve minutes, Jeff seconded. Minutes approved. 

## **Presentation:** 

**Packet Pg. 343**
{1}------------------------------------------------
**11.1.g** 

## Monthly Animal Services Report – Presented by Kaitlin Settlemyre 

|Species:|**DOG**||
|---|---|---|
|||Count|
|3/31/24|Dogs In Shelter|171|
||||
|Intakes|||
||Injured Animal|1|
||Other|1|
||Owner Arrested|0|
||Owner Surrender -||
||Behavioral|0|
||Owner Surrender -||
||Euthanasia Request|2|
||Owner Surrender -||
||Financial||
||Owner Surrender -||
||Relocation|1|
||Owner Surrender -||
||Other|5|
||Owner Surrender -||
||Unintended Litter|10|
||Quarantine|3|
||Stray|47|
||Stray - Finder To Foster|<br>1|
||Intakes - Total Count|71|
|Dispositions|||
||Adopted|22|
||Died in Shelter|1|
||Escaped|0|
||Euthanized - Behavioral|<br>3|



2 

**Packet Pg. 344**
{2}------------------------------------------------
**11.1.g** 

|Euthanized - Feral<br>5|||
|---|---|---|
|Euthanized - Medical<br>2|||
|Other<br>0|||
|Return To Owner<br>11|||
|Transfer - Bcffa|||
|Transfer-piedmont<br>Animal Rescue|||
|Dispositions - Total<br>Count Dogs<br>44|||
||||
|Species:<br>**CAT**|Count||
|Cats in Shelter|92||
||||
|**Intakes**|||
|Other|2||
|Owner Surrender -<br>Euthanasia Request|2||
|Owner Surrender - Medical|1||
|Owner Surrender - Other|5||
|Owner Surrender -<br>Relocation|5||
|Owner Surrender -<br>Unintended Litter|9||
|Stray|17||
|Stray- Finder To Foster|3||
|Tnr|22||
|Intakes - Total Count|66||
|**Dispositions**|||
|Adopted|18||
|Adopted - Tnr|31||
|Died In Foster|0||
|Escaped|1||
|Euthanized - Medical|4||
|Euthanized - Owner Elected|0||
|Transfer - Catawba Humane|0||
|Transfer - Cincinnati Animal<br>Care|0||
|Transfer - Forsyth Humane|11||
|Dispositions - Total Count<br>Cats|65||



3 

**Packet Pg. 345**
{3}------------------------------------------------
**11.1.g** 

**==> picture [518 x 120] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Small Furry<br>Animals in<br>Shelter  2<br>Horses in<br>Shelter  2<br>03-31-24<br>TOTAL Animals in Shelter  198<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


- # foster providers N/A 

- Rescues pulling / transporting: 1 rescue pulling. 

## **New Business** 

## Complete review of consultant’s, Susan Feingold re: our Suggested Ordinance Changes 

## Definitions 

- 1) Under definition of _Adequate Space_ : will not include length of tether as the board had previously listed requirements for chaining / tethering in Sec. 6-11. Chaining and Tethering. 

- 2) Under definition of _Adequate Space_ : agreed to move the portion identifying equines’ space requirement to adequate shelter and include other livestock. 

- 3) Under _Adequate Water_ : agreed to delete “constant” since it already indicates provided and at suitable intervals 

- _4)_ Under _Aggressive Animal_ : agreed to change wording of “adjoining property” to “not on the property of the owner.” 

- _5)_ Under _Approved Rescue_ : agreed to delete this definition since it is already covered in Sec. 6-74. Adoption or euthanization of unclaimed animals. 

- _6)_ Under _At Large_ : agreed to delete “See Stray definition” 

- _7)_ Under _Community Cat program_ : agreed to add “means a program designed to handle stray cats which are captured altered and returned back to their location in order to encourage the stabilization fo the free-roaming cat population.” 

- _8)_ Under _Neglect_ : agreed to add: “Neglect is a form of animal mistreatment. Failure to provide standards of care is neglectful, and the degree of neglect may warrant the designation of animal abuse / cruelty. See Sec. 6-4 of this Chapter.” 

- _9)_ Under _Owner_ : agreed to delete the word “harboring”; agreed to change “and” to “or” 

- _10)_ Under _Secure enclosure_ : moved this definition to Sec. 6-6, (e)(a) Dangerous Dogs. 

- _11)_ Under _Stray_ : corrected the section referred to Sec. 6-9. 

- _12)_ Under _Tethering_ : added “ _See Sec. 6-11._ ” 

## Section review 

4 

**Packet Pg. 346**
{4}------------------------------------------------
**11.1.g** 

- Sec. 6-3: agreed to delete “and forfeiture to the department” since this requires a court hearing. 

   - _Hearing:_ added “Dangerous Animal Appeal Board” to clarify who holds the hearing. 

   - Corrected the Section referenced to Sec. 6-6 (d) 

   - (e) Changed “control” to “enforcement”: disagreed to change recommended section title of _Mistreatment of Animals_ to separate out neglect from Abuse / Cruelty. 

   - (f) added to “managed intake basis” “as it pertains to owner surrender.” 

Sec. 6-4. “Mistreatment of Animals” 

Disagreed regarding comment to differentiate between neglect and cruelty. 

- (10) – (13): Disagreed to not repeat standards of care on the grounds we believe it should be emphasized by repeating. 

- (a) (3) Agreed to change wording to read, “At any time after seizure,” the Burke County Animal Services Director may petition the court for the owner to relinquish…. 

Sec. 6-5. “Exotic mammals and reptiles.” 

   - (f) Agreed to delete “Failure to comply will result in a fine.” 

   - (h) Agreed to delete the word “harbor”. (all throughout the ordinance since we deleted the definition) 

- Sec. 6-6. “Dangerous dog” 

   3. Disagreed to exempt bait dogs since they may or may not be identified as dangerous. That 

      - Is up to BCAS AE. 

   - (f) Agreed to leave in identifiers for a secure enclosure for a dangerous dog. 

   - (g) Agreed to add to “The owner of a dangerous dogs must provide proof that the identified dog has been spayed or neutered, or proof of a scheduled alteration appointment within 

      - fourteen days of the dangerous dog designation, or within fourteen days of the hearing appeal verdict.” 

Sec. 6-9. .”Handling of stray, at large, or abandoned animals” 

   - Agreed to delete first line, “For this section, “impounded” …. 

   - (g) Agreed to leave alone as BCAS will determine whether the animal is appropriate for foster or 

   - Transferred to an approved rescue group. 

- Sec. 6-10. “Animal advisory board.” 

5 

**Packet Pg. 347**
{5}------------------------------------------------
**11.1.g** 

The consultant suggested not identifying an at large breeder or large animal owner for appointment slots. This is something the Board of Commissioners decided. 

- Sec. 6-11. Chaining and Tethering. 

Agreed to add letters to lines (a) – (q) 

- Sec. 6-33. “Report and confinement…” 

Agreed to delete (b); added “After reviewing the circumstances of the particular case, under the direction of the Health Department, Burke County Animal Services may allow the owner to confine the animal on the owner’s property.” 

Sec. 6-72. “Notice to owner.” 

Consultant questioned if the “five-day impoundment” had been changed to three. This only applies to euthanization and this was in the original ordinance. The AAB had not suggested changing this. 

Sec. 6-73. “Reclamation by owner.” 

Agreed to leave sentence in but deleted the first word “Typically,” 

Agreed to move this first sentence as corrected to Sec. 6-114. ”Animals creating a nuisance.” 

Agreed to change wording in (d) to read, “The owner will be responsible for paying the assigned fees to reclaim their animal.” 

Agreed to delete last sentence of (h) 

Sec. 6-74. “Adoption or euthanization of unclaimed animals.” 

Agreed to delete (3) 

(4) Consultant questioned the five day stray hold again. This is only in regards to euthanizing so we did not change. 

Sec. 6-114. “Animals creating a nuisance.” 

Agreed to add “written” to complaint notice so that the public can either call to lodge a complaint or submit in writing. 

Agreed to leave in the last line of this section pertaining to reminding the public that the animal may be seized and impounded if found at large. 

Sec. 6-131. “General enforcement” 

Agreed to change (d.) to read, “All offenses after fourth, $300.00 penalty per incident or up to 30 days in jail. 

Agreed to delete “+ and boarding fees” for sterilized, micro-chipped animals and adding “+ boarding fees” to sterilized, non-micro-chipped animals 

These fees will be suggested as part of the Fee Schedule Section. 

6 

**Packet Pg. 348**
{6}------------------------------------------------
**11.1.g** 

Consultant questioned (6) and (b). These were both in the original ordinance. The AAB did not change these. 

All of the above items were voted on and approved unanimously. 

**Gwen Hood made the motion to approve changes. Liz seconded. Approved.** 

## **Old Business** 

– Cases updates 

- Diane Mangrum case – dismissed due to Pete not being petitioned by the DA to present. 

- Julie Sherrill – found guilty for nine of the 23 misdemeanor charges for animal cruelty. Sentenced to 1 year probation. Cannot own animals during the probation. Appealing. Continued. 

- March Hoarding Case – Charges dismissed with agreement to not own but 1 altered animal 

- October Cruelty Cases – Spring Meadows 8 emaciated pit bulls (Yates), no court date; Scott Road (9 cats in trailer, 1 deceased)charged but court date set; Melvin Nicely not served – dog hit by car; Settlemyer Road, cats abandoned in trailer. 

- 2 cruelty cases passed on to Sheriff’s dept (cat thrown, Pigeon case) 

Staffing – fully staffed; Administrative Spec. Katie Liammaytry 

Program Needs - working with Foundation, grants, TNR program donation funded; pet food pantry is 

low 

**New Shelter Update:** Architects doing the construction drawing for the new services center; June / July groundbreaking of new animal services center. 

**Foundation Report:** Kay reported the van is in the process of being fixed/ insulated / upgraded / wrapped. Van project will be complete. Some of the expenses were funded by a grant. Woofstock May 19[th] at Silver Fork Winery; working on replacing the treasurer position; softball fundraiser in June. Contributing $250 to the pet food bank monthly. Kaitlin and Elizabeth will be recognized at the next Commissioners meeting; Elizabeth for completing a certificate in management leadership and Kaitlin for completing the executive leadership certification. Debbie was nominated for the 2024 Governor’s Volunteer Service Award. 

**Animal Enforcement Report** : no report 

## **Public Comment** 

Each citizen allotted 3 minutes to present their comments 

**Other Discussion Items –** 

7 

**Packet Pg. 349**
{7}------------------------------------------------
**11.1.g** 

**Next Regular Meeting** May 8, 2024, at 5:30 p.m. 

## **Meeting was adjourned at: 7:17 p.m.** 

Prepared by: Debbie Hawkins 

Signed: 

Debbie Hawkins Burke County Animal Advisory Board Chair 

May 8, 2024 

8 

**Packet Pg. 350**
