{0}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**J A N U A R Y  2 0 2 0** 

# H E A L T H Y  N O R T H  C A R O L I N A 

A  P A T H  T O W A R D  H E A L T H 

FUNDED BY THE BLUE CROSS AND BLUE SHIELD OF NORTH CAROLINA FOUNDATION, FUNDED BY THE BLUE CROSS AND BLUE SHIELD OF NORTH CAROLINA FOUNDATION, THE DUKE ENDOWMENT, AND THE KATE B. REYNOLDS CHARITABLE TRUSTTHE DUKE ENDOWMENT, AND THE KATE B. REYNOLDS CHARITABLE TRUST 

NC 

**==> picture [296 x 67] intentionally omitted <==**

_In partnership with_ 

Division of Public Health 

**Packet Pg. 221**
{1}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

The North Carolina Institute of Medicine (NCIOM) is a nonpolitical source of analysis and advice on important health issues facing the state. The NCIOM convenes stakeholders and other interested people from across the state to study these complex issues and develop workable solutions to improve health care in North Carolina. 

The full text of this report is available online at: www.nciom.org 

**North Carolina Institute of Medicine** 

Keystone Office Park 630 Davis Drive, Suite 100 919.445.6150 

## **Suggested Citation** 

North Carolina Institute of Medicine. Healthy North Carolina 2030: A Path Toward Health. Morrisville, NC: North Carolina Institute of Medicine; 2020. 

Funded by the Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina Foundation, The Duke Endowment, and the Kate B. Reynolds Charitable Trust. 

Any opinion, finding, conclusion, or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the Task Force and do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina Foundation, The Duke Endowment, and the Kate B. Reynolds Charitable Trust. 

## **Credits** 

Report design and layout: Kayleigh Creech, Laser Image Printing & Marketing 

## **Dedication** 

This report is published in memory of Eleanor Howell, MS, former Director of the State Center for Health Statistics. 

## TABLE OF CONTENTS 

- 4 **ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS** 

- 6 

## **TASK FORCE AND WORK GROUP MEMBERS** 

- 16 

   - **ACRONYMS** 

- 17 

## **EXECUTIVE SUMMARY** 

- 21 

   - **CHAPTER 1** Introduction 

- 27 

**CHAPTER 2** 

- Background 

**CHAPTER 3** 

- 33 

Social & Economic Factors 

**CHAPTER 4** 

- 51 

Physical Environment 

- 63 

   - **CHAPTER 5** Health Behaviors 

- 81 

**CHAPTER 6** 

Clinical Care 

- 93 

   - **CHAPTER 7** Health Outcomes 

- 100 

   - **CONCLUSION** 

- 101 

   - **REFERENCES** 

- 117 

**APPENDIX A** 

Healthy North Carolina 2030 Indicators and Data 

- 121 

## **APPENDIX B** 

## Healthy North Carolina 2030 Process Details 

## **APPENDIX C** 

- 125 

Detailed Community Session Input 

**==> picture [191 x 171] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 222** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 

3
{2}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

## ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 

The North Carolina Institute of Medicine’s (NCIOM) Healthy North Carolina 2030 Task Force was convened in January 2019. Funding for the Task Force was provided by the Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina Foundation, The Duke Endowment, and the Kate B. Reynolds Charitable Trust. 

The Task Force was co-chaired by Ronny Bell, PhD, MS, Professor and Chair of the Department of Public Health and Associate Director of the Center for Health Disparities, East Carolina University; John F.A.V Cecil, MIM, President, Biltmore Farms, LLC; Laura Gerald, MD, MPH, President, Kate B. Reynolds Charitable Trust; and Elizabeth Cuervo Tilson, MD, MPH, State Health Director and Chief Medical Officer, North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services (NC DHHS). The Work Groups were co-led by: Social and Economic Factors – Wanda Boone, PhD, Executive Director of Together for Resilient Youth and Donnie Varnell, Special Law Enforcement Projects Consultant, North Carolina Harm Reduction Coalition and Investigator, Dare County Sheriff’s Office; Physical Environment – Myron Floyd, PhD, MS, Professor and Head, Department of Parks, Recreation, and Tourism Management, North Carolina State University and Larry Michael, REHS, MPH, Chief, Environmental Health Section, Division of Public Health, NC DHHS; Health Behaviors – Susan Kansagra, MD, MBA, Section Chief, Chronic Disease and Injury Section, Division of Public Health, NC DHHS and Carrie Rosario, DrPH, MPH, CHES, Associate Professor and Associate Department Chair, Department of Public Health Education, School of Health and Human Sciences, University of North Carolina-Greensboro; and Clinical Care – Randy Jordan, JD, MPA, Chief Executive Officer, North Carolina Association of Free and Charitable Clinics and Kia Williams, MD, MSPH, Associate Medical Director, BlueCross BlueShield of North Carolina. Their leadership and experience were important to the success of the Task Force’s work. 

The NCIOM would like to thank the members of the Task Force, Work Groups, and Steering Committee who gave freely of their time and expertise for this important work. The Steering Committee members provided expert guidance and content, helped develop meeting agendas, and identified expert speakers. For the complete list of Task Force, Work Group, and Steering Committee members, please see **Pages 6-15** of this report. In particular, Kathy Dail, Director, Community Health Assessment Program, Division of Public Health, NC DHHS, coordinated HNC 2030 work with NCIOM staff on behalf of the Division of Public Health. 

The NCIOM would also like to thank the individuals who attended the eight Community Input Sessions in Greenville, Henderson, Pembroke, Jacksonville, Charlotte, Greensboro, Cherokee, and Marion, NC. The 340 participants in these meetings represented 71 of the state’s 100 counties and provided vital input and feedback in the health indicator selection process. 

The Healthy North Carolina 2030 Task Force heard presentations from multiple experts through the course of the Task Force work. We would like to thank the following people for sharing their expertise and experiences with the Task Force (positions listed are as of the date of their presentation): 

Donyel Barber, Community Centered Health Coordinator, Family Practice of Gaston County; Ronny Bell, PhD, MEd, MS, Professor and Chair, Department of Public Health, East Carolina University; Battle Betts, MPA, Health Director, Albermarle Regional Health Services; Deitre Epps, MS, Results Based Accountability Consultant and CEO/Founder, R.A.C.E. for Equity; Pam Silberman, JD, DrPH, Director, Executive Doctoral Program in Health Leadership, Gillings School of Global Public Health, University of North Carolina – Chapel Hill; Elizabeth Cuervo Tilson, MD, MPH, State Health Director and Chief Medical Officer, NC 

DHHS; Josie Williams, Coordinator, Collaborative Cottage Grove, Gaston Family Health Services; and Cornell Wright, MPA, Executive Director, Office of Minority Health and Health Disparities, NC DHHS. 

Staff of several state agencies and organizations provided essential data for the health indicator selection process and production of the final report. These staff included Eleanor Howell, MS, Director of the State Center for Health Statistics (SCHS), who provided vital data expertise to the Task Force and Work Groups in the selection of health indicators; as well as Matt Avery, MA, Supervisor, Vital Statistics, SCHS, Division of Public Health, NC DHHS; James Cassell, Head of Survey Operations, SCHS, Division of Public Health, NC DHHS; Jim Martin, MS, Director of Policy and Programs, NC Tobacco Prevention and Control Branch, Division of Public Health, NC DHHS; Evan Galloway, MPS, Research Associate, Randy Randolph, MRP, Programmer/Analyst, and Julie Spero, MSPH, Director, North Carolina Health Professions Data System,  Cecil G. Sheps Center for Health Services Research; Victoria Mobley, MD, MPH, Medical Epidemiologist and Erika Samoff, MPH, PhD, HIV/STD/Hepatitis Surveillance Manager, Communicable Disease Branch, Division of Public Health, NC DHHS; Amy Powell Moman, Business Systems Analyst, School Research, Data, and Reporting, North Carolina Department of Public Instruction; and Les Spell, Data and Policy Consultant, NC Department of Public Instruction. NCIOM also received consultation from Andrew Brod, PhD, Senior Research Fellow, Center for Business and Economic Research, Bryan School of Business and Economics, University of North Carolina at Greensboro. 

In addition to the above individuals, the staff of the NCIOM contributed to the Task Force’s work and the development of this report. Adam J. Zolotor, MD, DrPH, President and CEO, guided the work of the Task Force. Berkeley Yorkery, MPP, Associate Director, helped guide the work of the Task Force and made contributions to the writing of this report. Brieanne Lyda-McDonald, MSPH, Project 

Director, served as Project Director for the Task Force and was primary author of the final Task Force report. Erin Bennett, BA, NCIOM intern, researched and wrote many sections of the final Task Force report. Kaitlin Phillips, MS, edited the final Task Force report and provided social media publicity for the Task Force. Key staff support was also provided by Kisha Markham, BS, Administrative Assistant and Don Gula, MBA, Director of Administrative Operations. Former staff member, Chloe Donohoe, BS, served as Research Assistant for the project. Tibaria Alnouri, Summer Intern, researched and wrote several sections of the final Task Force report. 

**==> picture [174 x 171] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 223** 

4 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

5 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{3}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

## **M E M B E R  L I S T** 

## HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

**TASK FORCE CO-CHAIRS** 

## **Vickie Bradley, RN, MPH** 

_Secretary, Public Health and Human Services_ Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians 

**Ronny Bell, PhD, MS** _Professor and Chair_ Department of Public Health East Carolina University 

**Alisahah Cole, MD** 

_Clinical Care Work Group Representative Vice President and System Medical Director of Community Health_ Atrium Health 

**John “Jack” F.A.V. Cecil, MIM** _President_ Biltmore Farms, LLC **Laura Gerald, MD, MPH** _President_ Kate B. Reynolds Charitable Trust 

**John Eller, MBA** _Social and Economic Work Group Representative County Manager_ Davie County 

**Vanessa Ervin, MBA** _President/CEO_ Carobell 

**Elizabeth Cuervo Tilson, MD, MPH** _State Health Director & Chief Medical Officer_ North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Myron Floyd, PhD, MS** _Co-Leader: Physical Environment Work Group Professor and Head, Department of Parks, Recreation, and Tourism Management_ North Carolina State University 

**TASK FORCE MEMBERS** 

**Sheryl Bedno, MPH, MS, MD, DrPH** _Director, Department of Public Health_ Womack Army Medical Center, Fort Bragg 

**Ophelia Garmon-Brown, MD** 

**Amy Belflower Thomas, MHA, MSPH, CPH** _Director, Community Assessment and Strategy_ North Carolina Institute of Public Health 

_Social and Economic Work Group Representative Chief Community Wellness & Health Equity Executive_ Novant Health 

**Nicole Hiegl** _Director_ High County Area Agency on Aging 

**Battle Betts, MPA** _Health Director_ Albemarle Regional Health Services 

**Kendra Johnson, MPA** _Executive Director_ Equality NC 

**Leslie Boney** _Executive Director_ Institute for Emerging Issues North Carolina State University 

**Randy Jordan, JD, MPA** _Co-Leader: Clinical Care Work Group CEO_ North Carolina Association of Free and Charitable Clinics 

**Wanda Boone, PhD** _Co-Leader: Social & Economic Factors Work Group Executive Director_ Together for Resilient Youth (TRY) 

**==> picture [105 x 111] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [45 x 55] intentionally omitted <==**

## **Susan Kansagra, MD, MBA** 

_Co-Leader: Health Behaviors Work Group Section Chief, Chronic Disease and Injury Section_ Division of Public Health North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Jay Leggette** _Grassroots Community Health Coordinator_ The Stimulus 

**Magbis Love, MHR** 

_Health/Outreach Coordinator_ Levine Cancer Institute 

**Jim Martin, MS** _Health Behaviors Work Group Representative Director of Policy and Programs_ NC Tobacco Prevention and Control Branch Division of Public Health North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Andrea Martinez** _Advocate/Investigator_ Disability Rights NC 

## **M. Leah Mayo, MPH, MCHES** 

_Physical Environment Work Group Representative Center for Healthy Communities Coordinator_ College of Health and Human Services University of North Carolina Wilmington 

**Sara McEwen, MD, MPH** _Health Behaviors Work Group Representative Executive Director_ Governor’s Institute 

**Larry Michael, REHS, MPH** _Co-Leader: Physical Environment Work Group Chief, Environmental Health Section_ Division of Public Health North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

## **Sandy Mort, MS, PhD** 

_Physical Environment Work Group Representative Environmental Toxicologist_ North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality 

**Danya Perry, MA** _Social and Economic Work Group Representative Equitable Economic Development Manager_ Greater Raleigh Chamber of Commerce 

**Carrie Rosario, DrPH, MPH, CHES** _Co-Leader: Health Behavior Work Group Associate Professor and Associate Department Chair_ School of Health and Human Sciences Department of Public Health Education University of North Carolina at Greensboro 

**Margaret “Maggie” Sauer, MHA, MS** 

_Clinical Care Work Group Representative Director, Office of Rural Health_ North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Jeffrey Spade, MHA, FACHE** 

_Rural Healthcare Consultant_ 

**Donnie Varnell** 

Co- _Leader_ : Social and Economic Work Group 

_Investigator_ Dare County Sheriff’s Office Special Law Enforcement Projects Consultant North Carolina Harm Reduction Coalition 

**Kia Williams, MD, MSPH** 

_Co-Leader: Clinical Care Work Group Associate Medical Director_ BlueCross BlueShield of North Carolina 

**Ciara Zachary, PhD, MPH** _Health_ Program Director NC Child 

**Packet Pg. 224** 

6 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

7 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{4}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

## **M E M B E R  L I S T** 

## SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC FACTORS WORK GROUP 

**John Eller, MBA** _Task Force Member County Manager_ Davie County 

**CO-LEADERS** 

**Wanda Boone, PhD** _Executive Director_ Together for Resilient Youth (TRY) 

**Brian Ellerby, MSPH** _Director of Financial Analysis and Planning_ Opportunities Industrialization Center, Inc. of Rocky Mount 

**Donnie Varnell** _Investigator_ Dare County Sheriff’s Office _Special Law Enforcement Projects Consultant_ North Carolina Harm Reduction Coalition 

**Ellen Essick, PhD** _Section Chief_ , NC Healthy Schools North Carolina Department of Public Instruction 

**WORK GROUP MEMBERS** 

**Charmaine Fuller Cooper, MPA** _Director_ AARP Advocacy 

**Carolyn Allison, MPH** _CEO_ Charlotte Community Health Clinic 

**Ophelia Garmon-Brown, MD** _Task Force Member Chief Community Wellness & Health Equity Executive_ Novant Health 

**Shorlette Ammons** _Community Food Systems Outreach Coordinator_ Center for Environmental Farming Systems 

**Mackenzie Harkey, MSPH** _Wellness Coordinator_ Compass Group 

**Kia Baker** _Executive Director_ Southeast Raleigh Promise 

**Tara Kenchen, JD** _President and CEO_ North Carolina Community Development Initiative 

**David Beck, BA** _Director of Public Policy and Media Relations_ Self-Help Credit Union 

**Andrea Korte** _Vice President, Continuing Education & Workforce Development_ Sandhills Community College 

**Michael Becketts, MSW, MS, MEd** _Assistant Secretary for Human Services_ North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Roger Manus, JD** _Chair_ Governor’s Advisory Council on Aging _Director_ Senior Law Clinic, Campbell University 

**Olivia Collier, MPA** _Appalachian Regional Commission Program Manager_ Appalachian Regional Commission 

**Henry Crews** _Executive Director_ Green Rural Redevelopment 

**Danya Perry, MA** _Task Force Member Equitable Economic Development Manager_ Greater Raleigh Chamber of Commerce 

**==> picture [105 x 111] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [45 x 55] intentionally omitted <==**

**Rebecca Planchard, MPP** _Senior Early Childhood Policy Advisor_ North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services Office of the Secretary 

**LaVerne Reid, PhD** _Professor, Department of Public Health Education_ College of Behavioral & Social Sciences North Carolina Central University 

**Micki Sager, BS** _Vice President Director of Resourceful Communities_ The Conservation Fund 

**Stacie Saunders, MPH** _Health Director_ Alamance County 

**Stephen J. Sills, PhD** _Professor of Sociology Director, Center for Housing and Community Studies_ University of North Carolina Greensboro 

**David Sousa, JD, MBA** _Chief Operating Officer & General Counsel_ Curi, a Medical Mutual Company 

**Vivian St. Juste-Schweizer, MPA** _Former Executive Director_ Blue Ribbon Commission on Prevention of Youth Violence _Owner_ Bridge for Resources 

**David Tillman, PhD** _Chair, Department of Public Health_ College of Pharmacy & Health Sciences Campbell University 

**Thomas Walker, PhD, MPA** _President_ Wayne Community College 

**Napoleon Wallace, MBA** _Deputy Secretary for Rural Economic Development and Workforce_ North Carolina Department of Commerce 

**Donna White, MSHE** _Deputy Director & Vice President_ North Carolina Partnership for Children 

**Patrick Woodie, JD** _President_ NC Rural Center 

**==> picture [191 x 171] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 225** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 

8 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

9
{5}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

## **M E M B E R  L I S T** 

## PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT WORK GROUP 

**Marian Johnson-Thompson, PhD** _Adjunct Professor, Department of Maternal and Child Health_ University of North Carolina - Chapel Hill _Vice Chair_ Secretary’s Environmental Justice & Equity Board 

## **CO-LEADERS** 

**Myron Floyd, PhD, MS** Professor and Head, Department of Parks, Recreation, and Tourism Management North Carolina State University 

**Lillian Koontz, MPA, REHS** _Health Director_ Davidson County 

**Larry Michael, REHS, MPH** _Chief, Environmental Health Section_ Division of Public Health North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**M. Leah Mayo, MPH, MCHES** _Task Force Member_ Center for Healthy Communities Coordinator College of Health and Human Services University of North Carolina Wilmington 

## **WORK GROUP MEMBERS** 

**Donyel Barber** _Community Centered Health Coordinator_ Gaston Family Health Services 

**William “Mack” MacDonald, MBA** _CEO_ Renaissance West Community Initiative 

**Karen Beck, DVM, PhD** _Surveillance Veterinarian, Emergency Programs Division_ North Carolina Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services 

**Sandy Mort, MS, PhD** _Task Force Member Environmental Toxicologist_ North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality 

**Shannon Binns, MPA** _Executive Director_ Sustain Charlotte 

**Michelle Nance, MPA, AICP** _Planning Director_ Centralina Council of Governments 

**Joseph Furstenberg, MPA** _Transportation Consultant, Bicycle and Pedestrian Division_ North Carolina Department of Transportation 

**Mai Nguyen, PhD, MA** _Associate Professor & Interim MURAP Program Director, Department of City and Regional Planning_ University of North Carolina – Chapel Hill 

**Lindsey Haynes-Maslow, PhD, MHA** _Assistant Professor & Extension Specialist_ Department of Agricultural and Human Sciences North Carolina State University 

**Brian Queen** _Community Solutions Specialist_ United States Department of Agriculture Rural Development Innovation Center 

**Brian Horton, MS** _Transportation Planning Manager_ Western Piedmont Council of Governments 

**Peter Skillern, MCRP** _Executive Director_ Reinvestment Partners 

**Ed Johnson, ASLA, RLA** _Safe Routes to School Coordinator_ Integrated Mobility Division North Carolina Department of Transportation 

**Lenora S. Smith, MS** _Program Director_ Partnership Effort for the Advancement of Children’s Health (PEACH) 

**Timothy Lawrence Johnson, PhD, MS, MS** _Associate Professor of the Practice in Energy and the Environment Chair,_ Master of Environmental Management Energy and Environment Program Nicholas School of the Environment Duke University 

**Dale Threatt-Taylor, MEM** _District Director_ Wake Soil and Water Conservation District 

**Josie Williams** _Coordinator, Collaborative Cottage Grove_ Greensboro Housing Coalition 

**==> picture [105 x 111] intentionally omitted <==**

## **M E M B E R  L I S T** 

## HEALTH BEHAVIORS WORK GROUP 

## **CO-LEADERS** 

**Lynne Grey, MA, LPC, LCAS, CSI** _MH/SU Clinical Director_ Partners Behavioral Health Management 

**Susan Kansagra, MD, MBA** _Section Chief_ Chronic Disease and Injury Section Division of Public Health North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Audrey Hardy, MSN** _Roanoke Valley Community Health Initiative Coordinator_ Halifax Regional Medical Center 

**Carrie Rosario, DrPH, MPH, CHES** _Associate Professor and Associate Department Chair_ School of Health and Human Sciences Department of Public Health Education University of North Carolina-Greensboro 

**Tracie Heavner, MPH** 

_Director of Diabetes Prevention Program_ YMCA of Greensboro 

## **Kody Kinsley, MPP** 

**WORK GROUP MEMBERS** 

_Deputy Secretary for Behavioral Health & Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities_ North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Donna Albertone, MS** _Senior Program Director_ Population Health Improvement Partners 

**Suzanne Lazorick, MD, MPH, FAAP** _Professor, Departments of Pediatrics and Public Health_ Brody School of Medicine East Carolina University 

**Alice Ammerman, DrPH** 

_Director_ Center for Health Promotion and Disease Prevention University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill 

**Layton Long, REHS, MSA** 

_Health Director_ Chatham County Public Health Department 

**Tanya Bass, MS, MEd, CHES** _Adjunct Instructor_ Department of Public Health Education College of Behavioral & Social Sciences North Carolina Central University 

**Jim Martin, MS** _Task Force Member Director of Policy and Programs_ NC Tobacco Prevention and Control Branch Division of Public Health North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Phil Daye, MS** _NC Program Director_ FoodCorps 

**Sara McEwen, MD, MPH** 

**LaPonda Edmondson, DrPH, MHS** _Senior Director of Evaluation_ North Carolina Healthcare Foundation 

_Task Force Member Executive Director_ Governor’s Institute 

**Scottie Gaskins, MEd** _Senior Administrator – Wellness_ Vidant Health 

## **Victoria Mobley, MD, MPH** 

_Medical Epidemiologist, Communicable Disease Branch_ Division of Public Health North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Morgan Gramann, JD** _Executive Director_ NC Alliance for Health 

**==> picture [191 x 171] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 226** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 11 

10 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

11
{6}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

## **M E M B E R  L I S T** 

## HEALTH BEHAVIORS WORK GROUP 

## **Zo Mpofu** 

_Human Services Program Consultant_ Buncombe County Health and Human Services 

**Heather Murphy, CFRE** _Executive Director_ The Health Foundation 

**Christine Pernell** _Project Director, Partners in Health and Wholeness_ NC Council of Churches 

**Scott K. Proescholdbell, MPH** _Injury Epidemiologist and Surveillance Unit Manager_ Division of Public Health North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Michelle Reese** _Director of Clinical Improvement Services_ Shift NC 

**Carol Runyan, PhD, MPH** _Emeritus Professor, Department of Health Behavior_ Gillings School of Global Public Health University of North Carolina – Chapel Hill 

**Joseph Skelton, MD** _Associate Professor of Pediatrics_ Brenner Families in Training (FIT) at Wake Forest Baptist Health 

**Glorina Stallworth, BSW** _Rape Prevention and Education Program Manager_ Division of Public Health North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Sarah Zoubek, MEM** _Associate Director, World Food Policy Center Sanford School of Public Policy_ Duke University 

## **M E M B E R  L I S T** 

## CLINICAL CARE WORK GROUP 

## **CO-LEADERS** 

**Randy Jordan, JD, MPA** _CEO_ North Carolina Association of Free and Charitable Clinics 

**Kia Williams, MD, MSPH** _Associate Medical Director_ BlueCross BlueShield of North Carolina 

## **WORK GROUP MEMBERS** 

**Cherry Beasley, PhD, MS, FNP, RN, CNE** _Interim Chair and Professor, Department of Nursing_ University of North Carolina – Pembroke 

**Seth A. Berkowitz, MD, MPH** _Assistant Professor, School of Medicine_ University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill 

**Anna Boone, RN, BSN, MSPH** _Director of Quality Management_ Community Care of North Carolina 

**Michelle Bucknor, MD, MBA, FAAP** _Chief Medical Officer_ UnitedHealthcare of North Carolina 

**Darryl Childers, MPP** _Policy Advisor_ North Carolina Office of the Governor 

**Alisahah Cole, MD** _Vice President and System Medical Director of Community Health_ Atrium Health 

**Frank Courts, DDS, PhD** _Pediatric Dentist, Chair_ Council on Prevention and Oral Health 

**Kelly Crosbie, MSW, LCSW** _Deputy Director, Quality and Population Health, Division of Health Benefits_ North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Doyle “Skip” Cummings, PharmD** _Professor, Department of Family Medicine_ Brody School of Medicine East Carolina University 

**Robin Fox, MSN, RN, ACM-RN** _System Director of Care Management_ Appalachian Regional Healthcare System 

**Suzanne King, MPH** _Community Paramedic Coordinator_ Cape Fear Valley Health System 

**André Logan** _Community Health Worker_ Community Care Partners of Greater Mecklenburg 

**Wanda Nicholson, MD, MPH, MBA** _Professor, School of Medicine Director, Diabetes and Obesity Core, Center for Women’s Health Research_ University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill **Bryan Parrish, MA** _Outreach Coordinator_ Piedmont Health Services **Marilyn Pearson, MD** _Health Director_ Johnson County Public Health Department 

**Lisa Renfrow, MSN, RN** _Director-Nursing Education Services_ Area L AHEC 

**Sy A. Saeed, MD, MS, FACPsych** _Professor and Chairman_ Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Medicine Brody School of Medicine East Carolina University 

**Margaret “Maggie” Sauer, MHA, MS** _Director_ Office of Rural Health North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Packet Pg. 227** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 13 

12 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

13
{7}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

## **M E M B E R  L I S T** 

## CLINICAL CARE WORK GROUP 

**Jennifer Schroeder Tyson, MPH** _Director of Preparedness and Special Projects_ AppHealthCare (Appalachian District Health Department) 

**Melissa Selby, MSW** _Former Interprofessional Clinic Coordinator & Lecturer, Department of Social Work_ Appalachian State University 

**Lisa Shock, DrPH, MHS, PA-C** _Vice President, Clinical Strategy & Operations_ Evolent Clinical Services 

**Janeth Tapia** _Outreach Coordinator_ NC Farmworkers Project 

**Hugh Tilson Jr., JD, MPH** _Associate Dean and Director_ North Carolina Area Health Education Centers 

**Julia Wacker, MSW, MSPH** _Senior Vice President, Foundation_ North Carolina Healthcare Association 

**Charlene Wong, MD, MSPH** _Assistant Professor, Department of Pediatrics Member_ Margolis Center for Health Policy Duke University 

## **M E M B E R  L I S T** 

## STEERING COMMITTEE 

**Renee Godwin Batts, RN, MSN** _Former Associate Director, Academic Programs_ North Carolina Community Colleges 

**Ronny Bell, PhD, MS** 

_Professor and Chair_ Department of Public Health East Carolina University 

**Battle Betts, MPA** 

_Health Director_ Albemarle Regional Health Services 

**Chris Collins, MSW** 

_Associate Director of Health Care_ The Duke Endowment 

**Gail Cormier** 

_Executive Director_ NC Families United 

**Kathryn Dail, PhD, RN** 

_Director, Community Health Assessment Program_ Division of Public Health North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Merry Davis** 

_Senior Program Officer_ Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina Foundation 

**Alison Duncan, MPA** _Program Coordinator_ Kate B. Reynolds Charitable Trust 

**Ronald Gaskins, DHA, MBA, MPA** 

_Vice-President, Population Health Management_ Vidant Health _President, Vidant Integrated Care President, Coastal Plains Network_ 

## **Eleanor Howell, MS** 

_Director, State Center for Health Statistics_ Division of Public Health North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

## **Andrea Radford, DrPH, MHA** 

UNC Health Care - System Affiliations & Network Development 

**Cathy Thomas, MAEd** 

_Branch Manager, Community and Clinical Connections for Prevention and Health Branch Chronic Disease and Injury Section_ North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**Julia Wacker, MSW, MSPH** _Senior Vice President, Foundation_ North Carolina Healthcare Association 

**Cornell Wright, MPA** 

_Executive Director_ Office of Minority Health and Health Disparities North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**==> picture [191 x 171] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 228** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 15 

14 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

15
{8}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

## ACRONYMS 

**ACC** – Accountable Care Community **ACEs** – Adverse Childhood Experiences **BRFSS** - Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System **CDC** – Centers for Disease Control and Prevention **DPH** – Division of Public Health **FPL** – Federal Poverty Level **HIV** – Human Immunodeficiency Virus **HNC** – Healthy North Carolina **HPV** – human papillomavirus **IUD** – intrauterine device **KEA** – Kindergarten Entry Assessment **LARC** – long-acting reversible contraceptives **LEA** – Local Education Agency **LGBTQ** – lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer 

## **MSM** – men who have sex with men 

**NC DHHS** – North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services 

**NC DPI** – North Carolina Department of Public Instruction **NCIOM** – North Carolina Institute of Medicine **PA** – physician assistant 

**PrEP** – pre-exposure prophylaxis 

**SNAP/EBT** – Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program/Electronic Benefits Transfer **SSB** – sugar-sweetened beverage **STI** – sexually transmitted infection **SUD** – substance use disorder **VA** – Veterans Health Administration **YRB** S – Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance 

## EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 

Healthy people and healthy communities are the foundation of a thriving, prosperous state, and improving the health, safety, and well-being of North Carolinians is a core part of the work of state government.  In parallel with the national Healthy People initiative run by the United States Department of Health and Human Services, the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services (NC DHHS) has released Healthy North Carolina (HNC) goals at the beginning of each decade since 1990. HNC is a set of health indicators with 10-year targets designed to guide state efforts to improve health and wellbeing. Identifying key indicators and targets allows NC DHHS, the Division of Public Health (DPH), local health departments, and other partners across the state to work together toward shared goals. 

One of the goals of NC DHHS is to ensure that all North Carolinians have the opportunity for health. Health equity is the opportunity for all people to attain the highest level of personal health regardless of demographic characteristics.[1] Health begins in families and communities, and is largely determined by the social and economic contexts (responsible for 40% of the variation in health outcomes) in which we grow up, live, work, and age; the healthy behaviors (30%) that those contexts make easier or harder[2] , and our physical environments (10%). These factors are called drivers of health (also known as social determinants of health) and they directly affect health outcomes like development of disease and life expectancy. HNC 2030 sets the stage to a focus on health equity and these overall drivers of health outcomes. 

The HNC 2030 process from January-August 2019 integrated input from a Task Force, four work groups (Social & Economic Factors, Physical Environment, Health Behaviors, and Clinical Care), and communities across the state through a series of eight Community Input Sessions. Participants considered several priorities during the HNC 2030 process. Because the HNC 2030 indicators represent issues across many sectors of society, it is important that they be understandable to a broad audience. Each indicator is measurable using existing data sources. 

_A https://www.ncdhhs.gov/about/dhhs-mission-vision-values-and-goals/mission-vision_ 

The group had a preference for data measured at least every three years to allow for monitoring between now and 2030. When possible, there was also a preference for data available at the county level to allow for local goal setting and local action as well as comparisons within the state. In addition, the Task Force tried to align with statewide health improvement plans and measure sets when possible, including the Early Childhood Action Plan, the Opioid Action Plan, the Perinatal Strategic Plan, and the Medicaid Transformation Quality Strategy . The Task Force and work groups prioritized health equity by selecting indicators related to health disparities within the state. Overall, 21 health indicators were chosen across the topics of Social & Economic Factors, Physical Environment, Health Behaviors, Clinical Care, and Health Outcomes ( **Table 1** ). 

NC DHHS, DPH, and local health departments will remain at the forefront of HNC 2030 efforts; however, they cannot achieve these goals alone. HNC 2030 should be more than a health plan for public health, it should be a health plan for the whole state. The inclusion of factors traditionally outside the sphere of public health (e.g., education, employment, housing) means that achieving the HNC 2030 goals will require engaging partners across multiple sectors to improve population health and drive health equity over the next decade. 

As the new decade begins, the NC DHHS and DPH will be developing a population health improvement strategy and resources to be used at the local level. The broader view of the drivers of health and well-being with attention to health disparities is an exciting step toward making North Carolina a place for everyone to live a healthy life. 

**==> picture [191 x 171] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 229** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 17 

16 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

17
{9}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA<br>(TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL)<br>**T A B L E  1**<br>**W**= WHITE<br>**B/AA**= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>**H/LX**= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)<br>**A/PI**= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**AI**= AMERICAN INDIAN<br>**FPL**= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**‡**NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE<br>*****2016-18 AVERAGE<br>**^**INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY<br>**#**DATA FROM 2015<br>**A**- ASIAN ONLY<br>**B**- PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>**C**- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED<br>BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION<br>**D**- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**E**- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**F**- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>**G**- TWO OR MORE RACES<br>**H**- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY<br>DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC<br>INSTRUCTION|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
||||TOTAL POPULATION||||||||||||||
||||TOTAL POPULATION|||RACE / ETHNICITY||||||SEX||FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL|||
||**HEALTH INDICATOR**|**DESIRED RESULT**||||||||||**MALE**|**FEMALE**||||
||||**CURRENT(YEAR)**|**2030 TARGET**||**W**|**B/AA**|**H/LX**|**O**|**A/PI**|**AI**|||**<200%**|**200-399%**|**400%+**|
||INDIVIDUALS BELOW 200% FPL|**Decrease the number of people**<br>**living inpoverty**|**36.8%**<br>**(2013-17)**|**27.0%**||**30.7%**|**51.1%**|**63.6%**|**46.1%G**|**30.6%**|**51.5%**|**34.8%**|**38.7%**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|
||UNEMPLOYMENT|**Increase economic security**|**7.2%**<br>**(2013-17)**|Reduce unemployment disparity<br>ratio between white and other<br>populations to 1.7 or lower||**5.7%^**|**11.7%^**|**7.1%^**|**7.3%^**<br>**11.0%^G**|**5.2%^**|**10.3%^**|**6.4%**|**6.7%**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|
||SHORT-TERM SUSPENSIONS<br> (PER 10 STUDENTS)|**Dismantle structural racism**|**1.39**<br>**(2017-18)**|**0.80**||**0.73**|**3.00**|**0.88**|**1.69**|**0.18A**|**2.46**|**1.98**|**0.74**|**2.09C**|**‡**|**‡**|
||INCARCERATION RATE<br>(PER 100,000 POPULATION)||**341**<br>**(2017)**|**150**||**203#**|**915#**|**209#**|**‡**|**‡**|**488#**|**649**|**50**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|
||ADVERSE CHILDHOOD EXPERIENCES|**Improve child well-being**|**23.6%**<br>**(2016-17)**|**18.0%**||**17.5%**|**36.0%**|**23.2%**|**37.2%**|**11.1%**|**‡**|**23.8%**|**23.5%**|**47.9%**|**19.9%**|**8.3%**|
||THIRD GRADE READING PROFICIENCY|**Improve third grade reading profciency**|**56.8%**<br>**(2018-19)**|**80.0%**||**70.1%**|**40.8%**|**42.6%**|**59.5%G**|**75.6%A**|**44.5%**|**54.0%**|**59.8%**|**42.6%C**|**70.6%H**|**‡**|
||ACCESS TO EXERCISE OPPORTUNITIES|**Increase physical activity**|**73%**<br>**(2010/18)**|**92%**||**DATA NOT AVAILABLE**|||||||||||
||LIMITED ACCESS TO HEALTHY FOOD|**Improve access to healthy food**|**7%**<br>**(2015)**|**5%**|||||||||||||
||SEVERE HOUSING PROBLEMS|**Improve housing quality**|**16.1%**<br>**(2011-15)**|**14.0%**|||||||||||||
||DRUG OVERDOSE DEATHS<br>(PER 100,000 POPULATION)|**Decrease drug overdose deaths**|**20.4**<br>**(2018)**|**18.0**||**26.4**|**12.9**|**5.4**|**4.4**|**‡**|**32.6**|**27.8**|**13.2**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|
||TOBACCO USE|**Decrease tobacco use**|**19.8% (2017)**<br>YOUTH|**9.0%**||**20.6%**|**17.0%**|**20.7%**|**19.0%**|**‡**|**‡**|**23.0%**|**16.5%**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|
||||**23.8% (2018)**<br>ADULT|**15.0%**||**25.9%**|**22.5%**|**12.2%**|**17.1%**|**‡**|**‡**|**29.9%**|**18.5%**|**32.8%**|**21.6%**|**17.2%**|
||EXCESSIVE DRINKING|**Decrease excessive drinking**|**16.0%**<br>**(2018)**|**12.0%**||**17.2%**|**12.5%**|**17.8%**|**13.1%**|**‡**|**‡**|**21.7%**|**10.8%**|**14.5%**|**17.6%**|**21.2%**|
||SUGAR-SWEETENED BEVERAGE<br>CONSUMPTION|**Reduce overweight and obesity**|**33.6%(2017)**<br>YOUTH|**17.0%**||**36.1%**|**31.5%**|**28.9%**|**24.3%**|**‡**|**‡**|**38.7%**|**28.3%**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|
||||**34.2%  (2017)**<br>ADULT|**20.0%**||**32.6%**|**38.7%**|**37.0%**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|**37.6%**|**31.0%**|**41.0%**|**32.7%**|**24.1%**|
||HIV DIAGNOSIS<br>(PER 100,000 POPULATION)|**Improve sexual health**|**13.9**<br>**(2018)**|**6.0**||**4.9**|**40.8**|**17.7**|**‡**|**4.3**|**5.9**|**23.1**|**5.4**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|
||TEEN BIRTH RATE<br>(PER 1,000 POPULATION)||**18.7**<br>**(2018)**|**10.0**||**12.9**|**24.1**|**34.3**|**6.9**|**‡**|**38.3**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|
||UNINSURED|**Decrease the uninsured population**|**13%**<br>**(2017)**|**8%**||**10%**|**13%**|**31%**|**8%**|**9%**|**18%**|**14%**|**11%**|**21%**|**12%**|**4%**|
||PRIMARY CARE CLINICIANS<br>(COUNTIES AT OR BELOW 1:1,500 PROVIDERS TO POPULATION)|**Increase the primary care workforce**|**62**<br>**(2017)**|**25% decrease for counties above**<br>**1:1,500 providers to population**||**NOT APPLICABLE**|||||||||||
||EARLY PRENATAL CARE|**Improve birth outcomes**|**68.0%**<br>**(2018)**|**80.0%**||**74.8%**|**60.5%**|**57.5%**|**66.0%**|**‡**|**54.3%**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|
||SUICIDE RATE<br>(PER 100,000 POPULATION)|**Improve access and treatment**<br>**for mental health needs**|**13.8**<br>**(2018)**|**11.1**||**17.8**|**5.7**|**5.8**|**7.7**|**‡**|**‡**|**22.4**|**5.9**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|
||INFANT MORTALITY<br>(PER 1,000 BIRTHS)|**Decrease infant mortality**|**6.8(2018)**|**6.0**||**5.0**|**12.2**|**4.8**|**5.0**|**‡**|**9.3**|**8.0**|**5.5**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|
||||**Black/white disparity ratio = 2.4**|**Black/white disparity ratio = 1.5**|||||||||||||
||LIFE EXPECTANCY (YEARS)|**Increase life expectancy**|**77.6**<br>**(2018)**|**82.0**||**78.3***|**75.5***|**‡**|**87.0***|**‡**|**75.6***|**74.8**|**80.3**|**‡**|**‡**|**‡**|



_Source: See descriptions of health indicators throughout this report for information on data sources._ 

**==> picture [191 x 171] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 230** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 19 

18 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

19
{10}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

## **C H A P T E R  1** 

## INTRODUCTION 

**==> picture [233 x 88] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [441 x 257] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 231** 

20 

21 

HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{11}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

## INTRODUCTION 

## **Overview of Healthy North Carolina 2030** 

Healthy people and healthy communities are the foundation of a thriving, prosperous state, and improving the health, safety, and well-being of North Carolinians is a core part of the work of state government.[B] In parallel with the national Healthy People initiative run by the United States Department of Health and Human Services, the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services (NC DHHS) has released Healthy North Carolina (HNC) goals at the beginning of each decade since 1990. HNC is a set of health indicators with 10-year targets designed to guide state efforts to improve health and well-being. Identifying key indicators and targets allows NC DHHS, the Division of Public Health (DPH), local health departments, and other partners across the state to work together toward shared goals. 

One of the goals of NC DHHS is to ensure that all North Carolinians have the opportunity for health. Health equity is the opportunity for all people to attain the highest level of personal health regardless of demographic characteristics.[1] Although traditionally discussions around health have focused on clinical health care, research has shown that clinical care only accounts for around 20% of health outcomes. While access to medical care is important, health begins long before medical care is needed. 

Health begins in families and communities, and is largely determined by the social and economic contexts (responsible for 40% of the variation in health outcomes) in which we grow up, live, work, and age; the healthy behaviors (30%) that those contexts make easier or harder[2] , and our physical environments (10%). Some of the social, economic, behavioral, and environmental factors that affect health include: 

- safety of families and communities, 

- • exposure to environmental contaminants in air, water, and soil, • quality of housing and education, 

- access to transportation and healthy food, 

- • availability of employment opportunities and a living wage, • exposure to and use of alcohol, tobacco, and other drugs, and • opportunities for physical activity. 

_B https://www.ncdhhs.gov/about/dhhs-mission-vision-values-and-goals/mission-vision_ 

HNC 2030 embodies this shift to a focus on health equity and overall drivers of health outcomes, whereas HNC 2020 focused on specific clinical and health behavior topics. HNC 2030 uses the County Health Rankings population health model developed by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation ( **see Figure 1** )[5] , which identifies the primary drivers of health, as well as their proportional contribution to overall health outcomes. 

These factors are called drivers of health (also known as social determinants of health) and they directly affect health outcomes like development of disease and life expectancy. Underlying these drivers of health are the public policies that influence opportunities for education, employment, and safety; shape our communities; and promote or discourage various behaviors. 

## EXAMPLES 

## **F I G U R E  1** 

## **Drivers of Health and their Effects on Health Outcomes** 

Population Health Model 

44% of asthma cases in children are related to home-based exposures (Lanphear, 2001) 

|home-based exposures(Lanphear, 2001)<br>Food insecurity signifcantly afects adult Type 2<br>diabetes mellitus outcomes(Seligman, 2012)<br>Living in a neighborhood with economic<br>disadvantages increases risk of coronary heart<br>disease(Diez Roux, 2001)<br>When opportunities or resources to be healthy are not available,<br>people’s health and well-being are negatively impacted. Health<br>inequities are created when people cannot attain optimal health because<br>of unjust, unnecessary, and avoidable circumstances (e.g., greater<br>barriers to accessing healthy foods, transportation, physical activity, and<br>health care in historically segregated, low-income and racial and ethnic<br>minority communities).3These inequities lead to health disparities,<br>or diferences in health status and outcomes between groups based<br>on characteristics like race, ethnicity, gender, geography, educational<br>attainment,  and income.4<br>Long-term sustainable improvements in the health and well-being of<br>Nth Clii ill l  b ddi th il i d<br>**HEALTH**<br>**FACTORS**<br>**POLICIES**<br>**AND**<br>**PROGRAMS**<br>**HEALTH**<br>**OUTCOMES**|**Length of Life (50%)**<br>**Quality of Life (50%)**<br>**HEALTH**<br>**B**~~**E**~~**HAVIORS**<br>**(30%)**<br>**CLINICAL**<br>**CARE**<br>**(20%)**<br>**SOCIAL AND**<br>**ECONOMIC**<br>**FACTORS**<br>**(40%)**<br>**PHYSICAL**<br>**EN**~~**V**~~**IRONMENT**<br>**(10%)**<br>**Tobacco Use**<br>**Diet and Exercise**<br>~~**A**~~**lcohol and Drug Use**<br>**Sexual Activity**<br>**Access to Care**<br>**Quality of Care**<br>**Education**<br>**Employment**<br>**Income**<br>**Fa**~~**m**~~**ily and Social Support**<br>**Community Safety**<br>~~**A**~~**ir and Water Quality**<br>~~**H**~~**ousing and Transit**|**Length of Life (50%)**<br>**Quality of Life (50%)**<br>**HEALTH**<br>**B**~~**E**~~**HAVIORS**<br>**(30%)**<br>**CLINICAL**<br>**CARE**<br>**(20%)**<br>**SOCIAL AND**<br>**ECONOMIC**<br>**FACTORS**<br>**(40%)**<br>**PHYSICAL**<br>**EN**~~**V**~~**IRONMENT**<br>**(10%)**<br>**Tobacco Use**<br>**Diet and Exercise**<br>~~**A**~~**lcohol and Drug Use**<br>**Sexual Activity**<br>**Access to Care**<br>**Quality of Care**<br>**Education**<br>**Employment**<br>**Income**<br>**Fa**~~**m**~~**ily and Social Support**<br>**Community Safety**<br>~~**A**~~**ir and Water Quality**<br>~~**H**~~**ousing and Transit**|
|---|---|---|
|||**Tobacco Use**<br>**Diet and Exercise**<br>~~**A**~~**lcohol and Drug Use**<br>**Sexual Activity**<br>**Access to Care**<br>**Quality of Care**<br>**Education**<br>**Employment**<br>**Income**<br>**Fa**~~**m**~~**ily and Social Support**<br>**Community Safety**<br>~~**A**~~**ir and Water Quality**<br>~~**H**~~**ousing and Transit**|



Long-term sustainable improvements in the health and well-being of North Carolinians will only occur by addressing the social, economic, and place-based challenges that keep people from achieving optimal health. National and state public health leaders are focusing on health equity by shifting focus from individual health topics to overall drivers of health outcomes, including social and economic factors, physical environment, health behaviors, and clinical care. 

_Source: County Health Rankings & Roadmaps, County Health Rankings Model. https://www.countyhealthrankings.org/explore-health-rankings/measuresdata-sources/county-health-rankings-model_ 

Although the framework used for HNC 2030 has required broader consideration of factors that affect health and well-being, the total number of health indicators has been reduced to 21 from 40 in 2020 and 100 in 2010 in order to focus attention, energy, and resources on a narrower set of priorities. 

NC DHHS, DPH, and local health departments will remain at the forefront of HNC 2030 efforts; however, they cannot achieve these goals alone. The inclusion of factors traditionally outside the sphere of public health (e.g., education, employment, housing) means that achieving the HNC 2030 goals will require engaging partners across multiple sectors to improve population health and drive health equity over the next decade (See Appendix A for list of all health indicators and targets). 

## **Process** 

The NC DHHS and DPH is accountable for developing HNC 2030 and partnered with the North Carolina Institute of Medicine (NCIOM) to lead the process. Funding for this work was provided by the Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina Foundation, The Duke Endowment, and the Kate B. Reynolds Charitable Trust. This work involved a total of eight months of meetings throughout 2019 with an overall Task Force, Work Groups for each of the driver of health topic areas (Social and Economic Factors, Physical Environment, Health Behaviors, and Clinical Care), and Community Input Sessions. The overall Task Force was chaired by Ronny Bell, PhD, MS, Professor and Chair of the Department of Public Health and Associate Director of the Center for Health Disparities, East Carolina University; John F.A.V Cecil, MIM, President, Biltmore Farms, LLC; Laura Gerald, MD, MPH, President, Kate B. Reynolds Charitable Trust; and Elizabeth Cuervo Tilson, MD, MPH, State Health Director and Chief Medical Officer, NC DHHS. Each of the Work Groups was co-led by two individuals who were also members of the Task Force: Social and Economic Factors – Wanda Boone, PhD, Executive Director of Together for Resilient Youth and Donnie Varnell, Special Law Enforcement Projects Consultant, North Carolina Harm Reduction Coalition and Investigator, Dare County Sheriff’s Office; Physical Environment – Myron Floyd, PhD, MS, Professor and Head, Department of Parks, Recreation, and Tourism Management, North Carolina State University and Larry Michael, REHS, MPH, Chief, 

**Packet Pg. 232** 

22 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

23 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{12}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

## INTRODUCTION 

place from February to April 2019 ( **see Figure 2** for dates, locations, and number of participants). The integration of community input was a new and intentional effort to represent the voices of people around the state in choosing the population health goals for the next decade. Of note, two of the community input sessions were held in the traditional homelands of the two largest American Indian tribes in the state (Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians and the Lumbee Tribe of North Carolina). While all sessions were open to any member of the community to attend, most participants represented public health or the health professions. 

Environmental Health Section, Division of Public Health, NC DHHS; Health Behaviors – Susan Kansagra, MD, MBA, Section Chief, Chronic Disease and Injury Section, Division of Public Health, NC DHHS and Carrie Rosario, DrPH, MPH, CHES, Associate Professor and Associate Department Chair, Department of Public Health Education, School of Health and Human Sciences, University of North Carolina-Greensboro; and Clinical Care – Randy Jordan, JD, MPA, Chief Executive Officer, North Carolina Association of Free and Charitable Clinics and Kia Williams, MD, MSPH, Associate Medical Director, BlueCross BlueShield of North Carolina. They were joined by 40 Task Force members who represented a wide range of expertise and interests from across the state. Seventeen Task Force members were also members of one of the Work Groups. A fourteen-person Steering Committee helped guide the process. 

For more details about the HNC 2030 indicator selection process and timeline and results from Community Input Sessions, please see **Appendix B and C** . 

The HNC 2030 process integrated input from communities across the state through a series of eight Community Input Sessions, which took 

**F I G U R E  2** 

Dates, locations, and attendees at HNC 2030 Community Input Sessions 

**==> picture [518 x 296] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Attendance:<br>Attendance: 29  counties<br>Attendance:<br>6  counties 117  participants<br>6  counties<br>Attendance: 21  participants 24  participants Eastern AHEC<br>12  counties Health ENC meeting<br>Perry Memorial Library<br>39  participants GTCC-East Campus March 5th February 27th<br>Attendance: April 3rd 5:00-7:30pm 12:45-3:10pm<br>5:00-7:30pm<br>8  counties Marion Senior Center<br>29  participants April 9th<br>1:30-4:00pm<br>Cherokee Indian Hospital<br>April 9th<br>8:00-10:00am<br>Attendance:<br>11  counties<br>56  participants Attendance:<br>Attendance:<br>8  counties<br>Charlotte – Goodwill  11  counties 20  participants<br>Opportunity Center 34  participants<br>April 3rd<br>11:30am-2:00pm UNC Pembroke Coastal Carolina<br>Community College<br>March 6th<br>March 19th<br>12:00-2:30pm<br>12:00-2:30pm<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **Priorities for Indicator Selection** 

our communities and our health care system.”[6] To do this, NC DHHS is taking a multi-layered approach to addressing the drivers of health, including: 

Participants considered several priorities during the HNC 2030 process. Because the HNC 2030 indicators represent issues across many sectors of society, it is important that they be understandable to a broad audience. Each indicator needs to be measurable using existing data sources, with a preference for data measured at least every three years to allow for monitoring between now and 2030. When possible, there was also a preference for data available at the county level to allow for comparisons within the state. In addition, the Task Force tried to align with statewide health improvement plans and measure sets when possible, including the Early Childhood Action Plan and the Opioid Action Plan. The Task Force and Work Groups prioritized health equity by selecting indicators related to health disparities within the state. 

1. Creating standardized screening questions to identify resource needs, 

2. Deploying a statewide digital resource and referral platform to connect health and social services NCCARE360, 

3. Mapping social drivers of health indicators, 

4. Building infrastructure to support the recommendations of the Community Health Worker Initiative, 

5. Implementing Medicaid transformation through Medicaid Managed Care to address whole person health including medical and nonmedical drivers of health, 

6. Testing public-private pilots of Accountable Care Community-style models focused on people enrolled in Medicaid Managed Care, and 

While the indicators selected for HNC 2030 are all important for North Carolina’s population health status, they are not the only important health indicators for the state. HNC 2030 indicators were selected to represent a broad range of important issues for health in North Carolina and oftentimes represent larger issues. For example, primary care providers per population and health insurance status are indicators of broader health care access issues but are not the only important characteristics of that access. The discussions within each indicator description will provide the broader context within which that indicator was selected. 

7. Fostering multi-payer alignment around accelerating value-based payment and addressing non-medical drivers of health. 

The NCIOM Task Force on Accountable Care Communities (ACC) published a report that describes a new model of multi-sector partnership at the community level and provides twenty-four recommendations to policymakers, public health leaders, providers, payers, human services organizations, and communities to promote ACC development.  A guide for community members looking to develop these partnerships is also available online.  Local health departments across the state may be natural leaders in developing the partnerships needed to address many of the issues related to health that were chosen as goals for HNC 2030. This is reflective of the Public Health 3.0 call to action for cross-sectoral collaboration to drive collective action.[7] To complement the development of ACC models, the NC DHHS framework for addressing the drivers of health seeks to provide many of the tools to start addressing these issues. Partners from a variety 

## NEXT STEPS: 

**Partnerships to Improve Health – A Model for Addressing HNC 2030** 

Public health leaders across the state are charged with working toward framework for addressing the drivers of health seeks to provide many the goals set by Healthy North Carolina. The new framework for HNC of the tools to start addressing these issues. Partners from a variety 2030 includes broader issues related to social and economic factors and the physical environment than those with which public health traditionally engages. The wide range of indicators selected for HNC Accountable Care Communities (ACCs) address health 2030 brings new opportunities for public health to partner across from a community perspective. ACCs bring together sectors to address many drivers of health. a coalition of cross-sector stakeholders that share responsibility to address the drivers of health while In addition, the NC DHHS has a vision to “optimize health and wellreducing, or holding steady, health spending. 

In addition, the NC DHHS has a vision to “optimize health and wellbeing for all people by effectively stewarding resources that bridge 

**Packet Pg. 233** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 25 

24 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

25
{13}------------------------------------------------
## INTRODUCTION 

of sectors will need to engage with public health leaders to develop strategies to improve the variety of social, economic, environmental, and behavioral factors that influence our health outcomes. Community members should also be engaged in these efforts so that local voices are always a part of any strategies for action at the local level. 

## **Structure of this Report** 

The presentation of the HNC 2030 health indicators is divided into five sections based on the drivers of health: Social and Economic Factors ( **Chapter 3** ); Physical Environment ( **Chapter 4** ); Health Behaviors ( **Chapter 5** ); Clinical Care ( **Chapter 6** ); and Health Outcomes ( **Chapter 7** ). At the beginning of each chapter is a description of how those issues drive health. Selected health indicators are presented within their topic areas, including a description of how the indicator impacts health, disparities across populations, how the target for HNC 2030 was selected, and potential levers for change. Current data across populations is provided, when available, for race/ethnicity, sex, and poverty status with calculations showing the distance to the target for each of those populations. Indicators are numbered for reference purposes only. At the end of each section is a discussion of developmental measures, which are measures that would provide useful information about an aspect of population health that participants were interested in but could not select because of issues with the availability or quality of data. 

## **Language** 

Throughout this report, data are referenced from surveys, vital statistics, and research studies. Population-specific data from these sources vary in reporting of Hispanic ethnicity with race. Data sources also vary in reporting terminology for Black/African American populations. References to racial groups have been standardized throughout the report as African American, American Indian, Asian, and white. Unless otherwise noted, these groups are all non-Hispanic and data for individuals indicating Hispanic ethnicity are reported separately. 

**9.13.a** 

**C H A P T E R  2** 

BACKGROUND 

**==> picture [233 x 88] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [441 x 257] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 234** 

26 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

27 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{14}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## BACKGROUND 

## **North Carolina Demographics** 

North Carolina is a diverse state in many ways, with a geography spanning coast to mountains. See below for basic demographic information about the state’s residents. 

**==> picture [534 x 220] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
North Carolina by Race/Ethnicity, 2013-2017 Estimate Other North Carolina Demographics<br>TOTAL POPULATION [1]<br>10,052,564<br>GEOGRAPHY [2]<br>Urban 66%<br>Rural 34%<br>AGE GROUP [1]<br>Under 18 22.8%<br>18-64 62.1%<br>65 and older 15.1%<br>*non-Hispanic 12013-2017 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates: Age<br>Source: American Community Survey, 2013-2017  and Sex<br>Comparative Demographic Estimates 22010 Census<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **Health Trends in North Carolina and the Drivers of Health** 

Health behaviors are actions that are either beneficial or detrimental to an individual’s health. The drivers of health have direct effects on individual opportunities to make healthy choices and can either limit or facilitate opportunities to engage in healthy activities and behaviors. For example, people who do not receive comprehensive sex education may not know the necessary safe sexual practices to avoid unintended pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases. Individuals who lack access to full-service grocery stores that sell fresh fruits and vegetables may not be able to prepare healthy meals and those who do not have safe spaces or spare leisure time to exercise may have low physical activity. Consequently, individuals living within these circumstances tend to have higher rates of obesity, diabetes, and heart disease.[8] 

Over the past decade, North Carolina’s overall health ranking has improved from a low of 37th in 2014 to a high of 31st in 2015 and is now 33rd as of 2018 (ranking of 1st as best and 50th as worst) according to America’s Health Rankings. The improvement in ranking is a result of successes in several areas. However, there are some growing challenges in the state that have prevented North Carolina from rising higher. **See Figure 3** for examples of these successes and challenges. 

Included in **Figure 3** are some examples of non-clinical drivers of health that have not traditionally been considered, such as graduation rate, violent crime, poverty, and food insecurity. Many of these and other drivers of health have interrelated and compounding effects. For example, people with higher incomes have more opportunities to live in safe and healthy homes near schools with better funding. People with higher incomes generally have more opportunities to purchase healthy foods and more time and resources for leisure-time physical activity. Health insurance and health care also become more accessible with higher incomes. 

In addition to the slow improvement in overall health in the state, stark disparities exist, particularly between different racial and ethnic groups. Throughout this report, disparities are described within each indicator. **Figure 4** provides examples of health outcome disparities in the state. 

**F I G U R E  3** 

## Health Status Successes and Challenges in North Carolina 

**==> picture [462 x 166] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
 Graduation Rate - 85.9%  (National Avg. 84.1%, 2015-16)<br>SUCCESSES<br> Violent Crime - 364 per 100,000  (National Avg. 394 per 100,000, 2017)<br>2018<br> Infant Mortality - 7.1 per 1,00 live births  (National Avg. 5.8 per 1,00 live births, 2017)<br>NC OVERALL<br>HEALTH RANK  IMPROVEMENTS,STILL ABOVE  Adult Smoking - 17.2%  (National Avg. 17.1%, 2017)<br>AMONG 50  AVERAGE  Children Living in Poverty - 21.2%  (National Avg. 18.4%, 2017)<br>STATES:  Uninsured - 13%  (National Avg. 8.7%, 2017)<br>33 [RD]  Drug Overdose Dealths - 16.2 per 100,000  (National Avg. 16.9, 2014-16)<br>GROWING<br>CHALLENGES  Obesity - 32.1%  (National Avg. 31.3%, 2017)<br> Youth Tobacco Use - 19.8%  (National Avg. 12.6%, 2017)<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


_Sources: America’s Health Rankings (https://www.americashealthrankings.org/explore/annual); Kaiser Family Foundation State Health Facts (https://www.kff.org/other/stateindicator/nonelderly-0-)64/?currentTimeframe=0&selectedDistributions=uninsured&selectedRows=%7B%22wrapups%22:%7B%22united-states%22:%7B%7D%7D,%22states%22:%7B%22all%22:%7B%7D%7D%7D&sortModel=%7B%22colId%22:%22Uninsured%22,%22sort%22:%22asc%22%7D; NC DHHS NC Tobacco Prevention and Control Branch analysis of Youth Tobacco Survey      Note: Data presented in this graphic are the most recent available to compare to national average._ 

**F I G U R E  4** 

**Systems and Policies and the Drivers of Health** Often public policies are not included as a driver of health; however, public policies create the context within which the drivers of health exist. Federal, state, and local systems and policies shape the conditions in which individuals live, work, learn, and age.[9,10] Public policies are those policies, and the systems and programs they create, that result from government action. The results of some public policies are easier to see: traffic and public safety laws, tax policies, “[Public policies create the ] education financing, and context within which the public assistance programs. drivers of health exist. Federal, Others may be harder to see state, and local systems and in our daily lives but shape them nonetheless: zoning and policies shape the conditions land use policies; food safety in which individuals live, work, regulations; agriculture policies; ” learn, and age. regulations around banking, communications, air and water quality; and laws around health insurance access and coverage. As such, public policy can often provide an avenue for intervening in the drivers of health. 

## Examples of Health Disparities in North Carolina 

|**KIDNEY DISEASE MORTALITY**<br>African Americans2.3times<br>more likely to die than whites<br>from kidney disease<br>American Indians1.5times<br>more likely to die than whites<br>from kidney disease<br>**INFANT MORTALITY**<br>African American babies2.4<br>times more likely to die than<br>white babies<br>American Indian babies1.7<br>times more likely to die than<br>white babies|**DIABETES MORTALITY**<br>African Americans2.3times<br>more likely to die than whites<br>from diabetes<br>American Indians2.4times<br>more likely to die than whites<br>from diabetes<br>**GEOGRAPHY, LIFE**<br>**EXPECTANCY, AND RACE**<br>**Swain County**<br>Overall 73.1 years – lowest in<br>NC(67.5 for American Indians;<br>75.6 for whites)<br>**Orange County**<br>Overall 82.1 years – highest in<br>NC (75.2 for African Americans;<br>83.1 for whites)||
|---|---|---|



**==> picture [215 x 12] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Sources: NC DHHS, Health Equity Report, 2018; NC DHHS, Life Expectancy, 2016-2018<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Packet Pg. 235** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 29 

28 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

29
{15}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

## BACKGROUND 

## ACCUMULATING CHALLENGES: **William and the Drivers of Health** 

William grew up in a working-class neighborhood. He graduated from high school and went to work in a local factory because his family could not afford to pay for college. He made enough to make ends meet and had health insurance through his job. William worked long hours and didn’t have a lot of time to exercise or make healthy meals at home. He gained weight and was eventually diagnosed with diabetes. A few years ago, the factory closed, and William lost his job and health insurance benefits. He found odd jobs around town to make some money but had to move to a low-cost rental apartment that was not being properly maintained by the ~~property owner. He had to sell his car and rely on a fri~~ end to help him get around. He stopped going to regular medical appointments for his diabetes and also had to stop buying the medications he needed. One day William tripped on the carpet in his home that was buckled because of water damage and broke his arm. He became more limited in the work he could do and feared he may be evicted from his apartment. 

_“ Structural racism refers to the way public policies, institutional practices, cultural representations, and other social norms interact to generate and reinforce inequities among racial and ” ethnic groups._ 

## **Structural Racism and Health** 

The root cause for the health disparities we see in populations of color is the historical and continued structural racism that has resulted in inequitable opportunities for healthy lives. Structural racism refers to the way public policies, institutional practices, cultural representations, and other social norms interact to generate and reinforce inequities among racial and ethnic groups.[11,12] This includes health care, housing, education, transportation and other policies that have either explicitly or implicitly resulted in discriminatory practices. Policies which are an example of structural racism include: 

• Redlining – Exclusionary zoning laws across the country in the early- to mid-1900’s prevented African Americans from buying property in certain neighborhoods. In 1933, the Home Owners’ Loan Corporation introduced a color-coded system showing the “risk” of neighborhoods for mortgage lending. Red zones were those almost entirely populated by African American residents and considered high risk for mortgages. In 1934, the Federal Housing Administration continued the policies. These policies helped to produce the racially segregated, and often under-resourced, neighborhoods that are still found in many cities. This form of housing segregation was supported by lending policies into the 1970’s, when new laws were enacted with the intention of ending explicit redlining. 

- 

Segregated schools – Until the Supreme Court ruled in Brown v. Board of Education in 1954 that school segregation was unconstitutional, children of different races often went to separate schools by law. Despite the change in law, desegregation of schools took many years. Even today, due to historically segregated neighborhoods and other local policies, children do not always attend schools where the student population is racially or ethnically diverse. Schools that are racially isolated often are older and in poorer condition, have fewer resources, struggle to attract high-performing teachers, and offer fewer advanced courses and extra-curricular activities.[13] 

• High-interest loans – African Americans and Hispanics are more likely to have high-interest home loans, even when controlling for credit score and other risk factors. This is largely due to the concentration of high-risk lenders who target people of color. These high-risk lenders are more likely to offer high-interest loans. These lenders charge higher rates to clients of color with the same credit score and risk factors as white clients.[14] 

These structural policies pose challenges to achieving optimal health. Other examples of institutional racism reside within the health care system itself. The historical injustices of segregated hospitals, unethical research practices (e.g., Tuskegee Syphilis Study), and eugenics (e.g., forced sterilization) have resulted in a lack of trust in health care institutions for many people of color.  Today, we see an underrepresentation of many racial/ethnic minority groups in the health professions[15] and lower quality of care for people of color (e.g., receiving less information from health care providers, higher morbidity and mortality in coronary artery disease care, and more challenges getting appointments and care quickly).[15,16,17] 

_“ These impacts are numerous, including unemployment, fewer educational resources, harsher punishments in schools and the judicial system, intergenerational poverty, and the accumulated physiologic stress of discrimination regardless of socioeconomic ” status (i.e., “weathering”)._ 

These examples begin to illustrate the widespread social, economic, and health impacts of structural racism on people of color. These impacts are numerous, including unemployment, fewer educational resources, harsher punishments in schools and the judicial system, intergenerational poverty, and the accumulated physiologic stress of discrimination regardless of socioeconomic status (i.e., “weathering”).[18] These issues encompass some of the upstream causes of the poor health outcomes that are seen for people of color. Correcting these injustices will require acknowledgement and understanding of the issues and intentional work to change them. Even with intentional efforts to eliminate these structural barriers to health equity, the work and the potential positive effects will take decades to accumulate. Structural racism, health equity, and health disparities were a part of discussions and the indicator selection process for HNC 2030. In several cases, indicators were chosen precisely because they are closely connected to structural racism in our 

society. For example, children of color are more likely to experience suspension from school and adults of color face harsher punishments than their white peers for the same infractions. Lower educational attainment and incarceration both have long-term negative impacts on health and well-being by decreasing employment opportunities and income potential.[19,20] Therefore, school suspension and incarceration rate were selected as indicators for HNC 2030. 

## **Structural Racism and Health Outcomes – An Example** 

Looking to infant mortality, we see that African American women are more likely to live in communities that have fewer educational resources and employment opportunities due to historical segregation through housing and education policies. These socioeconomic factors are linked to birth outcomes and infant mortality. In addition, even for African American women who attain a higher socioeconomic status, pregnancy-related outcomes are worse than those of white women at lower socioeconomic levels (Harper et al., 2004). On top of the “weathering” that African American women’s bodies experience through the stress of discrimination, research is now showing that African Americans who increase their socioeconomic status may face added negative health effects through increased experiences of acute discrimination as they work and live in predominately white environments (Colen et al., 2018). Inside the medical system, disparate treatment of African American mothers may also play a role. Studies show that implicit bias in health care delivery may prevent African American women from receiving sufficient patient education in the prenatal period about risks to maternal and fetal health (Lu, et al., 2010), and may also contribute to African American women’s increased risk of life-threatening conditions such as preeclampsia and postpartum hemorrhage (ACOG Postpartum Toolkit, 2018; Howell et al., 2018; Gyamfi-Bannerman et al., 2018). Thus, stressrelated impacts on the body, coupled with the implicit bias in health care, contribute to the disparate birth outcomes we continue to see for African American women and their babies (Lu et al., 2010). 

**Packet Pg. 236** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 31 

30 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

31
{16}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [1009 x 205] intentionally omitted <==**

**9.13.a** 

> **C H A P T E R 3** 

# SOCIAL & ECONOMIC FACTORS 

**==> picture [233 x 88] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [441 x 257] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 237** 

32 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

33 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{17}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## INTRODUCTION 

Factors like education, employment, income, family and social support, and community safety provide the foundation for health and wellbeing. These social and economic factors strongly determine where we live, the jobs we have, the people we interact with, and our day-to-day experiences. These factors are also highly inter-related. For example, educational attainment drives opportunities for employment, and thus income. Families with lower incomes have a higher likelihood of living in areas with poor quality schools and have fewer resources to send their children to college. People with higher incomes can choose safer communities to live in. 

Read an example below of how social and economic factors can impact an individual’s opportunities to achieve health and well-being.[E] For each health indicator, this report includes recommended evidenceinformed policies and practices to address that indicator of interest. We recommend community coalitions use multi-sector partnerships to pursue all the strategies recommended. 

**Social & Economic Factors and Health – Jennifer’s Experience** 

Social and economic factors drive all the topics that are covered Jennifer was raised by a single mother in a small, throughout this report: rural community in Western North Carolina. Her • Physical Environment – Our incomes often determine how close mother worked long hours at a minimum wage we live to areas for safe physical activity, the quality of our homes, job and couldn’t spend much time at home. Aside our access to healthy foods, and distance from known risks (e.g., from the stress of her living situation, Jennifer had tobacco shops). a learning disability that was never identified by • Health Behaviors – Many social and economic factors create the her local schools and she barely got by with passing opportunity, or lack of opportunity, for people to participate in behaviors that are important for supporting a healthy life. grades. When she was 16, she quit school to start • Clinical Care – People in low-income jobs often lack health working. Like her mother, her job had low wages insurance, decreasing access to the care they need. Areas of the and no opportunities for career advancement. A state with fewer resources also tend to have less geographic access year after she quit school, Jennifer gave birth to her to health care providers. first daughter. The baby was born several weeks • Health Outcomes – All of these factors combine to drive our prematurely and needed to be cared for at home health from birth to death, with people who face greater social for longer than Jennifer’s employer allowed her and economic challenges suffering higher rates of morbidity and mortality. to be away from work. Now, Jennifer’s mother is supporting her daughter and granddaughter by Social and economic factors often have long-lasting impacts on taking on another job. The stress of it all weighs on families. Families who face social and economic challenges may lack both Jennifer and her mother. Both deal with high equitable access to opportunities or the resources needed for social blood pressure and struggle with depression. They mobility, leaving their children with similar prospects for the future. In North Carolina, as in the rest of the country, people of color are don’t see how they can change their situation and disproportionately affected by these factors due to historical and worry what opportunities the new baby will have as current structural racism. The social and economic health indicators she grows up. 

Social and economic factors drive all the topics that are covered throughout this report: 

Social and economic factors often have long-lasting impacts on families. Families who face social and economic challenges may lack equitable access to opportunities or the resources needed for social mobility, leaving their children with similar prospects for the future. In North Carolina, as in the rest of the country, people of color are disproportionately affected by these factors due to historical and current structural racism. The social and economic health indicators selected for HNC 2030 highlight the impact of structural racism in our society directly (e.g., school suspension and incarceration) and indirectly (e.g., poverty and unemployment). 

## **HEALTH INDICATORS:** 

- **1 INDIVIDUALS BELOW 200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL (FPL)** 

   - Decrease the Number of People Living in Poverty 

- **2 UNEMPLOYMENT RATE** 

   - Increase Economic Security 

- **3 SHORT-TERM SUSPENSION RATE** Dismantle Structural Racism 

- **4 INCARCERATION RATE** Decrease the Incarceration Rate 

- **5 ADVERSE CHILDHOOD EXPERIENCES** Improve Child Well-Being 

- **6 THIRD GRADE READING PROFICIENCY** 

   - Improve Third Grade Reading Proficiency 

> _[E] Examples are of hypothetical scenarios commonly faced by individuals with health-related social needs._ 

**Packet Pg. 238** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 35 

34 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

35
{18}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 1: INDIVIDUALS BELOW 200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL (FPL)** 

**DESIRED RESULT: DECREASE THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE LIVING IN POVERTY** 

**DESIRED RESULT: DECREASE THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE LIVING IN POVERTY** 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

**CURRENT TARGET** 36.8% 27% (2013-17) **DEFINITION** Percent of individuals with incomes at or below 200% of the FPL 

_Income level is a strong predictor of a person’s access to resources and health status. Low income restricts access to quality housing, transportation, food, and education, which limits opportunities for people to live healthy lives.[F, G  ]_ 

## **Context** 

**DETAILS** Not applicable 

Poverty is directly linked to negative health outcomes. Income is central to accessing resources needed to be healthy such as safe housing, nutritious food, education, and transportation, as well as health services and treatment. Income is one of the greatest predictors of disease and mortality rates.[21] Low-income adults have higher rates of heart disease, diabetes, stroke, and other chronic disorders than their wealthier counterparts.[22] Income is an even stronger predictor of health disparities than race when considering the rates of disease within racial/ ethnic groups.[22] People below 200% of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL) are more likely to rate themselves in fair or poor health (20%), have higher rates of obesity (36%), and are more likely to be a current smoker (25%).[23] They have fewer medical care options, are more likely to be uninsured, and the upfront costs of services are a greater burden for them.[22] Mental health services can also be inaccessible for adults with low incomes.[24] Adults with family incomes below and near poverty experience more stress, particularly financial stress, which is detrimental to their overall health and well-being. 

**NC PERCENT OF INDIVIDUALS BELOW 200% FPL (2013-17)** 37% **2030 TARGET** 27% **RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** Not Available **RANK AMONG STATES (2017)** 39th* **DATA SOURCE** American Community Survey 

Lower-income earners are constrained in their options for where to live. Lower-cost housing tends to be in areas that are farther removed from services, require higher transportation costs, have overcrowding, and have greater exposure to hazardous toxins such as mold. These poor housing conditions correlate with the poor health conditions of low-income children such as asthma and elevated lead levels.[22] 

**STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** 

Children’s health is positively correlated to parents’ incomes, with children born to low-income mothers having a greater risk of low birth weight and higher rates of heart conditions, hearing problems, and intestinal disorders.[22] Controlling for children’s health at birth, those born to lower income parents are less healthy in adulthood than their wealthier peers[25] . 

North Carolina Perinatal Health Strategic Plan[F] - indicator of addressing social and economic inequities for families 

Early Childhood Action Plan[G] - Families living at or below 200% of FPL is a sub-target of all 10 goals in the Early Childhood Action Plan 

The five-year average of individuals below 200% FPL between 2013-17 in North Carolina was 37% compared to approximately 33% of families nationwide.[26] For 2019, 200% FPL for individuals was $24,980.[27 ] 

*Rank of 1st for state with lowest percent of individuals below 200% FPL 

_F North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. North Carolina Perinatal Health Strategic Plan: 2016-2020. March 2016. https://whb.ncpublichealth.com/phsp/ G North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. North Carolina Early Childhood Action Plan. February 2019. https://files.nc.gov/ncdhhs/ECAP-Report-FINAL-WEB-f.pdf_ 

**F I G U R E  5** 

Percent of individuals below 200% Federal Poverty Level across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target 

**==> picture [511 x 266] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
65%<br>63.6%<br>60%<br>55%<br>51.1% 51.5%<br>50%<br>46.1% [A]<br>45% CURRENT<br>40% 36.8% 38.7%<br>34.8%<br>35%<br>30.7% 30.6%<br>30%<br>25% TARGET<br>20% 27%<br>15%<br>10%<br>5%<br>NO DATA AVAILABLE<br>0%<br>W          B/AA        H/LX            O            A/PI            AI          MALE    FEMALE     ≤  200% 200-399% 400%+<br>W  = WHITE  O  = OTHER<br>B/AA  = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN A/PI  = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>H/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) AI  = AMERICAN INDIAN<br>A Two or more races<br>PERCENT OF INDIVIDUALS BELOW 200% FPL<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **Disparities** 

**Levers for Change** 

Nationally, children are the most likely of any age group to live in poverty, with 38.8% of people under the age of 18 living under 200% of the FPL compared to 26.2% aged 18 to 64 and 30.1% aged 65 and older.[28] Whites make up the largest share of those living with incomes below 200% of the FPL (58%). However, people of color are disproportionately more likely to live in poverty. In North Carolina, half of American Indians (52%) and African American (51%) and 64% of Hispanic individuals have incomes below 200% of the FPL, compared to 31% of whites. 

• Raise the minimum wage to $15 per hour (Children’s Defense Fund, 2019) 

• Increase the state earned income tax credit 

• 

Focus economic development on well-paying jobs Increase subsidized childcare Expand Medicaid eligibility Increase paid medical leave 

• 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

• 

Although the percentage of individuals below 200% FPL has been decreasing slowly over the past decade, North Carolina ranks 39th out of 50 states in this indicator (single-year estimate, 2017).[29] The HNC 2030 group looked at averages in other states across the country and set an ambitious target of 27% of individuals living below 200% of the FPL by the end of the next decade. The state with the lowest percentage is New Hampshire at 16%, and many other states are around 25%. A faster decrease in the percentage than seen over the past decade will be seen as a success, even if the exact target is not met by 2030. 

• 

• Improve teen pregnancy prevention • Improve 3rd grade reading proficiency, high school graduation rates, and support and strengthen the community college system • Reduce incarceration 

36 

**Packet Pg. 239** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 37 

37 

HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030
{19}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 2: UNEMPLOYMENT RATE** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: INCREASE ECONOMIC SECURITY** 

**==> picture [158 x 89] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
CURRENT TARGET<br>Reduce<br>7.2% unemployment disparity ratio<br>between white and<br>other populations to<br>1.7 or lower<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**DEFINITION** 

Percent of population aged 16 and older who are unemployed but seeking work 

**DETAILS** Data based on 5-year average 

**NC UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (2013-17)** State overall: 7.2%; _Disparity ratios:_ Black/white – 2.1 American Indian/white – 1.8 

**2030 TARGET** 

Reduce the unemployment disparity ratio between white and other populations to 1.7 or lower **RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** 3.5 – 13.4% **RANK AMONG STATES (2017)** Not Available 

**DATA SOURCE** American Community Survey 

**STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Not applicable 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

_Employment opportunities are vital to providing income and, for many, health insurance. While the state’s unemployment rate is at an all-time low overall, there are still communities and populations that face challenges finding employment opportunities_ 

## **Context** 

As of 2018, North Carolina’s unemployment rate has reached an all-time low of 3.9%. However, this figure masks significant disparities in access to economic opportunity as specific segments of the population face much higher rates, particularly rural residents and residents of color. 

Though unemployment is not an orthodox measure of health, economic well-being is inextricably linked to health outcomes. Without the necessary savings to cushion against sudden unemployment, the lost source of income can push people into poverty. Loss of income poses clear financial barriers to accessing resources that protect and improve health. Furthermore, because employer insurance is the most common form of coverage, insuring 56% of the population, job loss can also mean a rise in the uninsured population.[28] “[[Though unemployment is]] 

“[[Though unemployment is]] not an orthodox measure of health, economic wellbeing is inextricably linked to health outcomes. Without the necessary savings to cushion against sudden unemployment, the lost source of income can push people into poverty.” 

Beyond the financial strain, unemployment is correlated with adverse health outcomes related to stress. Treated as a stress-inducing event, the experience of unemployment increases vulnerability to stroke, heart attack, heart disease, and arthritis. Those laid off are more likely to have fair or poor health, have higher admissions to hospitals, and have a greater need for medical attention and medication.[30] For mental health issues such as distress, depression, anxiety, psychosomatic symptoms, subjective well-being, and self-esteem, one study found unemployed individuals were twice as likely to experience 

these problems compared to those who were employed.[31] Unemployment can also lead to increased unhealthy behaviors such as alcohol and tobacco consumption, poor diet, and less exercise which further exacerbates poor health and is compounded by limited income/resources to address illnesses.[32] 

## **F I G U R E  6** 

Unemployment across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target 

**==> picture [519 x 525] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
11.7%^<br>12%<br>11.0%^ [A]<br>11%<br>10.3%^<br>10%<br>9% CURRENT<br>8% 7.2% 7.1%<br>6.7%<br>7%<br>6.4%<br>5.7%^<br>6%<br>5.2%^<br>5%<br>TARGET<br>4% Reduce unemployment<br>disparity ratio between<br>white and other<br>3% populations to<br>1.7 or lower<br>2%<br>1%<br>NO DATA AVAILABLE<br>0%<br>W          B/AA        H/LX            O            A/PI            AI           MALE    FEMALE     <200% 200-399% 400%+<br>W  = WHITE  O  = OTHER RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>B/AA  = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN A/PI  = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>H/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) AI  = AMERICAN INDIAN<br>^ Includes Hispanic ethnicity     |    [ A]  Two or more races<br>Levers for Change<br>Disparities<br>•<br>Rural North Carolinians face higher levels of unemployment and poverty and earn less than urban  Increase workforce development efforts<br>residents. [33]  In some rural counties the unemployment rate is twice that of well-off metropolitan  targeted to reach those who need it<br>most<br>areas. [33]<br>•  Increase percentage of jobs that pay a<br>living wage<br>Racial and ethnic disparities also exist, with unemployment rates for African Americans and American  •  Improve personal finance credit scores<br>Indians nearly twice that of white populations (11.7%, 10.3%, and 5.7%, respectively, 2013-2017  and access to financial capital<br>average) and Hispanic populations also facing higher rates of unemployment (7.1%) as compared to  •  Expand transit options in rural and<br>low-income communities, and increase<br>the white population. [26]  African Americans are also disproportionately represented in economically<br>access to affordable personal vehicles<br>distressed rural areas. In 2018, unemployment in rural areas of the state was at 11.4% for African<br>•<br>Increase access to affordable childcare<br>Americans and 5.9% for whites. [33]<br>•  Improve educational outcomes and<br>increase participation in post-secondary<br>People who have been incarcerated face very high rates of unemployment, with one analysis finding  education<br>that 27% of this population is unemployed. [34]  Contributing factors include limited numbers of reentry  •  Support economic opportunities that<br>programs, employment and housing discrimination, and lack of qualifications and training for jobs  provide full-time employment and grow<br>local businesses<br>earning a livable wage.<br>•  Support “fair-chance” hiring policies<br>UNEMPLOYMENT RATE<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


_H This is largely due to seasonal employment patterns in agricultural industries. Unemployment is least severe in October hovering around 5% but spikes in December and January. This is true for all counties with high unemployment._ 

**Packet Pg. 240** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 39 

38 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

39
{20}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 2: UNEMPLOYMENT RATE** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: INCREASE ECONOMIC SECURITY** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: INCREASE ECONOMIC SECURITY** 

## DISMANTLE STRUCTURAL RACISM 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

disparities in the state and selected a target for 2030 of reducing the disparity ratio[I] between white and other populations to a maximum of 1.7. The current disparity ratio between African Americans and whites in North Carolina is 2.1 and for American Indians it is 1.8.[J ] This goal is relevant at both the state and county levels. 

The disparities we often see in health outcomes for people of color are rooted in the historical and continued structural racism found in our society that have resulted in inequitable opportunities for healthy lives.  Conscious and unconscious bias and stereotyping of people of color remains pervasive, influencing policies and institutions at the federal, state, and local levels.[35] This includes housing, education, and transportation policies that have either explicitly or implicitly resulted in discriminatory practices (e.g., redlining in housing, segregated schools, high-interest loan practices). 

“[Structural racism refers to the ] way public policies, institutional practices, cultural representations, and other social norms interact to generate and reinforce inequities among racial and ethnic groups.”[12,11] 

The state unemployment rate has been falling for nearly a decade and is likely near the lowest rate possible without negative consequences to other economic factors (e.g., inflation). While the overall unemployment rate has been at an historically low level, the disparities seen across geography and race/ethnicity in the state are concerning and are the primary reason the HNC 2030 group selected this health indicator. To set the target for 2030, the group looked at averages across counties in the state and other states and disparities among different racial and ethnic groups. Setting a target to lower or maintain the unemployment rate was identified as an unrealistic goal due to the greater economic climate in the country. Therefore, the group focused on the racial/ethnic 

Overall unemployment rate between counties will continue to be an important factor to address in coming years, particularly in rural areas. The HNC 2030 target of reducing disparities among racial/ethnic groups can encourage even those counties with the lowest unemployment rates to look more deeply at the rates across populations in the county. 

The impacts of structural racism are numerous, including unemployment, fewer educational resources, harsher punishments in schools and the judicial system, intergenerational poverty, and the accumulated stress of discrimination regardless of socioeconomic status (i.e., “weathering”).[18] These issues encompass many of the upstream causes of the poor health outcomes that are seen for people of color. Correcting these injustices will require acknowledgement and understanding of the issues, and intentional work to change them. Two HNC 2030 indicators serve as measures of structural racism: short-term suspensions from school and incarceration rate. These are not the only possible measures closely related to structural racism. Other indicators selected for HNC 2030 are also affected by the experiences that people of color have as a result of structural racism, although they were not chosen explicitly for that reason. 

## **F I G U R E  7** 

Percent of population in North Carolina aged 16+ unemployed but seeking work, not seasonally adjusted, one-year average 

**==> picture [456 x 281] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
13%<br>12.7%<br>12%<br>11.7%<br>11% 11.0%<br>10.8%<br>10%<br>9.7%<br>9%<br>8.3%<br>8%<br>7% 6.9%<br>6.2%<br>6%<br>5.3%<br>5%<br>4%<br>3.9%<br>3%<br>2%<br>1%<br>0%<br>2009      2010       2011       2012         2013         2014         2015        2016         2017          2018<br>Source: American Community Survey. Employment Status, 1-Year Estimates.<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **Structural Racism Example - School-to-Prison-Pipeline** 

The school-to-prison-pipeline refers to “the system of policies and practices that push students out of school and into the juvenile and adult criminal systems” (Youth Justice Project: Pipeline). Entry into the pipeline includes experiencing suspension, expulsion, truancy, drop-out, engagement with School Resource Officers, and court involvement (Youth Justice Project: Pipeline). There is extensive research and growing recognition of the linkage between early interaction and future entanglement in the criminal justice system. For example, suspension from school is linked with lower educational achievement and higher likelihood of involvement with the criminal justice system in the future (Rosenbaum, 2018). Youth of color, particularly boys, face disproportionately higher rates of school-based discipline and are therefore put at greater disadvantage for future interactions with the justice system. 

_I A disparity ratio is determined by dividing a rate or percentage for one group by the rate or percentage for another group. Ratios above 1.0 indicate disparities between the two groups. For example, an unemployment disparity ratio of 1.5 would indicate that a group is 1.5 times more likely to be unemployed than the comparison group. J Calculations based on 5-year unemployment averages from the American Community Survey._ 

**Packet Pg. 241** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 41 

40 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

41
{21}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 3: SHORT-TERM SUSPENSION RATE** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: DISMANTLE STRUCTURAL RACISM** 

**CURRENT** 

**TARGET** 

1.39 0.80 Per 10 students Per 10 students (2017-18) 

**DEFINITION** 

Number of out-of-school short-term suspensions in educational facilities for all grades per 10 students 

**DETAILS** Includes Kindergarten – 12th grade; short-term suspension is 10 days or less; data reflect total numbers of short-term suspensions that may include multiple suspensions per student 

**NC SHORT-TERM SUSPENSIONS (2017-18)** 1.39 per 10 students **2030 TARGET** 0.80 per 10 students 

**RANGE AMONG NC LOCAL EDUCATION AGENCIES** 0.0 – 8.22 per 10 students **RANK AMONG STATES** Not Available **DATA SOURCE** NC Department of Public Instruction 

**STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** 

North Carolina Perinatal Health Strategic Plan[K ] - indicator of addressing social and economic inequities 

_**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

_In the education system, children of color are disproportionately punished through mechanisms like short-term suspension from school. These punishments inhibit academic achievement and open a gateway that can, in time, lead to subsequent involvement with the justice system. Limitations in academic achievement can have lifelong effects on health and well-being.[K]_ 

## **Context** 

Exclusionary discipline (i.e., suspensions and expulsions) is a strong predictive factor for negative outcomes in students’ academic achievement and high school completion. Some of the negative student outcomes associated with suspension include: 

• lower academic performance, “ • higher rates of dropout, In North Carolina, on • failure to graduate on time, average, there were 3 short• lower academic engagement, and term suspensions for every • continued targeting for future disciplinary action.[36 ] 10 African American students These negative educational outcomes can have lifelong impacts compared to less than 1 shorton health as those with less education have more challenges term suspension for every 10 finding employment that provides a living wage and have ” white and Hispanic students. decreased levels of social supports. It is estimated that each additional year of education leads to around 11% more in annual income and high-paying jobs are more likely to provide benefits such as health insurance and paid leave.[37] 

Besides missing important class time essential for academic success, suspensions also force students to miss out on extracurricular activities key to accumulating the social experiences just as necessary for a high-quality life. 

## **Disparities** 

Across the nation, students of color are suspended and expelled at higher rates than their peers even though studies have shown no difference in behavior among students by race/ethnicity.[38] In North Carolina, on average, there were 3 short-term suspensions for every 10 African American students compared to less than 1 short-term suspension for every 10 white and Hispanic students ( **See Figure 9** ).[39] 

North Carolina’s suspension data reveal other stark disparities across different groups of students, including American Indian and multiracial students who are more likely to be suspended than their white, Asian, and Hispanic peers. Children receiving special education services account for 24% of all suspensions.[39] Boys receive the majority of suspensions, representing half of school populations but nearly two-thirds of suspensions. However, African American and American Indian girls had notably higher rates of suspension than their white peers, receiving 1.81 and 1.36 suspensions per 10 students, respectively, compared to 0.30.[39] 

## **F I G U R E  8** 

## Short-term suspension rates across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target 

**==> picture [518 x 393] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.00<br>3.00<br>2.75<br>2.46<br>2.50<br>2.25<br>2.09 [*]<br>1.98<br>2.00<br>CURRENT<br>1.69<br>1.75 1.39<br>1.50<br>1.25<br>0.88<br>1.00<br>0.73 0.74<br>0.75<br>TARGET<br>0.50<br>0.80<br>0.18 [^]<br>0.24<br>NO DATA<br>0 AVAILABLE<br>W          B/AA        H/LX            O           A/PI            AI           MALE    FEMALE     <200% 200-399% 400%+<br>WB/AA  = WHITE  = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN OA/PI  = OTHER = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>H/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) AI  = AMERICAN INDIAN ^ Asian Only   |   *Economically Disadvantaged students, as defined by NC Department or Public Instruction<br>F I G U R E  9<br>North Carolina Student Population and Short-Term Suspensions by Race<br>Levers for Change<br>NC STUDENT POPULATION BY RACE SHORT-TERM SUSPENSION BY RACE (Kostyo et al, 2018)<br>OTHER<br>B/AA OTHER 17.80% •  Train teachers, administrators, school<br>25.5% 25.4% B/AA resource officers, and others working<br>W 56.80% with students on implicit bias<br>W 25.4%<br>49.1% •  Develop collaborative learning groups<br>for schools to share best practices<br>SHORT-TERM SUSPENSIONS (PER 10 STUDENTS)<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


• Develop collaborative learning groups for schools to share best practices • Include suspension rate in measures of school quality 

_Source: Youth Justice Project. The State of Discipline in NC Schools. April 2018. http://youthjusticenc.org/2018/04/11/state-of-discipline/_ 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

• Develop statewide system of restorative justice programs 

The HNC 2030 group considered the current data across student race/ethnicity as a primary method for target setting. With white, Hispanic, and Asian around or below 0.80 suspensions per 10 students, this was chosen as the target for all students. Meeting this target is largely dependent upon eliminating the disparities we see in the use of short-term suspension for African American and American Indian students. With the growing understanding of disproportionate use of exclusionary discipline approaches, the group felt confident that significant movement toward the target could be achieved in the next decade. 

• Provide informational resources for schools on how to reduce disciplinary actions • Promote non-exclusionary approaches to discipline 

_K North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. North Carolina Perinatal Health Strategic Plan: 2016-2020. March 2016. https://whb.ncpublichealth.com/phsp/_ 

**Packet Pg. 242** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 43 

42 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

43
{22}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 4: INCARCERATION RATE** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: DECREASE THE INCARCERATION RATE** 

**==> picture [158 x 89] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
CURRENT TARGET<br>341 150<br> Per 100,000       Per 100,000<br>people      people<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**DEFINITION** Incarceration in North Carolina prisons per 100,000 population 

**DETAILS** Rate based on jurisdictional population with sentences greater than one year 

**NC INCARCERATION RATE (2017)** 341 per 100,000 people 

**==> picture [82 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
2030 TARGET<br>150 per 100,000 people<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [123 x 73] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES<br>NOT APPLICABLE<br>RANK AMONG STATES<br>21st*<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**DATA SOURCE** US Bureau of Justice Statistics 

**==> picture [119 x 44] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR<br>INDICATORS<br>Not Applicable<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [140 x 13] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
*Rank of 1st for state with lowest incarceration rate<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

_People of color, notably African American men, are imprisoned at disproportionate rates and tend to face harsher punishment for similar crimes as their white counterparts. There are enormous health, social, and economic consequences of incarceration for both the imprisoned person, their families, and our communities._ 

## **Context** 

Incarceration is a key health indicator for its sweeping effects on communities, families, and individuals. Communities with high rates of incarceration are affected by damage to social networks and family ties, increased poverty and crime, and reduced life expectancy.[40] High rates of incarceration weaken communities and contribute to adverse health outcomes.[41] For much of the 20th century, the incarceration rate in the United States (and internationally) averaged 110 inmates per 100,000 persons. A shift in U.S. crime policy at the local, state, and federal levels toward mandatory lengthy jail and prison sentences in the 1980s led to the prison boom (450 inmates per 100,000 persons) or mass incarceration. 

Families with an incarcerated adult member face economic hardships including housing insecurity, difficulty meeting basic needs, and increased use of public assistance.[35] Incarceration of a parent is a traumatic experience for a child, increasing their risk of depression and anxiety, antisocial behavior, substance abuse, involvement with crime, disengagement from school, and risky sexual behaviors.[35] (See Adverse Childhood Experiences, **Pages 46-47** ) 

Inmates are likely to develop chronic conditions such as hypertension, diabetes, arthritis, and asthma and are more at risk of contracting communicable diseases such as HIV, hepatitis C, and tuberculosis. Incarcerated individuals experience poor diets (high calorie, high fat, low nutrient density foods), low sanitation standards, presence of infestations, inmate violence, excessive use of force by officers, sexual violence, and lack of social connection.[43] Inmates are also at higher risk of dying from a drug overdose or suicide. These risk factors are exacerbated by conditions upon reentry into society such as limited resources, less educational attainment, disadvantages in employment, absence of drug rehabilitation resources, and unstable housing. Without proper rehabilitation, released into a less structured environment, and significantly disadvantaged due to their criminal records, the formerly incarcerated often fall into poverty and reoffend. 

## **Disparities** 

Application of law enforcement and sentencing has led to disproportionate incarceration rates, with African Americans making up 52% of the total incarcerated population, but only 22% of the state population.[44,45] For example, although drug use is lower among African Americans and rates of trafficking are not different based on race/ethnicity, African Americans are 6.5 times more likely to be incarcerated for drug-related offenses.[35] Numerous studies have shown systematic differences exist in outcomes for people of color from arrest, case processing, sentencing, and parole, all of which increase their likelihood of serving time in jail or prison.[35] 

## **F I G U R E  1 0** 

Incarceration rates across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target 

**==> picture [517 x 306] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
1000<br>915 [#]<br>900<br>800<br>700<br>649<br>600<br>500 CURRENT  488 [#]<br>341<br>400<br>300<br>203 [#] 209 [#]<br>200<br>100 TARGET 50<br>0 150 NO DATA AVAILABLE NO DATA AVAILABLE<br>W  = WHITE  O  = OTHER W           B/AA        H/LX            O           A/PI            AI           MALE    FEMALE     < 200% 200-399% 400%+<br>B/AAH/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN A/PIAI  = AMERICAN INDIAN = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER # Data from 2015 RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>F I G U R E  1 1<br>NC POPULATION ESTIMATE BY  NC PRISON POPULATION (2017)<br>RACE/ETHNICITY (2017) Levers for Change<br>(National Research Council, 2014)<br>•  Revise current criminal justice policies to<br>reduce the rates of incarceration<br>W      B/AA                OTHER W      B/AA                OTHER<br>64.1% 22.1% 13.8% 39.8% 52.3% 7.9% •  Improve conditions and programs<br>(PER 100,000 POPULATION)<br>INCARCERATION RATE IN NORTH CAROLINA PRISONS<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


• Revise current criminal justice policies to reduce the rates of incarceration 

• 

Improve conditions and programs in jails and prisons to reduce harmful impact and foster successful reintegration into community 

_Source:  North Carolina State Center for Health Statistics, Vital Statistics, 2017; NC Department of Public Safety, Annual Statistics Report 2016-2017. https://randp. doc.state.nc.us/pubdocs/0007081.PDF_ 

Incarceration rates across North Carolina’s counties also show disparities in the state. Figures from 2015 show the highest incarceration rate for African Americans was in Graham County with 2,864 per 100,000 African American residents (compared to 279 per 100,000 for whites) and for American Indians at 3,426 per 100,000 American Indian residents in Gates County (compared to 174 per 100,000 for whites).[47] In North Carolina, 17% of inmates have mental illnesses (3-4 times more than the general public).[44] 

**==> picture [121 x 80] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
•  Improve educational outcomes,<br>particularly for boys of color<br>•  Reduce intergenerational and<br>neighborhood poverty<br>•  Improve access to treatment for<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Improve access to treatment for substance use disorders, physical illnesses, and mental illnesses 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

North Carolina currently has the 21st lowest incarceration rate of the 50 states and the rate has been declining over the past decade. With this trend and considering the lowest state rate (Massachusetts – 120 per 100,000), the HNC 2030 group selected an aggressive target of 150 people incarcerated per 100,000 population. Meeting this target will be very challenging and is almost entirely dependent upon sharply reducing the disparities we see in the disproportionate incarceration of African American and American Indian populations. While rates have been trending down, faster decreases in these trends in the next decade will be viewed as a success. 

• Increase employment opportunities and job training programs in disadvantaged communities 

• Implement standardized, evidencebased programs to reduce recidivism 

**Packet Pg. 243** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 45 

44 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

45
{23}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 5: ADVERSE CHILDHOOD EXPERIENCES** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: IMPROVE CHILD WELL-BEING** 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

**==> picture [141 x 89] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
CURRENT TARGET<br>23.6% 18.0%<br>(2016-17)<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


_Children’s experiences of adversity and trauma can have lifelong impacts on health and well-being. Trauma-informed and resilience building practices are gaining attention and are being implemented to help children overcome their experiences and circumstances.[L]_ 

## **Context** 

**DEFINITION** 

Children thrive in safe, stable, and nurturing environments. Adverse experiences, such as exposure to trauma, violence, or neglect during childhood, increase the likelihood of poor physical and mental health as a child grows up.[48] The more  Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) an individual has, the greater the risk for health-related challenges in adulthood. This includes a higher risk for coronary heart disease, stroke, asthma, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, much higher risk of depression, higher rates of risky health behaviors like smoking and heavy drinking, and more socioeconomic challenges.[49] Research has shown that exposure to these Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) can impact children’s neurobiological development, negatively affecting their learning, language, behavior, and physical and mental health. Decreasing childhood exposures to trauma, building resilience, strong relationships with caregivers, and providing safe, stable environments can help children overcome the impact of ACEs. 

Percent of children who have experienced two or more of the following: • Hard to get by on money • Parent/guardian divorced or separated • Parent/guardian died • Parent/guardian served time in jail • Saw or heard violence in the home • Victim/witness of neighborhood violence; • Lived with anyone mentally ill, suicidal, or depressed; • Lived with anyone with alcohol or drug problem; • Often treated or judged unfairly due to race/ethnicity 

While two-thirds of people have at least one ACE, the more ACEs a child accumulates the more at risk to chronic disease and risky health behaviors they become.[48] In North Carolina, almost 1 in 4 children ages 0-17 has experienced two or more ACEs, including 18% of children ages 0-5.[M,50 ] 

**DETAILS** Measure relies on parental report of experiences or aspects of their children’s 

## lives 

## **Disparities** 

**NC CHILDREN WITH 2+ ACES (2016-17)** 23.6% **2030 TARGET** 18.0% 

## Factors associated with greater risk of two or more ACEs for children in North Carolina include: 

• Living arrangements: living with a caregiver other than their parents, those in non-married two parent households, and those in single mother households[50] • Income: children in low-income households • Care Needs: Children with complex health care needs or emotional, behavioral, or developmental issues • Race and ethnicity: African American or Other, non-Hispanic (i.e., not white, Asian, or Hispanic) 

**RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** Not Available **RANK AMONG STATES** 32nd* 

**DATA SOURCE** Children’s National Health Survey **STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Early Childhood Action Plan[L] - indicator of safe and nurturing relationships *Rank of 1st for state with lowest percent of children with 2+ ACEs 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

North Carolina is currently tied at 32nd of the 50 states in the number of children with two or more ACEs, with 23.6% of children (with 1st representing the lowest percent of children with two or more ACEs). Aiming for a 25% decrease in this number by 2030, the HNC work group chose a target of 18.0% of children with two or more ACEs. In setting the ambitious target, they took into account data for the states with the lowest averages (2016-17 - California: 14.8%; Maryland: 15.6%; New Jersey: 15.6%), and the United States average (20.5%). 

> _L North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. North Carolina Early Childhood Action Plan. February 2019. https://files.nc.gov/ncdhhs/ECAP-Report-FINAL-WEB-f.pdf_ 

> _[M] Data collected through the Children’s National Health Survey by parent report of the experiences of their children._ 

## **F I G U R E  1 2** 

Percent children with two or more Adverse Childhood Experiences across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target 

**==> picture [515 x 503] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
50%<br>47.9%<br>45%<br>40%<br>36.0% 37.2%<br>35%<br>CURRENT<br>30%<br>23.6%<br>25% 23.2% 23.8% 23.5% 24.0%<br>19.9%<br>20%<br>17.5%<br>15% TARGET<br>11.1%<br>8.3%<br>10% 18.0%<br>5%<br>NO DATA<br>0% AVAILABLE<br>W          B/AA        H/LX            O           A/PI            AI           MALE    FEMALE     <100%   100- 199% 200-399%   400%+<br>RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>W  = WHITE  O  = OTHER<br>B/AA  = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN A/PI  = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>H/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) AI  = AMERICAN INDIAN<br>Due to societal forces that entrench ACEs  F I G U R E  1 3<br>in the lives of many people with lower  ACEs Among Children in North Carolina,  Levers for Change<br>incomes and people of color, reaching  2016-17<br>•  Increase minimum wage and<br>the selected target will be challenging.<br>employment opportunities<br>Movement toward the target will be<br>viewed as a success in decreasing  2+ ACE •  Increase opportunities for trauma-<br>childhood exposure to trauma. At the  23.6% informed parenting support<br>same time, negative impacts on the  •  Expand community and domestic<br>violence prevention initiatives<br>children experiencing these challenges<br>NO ACEs<br>can be mitigated by increasing  53.1% •  Increase access to behavioral health<br>trauma-informed practices in medical,  1 ACE treatment<br>educational, and other settings, and  23.3% •  Increase access to evidence-based<br>implementing strategies and programs  parenting programs and home visiting<br>to support families and children and  programs<br>foster resilience.<br>Source: Children's National Health Survey<br>CHILDHOOD EXPERIENCES<br>PERCENT OF CHILDREN WITH TWO OR MORE ADVERSE<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Due to societal forces that entrench ACEs in the lives of many people with lower incomes and people of color, reaching the selected target will be challenging. Movement toward the target will be viewed as a success in decreasing childhood exposure to trauma. At the same time, negative impacts on the children experiencing these challenges can be mitigated by increasing trauma-informed practices in medical, educational, and other settings, and implementing strategies and programs to support families and children and foster resilience. 

**Packet Pg. 244** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 47 

46 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

47
{24}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 6: THIRD GRADE READING PROFICIENCY** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: IMPROVE THIRD GRADE READING PROFICIENCY** 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

**==> picture [158 x 89] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
CURRENT TARGET<br>56.8% 80.0%<br>(2018-19)<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


_Reading proficiency is a strong predictor of educational and other health-related outcomes. Children who are not proficient in reading by the end of third grade face greater challenges in subsequent years of their education. Large disparities exist for African American, Hispanic, and American Indian children.[N,O]_ 

**DEFINITION** 

## **Context** 

Percent of children reading at a proficient level or above based on third grade End of Grade exams 

Early reading proficiency is a key indicator for academic and career success. Third grade is a pivotal point in primary education, because, up until third grade, children are learning to read; after third grade, children must be able to read to learn. Therefore, students who do not meet third grade reading proficiency requirements are at risk of being left behind. In North Carolina, over 40% of students, or more than 53,000 each year, are not reading on grade level by the end of third grade. These children are at increased risk for ongoing academic difficulties, leaving school without a diploma, and fewer employment prospects.[51] 

“Children who have low reading proficiency are more likely to drop out of school before graduation, which can have lifelong economic consequences, including low-wage jobs and limited access to health care.” 

**DETAILS** Proficiency defined as Level 3 or higher 

**NC THIRD GRADE READING PROFICIENCY (2018-19)** 56.8% **2030 TARGET** 80.0% 

For those who are not achieving grade-level reading by the end of third grade, disadvantages will compound as they grow older. Children who have low reading proficiency are more likely to drop out of school before graduation, which can have lifelong economic consequences, including low-wage jobs and limited access to health care.[51,52] Literacy levels have been linked to increased risk of hospitalization and numerous adverse health outcomes.[53] Studies show people with lower literacy levels are more likely to miss school, smoke, have depressive symptoms as a child, have severe asthma, and are less likely to breastfeed their children.[54] 

**RANGE AMONG NC LOCAL EDUCATION AGENCIES** 24.6 – 81.7% 

**RANK AMONG STATES** Not Applicable **DATA SOURCE** NC Department of Public Instruction 

## **Disparities** 

**STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Early Childhood Action Plan[O] - indicator of learning and children being ready to succeed Every Student Succeeds Act Consolidated State Plan[N] – Measure of progress: State Level Reading Grades 3-8 

In the 2018-19 school year, only 4 in 10 students from economically disadvantaged families[P] and children in foster care were reading at or above grade level at the end of third grade.[39] Around 40% of African American, American Indian, and Hispanic third graders were reading at or above third grade level compared to 70% and 76% of white and Asian students, respectively. Children who had disabilities (23.0%), were English learners[Q] (27.7%), or who were homeless (32.8%) were least likely to be proficient in reading. Performance varies widely by school district. Seventy percent or more of students are at or above proficient on the third grade reading assessment in five school districts (Camden, Chapel Hill-Carrboro City, Elkin City, Polk, and Madison) while ten fall below 40% (Bertie, Edgecombe, Greene, Halifax, Nash-Rocky Mount, Northampton, Scotland, Warren, Washington, and Weldon). 

> _[N] Consolidated Plan for the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965, as amended by the Every Student Succeeds Act. September 2017. http://www.ncpublicschools.org/docs/succeeds/nc-essa-state-plan-final.pdf_ 

> _[O] North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. North Carolina Early Childhood Action Plan. February 2019. https://files.nc.gov/ncdhhs/ECAP-Report-FINAL-WEB-f.pdf_ 

> _[P] “Economically disadvantaged” indicates those students eligible for free and reduced-price lunch under the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) for agency reporting purposes (NCDPI, 2017)._ 

> _[Q] Students who are in the process of learning English._ 

## **F I G U R E  1 4** 

Percent children who are proficient in reading at the end of third grade across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target 

**==> picture [469 x 224] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
100%<br>TARGET<br>90% 80.0%<br>75.6% [B]<br>80%<br>70.1% 70.6% [D]<br>70%<br>59.5% [A] 59.8%<br>60%<br>54.0%<br>50%<br>CURRENT  42.6% 44.5% 42.6% [C]<br>40.8%<br>40%<br>56.8%<br>30%<br>20%<br>NO DATA<br>AVAILABLE<br>10%<br>0%<br>W          B/AA        H/LX            O           A/PI            AI           MALE    FEMALE     < 200% 200-399% 400%+<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## 

RACE / ETHNICITY 

FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL 

**==> picture [11 x 10] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
SEX<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**W** = WHITE **O** = OTHER **B/AAH/LX** = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN **A/PIAI** = AMERICAN INDIAN = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER A - Two or more races,  B - Asian only,  C - Economically Disadvantaged students, as defined by NC Department or Public Instruction, D - Students who are not Economically Disadvantaged, as defined by NC Department of Public Instruction 

**Levers for Change** (North Carolina Early Childhood Action Plan, 2019) 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years and all Local Education Agencies (LEAs) • Expand access to NC Pre-K, 4-, and 5-star early to develop a target for third grade reading proficiency. Over the past five years, proficiency rates learning programs and other high-quality early childhood programs, particularly for children who have declined from 60.2% in the 2013-14 school year to 55.9% in 2017-18, with a slight increase are homeless, in foster care, are from immigrant to 56.8% in 2018-19. Across LEAs, the highest proficiency rate is in Camden County at 82%; only families, or who have disabilities or other special healthcare needs four other LEAs (Chapel Hill-Carrboro City, Elkin City, Polk, and Madison) have proficiency rates • Increase funding to public schools and early between 74-77%. Despite this, the HNC 2030 group chose to select an ambitious target to make learning programs that serve children with the a statement to state and local leaders about how critically important reading proficiency is to highest barriers to success, including children from low-income families and people of color lifelong health and well-being. Turning the trend and making improvements toward the goal of 80% of children reading at a proficient level by 2030 will be considered a success. Making a • Improve the rigor and responsiveness of birth through third grade teacher and administrator change in recent trends will be largely dependent upon eliminating the disparities we see in preparation programs proficiency rates for African American, Hispanic, and American Indian students. • Raise wages to attract, recruit, and retain highly qualified birth through third grade teachers • Increase access to home visiting programs for young children • Expand use of evidence-based literacy programs connected to health care (e.g., Reach Out and Read) 

**Packet Pg. 245** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 49 

48 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

49
{25}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

# DEVELOPMENTAL MEASURES 

The social and economic factors measure below is one that the HNC 2030 group feels is important to population health but does not have reliable or robust data available at this time. A description of the data needed for this measure is listed as “developmental data needs.” State and local public health or other entities should consider identifying methods for collecting this data. 

## **Developmental Progress at Kindergarten Entry** 

The quality of educational systems is typically evaluated through student achievement and outcome measures, such as end of grade exam scores, drop-out, and graduation rates. These are important indicators for schools, yet the building blocks for learning begin much earlier. Students who enter Kindergarten at a deficit compared to their peers may face ongoing challenges throughout their years of education and can experience poor outcomes. A child’s readiness for Kindergarten is dependent on a variety of cognitive, social, and behavioral factors. 

The North Carolina Department of Public Instruction’s (NC DPI) Office of Early Learning is currently implementing a Kindergarten Entry Assessment (KEA). The KEA was developed with input from teachers, parents, and other stakeholders and includes five domains that are consistent with research and expertise in the area of school readiness: approaches to learning, cognitive development, emotional-social development, health and physical development, and language development and communication.[55] For the 2017-18 school year, 49.9% of children entering Kindergarten were assessed as ready for Kindergarten.[56] 

## Developmental data needs: 

• The comprehensive KEA has been implemented across the state since the 2016-2017 school year. Currently data are available for individual elementary schools, but not at the district level. As the assessment results continue to be analyzed and explored, local and statewide practitioners and policymakers should consider how these data can be used to inform decisions that can better support incoming students and the educators and staff who serve them. 

# **C H A P T E R 4** 

# PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT 

**==> picture [233 x 88] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [441 x 257] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 246** 

50 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

51 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{26}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## INTRODUCTION 

The places we live, learn, work, play, and age make up our physical environment. That environment is defined by structures, such as sidewalks, homes, and stores, but also by the air we breathe, the food we eat, and the water we drink, cook, and bathe with. These components of our environment directly and indirectly affect our health. 

**• DIRECT EFFECTS ON HEALTH** – The cleanliness of our water determines what contaminants we are exposed to, such as leadpoisoning hazards, that can have long-term impacts on our health and likelihood of disease morbidity. Access to safe and healthy food impacts both short- and long-term well-being. The air we breathe can determine our exposure to particulate matter and other toxins that can cause or exacerbate asthma or other respiratory conditions. Exposure to secondhand smoke is an independent risk factor for coronary heart disease, stroke, low birthweight babies, lung cancer in adults as well as Sudden Infant Death Syndrome and respiratory and middle ear disease in children. 

**• INDIRECT EFFECTS ON HEALTH** – Built environments and public policy (e.g., tobacco-free policies) often determine our proximity to safe places to play or participate in other physical activities, our ability to get from place to place, and exposure to harmful conditions in our own homes and communities. 

Many of the environmental conditions we are exposed to are determined by the social and economic factors we have in our lives, such as income and employment. The environments we live in often determine our ability to make choices about things like what we eat, how we spend our time, whether we exercise, and how long we spend commuting. 

The HNC 2030 health indicators for the physical environment look at access to healthy food, proximity to places for physical activity, and prevalence of housing quality problems. However, these issues do not stand alone. Transportation, community safety, and health education are among the cross-cutting factors that play into the choices people make about how they navigate their environment and their opportunity to make choices that are good for their health. 

**TRANSPORTATION:** Lack of public or personal transportation remains an obstacle for many people. Regardless of proximity, lack of sidewalks and unsafe pedestrian thoroughfares may mean people need to use public transportation to reach parks and other recreational facilities. Physical disabilities too may affect people’s ability to navigate their communities. 

**NEIGHBORHOOD SECURITY:** Neighborhoods experiencing crime or lacking in pedestrian-friendly areas (e.g., well-maintained sidewalks, crosswalks across busy roads, and well-lit pathways) may effectively keep in residents and prevent them from accessing parks or grocery stores within walking distance. 

**HEALTH EDUCATION:** Measures of access prioritize proximity to facilities or structures and do not evaluate individual motivation to seek out resources. What people know about activities that promote health, or their level of health education, plays a role in boosting or inhibiting their ability to make healthy choices. For example, people who are less knowledgeable about healthy ways to eat may not take advantage of access to grocery stores with healthy foods regardless of how close they are to them. 

Read an example below of how social and economic factors can impact an individual’s opportunities to achieve health and well-being.[R] For each health indicator, this report includes recommended evidenceinformed policies and practices to address that indicator of interest. We recommend community coalitions use multi-sector partnerships to pursue all the strategies recommended. 

## **Physical Environment and Health - Diego’s Experience** 

Diego is a farm worker in rural North Carolina. He lives 15 miles from the nearest grocery store, so he often shops at a nearby corner store, where he buys packaged meat and canned goods. His cholesterol and blood pressure are high due to his diet. He shares a small home with five other farm workers with poor plumbing that the landlord refuses to repair. Diego and his roommates share one car between them, leaving him isolated from family and social activities. 

## **HEALTH INDICATORS:** 

- **7** 

## **ACCESS TO EXERCISE OPPORTUNITIES** 

## Increase Physical Activity 

## **8 LIMITED ACCESS TO HEALTHY FOODS** Improve Access to Healthy Foods 

- **9 SEVERE HOUSING PROBLEMS** 

## Improve Housing Quality 

_R Examples are of hypothetical scenarios commonly faced by individuals with health-related social needs._ 

**Packet Pg. 247** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 53 

52 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

53
{27}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 7: ACCESS TO EXERCISE OPPORTUNITIES** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: INCREASE PHYSICAL ACTIVITY** 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

**==> picture [158 x 89] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
CURRENT TARGET<br>73% 92%<br>(2010/18)<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**F I G U R E  1 5** 

_Exercise is linked to positive physical, psychological, and social outcomes. Communities that create spaces for physical activity have healthier people with decreased risks of obesity, heart disease, and other chronic conditions that increase morbidity and mortality.[T]_ 

Percent of People with Access to Exercise Opportunities in North Carolina Counties, 2018 

**DEFINITION** 

## **Context** 

Percent of the population living half a mile from a park in any area, one mile from a recreational center in a metropolitan area, or three miles from a recreational center in a rural area 

> One of the most important things communities can do to improve “Regular physical activity the health of their people is to provide opportunities for physical fosters positive growth activity.[57] Research shows that everyone, regardless of health and development, status, benefits from being physically active. Regular physical improves brain health, activity fosters positive growth and development, improves and reduces the risk of brain health, and reduces the risk of a large number of chronic diseases.[57] Physical activity, or exercise, is a protective factor for a large number of 

> many chronic health conditions, premature mortality, and poor chronic diseases.” cardiovascular health.[58] 

**DETAILS** 

**0% - 29% (6 Counties) 30% - 49% (16 Counties) 50% - 69% (36 Counties) 70% - 89% (29 Counties) 90% - 100% (13 Counties)** 

Exercise access is based on census tract proximity to public parklands or recreational facilities such as “gyms, community centers, dance studios, pools,” and other exercise facilities **NC ACCESS TO EXERCISE OPPORTUNITIES (2010/18)** 73% of population 

The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services recognizes physical activity  as a means of improving health and preventing negative health outcomes.[57] However, in order to exercise, people must have access to safe places to be physically active. Such spaces include crime-free neighborhoods with sidewalks and bike lanes, well-maintained parks and recreation facilities, playgrounds, senior centers, sports fields, and other designated spaces to exercise.[57] Studies have shown that those who live in communities that facilitate easy access to exercise opportunities are better able to engage in physical activity.[58] 

_Source: County Health Rankings & Roadmaps; https://www.countyhealthrankings.org/app/north-carolina/2019/measure/factors/132/data_ 

**2030 TARGET** 92% of population 

**Levers for Change** (CDC, 2017; County Health Rankings, 2019) • Increase number of community parks, particularly in rural areas • Expand transit options to include places for physical recreation • Maintain safe and well-lit sidewalks • Increase number of biking, walking trails, and greenways • Support community walking clubs and public fitness classes • Increase access to evidenced-based and informed interventions that support physical activity in childcare, schools, churches, workplaces and other community-based settings 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years and projected a future level to develop a target for exercise access. The group chose 92% of the population having access to exercise opportunities as the target for 2030. This would reflect an acceleration in the current slow positive trend and signal a substantive step toward improving the physical health and well-being of North Carolina communities. 

**RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** 6 – 100% 

## **Disparities** 

**RANK AMONG STATES** Tied for 40th* 

Income level, race/ethnicity, and geography all have an impact on one’s access to exercise opportunities. Low-income communities may not have as many parks or as many recreational facilities as their more affluent counterparts.[59] People of color are less likely to live in areas with accessible parks or development of recreational facility systems.[58] Rural areas face more barriers to exercise access than their metropolitan counterparts.[60] Additionally, persons with physical disabilities may face difficulties accessing parks and recreational facilities that have necessary accommodations.[61] 

**DATA SOURCE** County Health Rankings and Roadmaps - Business Analyst, Delorme map data, ESRI, & US Census Tiger line Files 

**STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Not Applicable 

• Increase the number of joint use agreements for school playground facilities • Provide public access to municipal recreation facilities (NC DHHS, 2018) 

*Rank of 1st for state with best access to exercise opportunities 

> _[T] This measure does not account for sidewalks or other non-parkland spaces that can be used for exercise (CHR, 2019). Additionally, it measures access on distance alone, without taking into account physical barriers that might complicate access, such as busy roads or limited entryways to the park (CHR, 2019). Finally, it has no cost measure, and includes recreation facilities that may have financial barriers for the residents of the census block (CHR, 2019)._ 

**Packet Pg. 248** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 55 

54 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

55
{28}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 8: LIMITED ACCESS TO HEALTHY FOODS** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: IMPROVE ACCESS TO HEALTHY FOODS** 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

**F I G U R E  1 6** 

**CURRENT TARGET** 7% 5% (2015) 

_Food is a basic building block of health that affects weight, blood pressure, and countless other health outcomes. Access to healthy foods is strongly influenced by where someone lives. People in rural or underserved areas of North Carolina are particularly affected by lack of access to stores where they can purchase ingredients for healthy meals._ 

Percent of People with Limited Access to Healthy Foods in North Carolina Counties, 2015 

**DEFINITION** 

Percent of people who are low-income that are not in close proximity to a grocery store 

## **Context** 

“ Good nutrition is an essential factor in individuals’ mental and Limited access to healthy physical health. However, in many communities, affordable and foods has been linked to nutritious food is not easily accessible. In some areas, fast food obesity, cardiovascular and convenience stores abound yet access to  supermarkets is conditions, nutritional limited.[62] While individuals’ food choices are important, food choices are constrained by what is available.[63] Limited access deficiencies, diabetes, and ” to healthy foods has been linked to obesity, cardiovascular chronic kidney disease. conditions, nutritional deficiencies, diabetes, and chronic kidney disease.[64,65] Obesity and obesity-related conditions are now the second leading preventable cause of disease and death in the United States.[66] 

## **DETAILS** 

For metropolitan communities, living close to a grocery store is defined as being less than a mile from a store; in rural areas, the threshold proximity is 10 miles from a grocery store 

**0% (5 Counties) 1% - 3% (33 Counties) 4% - 6% (24 Counties) 7% - 9% (21 Counties) 10%+ (15 Counties) Not Available** 

**NC LIMITED ACCESS TO HEALTHY FOOD (2015)** 7% of population 

**2030 TARGET** 5% of population 

Areas with populations of individuals who have limited access to healthy foods are considered to be “food deserts.” In North Carolina, there are more than 340 food deserts, affecting more than half a million residents in the state.[67] Although persons living in food deserts may still have access to small food retailers such as corner or convenience stores, the food sold by these stores rarely meets nutritional needs.[68] Additionally, farmers’ markets or other farm stands may be helpful supplementary sources of healthy food, but their limited offerings, higher prices, and short operating hours may limit benefits to low-income communities.[65] As such, this measure only includes proximity to grocery stores and supermarkets, which has been linked to increasing access to healthy foods.[69] 

_County Health Rankings & Roadmaps; https://www.countyhealthrankings.org/app/north-carolina/2019/measure/factors/83/data_ 

**RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** 0 - 35% 

**Levers for Change** 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

**RANK AMONG STATES** Tied for 26th* 

• 

Increase technological support for SNAP/ EBT payments at food retailers 

The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years and projected a future level to develop a target for access to affordable food. The HNC 2030 group chose 5% as the target for the percent of the population that is low-income who are not in close proximity to a grocery store. The percent of the low-income population facing lack of access to grocery stores has remained static at 7% for the last 5 years after decreasing from 10% from 2006 to 2010. This target would bend the curve and be a meaningful step toward ensuring that all North Carolinians have access to healthy foods, regardless of income level. 

• Expand transit options in rural and lowincome communities • Support tax-incentive programs designed to encourage grocery stores and farmers markets to move into food deserts 

**DATA SOURCE** 

County Health Rankings and Roadmaps - United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) **STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Not Applicable 

## **Disparities** 

Race and income influence access to healthy food and likelihood of living in a food desert. Low-income neighborhoods and those with large minority populations are less likely to have supermarkets or other grocery stores, and the available stores often have more limited healthy options and may have higher prices than their counterparts in wealthier communities.[70,71] 

• Support nonprofit grocery stores working to meet the needs of residents of food deserts • Support school-based meal programs • Increase access to healthy foods in childcare, schools, churches, workplaces and other community-based settings 

*Rank of 1st for state with least limitations in access to healthy foods 

**Packet Pg. 249** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 57 

56 

57 

HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030
{29}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 9: SEVERE HOUSING PROBLEMS** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: IMPROVE HOUSING QUALITY** 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

**F I G U R E  1 7** 

**CURRENT TARGET** 16.1% 14.0% (2011-2015) **DEFINITION** Percent of households with at least 1 of 4 housing problems **DETAILS** Housing problems included are overcrowding, high housing costs, or lack of kitchen or plumbing facilities 

_People who live in homes that cost a large portion of their income, or where there is overcrowding or poor maintenance, are exposed to a variety of health risk factors. In many areas of North Carolina, there are insufficient affordable, quality housing options for low-income people and their families.[U]_ 

**==> picture [481 x 222] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Percent of People with Severe Housing Problems in North Carolina Counties, 2018<br>10% - 13% (18 Counties)<br>14% - 15% (27 Counties)<br>16% - 17% (30 Counties)<br>18% - 19% (12 Counties)<br>20% - 26% (13 Counties)<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **Context** 

Housing quality is an important determinant of overall health and well-being. Studies show that there is a direct link between housing quality and physical and mental health.[72] In North Carolina, 1 in 6 households across the state face severe housing problems, which means that at least one of the following problems is present: overcrowding,[V ] high housing costs,[W] or lack of kitchen and/or plumbing facilities.[X,67] In North Carolina, utilizing best-available data, approximately 14,000 households are overcrowded, 18,000 households lack complete plumbing, 24,000 households lack sufficient kitchen facilities, and half a million households face severe cost burden.[67,26] 

**NC SEVERE HOUSING PROBLEMS (2011-2015)** 16.1% of population 

Severe housing problems can exacerbate other housing quality issues such as environmental contaminant and repair issues.  Environmental triggers, such as exposure to mold, pests (cockroaches, mice, dust mites), chemicals, dust,  pet dander, secondhand smoke and thirdhand smoke - which lingers in carpets, drapes and other surfaces and can re-aerate - can exacerbate asthma and may be worsened by overcrowding, which increases risk of respiratory infections and psychological stressors that impact chronic conditions.[73] 

**2030 TARGET** 14.0% of population 

## _Source: Source: County Health Rankings & Roadmaps; https://www.countyhealthrankings.org/app/north-carolina/2019/measure/factors/136/data_ 

**RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** 10 - 26% **RANK AMONG STATES** 28th* **DATA SOURCE** County Health Rankings and Roadmaps - Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy (CHAS) data 

_**LACK OF KITCHEN AND/OR PLUMBING FACILITIES:**_ Lack of sufficient plumbing can pose sanitation risks that put inhabitants’ and others’ health at risk.[75] Untreated wastewater (effluent) surfacing outdoors or backing up into a home is a pathogen exposure concern and may also contaminate drinking water wells and nearby surface water. In addition, surfacing effluent provides breeding areas for mosquitoes and flies. Lack of kitchen facilities and inability to cook within the home has been connected to food insecurity and poor nutrition, both of which contribute to negative health outcomes such as diabetes and obesity.[78] 

**Levers for Change (RWJF, How home affects health)** 

_**OVERCROWDING:**_ Overcrowding can lead to many negative health consequences—particularly respiratory conditions such as asthma and tuberculosis, and mental health conditions that may be exacerbated by chronic stress produced by space-sharing conflicts.[74,75] 

• Increase living wage employment opportunities • Enforce fair housing laws • Improve access to social services and resources for affordable housing • Increase involvement of community members in decision-making • Support programs designed to increase home ownership for people of color 

_**HIGH HOUSING COSTS:**_ High housing costs[Z] have an interactive effect on the other housing problems— increasing the likelihood that individuals are forced to reduce spending on food, health care, and other necessities in order to pay housing expenses.[76,74] Individuals facing high housing costs are also less likely to have established health care providers, are less likely to get sufficient care for chronic conditions, and are more likely to seek care from emergency departments .[77] Severe cost burden forces families to choose between disproportionately allocating income for housing at the expense of other necessities, or alternatively, choosing poor quality housing options that are more affordable. This choice is particularly acute for renters, who face severe housing problems at higher rates than homeowners. Faced with severe cost burden, renters may be forced to choose housing options in unsafe neighborhoods that are poorly maintained, lack sufficient facilities, and are plagued by environmental issues such as lead paint and mold. These hazards produce additional mental stress, are linked to negative health outcomes, and compound preexisting chronic conditions.[76,74] 

## **Disparities** 

Severe housing problems do not affect the population uniformly, and distribution tracks with high rates of poverty and historic segregation that have confined people of color to under-resourced residential areas.[79] Therefore, disparities primarily arise along geographic, racial, educational, and income lines. Metropolitan residents and racial and ethnic minorities are more likely than their rural and white counterparts, respectively, to face all components of severe housing problems. Severe housing problems are also most prevalent among the poorest residents of North Carolina and affect renters at higher rates than homeowners.[76] Illustrating this fact, approximately 65% of residents own their homes, but homeowners are disproportionately white.[80] Among white residents living in the state, 71.2% live in a 

**STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Early Childhood Action Plan[U] includes indicators of safe and secure housing *Rank of 1st for state with least severe housing problems 

- _U North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. North Carolina Early Childhood Action Plan. February 2019. https://files.nc.gov/ncdhhs/ECAP-Report-FINAL-WEB-f.pdf_ 

- _V Overcrowding is defined as having more than 1 person per room of a residence, not inclusive of bathrooms. W High housing costs are assessed according to a cost burden analysis. An individual is severely cost burdened if his or her monthly housing costs exceed 50% of his or her monthly income. “Housing costs” are defined by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development as mortgage payments, rent payments, insurance payments, property taxes, and utility bills._ 

_X The Census Bureau evaluates household facilities according to the presence of six features: hot and cold running water, a flushing toilet, a bathtub or shower, a sink with a faucet, a stove, and a refrigerator. If a home does not have one of these factors, the census recognizes it as lacking in critical facilities (County Health Rankings, Severe Housing Problems). Y These additional environmental contaminants are not included in the measure of severe housing problems._ 

- _Z A contributing factor to cost burden is increasing energy costs. Across North Carolina, many homeowners spend 3-8% of their incomes on energy while renters may face energy costs in excess of 8% of their incomes. Although there is no conventional measure for energy costs disaggregated from housing cost burden, the Federal Department of Health and Human Services considers costs in excess of 6% of one’s income to be “unaffordable” (NC Housing Coalition, Mapping Housing Affordability in North Carolina)._ 

**Packet Pg. 250** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 59 

58 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

59
{30}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT: DEVELOPMENTAL MEASURES 

home they own, compared with only 43.9% of African American residents, and 43% of Hispanic residents.[3] Renters often do not have the ability to make changes to their residences to improve plumbing and kitchen facilities and face high housing costs/ severe cost burden at higher rates than homeowners. 

In addition, the multidimensional impacts of major natural disasters like Hurricanes Matthew (October 2016), Florence (September 2018), and Dorian (September 2019) illuminate the lack of safe and affordable housing in North Carolina in general, and expose interconnected layers of social vulnerability that have existed for decades in the housing sector throughout the state. Hurricane Matthew damaged or destroyed nearly 100,000 homes and displaced thousands of people. In some communities Matthew destroyed a significant amount of previously available rental housing stock - including low-income housing options.[81] Before Hurricane Florence made landfall, North Carolina had a shortage of 190,000 affordable housing units, in its wake there’s a shortage of 300,000 units.[82] As a result, developing strategies to help facilitate access to safe and affordable housing has quickly emerged as a short- and long-term recovery priority for the state. 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years and projected a future level to develop a target for severe housing problems. The group chose 14% as the target percent of households affected by one or more of the four severe housing problems as the target for 2030. The current measure of 16.1% is a slightly lower percentage than was seen in the state from 2012-2014, but the percentage is expected to trend upwards again over the next decade. Achieving the 14% target would reflect a meaningful reversal in the projected trend. 

Below are physical environment measures that the HNC 2030 group feels are important to population health, but do not have reliable or robust data available at this time. A description of the data needed for these measures is listed as “developmental data needs.” State and local public health or other entities should consider identifying methods for collecting this data. 

## **Air and Water Quality** 

The public is frequently exposed to environmental contaminants. Some environmental contaminants may not yet be identified and still others are not yet regulated. A better understanding of health effects of these contaminants and the risk of combined exposures is essential to better policies around environmental exposures.[AA] 

## Developmental data needs: 

• Advancements in analytical, research, and health sciences are needed to identify and quantify specific chemicals and classes of chemicals present in the environment to which people are exposed and at what exposure concentrations adverse health effects are a concern to the exposed generation and subsequent generations. This work would be followed by measures to reduce potentially harmful exposures. 

## **Access to Food** 

The Physical Environment Work Group chose the measure “Limited access to healthy foods” to draw attention to the needs of populations that are low income and do not have close access to foods. This measure is slightly limited in its scope, specifically measuring proximity to grocery stores and supermarkets. While this is an important measure, it may not fully represent a population’s access to foods. 

## Developmental data needs: 

• In addition to data on limited access to healthy foods, as measured for the HNC 2030 indicator, attention should be given to other potential approaches to provide access to food. Communities across the state have implemented healthy corner store initiatives, SNAP/ EBT support, payment incentive programs for farmers’ markets, and other methods to bring people closer to healthier options. Additionally, nonprofit organizations like the Inter-Faith Food Shuttle have worked to bring farmers’ market goods directly to low-income communities. To better capture these strategies and the effect that they have on North Carolinians, surveys such as the BRFSS and other county-level survey systems could be used to collect data on people’s access to healthy foods and evaluate remaining barriers. 

## **Access to Exercise Opportunities** 

The chosen HNC 2030 indicator of access to exercise opportunities is also limited in scope. The measure is calculated using Census data on the location of parks and recreational facilities using standard industry classification codes. It does not include access to sidewalks, malls, schools, and other locations that may provide opportunities for recreation. It also does not measure whether the recreational facilities are meaningfully accessible for community members as it does not capture cost barriers, time restrictions that may limit access to public spaces, and physical restrictions such as busy streets.  However, it is an important and reliable data source to identify communities where there may be fewer places for physical activity. 

## Developmental data needs: 

- Communities across the state have used additional methods to increase access to physical activity, such as building sidewalks and implementing shared use agreements designed to increase public access to school fields and playgrounds. While communities monitor the HNC 2030 indicator of access to exercise opportunities, they should also evaluate other ways their population can increase access that work best for them. 

## **Transportation and Access to Needed Destinations** 

A consistent concern shared by community members who provided input was access to reliable public transportation. Transportation is vital to sustained employment, maintaining social connections, and accessing food, medical care, and other resources. Despite the importance of this driver of health, there are few robust and reliable measures of public transportation availability and the ability of individuals to reach a desired location. 

## Developmental data needs: 

• Comprehensive measures of transportation needs, availability, and transit system effectiveness would help local and state health and transportation policymakers and planners to target the areas with the most need. North Carolina’s varying geography, from coastal areas to the mountains, provides different challenges to transportation access. These varying challenges must be accounted for when considering best measures for transportation needs. 

_AA Based on perspective shared by North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality participant in HNC 2030 process._ 

**Packet Pg. 251** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 61 

60 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

61
{31}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**Climate Change and Disaster Preparedness** According to the CDC, climate change has led to precipitation extremes, with heavy precipitation and drought events across the country that are projected to increase in all U.S. regions.[83] Heavy precipitation that causes flooding has immediate dangers to life and long-term ramifications on housing (discussed on **Page 60** ), mental health, and stress. Globally, warming temperatures are contributing to sea level rise. In North Carolina, estimates show that sea levels will rise one to four feet over the next century, drastically impacting people living in coastal areas.[84] Increased temperatures may impact crop yields and reduce livestock productivity.[84] An increasing number of days with high heat will impact populations vulnerable to heat-related illnesses like heat stroke and dehydration, such as children, older adults, and people who live in poverty.[84] High heat also creates more ground-level ozone, which can lead to increased asthma and risk of death from heart or lung disease.[84] 

North Carolina is beginning state-level efforts to decrease the amount of greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide, produced in the state that contribute to global climate change. Governor Roy Cooper signed Executive Order Number 80 in October 2018, supporting the 2015 Paris Agreement and calling on state agencies to collaborate on the reduction of energy use and development of climate adaption and resiliency planning.[85] Regardless of actions taken now, projections show that coastal communities will continue to experience impacts of heavy precipitation events and rising sea levels. Disaster preparedness and resiliency planning is vital to ensuring the health, safety, and economy of the eastern half of North Carolina. 

## Developmental data needs: 

• Ongoing monitoring of county-level and regional greenhouse gas production and climate change resiliency planning will be important in coming years. Resiliency planning will vary by region of the state and should account for the needs of various populations, such as individuals living in poverty. A variety of measures can be used to evaluate the impacts of climate change on populations, from number of days schools close for adverse weather events and number of extreme heat days, to the percent of the population in counties impacted by extreme weather who live in poverty. 

# **C H A P T E R 5** 

## HEALTH BEHAVIORS 

**==> picture [233 x 88] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [441 x 257] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 252** 

62 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

63 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{32}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## INTRODUCTION 

The things we put into and do with our bodies affect our health. What we eat, whether we exercise, wear seat belts, use substances like tobacco and alcohol, and our sexual health all directly promote or inhibit healthy living. A healthy diet and frequent exercise can help our bodies work as well as possible, while excessive eating, drinking, and substance use can lead to serious health conditions. These are called health behaviors. 

Our health behaviors are not always determined by a choice to be healthy or unhealthy. In particular, the places we live, learn, work, and play, as well as our social and economic circumstances and exposure to trauma often dictate our opportunities to make healthy choices. 

**• SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC FACTORS** – Individuals with low incomes and long work hours may have less time to prepare meals at home and less time to participate in physical activities. Their stress levels or history of trauma may make them more likely to use substances like alcohol or tobacco. Advertisers of unhealthy foods or products target low-income communities and people of color. People with higher levels of education may have more knowledge and access to information about safe sexual practices, healthy eating, and the dangers of tobacco use. 

**• PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT** – People in rural areas and lowincome communities may be far from a grocery store that sells healthy foods. Their communities may lack formal facilities for exercise, or the roads and public spaces may not be safe to move around in. 

The HNC 2030 health indicators chosen for the health behaviors topic area represent a range of issues and impact a variety of communities. Multiple indicators – drug overdose deaths and HIV diagnosis rates - highlight some issues, like injection drug use. Some indicators are not health behaviors themselves but are representative of a behavior. Most notable in this category are the teen birth and HIV diagnosis rates. Both are related to safe sexual practices, which we lack high quality data to evaluate at the population level.  For each health indicator, this report also includes recommended evidence-informed policies and practices to address that indicator of interest.  We recommend community coalitions use multisector partnerships to pursue all the strategies recommended. 

Read an example below of how the opportunities to make healthy choices can impact an individual’s ability to achieve health and well-being.[BB] 

## **Opportunities to Make Healthy Choices - Chris’s Experience** 

Chris grew up in an urban area with two loving parents. They had to work long hours to support Chris and his three brothers and sisters. When the family bought groceries, they tried to get the most for their dollar, but always picked out the kids’ favorite sugary drinks because it was an inexpensive way to provide them with something they enjoyed. With both his parents’ long hours, the family didn’t prepare fresh meals at home, preferring fast food. Their neighborhood wasn’t very safe, so Chris’s parents encouraged the kids to stay indoors when they came home from school and they didn’t get much physical activity. Chris and his siblings are all overweight. The school Chris attended didn’t provide robust sex education, so when he became sexually active with his girlfriend, they didn’t understand the risks for pregnancy. Chris and his girlfriend became parents at the age of 17. Chris now supports his small family working long hours at multiple minimum wage jobs without benefits. The baby’s health care is covered by Medicaid but Chris and his girlfriend go without health insurance because they cannot afford it. He feels his smoking and drinking habits help him relax and relieve stress. 

## **HEALTH INDICATORS:** 

## **10** 

## **DRUG OVERDOSE DEATHS** 

## Decrease Drug Overdose Deaths 

- **11** 

   - **TOBACCO USE** 

   - Decrease Tobacco Use 

- **12 EXCESSIVE DRINKING** 

   - Decrease Excessive Drinking 

- **13 SUGAR-SWEETENED BEVERAGE CONSUMPTION** Reduce Overweight and Obesity 

- **14 HIV DIAGNOSIS RATE** Improved Sexual Health 

- **15 TEEN BIRTH RATE** 

## Improved Sexual Health 

_BB Examples are of hypothetical scenarios commonly faced by individuals with health-related social needs._ 

**Packet Pg. 253** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 65 

64 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

65
{33}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 10: DRUG OVERDOSE DEATHS** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: DECREASE DRUG OVERDOSE DEATHS** 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

_As in other states, North Carolina has experienced a sharp increase in the number of drug overdose deaths over the last decade, largely due to the opioid epidemic. Substance Use Disorder has devastating impacts on the life of the people who experience it, their families, and their communities.[CC]_ 

**CURRENT TARGET** 20.4 18.0 Per 100,000 Per 100,000 people people 

## **Context** 

**DEFINITION** 

Substance use disorders (SUDs) are chronic or recurrent conditions that, like other chronic illnesses, require ongoing care and treatment for individuals to regain health and maintain recovery. As with any chronic disease, prevention, identification, treatment, and recovery services and supports are essential to ensuring positive health outcomes. Effective treatments for SUDs and underlying mental and physical health problems exist; however, access to services and supports for SUDs varies greatly across the state. 

Number of persons who die as a result of drug poisoning per 100,000 population **DETAILS** 

Age-adjusted; Includes deaths of any intent: unintentional, suicide, homicide, and undetermined; Includes medications and drugs like heroin, natural opioid analgesics and semisynthetic opioids, methadone, other synthetic opioid analgesics, benzodiazepines, cocaine, and psychostimulants with abuse potential **NC OVERDOSE DEATH RATE (2018)** 20.4 per 100,000 people **2030 TARGET** 18.0 per 100,000 people **RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES (AVERAGE 2014-18)** 6.2 – 40.9 per 100,000 people **RANK AMONG STATES** 32nd* **DATA SOURCE** NC State Center for Health Statistics, Vital Statistics 

Having a SUD affects an individual’s relationships with family and friends, ability to attend school or work, their overall physical and mental health, and may lead to problems with the legal system. In addition to increases in drug overdoses, the opioid epidemic has had devastating consequences including the spread of HIV and hepatitis B and C and increased rates of child maltreatment and entry into foster care as more and more parents and other relatives develop and struggle with SUDs.[86,87] 

There are a number of reasons the opioid epidemic has garnered so much attention. Across the nation, drug overdose deaths have skyrocketed, making it a leading cause of death due to injury in the United States, accounting for more than 70,000 deaths in 2017, surpassing the number of traffic fatalities.[88,89] In addition, many people who suffer a fatal opioid overdose initially received prescription opioids from a health care provider to treat pain, and their use progressed to opioid use disorder.[90] Heavy marketing of these drugs to physicians by pharmaceutical companies, as well as emphasis on the use of pain scales, led to overprescribing.  Those trends, as well as the increasing availability of cheap heroin and fentanyl, led to a rapid explosion in drug overdose deaths. 

In North Carolina, the drug overdose death rate in 2018 was 20.4 per 100,000 people.[DD,EE] While prescription opioids drove the increase in overdose deaths originally and they are still a significant contributor to this epidemic, in North Carolina heroin and other synthetic narcotics (like illicitly manufactured fentanyl and its analogues) are now  involved in over 70% of opioid overdose deaths.[91] 

The skyrocketing rates over the past two decades highlight the immense need for better prevention and identification of SUDs and access to effective treatment and recovery services and supports. In 2018, North Carolina saw its first decline in opioid overdose deaths.  Whether that trend continues will depend on several factors (see Levers for Change on next page). 

**STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** North Carolina Opioid Action Plan[CC] 

## **Disparities** 

Drug overdose death rates have increased across all segments of the population. Overall, men die from drug overdoses at much higher rates than women, and adults aged 25-55 years suffer fatal overdose at higher rates than younger and older adults.[88] White and American Indian populations had the highest drug overdose death rates in 2018 at 26.4 and 32.6 per 100,000, respectively, followed by African Americans at 12.9 per 100,000 ( **Figure 19** ).[FF] 

*Rank of 1st for state with lowest drug overdose death rate 

_CCNorth Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. North Carolina Opioid Action Plan 2.0. June 2019. https://www.ncdhhs.gov/about/department-initiatives/opioid-epidemic/north-carolinas-opioid-action-plan DDThe most recent national data available for comparison is from 2017, when the national average for drug overdose deaths was 21.7 per 100,000 people compared to 22.2 per 100,00 people in North Carolina (CDC, Drug Poisoning Mortality in the United States, 1999-2017, https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data-visualization/drug-poisoning-mortality/index.htm). EE Analysis of Vital Statistics records by the North Carolina State Center for Health Statistics_ 

**==> picture [536 x 550] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
F I G U R E  1 8<br>Drug overdose death rates across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target<br>40<br>35<br>32.6<br>27.8<br>30<br>CURRENT  26.4<br>25<br>20.4<br>20<br>15<br>TARGET 13.2<br>12.9<br>18.0<br>10<br>NO DATA<br>NO DATA AVAILABLE<br>5.4 AVAILABLE<br>4.4<br>5<br>0<br>W          B/AA        H/LX            O           A/PI            AI           MALE    FEMALE     < 200% 200-399% 400%+<br>W  = WHITE  O  = OTHER<br>B/AA  = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN A/PI  = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>H/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) AI  = AMERICAN INDIAN<br>F I G U R E  1 9<br>Drug Overdose Death Rate in North Carolina from 2008-2018, by Race/Ethnicity Levers for Change<br>(NC Opioid Action Plan 2.0, 2019; America’s Health<br>35.0 32.6 Rankings, Drug Deaths, 2018)<br>30.0 29.7 •  Reduce the supply of prescription and illicit opioids<br>25.0 22.7 26.4 •  Avert future opioid addiction by supporting youth<br>19.9<br>20.0 17.0 and families<br>15.010.05.00.0 1.012.913.33.5 0.9 1.510.913.4 0.5 3.6 1.115.011.62.80.8 11.712.20.83.9 1.310.812.73.91.2 1.214.312.34.41.1 1.614.45.21.4 2.515.57.6 1.5 3.819.010.03.0 18.012.25.94.4 12.95.44.4 • • •  Address the needs of justice-involved populationsIncrease distribution of naloxoneImplement needle exchange programs<br>2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018<br>•  Improve access to drug treatment programs,<br>including medication-assisted treatment<br>American Indian (non-Hispanic) Black or African American (non-Hispanic) White (non-Hispanic) Other (non-Hispanic) Hispanic (all races)<br>•  Implement broader use of NC Controlled<br>Source: North Carolina State Center for Health Statistics analysis of Vital Statistics. Substance Reporting System by health care<br>providers and pharmacies<br>2030 Target and Potential for Change •  Increase training for health care providers on safe<br>prescribing practices<br>The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years and a forecasted value for North Carolina based  •  Adopt and support payment of evidenced-based<br>on historical data to develop a target for drug overdose deaths. The group chose 18.0 deaths per 100,000  interventions that prevent opioid prescribing<br>people as the target for 2030. This would reflect a reversal of the increasing death rate and a return  •  Support policies that decriminalize and promote<br>treatment of substance use disorder<br>AGE-ADJUSTED<br>DRUG OVERDOSE DEATHS (PER 100,000 POPULATION),<br>(PER 100,000 POPULATION)<br>DRUG OVERDOSE DEATHS<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years and a forecasted value for North Carolina based on historical data to develop a target for drug overdose deaths. The group chose 18.0 deaths per 100,000 people as the target for 2030. This would reflect a reversal of the increasing death rate and a return to a rate similar to that of 2016 (17.6 per 100,000). Although this would still reflect a much higher rate than the low of the previous decade (8.5 per 100,000 in 2010), it would signal an important shift in the struggle to end a growing epidemic. 

_FFAnalysis of Vital Statistics records by the North Carolina State Center for Health Statistics._ 

**Packet Pg. 254** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 67 

66 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

67
{34}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 11: TOBACCO USE** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: DECREASE TOBACCO USE** 

**==> picture [158 x 92] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
CURRENT TARGET<br>19.7%  9.0%<br>  (Youth-2017) (Youth)<br>23.8% 15.0%<br>  (Adults-2018) (Adults)<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**DEFINITION** 

Percent of youth and adults reporting current use of e-cigarettes, cigarettes, cigars, smokeless tobacco, pipes, and/or hookah 

## **DETAILS** 

Youth (middle and high school students) and adults measured separately 

**NC TOBACCO USE** 19.7% of Youth (2017) 23.8% of Adults (2018) 

**2030 TARGET** 9.0% of Youth 15.0% of Adults 

**RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** Not available 

**RANK AMONG STATES** Not available **DATA SOURCE** Youth: NC Department of Public Health, Tobacco Prevention and Control Branch, NC Youth Tobacco Survey Adult: NC State Center for Health Statistics, Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) **STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Not Applicable 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

_Tobacco use remains the leading preventable cause of early death and disease in North Carolina and the nation. Tobacco use and secondhand smoke exposure are responsible for multiple causes of preventable morbidity and mortality in North Carolina. While combustible cigarette use has decreased among North Carolina’s youth, prevalence among adults has declined only slightly, and there are major disparities of tobacco-attributable disease and death among population groups. E-cigarette use among young people has become epidemic in North Carolina and the nation and poses a public health threat._ 

## **Context** 

Cigarette smoking is responsible for 14,200 North Carolina deaths per year – that is 1 of every 5 deaths in our state.[92] For each death, 30 more people are sick or live with a disability because of tobacco use.[93] North Carolina’s direct medical costs from smoking are $3.81 billion each year, including $931 million in Medicaid costs[92] , and the estimated annual health care costs from secondhand smoke are $293 million.[94] In addition, smoking costs North Carolina $4.2 billion in productivity losses each year.[92] 

“ Cigarette smoking is responsible for 14,200 North Carolina deaths per year – that is 1 of every 5 deaths in our state.[92] For each death, 30 more people are sick or live with a disability because of tobacco use.” 

> The combined tobacco use prevalence among high school and of tobacco use.” middle school students is 19.7%.  While cigarette smoking has declined among North Carolina’s young people, there has been an increase in tobacco use overall, particularly among high schoolers. Cigarette smoking among high school students has decreased from 15.5% in 2011 to 8.9% in 2017, yet use of any tobacco products among high school students increased from 25.8% in 2011 to 28.8% in 2017.  This increase reflects the rising use of emerging tobacco products, including electronic cigarettes. Between 2011 and 2017, electronic cigarette use among high school students increased 893%, from 1.7% to 16.9%.  In 2018, 23.8% of adults in North Carolina used at least one type of tobacco product every day or some days. While cigarette smoking had been declining among adults in North Carolina from 21.8% in 2011 to 17.5% in 2018, the recent trends are concerning, with 24.0% using a single tobacco product and an additional 3.9% reporting the use of multiple tobacco products. In 2018, 4.3% of adults smoked cigars or cigarillos (little cigars) during the past 30 days, 5.1% of adults used electronic cigarettes every day or some days, and 4.7% used chewing tobacco or snuff every day or some days.[95] 

Secondhand smoke is an independent risk factor for lung cancer, coronary heart disease, and stroke, as well as an increased risk for low birth weight babies, sudden infant death syndrome, and lower respiratory illness in children. In 2018, 9.6% of North Carolinians were exposed to secondhand smoke in the workplace, which makes young people more likely to start using tobacco and makes it more difficult for people of all ages to quit using tobacco. 

## **F I G U R E  2 0** 

Tobacco use across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target 

**==> picture [506 x 232] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
40%<br>35%<br>32.8%<br>29.9%<br>30%<br>CURRENT<br>25.9%<br>23.8%<br>25%<br>Adult 22.5% 23.0%<br>20% CURRENT  19.7% 20.6% 20.7% 19.0% 18.5% 21.6%<br>Youth 17.0% 17.1% 17.2%<br>TARGET 16.5%<br>15% 15.0%<br>Adult 12.2%<br>10% TARGET<br>9.0%<br>5% Youth<br>NO DATA<br>AVAILABLE<br>0%<br>W              B/AA             H/LX O           A/PI       AI         MALE         FEMALE     < 200% 200-399% 400%+<br>W  = WHITE  O  = OTHER<br>B/AAH/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN A/PIAI  = AMERICAN INDIAN = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>PERCENT OF YOUTH AND ADULTS USING TOBACCO<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## YOUTH ADULTS 

**Levers for Change** (CDC, Tobacco Control Interventions, 2017, US Surgeon General 2018) 

## **Disparities** 

Tobacco use varies among racial, income, geographic, and other demographic groups.[96] Low-income persons, those with lower levels of educational attainment, persons with mental illness and substance use disorders, and those who are unemployed smoke at higher rates than other groups.[96] American Indians have a higher prevalence of smoking than any other racial or ethnic group, yet African American tobacco users die from tobacco-related causes at higher rates than any other racial or ethnic group.[96] LGBTQ individuals are more likely to be smokers than their heterosexual counterparts.[96] Tobacco use is more common in rural areas than urban areas.[96] 

• Fund comprehensive state tobacco control programs to the levels recommended by the CDC • Implement high-impact media campaigns that warn people about the dangers of tobacco use • Implement strategies to curb tobacco product advertising and marketing that are appealing to young people • Raise the price of tobacco products through a tobacco tax • Raise the the age of tobacco product sales to 21 • License tobacco retailers • Implement state and local tobacco-free and smoke-free air policies that include e-cigarettes • Remove state preemption of local government regulations on the sale, promotion, distribution and display of tobacco products • Restrict the sales of flavored tobacco products • Increase access to standard-of-care tobacco use treatment 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years and populations, targets for the national Healthy People 2030 efforts, and a forecasted value for North Carolina based on historical data. The group chose to mirror the Healthy People 2030 targets with an HNC 2030 target of 9.0% for youth and 15.0% for adults reporting tobacco use. Public knowledge and concern over e-cigarettes are growing. Public attention paired with past lessons from successfully reducing cigarette smoking, are encouraging signs of the potential for reducing overall tobacco use. 

**Packet Pg. 255** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 69 

68 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

69
{35}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 12: EXCESSIVE DRINKING** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: DECREASE EXCESSIVE DRINKING** 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

**CURRENT TARGET** _Excessive drinking, a major cause of morbidity and mortality across the United States, has significant impacts on individuals, families, communities,_ 16.9% 12.0% _and state and local economies. Alcohol is the third leading cause of_ (2018) _preventable deaths in North Carolina._ 

## **Context** 

> Alcoholic beverages, while legal for those over the age of 21, can have “Alcohol-related death serious health impacts and can lead to premature death if not consumed in ranked third among moderation.[97] In North Carolina, 16.9% of adults use alcohol in an unsafe preventable deaths in way, either by binge drinking or exceeding recommended low risk levels.[98] Alcohol-related death ranked third among preventable deaths in the state, the state, accounting accounting for an estimated 4,000 deaths in 2017.[99] Survey data from the for an estimated 4,000 

> last few years show a rise in excessive drinking from 14.1% in 2014 to 16.0% deaths in 2017.” in 2018.[98] Excessive alcohol use places a significant burden on individuals, families, communities, health systems, and the state itself in the form of poor health outcomes, lost productivity, and increased risk of violent and criminal behavior. All told, excessive drinking costs North Carolina more than $7 billion per year— primarily in lost productivity.[99,100] 

**DEFINITION** Percent of adults reporting binge or heavy drinking **DETAILS** 

Binge drinking = having 4+ (women all ages/men age 65+) or 5+ (men under age 65) drinks on one occasion in the past 30 days; 

Heavy drinking = having 8+ (women all ages/men age 65+) or 15+ (men under age 65) drinks per week in the past 30 days 

Excessive alcohol consumption[JJ] is linked to heath conditions such as liver disease, hypertension, cardiopulmonary disease, cancers, mental health conditions, alcohol poisoning, and sexually transmitted infections.[97,101] It is also connected with suicide, unintended pregnancy, pregnancy complications, fetal alcohol spectrum disorder, and sudden infant death syndrome.[101] Additionally, excessive drinking contributes to increased rates of domestic violence and child maltreatment, increased risk of motor vehicle accidents, and negatively impacts employment and educational attainment and income potential.[100] 

**NC EXCESSIVE DRINKING (2018)** 16.9% of adults **2030 TARGET** 12.0% of adults 

**==> picture [349 x 122] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
F I G U R E  2 1<br>Definition and Impacts of Binge and Heavy Drinking<br>WOMEN ALL AGES MEN UNDER<br>& MEN AGE 65 ++ AGE 65<br>BINGE DRINKING  is associated with short-<br>term consequences, such as fatal car crashes  4+ 5+<br>and overdose DRINKS DRINKS<br>HEAVY DRINKING  is associated with dealths  8+ 15+<br>due to illness caused by long-term alcohol  DRINKS DRINKS<br>misuse, such as liver cirrhosis PER WEEK PER WEEK<br>Source: NC DHHS Alcohol Data Dashboard<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** Definition and Impacts of Binge and Heavy Drinking Not available **WOMEN ALL AGES MEN UNDER & MEN AGE 65 ++ AGE 65** _**BINGE DRINKING**_ is associated with short- **RANK AMONG STATES** term consequences, such as fatal car crashes **4+ 5+** and overdose **DRINKS DRINKS** 14th* _**HEAVY DRINKING**_ is associated with dealths **8+ 15+ DATA SOURCE** due to illness caused by long-term alcohol **DRINKS DRINKS** misuse, such as liver cirrhosis **PER WEEK PER WEEK** NC State Center for Health Statistics, _Source: NC DHHS Alcohol Data Dashboard_ Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) **Disparities** Excessive drinking rates vary across subpopulations. Almost two times as many men report excessive drinking **STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR** compared to women, and most binge drinking is found in persons aged 18-44 ( **Figure 22** ).[97,95] Across racial **INDICATORS** groups, whites, Hispanics, and persons who identify as multiracial are more likely to drink excessively than African Not Applicable Americans.[95,97] Individuals with higher incomes report higher rates of excessive drinking than those with lower *Rank of 1st for state with lowest levels of incomes, with individuals making $75,000 or more reporting excessive drinking at 23.5% compared to 17.7% for excessive drinking individuals making $25-$49,999.[98] 

**F I G U R E  2 2** 

Excessive drinking across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target 

**==> picture [532 x 458] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
35%<br>30%<br>25%<br>CURRENT<br>21.7%<br>17.2% 17.5% 17.6%  [21.2%]<br>20% 16.9%<br>14.5%<br>15%<br>13.1%<br>12.5% 10.8%<br>10%<br>TARGET NO DATA<br>AVAILABLE<br>5% 12.0%<br>0%<br>W          B/AA        H/LX            O           A/PI            AI           MALE    FEMALE     < 200% 200-399% 400%+<br>WB/AA  = WHITE  = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN OA/PI  = OTHER = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>H/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) AI  = AMERICAN INDIAN<br>F I G U R E  2 3<br>Excessive Drinking in North Carolina, by Sex, 2012-2018 Levers for Change<br>(America’s Health Rankings, Excessive Drinking,<br>2018; CDC, The Community Guide)<br>25.0%<br>20.0% 16.5%22.2% 19.4% 18.5% 21.0% 20.0% 16.7%20.1% 16.9%21.5% 16.00%21.70% •  Support and maintain state-controlled alcohol sales<br>15.0% 14.4% 14.1% 15.1% 14.9% •  Increase alcohol excise taxes<br>13.6% 12.7%<br>10.0% 11.3% 9.8% 10.2% 9.8% 10.4% 10.80% •  Reduce density of alcohol retailers<br>5.0% •  Reduce the days and hours of alcohol sales<br>0.0% •  Screen adults for excessive drinking and conduct<br>2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 brief intervention for those that screen positive<br>Male Female Overall •  Hold alcohol retailers liable for intoxicated or<br>underage customers who cause injury to others<br>Source. North Carolina State Center for Health Statistics analysis of Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System •  Integrate Screening, Brief Intervention, and<br>Referral to Treatment (SBIRT) into medical<br>settings<br>PERCENT OF ADULTS REPORTING BINGE OR HEAVY DRINKING<br>PERCENT OF ADULT POPULATION<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years and a forecasted value for North Carolina based on historical data to develop a target for excessive drinking. The group chose to set a target for 2030 of 12.0% of adults reporting binge or heavy drinking. This would reflect a reversal of the increasing trend over the past several years, with a low in 2014 of 14.1%. Focused decreases for men will facilitate achieving this goal. 

_JJExcessive drinking habits and alcohol dependence may coexist but can also be independent of one another; 9 in 10 adults who drink excessively are not alcohol-dependent. (NCDHHS, Alcohol & the Public’s Health in NC)._ 

**Packet Pg. 256** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 71 

70 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

71
{36}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 13: SUGAR-SWEETENED BEVERAGE CONSUMPTION** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: REDUCE OVERWEIGHT AND OBESITY** 

**CURRENT TARGET** 33.6% 17.0% (Youth-2017) (Youth) 34.2% 20.0% (Adults-2017) (Adults) 

**DEFINITION** Percent of youth and adults reporting consumption of one or more sugarsweetened beverages (SSBs) per day **DETAILS** Youth (high school students) and adults measured separately; SSBs include non-diet soda, fruit drinks (such as Kool-aid and lemonade), sweet tea, and sports or energy drinks (such as Gatorade and Red Bull) **NC SSB CONSUMPTION (2017)** 33.6% of Youth 34.2% of Adults **2030 TARGET** 17.0% of Youth 20.0% of Adults **RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** Not available 

**RANK AMONG STATES** Not available **DATA SOURCE** Youth: NC Department of Public Instruction, Youth Risk Behavior Survey (YRBS) Adult: NC State Center for Health Statistics, Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) 

**STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Not Applicable 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

_Obesity continues to be a concern in North Carolina. Sugar-sweetened beverages (SSB) are the leading source of calories and added sugars in the American diet._ 

## **Context** 

Obesity is one of the largest contributors to morbidity and mortality in the United States, for both youth and adults.[102] Across all ages, the rates of obesity continue to rise. For years, efforts to reduce overweight and obesity have largely been focused on physical activity and healthy eating (e.g., fruit and vegetable intake). New efforts are also targeting sugar-sweetened beverage consumption, which is directly linked to obesity, type 2 diabetes, heart disease, and dental problems.[103] Sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs) are the leading dietary source of added sugar for Americans.[103] Many popular drinks often contain large amounts of added sugar that may not be appreciated by consumers. 

“Sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs) are the leading dietary source of added sugar for Americans.[103] Many popular drinks often contain large amounts of added sugar that may not be appreciated by ” consumers. 

> In North Carolina, more than a third of high school students reported ” consumers. daily consumption of more than one SSB.[KK] For this population, it is In estimated that beverages make up a fifth of daily caloric intake.[104] addition to the connections with chronic nutrition-related conditions and dental problems, studies also show links between excess sugar consumption and attention difficulties.[105] 

The CDC’s National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion recommends that adults limit consumption of added sugars to no more than 10% of daily caloric intake.[106] Studies indicate that average sugar intake for adults far outpaces that figure, and that SSBs account for the largest source of added sugar consumption. Approximately 34% of adults consume one or more SSBs a day.[LL] 

## **Disparities** 

Members of certain populations are more likely to consume SSBs than others. Persons in low-income households, and those with low levels of educational attainment, or whose parents have low levels of educational attainment, have higher odds of consuming multiple SSBs a day .  Additionally, men are more likely to consume more SSBs[LL] than women. Across racial groups different factors are associated with likelihood of SSB consumption, including perceptions of tap water safety[107] and marketing of products (particularly to youth of color, as well as low-income populations).[108,109] 

## **F I G U R E  2 4** 

Sugar-sweetened beverage consumption across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target 

**==> picture [513 x 259] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
45%<br>CURRENT  38.7% 38.7% 41.0%<br>40%<br>34.2% CURRENT  37.0% 37.6%<br>36.1%<br>Adult 33.6%<br>35%<br>Youth 32.6% 31.0% 32.7%<br>31.5%<br>28.3%<br>30% 28.9%<br>TARGET<br>24.3%<br>25% 20.0% 24.1%<br>Adult<br>20%<br>15% TARGET<br>17.0%<br>10% Youth<br>5%<br>NO DATA AVAILABLE<br>0%<br>W    B/AA     H/LX   O   A/PI       AI     MALE     FEMALE   < 200% 200-399% 400%+<br>W  = WHITE  O  = OTHER<br>B/AAH/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN A/PIAI  = AMERICAN INDIAN = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>YOUTH ADULTS<br>SUGAR-SWEETENED BEVERAGE PER DAY<br>PERCENT OF YOUTH AND ADULTS CONSUMING ONE OR MORE<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Levers for Change** (ChangeLabSolutions, 2018) • Tax sugary drinks • Launch public awareness campaigns • Work with retailers to improve offerings and create healthier store environments • Limit sugary drinks through government and private sector procurement policies • Partner with schools and youth-oriented settings to remove or limit SSBs and their marketing • Create community coalitions to identify additional community strategies to reduce consumption 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

The HNC 2030 group reviewed current data and discussed the growing attention to SSBs to develop a target for SSB consumption. Due to differences in youth and adult consumption (according to data), the group chose different targets for these age groups, with 17% reporting consumption of one or more SSB per day for youth and 20% for adults as the target for 2030. 

_KK Analysis of Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance System by the North Carolina Department of Public Instruction. LL Analysis of the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System by the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services State Center for Health Statistics._ 

**Packet Pg. 257** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 73 

72 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

73
{37}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [626 x 594] intentionally omitted <==**

## IMPROVE SEXUAL HEALTH 

Good sexual health practices are important for family planning and prevention of sexually transmitted infections (STIs), both of which affect short- and long-term health and socioeconomic conditions. Diagnosis and treatment of STIs, as well as use of barrier protection during sex, protect against STI transmission. Family planning helps people to plan the timing of pregnancy and the size of their family. In 2017, 43.8% of pregnancies in North Carolina were not intended.[MM,110] Unintended pregnancy is associated with delayed prenatal care, higher incidence of postpartum depression, higher risk of physical abuse, and lower rates of breastfeeding.[111,112] Babies who are born from unintended pregnancy have higher rates of birth defects, low birth weight, and poor mental and physical health during childhood.[113,114] The health and social consequences of unintended pregnancy are greater for teenage mothers and their children. 

department for surveillance and disease prevention. Some STIs, such as genital herpes and HPV, are not required to be reported to local health departments; for these, data on prevalence come from studies. Rates of infection for some STIs have been increasing, with infections most common among young people and gay and bisexual men. STIs impact different populations at varying rates. Syphilis is most common among men who have sex with men and among younger African American men; however, it is also increasing among women, leading to increases in congenital syphilis infections.[117] Gonorrhea rates are particularly high for young men and women aged 20-24 years and African American and American Indian populations. Gonorrhea and chlamydia rates are highest among people under  29 years of age.[118] The largest race/ethnicity disparity is seen in HIV diagnosis rates, which are nearly ten times higher for African Americans compared to whites due to a variety of socioeconomic and health care access issues.[119] 

**==> picture [72 x 70] intentionally omitted <==**

There are no direct measures available for healthy sexual behaviors, such as contraception or condom use. HNC 2030 members selected two outcome measures to serve as indicators of healthy sexuality: HIV diagnosis rate and teen birth rate. 

STIs refer to the range of infectious diseases that are transmitted primarily through unprotected sexual activity with an infected person. Most STIs are largely preventable with proper protection such as condoms or vaccination. STIs are widespread, with 42.5% of adults ages 18-59 having human papillomavirus (HPV), the most common STI in the United States.[NN,OO] Some STIs can impact reproductive health, particularly for women; some  cause cancers (i.e., HPV), and some cannot be cured (e.g., HIV and herpes).[115,116] North Carolina requires six sexually transmitted STIs  to be reported;[PP] the most common include HIV, syphilis, gonorrhea, chlamydia and hepatitis B.[QQ] As for all reportable diseases, cases must be reported to the local health 

_MM “Not intended” is a combination of “unintended” and “was not sure” responses on the North Carolina Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System Survey. NN https://www.cdc.gov/std/hpv/stdfact-hpv.htm OO HPV vaccination became available in the U.S. in 2006, therefore most adults have not been vaccinated. https://www.kff.org/womens-health-policy/fact-sheet/the-hpv-vaccine-access-and-use-in-the-u-s/ PP 10A NCAC 41A .0101 QQ Rates of hepatitis C transmission are also collected, however sexual contact is not the primary means of hepatitis C transmission._ 

**Packet Pg. 258** 

74 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

75 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{38}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [777 x 49] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 14: HIV DIAGNOSIS RATE** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: IMPROVE SEXUAL HEALTH** 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

**==> picture [158 x 89] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
CURRENT CURRENT<br>13.9 6.0<br>   Per 100,000     Per 100,000<br>people people<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


_Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) remains a deadly disease if left untreated. Newly diagnosed HIV infection rates manifest extremely high disparities among men who have sex with men and African Americans. These disparities identify opportunities to improve access to prevention, care and treatment, which can end HIV transmission and associated deaths.[RR]_ 

## **Context** 

**DEFINITION** Number of new HIV diagnoses per 100,000 population **DETAILS** Not Applicable 

HIV is a virus that affects the immune system’s ability to defend itself, with deadly consequences if left untreated. North Carolina’s HIV diagnosis rate has been decreasing, and in 2018 the rate was 13.9 per 100,000 people, which is slightly lower than the national rate of 14.6 per 100,000 people.[120] The primary mechanisms through which the virus is spread are sexual contact and injection drug use.[121] Once contracted, the virus can have lifelong physical and psychological impacts, and increases the risk of negative health outcomes such as AIDS, cancer, tuberculosis, and other infectious diseases.[122] Pregnant women living with HIV who are not suppressed on antiretroviral therapy are at risk of passing it to their babies during delivery or breastfeeding.[122,123] 

**NC HIV DIAGNOSIS RATE (2018)** 13.9 per 100,000 people **2030 TARGET** 6.0 per 100,000 people 

While no cure exists at this time, advances in HIV antiretroviral medications make it possible for persons living with HIV to live largely normal lives and prevent transmission of the virus to others.[122] However, treatment remains expensive, costing an estimated $478,000 for lifelong care.[120] Recent advances have led to the development of pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP), a daily medication that reduces the risk of HIV transmission by 99% through sexual contact or 74% through injecting drug use if taken as directed.[124] Expanded access to and use of treatment and prevention medications can control the spread of HIV and drastically reduce diagnosis rates. 

**RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** 0 - 29.6 per 100,000 people **RANK AMONG STATES** 40th* **DATA SOURCE** NC Division of Public Health, Epidemiology Section 

Individuals may be fearful of being tested or of disclosing their status to friends, family members, and current or future sexual partners due to social stigma surrounding the disease or the exposure risk and the level of social stigma varies by cultural and religious background.[125] People may also be unaware that they have been exposed to or are living with HIV, since individuals can remain asymptomatic for months to years after initial infection.[126] 

**STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Not Applicable 

## **F I G U R E  2 5** 

Estimated HIV Infection Rates among Newly Diagnosed Adult and Adolescent (13 years and older) Gay and Bisexual Men and Other Men who have Sex with Men in North Carolina, 2018 

*Rank of 1st for state with lowest HIV diagnosis rate 

**==> picture [347 x 130] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Gay and Bisexual Men and other Men who  620<br>have sex with Men<br>13 to 30 years old 1,227<br>Over 30 years old 344<br>American Indian/Alaska Native* 142<br>Asian/Pacific Islander* 202<br>Black/Afican American* 1,908<br>Hispanic/Latino 845<br>White/Caucasian* 200<br>RATE PER 1000,000 POPULATION<br>*Non-Hispanic<br>Source: 2018 North Carolina HIV/STD/Hepatitis Surveillance Report. North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services, Division of Public Health, HIV/STD/<br>Hepatitis Survei llance Unit. https://epi.dph.ncdhhs.gov/cd/stds/figures/factsheet_HIV_2018.pdf<br>TOTAL<br>AGE<br>RACE/ETHNICITY<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


_RRIt is important to note that the HIV diagnosis rate would decrease with decreased testing, yet that is not an acceptable means to decrease diagnoses. Healthy sexual behaviors, increased testing, and proper treatment are important methods for decreasing transmission of the virus._ 

**==> picture [487 x 254] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
F I G U R E  2 6<br>HIV rate across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target<br>40.8<br>40<br>35<br>30<br>25<br>23.1<br>20 CURRENT<br>17.7<br>13.9<br>15<br>10<br>5.9 5.4<br>TARGET<br>5 4.9 4.3<br>6.0 AVAILABLENO DATA  NO DATA AVAILABLE<br>0<br>W          B/AA        H/LX            O           A/PI            AI           MALE    FEMALE     < 200% 200-399% 400%+<br>W  = WHITE  O  = OTHER<br>B/AA  = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN A/PI  = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>H/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) AI  = AMERICAN INDIAN<br>NEW HIV INFECTION DIAGNOSES (PER 100,000 POPULATION)<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **Disparities** 

**Levers for Change** (CDC, HIV Prevention in the United States, 2015) • Increase access to PrEP for individuals at high risk for HIV transmission • Implement interventions that improve access to HIV treatment • Make testing easy, accessible, and routine • Ensure people who are diagnosed are linked with appropriate care and receive behavioral interventions and other supports to decrease risk of transmission 

Despite the overall decrease in HIV diagnosis rate, significant racial/ethnic disparities in HIV diagnosis rates remain, with persons of color making up a disproportionate share of the population diagnosed with HIV annually. In 2018, the HIV diagnosis rates for African American men (68.7 cases per 100,000) and women (15.9 cases per 100, 000) far exceeded that of their white counterparts (8.0 and 2.0 cases per 100,000, respectively).[127] Persons of Hispanic ethnicity also have disparate HIV diagnosis rates (17.7 cases per 100,000) compared to whites (4.9 cases per 100,000).[127] The HIV diagnosis rate among men who have sex with men (MSM) is 155 times that of heterosexual men (MSM: 621.0 per 100,000 in 2018; heterosexual men: 4.0 per 100,000).[127] These two levels of disparity compound for African American MSM, who have estimated diagnosis rates of 1,908.2 per 100,000 compared to 199.7 per 100,00 for white MSM.[127] 

• Ensure availability of condoms at health departments and community-based organizations • Increase Medicaid eligibility 

HIV disproportionately affects lower-income communities and people without insurance, as well as people with vulnerable or chaotic life situations such as sex workers and incarcerated populations.[128] People living in impoverished areas often have fewer health care and prevention resources, including access to HIV treatment and PrEP, which can increase the potential for HIV transmission.[123] 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years and populations and a forecasted value for North Carolina based on historical data to develop a target for HIV diagnosis rate. The group chose 6.0 diagnoses per 100,000 people as the target for 2030. Effective HIV treatment and PrEP have the potential to drastically reduce transmission rates into the future. With this fact and the national efforts to end HIV transmission, the group set an aggressive goal. To meet this goal, it is critical that NC reduces disparities in infection rates for African Americans. 

**Packet Pg. 259** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 77 

76 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

77
{39}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 15: TEEN BIRTH RATE** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: IMPROVE SEXUAL HEALTH** 

**==> picture [158 x 89] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
CURRENT TARGET<br>18.7   10.0<br> Per 1,000        Per 1,000<br>people      people<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**DEFINITION** Number of births to girls aged 15-19 per 1,000 population 

**DETAILS** Not Applicable **NC TEEN BIRTH RATE (2018)** 18.7 per 1,000 **2030 TARGET** 10.0 per 1,000 **RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** 3.2 - 41.5 per 1,000 **RANK AMONG STATES** 23rd* (2017) **DATA SOURCE** NC State Center for Health Statistics, Vital Statistics **STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Not Applicable *Rank of 1st for state with lowest teen birth rate 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

_Having a child during one’s teenage years is associated with social, health, and financial burdens to the teen parents, their families, and their communities. Teenage mothers are less likely to complete high school and more likely to live in poverty. Children born to teenage parents are less likely to succeed in school, and more likely to drop out of school and be involved in the criminal justice system. Although the teen birth rate in North Carolina has decreased significantly, teen births remain high among American Indian, African American, and Hispanic populations._ 

## **Context** 

Young mothers and their babies face a host of negative health and economic outcomes. In North Carolina, the teen birth rate in 2018 was 18.7 per 1,000, a figure that exceeds the national rate of 17.4 per 1,000.[110,127] Despite reductions in the rate over the last decade, more than 8,800 mothers under the age of 19 gave birth in 2017.[129] Teenage girls may have underdeveloped reproductive systems and may face higher rates of pregnancy-related morbidity.[130] They are also less likely to receive early prenatal care.[131] From a mental health perspective, teenage mothers are more likely to suffer from psychological trauma associated with pregnancy and may be at higher risk for postpartum depression.[132,131] Babies born to teenage mothers are more likely to have low birth weight, pre-term delivery, and other complications.[131] 

Teenage mothers are more likely to drop out of school and may not attain the same level of education as their childless peers.[131] Thus, they are more likely to work lower-wage jobs and have lower lifetime earning potentials. They are also more susceptible to intimate partner violence and mistreatment by family members, which can compound psychological distress, and negatively impact both their children’s lives and their own.[132] Psychological distress associated with birth and interpersonal violence increases the likelihood that teenage mothers will use substances, have repeat pregnancies, and that the children of teenage mothers will suffer depression and other psychological barriers.[132] 

**==> picture [346 x 190] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
F I G U R E  2 7<br>Teen Birth Rate in North Carolina, by Race/Ethnicity, 2008-2018<br>TOTAL<br>WHITE<br>AFRICAN AMERICAN<br>AMERICAN INDIAN<br>HISPANIC<br>Source: North Carolina State Center for Health Statistics. Decline in Teen Births in North Carolina, 1996-2015. July 2017. https://schs.dph.ncdhhs.gov/schs/pdf/<br>SB_47_20170726.pdf; Vital Statistics - Pregnancies, Fertility<br>TEEN BIRTH RATE PER 1,000 POPULATION<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [49 x 13] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
F I G U R E  2 8<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [487 x 236] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Teen birth rate across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target<br>38.4<br>40<br>34.3<br>35<br>30<br>CURRENT  24.1<br>25<br>18.7<br>20<br>15<br>12.9<br>6.9<br>10<br>TARGET<br>5 10.0<br>NO DATA  NOT APPLICABLE NO DATA AVAILABLE<br>AVAILABLE<br>0<br>W          B/AA        H/LX            O           A/PI            AI           MALE    FEMALE     < 200% 200-399% 400%+<br>W  = WHITE  O  = OTHER<br>B/AA  = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN A/PI  = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>H/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) AI  = AMERICAN INDIAN<br> (PER 1,000 POPULATION)<br>BIRTH RATE FOR FEMALES AGE 15-19<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **Disparities** 

**Levers for Change** 

Income level, childhood trauma, racial identity, and geography all affect the teen birth rate. Girls from low-income families and those in the child welfare system are at higher risk of giving birth as a teenager than their more affluent peers.[133] History of adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) correlates with likelihood of teenage pregnancy and birth, as almost half of teenage mothers have a history of childhood sexual abuse or trauma.[132] 

(National Conference of State Legislatures, 

2018) • Increase access to long-acting reversible contraceptives, such as IUDs and implants, as well as condoms • Ensure access to information and services for youth sexual health • Examine school sex education policies to ensure they include information on how to avoid teen pregnancy and sexually transmitted infections 

Despite the recent downward trend in the teen birth rate, large disparities remain between racial and ethnic groups. African American, Hispanic, and American Indian girls give birth at rates that are more than two to three times that of white girls ( **Figure 28** ).[110] These disparities can be traced to persistent racial segregation of neighborhoods that contributes to sharp income inequality, poor economic development, and under-resourced schools associated with lower educational attainment and the number of safe recreational and social opportunities for teens.[134] 

Also, rural areas tend to face higher teen birth rates than their metropolitan counterparts. This disparity is particularly acute as the recent improvements in teen birth rates have largely only occurred in metropolitan areas.[134] 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years, populations, and states and a forecasted value for North Carolina based on historical data to determine a target for 2030. Recent trends show an increasing use of long-acting reversible contraceptives (LARCs), such as intrauterine devices (IUDs) and implants, which are more effective than other forms of birth control, as well as decreases in high school age girls having sexual intercourse (41.4% in 2015, compared to 57.6% in 1995).[135] With the strong downward trends and continued work to decrease rates further, the group chose 10.0 teen births per 1,000 population as the target for 2030. To meet this target, it will be critical to focus on reducing the disparities we see in teen birth rates for American Indians, Hispanics, and African Americans. 

**Packet Pg. 260** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 79 

78 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

79
{40}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [1009 x 53] intentionally omitted <==**

## DEVELOPMENTAL MEASURES 

Below are health behavior measures that the HNC 2030 group feels are important to population health, but do not have reliable or robust data available at this time. A description of the data needed for these measures is listed as “developmental data needs.” State and local public health or other entities should consider identifying methods for collecting this data. 

## **Sexual Health** 

HIV diagnosis was chosen for HNC 2030 as an important indicator of sexual health practices and for the disparities seen in the diagnosis rates of African Americans above other racial groups ( **see Page 77** ). Yet, this indicator is not the ultimate predictor of safe sex practices across populations and it is not the only sexually transmitted disease with large health impacts. 

Both the work group and communities expressed a desire to be able to more comprehensively measure the impact of STIs. A composite measure of STIs is unavailable at this time. 

## **Developmental data needs:** 

• There is no existing data source for the contraceptive or condom practices of the population. This data would be relevant to contextualize the Teen Birth Rate and HIV Diagnosis indicators chosen for HNC 2030 and would be important in contextualizing issues such as unintended pregnancy and other STI diagnosis rates. 

• A composite measure of all reportable STIs would provide a broader picture of the spectrum of sexual health issues across the state of North Carolina. The North Carolina HIV/ STD Prevention and Care program within the North Carolina Division of Public Health created a draft composite measure. The measure would evaluate average time to treat across STIs with the reasoning that achieving fast treatment is an effective way to cure and prevent the spread of disease. This composite measure will need peer review and testing in the coming years to prepare for potential future use, however it could be considered for work related to STIs in the coming decades. 

## **Overweight/Obesity** 

Obesity rates have continued to grow over the past several decades. The state-level data currently available uses self-reported survey data on height and weight, such as the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) data, to calculate the prevalence of overweight and obesity. While this data may provide an idea of the challenges a population faces with weight, it is not accurate. One study showed that BRFSS underestimates prevalence of obesity by 9.5 percentage points, with even higher inaccuracies among women at a 13.1 percentage point underestimate.[105] 

## **Developmental data needs:** 

• Weight and height data are routinely collected as part of clinical visits for children. This data provides a much more accurate picture of the obesity rate within the population. The now widespread use of electronic health records could facilitate the collection of this data for the population. The state’s NC HealthConnex Health Information Exchange is designed to collect clinical data from all health systems and providers, although all may not currently be connected. Statelevel population health data is not currently available from NC HealthConnex but should be in the future, which will provide more accurate data across all populations in the state. 

## **C H A P T E R  6** 

## CLINICAL CARE 

**==> picture [233 x 88] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [441 x 257] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 261** 

80 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

81 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{41}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

## INTRODUCTION 

While the non-clinical drivers of health – social and economic factors, physical environment, and health behaviors – provide the context for how we live and how likely we are to be healthy, our access to affordable and quality health care can help to prevent disease or detect it as soon as possible.[136] Access to care typically begins with affordable and comprehensive health insurance. Beyond that, geographic proximity to health care providers is key to ensuring that people can physically access the care they need. Within the health care system, quality care means the provision of safe, effective treatment in a timely manner.[136] 

In many ways, income, employment, race, and geographic location affect where and how we receive health care. 

• Social and Economic Factors – Employment is a key mechanism for health insurance coverage in the United States, although lowincome workers are less likely to receive this benefit from their employers. Individuals with less education are more likely to be employed without health insurance benefits. People of color face limitations in health care quality and access due to mistrust of the health care system, lack of representation in the health care workforce, and implicit bias in the treatment they receive. • Physical Environment – People who live in rural areas are more likely to be farther from health care providers and hospitals. This impacts their ability to receive regular health checkups and care for health conditions like pregnancy, mental health issues, or diabetes. These geographic challenges are compounded for people who lack reliable transportation. 

The HNC 2030 health indicators chosen for the clinical care topic area cover both access and quality, and even still cannot fully capture an individual’s ability to access quality care. For example, insurance rates are an important indicator of access, yet even people with insurance may face large financial barriers to care if the coverage is not robust or if the monthly premiums are high. 

Read the following example of how the drivers of health interact with clinical care to impact an individual’s opportunities to achieve health and well-being.[SS] For each health indicator, this report includes recommended evidence-informed policies and practices to address that indicator of interest. We recommend community coalitions use multisector partnerships to pursue all the strategies recommended. 

## **Clinical Care and Health – John’s Experience** 

John is a farmer in rural North Carolina. He has worked hard and loves his home, but his health has been deteriorating. John did not have health insurance until he turned 65 and hasn’t been to the doctor in ten years. Although he has not been feeling well, John put off seeing the doctor until he turned 65 and was able to enroll in Medicare for health insurance. Once insured, he made an appointment with the closest primary care doctor on the other side of the county, about 40 minutes away. By the time of his appointment, his health had deteriorated so much that he didn’t feel comfortable driving himself. John’s niece volunteered to drive him to the appointment, but that day she got sick and couldn’t take him. The appointment was rescheduled for a month later. The doctor diagnosed John with anemia and scheduled a colonoscopy two counties away. He was ultimately diagnosed with Stage III cancer of the colon. Treatment was only available at the hospital, which was also far from his house. John needs aggressive treatment requiring surgery and then weekly treatment at the hospital for the next couple of months. Although he has a source of payment now, John’s prognosis would have been much better had his cancer been caught earlier. 

## **HEALTH INDICATORS:** 

## **16** 

## **UNINSURED RATE** 

## Decrease the Uninsured Population 

## **17 PRIMARY CARE WORKFORCE** 

Increase the Primary Care Workforce 

- **18 EARLY PRENATAL CARE** 

Improve Birth Outcomes 

## **19 SUICIDE RATE** 

## Improve Access and Treatment for Mental Health Needs 

_SS Examples are of hypothetical scenarios commonly faced by individuals with health-related social needs._ 

**Packet Pg. 262** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 83 

82 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

83
{42}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 16: UNINSURED RATE** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: DECREASE THE UNINSURED POPULATION** 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

_For most people, access to affordable health care services is dependent_ **CURRENT TARGET** _upon whether they have health insurance coverage. Although uninsured_ 13% 8% _rates in North Carolina decreased between 2013 and 2016, they have started to rise again. Policy options available to state lawmakers have the potential to greatly reduce the number of people who are uninsured in North Carolina._ 

## **Context** 

**DEFINITION** Access to comprehensive, quality health care services is critical to achieve and maintain health, prevent and manage Population under age 65 without health disease, and achieve health equity. Health insurance is the most common means used to obtain affordable health insurance care services.[137] For those without health insurance, care may be inaccessible and unaffordable, resulting in poor health outcomes.[138] Those without coverage may not receive important preventive care services, may avoid **DETAILS** treatment for acute illness and injury, and may also have poorly managed chronic health conditions.[138,139,140] Lack of Individuals age 65 years and older are health insurance coverage can also lead to financial burdens that further negatively impact one’s health. Access to eligible for Medicare affordable health care positively impacts individuals’ health and well-being and overall quality of life.[141] 

**NC UNINSURED RATE (2017)** 13% **2030 TARGET** 8% 

In the United States, there are three broad categories of insurance: private, public, and the uninsured. In 2017, slightly more than half of all North Carolina residents had private insurance (53%).[142] The majority of North Carolinians with private insurance were enrolled in employer-based insurance programs that are jointly financed by employers and employees. Approximately 36% of North Carolinians were covered by public health insurance (i.e., Medicaid, Medicare, Tricare, Veterans Health Administration (VA) health care) with eligibility depending on their age, income, and military status.[142] Those who do not receive health care from their employer and do not qualify for public health insurance (11% ) can purchase private health insurance through the government-run health insurance marketplace, which provides subsidies based on income, or through the private insurance market. In 2018, the average annual cost of health insurance was $6,800 for individuals and $19,600 for family coverage.[143] Due to the high cost of insurance, both through employers and on the private market, many people cannot afford health insurance and go without. 

**RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** 9 – 20% 

**RANK AMONG STATES** 44th* 

**DATA SOURCE** Small Area Health Insurance Estimates 

## **Disparities** 

Certain types of workers may be less likely to have health insurance.[144] Persons engaged in seasonal, part-time, temporary, or caregiving work or who are self-employed or are small business owners and employees may not receive employer-sponsored insurance and may not qualify for public benefits or tax credits and subsidies to purchase coverage on the marketplace.[145] In North Carolina, those working in the agriculture, forestry, mining, construction, hospitality, and services industries are most likely to lack health insurance.[144] Veteran populations too may fall into the coverage gap, as they may be ineligible for VA health care coverage and may not qualify for TriCare.[145] 

**STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Not Applicable 

*Rank of 1st for state with lowest uninsured rate 

There are also racial and geographic disparities in who does and does not have insurance coverage. Hispanic North Carolinians are uninsured at higher rates than their white and African American counterparts, as members of that community may be more likely to lack access to job opportunities that provide insurance and may also face citizenship and status documentation barriers to qualifying for Medicaid and Medicare.[145] However, white North Carolinians account for almost half of residents in the state without health insurance.[144] Finally, residents of rural areas are more likely to be uninsured than their metropolitan counterparts and are more likely to be concentrated in the mountains and southern plain of the state.[146] 

## **F I G U R E  2 9** 

**==> picture [520 x 372] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Percent uninsured across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target<br>35%<br>31%<br>30%<br>25%<br>21%<br>18%<br>20%<br>CURRENT<br>14%<br>15% 13% 13% 11% 12%<br>10% 10% 8% 9%<br>TARGET 4%<br>5%<br>8%<br>0%<br>W          B/AA        H/LX            O           A/PI            AI           MALE    FEMALE     < 200% 200-399% 400%+<br>W  = WHITE  O  = OTHER<br>B/AA  = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN A/PI  = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>H/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) AI  = AMERICAN INDIAN<br>2030 Target and Potential for Change<br>Levers for Change<br>The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years and a forecasted value for North Carolina based on  (Collins, Bhupal, & Doty, 2019)<br>historical data to determine a target for 2030. They also discussed the policy options and their projected effect  •  Expand Medicaid eligibility criteria<br>on the uninsured population. Estimates show that Medicaid expansion in North Carolina would decrease the  •  Support bans or limitations on short-term health<br>uninsured population under the age of 65 from 13% to around 8%, therefore the group chose 8% as the target  plans<br>for uninsured for 2030. [[147]]  Analyses have shown that states where Medicaid eligibility has been expanded have  •  Increase publicity and navigator funding for<br>seen improved health outcomes, such as decreased infant mortality, decreased cardiovascular mortality rates,  open enrollment<br>improved self-reported health status, and improved rates of smoking cessation. [[140]] •  Increase public education about insurance<br>options<br>PERCENT OF POPULATION UNDER AGE 65 THAT IS UNINSURED<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years and a forecasted value for North Carolina based on historical data to determine a target for 2030. They also discussed the policy options and their projected effect on the uninsured population. Estimates show that Medicaid expansion in North Carolina would decrease the uninsured population under the age of 65 from 13% to around 8%, therefore the group chose 8% as the target for uninsured for 2030.[[147]] Analyses have shown that states where Medicaid eligibility has been expanded have seen improved health outcomes, such as decreased infant mortality, decreased cardiovascular mortality rates, improved self-reported health status, and improved rates of smoking cessation.[[140]] 

## **F I G U R E  3 0** 

Percent of Population who is Uninsured in North Carolina Counties: Residents Less than 65 years old, 2017 

**==> picture [457 x 125] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
8.8% - 11.4% (8 Counties)<br>11.5% - 12.4% (20 Counties)<br>12.5% - 13.4% (23 Counties)<br>13.5% - 14.9% (25 Counties)<br>15.0% - 19.6% (24 Counties)<br>Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Small Area Health Insurance Estimates, https://www.census.gov/data-tools/demo/sahie/#/?s_state<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Packet Pg. 263** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 85 

84 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

85
{43}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 17: PRIMARY CARE WORKFORCE** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: INCREASE THE PRIMARY CARE WORKFORCE** 

**CURRENT TARGET** 62 COUNTIES 100 COUNTIES 1:1,500 1:1,500 primary care Or provider to 25% Descrease population ratio 

**DEFINITION** 

Primary care workforce as a ratio of the number of full-time equivalent primary care clinicians to county population 

**DETAILS** 

Includes physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, and certified nurse midwives; provider location defined by primary practice location on licensure information **NC PRIMARY CARE WORKFORCE (2017)** 62 counties with a 1:1,500 primary care provider to population ratio 

**2030 TARGET** 100 counties reaching the 1:1,500 ratio or achieving a 25% decrease in the provider to population ratio **RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** 1:6,278 – 1:365 **RANK AMONG STATES** Not Applicable **DATA SOURCE** Cecil G. Sheps Center for Health Services Research analysis of licensure data from North Carolina Medical Board and North Carolina Board of Nursing **STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Not Applicable 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

_Access to primary care can encourage preventive health care and improve health outcomes. Many rural areas of North Carolina lack adequate access to medical professionals, including those providing primary care._ 

## **Context** 

Primary care providers typically serve as the entry point into the health care system and provide a wide array of services including preventive, diagnostic, chronic disease management, and urgent care. As such, primary care providers play an integral role in maintaining and improving the overall health and well-being of communities.[148] Access to primary care is associated with fewer health care disparities and better health outcomes across socioeconomic circumstances.[148] 

Ideally, people would have access to high quality primary care, dental care, and behavioral health care in their communities. However, 38 counties in North Carolina do not meet the recommended ratio of one primary care provider per 1,500 residents[V][V] ( **see Figure 31** ), with many counties also experiencing shortages of dental and/or behavioral health providers. The primary care workforce is experiencing increases in demand due to aging baby boomers requiring more care, overall growth in the population, and increasing numbers of people living with chronic illnesses. Despite overall growth in the primary care workforce in the last 30 years, North Carolina’s most underserved and rural areas face persistent primary care shortfalls. Rural communities often struggle to recruit and retain health care professionals due to professional, economic, infrastructure, and cultural challenges. Shortages of health care professionals in rural areas impede residents’ ability to get the care they need. To access services, those services must be available, obtainable in a timely manner, and affordable. Barriers to access, including shortages of health professionals, result in unmet health care needs, delays in receiving care, forgoing preventive care, preventable hospitalizations, and death.[149] 

Nationwide, the number of medical school graduates choosing primary care has been on the decline, arguably due to high costs of medical education and a large disparity between the earnings of primary care physicians and those of most specialists.[150] At the same time, the primary care workforce has been supplemented by increasing numbers of advanced practice nurses (e.g., nurse practitioners) and physician assistants (PAs) entering the work force. Similar to physicians, non-physician clinical providers often pursue medical subspecialties and work in specialty practices, although this is more true for PAs than for advanced practice nurses.[151,152,153] Also, like physicians, the percent of PAs practicing in rural areas has fallen, although a larger percent of PAs than physicians who practice in primary care are practicing in rural areas.[154] In contrast, there has been national growth in the number of primary care nurse practitioners practicing in rural areas.[155] 

## **F I G U R E  3 1** 

Population per primary care provider in North Carolina 

**==> picture [454 x 169] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [167 x 57] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [126 x 31] intentionally omitted <==**

**Levers for Change** • Support pipeline programs in rural areas to encourage high school and college students to pursue careers in medicine (Abernathy & Byerley, 2019) 

## **Disparities** 

Provider distribution is a critical barrier to meeting the primary care needs of the population. For a state where 1 in 5 residents lives in a rural area, this access barrier is particularly acute. Of the state’s 100 counties, 40 counties have a primary care ratio that exceeds the recommended access threshold ( **see Figure 31** ).[WW] At present, some incentives exist to encourage providers to relocate to rural communities, such as loan repayment. However, providers with families may be dissuaded by school systems with fewer resources, fewer career opportunities for partners or spouses, and slow economic development in rural areas, and may be concerned about the financial viability of opening practices when faced with low patient volumes.[156,149] 

• Identify rural provider champions and increase support for physicians in ongoing practice (Fraher & Spero, 2015) 

• Increase residency positions in rural areas (Fraher & Spero, 2015) 

• Invest in rural economies (Holmes, 2018) 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

• 

Increase telehealth primary care initiatives in rural areas (McGranaghan, 2018) 

Currently, only 62 of North Carolina’s 100 counties have a provider to population ratio of 1:1,500 or fewer. To set the target for this indicator, the group reviewed data across counties in North Carolina. Considerations included the fact that county borders do not limit access to health care (i.e., individuals can cross from one county to another to see their provider) and that it may not be possible for all counties in the state to meet the optimal 1:1,500 ratio. The group set the 2030 target of all counties being either at or below the 1:1,500 ratio or see a 25% decrease in provider to population ratio for counties that have not yet met the 1:1,500 ratio.[XX] The aim toward decreasing, rather than meeting a specific ratio, is a more attainable goal for counties that currently have high population to provider ratios. 

• Increase access and payment for specialist consults 

• Support increased funding for provider loan repayment programs that incentivize primary care providers to practice in medically underserved areas 

_VV Recommended provider to population ratio based on analysis by the Cecil G. Sheps Center for Health Services Research, which concluded that counties with ratios between 1:1,500 and 1:3000 are likely to have populations that periodically experience delays in access to care or conditions that require them to seek primary care outside their county and counties with ratios of 3,000 or more will have populations with regular difficulties seeing a local practitioner and will require special programs or procedures to overcome the lack of local, in-county primary care access._ 

_WW  Analysis and calculations by Spero, JC and Galloway, EM of the Cecil G. Sheps Center for Health Services Research. XX Achieving this goal by 2030 would mean that 20 of the 30 counties currently above the optimal primary care provider to population ratio would reach a ratio of 1:1,500 or lower by 2030. For those 11 counties that are closer to the 1:1,500 goal, a 25% decrease would bring them to ratios at or below the optimal 1:1,500. The 8 counties with the highest ratios would see meaningful increased access through a 25% decrease in their ratios._ 

**Packet Pg. 264** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 87 

86 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

87
{44}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 18: EARLY PRENATAL CARE** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: IMPROVE BIRTH OUTCOMES** 

**CURRENT TARGET** 

**==> picture [131 x 46] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
68.0% 80.0%<br>  2018<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**DEFINITION** 

Percent of women who receive pregnancyrelated health care services during the first trimester of a pregnancy 

**DETAILS** First trimester is the first three months of pregnancy 

**NC EARLY PRENATAL CARE RATE (2018)** 68.0% **2030 TARGET** 80.0% 

**RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** 41.4% - 86.9% 

**RANK AMONG STATES** Tied for 36th* 

**DATA SOURCE** NC State Center for Health Statistics, Vital Statistics 

**STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Not Applicable 

*Rank of 1st for state with greatest use of prenatal care 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

_Receipt of early prenatal care is a protective factor for many negative health outcomes for mothers and their babies. In North Carolina, only 68% of pregnant women receive care within the first trimester. Those who do not receive care are disproportionately women of color and teenage mothers._ 

## **Context** 

Women who receive early prenatal care have lower rates of negative pregnancy outcomes such as low birth weight and infant death ( **see Page 32** ).[157] Early prenatal care services include screening for substance use, chronic conditions like diabetes and hypertension, and fetal abnormalities.[158] Wellness visits early in a pregnancy can also ensure that women are connected to social support systems and programs that can help them navigate their pregnancy safely and healthily.[158] In North Carolina, only 68% of pregnant women receive necessary early prenatal care services, a figure that falls below the national average of 77%.[159] 

“In North Carolina, only 68% of pregnant women receive necessary early prenatal care services, a figure that falls below the national average of 77%.” 

## **Disparities** 

There are sharp disparities between those who receive and do not receive early prenatal care in North Carolina. Income is a key indicator of whether a mother will receive early prenatal care, as low-income mothers may be uninsured[160,159] and unaware of their Medicaid eligibility, or may lack the funds needed to seek care.[157] In North Carolina, Medicaid for Pregnant Women is available for women with incomes up to 200% of the federal poverty level for the duration of the pregnancy and ends 60 days postpartum.[161] Medicaid for Pregnant Women covers prenatal care, delivery, postpartum care, childbirth classes, and services to treat conditions that may complicate pregnancy.[161] Undocumented immigrant women are ineligible for Medicaid coverage of prenatal care, an option available under the Children’s Health Insurance Program and utilized by 16 states. 

The age of the mother is associated with early initiation of prenatal care, with teenage mothers and mothers in their early 20s seeking early prenatal care at lower rates than older mothers.[159] Race and ethnicity  are also associated with rates of early prenatal care. African American women, Hispanic women, and American Indian women are less likely to receive early prenatal care than their white counterparts ( **see Figure 32** ).[162,45] In addition, studies show that implicit bias in health care delivery may prevent African American women from receiving sufficient patient education in the prenatal period about risks to maternal and fetal health,[163] and may also contribute to African American women’s increased risk of life-threatening conditions such as preeclampsia and postpartum hemorrhage.[164,165,166] 

## **F I G U R E  3 2** 

Early prenatal care use across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target 

**==> picture [487 x 216] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
80% TARGET 74.8%<br>80.0%<br>70% 66.0%<br>60.5%<br>60% CURRENT  57.5%<br>54.3%<br>68.0%<br>50%<br>40%<br>30%<br>20%<br>10%<br>NO DATA  NOT APPLICABLE NO DATA AVAILABLE<br>AVAILABLE<br>0%<br>W          B/AA        H/LX            O           A/PI            AI           MALE    FEMALE     < 200% 200-399% 400%+<br>W  = WHITE  O  = OTHER<br>B/AA  = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN A/PI  = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>H/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) AI  = AMERICAN INDIAN<br>THE 1ST TRIMESTER OF PREGNANCY<br>PERCENT OF WOMEN WHO RECEIVE PRENATAL CARE IN<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **Levers for Change** 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

• Ensure group prenatal care, childbirth education, and doula services are covered services by Prepaid Health Plans • Use community health workers to provide outreach and education to women of childbearing age in underserved communities • Expand Medicaid eligibility 

The HNC 2030 work group reviewed data across several years and a forecasted value for North Carolina based on historical data to develop a target for the percentage of women receiving early prenatal care. The group chose 80% of women receiving care in the first trimester as the target for 2030. This would reflect a reversal of a negative trend seen over the past 10 years and represent a substantial move toward ensuring that all pregnant women in the state get care within the first trimester of pregnancy. 

• Encourage workforce diversity and cultural competence in the delivery of prenatal care services 

- 

Support quality improvement efforts to standardize treatment protocol to minimize provider bias 

• Expand safe and reliable public transit options (PRAMS, 2005) • Take advantage of the Children’s Health Insurance Program option to provide coverage for comprehensive prenatal care to undocumented immigrant women 

**Packet Pg. 265** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 89 

88 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

89
{45}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 19: SUICIDE RATE** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: IMPROVE ACCESS AND TREATMENT FOR MENTAL HEALTH NEEDS** 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

**CURRENT TARGET** _Mental health and access to treatment services are often overlooked in our health care system. One indicator of mental health outcomes –_ 13.8 11.1 _suicide –has been on the rise for years. Some special populations, such_ Per 100,000 Per 100,000 people people _as veterans and LGBTQ youth, have seen elevated rates of suicide that will require targeted prevention strategies._ 

**DEFINITION** 

## **Context** 

Age-adjusted number of deaths attributable to self-harm per 100,000 population **DETAILS** Not Applicable 

Suicide accounted for 1,499 deaths in North Carolina in 2018.[167] This corresponds with a national trend of rising suicide rates during the last decade.[168] The impact of suicide is felt on both the personal and community level. Family and friends of the deceased bear both emotional and financial burdens.[169] The state also shoulders a financial burden, losing an average of $1.1 million in “lifetime medical and work loss cost” in 2017.[167] 

**NC SUICIDE RATE (2018)** 13.8 per 100,000 people 

Suicide is inextricably linked to mental health care and well-being. Studies show that many persons who die of suicide either had diagnosed mental illnesses[169 ] or experienced high-stress traumas such as financial insecurity, housing instability, or physical illness.[170] Suicide is also connected with insurance status, as people who are uninsured or underinsured are less likely to seek mental health care and treatment for health conditions that may contribute to mental and financial strains.[171] However, for those who are able to access care, one study has shown that suicide prevention strategies are not a large focus of mental health provider training.[169] Rather, strategies to treat underlying mental health conditions are emphasized, without specific attention to suicidal ideation or patient safety planning.[169] The suicide rate can be used as a downstream indicator of access to comprehensive high-quality health care. 

**2030 TARGET** 11.1 per 100,000 people 

**RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES (2014-2018 AVERAGE)** 2.2 – 33.6 per 100,000 people 

**RANK AMONG STATES** 16th* 

## **Disparities** 

**DATA SOURCE** NC State Center for Health Statistics, Vital Statistics 

Suicide affects populations disproportionally based on gender, age, racial or ethnic group, and geography. Men, adults over the age of 45,[172] American Indians and whites,[141] and rural residents all face higher rates of suicide than their respective demographic counterparts.[173] 

**STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Not Applicable 

The suicide rate among veterans is 1.5 times that of the non-veteran population.[YY,174] Veterans face unique mental health, financial, and insurance coverage challenges that contribute to the increased rate within the population.[175] Veterans are also more likely to have access to firearms, a factor that increases the likelihood of fatal self-harm.[176,175] 

*Rank of 1st for state with lowest suicide rate 

Elevated suicide rates are also seen in LGBTQ populations. There is no comprehensive data source for the suicide rate amongst LGBTQ persons, as sexual identity is not a component of death records. However, survey data indicates that among LGBTQ youth, the rate of suicidal ideation is 4.5 times higher than their heterosexual peers. Additionally, 40% of transgender adults report a suicide attempt.[177] This disparity is only magnified in the young adult population, and among racial and ethnic minorities.[178,179 ] Discrimination, social 

## **F I G U R E  3 3** 

Suicide rate across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target 

**==> picture [498 x 210] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
24<br>22.4<br>21<br>17.8<br>18 CURRENT<br>13.8<br>15<br>12<br>9<br>TARGET<br>7.7<br>5.7 5.8 5.9<br>6 11.1<br>3<br>NO DATA AVAILABLE NO DATA AVAILABLE<br>0<br>W          B/AA        H/LX            O           A/PI            AI           MALE    FEMALE     < 200% 200-399% 400%+<br>W  = WHITE  O  = OTHER<br>B/AA  = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN A/PI  = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>H/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) AI  = AMERICAN INDIAN<br>ONE-YEAR, AGE-ADJUSTED<br>SUICIDE DEATH RATES (PER 100,000 POPLUTION),<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Levers for Change** 

ostracism, family rejection, financial barriers, and health care barriers all contribute to an increased mental health burden on this population that corresponds with an increased rate of suicidal behavior.[177] 

• Expand Medicaid eligibility criteria to increase access to mental health services • Increase state funding for mental health services provided through local mental health systems • Implement policies targeted to decrease access to lethal means • Improve access to social services and other supports • Increase programs that provide mental health services and support for LGBTQ youth 

Suicide is also on the rise among children age 10-17 and is now the second leading cause of death among this age group with rates doubling over the past decade.[180,181] In 2017, 8.2% of high schoolers reported they attempted suicide, with highest levels among African American high schoolers (11.1%), Hispanic high schoolers (9.3%), and high schoolers reporting their race as Other (17.9%). 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

The HNC 2030 work group reviewed data across several years and projected the future trend of suicide rate to develop a target. The group chose 11.1 as the number of deaths per 100,000 population by 2030. As the age-adjusted suicide rate has risen steadily over the last decade in North Carolina, and is expected to continue rising, movement toward this target would represent a meaningful reversal in this trend. 

• Increase programs that provide mental health services and support for veterans 

• Continue to support the integration of physical and mental health • Expand access to tele-mental health services • Create trauma informed schools with access to mental health providers 

_YYThis figure is adjusted by age and gender._ 

90 

**Packet Pg. 266** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 91 

91 

HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030
{46}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

## DEVELOPMENTAL MEASURES 

## **Underinsurance** 

The clinical care measures below are ones that the HNC 2030 group feels is important to population health but does not have data available at this time. A description of the data needed for this measure is listed as “developmental data needs.” State entities should consider identifying methods for collecting this data. 

Health insurance generally encourages people to use preventive health services and is meant to protect people from high medical bills. However, many people covered by health insurance face high deductibles and out-of-pocket spending for health care. These individuals are underinsured. People who are underinsured are less likely to access preventive services and can face challenges paying their medical bills. For example, a 2018 survey of Americans found that 25% of people who are underinsured did not fill a prescription (compared to 11% of people who are insured), 23% skipped recommended tests, treatments or follow-ups (10% insured), 24% did not see a doctor for a medical problem (11% insured), and 17% did not get needed specialty care (7% insured).[182] The same survey found that the number of adults who are underinsured is increasing, with 29% in 2018 up from 23% in 2014.[BBB,183] The largest growth in underinsurance is in employersponsored plans, with 28% of these plans leaving adults underinsured in 2018, compared to 20% in 2014. 

## **Social Determinants of Health Screening** 

The NC DHHS seeks to fundamentally change how we think about health and drivers of health. Rather than focusing just on the provision of health care, NC DHHS is highlighting the need to view health as a person’s well-being and to understand their social drivers of health status. One aspect of their work has been the development of a standardized set of questions related to food, housing, transportation, and interpersonal violence.[ZZ] This standardized set of questions is mandated for use by Medicaid managed care plans[AAA ] at enrollment of members. However, the NC DHHS is encouraging the adoption of the screening questions across all populations, regardless of insurance status. This data will provide information critical to painting a more accurate picture of the non-clinical health needs of residents. From a clinical perspective, measuring the implementation of the screening (i.e., percentage of patients with a completed social determinants of health screening in the past year) was viewed as a potentially important measure of clinical care. 

## **Developmental data needs:** 

- Ongoing monitoring of the underinsured population in North Carolina through surveys would help to identify populations that are facing high out-of-pocket health care spending. This information would be useful for policy-making purposes. 

## **Developmental data needs:** 

• With Medicaid managed care implementation beginning in winter 2020, there has been no systematic data collected and reported yet on the social determinants of health screenings for the population enrolled in Medicaid. Data should be collected on the use of the screening by managed care organizations and other insurance and health care providers, potentially through NC HealthConnex. 

• De-identified statistics on the non-clinical health needs across populations would be useful to evaluate the drivers of health across the state into the future. 

_ZZ Screening for health-related social needs is a sensitive matter that should involve considerations of trust and privacy. To have a successful screening process, individuals being screened need to trust that their information is safe and will be shared in a limited way to improve their health or access to services. Screening should be non-judgmental, performed by trained staff, offered in private settings, and enhance access to services. The NCIOM Task Force on Accountable Care Communities made recommendations about ensuring individuals are informed about personal data collection and sharing. (NCIOM, 2019)_ 

_AAA Instead of reimbursing health systems and providers directly, under Medicaid managed care NC DHHS will contract with Prepaid Health Plans (PHPs) to deliver health services to enrollees. PHPs will receive a monthly capitated payment for each enrollee. NC DHHS will provide monitoring and oversight of the PHPs, which will be required to meet quality and outcome metrics and other requirements. All PHPs will be required to use the standardized screening questions to measure beneficiary needs. Results will be used to determine the need for care management and will be shared with primary care providers. BBB The Commonwealth Fund survey defines underinsured as having yearly out-of-pocket costs, excluding premiums, that are 10% or more of household income, or equal to 5% or more of household income for people living under 200% of the Federal Poverty Level, or deductibles that are 5% or more of household income._ 

## **C H A P T E R  7** 

## HEALTH OUTCOMES 

**==> picture [233 x 88] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [441 x 257] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 267** 

92 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

93 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{47}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

## INTRODUCTION 

The drivers of health discussed to this point– Social & Economic Factors, Physical Environment, Health Behaviors, and Clinical Care – along with genetic predispositions of individuals and the policies and programs that lay the context for our society, culminate in the quality and length of the lives we lead. These are our health outcomes, which encompass the physical and mental health and well-being of North Carolinians. 

Throughout this report, the disparities discussed within each of the health indicators point to the ways that different populations face inequitable opportunities to achieve the best possible health. Race, ethnicity, geography, sex, age, sexual orientation, veteran status, and poverty level are just some of the qualities that influence the drivers of our health and well-being. The HNC 2030 group chose two health outcome indicators that together provide a bellwether for the state of health of North Carolinians—infant mortality and life expectancy. These indicators highlight the disparate realities we see in health outcomes across the state. By looking at these two indicators, and their changes over time, the impact of efforts to improve health and well-being can be seen for the population as a whole and for subpopulations. 

## **20** 

## **21** 

## **HEALTH INDICATORS:** 

## **INFANT MORTALITY RATE** 

## Decrease Infant Mortality 

## **LIFE EXPECTANCY** 

## Increase Life Expectancy 

**Packet Pg. 268** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 95 

94 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

95
{48}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 20: INFANT MORTALITY RATE** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: DECREASE INFANT MORTALITY** 

**==> picture [158 x 89] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
CURRENT TARGET<br>6.8 6.0<br>(2018)<br>Per 1,000 live births;  Per 1,000 live births;<br>Black/white disparity  Black/white disparity<br>ratio = 2.4 ratio = 1.5<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**DEFINITION** 

Rate of infant deaths per 1,000 live births 

## **DETAILS** 

Deaths are counted if they occur within the first year of life 

**NC INFANT MORTALITY (2018)** 6.8 per 1,000 live births Black/white disparity ratio = 2.4 

**2030 TARGET** 6.0 per 1,000 live births Black/white disparity ratio = 1.5 

**RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** 0.0 – 22.2 per 1,000 live births **RANK AMONG STATES** Tied for 40th* 

## **DATA SOURCE** 

NC State Center for Health Statistics, Vital Statistics **STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Early Childhood Action Plan - indictor of infant mortality disparity 

*Rank of 1st for state with lowest infant mortality 

rate 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

_Infant mortality is a common proxy for overall community health and health disparities and the health of infants reflects the health of the next generation. North Carolina has a higher infant mortality rate than the country as a whole and, in particular, babies born to African American and American Indian women are more likely to die in the first year of life than babies born to white women._ 

## **Context** 

Infant mortality is not only an indicator of maternal and child health, it is often looked to as an indicator of the health of a community.[184] This is because many of the factors that influence rates of infant mortality reflect the health equity of a community. These include maternal health and educational status, prenatal care, and social and economic factors of the child’s family. 

|The primary predictors of infant health are gestational age at birth and birth weight, and there are<br>many contributing factors to these outcomes.185Higher rates of low birth weight and infant mortality are<br>associated with:<br>•<br>Smoking or heavy consumption of alcohol while<br>pregnant186,187<br>•<br>Maternal age -  younger (under 20 years) and older<br>mothers (40-54 years)185<br>•<br>Maternal obesity188,189<br>•<br>Maternal educational status of less than a high school<br>degree190<br>•<br>Unmarried parents185<br>•<br>Intimate partner violence155<br>•<br>Food insecurity155<br>“Even for African American<br>women who attain a higher<br>socioeconomic status,<br>pregnancy-related outcomes<br>are worse than those of<br>white women at lower<br>socioeconomic levels.”|
|---|



## **Disparities** 

The United States, and North Carolina specifically, have struggled to keep pace with the improvements in maternal and infant health that have occurred in other developed countries. One reason for this is the large disparity seen in infant mortality for babies born to African American and American Indian women, who are more likely to die in the first year of life than babies born to white women.[45] In particular, the disparity between babies born to African American women and those born to white women is persistently high across time. Women of color are more likely to live in communities that have fewer educational resources and employment opportunities due to historical segregation through housing and education policies. Women of color also face accumulated stress of discrimination regardless of socioeconomic status (i.e., “weathering,” **see Page 31** in Introduction). These socioeconomic factors are linked to birth outcomes and infant mortality. In addition, research shows that even for African American women who attain a higher socioeconomic status, pregnancy-related outcomes are worse than those of white women at lower socioeconomic levels.[191] Inside the medical system, disparate treatment of mothers of color may also play a role in worse birth outcomes. Studies show that implicit bias in health care delivery may prevent women of color from receiving sufficient patient education in the prenatal period about risks to maternal and fetal health.[163] 

## **F I G U R E  3 4** 

Infant mortality rates across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target 

**==> picture [498 x 210] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
14<br>12.2<br>12<br>9.3<br>10<br>CURRENT<br>8.0<br>8 6.8<br>6<br>5.0 5.0 5.5<br>4.8<br>TARGET<br>4<br>6.0<br>2<br>NO DATA<br>AVAILABLE NO DATA AVAILABLE<br>0<br>W          B/AA        H/LX            O           A/PI            AI           MALE    FEMALE     < 200% 200-399% 400%+<br>W  = WHITE  O  = OTHER<br>B/AA  = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN A/PI  = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>H/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) AI  = AMERICAN INDIAN<br>INFANT MORTALITY RATE (PER 1,000 LIVE BIRTHS)<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Levers for Change** 

Disparities in infant mortality also exist for babies born to women in poverty and those who are uninsured. Women in poverty experience more challenging life circumstances, have lower educational attainment, are more likely to have limited access to adequate food, transportation, and housing, and are more likely to be uninsured than those not experiencing poverty. These populations are also more likely to have limited access to health care services. Even though Medicaid covers prenatal care and births for lowincome uninsured women, birth outcomes and subsequent infant mortality are not fully addressed by the care they receive during pregnancy because of the many social and health factors these women face prior to becoming pregnant.[192] Furthermore, in NC, women who are undocumented immigrants are ineligible for Medicaid during pregnancy, severely restricting their access to care. 

(America’s Health Rankings, Infant Mortality, 2018) 

• Increase access to health insurance • Improve male and female pre-conception routine medical check-ups and family planning counseling with a focus on intimate partner violence, substance use, immunizations, depression, body mass index, blood pressure, and diabetes 

• Improve access to, and use of, prenatal care, Centering Pregnancy Programs, and evidencebased home visiting programs • Reduce maternal obesity • Reduce maternal tobacco use before, during, and after pregnancy (Ward, 2003) • Take advantage of the Children’s Health 

## **2030 Target and Potential for Change** 

The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years, populations, and states, and a forecasted value for North Carolina based on historical data to set a target for 2030. While the overall infant mortality rate has decreased over the past decade, the disparity ratio between whites and African Americans has grown (currently 2.4), meaning that the infant mortality rate has improved much faster for white babies. With this in mind, the group chose an overall infant mortality target of 6.0 per 1,000 live births for 2030, as well as a target to decrease the Black/white disparity ratio to 1.5. Meeting this target will be largely dependent upon drastically reducing the disparities we see in infant mortality rates for African Americans and American Indians. 

Take advantage of the Children’s Health Insurance Program option to provide coverage for comprehensive prenatal care to undocumented immigrant women 

• 

Follow the recommendations of the Perinatal Health Strategic Plan 

**Packet Pg. 269** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 97 

96 

97 

HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030
{49}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

## **HEALTH INDICATOR 21: LIFE EXPECTANCY** 

## **DESIRED RESULT: INCREASE LIFE EXPECTANCY** 

**CURRENT TARGET** 78.0 82.0 years years 

**DEFINITION** 

Average number of years of life remaining for persons who have attained a given age **DETAILS** 

Life expectancy listed is for a person born in that year 

**NC LIFE EXPECTANCY (2016-18)** 78.0 years **2030 TARGET** 82.0 years 

**RANGE AMONG NC COUNTIES** 73.1 – 82.1 years 

**RANK AMONG STATES** Not Available **DATA SOURCE** NC State Center for Health Statistics, Vital Statistics **STATE PLANS WITH SIMILAR INDICATORS** Not Applicable 

## _**Rationale for Selection:**_ 

_Life expectancy is a proxy measure for the total health of a population. Disparities in life expectancy between populations point to areas where issues of health equity must be addressed._ 

## **Context** 

The ultimate measure of health that many people consider when thinking of population health is life expectancy. For most of human history, average life expectancy has steadily increased with improvements in health care, sanitary conditions, decreases in disease epidemics, and improved safety measures. Yet, in the past several years, the United States average life expectancy has been slowly creeping down, from 78.9 years in 2014 to 78.6 in 2017.[193] This is due to an increase in deaths from drug overdose and suicide.[194] The 2016-18 state average life expectancy was 78.0, with similar decreases as the national average (2014 life expectancy: 78.3). The top three causes of years of life lost in North Carolina are ischemic heart disease; trachea, bronchus, and lung cancers; and road injuries. Self-harm and drug use disorders rank sixth and seventh, respectively, in top causes, mirroring the national trends impacting overall life expectancy. 

## **Disparities** 

There are stark disparities in life expectancy across race, geography, and gender, as well as intersections of these characteristics that show wide gaps between groups. African Americans, American Indians, people in rural areas, and men typically have lower life expectancies than the average. Among African Americans (including those of Hispanic ethnicity), the average life expectancy  for women (79.0 years) is slightly above the state average (78.0 years), although lower than the average for white women (including those of Hispanic ethnicity) (81.1 years).[195] For African American men (including those of Hispanic ethnicity) the average is much lower at 72.2 years compared to 76.5 years for white men (including those of Hispanic ethnicity).[195] The disparities for African Americans compared to whites are due in part to issues stemming from limited health care access,[196] lack of trust in medical professionals, social and economic factors like racism (e.g., weathering, **see Page 31** in Introduction) and unemployment,[196] and firearm deaths of younger African American men.[197] On the other hand, Hispanic populations see the higher life expectancies despite lower average socioeconomic status.  This is largely due to lower rates of smoking, leading to lower cancer and cardiovascular disease mortality in adults, but also lower rates of suicide and accidental poisoning among young Hispanics compared to whites.[198] 

Geographic disparities are also clear across North Carolina ( **See Figure 36** ). People born in Swain County have the lowest life expectancy (average for 2016-18) at 73.1 years, while those in Orange County have the highest at 82.1 years.  Factoring race and geography together reveals the multiple levels of disparities. Life expectancy for the white population in Swain is 75.6 years and is 67.5 years for the American Indian population. In Orange County the life expectancy for the white population is  83.1 years compared to 75.2 years for the African American population in the same county.[199] 

## **F I G U R E  3 5** 

## Life expectancy across populations in North Carolina and distance to 2030 target 

**==> picture [523 x 278] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
87.0*<br>90 TARGET<br>80.3<br>82.0<br>80 78.3* 75.5* 75.6* 74.8<br>70<br>CURRENT<br>60 78.0<br>50<br>40<br>30<br>‡‡ LIFE EXPECTANCY<br>20 ETHE HISPANIC STIMATES FOR<br>POPULATION ARE<br>10 ESTIMATE FOR 2016-UNSTABLE. THE  NO DATA<br>18 IS 90.8 YEARS. AVAILABLE NO DATA AVAILABLE<br>0<br>W          B/AA        H/LX            O           A/PI            AI           MALE    FEMALE     < 200% 200-399% 400%+<br>W  = WHITE  O  = OTHER RACE / ETHNICITY SEX FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL<br>B/AA  = BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN A/PI  = ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER<br>H/LX  = HISPANIC/LATIN(X) AI  = AMERICAN INDIAN * 2016-18 AVERAGE<br>2030 Target and Potential for Change Levers for Change<br>The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years, populations, and states, and a forecasted value for  •  See Levers for Change throughout this report<br>AVERAGE LIFE EXPECTANCY AT BIRTH (YEARS)<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


The HNC 2030 group reviewed data across several years, populations, and states, and a forecasted value for North Carolina based on historical data to set a target for 2030. With the best life expectancy (average for 2016-18) in North Carolina currently at 82.1[FFF] years in Orange County the group chose to set an aggressive target of 82.0 years for the population overall for 2030. If improvements are made across the health indicators discussed in this report, overall life expectancy will likely see an increase. Increases toward this target will be seen as success, particularly as they will signal a change in the downward trend seen over the past several years. 

## **F I G U R E  3 6** 

Average Life Expectancy for People in North Carolina Counties, 2016-2018 

**==> picture [278 x 106] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [82 x 70] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
73.1 - 75.9 (27 Counties)<br>76.0 - 76.9 (25 Counties)<br>77.0 - 77.9 (20 Counties)<br>78.0 - 79.9 (21 Counties)<br>79.0 - 82.1 (7 Counties)<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


_Source: North Carolina State Center for Health Statistics; https://schs.dph.ncdhhs.gov/data/lifexpectancy/2016-2018/2018%20State%20and%202016-2018%20County%20Life%20Expectancies%20at%20birth.html Note: Life expectancy is the average number of additional years that someone at a given age would be expected to live if current mortality conditions remained constant throughout their lifetime._ 

_DDD The life expectancy averages listed here are averaged across three years, 2016 to 2018. EEE Estimated life expectancy for the Hispanic population in North Carolina for 2016 to 2018 is 90.8 years. This estimate has been excluded from the HNC 2030 report data presentation because of concerns that it may be  unreliable. FFF North Carolina State Center for Health Statistics, 2016-2018 County Life Expectancy at Birth, North Carolina Counties. https://schs.dph.ncdhhs.gov/data/lifexpectancy/2016-2018/2018%20State%20and%202016-2018%20County%20Life%20Expectancies%20at%20birth.html_ 

**Packet Pg. 270** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 99 

98 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

99
{50}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

## CONCLUSION 

## REFERENCES 

The HNC 2030 objectives and health indicators will help to guide state and local efforts over the next decade to ensure everyone in North Carolina can live the healthiest life possible. The process and framework of the HNC 2030 efforts reflect the desire to gather community input and select health indicators across a wide range of topics that drive health. Decision-makers in the HNC 2030 process sought to highlight key issues of health disparities and health inequities within our state for people across race, ethnicity, geographic location, sex, and poverty level. 

Overall, 21 health indicators were chosen across the topics of Social & Economic Factors, Physical Environment, Health Behaviors, Clinical Care, and Health Outcomes. Many of these indicators have not traditionally been considered in the work of public health, including reading proficiency, incarceration rates, housing problems, and employment. Yet, it is clear from growing research that these issues play a very large role in the opportunities people have to make healthy choices for their lives, and in some cases directly impact health outcomes. 

Each section of this report included statewide data and “Levers for Change,” yet it is important to remember that many of these issues vary widely on the local level. County-level data provides the best picture of the issues faced within communities, and even still, it is vital to dig deeper into that data to see variances across race, ethnicity, income, and other factors.[GGG] An overall unemployment rate or teen birth rate does not show the disparities that exist across groups. We encourage counties and communities to look at all available information for their populations to understand where efforts are needed to improve the drivers of health. 

Addressing the variety of topics that affect how we live, learn, work, play, and age will require the collaboration of leadership across public health and other sectors. Community-based cross-sector partnerships will be key to addressing the range of HNC 2030 objectives. People who work at the community level understand the specific issues that an area faces and what partners are needed to affect change. Partnerships should include community members impacted by an issue and stakeholders such as public health, health care, business, education, law enforcement, transportation, and housing, to name a few. 

As the new decade begins, the NC DHHS and DPH will be developing a population health improvement strategy and resources to be used at the local level. HNC 2030 is intended to be a road map not just for NC DHHS, but for the whole state, including state agencies that may not think of their role as traditionally aligned with health. The broader view of the drivers of health and well-being with attention to health disparities will help make North Carolina a place for everyone to live a healthy life. 

1. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion. Health Equity. Accessed September 1, 2019. http://www.cdc.gov/chronicdisease/healthequity/index.htm 

2. Glanz K, Rimer BK, Viswanath K. _Health Behavior: Theory, Research, and Practice_ . 5th ed. (Jossey-Bass, ed.). San Francisco, California. 2015. 

3. North Carolina Office of Minority Health and Health Disparities. _Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities in North Carolina: North Carolina Health Equity Report 2018_ . 2018. https://schs.dph.ncdhhs.gov/SCHS/pdf/MinorityHealthReport_Web_2018.pdf. 

4. National Institutes of Health Intramural Research Program. Health Disparities. https://irp.nih.gov/our-research/scientific-focusareas/health-disparities. Accessed October 16, 2018. 

5. County Health Rankings Model, County Health Rankings & Roadmaps. https://www.countyhealthrankings.org/explore-healthrankings/measures-data-sources/county-health-rankings-model. Accessed October 1, 2019. 

6. Tilson E. _North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services' Vision for Buying Health. Presentation to the North Carolina Institute of Medicine Task Force on Accountable Care Communities_ . 2018. http://nciom.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Tilson_NCDHHS_Presentation_3.5.2018.pdf. 

7. DeSalvo KB, Claire WY, Harris A, Auerbach J, Koo D, O’Carroll P. Public Health 3.0: A Call to Action for Public Health to Meet the Challenges of the 21st Century. _Preventing Chronic Disease_ . 2017;14(9). doi:10.5888/pcd14.170017. 

8. Chetty R, Stepner M, Abraham S, Lin S, Scuder B, Turner N, Bergeron A, Cutler D. The Association Between Income and Life Expectancy in the United States, 2001-2014. _Journal of the American Medical Association_ . 2016;315(16):1750-1766. doi:10.1001/jama.2016.4226. 

9. Adler NE, Newman K. Socioeconomic Disparities in Health: Pathways and Policies. _HealthAffairs_ . 2002;21(2):60-76. doi:10.1377/hlthaff.21.2.60. 

10. Braveman P, Gottlieb L. The Social Determinants of Health: It’s Time to Consider the Causes of the Causes. _Public Health Reports_ . 2014;129 Suppl:19-31. doi:10.1177/00333549141291S206. 

11. Gee GC, Ford CL. Structural Racism and Health Inequities: Old Issues, New Directions. _Du Bois Rev_ . 2011;8(1):115-132. doi:10.1017/S1742058X11000130. 

12. Bailey ZD, Krieger N, Agénor M, Graves J, Linos N, Bassett MT. Structural Racism and Health Inequities in the USA: Evidence and Interventions. _Lancet_ (London, England). 2017;389(10077):1453-1463. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(17)30569-X. 

13. Nordstrom K. _Stymied by Segregation: How Integration Can Transform North Carolina Schools and the Lives of its Students_ . 2018. https://www.ncjustice.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/STYMIED-BY-SEGREGATION-Integration-can-Transform-NC-FINALweb.pdf. 

14. Bayer P, Ferreira F, Ross S. _What Drives Racial and Ethnic Differences in High Cost Mortgages? The Role of High Risk Lenders_ . NBER Working Paper No. 22004. February 2016. https://www.nber.org/papers/w22004.pdf. 

15. American College of Physicians. _Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care_ , Updated 2010. Philadelphia: American College of Physicians' 2010: Policy Paper. (Available from American College of Phyciains, 190 N. Independence Mall West, Philadelphia, PA 19106). 

16. Fiscella K, Sanders MR. Racial and Ethnic Disparities in the Quality of Health Care. _Annual Review of Public Health_ . 2016;37(1):375394. doi:10.1146/annurev-publhealth-032315-021439. 

_GGG The most recent county-level data for HNC 2030 indicators as of publication can be found on the NCIOM website with the electronic version of this report._ 

**Packet Pg. 271** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 101 

100 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

101
{51}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

17. Youmans Q, Hastings-Spaine L, Princewill O, Shobayo T, Okwuosa I. Disparities in Cardiovascular Care: Past, present, and Solutions. _Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine_ . 2019;86(9):621-632. https://www.mdedge.com/ccjm/article/206853/cardiology/disparities-cardiovascular-care-past-present-and-solutions. 

18. Geronimus AT, Hicken M, Keene D, Bound J. “Weathering” and Age Patterns of Allostatic Load Scores Among Blacks and Whites in the United States. _American Journal of Public Health_ . 2006;96(5):826-833. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2004.060749. 

19. Ross CE, Chia-Ling Wu. The Links Between Education and Health. _Americna Sociological Review_ . 1995;60(5):719-745. doi:10.2307/2096319. 

20. Pager D. The Mark of a Criminal Record. _American Journal of Sociology_ . 2003;108(5):937-975. 

21. Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion. Poverty. https://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives/topic/social-determinants-health/interventions-resources/poverty#7. Accessed August 15, 2019. 

22. Dubay L, Simon SM, Zimmerman E, Luk KX, Woolf SH. _How Are Income and Wealth Linked to Health And Longevity?_ Urban Institute. Virginia Commonwealth University Center on Society and Health. 2015. https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/49116/2000178-How-are-Income-and-Wealth-Linked-to-Health-andLongevity.pdf. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

23. Cunningham TJ, Croft JB, Liu Y, Lu H, Eke PI, Giles WH. Vital Signs: Racial Disparities in Age-Specific Mortality Among Blacks or African Americans — United States, 1999–2015. _Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report_ . 2017;66(17):444-456. doi:10.15585/mmwr.mm6617e1. 

24. Seervai S, Lewis C. _Listening to Low-Income Patients: Mental Health Stigma Is a Barrier to Care_ . March 20, 2018. https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/other-publication/2018/mar/listening-low-income-patients-mental-healthstigma-barrier. 

25. Deaton A. _Health, Income, and Inequality_ . The National Bureau of Economic Research. https://www.nber.org/reporter/spring03/health.html. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

26. United States Census Bureau. American Fact Finder. American Community Survey. https://factfinder.census.gov/faces/nav/jsf/pages/searchresults.xhtml?refresh=t. Published 2017. Accessed May 22, 2019. 

27. Office of the Assistant Secretary of Planning and Evaluation. 2019 Poverty Guidelines. https://aspe.hhs.gov/2019-povertyguidelines. Accessed November 24, 2019. 

28. United States Census Bureau. Income and Poverty in the United States: 2017. https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2018/demo/p60-263.html. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

29. Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. Distribution of the Total Population by Federal Poverty Level (above and below 200% FPL). https://www.kff.org/other/state-indicator/population-up-to-200-fpl/?currentTimeframe=0&selectedDistributions=under200percent&sortModel=%7B%22colId%22:%22Under 200%25%22,%22sort%22:%22asc%22%7D. Accessed November 24, 2019. 

30. Rantakeisu U, Starrin B, Hagquist C. Unemployment: A Double Burden and a Public Issue. _Social Justice Research_ . 1997;10(2):153173. doi:10.1007/BF02683310. 

31. Paul KI, Moser K. Unemployment Impairs Mental Health: Meta-analyses. _Journal of Vocational Behavior._ 2009;74(3):264-282. doi:10.1016/j.jvb.2009.01.001. 

32. County Health Rankings & Roadmaps. Unemployment. https://www.countyhealthrankings.org/explore-healthrankings/measures-data-sources/county-health-rankings-model/health-factors/social-and-economicfactors/employment/unemployment. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

33. Crowder JA, Bastien A, Stephens P, Treuhaft S, Scoggins J. _Advancing Employment Equity in Rural North Carolina_ . 2018. http://plcylk.org/2ApazHr. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

34. Couloute L, Kopf D. Out of Prison & Out of Work: Unemployment Among Formerly Incarcerated People. https://www.prisonpolicy.org/reports/outofwork.html. 

35. Travis J, Western B, Redburn S. _The Growth of Incarceration in the United States: Exploring Causes and Consequences_ . National Academies Press. 2014. doi:10.17226/18613. 

36. Gordon N. _Disproportionality in Student Discipline: Connecting Policy to Research_ . January 18, 2018. https://www.brookings.edu/research/disproportionality-in-student-discipline-connecting-policy-to-research/. 

37. Egerter S, Braveman P, Sadegh-Nobari T, Grossman-Kahn R, Dekker M. _Education and Health_ . April 2, 2011. https://www.rwjf.org/en/library/research/2011/05/education-matters-for-health.html. 

38. Skiba RJ, Horner RH, Chung C-G, Rausch MK, May SL, Tobin T. Race Is Not Neutral: A National Investigation of African American and Latino Disproportionality in School Discipline. _School Psychology Review_ . 2011;40(1):85-107. 

39. North Carolina Department of Public Instruction. March 15, 2019. Report to the North Carolina General Assembly. Consolidated Data Report 2017-18. http://www.ncpublicschools.org/docs/research/discipline/reports/consolidated/2017-18/consolidatedreport.pdf. 

40. Kennedy JE, Chance M. _Collateral Damage: How Mass Incarceration Increases Poverty and Crime in North Carolina’s Poorest African American Communities_ . August 2011. https://www.yumpu.com/en/document/view/4484815/collateral-damage-how-massincarceration-increases-poverty-and-. 

41. Thomas JC, Torrone E. Incarceration as Forced Migration: Effects on Selected Community Health Outcomes. _American Journal of Public Health_ . 2006;96(10):1762-1765. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2005.081760. 

42. Dumont DM, Brockmann B, Dickman S, Alexander N, Rich JD. Public Health and the Epidemic of Incarceration. _Annual Review of Public Health_ . 2012;33(1):325-339. doi:10.1146/annurev-publhealth-031811-124614. 

43. Committee on Causes and Consequences of High Rates of Incarceration; Committee on Law and Justice; Division of Behavioral and Social Sciences and Education; National Research Council; Board on the Health of Select Populations; Institute of Medicine. 2013. Health and Incarceration: A Workshop Summary. Washington, D.C. https://www.nap.edu/read/18372/chapter/2. 

44. Department of Public Safety Division of Adult Correction and Juvenile Justice Task Force on Sentencing Reforms for Opioid Drug Convictions. Presentation to Task Force on Sentencing Reforms for Opioid Drug Convictions. March 6, 2018. https://www.ncleg.gov/documentsites/committees/BCCI-6684//March 6, 2018/Powerpoint 02 - DPS_Snapshot of Current Incarceration Statistics_030618 (002).pdf. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

45. North Carolina State Center for Health Statistics. Vital Statistics. https://schs.dph.ncdhhs.gov/data/provisional/Birth/2017/CY2017 PB17 Resident Births by PNC.html. Published 2017. Accessed August 15, 2019. 

46. The Sentencing Project. State-by-State Data. https://www.sentencingproject.org/the-facts/#map?dataset-option=SIR. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

**Packet Pg. 272** 

102 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

103 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{52}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

47. McGuire H. North Carolina Prison Population Figures and Demographics - Infogram. https://infogram.com/north-carolinaprison-population-figures-and-demographics-1g6qo2q93o1wm78. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

48. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. About Adverse Childhood Experiences. April 9, 2019. https://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/childabuseandneglect/acestudy/aboutace.html. Accessed October 1, 2019. 

49. Merrick MT, Ford DC, Ports KA, et al. Vital Signs: Estimated Proportion of Adult Health Problems Attributable to Adverse Childhood Experiences and Implications for Prevention — 25 States, 2015–2017. _Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report_ . 2019;68(44). doi:10.15585/mmwr.mm6844e1. 

50. Child and Adolescent Health Measurement Initiative. 2016-2017 National Survey of Children’s Health (NSCH) Data Query. Data Resource Center for Child and Adolescent Health Supported by Cooperative Agreement U59MC27866 from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Health Resources and Services Administration’s Maternal and Child Health Bureau (HRSA MCHB). www.cahmi.org. Accessed July 23, 2019. 

51. Annie E. Casey Foundation. Reading by Third Grade. January 1, 2010. https://www.aecf.org/resources/early-warning-whyreading-by-the-end-of-third-grade-matters/. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

52. Rumberger RW. Poverty and High School Dropouts. May 2013. https://www.apa.org/pi/ses/resources/indicator/2013/05/poverty-dropouts. Accessed October 1, 2019. 

53. DeWalt DA, Berkman ND, Sheridan S, Lohr KN, Pignone MP. Literacy and Health Outcomes: A Systematic Review of the Literature. _Journal of General Internal Medicine_ . 2004;19(12):1228-1239. doi:10.1111/j.1525-1497.2004.40153.x. 

54. Berkman N, Dewalt D, Pignone M, et al. Literacy and Health Outcomes: Summary. 2004. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK11942/. 

55. K-3 North Carolina Assessment Think Tank. Assessment for Learning and Development in K-3. 2013. http://www.ncpublicschools.org/docs/earlylearning/k3assessment/oel-think-tank.pdf. 

56. North Carolina Department of Public Instruction. North Carolina School Report Cards. https://ncreportcards.ondemand.sas.com/src. Accessed August 30, 2019. 

57. United States Department of Health and Human Services. Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans 2nd Edition. 2018. https://health.gov/paguidelines/second-edition/pdf/Physical_Activity_Guidelines_2nd_edition.pdf. 

58. Angraal S, Gupta A, Khera R, Nasir K, Desai NR. Association of Access to Exercise Opportunities and Cardiovascular Mortality. _American Heart Journal_ . 2019;212:152-156. doi:10.1016/j.ahj.2019.02.010. 

59. Keith NC, Mi D, Alexander K, Kaiser S, de Groot M. PARCS: A Safety Net Community-based Fitness Center for Low-income Adults. _Progress in Community Health Partnerships: Research, Education, and Action_ . 2016;10(2):185-195. doi:10.1353/cpr.2016.0038. 

60. Park T, Eyler AA, Tabak RG, Valko C, Brownson RC. Opportunities for Promoting Physical Activity in Rural Communities by Understanding the Interests and Values of Community Members. _Journal of Environmental and Public Health_ . 2017. doi:10.1155/2017/8608432. 

61. North Carolina Office on Disability and Health. Removing Barriers to Health Clubs and Fitness Facilities A Guide for Accommodating All Members, Including People with Disabilities and Older Adults. 2008. https://fpg.unc.edu/sites/fpg.unc.edu/files/resources/other-resources/NCODH_RemovingBarriersToHealthClubs.pdf. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

62. Farrigan T, Hamrick K, Hopkins D, et al. Access to Affordable and Nutritious Food Measuring and Understanding Food Deserts and Their Consequences. June 2009. https://www.ers.usda.gov/webdocs/publications/42711/12716_ap036_1_.pdf. 

63. Bleich SN, Jones-Smith J, Wolfson JA, Zhu X, Story M. The Complex Relationship Between Diet and Health. _HealthAffairs_ . 2015;34(11):1813-1820. doi:10.1377/hlthaff.2015.0606. 

64. Seligman HK, Berkowitz SA. Aligning Programs and Policies to Support Food Security and Public Health Goals in the United States. _Annual Review of Public Health_ . 2019;40(1):319-337. doi:10.1146/annurev-publhealth-040218-044132. 

65. Evans A, Banks K, Jennings R, et al. Increasing Access to Healthful Foods: A Qualitative Study With Residents of Low-income Communities. _International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity_ . 2015;12(1). doi:10.1186/1479-5868-12-S1-S5. 

66. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. CDC National Health Report Highlights. https://www.cdc.gov/healthreport/publications/compendium.pdf. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

67. County Health Rankings & Roadmaps. 2019 County Health Rankings Report: North Carolina. 2019. https://www.countyhealthrankings.org/sites/default/files/state/downloads/CHR2019_NC.pdf. 

68. Food Research & Action Center. Why Low-income and Food-insecure People Are Vulnerable to Poor Nutrition and Obesity. https://www.opportunityhome.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/frac_org.pdf. Published 2019. Accessed July 2, 2019. 

69. County Health Rankings & Roadmaps. Food environment index. https://www.countyhealthrankings.org/explore-healthrankings/measures-data-sources/county-health-rankings-model/health-factors/health-behaviors/diet-exercise/foodenvironment-index. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

70. The Food Trust. The Grocery Gap, Who Has Access to Healthy Food and Why It Matters. 2010. http://thefoodtrust.org/uploads/media_items/grocerygap.original.pdf. 

71. Caspi CE, Pelletier JE, Harnack LJ, Erickson DJ, Lenk K, Laska MN. Pricing of Staple Foods at Supermarkets Versus Small Food Stores. _International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health_ . 2017;14(8). doi:10.3390/ijerph14080915. 

72. Taylor L. Housing and Health: An Overview of the Literature. _HealthAffairs_ . June 7, 2018. https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hpb20180313.396577/full/. 

73. Ganesh B, Scally CP, Skopec L, Zhu J. _The Relationship Between Housing and Asthma Among School-Age Children_ . October 16, 2017. https://www.urban.org/research/publication/relationship-between-housing-and-asthma-among-school-age-children 

74. Braveman P, Dekker M, Egerter S, Sadegh-Nobari T PC. _How Does Housing Affect Health?_ https://www.rwjf.org/en/library/research/2011/05/housing-and-health.html. Accessed July 1, 2019. 

75. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Chapter 2: Basic Principles of Healthy Housing. Healthy Housing Reference Manual. October 1, 2009. https://www.cdc.gov/nceh/publications/books/housing/cha02.htm. 

76. Rohe W, Owen T, Kerns S. Extreme Housing Conditions In North Carolina. February 2017. https://curs.unc.edu/files/2017/02/Extreme-Housing-Conditions-in-North-Carolina.pdf. 

77. Maqbool N, Viveiros J, Ault M. The Impacts of Affordable Housing on Health: A Research Summary. 2015. www.greenandhealthyhomes.org. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

78. Miewald C, Ostry A. A Warm Meal and a Bed: Intersections of Housing and Food Security in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside. _Housing Studies_ . 2014;29(6):709-729. doi:10.1080/02673037.2014.920769. 

**Packet Pg. 273** 

104 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

105 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{53}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

79. University of North Carolina Center for Civil Rights. _The State of Exclusion: An Empirical Analysis of the Legacy of Segregated Communities in North Carolina_ . 2013. http://www.uncinclusionproject.org/documents/stateofexclusion.pdf. 

80. County Health Rankings & Roadmaps. Severe Housing Problems in North Carolina. https://www.countyhealthrankings.org/app/north-carolina/2019/measure/factors/136/datasource. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

81. North Carolina Office of the Governor. NC Gov. Cooper: One Year Later: North Carolina Continues Recovering From Hurricane Matthew. https://governor.nc.gov/news/one-year-later-north-carolina-continues-recovering-hurricane-matthew. Accessed October 29, 2019. 

82. Wiltz T. Climate Change Is Making the Affordable Housing Crunch Worse. _Pew Stateline_ . August 30, 2019. https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/blogs/stateline/2019/08/30/climate-change-is-making-the-affordablehousing-crunch-worse. Accessed October 29, 2019. 

83. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Climate Change and Public Health - Health Effects - Precipitation Extremes. September 9, 2019. https://www.cdc.gov/climateandhealth/effects/precipitation_extremes.htm. Accessed October 31, 2019. 

84. Epa U. What Climate Change Means for North Carolina. www.epa.gov/climatechange. Accessed November 18, 2019. 

85. Governor Roy Cooper. Executive Order No. 80 - North Carolina’s Commitment to Address Climate Change and Transition to a Clean Energy Economy. https://files.nc.gov/governor/documents/files/EO80- NC%27s Commitment to Address Climate Change %26 Transition to a Clean Energy Economy.pdf. 

86. Radel L, Baldwin M, Crouse G, Waters A. ASPE Research Brief Substance Use, the Opioid Epidemic, and the Child Welfare System: Key Findings from a Mixed Methods Study. 2018. https://aspe.hhs.gov/child-welfare-and-substance-use. Accessed October 1, 2019. 

87. National Institute on Drug Abuse. Opioid Overdose Crisis. https://www.drugabuse.gov/drugs-abuse/opioids/opioid-overdosecrisis. Accessed August 1, 2019. 

88. America's Health Rankings. Explore Drug Deaths in North Carolina: 2018 Annual Report. https://www.americashealthrankings.org/explore/annual/measure/Drugdeaths/state/NC. Accessed October 2, 2019. 

89. Ruhm CJ. Nonopioid Overdose Death Rates Rose Almost as Fast as Those Involving Opioids, 1999–2016. _HealthAffairs_ . 2019;38(7):1216-1224. doi:10.1377/hlthaff.2018.05522. 

90. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Prescription Opioids. https://www.cdc.gov/drugoverdose/opioids/prescribed.html. Accessed October 25, 2019. 

91. North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services, Division of Public Health. NC Overdose Data: Trends and Surveillance, January 2019. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eE__HL3YL9Q&feature=youtu.be. Accessed October 2, 2019. 

92. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Best Practices for Comprehensive Tobacco Control Programs—2014. 2014. https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/stateandcommunity/best_practices/index.htm. 

93. National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion (US) Office on Smoking and Health. Reports of the Surgeon General. The Health Consequences of Smoking-50 Years of Progress: A Report of the Surgeon General. 2014. 

94. Plescia M, Wansink D, Waters HR, Herndon S. Medical Costs of Secondhand-smoke Exposure in North Carolina. _North Carolina Medical Journal_ . 72(1):7-12. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21678683. Accessed October 2, 2019. 

95. North Carolina State Center for Health Statistics. Statistics and Reports: BRFSS: Survey Results 2017. https://schs.dph.ncdhhs.gov/data/brfss/2017/. Accessed October 2, 2019. 

96. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Tobacco-Related Disparities. Smoking & Tobacco Use. https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/disparities/index.htm. Published 2018. Accessed August 15, 2019. 

97. County Health Rankings & Roadmaps. Excessive Drinking in North Carolina.  https://www.countyhealthrankings.org/app/northcarolina/2019/measure/factors/49/datasource. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

98. America’s Health Rankings. _Explore Excessive Drinking in North Carolina: 2018 Annual Report_ . https://www.americashealthrankings.org/explore/annual/measure/ExcessDrink/state/NC. Accessed October 25, 2019. 

99. North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. North Carolina Alcohol Data Dashboard. https://public.tableau.com/profile/nc.injury.and.violence.prevention.branch#!/vizhome/NCAlcoholDataDashboard/Story. Accessed October 25, 2019. 

100. North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. New Data Dashboard Illustrates State, County Impacts of Excessive Alcohol Use in North Carolina. April 12, 2019. https://www.ncdhhs.gov/news/press-releases/new-data-dashboard-illustratesstate-county-impacts-excessive-alcohol-use-north. 

101. County Health Rankings & Roadmaps. Excessive drinking. https://www.countyhealthrankings.org/explore-healthrankings/measures-data-sources/county-health-rankings-model/health-factors/health-behaviors/alcohol-drug-use/excessivedrinking. Accessed October 2, 2019. 

102. Eat Smart, Move More North Carolina. 2020. North Carolina’s Plan to Address Overweight and Obesity. Eat Smart, Move More North Carolina, Raleigh, NC. Available at: www.eatsmartmovemorenc.com. 

103. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Get the Facts: Sugar-sweetened Beverages and Consumption. https://www.cdc.gov/nutrition/data-statistics/sugar-sweetened-beverages-intake.html. Accessed August 30, 2019. 

104. Miller G, Merlo C, Demissie Z, Sliwa S, Park S. Trends in Beverage Consumption Among High School Students — United States, 2007–2015. _Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report_ . 2017;66(4):112-116. doi:10.15585/mmwr.mm6604a5. 

105. Yun S, Zhu B-P, Black W, Brownson RC. A Comparison of National Estimates of Obesity Prevalence From the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System and the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey. _International Journal of Obesity_ (London). 2006;30(1):164-170. doi:10.1038/sj.ijo.0803125. 

106. Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion. 2015-2020 Dietary Guidelines. https://health.gov/dietaryguidelines/2015/guidelines/. Accessed October 2, 2019. 

107. Onufrak SJ, Park S, Sharkey JR, Sherry B. The Relationship of Perceptions of Tap Water Safety With Intake of Sugar-sweetened Beverages and Plain Water Among US Adults. _Public Health Nutrition_ . 2014;17(1):179-185. doi:10.1017/S1368980012004600. 

108. Powell LM, Wada R, Kumanyika SK. Racial/Ethnic and Income Disparities in Child and Adolescent Exposure to Food and Beverage Television Ads Across the U.S. Media Markets. _Health Place_ . 2014;29:124-131. doi:10.1016/j.healthplace.2014.06.006. 

109. Harris JL, Schwartz MA, LoDolce M, Munsell C, Fleming-Milici F, Elsey J, Liu S, Hyary M, Gross R, Hazen C, Dembek C. _Sugary Drink FACTS 2014, Sugary Drink Marketing to Youth: Some Progress but Much Room to Improve_ . Rudd Center for Food Policy & Obesity. 2014. http://www.sugarydrinkfacts.org/resources/SugaryDrinkFACTS_Report.pdf. 

**Packet Pg. 274** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 107 

106 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

107
{54}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

110. North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services State Center for Health Statistics. 2018 NC Resident Fertility Rates: Females Ages 15-19 by Race/Ethnicity, Perinatal Care Regions, and County of Residence. https://schs.dph.ncdhhs.gov/data/vital/pregnancies/2018/fert1519.pdf. Published 2018. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

111. Cheng D, Schwarz EB, Douglas E, Horon I. Unintended Pregnancy and Associated Maternal Preconception, Prenatal and Postpartum Behaviors. _Contraception_ . 2009;79(3):194-198. doi:10.1016/j.contraception.2008.09.009. 

112. D’Angelo D V, Gilbert BC, Rochat RW, Santelli JS, Herold JM. Differences Between Mistimed and Unwanted Pregnancies Among Women Who Have Live Births. _Perspectives on Sexual and Reporductive Health_ . 36(5):192-197. doi:10.1363/psrh.36.192.04. 

113. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report Preconception and Interconception Health Status of Women Who Recently Gave Birth to a Live-Born Infant--Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (PRAMS), United States, 26 Reporting Areas, 2004. https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/ss5610a1.htm. Accessed October 3, 2019. 

114. Logan C, Holcombe Jennifer E, Manlove J, Ryan S. _The Consequences of Unintended Childbearing_ . May 1, 2007. https://www.childtrends.org/publications/the-consequences-of-unintended-childbearing-a-white-paper. 

115. National Cancer Institute. HPV and Cancer. https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/infectious-agents/hpvand-cancer. Accessed October 3, 2019. 

116. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. CDC Fact Sheet: Reported STDs in the United States, 2017. www.cdc.gov/std/stats. Accessed October 3, 2019. 

117. North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services, Division of Public Health, Communicable Disease Branch. Early Syphilis Infections in North Carolina, 2017. 2017. https://epi.dph.ncdhhs.gov/cd/stds/figures/factsheet_syphilis_2017.pdf. 

118. North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services, Division of Public Health, Communicable Disease Branch. _2018 North Carolina STD Surveillance Report_ . 2019. https://www.ncdhhs.gov/. Accessed October 25, 2019. 

119. North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services, Division of Public Health, Communicable Disease Branch. _2018 North Carolina HIV Surveillance Report_ . 2019. https://www.ncdhhs.gov/. Accessed October 25, 2019. 

120. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. HIV Prevention: North Carolina. https://www.cdc.gov/hiv/pdf/policies/profiles/cdchiv-north-carolina-PrEP.pdf. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

121. North Carolina - AIDSVu. https://aidsvu.org/local-data/united-states/south/north-carolina/. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

122. World Health Organization. HIV/AIDS. November 15, 2019. https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/hiv-aids. 

123. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. HIV and Women in North Carolina, 2017. February 2016. Newly Diagnosed HIV Infection Rates. https://www.cdc.gov/nchhstp/newsroom/docs/factsheets/new-hiv-infections-508.pdf. 

124. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. PrEP. HIV Basics. 18 July 2019. https://www.cdc.gov/hiv/basics/prep.html. Accessed August 30, 2019. 

125. Barnes J. It’s Not Time to Celebrate Yet: How the Rise in HIV Funding Tells a Deeper Story. _HealthAffairs_ . February 22, 2018. https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hblog20180220.638968/full/. Accessed August 30, 2019. 

126. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. About HIV/AIDS. https://www.cdc.gov/hiv/basics/whatishiv.html. Accessed September 20, 2019. 

127. North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services, Division of Public Health, Communicable Disease Branch. _2018 North Carolina HIV Surveillance Report_ . 2019. https://www.ncdhhs.gov/. Accessed October 28, 2019. 

128. Hecht R, Flanagan K, Huffstetler H, Yamey G. Donor Transitions From HIV Programs: What Is the Impact on Vulnerable Populations. _HealthAffairs_ . December 14, 2018. https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hblog20181213.623294/full/. Accessed August 30, 2019. 

129. North Carolina Division of Public Health. NC Resident Pregnancy Rates. 2017. https://schs.dph.ncdhhs.gov/data/vital/pregnancies/2017/preg1519.pdf. 

130. Meade CS, Ickovics JR. Systematic Review of Sexual Risk Among Pregnant and Mothering Teens in the USA: Pregnancy as an Opportunity for Integrated Prevention of STD and Repeat Pregnancy. _Social Science & Medicine_ . 2005;60(4):661-678. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2004.06.015. 

131. County Health Rankings & Roadmaps. Teen birth. https://www.countyhealthrankings.org/explore-health-rankings/measuresdata-sources/county-health-rankings-model/health-factors/health-behaviors/sexual-activity/teen-births. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

132. Battle LS, Freed P. Teen Mothers’ Mental Health. _MCN: The American Journal of maternal/Child Nursing_ . 2016;41(1):31-36. doi:10.1097/NMC.0000000000000198. 

133. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. About Teen Pregnancy. Reproductive Health: Teen Pregnancy. https://www.cdc.gov/teenpregnancy/about/index.htm. Published 2019. Accessed August 15, 2019. 

134. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Social Determinants and Eliminating Disparities in Teen Pregnancy. Reproductive Health: Teen Pregnancy. October 15, 2019. https://www.cdc.gov/teenpregnancy/about/social-determinants-disparities-teenpregnancy.htm. Accessed November 1, 2019. 

135. Avery M. Decline in Teen Births in North Carolina, 1996-2015. https://schs.dph.ncdhhs.gov/schs/pdf/SB_47_20170726.pdf. 

136. County Health Rankings & Roadmaps. Access to Care. https://www.countyhealthrankings.org/explore-healthrankings/measures-data-sources/county-health-rankings-model/health-factors/clinical-care/access-to-care. Accessed October 1, 2019. 

137. Institute of Medicine. Coverage Matters: Insurance and Health Care. Shaping the Future for Health. http://www.nationalacademies.org/hmd/~/media/Files/Report Files/2003/Coverage-Matters-Insurance-and-HealthCare/Uninsurance8pagerFinal.pdf. 

138. McWilliams MJ. Health Consequences of Uninsurance among Adults in the United States: Recent Evidence and Implications. _The Milibank Quarterly_ . 2009;87(2):443-494. doi:10.1111/j.1468-0009.2009.00564.x. 

139. Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. _Key Facts About the Uninsured Population_ . December 7, 2018. https://www.kff.org/uninsured/fact-sheet/key-facts-about-the-uninsured-population/. 

140. Zhou RA, Baicker K, Taubman S, Finkelstein AN. The Uninsured Do Not Use the Emergency Department More- They Use Other Care Less. _HealthAffairs_ . 2017;36(12):2115-2122. doi:10.1377/hlthaff.2017.0218. 

141. Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion. Access to Health Services. https://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives/topic/Access-to-Health-Services. Accessed August 1, 2019. 

**Packet Pg. 275** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 109 

108 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

109
{55}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

142. Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. Health Insurance Coverage of the Total Population. https://www.kff.org/other/stateindicator/total-population/?currentTimeframe=0&selectedRows=%7B%22states%22:%7B%22northcarolina%22:%7B%7D%7D%7D&sortModel=%7B%22colId%22:%22Non-Group%22,%22sort%22:%22desc%22%7D. Accessed October 28, 2019. 

143. National Conference of State Legislatures. _Health Insurance: Premiums and Increases_ . December 4, 2018. http://www.ncsl.org/research/health/health-insurance-premiums.aspx. 

144. North Carolina Institute of Medicine. _Characteristics of Uninsured North Carolinians: 2015 Data Snapshot_ . http://nciom.org/wpcontent/uploads/2017/07/2017-Data-Snapshot-.pdf. Accessed August 1, 2019. 

145. Riley B. _Profiling North Carolina’s Uninsured: How Expanding Medicaid Can Make a Difference_ . North Carolina Justice Center. https://www.ncjustice.org/publications/profiling-north-carolinas-uninsured-how-expanding-medicaid-can-make-a-difference/. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

146. Randolph R, Holmes M. Running the Numbers: Health Insurance Coverage in North Carolina: The Rural-Urban Uninsured Gap. _North Carolina Medical Journal_ . 2018;79(6):397-401. doi:10.18043/ncm.79.6.397. 

147. Buettgens M, White KG. _What if More States Expanded Medicaid in 2017? Changes in Eligibility, Enrollment, and the Uninsured_ . July 2016. http://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/82786/2000866-What-if-More-States-Expanded-Medicaid-in-2017Changes-in-Eligibility-Enrollment-and-the-Uninsured.pdf. 

148. Pohl JM, Thomas A, Bigley MB, Kopanos T. Primary Care Workforce Data and the Need for Nurse Practitioner Full Practice Authority. _HealthAffairs_ . December 13, 2018. https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hblog20181211.872778/full/. 

149. Ries M, Yorkery B, Zolotor A. _Recruitment and Retention of the Rural Health Workforce_ . http://nciom.org/wpcontent/uploads/2018/06/Issue-brief_FINALv2.pdf. 

150. National Resident Matching Program, Results and Data: 2018 Main Residency Match®. Washington, D.C. 2018. https://mk0nrmp3oyqui6wqfm.kinstacdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/Main-Match-Result-and-Data-2018.pdf. 

151. Coplan B, Smith N, Cawley JF. PAs in Primary Care: Current Status and Workforce Implications. _Journal of the American Academy of Physician Assistants_ . 2017;30(9):35-42. doi:10.1097/01.JAA.0000522136.76069.15. 

152. Morgan P, Johnson A, Fraher E. _Comparison of Specialty Distribution of Nurse Practitioners and Physician Assistants in North Carolina_ , 1997-2013 (2013-14). https://www.shepscenter.unc.edu/project/comparison-of-specialty-distribution-of-nursepractitioners-and-physician-assistants-in-north-carolina-1997-2013/. Accessed October 28, 2019. 

153. American Association of Nurse Practitioners. NP Fact Sheet. https://www.aanp.org/about/all-about-nps/np-fact-sheet. Accessed October 28, 2019. 

154. Cawley JF, Lane S, Smith N, Bush E. Physician Assistants in Rural Communities. _Journal of the American Academy of Physician Assistants_ . 2016;29(1):42-45. doi:10.1097/01.JAA.0000475463.23218.c9. 

155. Xue Y, Smith JA, Spetz J. Primary Care Nurse Practitioners and Physicians in Low-Income and Rural Areas, 2010-2016. _Journal of the American Medical Association_ . 2019;321(1):102-105. doi:10.1001/jama.2018.17944. 

156. Holmes M. The Sufficiency of Health Care Professional Supply in Rural North Carolina. _North Carolina Medical Journal_ . 2018;79(6):372-377. doi:10.18043/ncm.79.6.372. 

157. Tucker W, Beatty L. _Giving Birth in North Carolina Is Still a Risky Business Promoting Women’s Health to Improve Birth Outcomes_ . February 2018. http://www.ncchild.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/FINAL-Birth-Outcomes-Brief.pdf. 

158. Lockwood CJ, Magriples U. Prenatal Care: Initial Assessment. UpToDate. 2019. https://www.uptodate.com/contents/prenatalcare-initial-assessment. 

159. Osterman MJK, Martin JA. Timing and Adequacy of Prenatal Care in the United States, 2016. _National Vital Statistics Reports_ . 2018 May;67(3):1-14. 

160. Garro N, Hernandez B, Pellegrini C. HHS Must Remove Barriers to Coverage for Pregnant Women. February 19, 2016. _HealthAffairs_ .  https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hblog20160219.053241/full/. 

161. North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. Medicaid Income and Resource Requirements. https://medicaid.ncdhhs.gov/medicaid/get-started/learn-if-you-are-eligible-medicaid-or-health-choice/medicaid-income-and. Accessed October 1, 2019. 

162. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Health Resources and Services Administration, Maternal and Child Health Bureau. Child Health USA 2014. http://mchb.hrsa.gov/chusa14/. Published 2015. Accessed August 30, 2019. 

163. Lu MC, Kotelchuck M, Hogan V, Jones L, Wright K, Halfon N. Closing the Black-White Gap in Birth Outcomes: A Life-course Approach. _Ethnicity & Disease_ . 2010;20(1 Suppl 2):S2-62-76. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20629248. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

164. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Racial Disparities in Maternal Mortality in the United States: The Postpartum Period Is a Missed Opportunity for Action Background.; 2018. https://s3.amazonaws.com/cdn.smfm.org/media/1107/Leadership_-_January_2017. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

165. Howell EA, Brown H, Brumley J, et al. Reduction of Peripartum Racial and Ethnic Disparities: A Conceptual Framework and Maternal Safety Consensus Bundle. _Journal of Midwifery& Women's Health_ . 2018;63(3):366-376. doi:10.1111/jmwh.12756. 

166. Gyamfi-Bannerman C, Srinivas SK, Wright JD, et al. Postpartum Hemorrhage Outcomes and Race. _American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology_ . 2018;219(2):185.e1-185.e10. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2018.04.052. 

167. American Foundation for Suicide Prevention. Suicide Facts & Figured: North Carolina 2019. State Fact Sheets. https://afsp.org/about-suicide/state-fact-sheets/#North-Carolina. Published 2019. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

168. Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion. Mental Health. n.d. https://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/leading-healthindicators/2020-lhi-topics/Mental-Health/data. Accessed August 15, 2019. 

169. Hogan MF, Grumet JG. Suicide Prevention: An Emerging Priority for Health Care. _HealthAffairs_ . 2016;35(6):1084-1090. doi:10.1377/hlthaff.2015.1672. 

170. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Suicide Rising Across the US, More than a Mental Health Concern. June 7, 2018. https://www.cdc.gov/vitalsigns/suicide/index.html. Accessed October 1, 2019. 

171. RAND. The Relationship Between Mental Health Care Access and Suicide. March 2, 2018. https://www.rand.org/research/gunpolicy/analysis/essays/mental-health-access-and-suicide.html. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

172. American Foundation for Suicide Prevention. Suicide Statistics. About Suicide. https://afsp.org/about-suicide/suicide-statistics/. Published 2017. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

173. Rubin R. Suicide Rates Higher in Rural Areas for Most Demographic Groups. _Journal of the American Medical Association._ 2017;318(20):1969. doi:10.1001/jama.2017.17273. 

**Packet Pg. 276** 

110 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

111 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{56}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

174. U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs Office of Mental Health and Suicide Prevention. 2019 _National Veteran Suicide Prevention Annual Report_ . September 2019. https://www.mentalhealth.va.gov/docs/datasheets/2019/2019_National_Veteran_Suicide_Prevention_Annual_Report_508.pdf. 

175. Hester RD. Lack of Access to Mental Health Services Contributing to the High Suicide Rates Among Veterans. _International Journal of Mental Health Systems_ . 2017;11(1). doi:10.1186/s13033-017-0154-2. 

176. Speer M, Phillips MA, Winkel T, Wright W, Winkel N RS. Serving Those Who Serve: Upstream Intervention and the Uphill Battle of Veteran Suicide Prevention in the US. July 11, 2019. _HealthAffairs_ . https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hblog20190709.197658/full/. 

177. The Trevor Project. Facts about suicide. Preventing Suicide. https://www.thetrevorproject.org/resources/preventingsuicide/facts-about-suicide/. Accessed August 1, 2019. 

178. National LGBT Health Education Center. _Suicide Risk and Prevention for LGBTQ People_ . September 2018. https://www.lgbthealtheducation.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/Suicide-Risk-and-Prevention-for-LGBTQ-Patients-Brief.pdf. 

179. O’Donnell S, Meyer IH, Schwartz S. Increased Risk of Suicide Attempts Among Black and Latino Lesbians, Gay Men, and Bisexuals. _American Journal of Public Health_ . 2011;101(6):1055-1059. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2010.300032. 

180. North Carolina Institute of Medicine and NC Child. _North Carolina Child Health Report Card_ , 2019. 2019. http://nciom.org/wpcontent/uploads/2019/02/2019-NCreportcard-FINAL.pdf. Accessed October 2, 2019. 

181. North Carolina State Center for Health Statistics. _Vital Statistics: 2017 Child Death Fact Sheet_ . 2017. https://schs.dph.ncdhhs.gov/data/vital/cd/2017/CFinNC2017_v3.pdf. 

182. The Commonwealth Fund. _Health Insurance Coverage Eight Years After the ACA — 2018 Biennial_ . https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/issue-briefs/2019/feb/health-insurance-coverage-eight-years-after-aca. Published 2019. Accessed November 18, 2019. 

183. The Commonwealth Fund. _Underinsured Rate Rose From 2014-2018, With Greatest Growth Among People in Employer Health Plans_ . https://www.commonwealthfund.org/press-release/2019/underinsured-rate-rose-2014-2018-greatest-growth-among-peopleemployer-health. Published 2019. Accessed November 18, 2019. 

184. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention National center for Health Statistics. Infant Mortality Rates by State. 2017. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/sosmap/infant_mortality_rates/infant_mortality.htm. 

185. Mathews TJ, Macdorman MF, Thoma ME. Infant Mortality Statistics From the 2013 Period Linked Birth/Infant Death Data Set Non-Hispanic Black Total Non-Hispanic White Hispanic. _National Vital Statistics Reports_ . 2013;64(9):1-30. 

186. Metzger MJ, Halperin AC, Manhart LE, Hawes SE. Association of Maternal Smoking During Pregnancy with Infant Hospitalization and Mortality due to Infectious Diseases. _The Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal_ . 2013;32(1). doi:10.1097/INF.0b013e3182704bb5. 

187. O’Leary CM, Jacoby PJ, Bartu A, D’Antoine H, Bower C. Maternal Alcohol Use and Sudden Infant Death Syndrome and Infant Mortality Excluding SIDS. _Pediatrics_ . 2013;131(3). doi:10.1542/peds.2012-1907. 

188. Meehan S, Beck CR, Mair-Jenkins J, Leonardi-Bee J, Puleston R. Maternal Obesity and Infant Mortality: A Meta-Analysis. _Pediatrics_ . 2014;133(5):863-871. doi:10.1542/peds.2013-1480. 

189. Chen A, Feresu SA, Fernandez C, Rogan WJ. Maternal Obesity and the Risk of Infant Death in the United States. _Epidemiology_ . 2009;20(1):74-81. doi:10.1097/EDE.0b013e3181878645. 

190. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Health Resources and Services Administration, Maternal and Child Health Bureau. Child Health USA 2014. Rockville, Maryland: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2014. 

191. Harper MA, Espeland MA, Dugan E, Meyer R, Lane K, Williams S. Racial Disparity in Pregnancy-Related Mortality Following a Live Birth Outcome. _Annals of Epidemiology_ . 2004;14(4):274-279. doi:10.1016/S1047-2797(03)00128-5. 

192. Medicaid and CHIP Payment and Access Commission. _Access in Brief: Pregnant Women and Medicaid_ . November 2018. https://www.macpac.gov/publication/access-in-brief-pregnant-women-and-medicaid/. 

193. Murphy SL, Xu J, Kochanek KD, Arias E. Mortality in the United States, 2017 Key Findings Data from the National Vital Statistics System. 2017. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db328_tables-508.pdf#1. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

194. Redfield R. CDC Director’s Media Statement on U.S. Life Expectancy, Media Statement. November 29, 2018. https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2018/s1129-US-life-expectancy.html. 

195. North Carolina State Center for Health Statistics. 2015-2017 State-Level Life Expectancies by Age, Sex, Race and Race by Sex. https://schs.dph.ncdhhs.gov/data/lifexpectancy/2015-2017/North Carolina 2015-2017 Life Expectancies.html. Accessed October 28, 2019. 

196. Cunningham P. _Why Even Healthy Low-Income People Have Greater Health Risks Than Higher-Income People_ . September 27, 2018. https://www.commonwealthfund.org/blog/2018/healthy-low-income-people-greater-health-risks. 

197. Kalesan B, Vyliparambil MA, Zuo Y, et al. Cross-sectional Study of Loss of Life Expectancy at Different Ages Related to Firearm Deaths Among Black and White Americans. _BMJ Evidence-Based Medicine_ . 2019;24(2):55-58. doi:10.1136/bmjebm-2018-111103. 

198. Lariscy JT, Nau C, Firebaugh G, Hummer RA. Hispanic-White Differences in Lifespan Variability in the United States. _Demography_ . 2016;53(1):215-239. doi:10.1007/s13524-015-0450-x. 

199. North Carolina State Center for Health Statistics. Statistics and Reports: Life Expectancy. https://schs.dph.ncdhhs.gov/data/lifexpectancy/. Accessed September 30, 2019. 

**Packet Pg. 277** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 113 

112 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

113
{57}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**A P P E N D I X  A** 

HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 INDICATORS AND DATA 

**==> picture [233 x 88] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [441 x 257] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 278** 

114 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

115 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{58}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [512 x 263] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|W|= WHITE|*|2016-18 AVERAGE|D|- 50%-100% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL|
|B/AA|= BLACK/AFRICAN AMERICAN|^|INCLUDES HISPANIC ETHNICITY|E|- 101%-150% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL|
|H/LX|= HISPANIC/LATIN(X)|#|DATA FROM 2015|F|- 151%-200% FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL|
|A/PI|= ASIAN/PACIFIC ISLANDER|A|- ASIAN ONLY|G|- TWO OR MORE RACES|
|AI|= AMERICAN INDIAN|B|- PACIFIC ISLANDER|H|- STUDENTS WHO ARE NOT ECONOMICALLY|
|FPL|= FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL|C|- ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS, AS DEFINED|DISADVANTAGED, AS DEFINED BY NC DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC|
|‡|NOT AVAILABLE OR NOT APPLICABLE|BY NC DEPARTMENT OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION|INSTRUCTION|
|RACE / ETHNICITY|SEX|FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL|
|W             B/AA           H/LX              O               A/PI              AI             MALE       FEMALE     <200%     200-399%   400%+200-399%   400%+   400%+|
|30.7%|51.1%|63.6%|46.1%|[[G]]|30.6%|51.5%|34.8%|38.7%|‡|‡|‡|
|7.3%|[[^]]|
|5.7%|[[^]]|11.7%|[[^]]|7.1%^|5.2%|[[^]]|10.3%|[[^]]|6.4%|6.7%|‡|‡|‡|
|11.0%|[[^G]]|
|0.73|3.00|0.88|1.69|0.18|[[A]]|2.46|1.98|0.74|2.09|[[C]]|‡|‡|
|203|[[#]]|915|[[#]]|209|[[#]]|‡|‡|488|[[#]]|649|50|‡|‡|‡|
|17.5%|36.0%|23.2%|37.2%|11.1%|‡|23.8%|23.5%|47.9%|19.9%|8.3%|
|70.1%|40.8%|42.6%|59.5%|[[G]]|75.6%|[[A]]|44.5%|54.0%|59.8%|42.6%|[[C]]|70.6%|[[H]]|‡|

**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **T A B L E  1** 

HEALTH INDICATORS AND DATA (TOTAL NC POPULATION, 2030 TARGET, AND DATA BY RACE/ETHNICITY, SEX, AND POVERTY LEVEL) 

**==> picture [1171 x 606] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
||||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|TOTAL POPULATION|RACE / ETHNICITY|SEX|FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL|
|HEALTH INDICATOR|DESIRED RESULT|CURRENT|[(YEAR)]|2030 TARGET|W             B/AA           H/LX              O               A/PI              AI             MALE       FEMALE     <200%     200-399%   400%+200-399%   400%+   400%+|
|1|INDIVIDUALS BELOW 200% FPL|Decrease the number of people living in poverty|(2013-17)36.8%|27.0%|30.7%|51.1%|63.6%|46.1%|[[G]]|30.6%|51.5%|34.8%|38.7%|‡|‡|‡|
|7.2%|Reduce unemployment disparity|7.3%|[[^]]|
|2|UNEMPLOYMENT|Increase economic security|(2013-17)|ratio between white and other populations to 1.7 or lower|5.7%|[[^]]|11.7%|[[^]]|7.1%^|11.0%|[[^G]]|5.2%|[[^]]|10.3%|[[^]]|6.4%|6.7%|‡|‡|‡|
|3|SHORT-TERM SUSPENSIONS(PER 10 STUDENTS)|(2017-18)1.39|0.80|0.73|3.00|0.88|1.69|0.18|[[A]]|2.46|1.98|0.74|2.09|[[C]]|‡|‡|
|Dismantle structural racism|
|4|INCARCERATION RATE (PER 100,000 POPULATION)|(2017)341|150|203|[[#]]|915|[[#]]|209|[[#]]|‡|‡|488|[[#]]|649|50|‡|‡|‡|
|5|ADVERSE CHILDHOOD EXPERIENCES|Improve child well-being|(2016-17)23.6%|18.0%|17.5%|36.0%|23.2%|37.2%|11.1%|‡|23.8%|23.5%|47.9%|19.9%|8.3%|
|THIRD GRADE READING PROFICIENCY|56.8%|80.0%|70.1%|40.8%|42.6%|59.5%|[[G]]|75.6%|[[A]]|44.5%|54.0%|59.8%|42.6%|[[C]]|70.6%|[[H]]|‡|
|6|Improve third grade reading proficiency|(2018-19)|
|7|ACCESS TO EXERCISE OPPORTUNITIES|Increase physical activity|(2010/18)73%|92%|
|8|LIMITED ACCESS TO HEALTHY FOOD|Improve access to healthy food|(2015)7%|5%|DATA NOT AVAILABLE|
|9|SEVERE HOUSING PROBLEMS|Improve housing quality|(2011-15)16.1%|14.0%|
|10|DRUG OVERDOSE DEATHS (PER 100,000 POPULATION)|Decrease drug overdose deaths|(2018)20.4|18.0|26.4|12.9|5.4|4.4|‡|32.6|27.8|13.2|‡|‡|‡|
|YOUTH|19.8%|(2017)|9.0%|20.6%|17.0%|20.7%|19.0%|‡|‡|23.0%|16.5%|‡|‡|‡|
|11|TOBACCO USE|Decrease tobacco use|ADULT|23.8%|(2018)|15.0%|25.9%|22.5%|12.2%|17.1%|‡|‡|29.9%|18.5%|32.8%|21.6%|17.2%|
|12|EXCESSIVE DRINKING|Decrease excessive drinking|16.0%|12.0%|17.2%|12.5%|17.8%|13.1%|‡|‡|21.7%|10.8%|14.5%|17.6%|21.2%|
|(2018)|
|13|SUGAR-SWEETENED BEVERAGE CONSUMPTION|Reduce overweight and obesity|YOUTHADULT|34.2%     33.6% ((2017)2017)|2017.0%.0%|36.1%32.6%|31.5%38.7%|28.9%37.0%|24.3%‡|‡‡|‡‡|38.7%37.6%|28.3%31.0%|41.0%‡|32.7%‡|24.1%‡|
|HIV DIAGNOSIS|13.9|
|14|(PER 100,000 POPULATION)|(2018)|6.0|4.9|40.8|17.7|‡|4.3|5.9|23.1|5.4|‡|‡|‡|
|Improve sexual health|
|TEEN BIRTH RATE|18.7|
|15|(PER 1,000 POPULATION)|(2018)|10.0|12.9|24.1|34.3|6.9|‡|38.3|‡|‡|‡|‡|‡|
|16|UNINSURED|Decrease the uninsured population|(2017)13%|8%|10%|13%|31%|8%|9%|18%|14%|11%|21%|12%|4%|
|PRIMARY CARE CLINICIANS|62|25% decrease for counties above|
|17|(COUNTIES AT OR BELOW 1:1,500 PROVIDERS TO POPULATION)|Increase the primary care workforce|(2017)|1:1,500 providers to population|NOT APPLICABLE|
|68.0%|
|18|EARLY PRENATAL CARE|Improve birth outcomes|(2018)|80.0%|74.8%|60.5%|57.5%|66.0%|‡|54.3%|‡|‡|‡|‡|‡|
|19|(PER 100,000 POPULATION)SUICIDE RATE|Improve access and treatment for mental health needs|(2018)13.8|11.1|17.8|5.7|5.8|7.7|‡|‡|22.4|5.9|‡|‡|‡|
|6.8 (2018)|6.0|
|20|INFANT MORTALITY(PER 1,000 BIRTHS)|Decrease infant mortality|Black/white disparity ratio = 2.4|Black/white disparity ratio = 1.5|5.0|12.2|4.8|5.0|‡|9.3|8.0|5.5|‡|‡|‡|
|21|LIFE EXPECTANCY (YEARS)|Increase life expectancy|(2018)77.6|82.0|78.3*|75.5*|‡|87.0*|‡|75.6*|74.8|80.3|‡|‡|‡|

**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


_Source: See descriptions of health indicators throughout this report for information on data sources._ 

**Packet Pg. 279** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 117 

116 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

117
{59}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [1009 x 53] intentionally omitted <==**

**A P P E N D I X  B** 

HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 PROCESS DETAILS 

**==> picture [233 x 88] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [441 x 257] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 280** 

118 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

119 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{60}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

The Healthy North Carolina 2030 (HNC 2030) process involved several meetings of an overall Task Force, four Work Groups, and Community Input Sessions, illustrated by the figure below. 

**==> picture [529 x 232] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
F I G U R E  1<br>Task Force, Work Group, and Community Input Structure<br>STEERING COMMITTEE<br>TASK FORCE (chose Health Outcomes indicators)<br>23 Additional Task Force<br>4 Co-chairs 2 Co-leaders from each Work Group (total = 8) each Work Group (total = 9)2-3 Representatives from  members representing<br>various expertise<br>COMMUNITY<br>INPUT<br>WORK GROUPS (chose indicators relevant to Work Group topic area)<br>Health Behaviors Clinical Care Social & Economic Factors Physical Environment<br>2 Co-leaders 2 Co-leaders 2 Co-leaders 2 Co-leaders<br>2 Task Force representatives 2 Task Force representatives 3 Task Force representatives 2 Task Force representatives<br>23 additional members 23 additional members 27 additional members 18 additional members<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **Allocation of Indicators Across Topic Areas** 

The initial goal of HNC 2030 was to select a total of 20 indicators. Using the percentages associated with each health factor topic area of the Population Health Model, the number of indicators was distributed amongst the Task Force to select Health Outcomes and each of the Work Groups. Table 1 below shows the original allocation of indicators and the final allocation with explanations for any changes. 

**T A B L E  1** 

## Number of Indicators Allocated to Topic Areas and Changes Made 

**==> picture [516 x 190] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Number of Indicators<br>ORIGINAL  FINAL<br>TOPIC AREA EXPLANATION OF CHANGES<br>ALLOCATION ALLOCATION<br>Health Outcomes 3 2 The Task Force decided to select only 2 Health Outcome indicators, leaving 1 extra for a Work<br>Group. The extra indicator was given to Physical Environment.<br>Health Behaviors 5 6 The Health Behaviors Work Group lobbied the Task Force for inclusion of an additional indicator that they determined to be vital to the state’s health.<br>Clinical Care 4 4 No change<br>Social and Economic<br>Factors 6 6 No change<br>The Physical Environment Work Group took on the extra indicator that the Task Force did not<br>Physical Environment 2 3 use for Health Outcomes.<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **Timeline and Procedures** 

Participants then discussed in small groups and indicated their top priority indicators in each topic area. Lists of indicators were edited slightly after the first few community sessions to reflect feedback from the participants, such as the addition of a transportation measure in the Physical Environment topic area and the change from “Emergency Department visits for violence” to “Violent crime rate.”  Table 2 shows the indicators discussed in community meetings and the average ranking they received. 

The Task Force began meeting in January 2019, meeting a total of four times through August 2019. Each Work Group met three times – once each in February, May, and June 2019. Community meetings were held February through April 2019. 

The first Task Force meeting provided background information and set a vision for HNC 2030. Each Work Group first met in February to narrow down larger lists of potential indicators to smaller lists for community input. These initial lists were gathered from HNC 2020, Healthy People 2030, state health improvement plans, and County Health Rankings & Roadmaps. Each Work Group used a process of small group and large group discussion, followed by an online survey. NCIOM staff created the final narrowed lists for community input. 

The Task Force met in March to select the Health Outcomes measures. Work Groups met in May to review the community input and determine the final list of indicators for their topic area. In some cases, with additional data and discussion, the Work Group chose to prioritize some indicators differently from the community input because of data quality, issues related to health disparities or health equity, or choice of an indicator that measures a similar concept. 

At Community Input Sessions, each participant was given worksheets to provide an individual ranking of the indicators in each topic area. 

## **T A B L E  2** 

Indicators Discussed at Community Input Sessions and Average Rankings of Indicators 

**==> picture [508 x 297] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
HEALTH BEHAVIORS CLINICAL CARE SOCIAL & ECONOMIC FACTORS PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT<br>Youth tobacco use 1.6 Uninsured 1.0 Families at or below 200% FPL 1.3 Food Environment Index 1.4<br>Adverse Childhood<br>Illicit drug use 2.0 Mental health ED visits 2.1 Experiences 2.3 Housing cost burden 2.3<br>Unemployment 3.6 Housing quality<br>Physical activity 2.3 Early prenatal care 3.4 problems 2.6<br>Children in low-income<br>Unintentional  4.3 Routine checkups 4.5 homes 3.7 Access to public  3.8<br>poisoning deaths transportation<br>Income inequality 4.6<br>Teen birth rate 4.5 Primary care physicians 5.0 Community water  5.2<br>Children investigated  5.2 safety<br>Adult smoking 6.3 Heart disease mortality 5.3 for abuse Access to exercise opportunities 5.3<br>4th grade reading 5.9<br>Excessive drinking 6.5 Suicide 6.5 Blood lead levels 5.7<br>High school graduation 7.0<br>Unintended pregnancy 6.8 School nurse/ 7.6 Air pollution 6.6<br>student ratio Disconnected youth 9.0<br>Smoking during pregnancy 7.0 Vaccinations 8.3 Incarceration rate 9.5 Asthma-related ED visits 7.2<br>Sugar-sweetened  7.4<br>beverage consumption Residential segregation 9.6<br>HIV diagnosis 8.9 ED visits for violence 9.8<br>ED = Emergency Department; FPL = Federal<br>Breastfeeding 9.6 Poverty Level Violent crime rate 9.8<br>Deaths due to falls 11.0 Note: Rankings in table are with ‘1’ rating the  Suspension from  10.9<br>highest priority. school<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Packet Pg. 281** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 121 

120 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

121
{61}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [1009 x 53] intentionally omitted <==**

The final meeting of each Work Group in June was used to set targets for selected indicators. Work Groups were presented with data on current and past trends for each indicator, a forecasted estimate of the status of each indicator in 2030 (forecast estimates can be found on the NCIOM website with the electronic version of this report) based on past data, and any available data across counties and other states. In target-setting considerations, Work Group members discussed the potential for movement in each indicator, what is currently being done at community and state levels, what political will and public interest exists to create change, and whether there is funding for the work needed to create change. These considerations informed how ambitious the groups were in the targets they set. 

## **A P P E N D I X  C** 

Finally, the Task Force met to set targets on the Health Outcomes they had selected and review and approved the decisions made by the Work Groups. 

## DETAILED COMMUNITY SESSION INPUT 

**==> picture [233 x 88] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [441 x 257] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 282** 

122 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

123 

A PATH TOWARD HEALTH
{62}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

The NCIOM scheduled eight Community Input Sessions throughout North Carolina from February 27 to April 9, 2019 to collect input on a narrowed list of potential health indicators under consideration for Healthy North Carolina 2030. At each meeting, participants were given work sheets for each of the topic areas – Social & Economic Factors, Physical Environment, Health Behaviors, and Clinical Care – to rank for importance in their communities. The NCIOM team revised the list of indicators during this process to account for common feedback about missing indicators. Below is a summary of the ranking of indicators in each section. 

## **T A B L E  1** 

Community Session Input on Social & Economic Factors 

|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**HEALTH INDICATOR**|**GREENVILLE**|**HENDERSON**|**PEMBROKE**|**JACKSONVILLE**|**CHARLOTTE**|**GREENSBORO**|**CHEROKEE**|**MARION**|**AVERAGE**|
||<br>**(112)**|<br>**(25)**|<br>**(32)**|<br>**(17)**|<br>**(56)**|<br>**(21)**|<br>**(29)**|<br>**(39)**|<br>**RANK^**|
|Families at or below 200% FPL|1|2|1|1|2|1|1|1|1.3|
|Adverse Childhood<br>Experiences|2|1|2|2|4|3|2|2|2.3|
|Unemployment|3|6|3|4|1|2|5|5|3.6|
|Children in low-income<br>homesA|4|3|4|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|3.7|
|Income inequality|5|5|6|5|3|5|4|4|4.6|
|Children investigated for<br>abuseB|N/A|N/A|N/A|3|9|8|3|3|5.2|
|Fourth grade reading|6|4|5|8|8|4|6|6|5.9|
|High school graduation rate|8|7|8|7|6|6|7|7|7.0|
|Disconnected youth|9|8|7|9|12|11|8|8|9.0|
|Incarceration rate|11|9|9|10|7|12|9|9|9.5|
|Residential segregation|10|10|12|11|5|7|12|10|9.6|
|Emergency department<br>visits for violenceC|7|12|10|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|9.8|
|Violent crime rateD|N/A|N/A|N/A|6|10|10|11|12|9.8|
|Short-term suspension rate|12|11|11|12|11|9|10|11|10.9|



_N/A=Not Applicable; FPL=Federal Poverty Level  |  *Rank of 1 for most important.  |  ^Average of rankings across 8 meetings (or fewer if indicator only discussed in first three or last five meetings)._ 

_A This indicator was eliminated after the third meeting due to confusion with Families at or below 200% FPL.  |   B This indicator was added at the fourth meeting to replace “children in low-income homes.”_ 

_C This indicator was eliminated after the third meeting due to community interest in discussing violent crime rate.  |  D This indicator was added at the fourth meeting to replace “emergency department visits for violence.”_ 

## **T A B L E  2** 

Community Session Input on Physical Environment 

|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**HEALTH INDICATOR**|**GREENVILLE**|**HENDERSON**|**PEMBROKE**|**ACKSONVILLE**|**CHARLOTTE**|**GREENSBORO**|**CHEROKEE**|**MARION**|**AVERAGE**|
||<br>**(113)**|<br>**(25)**|<br>**(31)**|**J**<br>**(17)**|<br>**(56)**|<br>**(21)**|<br>**(29)**|<br>**(39)**|<br>**RANK^**|
|Food environment index|1|1|2|1|2|1|2|1|1.4|
|Housing cost burden|2|3|3|3|1|3|1|2|2.3|
|Housing quality problems|3|2|1|2|3|2|4|4|2.6|
|Access to public<br>transportationA|N/A|N/A|N/A|5|4|4|3|3|3.8|
|Community water safetyB|N/A|N/A|N/A|4|5|5|7|5|5.2|
|Access to exercise<br>opportunities|4|4|4|7|6|6|5|6|5.3|
|Blood lead levelsC|6|5|6|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|5.7|
|Air pollution|5|6|5|8|7|7|8|7|6.6|
|Asthma-related emergency<br>department visitsD|N/A|N/A|N/A|6|8|8|6|8|7.2|



_N/A=Not Applicable; FPL=Federal Poverty Level   |    *Rank of 1 for most important.    |     ^Average of rankings across 8 meetings (or fewer if indicator only discussed in first three or last five meetings)._ 

_A This indicator was added at the fourth meeting due to community interest in discussing public transportation  |  B This indicator was added at the fourth meeting due to community interest in discussing community water safety. C This indicator was eliminated after the third meeting due to limited interest.  |  D This indicator was added at the fourth meeting due to oversight of inclusion for first three meetings._ 

## **T A B L E  3** 

## Community Session Input on Health Behaviors 

|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**HEALTH INDICATOR**|**GREENVILLE**|**HENDERSON**|**PEMBROKE**|**ACKSONVILLE**|**CHARLOTTE**|**GREENSBORO**|**CHEROKEE**|**MARION**|**AVERAGE**|
||<br>**(117)**|<br>**(24)**|<br>**(29)**|**J**<br>**(17)**|<br>**(56)**|<br>**(21)**|<br>**(29)**|<br>**(39)**|<br>**RANK^**|
|Youth tobacco use|1|1|2|4|1|1|1|2|1.6|
|Illicit drug useA|N/A|N/A|N/A|1|3|3|2|1|2.0|
|Physical activity|3|2|1|2|2|2|3|3|2.3|
|Unintentional poisoning<br>deathsB|2|4|7|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|4.3|
|Teen birth rate|4|3|3|3|6|5|7|5|4.5|
|Adult smoking|5|8|4|11|7|4|5|6|6.3|
|Excessive drinking|7|7|5|5|9|6|6|7|6.5|
|Unintended pregnancyC|N/A|N/A|N/A|6|4|7|9|8|6.8|
|Smoking during pregnancy|6|5|6|8|10|8|4|9|7.0|
|Sugar-sweetened beverage<br>consumptionC|N/A|N/A|N/A|10|5|10|8|4|7.4|
|HIV diagnosis|9|6|9|7|8|9|11|12|8.9|
|Breastfeeding|8|9|8|9|11|11|10|11|9.6|
|Deaths due to falls|10|10|10|12|12|12|12|10|11.0|



_N/A=Not Applicable; FPL=Federal Poverty Level  |  *Rank of 1 for most important.  |  ^Average of rankings across 8 meetings (or fewer if indicator only discussed in first three or last five meetings)._ 

_A This indicator was added at the fourth meeting to replace “unintentional poisoning deaths.”  |  B This indicator was eliminated after the third meeting and replaced with “illicit drug use.”_ 

_C This indicator was added at the fourth meeting due to oversight of inclusion for first three meetings._ 

**Packet Pg. 283** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 125 

124 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

125
{63}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

**==> picture [776 x 48] intentionally omitted <==**

## **T A B L E  4** 

## Community Session Input on Clinical Care 

|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|Ranking of Indicators by Area of North Carolina* (Number of Participants)|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**HEALTH INDICATOR**|**GREENVILLE**|**HENDERSON**|**PEMBROKE**|**ACKSONVILLE**|**CHARLOTTE**|**GREENSBORO**|**CHEROKEE**|**MARION**|**AVERAGE**|
||<br>**(116)**|<br>**(25)**|<br>**(32)**|**J**<br>**(17)**|<br>**(56)**|<br>**(21)**|<br>**(29)**|<br>**(39)**|<br>**RANK^**|
|Uninsured|1|1|1|1|1|1|1|1|1.0|
|Mental health emergency<br>department visits|2|2|2|2|2|3|2|2|2.1|
|<br>Early prenatal care|4|3|3|3|3|5|3|3|3.4|
|Routine checkup|6|4|5|4|4|2|6|5|4.5|
|Primary care physicians|3|5|6|5|7|6|4|4|5.0|
|Heart disease mortality|5|6|4|6|5|4|5|7|5.3|
|SuicideA|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|6|7|7|6|6.5|
|School nurse ratio|7|7|8|7|8|8|9|8|7.6|
|Vaccinations|8|8|7|8|9|9|8|9|8.3|



_N/A=Not Applicable; FPL=Federal Poverty Level  |  *Rank of 1 for most important.  |  ^Average of rankings across 8 meetings (or fewer if indicator only discussed in first three or last five meetings). A This indicator was added at the fifth meeting as an additional measure related to mental health._ 

**Packet Pg. 284** A PATH TOWARD HEALTH 127 

126 HEALTHY NORTH CAROLINA 2030 

127
{64}------------------------------------------------
**9.13.a** 

630 DAVIS DRIVE, SUITE 100 MORRISVILLE, NC 27560     (919) 445-6500       @NCIOM W W W. N C I O M .C O M 

**==> picture [684 x 44] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 285**
