{0}------------------------------------------------
**6.3.c** 

|**Trail Design & Engineering RFQ**|||
|---|---|---|
|**Ranking Committee Scoring**|**Firm**||
|**S. Chabaane**|**DbD**|**Alta**|
|Design development and experience with similarprojects, generate construction docs.|29.0|34.0|
|On time and on budget. Firm's reputation. Geographic familiarty.|23.0|21.0|
|Team membersqualities- displines,experience,certification,demonstrated abilities.|15.0|19.0|
|Proven experiencepermittingincludingNCDOT and regulatoryconstraints.|15.0|12.0|
|Experience withprovidingservices togovernment entities.|5.0|5.0|
|**Sub-Total**|**87.0**|**91.0**|
|**OVNCST(B. Lindsey)**|**DbD**|**Alta**|
|Design development and experience with similarprojects, generate construction docs.|30.0|25.0|
|On time and on budget. Firm's reputation. Geographic familiarty.|20.0|15.0|
|Team membersqualities- displines,experience,certification,demonstrated abilities.|15.0|10.0|
|Proven experiencepermittingincludingNCDOT and regulatoryconstraints.|10.0|5.0|
|Experience withprovidingservices togovernment entities.|5.0|5.0|
|**Sub-Total**|**80.0**|**60.0**|
|**F3ST(H. Cotton)**|**DbD**|**Alta**|
|Design development and experience with similarprojects, generate construction docs.|32.0|33.0|
|On time and on budget. Firm's reputation. Geographic familiarty.|20.0|22.0|
|Team membersqualities- displines,experience,certification,demonstrated abilities.|20.0|17.0|
|Proven experiencepermittingincludingNCDOT and regulatoryconstraints.|14.0|13.0|
|Experience withprovidingservices togovernment entities.|5.0|5.0|
|**Sub-Total**|**91.0**|**90.0**|
|**P. Minter**|**DbD**|**Alta**|
|Design development and experience with similarprojects, generate construction docs.|25.0|35.0|
|On time and on budget. Firm's reputation. Geographic familiarty.|20.0|20.0|
|Team membersqualities- displines,experience,certification,demonstrated abilities.|15.0|20.0|
|Proven experiencepermittingincludingNCDOT and regulatoryconstraints.|15.0|10.0|
|Experience withprovidingservices togovernment entities.|5.0|5.0|
|**Sub-Total**|**80.0**|**90.0**|
|**T. McGee**|**DbD**|**Alta**|
|Design development and experience with similarprojects, generate construction docs.|32.0|35.0|
|On time and on budget. Firm's reputation. Geographic familiarty.|25.0|23.0|
|Team membersqualities- displines,experience,certification,demonstrated abilities.|20.0|20.0|
|Proven experiencepermittingincludingNCDOT and regulatoryconstraints.|15.0|12.0|
|Experience withprovidingservices togovernment entities.|5.0|3.0|
|**Sub-Total**|**97.0**|**93.0**|
|**B. Nieft**|**DbD**|**Alta**|
|Design development and experience with similarprojects, generate construction docs.|35.0|35.0|
|On time and on budget. Firm's reputation. Geographic familiarty.|20.0|25.0|
|Team membersqualities- displines,experience,certification,demonstrated abilities.|20.0|20.0|
|Proven experiencepermittingincludingNCDOT and regulatoryconstraints.|15.0|13.0|
|Experience withprovidingservices togovernment entities.|5.0|5.0|
|**Sub-Total**|**95.0**|**98.0**|
|**B. Kirkley**|**DbD**|**Alta**|
|Design development and experience with similarprojects, generate construction docs.|30.0|32.0|
|On time and on budget. Firm's reputation. Geographic familiarty.|23.0|22.0|
|Team membersqualities- displines,experience,certification,demonstrated abilities.|18.0|18.0|
|Proven experiencepermittingincludingNCDOT and regulatoryconstraints.|15.0|14.0|
|Experience withprovidingservices togovernment entities.|4.0|4.0|
|**Sub-Total**|**90.0**|**90.0**|
|**TOTAL**|620.0|612.0|
|**Average Score**|88.6|87.4|



**Packet Pg. 169**
