{0}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

# HOUSING NEEDS ASSESSMENT Burke County, North Carolina 

DRF 

2023 **Packet Pg. 72**
{1}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **TABLE OF CONTENTS** 

- I. Introduction 

- II. Executive Summary 

- III. Community Overview and Study Areas 

- IV. Demographic Analysis 

- V. Economic Analysis 

- VI. Housing Supply Analysis 

- VII. Other Housing Market Factors 

- VIII. Housing Gap/Demand Estimates 

- IX. Community Input Results and Analysis 

- Addendum A – Field Survey of Conventional Rentals 

- Addendum B – Non-Conventional Rental Survey 

- Addendum C – Senior Care Housing Survey 

Addendum D – Qualifications 

Addendum E – Glossary 

Note:  For-Sale housing data provided upon request. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**Table of Contents** 

~~**Packet Pg. 73**~~
{2}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|||~~**3.2.b**~~|~~**3.2.b**~~|
|---|---|---|---|
|**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH**<br>**I-1**<br>**I.  INTRODUCTION**<br>**A.PURPOSE**<br>Burke County retained Bowen National Research in July of 2023 for the purpose<br>of conducting a Housing Needs Assessment of Burke County, North Carolina and<br>its municipalities.  We completed a preliminary study for this market in April of<br>2018 and have included some data from that original study in this current report.<br>With changing demographic and employment characteristics and trends expected<br>over the years ahead, it is important for the local government, stakeholders and<br>its citizens to understand the current market conditions and projected changes that<br>are anticipated to occur that will influence future housing needs. Toward that end,<br>this report intends to:<br>• Provide an overview of present-day Burke County.<br>• Present and evaluate past, current and projected detailed demographic<br>characteristics.<br>• Present and evaluate employment characteristics and trends, as well as the<br>economic drivers impacting the area.<br>• Determine current characteristics of major housing components within the<br>market (for-sale/ownership and rental housing alternatives).<br>• Evaluate ancillary factors that affect housing market conditions and<br>development (e.g., transportation analysis, community services, residential<br>blight,<br>development<br>opportunities,<br>development<br>costs,<br>government<br>regulations, and identification of potential developer/investor partners).<br>• Provide housing gap estimates by tenure (renter and owner) and income<br>segment.<br>• Collect input from community members including area stakeholders,<br>employers, residents/commuters, and developers in the form of online<br>surveys.<br>By accomplishing the study’s objectives, government officials, area stakeholders,<br>and area employers can: (1) better understand the county’s evolving housing<br>market, (2) establish housing priorities, (3) modify or expand local government<br>housing policies, and (4) enhance and/or expand the county’s housing market to<br>meet current and future housing needs.<br>~~**..**~~<br> <br>||~~**..**~~||
||||**Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen National Research Housing Study)**|
|||||
|||||



**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**I-1** 

~~**Packet Pg. 74**~~
{3}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **B. METHODOLOGIES** 

The following methods were used by Bowen National Research. 

## Study Area Delineation 

The primary geographic scope of this study is Burke County, North Carolina. Additionally, supplemental data and analysis is provided for the city of Morganton. A full description of the market areas and corresponding maps are included in Section III. 

Demographic Information 

Demographic data for population, households, and housing was secured from ESRI, the 2000, 2010 and 2020 U.S. Census, the U.S. Department of Commerce, and the American Community Survey. This data has been used in its primary form and by Bowen National Research for secondary calculations. All sources are referenced throughout the report. Estimates and projections of key demographic data for 2023 and 2028 were also provided. 

## Employment Information 

Employment information was obtained and evaluated for various geographic areas that were part of this overall study. This information included data related to wages by occupation, employment by job sector, total employment, unemployment rates, identification of top employers, and identification of largescale job expansions or contractions. Most information was obtained through the U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics. Bowen National Research also conducted numerous interviews with local stakeholders familiar with the area’s employment characteristics and trends. 

## Housing Component Definitions 

This study focuses on rental and for-sale housing components. Rentals include multifamily apartments (generally five+ units per building), non-conventional rentals (single-family homes, duplexes, units over storefronts, etc.), vacation rentals, and senior care housing (e.g., assisted living and nursing homes). Forsale housing includes individual homes, mobile homes, and projects within subdivisions. 

## Housing Supply Documentation 

Between August and October of 2023, Bowen National Research conducted telephone research, as well as online research, of the area’s housing supply. Additionally, market analysts from Bowen National Research traveled to the area in October 2023, conducting research on the housing properties identified in this study, as well as obtaining other on-site information relative to this analysis. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**I-2** 

~~**Packet Pg. 75**~~
{4}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following data was collected on each multifamily rental property: 

1. Property Information: Name, address, total units, and number of floors 2. Owner/Developer and/or Property Manager: Name and telephone number 3. Population Served (i.e., seniors vs. family, low-income vs. market-rate, etc.) 4. Available Amenities/Features: Both in-unit and within the overall project 5. Years Built and Renovated (if applicable) 6. Vacancy Rates 7. Distribution of Units by Bedroom Type 8. Square Feet and Number of Bathrooms by Bedroom Type 9. Gross Rents or Price Points by Bedroom Type 10. Property Type 11. Quality Ratings 12. GPS Locations 

Non-Conventional rental information includes such things as collected and gross rent, bedroom types, square footage, price per square foot, and total available inventory. 

Vacation rental data includes share of vacation rentals compared to overall rental supply, bedroom types, average daily rents, annual revenue, seasonal trends and other data points. 

For-sale housing data includes details on home price, year built, location, number of bedrooms/bathrooms, price per-square-foot, and other property attributes. Data was analyzed for both historical transactions and currently available residential units. 

We also surveyed senior care facilities including assisted living facilities and nursing homes within the county.  Information gathered includes total beds, vacancies, fees/rents, unit mix by bedroom type, square footage, unit features/amenities, and services. 

## Other Housing Factors 

We evaluated other factors that impact housing, including cost and accessibility of public transportation (including walkability), availability of common community services, residential blight, residential development opportunities (potential sites), local development costs and regulations, and identification of potential development/investment partners. 

## Housing Demand 

Based on the demographic data for both 2023 and 2028 and taking into consideration the housing data from our field survey of area housing alternatives, we are able to project the potential number of new housing units Burke County can support.  The following summarizes the metrics used in our demand estimates. 

**==> picture [574 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Packet Pg. 76<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**I-3**
{5}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

- Rental Housing – We included renter household growth, the number of units required for a balanced market, the need for replacement housing, commuter/ external market support, severe housing cost burdened households, and stepdown support as the demand components in our estimates for new rental housing units. As part of this analysis, we accounted for vacancies reported among all rental alternatives. We concluded this analysis by providing the number of units that the market can support by different income segments and rent levels. 

- For-Sale Housing – We considered potential demand from owner household growth, the number of units required for a balanced market, the need for replacement housing, commuter/external market support, severe housing cost burdened households, and step-down support in our estimates for new forsale housing. As part of this analysis, we accounted for vacancies reported among all surveyed for-sale alternatives. We concluded this analysis by providing the number of units that the market can support by different income segments and price points. 

## Community Engagement 

Bowen National Research conducted four separate online surveys to solicit input from area stakeholders, employers, residents/commuters and developers in the county.  Overall, 282 individuals participated in the surveys, providing valuable local insight on the housing challenges, issues and opportunities in Burke County. The aggregate results from these surveys are presented and evaluated in Section IX. 

## **C.  REPORT LIMITATIONS** 

The intent of this report is to collect and analyze significant levels of data for Burke County, North Carolina.  Bowen National Research relied on a variety of data sources to generate this report. These data sources are not always verifiable; however, Bowen National Research makes a concerted effort to assure accuracy. While this is not always possible, we believe that our efforts provide an acceptable standard margin of error. Bowen National Research is not responsible for errors or omissions in the data provided by other sources. 

We have no present or prospective interest in any of the properties included in this report, and we have no personal interest or bias with respect to the parties involved. Our compensation is not contingent on an action or event resulting from the analyses, opinions, or use of this study. Any reproduction or duplication of this study without the expressed approval of Burke County or Bowen National Research is strictly prohibited. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**I-4** 

~~**Packet Pg. 77**~~
{6}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **II.  EXECUTIVE SUMMARY** 

The purpose of this report is to evaluate the housing needs of Burke County, North Carolina and to recommend priorities and strategies to address such housing needs. To that end, we have conducted a comprehensive Housing Needs Assessment that considered the following: 

- Demographic Characteristics and Trends 

- Economic Conditions and Initiatives 

- Existing Housing Stock Costs, Performance, Conditions and Features 

- Various Other Housing Market Factors (Transportation Analysis, Residential Blight, Development Opportunities, etc.) 

- Community Input (via Online Surveys of Stakeholders, Employers, Residents/Commuters and Developers) 

- Submarket Analysis of the City of Morganton 

Based on these metrics and input, we were able to identify housing needs by affordability and tenure (rental vs. ownership). Using these findings, we developed an outline of strategies that should be considered for implementation. This Executive Summary provides key findings and recommended strategies. Detailed data analysis is presented within the individual sections of this Housing Needs Assessment. 

Geographic Study Areas 

This report focuses on the Primary Study Area (PSA), which consists of Burke County, North Carolina. Additionally, supplemental data and analysis is provided for a submarket which is comprised of the City of Morganton. 

Maps of the various market areas used in this report are shown on the following page. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-1** 

~~**Packet Pg. 78**~~
{7}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

**==> picture [388 x 150] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [388 x 150] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [386 x 150] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [386 x 150] intentionally omitted <==**

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-2** 

~~**Packet Pg. 79**~~
{8}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## Demographics 

**Following a decline between 2010 and 2020, the overall household base within the PSA (Burke County) increased between 2020 and 2023, a trend which is projected to continue through 2028.** Between 2010 and 2020, the number of households within the PSA decreased by 624 (1.7%). This contrasts with the 11.1% increase in the number of households for the state of North Carolina during this time period. Conversely, the number of households in the Morganton Submarket increased by 171 (2.6%) during this time period.  In 2023, there is an estimated total of 35,602 households in the PSA, with the Morganton Submarket accounting for 19.3% of the total households in Burke County. Between 2023 and 2028, the number of households in the PSA is projected to increase by 780 (2.2%), while households in the Morganton Submarket are projected to increase by 0.8% (53 households). Regardless, this represents a smaller increase in households as compared to the projected statewide increase (3.5%) over the next five years. 

While the projected increase in households within Burke County will have some effect on demand for housing in the market, household growth or decline alone does not dictate the total housing needs of a market. Other factors that influence housing needs, which are addressed throughout this report, include: households living in substandard or cost-burdened housing, commuting patterns, pent-up demand, availability of existing housing, and product in the development pipeline. 

**==> picture [442 x 173] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Household Growth Trends (2010-2028)<br>Morganton Burke County North Carolina<br>12.0%<br>10.0% 11.1%<br>8.0%<br>6.0%<br>4.0%<br>2.2%<br>2.0% 0.4% 1.3% 3.7% 0.8% 3.5%<br>2.6%<br>0.0%<br>-1.7%<br>-2.0%<br>2010-2020 2020-2023 2023-2028<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-3** 

~~**Packet Pg. 80**~~
{9}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

**==> picture [449 x 178] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
PSA (Burke County) Household Growth Trends (2010-2028)<br>36,500<br>36,382<br>36,250<br>36,000<br>35,750 35,764<br>35,602<br>35,500<br>35,250<br>35,140<br>35,000<br>2010 2020 2023 2028<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Projected growth and distribution of households among various age cohorts will contribute to ongoing demand for housing among younger and senior households within the PSA (Burke County).** In 2023, household heads between the ages of 55 and 64 within the PSA comprise the largest share (20.0%) of all households in the PSA, closely followed by households between the ages of 65 and 74 (19.4%).  Overall, senior households (age 55 and older) constitute over one-half (53.7%) of all households within the PSA. This represents a larger share of senior households when compared to the share within the state (46.1%). Household heads under the age of 35, which are typically more likely to be renters or first-time homebuyers, comprise 14.5% of PSA households, while those between the ages of 35 and 54 account for 31.7% of Burke County households.  The distribution of households by age within the Morganton Submarket is similar to the overall PSA, with households ages 55 and older comprising 53.2% of all households in the submarket, and households under the age of 35 comprising 16.7% of households. 

Between 2023 and 2028, projections indicate significant household growth in the PSA among household heads ages 75 and older (24.3%). Households between the ages of 35 and 44 and those between the ages of 65 and 74 are projected to increase by 6.3% and 2.9%, respectively. All other age cohorts are projected to experience declines of at least 2.6% during this time period, with the largest percentage decline (11.8%) projected for the age cohort of 25 to 34. Although the projections for the Morganton Submarket are largely consistent with the PSA, it is noteworthy that households under the age of 25 are projected to increase by 4.3% in the submarket over the next five years. Similarly, the most significant increase of households by age within the Morganton Submarket over the next five years is projected to occur among households aged 75 and older, which is projected to increase by 17.1% between 2023 and 2028. The notable projected increase of households age 75 and older in the PSA and Morganton Submarket is generally consistent with projections for the state of North Carolina over the next five years. The aforementioned changes in households by age in the PSA will likely have an impact on the area housing market, particularly the demand for senior-oriented housing. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-4** 

~~**Packet Pg. 81**~~
{10}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

**==> picture [441 x 206] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
PSA (Burke County) Change in Household Heads by Age (2023-2028)<br><25 -24<br>25-34 -508<br>35-44 331<br>45-54 -234<br>55-64 -219<br>65-74 198<br>75+ 1,236<br>-600 -400 -200 0 200 400 600 800 1,000 1,200 1,400<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**A higher poverty rate within the PSA (Burke County) likely creates more housing affordability challenges for area residents as compared to the state.** Overall, 18.1% of the population within the PSA lives in poverty, which is a larger share as compared to the state of North Carolina (13.7%). The share of children under the age of 18 years in the PSA living in poverty (28.4%) is also higher than the corresponding state share (19.3%). When considering these shares, more than 15,000 people (all ages) within the PSA live in poverty. Notably, more than 4,500 of these individuals are estimated to be children under the age of 18. It is also of note that while poverty rates within the PSA are higher than those reported for the state of North Carolina, those reported for the Morganton Submarket are considerably higher than countywide levels. Specifically, 25.4% of the overall population and 48.0% of children under the age of 18 within the Morganton Submarket live in poverty. The higher rates of poverty within both Burke County and the city of Morganton indicate that affordable housing alternatives will remain an important component of the area housing stock for the foreseeable future. 

**The PSA (Burke County) comprises a notably larger share of owner-occupied households as compared to both the state of North Carolina and the Morganton Submarket.** In 2023, there is a 76.7% share of _owner_ households and a 23.3% share of _renter_ households in the PSA. Owner households in the PSA comprise a notably higher share of the total households as compared to the corresponding share for the state (66.1%). Conversely, the share of owner households in the Morganton Submarket (60.6%), is considerably lower than the PSA and statewide shares, illustrating the prevalence of renter-occupied households in the submarket. Between 2023 and 2028, the number of owner households in the PSA is projected to increase by 3.0% (824 households), while the number of renter households is projected to decrease by 0.5% (44 households). Within the Morganton Submarket, owner households are projected to increase by 0.8% (35 households) over the next five years, while renter households are projected to increase by 0.7% (18 households). 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-5** 

~~**Packet Pg. 82**~~
{11}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

**Despite an overall decline in renter households, growth is projected to occur among several income segments within the PSA (Burke County) while growth among owner households is projected to be concentrated among those earning $60,000 or more.** Between 2023 and 2028, all _renter_ household income cohorts earning less than $30,000 in the PSA are projected to decrease, while a majority of the income cohorts earning more than $30,000 are projected to increase. The largest increase (14.0%) of renter households by income in the PSA over the next five years is projected among those earning between $60,000 and $99,999, although a noteworthy increase is also projected for renter households earning between $30,000 and $39,999 (12.8%). While the increase among higher earning renter households in the PSA over the next five years likely indicates an increase in demand for premium rental product, it is critical to understand that nearly 40% of renter households in the PSA will continue to earn less than $30,000 annually. As such, the need for affordable rental alternatives will persist within Burke County. 

Projected growth among _owner_ households in the PSA during this same time period is isolated to those earning $60,000 or more annually, with households earning $100,000 or more increasing by 26.2%. All owner income cohorts earning less than $60,000 are projected to decline in the PSA during this time, with the most notable decrease (23.2%) projected to occur in the cohort earning between $20,000 and $29,999 annually. Overall, these projections for the PSA are generally consistent with statewide projections during the same time period. With the overall number of owner households in the PSA projected to increase by 0.8% between 2023 and 2028 and a notable shift in the distribution of owner households by income toward the higher earning cohorts, these projected changes should be considered when evaluating the for-sale housing market in Burke County. 

**==> picture [428 x 221] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Burke Co. (PSA) Change in Households by Tenure & Income (2023-2028)<br>Renter Owner<br><$20,000 -360<br>-330<br>$20k-$29,999 -68<br>-388<br>$30k-$39,999 161<br>-272<br>$40k-$49,999 -18<br>-435<br>$50k-$59,999 15<br>-77<br>$60k-$99,999 197<br>289<br>$100,000+ 30<br>2,035<br>-500 -250 0 250 500 750 1,000 1,250 1,500 1,750 2,000 2,250<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Additional demographic data and analysis are included in Section IV of this report. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-6** 

~~**Packet Pg. 83**~~
{12}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## Economy & Workforce 

**Several metrics in the PSA (Burke County) economy have exhibited significant improvements in recent years and the county appears to be well positioned for continued economic growth.** The economy in the PSA is heavily influenced by the manufacturing and healthcare sectors, which collectively account for 35.1% of the employment by sector and includes six of the 10 largest employers within the county. Overall, wages within the PSA are lower than wages at the state level, and housing affordability, particularly home ownership, is an issue for a significant share of individuals working within the most common occupations in the area. In addition, nearly 7,800 Burke County residents commute 50 miles or more to their place of employment. Total employment in the PSA as of August 2023 recovered to 102.4% of the 2019 level, while at-place employment (total jobs in county regardless of employee’s county of residence) through March 2023 is at 98.6% of the pre-COVID level. As such, the economy in the PSA has improved significantly during the past few years, and the annual unemployment rate through August 2023 is 3.3%, which is the lowest recorded rate for the county since 2013. A number of noteworthy economic development projects and a significant infrastructure expansion will likely position Burke County to benefit from continued economic improvement. Most notably, a potential manufacturing/industrial megasite being planned for the western portion of the county. This project is anticipated to create many jobs within the area and enhance housing development potential within western Burke County due to infrastructure improvements/expansions from the city of Morganton to the location of the planned megasite. In addition, nearly 14,000 individuals commute into the county daily for employment, which represents a notable base of potential support for future housing development. While this positive economic activity will contribute to the ongoing demand for housing in Burke County, it is important that an adequate supply of income-appropriate housing is available to capture new residents and retain existing residents, particularly those with lengthy commutes. 

Additional economic data and analysis is included in Section V of this report. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-7** 

~~**Packet Pg. 84**~~
{13}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## Housing Supply 

_Note that Bowen National Research first conducted a Housing Needs Assessment for Burke County in 2018. When possible/applicable, we have provided housing supply comparisons between current data and data included in the original 2018 analysis._ 

**Lower shares of cost burdened households as compared to statewide levels are likely reflective of older lower priced housing options within the PSA (Burke County) as compared to the state.** The PSA’s median home value of $185,407 is 29.5% lower than the state’s estimated median home value of $262,944. The average gross rent of $761 in the PSA is approximately 28.7% lower than the state’s average gross rent of $1,067. Overall, these factors result in lower shares of cost burdened renter households (36.8%) and owner households (13.5%) in the PSA compared to the shares within the state (43.2% and 18.9%, respectively). While housing costs appear to be more affordable within the county as compared to the state, it is also of note that the PSA has notably higher shares of housing units built prior to 1970 as compared to the state. Within the PSA, 38.1% of renter-occupied housing units and 31.9% of owner-occupied housing units were built prior to 1970, as compared to the shares for the state of North Carolina (24.0% and 21.8%, respectively). As such, the housing stock in the PSA is, on average, older than housing statewide.  Further and regardless of the lower shares of cost burdened households, there are approximately 3,055 renter households and 3,686 owner households in the PSA that are housing cost burdened (paying more than 30% of income towards housing costs). Of these, approximately 1,519 renter households and 1,638 owner households are _severe_ housing cost burdened (paying 50% or more of their income toward housing costs). Overall, this data illustrates the importance of modern and affordable rental and for-sale housing for the residents of Burke County. 

**Demand remains strong for multifamily rental product within the PSA (Burke County), despite a slightly lower overall occupancy rate as compared to that reported in 2018.** A total of 47 multifamily rental properties containing 2,155 units within the PSA were surveyed. Notably, more than three-quarters (78.7%) of the surveyed multifamily properties are located within the Morganton Submarket. Typically, healthy, well-balanced markets have rental housing occupancy rates generally between 94% and 96%. The rental properties surveyed in the PSA have an overall occupancy rate of 97.3%. In comparison, multifamily properties surveyed at the time of our 2018 analysis reported a slightly higher overall occupancy rate of 98.0%. Nonetheless, the PSA’s multifamily rental market is operating at a high occupancy level with very limited availability. It is noteworthy that, among the 59 total vacancies in the PSA, 96.6% (57 units) are contained within market-rate projects. While the surveyed Tax Credit projects in the PSA are fully occupied, government-subsidized properties in the PSA are operating at an occupancy rate of 99.7%. Additionally, a vast majority of the Tax Credit and government-subsidized properties maintain waiting lists. Further, 46 (78.0%) of the 59 total vacancies 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-8** 

~~**Packet Pg. 85**~~
{14}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

reported are concentrated within one property (Riverview Apartments). According to management, this market-rate property was recently sold and is undergoing renovations. This has likely contributed to the lower occupancy rate and vacancies at this property. When excluding this property, the 2,055 additional units surveyed in the PSA are 99.4% occupied. This is a higher occupancy rate than that reported in 2018 (98.0%). 

|**Project Type**|**Projects**|**Total**<br>**Units**|**Vacant**<br>**Units**|**2023**<br>**Occupancy**<br>**Rate**|**2018**<br>**Occupancy**<br>**Rate**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Morganton**||||||
|Market-Rate|18|934|57|93.9%|95.2%|
|Tax Credit|6|262|0|100.0%|100.0%|
|Tax Credit/Government-Subsidized|2|76|0|100.0%|100.0%|
|Government-Subsidized|11|467|2|99.6%|100.0%|
|Total|37|1,739|59|96.6%|97.9%|
|**Burke County (PSA)**||||||
|Market-Rate|21|1,002|57|94.3%|94.7%|
|Tax Credit|7|322|0|100.0%|100.0%|
|Tax Credit/Government-Subsidized|4|134|0|100.0%|100.0%|
|Government-Subsidized|15|697|2|99.7%|100.0%|
|Total|47|2,155|59|97.3%|98.0%|



Source: Bowen National Research 

**Increasing rental rates within the PSA (Burke County) contribute to ongoing housing affordability challenges for area renters.** Common unit types (i.e., one-, two-, and three-bedroom) offered among PSA rental properties have median collected market-rate rents ranging from $1,175 to $1,400.  Comparatively, these rates are at least 76.1% higher than the median collected rents reported for similar units surveyed in the PSA in 2018. It is of note that the large median rent increases among market-rate properties surveyed in the PSA is partially attributed to the addition of one new market-rate property and renovations resulting in substantial rent increases among an existing property since the time of our 2018 analysis. Although not as severe, median collected rents among non-subsidized Tax Credit properties surveyed in the PSA have also increased since 2018, by rates ranging from 4.1% to 18.4%. The notable increases to area rents since 2018 demonstrate the strength of the local rental market and likely contribute to the ongoing need for affordable rental product in the PSA. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-9** 

~~**Packet Pg. 86**~~
{15}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

**==> picture [442 x 366] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Market-Rate Median Collected Rents (2018 vs 2023)<br>Morganton 2018 Morganton 2023 PSA 2018 PSA 2023<br>$1,400<br>$1,200<br>$1,000<br>$800<br>$600<br>$400<br>$200<br>$0<br>1-Br/1.0-Ba 2-Br/1.0-Ba 2-Br/2.0-Ba 3-Br/2.0-Ba<br>Tax Credit Median Collected Rents (2018 vs 2023)<br>Morganton 2018 Morganton 2023 PSA 2018 PSA 2023<br>$800<br>$700<br>$600<br>$500<br>$400<br>$300<br>$200<br>$100<br>$0<br>1-Br/1.0-Ba 2-Br/1.0-Ba 2-Br/2.0-Ba 3-Br/2.0-Ba<br>$1,385 $1,385 $1,400 $1,400 $1,400 $1,400<br>$1,175 $1,175<br>$795 $795<br>$615 $615 $650 $650<br>$570 $570<br>$770<br>$720<br>$675 $675<br>$650 $650<br>$570 $570<br>$481 $477 $455 $475 $455 $475<br>$432 $432<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Limited supply of available non-conventional rental units further demonstrates limited availability within the PSA (Burke County) rental market.** In total, 34 non-conventional (i.e., single-family homes, mobile homes, structures containing less than five units, etc.) were identified within the PSA, nine of which are located within the Morganton Submarket.  When compared to the overall non-conventional inventory of the PSA (6,838 units), these 34 units represent an overall vacancy rate of 0.5%, which is considered very low. By comparison, the nine available units in the Morganton Submarket also represent a vacancy rate of 0.5%, demonstrating the lack of available non-conventional rentals within Burke County and the Morganton Submarket. The available nonconventional rentals identified in the PSA have rents ranging from $500 to $2,500, depending on the bedroom type. Two- and three-bedroom units, which comprise the largest individual shares (41.2%, each) of the available units in the PSA, have average rents of approximately $1,121 to $1,698, respectively. Such rents are generally similar to, if not higher than, traditional market-rate rents in the PSA and are likely unaffordable to most lower-income renters in the area. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-10** 

~~**Packet Pg. 87**~~
{16}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

**Despite the declining number of annual home sales within the PSA (Burke County), median sale prices continue to increase.** Annual home sales within the PSA declined by nearly 9.0% in 2022 as compared to sales in 2021, with a similar decline reported for the Morganton Submarket during this same time period. Based on home sales data as of October 2023, the PSA is projected to experience a decline of approximately 27.0% in annual home sales in 2023. The recent decline in home sales is likely attributed to increased interest rates and/or construction costs in recent years. Regardless of the decline in annual sales, the median home sales price has steadily increased since 2019.  Notably, the median sales price of $250,000 reported from 2023 is 56.3% higher than that reported in 2019 ($160,000).  These preceding factors likely create challenges for some potential buyers while others decide to delay their purchase. A combination of increased pricing, high mortgage rates and low housing supply in the market will likely keep housing sale volumes relatively low for the foreseeable future. 

**==> picture [441 x 208] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Burke County Annual Sales/Median Price (2019-2023*)<br>Number Sold Median Price<br>1,000 $250,000<br>985 $250,000  $240,000<br>800 899 $230,000<br>773 $230,000  788 $220,000<br>600<br>$205,000  $210,000<br>$200,000<br>400<br>$190,000<br>200 $180,000<br>$160,000  $170,000<br>0 $160,000<br>2019 2021 2022 2023*<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


*Excludes 2020 sales data (unavailable); 2023 full year projection 

**The available for-sale housing inventory in the PSA (Burke County) has diminished from 240 homes at the time of our original analysis in 2018 to 125 homes in 2023, with very few homes now available under $200,000.** There are two inventory metrics most often used to evaluate the health of a for-sale housing market. These metrics include _Months Supply of Inventory_ (MSI) and availability rate. The MSI for the PSA was calculated based on sales history occurring between January 1, 2019 and October 31, 2023 (excluding 2020), which equates to an overall absorption rate of approximately 72 homes per month. Overall, based on the monthly absorption rate of 72 homes, the 125 homes listed as available for purchase in the PSA represent approximately 1.7 months of supply.  Typically, healthy and well-balanced markets have an available supply that should take about four to six months to absorb (if no other units are added to the market). Therefore, the PSA’s inventory is considered low and indicates limited available supply. This also represents a significant decrease in MSI for the PSA compared to our original analysis in 2018, which was approximately 5.5 months. When comparing the 125 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-11** 

~~**Packet Pg. 88**~~
{17}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

available units with the overall inventory of 26,917 owner-occupied units, the PSA has a vacancy/availability rate of 0.5%, which is well below the normal range of 2.0% to 3.0% for a well-balanced for-sale/owner-occupied market. Further, the current availability rate (0.5%) is lower than that reported at the time of our original analysis in 2018 (1.0%). Thus, the for-sale market has experienced reduced availability since 2018. The largest share (32.0%) of available homes in the PSA as of October 2023 are priced between $200,000 and $299,999. While homes priced below $200,000 comprise a notable share (22.4%) of the available supply, this share has decreased significantly compared to the share reported in our 2018 analysis (57.0%). The limited and decreasing supply of product priced under $200,000 may create challenges for lower-income households, including first-time homebuyers, to find affordable for-sale housing in the county. The following tables and graph summarize changes in availability and pricing among homes available for purchase within the PSA since the time of our original analysis in 2018. 

||**Available PSA For-Sale Housing Stock Comparison (2018-2023)**|**Available PSA For-Sale Housing Stock Comparison (2018-2023)**|**Available PSA For-Sale Housing Stock Comparison (2018-2023)**|
|---|---|---|---|
||**2018**|**2023**|**Change**|
|Number of Available Homes|240|125|-115 (-47.9%)|
|Availability Rate|1.0%|0.5%|-0.5|
|Months Supply of Inventory (MSI)|5.3|1.7|-3.6|
|Median List Price|$179,450|$289,000|61.0%|
|Median PricePerSq.Ft.|$96.55|$183.80|90.4%|



Source: Multiple Listing Service (MLS) and Bowen National Research 

|**List Price**<br>Up to $99,999<br>$100,000 to $199,999<br>$200,000 to $299,999<br>$300,000 to $399,999<br>$400,000+<br>Total|**Available For-Sale Housing by Price (January **<br>**Morganton**<br>**2018**<br>**2023**<br>**Number**<br>**Available**<br>**Percent**<br>**of Supply**<br>**Number**<br>**Available**<br>**Percent of**<br>**Supply**<br>13<br>24.5%<br>3<br>12.5%<br>20<br>37.7%<br>2<br>8.3%<br>6<br>11.3%<br>8<br>33.3%<br>9<br>17.0%<br>5<br>20.8%<br>5<br>9.4%<br>6<br>25.0%<br>53<br>100.0%<br>24<br>100.0%|**2018 vs. October 2023)**<br>**Burke County (PSA)**<br>**2018**<br>**2023**<br>**Number**<br>**Available**<br>**Percent**<br>**of Supply**<br>**Number**<br>**Available**<br>**Percent of**<br>**Supply**<br>62<br>25.8%<br>9<br>7.2%<br>75<br>31.3%<br>19<br>15.2%<br>40<br>16.7%<br>40<br>32.0%<br>24<br>10.0%<br>20<br>16.0%<br>39<br>16.3%<br>37<br>29.6%<br>240<br>100.0%<br>125<br>100.0%|
|---|---|---|



Source: Multiple Listing Service (MLS) and Bowen National Research 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-12** 

~~**Packet Pg. 89**~~
{18}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [574 x 754] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.2.b<br>Available For-Sale Housing by Price<br>Morganton Burke County<br>45<br>40<br>40<br>35<br>37<br>30<br>25<br>20<br>15 19 20<br>9 8<br>10 5 6<br>5 3 2<br>0<br>Up to $99,999 $100k- $200k- $300k- $400,000+<br>$199,999 $299,999 $399,999<br>Occupancy rates among senior nursing care facilities increase while the overall<br>assisted living facility occupancy rate declines within the PSA (Burke County).<br>A total of 13 senior care facilities containing a total of 834 marketed beds were<br>surveyed in Burke County. These facilities report an overall occupancy rate of<br>81.9%, which is lower than the national occupancy rate of 84.4% and is more than<br>two full percentage points lower than the overall rate (84.2%) reported among such<br>properties surveyed within the county at the time of our 2018 analysis. It is of note,<br>however, that senior  nursing care  facilities report an overall occupancy rate of<br>87.5%, which is higher than that reported at the time of our 2018 analysis (83.4%)<br>and is more than five full percentage points higher than the national occupancy rate<br>for this product type. The lower overall occupancy rate (81.9%) among all senior<br>care facilities surveyed is attributed to the lower 70.3% occupancy rate reported for<br>the seven  assisted living  properties surveyed. Representatives at the facilities cited<br>ongoing staffing shortages following the COVID-19 pandemic as the primary<br>reason for the low occupancy rates in their respective facilities. Although the<br>overall occupancy rate for the assisted living facilities in the PSA is considered low,<br>it should be noted that three of these surveyed facilities have occupancy rates of<br>95% or higher, and one facility currently maintains a waiting list of five households.<br>Demographic projections over the next five years indicate that senior households,<br>age 75 and older, are expected to increase by 1,236 households (24.3% increase) in<br>Burke County. These demographic projections, along with the high occupancy rates<br>at select facilities in the PSA, indicate the occupancy rates for senior care facilities<br>in the county may increase if no additional beds are added to the market.<br>Nonetheless, occupancy rates among area senior care facilities should continue to<br>be monitored for the foreseeable future to ensure adequate housing remains<br>available for area seniors.<br>Additional housing supply information is included in Section VI.<br>BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH  II-13<br>Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen National Research Housing Study)<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


~~**Packet Pg. 90**~~
{19}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## Other Housing Factors 

**Various potential residential development sites identified within the PSA (Burke County) along with competitive development costs relative to surrounding counties is expected to contribute to future development within Burke County.** The various residential development sites identified are also mostly located in the Morganton Submarket, which is to be expected given the more densely populated/developed nature of this area compared to other areas throughout the county. In total, the 38 sites identified contain approximately 777 acres of land and more than 100,000 square feet of existing structure area which could potentially be redeveloped into residential product. Thus, Burke County appears to have various viable site options for residential developers to consider. A full list of all identified properties is included on page VII-18. 

It does not appear that residential development costs associated with labor costs, utility costs, government fees, or taxes/assessments are significantly higher in Burke County compared to adjacent counties. It is also of note that the median price per acre of vacant land ($19,305/acre) within Burke County is considerably lower than those reported for three of the five adjacent counties evaluated within this analysis. Construction labor rates within the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton MSA are generally lower than those reported for the state of North Carolina. However, it is also important to note that the construction sector accounts for approximately only 2.5% of the MSA job market, a slightly lower figure than that reported for the state of North Carolina (4.0%) as a whole. Thus, while labor rates may be lower within the Burke County area, there is also a more limited skilled labor force within the area as compared to the state, which could potentially limit development within the area. In addition, Burke County zoning regulations primarily favor lower-density development and/or require a special-use permit for multifamily development. This likely creates some challenges for larger multifamily development outside of municipal boundaries. 

## Community Input 

To gain information, perspective and insight about Burke County housing issues and the factors influencing housing decisions by its residents, developers and others, our firm conducted targeted surveys of area stakeholders, employers, residents/commuters, and developers. Nearly 300 survey responses were received from a broad cross section of the community. The following is a summary of **key** responses from each survey group. 

_**Stakeholders:**_ Based on the feedback provided by area stakeholders, it appears that Burke County and Morganton are most in need of affordable workforce housing (both for-sale and rental) and housing that targets single-person households and/or young professionals. While single-family detached homes were rated as the top style in both Burke County and Morganton, apartments and duplex/triplex/ townhomes were also considered substantial needs.  Although it appears the most notable need by price point is for affordable rental ($500 to $749/month) and forsale ($150,000 to $199,999) housing, there is a significant need for housing at a 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-14** 

~~**Packet Pg. 91**~~
{20}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

variety of affordability levels based on feedback from respondents.  Limited availability is one of the most common housing issues experienced in both Burke County and Morganton. However, home purchase affordability, substandard housing, the cost of renovation and upkeep, and rent affordability are also very common housing issues within the markets. Stakeholder respondents believe new construction, the renovation/revitalization of existing housing, and adaptive reuse should be priorities in both markets.  A substantial share of respondents also rated mixed-used development as an important priority within the Morganton Submarket. Funding types such as homebuyer assistance, tax credit financing, project-based rental subsidies, and other homeowner assistance programs were rated as top priorities by respondents.  Overall, the cost of labor and materials, the lack of infrastructure support, financing, and the availability and cost of land were cited as the most common barriers to residential development within Burke County and Morganton.  While these barriers likely limit the ability of the area to attract new households and result in households living in substandard and cost-burdened housing situations, stakeholders provided a variety of possible solutions (page IX-6) that could potentially reduce or eliminate many of these barriers. 

_**Employers:**_ Based on the feedback provided by area employers, it appears that onethird (33.3%) of employers in the county have experienced staffing issues as a result of housing.  Overall, the lack of available housing and affordability (rental and for-sale) are the top issues experienced by employees in the area.  These housing issues adversely impact productivity, prevent businesses from growing or expanding, add to company costs, and create difficulty attracting and retaining employees for a notable share of employers.  The majority (58.3%) of employer respondents indicated that they would be at least “somewhat” more likely to hire new employees if adequate housing were available in the county. Despite the issues that housing can create for employers, it is noteworthy that approximately threequarters of the surveyed employers do not currently provide housing assistance and would not consider providing housing assistance programs in the future. Among various future government housing programs and initiatives, employer respondents consider new housing development/redevelopment, renter assistance, housing assistance for public employees, and the development of additional public housing to be the most important. Overall, the consensus among area employers is that Burke County is most in need of moderate market-rate rental housing ($750 to $1,250 per month), affordable rental housing (under $750 per month), and entry level for-sale housing (below $200,000). Among product types, it appears that employers consider single-family homes (both rental and for-sale) and multifamily apartments to be the most critical need in the area. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-15** 

~~**Packet Pg. 92**~~
{21}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

_**Residents/Commuters:**_ Based on the feedback provided by Burke County residents and commuters, over one-half (57.7%) of respondents rated the local housing market as “Poor.”  Some of the most commonly cited issues that negatively impact the housing market include high prices or rents, the lack of rental vacancies, and the mismatch of local wages and housing costs.  Housing affordability and limited availability were cited as the top reasons that people have difficulty finding suitable housing in Burke County.  While a variety of housing options appear to be in high demand within the county, respondents rated rental housing priced between $500 and $1,000 per month and for-sale housing priced between $100,000 and $200,000 as the housing types in the highest demand.  Apartments and single-family homes (both modern, move-in ready and ranch style) were cited as top housing styles needed in the county. It is also noteworthy that 61.1% of non-resident respondents indicated that they would be interested in relocating to Burke County if suitable housing were available. 

_**Developers:**_ Among the five developers that participated in the survey, the majority are either currently involved in building, or are interested in building, single-family for-sale homes, multifamily rentals, and mixed-use product (commercial and residential). All respondents noted that they either develop or seek to develop higher-end market-rate housing (for incomes between $75,000 and $100,000), and the majority either develop or seek to develop luxury housing (for incomes above $100,000).  While housing developed by the respondents most commonly serves older adults (ages 55 and older), half of the respondents noted that their developments also target millennials (ages 25 to 44), middle-aged adults (ages 4554), and seniors (ages 65 and older).  Although low appraisal amounts, the cost and lack of infrastructure, and zoning regulations were cited as common barriers to development by the majority of respondents, the most common barriers noted were the cost of labor and materials and financing.  Developer respondents believe priority should be given to updating subdivision regulations and requirements, obtaining government assistance for infrastructure development, and revisiting and/or modifying zoning regulations. While there is minimal to moderate interest in partnering with local employers and nonprofit groups, developers appear to be more interested in partnering with public entities to develop residential units. 

## Housing Gap Estimates 

**Burke County has an overall housing gap of 4,822 units for rental and for-sale product at a variety of affordability levels** . It is projected that Burke County has a five-year **rental housing gap of 1,499 units** and a **for-sale housing gap of 3,323 units** . While there are housing gaps among all affordability levels of both rental and for-sale product, the rental housing gap is primarily for product with rents at or below $891 and the for-sale housing gap is primarily for product priced between $190,134 and $285,600. Details of this analysis, including our methodology and assumptions, are included in Section VIII. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-16** 

~~**Packet Pg. 93**~~
{22}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following table summarizes the approximate potential number of new residential units that could be supported in the PSA (Burke County) over the next five years. 

**==> picture [409 x 197] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
-<br>PSA (Burke County) Housing Needs Estimates (2023 2028)<br>Number<br>Housing Segment (Price)  of Units*<br>Extremely/Very Low-Income Rental Housing (≤$891/Month Rent) 834<br>Low-Income Rental Housing ($892-$1,426/Month Rent) 327<br>Moderate-Income Rental Housing ($1,427-2,142/Month Rent) 199<br>Higher-Income Rental Housing ($2,143+/Month Rent)  139<br>Total Units  1,499<br>Entry-Level For-Sale Homes (≤$118,833) 61<br>Lower-Income For-Sale Homes ($118,834-$190,133) 815<br>Moderate-Income For-Sale Homes ($190,134-$285,600)  1,517<br>Higher-Income For-Sale Homes ($285,601+)  930<br>Total Units 3,323<br>*Number of units assumes product is marketable, affordable and in a marketable location. Variations of product<br>types will impact the actual number of units that can be supported. Additionally, incentives and/or government<br>policy changes could encourage support for additional units that exceed the preceding projections.<br>Rentals<br>For-Sale<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


The preceding estimates are based on current government policies and incentives, recent and projected demographic trends, current and anticipated economic trends, and available and planned residential units. Numerous factors impact a market’s ability to support new housing product. This is particularly true of individual housing projects or units. Certain design elements, pricing structures, target market segments (e.g., seniors, workforce, families, etc.), product quality and location all influence the actual number of units that can be supported. Demand estimates could exceed those shown in the preceding table if the county and/or its incorporated municipalities changed its policies or offer incentives to encourage people to move into the market or for developers to develop new housing product. 

## Recommended Housing Strategies 

The following summarizes key strategies for Burke County that should be considered to address housing issues and needs of the market. These strategies do not need to be done concurrently, nor do all strategies need to be implemented to create an impact. Instead, the following housing strategies should be used as a guide by the local government, stakeholders, developers and residents to help inform housing decisions. 

– _**Develop Next-Steps Plans**_ Using the findings and recommendations of this report, local government and stakeholders should begin to prioritize housing objectives and refine housing strategies that best fit the overarching goals of the area. Input from stakeholders and residents should be solicited. From these efforts a specific Action Plan could be put together with measurable goals and a timeline to follow. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-17** 

~~**Packet Pg. 94**~~
{23}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

_**Set Realistic/Attainable Short-Term Housing Goals, Outline Long-Term Objectives and Monitor Progress**_ – Using the housing needs estimates and recommendations provided in this report as a guide, the county could set realistic short-term (two to three years) housing development goals along with long-term (five years or longer) objectives to support housing. Short-term goals could focus on establishing an Action Plan that outlines priorities, such as broad housing policies, initiatives, and incentives that support the preservation and development of residential units. The recommendations included in this section could serve as a guide for developing an Action Plan. Long-term objectives could include establishing a goal for the number of housing units that could be built or repaired and broadly outline the types of housing that could be considered, such as rentals and for-sale housing, as well as geographical locations (e.g., within walkable communities, selected neighborhoods, etc.). The goals could also broadly outline affordability (e.g., income levels) objectives and market segments (e.g., families, seniors, etc.) that could be served. From such goals, the county could periodically collect key metrics (e.g., vacancy rates, changes in rents/prices, reassess cost burdened and overcrowded housing, evaluate housing cost increases relative to income/wage growth, etc.) so that they can monitor progress and adjust efforts to support stated goals. 

_**Consider Establishing a Housing Committee and/or Hiring a Housing Director to Help Define and Implement Housing Policies, Programs and Goals for the County**_ – Given the scope and complexity of housing issues and needs facing the county, the county should consider establishing a housing committee to provide oversight on various housing issues and efforts. This committee would be responsible for collecting and assessing information on housing issues, providing direction and/or recommendations to the county, and helping coordinate housing efforts within the county. Consideration should be given to expanding housing committee representation to include persons and organizations from various municipalities throughout Burke County. Such a committee should be comprised of a broad mix of both public and private sector representatives. The county may also want to explore hiring a Housing Director with knowledge and experience in overseeing housing programs, developing policies, and securing housing funding. This position may be merged with an existing position already within the local government and/or could be a part-time or short-term position (e.g., one- or twoyear contract). 

**Consider Implementing/Modifying Policies to Encourage or Support the Development of New Housing and the Preservation of Existing Housing.** One of the key findings from this report is that there is _limited availability_ among the existing housing stock in the county and relatively limited residential development currently in the development pipeline. The lack of available housing likely limits demographic growth within the county as many residents seeking new housing, as well as persons/households looking to relocate to the area, have very few options from which to choose. Notably, nearly 14,000 people commute to Burke County for employment, with nearly 4,500 of these commuters traveling more than 50 miles each way. These commuters represent a large base of potential household growth 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-18** 

~~**Packet Pg. 95**~~
{24}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

for Burke County should housing that meets their needs become available within the area. Local government could consider supporting housing policies such as expanding residential density to allow for more units, modifying unit size requirements (allowing for smaller units), supporting or leveraging developer incentives (e.g., Qualified Opportunity Zones, TIF districts, tax abatements, etc.), waiving/deferring/lowering government fees, and exploring other measures specifically targeted to the types of housing (e.g. affordable, senior, etc.) that lead to meeting housing goals. In an effort to support more affordable housing alternatives, the county should consider supporting projects being developed with affordable housing development programs (e.g., Tax Credit and HUD programs), providing pre-development financial assistance, supporting a Housing Trust Fund, exploring the establishment of a land bank to acquire, improve and convey tax delinquent and neglected properties, and providing low-interest or forgivable loans and grants to lower income households that can be used to cover costs directly associated with the repairs and maintenance of the existing housing stock. Overall, focus should be placed on programs that support low-income households (seniors and families), workforce households, and first-time homebuyers. Additional housing is needed in order to have a healthy housing market, which will ultimately contribute to the local economy, quality of life and overall prosperity of Burke County. 

**Formulate Education and Outreach Campaign to Help Support Housing Initiatives** _**.**_ Using both existing and newly created housing education initiatives, local stakeholders could develop an overarching education program with a more unified objective that ultimately supports local housing efforts. The program could, for example, include educating landlords on the Housing Choice Voucher program, informing potential homebuyers about homebuying requirements and assistance (credit repair, down payments, etc.), and advising existing homeowners on home repair assistance. Additional outreach efforts should involve both informing and engaging area residents, elected officials, area employers and other stakeholders on the benefits of developing affordable housing. Such efforts could help to mitigate stigmas associated with affordable housing, illustrate the benefits such housing has on the local economy, and help to get the community to “buy in” on housing initiatives. Annual or other periodic housing forums, or workshops, preparing annual reports or marketing material could be used to help communicate housing advocate messaging. Examples of marketing and outreach efforts can be provided upon request. 

_**Support Efforts to Enable Area Seniors to Transition into Housing to Meet Their Changing Needs**_ – Burke County has a large base of older adults, with significant growth projected to occur among senior households ages 65 and older over the next several years. Currently, there is a limited inventory of _available_ housing in the market, and the few senior-restricted rental housing projects in the county are typically fully occupied with waiting lists. As a result, seniors in the county who wish to downsize into smaller, more maintenance-free independent housing, or seniors seeking affordable rentals will have difficulty finding housing that meets their needs. Based on the Bowen National Research survey of housing alternatives 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-19** 

~~**Packet Pg. 96**~~
{25}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

in the market, an assessment of area demographic characteristics and trends, and input from area stakeholders, senior-oriented housing is and will continue to be an important component to the overall housing market. New housing product for seniors that could be considered include but may not be limited to affordable (lowincome) rentals, market-rate independent living rentals, and for-sale condominiums that include accessibility design elements. While senior care housing (assisted living and nursing homes) is also a popular senior housing product, it will be important for local officials and developers to continue to monitor occupancy trends/rates among such existing properties in the county, particularly assisted living facilities, prior to committing to additional such development in the area. This is due to the lower overall occupancy rate(s) reported among existing senior care facilities surveyed in the county. 

_**Explore and Encourage Development Partnerships –**_ Government entities within the county may want to establish formal relationships with other entities to support housing development efforts.  This may include relationships with nonprofit groups (e.g., Community Action Agency, Habitat for Humanity, etc.) local businesses and private sector developers. The consolidation of the public and private sectors for certain housing initiatives can lead to improved efficiencies, larger financial capacities, and more cohesive residential development efforts. For example, this could include a large employer providing financial benefits (e.g., down payment assistance) to its qualified employees (possibly those earning below a certain income level) to reside at a residential development in which the county is providing tax abatements or other incentives for the developer/property owner. There are numerous examples around the country of public-private sector partnerships that could be explored further for potential replication in Burke County. 

_**Market Burke County’s Housing Needs and Opportunities to Potential Residential Development Partners and Develop a Centralized Housing Resource Center**_ – Using a variety of sources, the county should attempt to identify and market itself to the residential developers (both for-profit and nonprofit), real estate investors, housing advocacy groups and others active in the region.  Identification could be through trade associations, published lists of developers, real estate agents or brokers, and other real estate entities in the region.  Marketing of the county through trade publications, direct solicitation or public venues (e.g., housing and economic conferences) should be considered. The promotion of market data (including this Housing Needs Assessment), development opportunities, housing programs and incentives should be the focus of such efforts. It is common for economic development organizations to have a website that educates potential developers of industrial, manufacturing or warehouse space on such things as potential development sites, profiles of the local workforce, local tax rates and other pertinent factors that may influence building or investment decisions. This same approach can be used for promoting _residential_ development and investment opportunities in Burke County. The development of an online _residential_ resource center should be considered that includes or directs people to development and housing resources such as: 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-20** 

~~**Packet Pg. 97**~~
{26}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|**Housing Assistance and Resources**|**Housing Assistance and Resources**|
|---|---|
|**Resident Track**|**Developer Track**|
|Housing Advocacy Contacts|Published Reports (Housing Study)|
|Renter and Homebuyer Education<br>Information/Programs|Government Contacts<br>(Planning, Zoning, etc.)|
|Fair Housing Information & Contacts|Building and Zoning Regulations|
|Housing Supply Inventory<br>(Rental Listings, Realtors Listing, etc.)|Potential Development Sites|
|Renter & Homebuyer Financial Assistance|Infrastructure & Public Works Information|
|Supportive Service Contacts|Development Incentives|



This website could be an addition to an existing government website or the creation of a new website through a housing or economic advocacy organization. While this recommendation focuses on a website, it is also possible that such resources be provided through a physical organization or staffed office. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**II-21** 

~~**Packet Pg. 98**~~
{27}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **III. COMMUNITY OVERVIEW AND STUDY AREAS** 

## **A.  BURKE COUNTY, NORTH CAROLINA** 

This report focuses on the housing needs of Burke County, North Carolina. Founded in 1777, Burke County is approximately 514 square miles and is located in the western portion of North Carolina. The county seat, the city of Morganton, is approximately 70 miles northwest of Charlotte, North Carolina. The main thoroughfares that serve Burke County include Interstate 40 and U.S. Highways 64 and 70. 

Burke County has an estimated population of 88,095 in 2023, an increase of 525, or 0.6%, since 2020. The county’s estimated population density is 171.3 persons per-square-mile in 2023, which is lower compared to the state of North Carolina (218.2 persons per-square-mile). The county’s notable incorporated communities include the city of Morganton and the towns of Connelly Springs, Drexel, Glen Alpine, Rutherford College, and Valdese. There are also various villages and unincorporated areas within Burke County. The city of Morganton, which serves as the county seat, is home to the county courthouse, various commercial businesses, employment opportunities, and a hospital. Notable attractions within the county include the South Mountains State Park and several national historic locations and trails. 

Based on 2023 estimates, 76.7% of the county’s households are owner households. Over three quarters (80.6%) of rental units are within structures of four or fewer units (including mobile homes), while the majority (99.6%) of the owner-occupied units are within these smaller structures and mobile homes (primarily single-family homes). As shown in the supply section (Section VI) of this report, the market offers a wide variety of price points and rents. Additional information regarding the county’s demographic characteristics and trends, economic conditions, housing supply, and other factors that impact housing are included throughout this report. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**III-1** 

~~**Packet Pg. 99**~~
{28}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **B.  STUDY AREA DELINEATIONS** 

This report addresses the residential housing needs of Burke County, North Carolina. To this end, the evaluation is focused on the demographic and economic characteristics, as well as the existing housing stock, of areas within Burke County. Additionally, a supplemental analysis is provided for the city of Morganton to understand trends and attributes that affect this designated area. The following summarizes the various study areas used in this analysis. 

_**Primary Study Area**_ – The Primary Study Area (PSA) includes all of Burke County. 

_**Submarket**_ – The submarket is comprised of the area within the city limits of Morganton. 

Maps delineating the boundaries of the various study areas are shown on the following pages. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**III-2** 

~~**Packet Pg. 100**~~
{29}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [55 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.2.b<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [19 x 516] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Packet Pg. 101**
{30}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 102**
{31}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 103**
{32}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **IV.  DEMOGRAPHIC ANALYSIS** 

## **A. INTRODUCTION** 

This section of the report evaluates key demographic characteristics for the Primary Study Area (PSA, Burke County) and the select submarket of the city of Morganton. Through this analysis, unfolding trends and unique conditions are often revealed regarding populations and households residing in the selected geographic areas. Demographic comparisons between these geographies and the state of North Carolina provide insights into the human composition of housing markets. Critical questions, such as the following, can be answered with this information: 

- Who lives in Burke County and what are these people like? 

- In what kinds of household groupings do Burke County residents live? 

- What share of people rent or own their Burke County residence? 

- Are the number of people and households living in Burke County increasing or decreasing over time? 

- How has migration contributed to the population changes within Burke County in recent years, and what are these in-migrants like? 

- How do Burke County residents, submarket residents and residents of the state compare with each other? 

This section is comprised of three major parts: population characteristics, household characteristics, and demographic theme maps. Population characteristics describe the qualities of individual people, while household characteristics describe the qualities of people living together in one residence. Demographic theme maps graphically show varying levels (low to high concentrations) of a demographic characteristic across a geographic region. 

It is important to note that 2010 and 2020 demographics are based on U.S. Census data (actual count), while 2023 and 2028 data are based on calculated estimates provided by ESRI, a nationally recognized demography firm, and the North Carolina Office of State Budget and Management (NCOSBM). The accuracy of these estimates depends on the realization of certain assumptions: 

- Economic projections made by secondary sources materialize. 

- Governmental policies with respect to residential development remain consistent. 

- Availability of financing for residential development (i.e., mortgages, commercial loans, subsidies, Tax Credits, etc.) remains consistent. 

- Sufficient housing and infrastructure are provided to support projected population and household growth. 

Significant unforeseen changes or fluctuations among any of the preceding assumptions could have an impact on demographic estimates/projections. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-1** 

~~**Packet Pg. 104**~~
{33}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **B. POPULATION CHARACTERISTICS** 

Population by numbers and percent change (growth or decline) for selected years is shown in the following table. It should be noted that some total numbers and percentages may not match the totals within or between tables in this section due to rounding. Positive changes between time periods in the following table are illustrated in green, while negative changes are illustrated in red. 

|**Total Population**<br>**2010**<br>**Census**<br>**2020**<br>**Census**<br>**Change 2010-2020**<br>**2023**<br>**Estimated**<br>**Change 2020-2023**<br>**Number**<br>**Percent**<br>**Number**<br>**Percent**<br>**Morganton**<br>16,830<br>17,474<br>**644**<br>**3.8%**<br>17,595<br>**121**<br>**0.7%**<br>**Burke County**<br>90,849<br>87,570<br>**-3,279**<br>**-3.6%**<br>88,095<br>**525**<br>**0.6%**<br>**North Carolina**<br>9,535,483<br>10,439,388<br>**903,905**<br>**9.5%**<br>10,765,678<br>**326,290**<br>**3.1%**<br>Source:  2010, 2020 Census; ESRI; NCOSBM; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research|**2028**<br>**Projected**<br>17,539<br>88,976<br>11,052,161|**Change 2023-2028**<br>**Number**<br>**Percent**<br>**-56**<br>**-0.3%**<br>**881**<br>**1.0%**<br>**286,483**<br>**2.7%**|
|---|---|---|



Between 2010 and 2020, the population within the PSA (Burke County) decreased by 3,279 (3.6%), which contrasts with the increase (9.5%) within the state of North Carolina during this time period.  During this time period, the Morganton Submarket experienced a notable increase (3.8%) in population.  In 2023, the total estimated population of Burke County is 88,095, which represents a slight increase (0.6%) from the population in 2020.  The Morganton Submarket, which has an estimated population of 17,595 in 2023, comprises 20.0% of the total population in the PSA.  Between 2023 and 2028, the population of the PSA is projected to increase by 1.0%, or 881 individuals.  The population of Morganton Submarket is projected to moderately decrease (0.3%) during this time.  The projected population decline in the Morganton Submarket contrasts with the county and statewide population increases projected over the next five years. It is critical to point out that _household_ changes, as opposed to population, are more material in assessing housing needs and opportunities. Historical and projected household changes for the PSA and submarket are covered later in this section starting on page IV-12. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-2** 

~~**Packet Pg. 105**~~
{34}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following graph compares the percent change in population since 2010 and projected through 2028. 

**==> picture [449 x 479] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Population Growth Trends (2010-2028)<br>Morganton Burke County North Carolina<br>10.0%<br>9.5%<br>8.0%<br>6.0%<br>4.0%<br>3.8%<br>2.0% 0.7% 0.6% 3.1% 1.0% 2.7%<br>0.0%<br>-0.3%<br>-2.0%<br>-3.6%<br>-4.0%<br>2010-2020 2020-2023 2023-2028<br>PSA (Burke County) Population Growth Trends (2010-2028)<br>91,000<br>90,849<br>90,500<br>90,000<br>89,500<br>88,976<br>89,000<br>88,500<br>88,095<br>88,000<br>87,500 87,570<br>87,000<br>2010 2020 2023 2028<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-3** 

~~**Packet Pg. 106**~~
{35}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Population densities for selected years are shown in the following table: 

|||**Population Densities**|**Population Densities**|**Population Densities**|**Population Densities**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|||**2010**|**2020**|**2023**|**2028**|
|**Morganton**|Population|16,830|17,474|17,595|17,539|
||Area in Square Miles|19.24|19.24|19.24|19.24|
||Density|874.6|908.0|914.3|911.4|
|**Burke County**|Population|90,849|87,570|88,095|88,976|
||Area in Square Miles|514.23|514.23|514.23|514.23|
||Density|176.7|170.3|171.3|173.0|
|**North Carolina**|Population|9,535,483|10,439,388|10,765,678|11,052,161|
||Area in Square Miles|49,336.79|49,336.79|49,336.79|49,336.79|
||Density|193.3|211.6|218.2|224.0|



Source:  2010, 2020 Census; ESRI; NCOSBM; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research 

With a population density of 171.3 persons per square mile in 2023, the PSA (Burke County) is less densely populated than the state (218.2 persons per square mile), overall. The population density of the PSA decreased by 3.1% between 2010 and 2023, and it is projected that the density will increase slightly over the next five years. The Morganton Submarket, by comparison, is much more densely populated (914.3 persons per square mile) than both Burke County and the state of North Carolina in 2023. 

Noteworthy population characteristics for each area are illustrated in the following table. Note that data included within this table is derived from multiple sources (2020 Census, ESRI, American Community Survey) and is provided for the most recent time period available for the given source. 

|||**Population Characteristics(Year)**|**Population Characteristics(Year)**|**Population Characteristics(Year)**|**Population Characteristics(Year)**|**Population Characteristics(Year)**|**Population Characteristics(Year)**|**Population Characteristics(Year)**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|||**Minority**<br>**Population**<br>**(2020)**|**Unmarried**<br>**Population**<br>**(2023)**|**No High**<br>**School**<br>**Diploma**<br>**(2023)**|**College**<br>**Degree**<br>**(2023)**|**< 18 Years**<br>**Below**<br>**Poverty**<br>**Level**<br>**(2021)**|**Overall**<br>**Below**<br>**Poverty**<br>**Level**<br>**(2021)**|**Movership**<br>**Rate**<br>**(2021)**|
|**Morganton**|Number|6,596|8,128|2,402|4,989|2,104|4,033|2,842|
||Percent|37.7%|55.9%|19.0%|39.4%|48.0%|25.4%|17.3%|
|**Burke County**|Number|17,899|35,201|9,387|22,817|4,516|15,490|9,306|
||Percent|20.4%|47.4%|14.4%|35.0%|28.4%|18.1%|10.7%|
|**North Carolina**|Number|3,950,929|4,317,225|689,512|3,498,051|436,890|1,379,667|1,450,877|
||Percent|37.8%|48.9%|9.3%|47.0%|19.3%|13.7%|14.1%|



Source: U.S. Census Bureau; 2020 Census; 2017-2021 American Community Survey; ESRI; NCOSBM; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research 

As the preceding table illustrates, minorities in the PSA (Burke County) comprise a notably smaller share (20.4%) of the overall population as compared to the state (37.8%).  Among the adult population of the PSA, 47.4% of the population is unmarried, which is a slightly smaller share than the state share (48.9%). The share of the adult population in the PSA that lacks a high school diploma (14.4%) is higher than the share within the state (9.3%), while the share of individuals in Burke County with a college degree (35.0%) is notably less than the corresponding share in the state (47.0%). Overall, 18.1% of the 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-4** 

~~**Packet Pg. 107**~~
{36}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

population within the PSA lives in poverty, which is a much larger share as compared to the share for the state of North Carolina (13.7%). The share of children under the age of 18 years in the PSA living in poverty (28.4%) is also much higher than the corresponding state share (19.3%). The movership rate (the share of the population moving within or to a given area year over year) of the PSA is 10.7%, which is less than the 14.1% rate reported within the state. 

Within the Morganton Submarket, minorities comprise a significantly larger share (37.7%) of the total population as compared to the PSA.  While there is a larger share of unmarried population (55.9%) and a larger share of individuals lacking a high school diploma (19.0%) in the Morganton Submarket, there is a slightly greater share of individuals in the submarket with a college degree (39.4%) compared to the PSA.  The shares of the overall population living below poverty level (25.4%) and the population less than 18 years of age living below poverty level (48.0%) in the Morganton Submarket are notably higher than the corresponding shares for the PSA.  Additionally, the movership rate in the submarket (17.3%) is higher than both the PSA and state shares. As marital status and educational attainment typically affect household income, these factors can play an important role in the overall housing affordability of an area. 

The following graph compares the overall poverty rate for each study area and the shares of each population that is unmarried and that lacks a high school diploma. 

**==> picture [441 x 233] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Poverty Rates vs Population Shares of Unmarried & No High School Diploma<br>Overall Poverty Rate Unmarried % No High School Diploma %<br>30.0% 60.0%<br>55.9%<br>47.4% 48.9%<br>25.0% 50.0%<br>25.4%<br>20.0% 40.0%<br>18.1%<br>15.0% 30.0%<br>19.0% 13.7%<br>10.0% 20.0%<br>14.4%<br>5.0% 9.3% 10.0%<br>0.0% 0.0%<br>Morganton Burke County North Carolina<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-5** 

~~**Packet Pg. 108**~~
{37}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

While the analysis on the preceding pages illustrates recent population changes, future population projections, and population characteristics such as age, marital status, and educational attainment, the following addresses where people _move_ to and from, referred to as migration patterns. For the purposes of this analysis, the Census Bureau’s Population Estimates Program (PEP) is considered the most reliable source for the total _volume_ of domestic migration. To evaluate migration _flows_ between counties and mobility patterns by age and income at the county level, we use the U.S. Census Bureau’s migration estimates published by the American Community Survey (ACS) for 2021.  It is important to note that while county administrative boundaries are likely imperfect reflections of commuter sheds, moving across a county boundary is often an acceptable distance to make a meaningful difference in a person’s local housing and labor market environment. The data provided by the PEP is intended to provide general insight regarding the contributing factors of population change (natural increase, domestic migration, and international migration), and as such, gross population changes within this data should not be compared to other tables which may be derived from alternate data sources such as the Decennial Census or American Community Survey. 

The following table illustrates the cumulative change in total population for the PSA (Burke County) between April 2010 and July 2022. 

||**Estimated Components of Population Change by County for the PSA (Burke County)**<br>**April 1, 2010 to July 1, 2022**|**Estimated Components of Population Change by County for the PSA (Burke County)**<br>**April 1, 2010 to July 1, 2022**|**Estimated Components of Population Change by County for the PSA (Burke County)**<br>**April 1, 2010 to July 1, 2022**|**Estimated Components of Population Change by County for the PSA (Burke County)**<br>**April 1, 2010 to July 1, 2022**|**Estimated Components of Population Change by County for the PSA (Burke County)**<br>**April 1, 2010 to July 1, 2022**|**Estimated Components of Population Change by County for the PSA (Burke County)**<br>**April 1, 2010 to July 1, 2022**|**Estimated Components of Population Change by County for the PSA (Burke County)**<br>**April 1, 2010 to July 1, 2022**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
||**Years**|**Population**<br>**Change***|**Percent**<br>**Change**|**Natural**<br>**Change**|**Net**<br>**Domestic**<br>**Migration**|**Net**<br>**International**<br>**Migration**|**Total**<br>**Net**<br>**Migration**|
|Burke County|2010-2020|-406|-0.4%|-1,658|546|754|1,300|
||2020-2022|308|0.4%|-1,017|1,255|42|1,297|



Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Population Division, June 2023 

*Includes residuals of (-48) and (28) representing the change that cannot be attributed to any specific demographic component 

Based on the preceding data, the population decline within Burke County from 2010 to 2020 was the result of natural decrease (more deaths than births). While total net migration for the PSA was positive during this time, the migration component was not sufficient to offset the population decline from natural change.  Between 2020 and 2022, the combination of natural decrease and positive total net migration continued within Burke County.  It is apparent that the overarching population trends for Burke County are indicative of notable natural decrease and positive domestic and international migration. In order for Burke County to improve population trends, it is important that an adequate supply of income-appropriate rental and for-sale housing is available to continue attracting domestic and international migrants, and to retain young adults and families in the area, which contributes to natural increase of a population.  Other factors such as job availability, wage competitiveness, and housing conditions can substantially impact population change. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-6** 

~~**Packet Pg. 109**~~
{38}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following table details the _shares_ of domestic in-migration by three select age cohorts for the PSA (Burke County) from 2012 to 2021. 

|**Burke County, North Carolina**<br>**Domestic County Population In-Migrants by Age, 2012 to 2021**|**Burke County, North Carolina**<br>**Domestic County Population In-Migrants by Age, 2012 to 2021**|**Burke County, North Carolina**<br>**Domestic County Population In-Migrants by Age, 2012 to 2021**|
|---|---|---|
|**Age**|**2012-2016**|**2017-2021**|
|1 to 34|57.3%|43.5%|
|35 to 54|24.6%|31.5%|
|55+|18.0%|25.0%|
|Median Age (In-state migrants)|30.1|35.5|
|Median Age (Out-of-state migrants)|34.5|50.3|
|Median Age (Burke County)|43.5|44.7|



Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2016 & 2021 5-Year ACS Estimates (S0701); Bowen National Research 

According to 2012-2016 American Community Survey estimates, 57.3% of domestic in-migrants to Burke County were less than 35 years of age. Between 2017 and 2021, the share of in-migrants less than 35 years of age (43.5%) decreased, while the share of in-migrants between the ages of 35 and 54 (31.5%) and those age 55 and older (25.0%) increased. The median age of in-state migrants (originating from a different county in North Carolina) increased from 30.1 years to 35.5 years between the two time periods, while the median age of out-of-state migrants increased from 34.5 years to 50.3 years. Overall, the data suggests that while a significant share of recent domestic in-migrants to Burke County are under the age of 35, this share has decreased over time. While instate migrants are generally younger than the existing population of the PSA, out-of-state migrants in recent years have been, on average, older than the existing population of Burke County. 

The following table illustrates the top 10 gross migration counties (total combined inflow and outflow) for Burke County with the resulting net migration (difference between inflow and outflow) for each. Note that counties which directly border the PSA (Burke County) are illustrated in red text. 

**==> picture [398 x 194] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
County-to-County Domestic Population Migration for Burke County, NC<br>Top 10 Gross Migration Counties*<br>Gross Migration<br>County Number  Percent  Net Migration<br>Catawba County, NC  1,549  18.2%  -531<br>Caldwell County, NC  1,149  13.5%  153<br>McDowell County, NC  501  5.9%  -251<br>Cabarrus County, NC 374 4.4% -348<br>Mecklenburg County, NC 174  2.0%  -104<br>Rowan County, NC  146  1.7%  26<br>Buncombe County, NC  142  1.7%  134<br>Lincoln County, NC  139  1.6%  57<br>Pitt County, NC  131  1.5%  -77<br>Carteret County, NC  118  1.4%  20<br>All Other Counties  4,088  48.0%  562<br>Total Migration  8,511  100.00%  -359<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2020 5-Year American Community Survey; Bowen National Research *Top 10 counties only include nearby regional counties. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-7** 

~~**Packet Pg. 110**~~
{39}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

As the preceding table illustrates, four of the top 10 gross migration counties directly border the PSA (Burke County) and comprise 39.2% of the total gross migration for the PSA. The four adjacent counties have an overall negative netmigration influence (-572) on Burke County. In total, slightly over one-half (52.0%) of the gross migration for the PSA is among the top 10 counties listed. Among these counties, Caldwell County and Buncombe County have the largest _positive_ net-migration influence on the PSA. Conversely, the counties of Catawba, Cabarrus, and McDowell have the largest overall _negative_ netmigration impact for the PSA.  While it appears that the overall domestic migration in Burke County has been negative in recent years, it is noteworthy that migration among the counties outside the top 10 listed has been positive. This indicates that Burke County likely attracts new residents from a large geographic area, while typically incurring a net loss of residents to nearby counties in the immediate region, with the exception of Buncombe County and Caldwell County. 

Maps illustrating the regional gross migration and net-migration between Burke County and nearby regional counties for 2020 are shown on the following pages. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-8** 

~~**Packet Pg. 111**~~
{40}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [55 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.2.b<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [91 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Packet Pg. 112<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>
{41}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**==> picture [19 x 516] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Packet Pg. 113**
{42}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

While the data contained in the previous pages illustrates the overall net migration trends for the PSA (Burke County) and gives perspective about the general location where these individuals migrate to and from, it is also important to understand the income levels of in-migrants as they directly relate to affordability of housing. The following table illustrates the _per-person_ income distribution by geographic mobility status for Burke County inmigrants. Note that this data is provided for the county _population_ , not households, ages 15 and above: 

|**Burke County: Income Distribution by Mobility Status for Population Age 15+ Years***|**Burke County: Income Distribution by Mobility Status for Population Age 15+ Years***|**Burke County: Income Distribution by Mobility Status for Population Age 15+ Years***|**Burke County: Income Distribution by Mobility Status for Population Age 15+ Years***|**Burke County: Income Distribution by Mobility Status for Population Age 15+ Years***|**Burke County: Income Distribution by Mobility Status for Population Age 15+ Years***|**Burke County: Income Distribution by Mobility Status for Population Age 15+ Years***|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**2021 Inflation**<br>**Adjusted Individual**<br>**Income**|||**Moved From**||**Moved From**<br>**Different State**||
||**Moved Within**||**Different County,**||||
||**Same County**||**Same State**||||
||**Number**|**Percent**|**Number**|**Percent**|**Number**|**Percent**|
|<$10,000|640|19.6%|291|21.2%|200|18.3%|
|$10,000 to $14,999|509|15.6%|254|18.5%|118|10.8%|
|$15,000 to $24,999|675|20.7%|200|14.6%|117|10.7%|
|$25,000 to $34,999|595|18.2%|135|9.9%|149|13.6%|
|$35,000 to $49,999|496|15.2%|242|17.7%|258|23.6%|
|$50,000 to $64,999|191|5.9%|226|16.5%|116|10.6%|
|$65,000 to $74,999|20|0.6%|0|0.0%|45|4.1%|
|$75,000+|135|4.1%|22|1.6%|91|8.3%|
|Total|3,261|100.0%|1,370|100.0%|1,094|100.0%|



Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2021 5-Year American Community Survey (B07010); Bowen National Research *Excludes population with no income 

According to data provided by the 2021 American Community Survey, over one-half (54.3%) of the population that moved to Burke County from a different county within North Carolina earned less than $25,000 per year. This is a larger share of such individuals when compared to the share (39.8%) of individuals migrating from outside the state that earn less than $25,000 per year. By comparison, the share of individuals earning $50,000 or more per year is smaller for both in-migrants from a different county within North Carolina (18.1%) and those from outside the state (23.0%). Although it is likely that a significant share of the population earning less than $25,000 per year consists of children over the age of 15 and young adults considered to be dependents within a larger family, this illustrates that affordable housing options are likely important for a significant portion of in-migrants to Burke County. 

Based on our evaluation of the components of population change between 2010 and 2020, the population decrease during this time in Burke County was due primarily to natural decrease, despite positive domestic and international migration. Although a notable share of in-migrants to Burke County are less than 35 years of age, approximately one-quarter of recent in-migrants are age 55 and older, and a considerable share of in-migrants to Burke County earns less than $25,000 annually. In order for the PSA to maximize migration potential and retain or attract young households, it is important that an adequate supply of income-appropriate housing is readily available in the future. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-11** 

~~**Packet Pg. 114**~~
{43}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **C. HOUSEHOLD CHARACTERISTICS** 

Households by numbers and percent change (growth or decline) for selected years are shown in the following table. Note that decreases are illustrated in red text, while increases are illustrated in green text: 

||||**Total Households**|**Total Households**|**Total Households**|**Total Households**|**Total Households**|**Total Households**|||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
||**2010**<br>**Census**|**2020**<br>**Census**|**Change 2010-2020**||**2023**<br>**Estimated**|**Change 2020-2023**||**2028**<br>**Projected**|**Change 2023-2028**||
||||**Number**|**Percent**||**Number**|**Percent**||**Number**|**Percent**|
|**Morganton**|6,691|6,862|**171**|**2.6%**|6,887|**25**|**0.4%**|6,940|**53**|**0.8%**|
|**Burke County**|35,764|35,140|**-624**|**-1.7%**|35,602|**462**|**1.3%**|36,382|**780**|**2.2%**|
|**North Carolina**|3,745,143|4,160,856|**415,713**|**11.1%**|4,313,442|**152,586**|**3.7%**|4,462,411|**148,969**|**3.5%**|
|Source:  2010, 2020|Census; ESRI; NCOSBM; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National|||||Research|||||



Between 2010 and 2020, the number of households within the PSA (Burke County) decreased by 624 (1.7%). This contrasts with the 11.1% increase in the number of households for the state of North Carolina during this time period. Conversely, the number of households in the Morganton Submarket increased by 171 (2.6%) during this time period.  In 2023, there is an estimated total of 35,602 households in the PSA, with the Morganton Submarket accounting for 19.3% of the total households in Burke County. Between 2023 and 2028, the number of households in the PSA is projected to increase by 780 (2.2%), while households in the Morganton Submarket are projected to increase by 53 households (0.8%).  Regardless, these represent smaller increases in households as compared to the projected statewide increase (3.5%) over the next five years. 

While the projected increase in households within Burke County will have some effect on demand for housing in the market, household growth or decline alone does not dictate the total housing needs of a market. Other factors that influence housing needs, which are addressed throughout this report, include: households living in substandard or cost-burdened housing, commuting patterns, pent-up demand, availability of existing housing, and product in the development pipeline. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-12** 

~~**Packet Pg. 115**~~
{44}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following graphs compare household growth between 2010 and 2028: 

**==> picture [449 x 479] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Household Growth Trends (2010-2028)<br>Morganton Burke County North Carolina<br>12.0%<br>10.0% 11.1%<br>8.0%<br>6.0%<br>4.0%<br>2.2%<br>2.0% 1.3% 3.7% 3.5%<br>2.6% 0.4% 0.8%<br>0.0%<br>-1.7%<br>-2.0%<br>2010-2020 2020-2023 2023-2028<br>PSA (Burke County) Household Growth Trends (2010-2028)<br>36,500<br>36,382<br>36,250<br>36,000<br>35,764<br>35,750<br>35,602<br>35,500<br>35,250<br>35,140<br>35,000<br>2010 2020 2023 2028<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-13** 

~~**Packet Pg. 116**~~
{45}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Household heads by age cohorts for selected years are shown in the following table. Note that five-year projected declines are in red, while increases are in green: 

|||**Household Heads by Age**|**Household Heads by Age**|**Household Heads by Age**|**Household Heads by Age**|**Household Heads by Age**|**Household Heads by Age**|**Household Heads by Age**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|||**<25**|**25 to 34**|**35 to 44**|**45 to 54**|**55 to 64**|**65 to 74**|**75+**|
|**Morganton**|2010|306<br>(4.6%)|894<br>(13.4%)|1,046<br>(15.6%)|1,239<br>(18.5%)|1,225<br>(18.3%)|891<br>(13.3%)|1,090<br>(16.3%)|
||2023|257<br>(3.7%)|896<br>(13.0%)|1,038<br>(15.1%)|1,030<br>(15.0%)|1,186<br>(17.2%)|1,281<br>(18.6%)|1,199<br>(17.4%)|
||2028|268<br>(3.9%)|787<br>(11.3%)|1,094<br>(15.8%)|1,017<br>(14.7%)|1,111<br>(16.0%)|1,259<br>(18.1%)|1,404<br>(20.2%)|
||Change<br>2023-2028|**11**<br>**(4.3%)**|**-109**<br>**(-12.2%)**|**56**<br>**(5.4%)**|**-13**<br>**(-1.3%)**|**-75**<br>**(-6.3%)**|**-22**<br>**(-1.7%)**|**205**<br>**(17.1%)**|
|**Burke County**|2010|1,182<br>(3.3%)|4,034<br>(11.3%)|6,323<br>(17.7%)|7,592<br>(21.2%)|7,107<br>(19.9%)|5,216<br>(14.6%)|4,310<br>(12.1%)|
||2023|906<br>(2.5%)|4,286<br>(12.0%)|5,247<br>(14.7%)|6,037<br>(17.0%)|7,131<br>(20.0%)|6,905<br>(19.4%)|5,090<br>(14.3%)|
||2028|882<br>(2.4%)|3,778<br>(10.4%)|5,577<br>(15.3%)|5,802<br>(15.9%)|6,912<br>(19.0%)|7,103<br>(19.5%)|6,327<br>(17.4%)|
||Change<br>2023-2028|**-24**<br>**(-2.6%)**|**-508**<br>**(-11.8%)**|**331**<br>**(6.3%)**|**-234**<br>**(-3.9%)**|**-219**<br>**(-3.1%)**|**198**<br>**(2.9%)**|**1,236**<br>**(24.3%)**|
|**North Carolina**|2010|192,967<br>(5.2%)|588,691<br>(15.7%)|712,155<br>(19.0%)|771,236<br>(20.6%)|673,801<br>(18.0%)|443,532<br>(11.8%)|362,761<br>(9.7%)|
||2023|184,917<br>(4.3%)|659,949<br>(15.3%)|751,282<br>(17.4%)|732,949<br>(17.0%)|784,882<br>(18.2%)|714,147<br>(16.6%)|485,316<br>(11.3%)|
||2028|191,111<br>(4.3%)|648,223<br>(14.5%)|774,503<br>(17.4%)|738,911<br>(16.6%)|748,823<br>(16.8%)|746,808<br>(16.7%)|614,032<br>(13.8%)|
||Change<br>2023-2028|**6,194**<br>**(3.3%)**|**-11,726**<br>**(-1.8%)**|**23,221**<br>**(3.1%)**|**5,962**<br>**(0.8%)**|**-36,059**<br>**(-4.6%)**|**32,661**<br>**(4.6%)**|**128,716**<br>**(26.5%)**|



Source:  2010 Census; ESRI; NCOSBM; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research 

In 2023, household heads between the ages of 55 and 64 within the PSA (Burke County) comprise the largest share (20.0%) of all households in the PSA, closely followed by households between the ages of 65 and 74 (19.4%). Overall, senior households (age 55 and older) constitute over one-half (53.7%) of all households within the PSA. This represents a larger share of senior households when compared to the share within the state (46.1%). Household heads under the age of 35, which are typically more likely to be renters or firsttime homebuyers, comprise 14.5% of PSA households, while those between the ages of 35 and 54 account for 31.7% of Burke County households.  The distribution of households by age within the Morganton Submarket is similar to the overall PSA, with households ages 55 and older comprising 53.2% of all households in the submarket, and households under the age of 35 comprising 16.7% of households. 

Between 2023 and 2028, projections indicate significant household growth in the PSA among household heads ages 75 and older (24.3%). Households between the ages of 35 and 44 and those between the ages of 65 and 74 are projected to increase by 6.3% and 2.9%, respectively. All other age cohorts are projected to experience declines of at least 2.6% during this time period, with 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-14** 

~~**Packet Pg. 117**~~
{46}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

the largest percentage decline projected for the age cohort of 25 to 34 (11.8%). Although the projections for the Morganton Submarket are largely consistent with the PSA, it is noteworthy that households under the age of 25 are projected to increase by 4.3% in the submarket over the next five years. Similarly, the most significant increase of households by age within the Morganton Submarket over the next five years is projected to occur among households aged 75 and older, which is projected to increase by 17.1% between 2023 and 2028. The notable projected increase of households age 75 and older in the PSA and Morganton Submarket is generally consistent with projections for the state of North Carolina over the next five years. The aforementioned changes in households by age in the PSA will likely have an impact on the area housing market, particularly the demand for senior-oriented housing. 

The following graph illustrates the projected change in households by age. 

**==> picture [441 x 234] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
PSA (Burke County) Change in Household Heads by Age (2023-2028)<br><25 -24<br>25-34 -508<br>35-44 331<br>45-54 -234<br>55-64 -219<br>65-74 198<br>75+ 1,236<br>-600 -400 -200 0 200 400 600 800 1,000 1,200 1,400<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-15** 

~~**Packet Pg. 118**~~
{47}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Households by tenure (renters and owners) for selected years are shown in the following table. Note that 2028 numbers which represent a decrease from 2023 are illustrated in red text, while increases are illustrated in green text. 

|||**Households by Tenure**|**Households by Tenure**|**Households by Tenure**|**Households by Tenure**|**Households by Tenure**|**Households by Tenure**|**Households by Tenure**|**Households by Tenure**||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
||**Household Type**|**2000**||**2010**||**2023**||**2028**|||
|||**Number**|**Percent**|**Number**|**Percent**|**Number**|**Percent**|**Number**|**Percent**||
|**Morganton**|Owner-Occupied|3,955|57.7%|3,714|55.5%|4,176|60.6%|**4,211**|**60.7%**||
||Renter-Occupied|2,899|42.3%|2,978|44.5%|2,711|39.4%|**2,729**|**39.3%**||
||Total|6,854|100.0%|6,692|100.0%|6,887|100.0%|**6,940**|100.0%||
|**Burke County**|Owner-Occupied|25,581|74.1%|25,841|72.3%|27,300|76.7%|**28,124**|**77.3%**||
||Renter-Occupied|8,936|25.9%|9,923|27.7%|8,302|23.3%|**8,258**|**22.7%**||
||Total|34,517|100.0%|35,764|100.0%|35,602|100.0%|**36,382**|100.0%||
|**North**<br>**Carolina**|Owner-Occupied|2,172,355|69.4%|2,497,890|66.7%|2,852,254|66.1%|**2,965,382**|**66.5%**||
||Renter-Occupied|959,658|30.6%|1,247,253|33.3%|1,461,188|33.9%|**1,497,029**|**33.5%**||
||Total|3,132,013|100.0%|3,745,143|100.0%|4,313,442|100.0%|**4,462,411**|100.0%||



Source:  2000 Census; 2010 Census; ESRI; NCOSBM; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research 

In 2023, there is a 76.7% share of _owner_ households and a 23.3% share of _renter_ households in the PSA (Burke County). This represents a four-and-four-tenths percentage point (4.4) increase in the share of owner households in the PSA between 2010 and 2023. Owner households in the PSA comprise a notably higher share of the total households as compared to the corresponding share in the state (66.1%). Conversely, the share of owner households in the Morganton Submarket (60.6%), is considerably less than the PSA and statewide shares, illustrating the prevalence of renter-occupied households in the submarket. Between 2023 and 2028, the number of owner households in the PSA is projected to increase by 3.0% (824 households), while the number of renter households is projected to decrease by 0.5% (44 households).  Within the Morganton Submarket, owner households are projected to increase by 0.8% (35 households) over the next five years, while renter households are projected to increase by 0.7% (18 households).   Although these tenure projections will likely have an impact on the local housing market, recent changes in home mortgage interest rates and home construction costs, which have increased significantly, can greatly influence tenure projections. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-16** 

~~**Packet Pg. 119**~~
{48}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following graphs illustrate households by tenure for each study area and the state of North Carolina for 2023 and the households by tenure for the entirety of Burke County from 2000 and projected to 2028: 

**==> picture [441 x 462] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Households by Tenure (2023)<br>Owner-Occupied Renter-Occupied<br>100.0%<br>23.3%<br>33.9%<br>80.0% 39.4%<br>60.0%<br>40.0% 76.7%<br>66.1%<br>60.6%<br>20.0%<br>0.0%<br>Morganton Burke County North Carolina<br>Burke County (PSA) Households by Tenure (2000-2028)<br>Owner-Occupied Renter-Occupied<br>100.0%<br>25.9% 27.7% 23.3% 22.7%<br>80.0%<br>60.0%<br>40.0% 74.1% 72.3% 76.7% 77.3%<br>20.0%<br>0.0%<br>2000 2010 2023 2028<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-17** 

~~**Packet Pg. 120**~~
{49}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Median household income for selected years is shown in the following table: 

|**Morganton**<br>**Burke County**<br>**North Carolina**|**2010**<br>**Census**<br>$35,410<br>$35,210<br>$44,080|**2023**<br>**Estimated**<br>$47,913<br>$55,356<br>$65,879|**Median Household Income**<br>**% Change**<br>**2010-2023**<br>35.3%<br>57.2%<br>49.5%|**2028**<br>**Projected**<br>$52,921<br>$63,769<br>$76,213|**% Change**<br>**2023-2028**<br>10.5%<br>15.2%<br>15.7%|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|



Source:  2010 Census; ESRI; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research 

As the preceding table illustrates, the median household income for the PSA (Burke County) in 2023 is $55,356, which represents an increase of 57.2% over the median household income in 2010. The estimated median household income in the PSA in 2023 is approximately 16.0% lower than the median income for the state ($65,879).  Within the Morganton Submarket, the median household income of $47,913 in 2023 is 13.4% less than the median household income for Burke County and 27.3% lower than the statewide median household income. Between 2023 and 2028, it is projected that the median household income in the PSA will increase by 15.2%, at which time the median household income will be $63,769.  Within the Morganton Submarket, the median household income is projected to increase by 10.5% over the next five years, which is less than the projected increases for both the PSA and state of North Carolina during this time period.  As a result, the overall median household incomes for the PSA and the Morganton Submarket are expected to remain well below that of the state through 2028. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-18** 

~~**Packet Pg. 121**~~
{50}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The distribution of _renter_ households by income is illustrated in the following table. Note that declines between 2023 and 2028 are in red, while increases are in green: 

|**Morganton**<br>**Burke**<br>**County**<br>**North**<br>**Carolina**|2010<br>2023<br>2028<br>Change<br>2023-2028<br>2010<br>2023<br>2028<br>Change<br>2023-2028<br>2010<br>2023<br>2028<br>Change<br>2023-2028|**<$10,000**<br>618<br>(20.8%)<br>304<br>(11.2%)<br>256<br>(9.4%)<br>**-48**<br>**(-15.8%)**<br>2,011<br>(20.3%)<br>1,030<br>(12.4%)<br>848<br>(10.3%)<br>**-183**<br>**(-17.7%)**<br>195,552<br>(15.7%)<br>149,128<br>(10.2%)<br>128,610<br>(8.6%)<br>**-20,518**<br>**(-13.8%)**|**$10,000 -**<br>**$19,999**<br>776<br>(26.1%)<br>510<br>(18.8%)<br>471<br>(17.3%)<br>**-39**<br>**(-7.6%)**<br>2,674<br>(26.9%)<br>1,497<br>(18.0%)<br>1,320<br>(16.0%)<br>**-177**<br>**(-11.8%)**<br>268,561<br>(21.5%)<br>203,330<br>(13.9%)<br>173,781<br>(11.6%)<br>**-29,549**<br>**(-14.5%)**|**Renter Households by Income**<br>**$20,000 -**<br>**$29,999**<br>**$30,000 -**<br>**$39,999**<br>**$40,000 -**<br>**$49,999**<br>**$50,000 -**<br>**$59,999**<br>525<br>(17.6%)<br>364<br>(12.2%)<br>240<br>(8.1%)<br>147<br>(4.9%)<br>373<br>(13.7%)<br>421<br>(15.5%)<br>399<br>(14.7%)<br>167<br>(6.2%)<br>371<br>(13.6%)<br>455<br>(16.7%)<br>401<br>(14.7%)<br>179<br>(6.5%)<br>**-2**<br>**(-0.5%)**<br>**34**<br>**(8.1%)**<br>**2**<br>**(0.5%)**<br>**12**<br>**(7.2%)**<br>1,836<br>(18.5%)<br>1,200<br>(12.1%)<br>818<br>(8.2%)<br>500<br>(5.0%)<br>1,057<br>(12.7%)<br>1,258<br>(15.1%)<br>1,100<br>(13.3%)<br>532<br>(6.4%)<br>989<br>(12.0%)<br>1,419<br>(17.2%)<br>1,082<br>(13.1%)<br>547<br>(6.6%)<br>**-68**<br>**(-6.4%)**<br>**161**<br>**(12.8%)**<br>**-18**<br>**(-1.7%)**<br>**15**<br>**(2.8%)**<br>209,437<br>(16.8%)<br>164,848<br>(13.2%)<br>128,251<br>(10.3%)<br>77,774<br>(6.2%)<br>180,309<br>(12.3%)<br>168,451<br>(11.5%)<br>147,977<br>(10.1%)<br>116,217<br>(8.0%)<br>157,688<br>(10.5%)<br>155,884<br>(10.4%)<br>141,178<br>(9.4%)<br>121,807<br>(8.1%)<br>**-22,621**<br>**(-12.5%)**<br>**-12,567**<br>**(-7.5%)**<br>**-6,799**<br>**(-4.6%)**<br>**5,590**<br>**(4.8%)**|**$60,000 -**<br>**$99,999**<br>261<br>(8.8%)<br>414<br>(15.3%)<br>469<br>(17.2%)<br>**55**<br>**(13.3%)**<br>783<br>(7.9%)<br>1,410<br>(17.0%)<br>1,606<br>(19.5%)<br>**197**<br>**(14.0%)**<br>154,380<br>(12.4%)<br>300,185<br>(20.5%)<br>349,301<br>(23.3%)<br>**49,116**<br>**(16.4%)**|**$100,000+**<br>48<br>(1.6%)<br>122<br>(4.5%)<br>128<br>(4.7%)<br>**6**<br>**(4.9%)**<br>101<br>(1.0%)<br>418<br>(5.0%)<br>448<br>(5.4%)<br>**30**<br>**(7.1%)**<br>48,450<br>(3.9%)<br>195,587<br>(13.4%)<br>268,775<br>(18.0%)<br>**73,188**<br>**(37.4%)**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|



Source:  2010 Census; ESRI; NCOSBM; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research 

In 2023, approximately 43.1% of _renter_ households within the PSA (Burke County) earn less than $30,000 annually. This is a higher share of such households when compared to the state (36.4%). Approximately 34.8% of renter households in the PSA earn between $30,000 and $59,999 annually, while the remaining 22.0% of renter households earn $60,000 or more annually. This represents a notably smaller share of higher income renter households (earning $60,000 or more annually) than the share within the state (33.9%). Within the Morganton Submarket, the share (43.7%) of renter households earning less than $30,000 annually is slightly higher than the share within the PSA.  Approximately, 36.4% of renter households in the Morganton Submarket earn between $30,000 and $59,999, while the remaining 19.8% earn $60,000 or more.   As such, the overall distribution of renter households by income within the PSA and Morganton Submarket is more heavily concentrated among the lower- and middle-income cohorts as compared to the state. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-19** 

~~**Packet Pg. 122**~~
{51}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Between 2023 and 2028, all renter household income cohorts earning less than $30,000 in the PSA are projected to decrease, while a majority of the income cohorts earning more than $30,000 are projected to increase. The largest increase (14.0%) of renter households by income in the PSA over the next five years is projected among those earning between $60,000 and $99,999, although a noteworthy increase is also projected for renter households earning between $30,000 and $39,999 (12.8%).  The projected changes of renter households by income within the Morganton Submarket are similar, with substantial declines projected in the lowest income cohorts and notable increases among the moderate- and higher-income cohorts. The projections for the PSA differ from statewide projections in that renter household growth at the state level is confined to households earning $50,000 or more.  While the increase among higher earning renter households in the PSA and the Morganton Submarket over the next five years likely indicates an increase in demand for premium rental product, it is critical to understand that nearly 40% of renter households in the PSA will continue to earn less than $30,000 annually.  As such, the need for affordable rental alternatives will persist within Burke County. 

The following table shows the distribution of _owner_ households by income. Note that declines between 2023 and 2028 are in red, while increases are in green: 

|**Morganton**<br>**Burke**<br>**County**<br>**North**<br>**Carolina**|2010<br>2023<br>2028<br>Change<br>2023-2028<br>2010<br>2023<br>2028<br>Change<br>2023-2028<br>2010<br>2023<br>2028<br>Change<br>2023-2028|**<$10,000**<br>190<br>(5.1%)<br>155<br>(3.7%)<br>139<br>(3.3%)<br>**-16**<br>**(-10.3%)**<br>1,832<br>(7.1%)<br>1,224<br>(4.5%)<br>1,096<br>(3.9%)<br>**-128**<br>**(-10.4%)**<br>131,928<br>(5.3%)<br>95,952<br>(3.4%)<br>86,397<br>(2.9%)<br>**-9,555**<br>**(-10.0%)**|**$10,000 -**<br>**$19,999**<br>357<br>(9.6%)<br>315<br>(7.5%)<br>289<br>(6.9%)<br>**-26**<br>**(-8.3%)**<br>3,338<br>(12.9%)<br>2,098<br>(7.7%)<br>1,895<br>(6.7%)<br>**-202**<br>**(-9.6%)**<br>229,206<br>(9.2%)<br>156,733<br>(5.5%)<br>137,207<br>(4.6%)<br>**-19,526**<br>**(-12.5%)**|**Owner Households by Income**<br>**$20,000 -**<br>**$29,999**<br>**$30,000 -**<br>**$39,999**<br>**$40,000 -**<br>**$49,999**<br>**$50,000 -**<br>**$59,999**<br>444<br>(12.0%)<br>441<br>(11.9%)<br>348<br>(9.4%)<br>386<br>(10.4%)<br>264<br>(6.3%)<br>383<br>(9.2%)<br>509<br>(12.2%)<br>347<br>(8.3%)<br>201<br>(4.8%)<br>307<br>(7.3%)<br>428<br>(10.2%)<br>343<br>(8.2%)<br>**-63**<br>**(-23.9%)**<br>**-76**<br>**(-19.8%)**<br>**-81**<br>**(-15.9%)**<br>**-4**<br>**(-1.2%)**<br>3,800<br>(14.7%)<br>3,389<br>(13.1%)<br>2,705<br>(10.5%)<br>2,855<br>(11.0%)<br>1,670<br>(6.1%)<br>2,470<br>(9.0%)<br>2,927<br>(10.7%)<br>2,213<br>(8.1%)<br>1,282<br>(4.6%)<br>2,198<br>(7.8%)<br>2,492<br>(8.9%)<br>2,136<br>(7.6%)<br>**-388**<br>**(-23.2%)**<br>**-272**<br>**(-11.0%)**<br>**-435**<br>**(-14.9%)**<br>**-77**<br>**(-3.5%)**<br>255,998<br>(10.2%)<br>264,219<br>(10.6%)<br>246,324<br>(9.9%)<br>235,866<br>(9.4%)<br>178,373<br>(6.3%)<br>194,099<br>(6.8%)<br>187,449<br>(6.6%)<br>214,012<br>(7.5%)<br>152,591<br>(5.1%)<br>167,481<br>(5.6%)<br>162,337<br>(5.5%)<br>196,584<br>(6.6%)<br>**-25,782**<br>**(-14.5%)**<br>**-26,618**<br>**(-13.7%)**<br>**-25,112**<br>**(-13.4%)**<br>**-17,428**<br>**(-8.1%)**|**$60,000 -**<br>**$99,999**<br>872<br>(23.5%)<br>1,014<br>(24.3%)<br>1,037<br>(24.6%)<br>**23**<br>**(2.3%)**<br>5,438<br>(21.0%)<br>6,919<br>(25.3%)<br>7,209<br>(25.6%)<br>**289**<br>**(4.2%)**<br>610,174<br>(24.4%)<br>676,694<br>(23.7%)<br>658,932<br>(22.2%)<br>**-17,762**<br>**(-2.6%)**|**$100,000+**<br>674<br>(18.2%)<br>1,190<br>(28.5%)<br>1,467<br>(34.8%)<br>**277**<br>**(23.3%)**<br>2,484<br>(9.6%)<br>7,780<br>(28.5%)<br>9,815<br>(34.9%)<br>**2,035**<br>**(26.2%)**<br>524,175<br>(21.0%)<br>1,148,924<br>(40.3%)<br>1,403,835<br>(47.3%)<br>**254,911**<br>**(22.2%)**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|



Source:  2010 Census; ESRI; NCOSBM; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-20** 

~~**Packet Pg. 123**~~
{52}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

In 2023, over one-half (53.8%) of _owner_ households in the PSA (Burke County) earn $60,000 or more annually, which represents a smaller share as compared to the state (64.0%). Approximately 18.3% of owner households in the PSA earn less than $30,000 annually, while 27.8% earn between $30,000 and $59,999. As such, the overall distribution of owner households by income in the PSA is much more heavily weighted toward the lower- and moderateincome cohorts compared to that within the state. Within the Morganton Submarket, the distribution of owner households by income is very similar to the PSA.  Specifically, 17.5% of owner households earn less than $30,000 annually, 29.7% earn between $30,000 and $59,999, and 52.8% earn $60,000 or more annually. 

Between 2023 and 2028, projected growth among owner households in the PSA is isolated to those earning $60,000 or more annually, with households earning $100,000 or more increasing by 26.2% in the PSA. All owner income cohorts earning less than $60,000 are projected to decline in the PSA during this time, with the most notable decrease (23.2%) projected to occur in the cohort earning between $20,000 and $29,999 annually. Similar trends are projected within the Morganton Submarket, with owner households earning $100,000 or more projected to increase by 23.3% over the next five years.  Overall, these projections for the PSA and Morganton Submarket are generally consistent with statewide projections during the time period. With the overall number of owner households in the PSA projected to increase by 0.8% between 2023 and 2028 and a notable shift in the distribution of owner households by income toward the higher earning cohorts, these projected changes should be considered when evaluating the for-sale housing market in Burke County. 

The following graph illustrates household income growth by tenure for Burke County between 2023 and 2028. 

**==> picture [428 x 220] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Burke Co. (PSA) Change in Households by Tenure & Income (2023-2028)<br>Renter Owner<br><$20,000 -360<br>-330<br>$20k-$29,999 -68<br>-388<br>$30k-$39,999 161<br>-272<br>$40k-$49,999 -18<br>-435<br>$50k-$59,999 15<br>-77<br>$60k-$99,999 197<br>289<br>$100,000+ 30<br>2,035<br>-500 -250 0 250 500 750 1,000 1,250 1,500 1,750 2,000 2,250<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-21** 

~~**Packet Pg. 124**~~
{53}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **D. DEMOGRAPHIC THEME MAPS** 

The following demographic theme maps for the study area are presented after this page: 

- Median Household Income 

- Renter Household Share 

- Owner Household Share 

- Older Adult Population Share (55 + years) 

- Younger Adult Population Share (20 to 34 years) 

- Population Density 

The demographic data used in these maps is based on U.S. Census, American Community Survey (ACS) and ESRI data sets. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IV-22** 

~~**Packet Pg. 125**~~
{54}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [55 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.2.b<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [19 x 516] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [91 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Packet Pg. 126<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>
{55}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [55 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.2.b<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Packet Pg. 127**
{56}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**==> picture [91 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Packet Pg. 128<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>
{57}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**==> picture [91 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Packet Pg. 129<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>
{58}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 130**
{59}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**==> picture [91 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Packet Pg. 131<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>
{60}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **V.   ECONOMIC ANALYSIS** 

## **A. INTRODUCTION** 

The need for housing within a given geographic area is influenced by the number of households choosing to live there. Although the number of households in the subject area at any given time is a function of many factors, one of the primary reasons for residency is job availability. In this section, the workforce and employment trends that affect the PSA (Burke County) and the select submarket are examined and compared to the state of North Carolina and the United States. 

An overview of the Burke County workforce is provided through several overall metrics: employment by industry, wages by occupation, total employment, unemployment rates and at-place employment trends. We also evaluated the area’s largest employers, economic and infrastructure developments, and the potential for significant closures or layoffs in the area (WARN notices). In addition, commuting patterns for the PSA, which include commuting modes, times, and county-to-county commuter flows are analyzed. 

## **B. WORKFORCE ANALYSIS** 

The PSA has an employment base comprised of individuals within a broad range of employment sectors. The primary industries of significance within the PSA include manufacturing, health care and social assistance, retail trade, public administration, and accommodation and food services. Each industry within the PSA requires employees of varying skill and education levels, and there is a broad range of typical wages within the PSA based on occupation. The following evaluates key economic metrics within Burke County. It should be noted that based on the availability of various economic data metrics, some information is presented only for select geographic areas, which may include the PSA (Burke County), the Morganton Submarket, the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA), and/or the state of North Carolina, depending upon the availability of such data. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-1** 

~~**Packet Pg. 132**~~
{61}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## Employment by Industry 

The following table illustrates the distribution of employment by industry sector for the various study areas (note that the top five industry groups by employment for each area are illustrated in **red** text). 

||**Employment by Industry**|**Employment by Industry**|**Employment by Industry**|**Employment by Industry**|**Employment by Industry**|**Employment by Industry**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**NAICS Group**|**Morganton**||**PSA (Burke County)**||**North Carolina**||
||**Employees**|**Percent**|**Employees**|**Percent**|**Employees**|**Percent**|
|Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing & Hunting|2|0.0%|81|0.2%|25,956|0.6%|
|Mining|4|0.0%|14|0.0%|3,118|0.1%|
|Utilities|36|0.2%|52|0.2%|21,553|0.5%|
|Construction|280|1.6%|893|2.7%|227,264|5.0%|
|Manufacturing|**2,926**|**16.6%**|**6,275**|**19.0%**|**410,949**|**9.0%**|
|Wholesale Trade|350|2.0%|955|2.9%|185,068|4.1%|
|Retail Trade|**2,212**|**12.6%**|**3,880**|**11.8%**|**607,688**|**13.3%**|
|Transportation & Warehousing|90|0.5%|268|0.8%|104,390|2.3%|
|Information|132|0.8%|231|0.7%|110,199|2.4%|
|Finance & Insurance|419|2.4%|597|1.8%|137,360|3.0%|
|Real Estate & Rental & Leasing|256|1.5%|369|1.1%|131,253|2.9%|
|Professional, Scientific & Technical Services|**1,685**|**9.6%**|1,891|5.7%|280,489|6.1%|
|Management of Companies & Enterprises|6|0.0%|18|0.1%|11,825|0.3%|
|Administrative, Support, Waste Management &<br>Remediation Services|112|0.6%|303|0.9%|99,111|2.2%|
|Educational Services|1,122|6.4%|2,710|8.2%|**359,835**|**7.9%**|
|Health Care & Social Assistance|**3,032**|**17.2%**|**5,314**|**16.1%**|**714,436**|**15.6%**|
|Arts, Entertainment & Recreation|179|1.0%|524|1.6%|82,250|1.8%|
|Accommodation & Food Services|**1,672**|**9.5%**|**2,840**|**8.6%**|**439,038**|**9.6%**|
|Other Services (Except Public Administration)|1,499|8.5%|2,792|8.5%|283,769|6.2%|
|Public Administration|1,526|8.7%|**2,856**|**8.7%**|303,078|6.6%|
|Non-classifiable|58|0.3%|79|0.2%|28,041|0.6%|
|Total|17,598|100.0%|32,942|100.0%|4,566,670|100.0%|



Source: 2010 Census; ESRI; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research 

Note: Since this survey is conducted of establishments and not of residents, some employees may not live within each market. These employees, however, are included in our labor force calculations because their places of employment are located within each market. 

The labor force within the PSA (Burke County) is based primarily in five sectors: Manufacturing (19.0%), Health Care & Social Assistance (16.1%), Retail Trade (11.8%), Public Administration (8.7%), and Accommodation & Food Services (8.6%). Combined, these five job sectors represent 64.2% of the PSA employment base. This represents a greater concentration of employment within the top five sectors compared to the top five sectors in the state (55.4%). Areas with a heavy concentration of employment within a limited number of industries can be more vulnerable to economic downturns with greater fluctuations in unemployment rates and total employment. With a greater concentration of employment and three of the top sectors in the PSA (manufacturing, retail trade, and accommodation and food services) being somewhat more vulnerable to downturns, the economy within Burke County is likely less insulated from economic fluctuations as compared to the state. It is also important to note that many occupations within the top industries of the PSA typically have lower average wages which can contribute to demand for affordable housing options. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-2** 

~~**Packet Pg. 133**~~
{62}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Within the Morganton Submarket, 65.5% of the total employment is within the top five sectors.  While Health Care & Social Assistance (17.2%), Manufacturing (16.6%), Retail Trade (12.6%), and Accommodation & Food Services (9.5%) are also among the top sectors of employment within the Morganton Submarket, it is noteworthy that Professional, Scientific & Technical Services (9.6%) is among the top five sectors within this area. Regardless, over one-half (53.4%) of the total employment in the PSA is within the Morganton Submarket, which illustrates the economic importance of this area for Burke County. 

The following graph illustrates the distribution of employment by job sector for the five largest employment sectors in the PSA (Burke County) and the state of North Carolina: 

**==> picture [449 x 241] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Top 5 Employment by Industry<br>Burke Co. North Carolina<br>20.0%<br>19.0%<br>15.0%<br>16.1%<br>15.6%<br>13.3%<br>10.0% 11.8%<br>9.6%<br>9.0% 8.7% 8.6%<br>6.6%<br>5.0%<br>0.0%<br>Manufacturing Health Care & Retail Trade Public Admin. Accom. & Food<br>Social Assist. Services<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-3** 

~~**Packet Pg. 134**~~
{63}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## Employment Characteristics and Trends 

Burke County is in the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA). Typical wages by job category for the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton Metropolitan Statistical Area are compared with those of North Carolina in the following table: 

|**Typical Wage by Occupation Type**|**Typical Wage by Occupation Type**|**Typical Wage by Occupation Type**|
|---|---|---|
|**Occupation Type**|**Hickory-Lenoir-**<br>**Morganton MSA**|**North Carolina**|
|Management Occupations|$110,910|$126,640|
|Business and Financial Occupations|$69,350|$82,730|
|Computer and Mathematical Occupations|$91,990|$104,530|
|Architecture and Engineering Occupations|$75,600|$85,090|
|Community and Social Service Occupations|$49,930|$51,620|
|Art, Design, Entertainment and Sports Medicine Occupations|$60,700|$66,670|
|Healthcare Practitioners and Technical Occupations|$84,700|$87,180|
|Healthcare Support Occupations|$31,950|$33,240|
|Protective Service Occupations|$40,170|$42,860|
|Food Preparation and Serving Related Occupations|$26,790|$28,190|
|Building and Grounds Cleaning and Maintenance Occupations|$30,350|$31,760|
|Personal Care and Service Occupations|$30,930|$33,440|
|Sales and Related Occupations|$40,510|$47,660|
|Office and Administrative Support Occupations|$39,290|$41,880|
|Construction and Extraction Occupations|$45,230|$47,720|
|Installation, Maintenance and Repair Occupations|$49,090|$52,160|
|Production Occupations|$40,390|$41,140|
|TransportationandMoving Occupations|$39,900|$38,520|



Source: U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Statistics 

Most annual blue-collar salaries range from $26,790 to $60,700 within the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton MSA. White-collar jobs, such as those related to professional positions, management and medicine, have an average salary of $86,510. Average wages within the area are typically 8.2% lower than the overall average state wages. White-collar professions in the study area typically earn 11.0% less than those within North Carolina, while blue-collar wages are typically 5.7% less than the average state wages. Within the MSA, wages by occupation vary widely and are reflective of a diverse job base that covers a wide range of industry sectors and job skills, as well as diverse levels of education and experience. Because employment is distributed among a variety of professions with diverse income levels, there are likely a variety of housing needs by affordability level. As a significant share of the labor force within Burke County is contained within manufacturing, healthcare, retail trade, accommodation and food services, and public administration, many workers in the area have typical wages ranging between approximately $25,000 and $40,000 annually, likely contributing to the need for lower priced housing product in the county. It is important to point out that the wages cited above are by single wage-earning households, and multiple wage-earning households often have a greater capacity to spend earnings toward housing than single wage earners. Households by income data is included starting on page IV-18. 

~~**Packet Pg. 135**~~ 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-4**
{64}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

In an effort to better understand how area wages by occupation affect housing affordability, wages for the top 35 occupations by share of total employment within the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA) were analyzed. While this data does not include every possible occupation and wage within each sector and is not specific to just Burke County (includes Alexander, Burke, Caldwell and Catawba counties), the occupations included in this table represent over one-half (50.2%) of the total employment in the MSA in 2022 and provide a general overview of housing affordability for some of the most common occupations in the region. Based on the annual wages at the lower quartile (bottom 25%) and median levels, the maximum affordable monthly rent and home price (at 30% of income) for each occupation was calculated. It is important to note that calculations based on the median annual wage mean that half of the individuals employed in this occupation earn less than the stated amount. It is equally important to understand that the supplied data is based on _individual_ income. As such, affordability levels will proportionally increase for households with multiple income sources at a rate dependent on the additional income. Affordable rents and home prices for each occupation presented in this analysis that are **below** the two-bedroom Fair Market Rent ($791) or the overall median list price ($289,000) of the available for-sale inventory in the PSA (Burke County) as of October 31, 2023, are shown in **red** text, indicating that certain lower-wage earning occupations cannot reasonably afford a typical housing unit in the market. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-5** 

~~**Packet Pg. 136**~~
{65}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following table illustrates the wages (lower quartile and median) and housing affordability levels for the top 35 occupations in the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA). 

|||||||||||~~**3.2.b**~~|~~**3.2.b**~~|~~**3.2.b**~~|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|The following table illustrates the wages (lower quartile and median) and housing<br>affordability levels for the top 35 occupations in the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton<br>Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA).<br>~~**..**~~||||||||||~~**..**~~|||
|||||||||||||**Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen National Research Housing Study)**|
||**Wages and Housing Affordability for Top 35 Occupations by Share of Labor Force**||||||||||||
||**Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA)**||||||||||||
||**Occupation Sector, Title & Wages***||||**Housing Affordability****||||||||
|**Sector Group**<br>**(Code)**|**Labor**<br>**Force**<br>**Share**|**Occupation Title**|**Annual Wages**||**Max. Monthly Rent**||**Max. Purchase Price**||||||
||||**Lower**<br>**Quartile**|**Median**|**Lower**<br>**Quartile**|**Median**|**Lower**<br>**Quartile**||**Median**||||
|Sales & Related<br>Occupations<br>(41)|2.6%|Cashiers|$21,030|$22,880|**$526**|**$572**|**$70,100**||**$76,267**||||
||2.3%|Retail Salespersons|$22,870|$27,560|**$572**|**$689**|**$76,233**||**$91,867**||||
||1.1%|Sales Reps, Wholesale/Mfg.|$39,010|$53,140|$975|$1,329|**$130,033**||**$177,133**||||
||0.8%|First-Line Supervisors,Retail|$33,430|$41,280|$836|$1,032|**$111,433**||**$137,600**||||
|Food<br>Preparation/<br>Serving (35)|2.0%|Cooks, Fast Food|$20,110|$22,150|**$503**|**$554**|**$67,033**||**$73,833**||||
||1.2%|Waiters/Waitresses|$17,270|$20,380|**$432**|**$510**|**$57,567**||**$67,933**||||
||1.2%|Fast Food and Counter Workers|$19,260|$22,050|**$482**|**$551**|**$64,200**||**$73,500**||||
||0.8%|Cooks, Restaurant|$23,990|$28,530|**$600**|**$713**|**$79,967**||**$95,100**||||
||0.8%|First-Line Supervisors,Food Prep|$28,050|$34,160|**$701**|$854|**$93,500**||**$113,867**||||
|Office and<br>Administrative<br>Support (43)|1.5%|Customer Services Reps.|$27,650|$33,540|**$691**|$839|**$92,167**||**$111,800**||||
||1.4%|Office Clerks, General|$28,410|$33,400|**$710**|$835|**$94,700**||**$111,333**||||
||1.1%|Shipping/Receiving Clerks|$30,440|$35,420|**$761**|$886|**$101,467**||**$118,067**||||
||0.9%|First-Line Supervisors, Office|$44,170|$53,120|$1,104|$1,328|**$147,233**||**$177,067**||||
||0.9%|Bookkeeping/Accounting Clerks|$31,990|$39,020|$800|$976|**$106,633**||**$130,067**||||
||0.9%|Secretaries/Administrative Assts.|$33,440|$38,200|$836|$955|**$111,467**||**$127,333**||||
||0.7%|Receptionists/Information Clerks|$27,630|$30,360|**$691**|**$759**|**$92,100**||**$101,200**||||
|Transportation<br>Material<br>Moving (53)|3.9%|Laborers/Stock/Material Movers|$31,180|$37,540|**$780**|$939|**$103,933**||**$125,133**||||
||2.4%|Heavy/Tractor-Trailer Drivers|$43,200|$50,480|$1,080|$1,262|**$144,000**||**$168,267**||||
||2.0%|Stockers/Order Fillers|$26,680|$30,190|**$667**|**$755**|**$88,933**||**$100,633**||||
||1.0%|Light Truck Drivers|$28,700|$36,710|**$718**|$918|**$95,667**||**$122,367**||||
||0.7%|Packagers,Hand|$28,420|$32,280|**$711**|$807|**$94,733**||**$107,600**||||
|Production<br>Occupations<br>(51)|2.7%|Misc. Assemblers/Fabricators|$31,100|$36,640|**$778**|$916|**$103,667**||**$122,133**||||
||1.8%|Upholsterers|$38,970|$48,780|$974|$1,220|**$129,900**||**$162,600**||||
||1.6%|Sewing Machine Operators|$30,500|$38,410|**$763**|$960|**$101,667**||**$128,033**||||
||1.2%|Inspectors/Samplers/Testers|$31,490|$36,130|**$787**|$903|**$104,967**||**$120,433**||||
||1.1%|First-Line Supervisors, Production|$46,850|$59,690|$1,171|$1,492|**$156,167**||**$198,967**||||
||1.1%|Electrical Assemblers|$38,950|$44,280|$974|$1,107|**$129,833**||**$147,600**||||
|Education/<br>Library (25)|1.3%|Elementary School Teachers|$38,760|$47,980|$969|$1,200|**$129,200**||**$159,933**||||
|Healthcare<br>(29, 31)|2.0%|Registered Nurses|$61,270|$65,830|$1,532|$1,646|**$204,233**||**$219,433**||||
||1.8%|Nursing Assistants|$27,970|$32,430|**$699**|$811|**$93,233**||**$108,100**||||
||1.4%|Home Health/Personal Aides|$22,570|$24,830|**$564**|**$621**|**$75,233**||**$82,767**||||
|Management/<br>Business<br>(11,13)|1.5%|General/Operations Managers|$61,060|$92,070|$1,527|$2,302|**$203,533**||$306,900||||
||0.6%|Accountants/Auditors|$55,550|$68,840|$1,389|$1,721|**$185,167**||**$229,467**||||
|Maintenance/<br>Repair(49)|1.1%|Maintenance/Repair Workers|$34,530|$42,020|$863|$1,051|**$115,100**||**$140,067**||||
|Bldg./Grounds<br>Maintenance(37)|0.8%|Janitors/Cleaners|$24,170|$27,790|**$604**|**$695**|**$80,567**||**$92,633**||||
|**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH**<br>**V-6**<br>Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, May 2022 Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS)<br>*Annual wages listed are at the lower 25thpercentile (quartile) and median level for each occupation<br>**Housing Affordability is the maximum monthly rent or total for-sale home price a household can reasonably afford based on stated wages.<br>|||||||||||||
||||||||||||||
||||||||||||||



Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, May 2022 Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS) *Annual wages listed are at the lower 25[th] percentile (quartile) and median level for each occupation 

**Housing Affordability is the maximum monthly rent or total for-sale home price a household can reasonably afford based on stated wages. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-6** 

~~**Packet Pg. 137**~~
{66}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

In order to reasonably afford a two-bedroom rental at the Fair Market Rent of $791, an individual would need to earn at least $31,640 per year. As such, the _lower quartile_ of wage earners within 21 of the 35 occupations listed in the previous table do not have sufficient wages to afford a typical rental. Many of these occupations, particularly those within the food services and retail industries and support positions within various sectors, earn significantly less than the amount required to afford a typical rental in the market. When wages for each occupation are increased to their respective _median_ levels, 10 occupations still do not have the income necessary to afford a typical rental. While a share of these individuals likely lives in multiple-income households, this illustrates the reasonable conclusion that a significant portion of households with a single income earned in a variety of occupations in the PSA are likely housing cost burdened. 

Housing affordability issues among the listed occupations are more prevalent when home ownership is considered. In order to afford the purchase of a typical home in the PSA at the median list price of $289,000, an individual would have to earn at least $86,700 per year. As such, only one occupation with wages up to the median wage among the top 35 occupations has sufficient income to afford the purchase of a typical home in the PSA. As previously stated, it is likely that many of these individuals are part of multiple-income households. However, even if a household or person had double the single wage earner incomes of the median wages shown in the preceding table, 25 occupations would not be able to afford a home at the current median list price of $289,000. This illustrates that home ownership is not affordable for a significant share of workers in the most common occupations in the PSA. 

A full analysis of the area housing supply, which includes multifamily apartments, current and historical for-sale product, and non-conventional rentals (typically four units or less within a structure), is included in Section VI of this report. A lack of affordable workforce housing in a market can limit the ability of employers to retain and attract new employees, which can affect the performance of specific industries, the local economy, and household growth within an area. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-7** 

~~**Packet Pg. 138**~~
{67}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## Employment Base and Unemployment Rates 

Total employment reflects the number of employed persons who live within an area regardless of where they work. The following illustrates the total employment base for Burke County, the state of North Carolina, and the United States. 

||**Total Employment**|**Total Employment**|**Total Employment**|**Total Employment**|**Total Employment**|**Total Employment**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
||**Burke County**||**North Carolina**||**United States**||
|**Year**|**Total**<br>**Number**|**Percent**<br>**Change**|**Total**<br>**Number**|**Percent**<br>**Change**|**Total**<br>**Number**|**Percent**<br>**Change**|
|2013|36,937|-|4,336,379|-|144,904,568|-|
|2014|36,989|0.1%|4,410,647|1.7%|147,293,817|1.6%|
|2015|37,103|0.3%|4,493,882|1.9%|149,540,791|1.5%|
|2016|37,798|1.9%|4,598,456|2.3%|151,934,228|1.6%|
|2017|38,249|1.2%|4,646,212|1.0%|154,721,780|1.8%|
|2018|38,756|1.3%|4,715,616|1.5%|156,709,676|1.3%|
|2019|38,882|0.3%|4,801,094|1.8%|158,806,261|1.3%|
|2020|35,796|-7.9%|4,491,749|-6.4%|149,462,904|-5.9%|
|2021|37,656|5.2%|4,712,866|4.9%|154,624,092|3.5%|
|2022|39,563|5.1%|4,970,998|5.5%|159,884,649|3.4%|
|2023*|39,809|0.6%|5,046,123|1.5%|161,889,759|1.3%|



Source: Department of Labor; Bureau of Labor Statistics 

*Through August 

- From 2013 to 2019, total employment in the PSA (Burke County) increased by 5.3%, or 1,945 employees, which represents a much smaller rate increase than the state (10.7%) and nation (9.6%) during this time period. In 2020, total employment in the PSA decreased by 7.9%, which reflects a rate of _reduction_ above that for the state (6.4%) and nation (5.9%) during that year. This reduction in total employment during 2020 is primarily attributed to the economic impacts related to the COVID-19 pandemic. Following the end of many of the restrictions associated with the pandemic, total employment in the PSA increased by 5.2% in 2021 and 5.1% in 2022, which are larger than the nationwide increases (3.5% and 3.4%) for these two years, respectively. Through August 2023, total employment in the PSA is at 102.4% of the 2019 level, representing a full recovery and subsequent growth in total employment since the impact of the pandemic. 

**==> picture [438 x 153] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Burke County Total Employment (2013-2023*)<br>40,000<br>39,500<br>39,000<br>38,500<br>38,000<br>37,500<br>37,000<br>36,500<br>36,000<br>35,500<br>2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023*<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


*Through August 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-8** 

~~**Packet Pg. 139**~~
{68}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Unemployment rates for Burke County, the state of North Carolina and the United States are illustrated as follows: 

||**Unemployment Rate**|**Unemployment Rate**|**Unemployment Rate**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Year**|**Burke County**|**North Carolina**|**United States**|
|2013|8.1%|7.8%|7.4%|
|2014|6.0%|6.1%|6.2%|
|2015|5.6%|5.7%|5.3%|
|2016|4.9%|5.1%|4.9%|
|2017|4.2%|4.5%|4.4%|
|2018|3.7%|4.0%|3.9%|
|2019|3.7%|3.9%|3.7%|
|2020|7.1%|7.2%|8.1%|
|2021|4.6%|4.9%|5.4%|
|2022|3.5%|3.7%|3.7%|
|2023*|3.3%|3.5%|3.7%|



Source: Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics *Through August 

Between 2013 and 2019, unemployment rates in the county steadily decreased year over year, from a high of 8.1% in 2013 to a low of 3.7% in 2019. It is noteworthy that the unemployment rates in the PSA were lower than the statewide unemployment rate in each year from 2014 to 2019. In 2020, unemployment increased to 7.1% in the PSA, largely due to the impacts of the pandemic. However, this represents a lower rate than both the state (7.2%) and nation (8.1%) at this time. The unemployment rate within the county has declined since and is currently averaging 3.3% through August 2023, which is the lowest unemployment rate in the county since 2013 and lower than both the state (3.5%) and national (3.7%) unemployment rates. This is a positive economic indicator for the PSA and illustrates a thriving local economy. 

**==> picture [453 x 208] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Unemployment Rate (2013-2023*)<br>Burke Co. North Carolina U.S.<br>9.0%<br>8.0%<br>7.0%<br>6.0%<br>5.0%<br>4.0%<br>3.0%<br>2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023*<br>*Through August<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-9** 

~~**Packet Pg. 140**~~
{69}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

We evaluated monthly unemployment rates in order to get a better sense of the initial impact the COVID-19 pandemic had on the local economy and the subsequent recovery. The following table illustrates the monthly unemployment rates from January 2020 to August 2023 for the PSA: 

**==> picture [374 x 169] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
-<br>Burke County   Monthly Unemployment Rate<br>Month  2020  2021  2022  2023<br>January  3.7%  5.8%  3.7%  3.3%<br>February  3.5%  5.6%  3.5%  3.3%<br>March  4.4%  5.1%  3.2%  3.2%<br>April  16.6%  4.7%  3.0%  2.9%<br>May  12.6%  5.0%  3.4%  3.4%<br>June  9.0%  5.3%  3.9%  3.6%<br>July  8.4%  4.8%  3.6%  3.5%<br>August  6.1%  4.6%  3.9%  3.5%<br>September  5.9%  4.0%  3.3%<br>October  5.1%  4.0%  3.6%<br>November  5.1%  3.7%  3.4%<br>December  5.3%  3.1%  2.9%<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Source: Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics 

Prior to April 2020, which was the month when COVID-19 stay-at-home orders began to impact many non-essential businesses, the monthly unemployment rate in the PSA (Burke County) ranged between 3.5% and 4.4% in early 2020. In April 2020, the rate increased sharply to 16.6%. While the monthly unemployment rate steadily declined in the PSA since this time, it remained historically high well into 2021.  Since November 2021, the unemployment rate in the PSA has remained below 4% each month, and in 2023, the unemployment rate has been 3.6% or lower in each of the eight months reported. 

At-place employment reflects the total number of jobs within the county regardless of the employee's county of residence. The following illustrates the total at-place employment base for Burke County: 

||**At-Place Employment Burke County**|**At-Place Employment Burke County**|**At-Place Employment Burke County**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Year**|**Employment**|**Change**|**Percent Change**|
|2013|29,331|-|-|
|2014|29,378|47|0.2%|
|2015|29,517|139|0.5%|
|2016|29,387|-130|-0.4%|
|2017|29,545|158|0.5%|
|2018|29,165|-380|-1.3%|
|2019|29,772|607|2.1%|
|2020|28,501|-1,271|-4.3%|
|2021|28,961|460|1.6%|
|2022|29,145|184|0.6%|
|2023*|29,363|218|0.7%|



Source: Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics *Through March 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-10** 

~~**Packet Pg. 141**~~
{70}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The preceding table illustrates at-place employment (people working within Burke County) increased by 1.5%, or 441 jobs, from 2013 to 2019.  Prior to the COVID-19 related decrease (4.3%) in 2020, there was a significant increase (2.1%) in at-place employment within Burke County in 2019.  While at-place employment through March 2023 remains at 98.6% of the 2019 level, notable increases have occurred in each of the three recent reporting periods.  While this indicates that some economic challenges may persist from the pandemic, the local economy appears to have recovered well from the pandemic and most economic indicators are positive. 

Data for 2022, the most recent year that year-end figures are available, indicates at-place employment in Burke County to be 73.7% of the total Burke County employment. This means that there are more employed residents of the county than there are jobs located within the county. A significant number of residents seeking employment outside a subject area, particularly those with lengthy commutes, can increase the likelihood of residents relocating outside the county. Detailed commuting data, which includes modes, times, and an inflow/outflow analysis, is included later in this section. 

Based on the preceding analysis, the economy in the PSA appears to be experiencing notable growth.  While at-place employment has recovered to 98.6% of the 2019 level, total employment is currently at 102.4% of the 2019 level and the annual unemployment rate through August 2023 is at 3.3%.  Overall, it appears the economy in Burke County and the Morganton Submarket is wellpositioned and currently does not exhibit any notable weakness.  As such, housing availability and affordability will be critical components in promoting continued positive economic development. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-11** 

~~**Packet Pg. 142**~~
{71}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **C. EMPLOYMENT OUTLOOK** 

## WARN (layoff notices): 

The Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) Act requires advance notice of qualified plant closings and mass layoffs. WARN notices were reviewed on December 18, 2023. According to the North Carolina Department of Labor and Economic Opportunity, there have been no WARN notices reported for Burke County over the past 12 months. 

The 10 largest employers within Burke County are summarized in the following table. 

|**Employer Name**|**Business Type**|**Total**<br>**Employed**|
|---|---|---|
|UNC Health Blue Ridge|Healthcare|3,000|
|Burke County Schools|Public Education|1,500|
|Broughton Hospital|Mental Healthcare|1,200|
|J Iverson Riddle Dev. Center|Mental Health Care and Research Center|1,000|
|Case Farms|Food Processing|1,000|
|Valdese Weavers|Woven Fabric|700|
|Leviton|Electrical Manufacturing|600|
|Continental|Automotive Parts Manufacturing|550|
|Burke County|County Government|500|
|Western Piedmont Community College|College Education|400|
|Total||10,450|



Source: Burke Development Incorporated (December 2023) 

Major employers in the area are primarily engaged in healthcare, education, food production, manufacturing, and public administration.  As six of the 10 largest employers are involved in either healthcare or manufacturing, this further illustrates the heavy influence that these two industries have on the local economy. Overall, it appears that most of the major employers in the area are engaged in business activities with occupations that typically offer competitive compensation. Additionally, six of the top employers are engaged in critical services (healthcare, education, and public administration), which are generally less vulnerable to economic downturns. 

A map delineating the location of the area’s largest employers is included on the following page. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-12** 

~~**Packet Pg. 143**~~
{72}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 144**
{73}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## Economic Development 

Economic development can improve the economic well-being and quality of life for a region or community by building local wealth, diversifying the economy, and creating and retaining jobs. Local perspective on the economy as well as notable developments in the area are summarized in this section. 

According to a representative with Burke Development Incorporated, the Burke County economy is stable and improving.  Businesses are growing; however, Burke County does not have any industrial buildings available which limits new businesses coming to the area.  Most of the county’s industries still have job openings even though the pace of hiring has slowed. 

The following table summarizes notable recent and/or ongoing economic development and infrastructure projects within the Burke County area at the time of this analysis: 

|**Economic Development Activity– Burke County**|**Economic Development Activity– Burke County**|**Economic Development Activity– Burke County**|**Economic Development Activity– Burke County**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Project Name**|**Investment**|**Job Creation**|**Scope of Work/Details**|
|Meritor|$4 million|25|**Completed**: Vehicle systems supplier expanded the trailer<br>operation in the city of Morganton in 2022|
|Vanguard Furniture|$5.9 million|100|**Completed**: In mid-2022, furniture production plant opened in<br>163,000 square-foot former Drexel Heritage plant|
|Unix Packaging Warehouse|$25.9 million|100|**Under Construction**: Construction began January 2023 on the<br>beverage manufacturing company’s building in the Burke Business<br>Park; ECD unavailable|
|Molded Fiber Glass<br>Green Textile Hub|$7 million|30|**Under Construction**: Automotive molded fiberglass hub is<br>expanding facility; ECD end of 2023|
|Gerresheimer Glass, Inc.|$94 million|100|**Under**<br>**Construction**:<br>Company<br>produces<br>pharmaceutical<br>packaging; Expansion ECD 2025|
|Maynard Electric|$400,000|25|**Planned**: Commercial/industrial contractor is renovating an<br>800,000 square-foot building; $200,000 grant for project awarded<br>June 2023|
|Great Meadows Megasite|Over $35<br>million|N/A|**Proposed:**Possible manufacturing facility and/or data center<br>megasite consisting of approximately 1,343 acres in Burke and<br>McDowell counties near exit 94 along Interstate 40; Developer<br>undecided as of early January 2024|
|**Infrastructure Projects– Burke County**||||
|**Project Name**|**Investment**|**Status**|**Scope of Work**|
|City of Morganton Sewer<br>Extension/Burke Business<br>Park Water & Sewer<br>Extensions Project|$12,360,590<br>allocated as of<br>November 2023|<br>Planned|Sewer extension along Highway 181; Burke Development, Inc. is<br>in early stages of extending water and sewer west of Morganton that<br>will expand infrastructure to areas where it does not currently exist<br>(associated with the Great Meadows Megasite); ECD unavailable|



ECD – Estimated Completion Date 

As the preceding illustrates, economic development activity totaling approximately $172 million has either been recently completed, is currently under construction, or is planned to commence in the near future.  Overall, these projects have an estimated initial job creation impact of approximately 380 new jobs within Burke County.  In addition, a notable sewer extension project ($12 million) associated with the Great Meadows Megasite is expected to create considerable future development opportunities in the county. Specifically, water/sewer will be 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-14** 

~~**Packet Pg. 145**~~
{74}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

expanded from Morganton to the planned Great Meadows Megasite in western Burke County.  This is expected to create opportunities for future/additional development between Morganton and western Burke County, including future housing development.  The development of the aforementioned megasite could heavily influence growth potential, both economically and demographically, within the PSA (Burke County). 

## **D. PERSONAL MOBILITY** 

The ability of a person or household to travel easily, quickly, safely, and affordably throughout a market influences the desirability of a housing market. If traffic congestion creates long commuting times or public transit service is not available for carless people, their quality of life is diminished. Factors that lower resident satisfaction weaken housing markets. Typically, people travel frequently outside of their residences for three reasons: 1) to commute to work, 2) to run errands or 3) to recreate. 

Commuting Mode and Time 

The following tables show commuting pattern attributes for each study area: 

|||**Commuting Mode**|**Commuting Mode**|**Commuting Mode**|**Commuting Mode**|**Commuting Mode**|**Commuting Mode**|**Commuting Mode**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|||**Drove Alone**|**Carpooled**|**Public Transit**|**Walked**|**Other Means**|**Worked at**<br>**Home**|**Total**|
|**Morganton**|Number|4,956|1,009|22|28|97|239|6,351|
||Percent|78.0%|15.9%|0.3%|0.4%|1.5%|3.8%|100.0%|
|**Burke County**|Number|32,542|3,393|73|156|496|1,649|38,309|
||Percent|84.9%|8.9%|0.2%|0.4%|1.3%|4.3%|100.0%|
|**North Carolina**|Number|3,738,810|419,171|42,121|79,482|63,443|497,932|4,840,959|
||Percent|77.2%|8.7%|0.9%|1.6%|1.3%|10.3%|100.0%|



Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2017-2021 American Community Survey 

|||**Commuting Time**|**Commuting Time**|**Commuting Time**|**Commuting Time**|**Commuting Time**|**Commuting Time**|**Commuting Time**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|||**Less Than 15**<br>**Minutes**|**15 to 29**<br>**Minutes**|**30 to 44**<br>**Minutes**|**45 to 59**<br>**Minutes**|**60 or More**<br>**Minutes**|**Worked at**<br>**Home**|**Total**|
|**Morganton**|Number|2,712|1,659|1,131|308|303|239|6,352|
||Percent|42.7%|26.1%|17.8%|4.8%|4.8%|3.8%|100.0%|
|**Burke County**|Number|10,100|16,590|6,213|1,980|1,777|1,649|38,309|
||Percent|26.4%|43.3%|16.2%|5.2%|4.6%|4.3%|100.0%|
|**North Carolina**|Number|1,151,688|1,717,566|872,990|318,674|282,109|497,932|4,840,959|
||Percent|23.8%|35.5%|18.0%|6.6%|5.8%|10.3%|100.0%|



Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2017-2021 American Community Survey 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-15** 

~~**Packet Pg. 146**~~
{75}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Noteworthy observations from the preceding tables follow: 

- Within the PSA (Burke County), 93.8% of commuters either drive alone or carpool to work. This represents a higher share of such commuting modes when compared to the state of North Carolina (85.9%).  As such, the shares of PSA commuters that utilize public transit (0.2%), walk to work (0.4%), or work from home (4.3%) are notably less than the corresponding shares for the state. Within the Morganton Submarket, the overall distribution of commuting modes is similar to the PSA, with the exception that there is a notably larger share of commuters that carpool to work (15.9%) within the submarket. 

- Over one-quarter (26.4%) of commuters in Burke County have commute times of less than 15 minutes, representing a slightly larger share of very short commute times compared to the state (23.8%). Overall, 69.7% of PSA workers have commute times less than 30 minutes to work, which is a larger than the share statewide (59.3%). Within the Morganton Submarket, 42.7% of commuters have commute times less than 15 minutes, and 68.8% of commuters have commute times less than 30 minutes.  Only 4.6% of commuters in the PSA and 4.8% of commuters in the Morganton Submarket have commute times of 60 or more minutes. 

Based on the preceding analysis, a vast majority of PSA and submarket commuters utilize their own vehicles or carpool to work. Overall, commute times in the PSA and Morganton Submarket are, on average, notably shorter than commute times for the state of North Carolina and very few commuters in the area have commute times of 60 minutes or more. 

A drive-time map illustrating travel times from the center of Morganton, which is the county seat, is included on the following page. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-16** 

~~**Packet Pg. 147**~~
{76}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 148**
{77}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## Commuting Inflow/Outflow 

According to 2020 U.S. Census Longitudinal Origin-Destination Employment Statistics (LODES), of the 34,147 employed residents of Burke County, 22,056 (64.6%) are employed outside the county, while the remaining 12,091 (35.4%) are employed within Burke County. In addition, 13,883 people commute into Burke County from surrounding areas for employment. These 13,883 nonresidents account for 53.4% of the people employed in the county and represent a notable base of potential support for future residential development as some commuters would likely consider relocating to Burke County to be closer to their place of employment if housing that met their needs was available. The following illustrates the number of jobs filled by in-commuters and residents, as well as the number of resident out-commuters. 

**==> picture [404 x 454] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Burke County, NC – Inflow/Outflow Job Counts in 2021<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Source: U.S. Census, Longitudinal Origin-Destination Employment Statistics (LODES) 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-18** 

~~**Packet Pg. 149**~~
{78}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Characteristics of the Burke County commuting flow in 2021 are illustrated in the following table. 

|**Burke County, NC: Commuting****_Flow_ Analysis by Earnings, Age and Industry Group**<br>**(2021, All Jobs)**|**Burke County, NC: Commuting****_Flow_ Analysis by Earnings, Age and Industry Group**<br>**(2021, All Jobs)**|**Burke County, NC: Commuting****_Flow_ Analysis by Earnings, Age and Industry Group**<br>**(2021, All Jobs)**|**Burke County, NC: Commuting****_Flow_ Analysis by Earnings, Age and Industry Group**<br>**(2021, All Jobs)**|**Burke County, NC: Commuting****_Flow_ Analysis by Earnings, Age and Industry Group**<br>**(2021, All Jobs)**|**Burke County, NC: Commuting****_Flow_ Analysis by Earnings, Age and Industry Group**<br>**(2021, All Jobs)**|**Burke County, NC: Commuting****_Flow_ Analysis by Earnings, Age and Industry Group**<br>**(2021, All Jobs)**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Worker Characteristics**|**Resident Outflow**||**Workers Inflow**||**Resident Workers**||
||**Number**|**Share**|**Number**|**Share**|**Number**|**Share**|
|Ages 29 or younger|5,409|24.5%|3,416|24.6%|2,551|21.1%|
|Ages 30 to 54|11,308|51.3%|7,096|51.1%|6,180|51.1%|
|Ages 55 or older|5,339|24.2%|3,371|24.3%|3,360|27.8%|
|_Earning<$1,250 per month_|4,572|20.7%|3,130|22.5%|2,667|22.1%|
|_Earning $1,251 to $3,333_|8,341|37.8%|5,716|41.2%|5,129|42.4%|
|_Earning $3,333+ per month_|9,143|41.5%|5,037|36.3%|4,295|35.5%|
|Goods Producing Industries|5,436|24.6%|4,152|29.9%|3,828|31.7%|
|Trade, Transportation, Utilities|5,183|23.5%|2,773|20.0%|1,253|10.4%|
|All Other Services Industries|11,437|51.9%|6,958|50.1%|7,010|58.0%|
|**Total Worker Flow**|**22,056**|**100.0%**|**13,883**|**100.0%**|**12,091**|**100.0%**|



Source: U.S. Census, Longitudinal Origin-Destination Employment Statistics (LODES) Note: Figures do not include contract employees and self-employed workers 

Specifically, of the county’s 13,883 in-commuters, over one-half (51.1%) are between the ages of 30 and 54 years, 41.2% earn between $1,251 and $3,333 (between $15,000 and $40,000 annually), and 29.9% work in the goods producing industries. Resident outflow workers, by comparison, are similarly aged to inflow workers, earn higher wages, and are more likely than inflow workers to work in the trade, transportation and utilities industries. Regardless, given the diversity of incomes, ages, and occupation types of the approximately 14,000 people commuting into the area for work each day, a variety of housing product types could be developed to potentially attract these commuters to live in Burke County. A detailed analysis of the area housing market, which includes availability, costs, and product mixture is included in Section VI of this report. It is important to understand that the overall health of the local housing market can influence the probability of in-commuters relocating to the area. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-19** 

~~**Packet Pg. 150**~~
{79}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following map and corresponding tables illustrate the physical _home_ location (county) of people _working in_ Burke County, as well as the distribution of commute distances for the Burke County workforce. 

|**Burke County Workforce – Top 10 Counties of Residence & Commute Distance**<br>**All Jobs (2021)**|**Burke County Workforce – Top 10 Counties of Residence & Commute Distance**<br>**All Jobs (2021)**|**Burke County Workforce – Top 10 Counties of Residence & Commute Distance**<br>**All Jobs (2021)**|**Burke County Workforce – Top 10 Counties of Residence & Commute Distance**<br>**All Jobs (2021)**||
|---|---|---|---|---|
||||||
||**County**|**Number**|**Share**||
||Burke County, NC|12,091|46.6%||
||Catawba County, NC|2,599|10.0%||
||Caldwell County, NC|2,555|9.8%||
||McDowell County, NC|1,112|4.3%||
||Buncombe County, NC|470|1.8%||
||Mecklenburg County, NC|464|1.8%||
||Rutherford County, NC|463|1.8%||
||Cleveland County, NC|456|1.8%||
||Gaston County, NC|388|1.5%||
||Alexander County, NC|340|1.3%||
||All Other Locations|5,036|19.4%||
||**Total**|**25,974**|**100.0%**||
||**Commute Distance**||||
||**Distance**|**Number**|**Share**||
||Less than 10 miles|11,525|44.4%||
||10 to 24 miles|6,795|26.2%||
||25 to 50 miles|3,191|12.3%||
||Greater than 50 miles|4,463|17.2%||
||**Total**|**25,974**|**100.0%**||



Source: U.S. Census, Longitudinal Origin-Destination Employment Statistics (LODES) 

Statistics provided by LODES indicate that 46.6% of the Burke County workforce are residents of the county. The counties of Catawba (10.0%), Caldwell (9.8%), and McDowell (4.3%) contribute the next largest shares of people that work in Burke County. In total, approximately 74.3% of the Burke County workforce originates from either within the county or from an adjacent county, and only 19.4% of the labor force originates from outside of the top 10 counties listed. As such, the Burke County workforce is mostly regional based with 70.6% of individuals commuting less than 25 miles. Inflow workers with commute distances of more than 50 miles comprise 17.2% of the total Burke County workforce. These 4,463 inflow workers with lengthy commutes, as well as those with shorter commutes from outside the county, represent a base of potential support for future residential development in Burke County. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-20** 

~~**Packet Pg. 151**~~
{80}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following map and corresponding tables illustrate the physical _work_ location (county) of Burke County residents, as well as the commute distances for these workers. 

**==> picture [546 x 268] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Burke County Residents – Top 10 Counties of Employment & Commute Distance<br>All Jobs (2021)<br>County Number  Share<br>Burke County, NC 12,091  35.4%<br>Catawba County, NC 5,952  17.4%<br>Caldwell County, NC 2,220  6.5%<br>Mecklenburg County, NC  1,992  5.8%<br>McDowell County, NC  1,545  4.5%<br>Wake County, NC  1,295  3.8%<br>Iredell County, NC  777  2.3%<br>Buncombe County, NC  775  2.3%<br>Gaston County, NC  513  1.5%<br>Guilford County, NC  486  1.4%<br>All Other Locations  6,501  19.0%<br>Total  34,147  100.0%<br>Commute Distance<br>Distance Number Share<br>Less than 10 miles  12,559  36.8%<br>10 to 24 miles  8,598  25.2%<br>25 to 50 miles  5,204  15.2%<br>Greater than 50 miles  7,786  22.8%<br>Total   34,147  100.0%<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Source: U.S. Census, Longitudinal Origin-Destination Employment Statistics (LODES) 

Of the 34,147 employed residents of Burke County, 35.4% are employed within Burke County. The counties of Catawba (17.4%), Caldwell (6.5%), and Mecklenburg (5.8%) employ the next largest shares of Burke County residents. While 63.8% of Burke County residents are either employed within the county or in an adjacent county, it is noteworthy that 22.8% of PSA residents have commutes of 50 miles or more.   Although a number of factors contribute to where an individual chooses to reside, lengthy commute times can increase the likelihood of relocation if improved housing options are present closer to an individual’s place of employment. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-21** 

~~**Packet Pg. 152**~~
{81}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **E. CONCLUSIONS** 

The economy in the PSA (Burke County) is heavily influenced by the manufacturing and healthcare sectors, which collectively account for 35.1% of the employment by sector and includes six of the 10 largest employers within the county. Overall, wages within the PSA are lower than wages at the state level, and housing affordability, particularly home ownership, is an issue for a significant share of individuals working within the most common occupations in the area. In addition, nearly 7,800 Burke County residents commute 50 miles or more to their place of employment. Total employment in the PSA as of August 2023 recovered to 102.4% of the 2019 level, while at-place employment (total jobs in the county regardless of the employee’s county of residence) through March 2023 is at 98.6% of the pre-COVID level. As such, the economy in the PSA has improved significantly during the past few years, and the annual unemployment rate through August 2023 is 3.3%, which is the lowest recorded rate for the county since 2013.  A number of noteworthy economic development projects and a significant infrastructure expansion will likely position Burke County to benefit from continued economic improvement. Most notably, a potential manufacturing/industrial megasite being planned for the western portion of the county. This project is anticipated to create many jobs within the area and enhance housing development potential within western Burke County due to infrastructure improvements/expansions from the city of Morganton to the location of the planned megasite. In addition, nearly 14,000 individuals commute into the county daily for employment, which represents a notable base of potential support for future housing development. While this positive economic activity will contribute to the ongoing demand for housing in Burke County, it is important that an adequate supply of income-appropriate housing is available to capture new residents and retain existing residents, particularly those with lengthy commutes. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**V-22** 

~~**Packet Pg. 153**~~
{82}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **VI.  HOUSING SUPPLY ANALYSIS** 

This housing supply analysis includes a variety of housing alternatives. Understanding the historical trends, market performance, characteristics, composition, and current housing choices provide critical information as to current market conditions and future housing potential. The housing data presented and analyzed in this section includes primary data collected directly by Bowen National Research and secondary data sources including American Community Survey (ACS), U.S. Census housing information, and data provided by various government entities and real estate professionals. 

While there are a variety of housing options offered in Morganton and Burke County (PSA), we focused our analysis on the most common housing alternatives. The housing structures included in this analysis are: 

- **Rental Housing** – Rental properties consisting of multifamily apartments (generally with five or more units within a structure) were identified and surveyed. An analysis of non-conventional rentals (typically with four or less units within a structure) was also conducted. In addition, a survey of short-term (recreational/seasonal) rentals was completed to analyze the effect this housing segment has on the overall rental market. 

- **For-Sale Housing** – For-sale housing alternatives, both recent sales activity and currently available supply, were inventoried. This data includes singlefamily homes, condominiums, mobile homes, and other traditional housing alternatives. It includes stand-alone product as well as homes within planned developments or projects. 

- **Senior Care Housing** – We surveyed senior care facilities that provide both shelter and care housing alternatives to seniors requiring some level of personal care (e.g., dressing, bathing, medical reminders, etc.) and medical care. This includes independent living, assisted living, and nursing homes. 

For the purposes of this analysis, the housing supply information is presented for Morganton, the PSA (Burke County), and the state of North Carolina, when available. 

Maps illustrating the location of various housing types are included throughout this section. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-1** 

~~**Packet Pg. 154**~~
{83}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **A. OVERALL HOUSING SUPPLY (SECONDARY DATA)** 

This section of analysis on the area housing supply is based on secondary data sources such as the U.S. Census, American Community Survey, ESRI, and the North Carolina Office of State Budget and Management (NCOSMB), and is provided for Morganton, the PSA (Burke County), and the state of North Carolina, when applicable. Note that some small variation of total numbers and percentages within tables may exist due to rounding. 

## Housing Characteristics 

The estimated distribution of the area housing stock by tenure (renter and owner) within the study areas for 2023 is summarized in the following table: 

|||**Occupied and Vacant Housing Units by Tenure**<br>**2023 Estimates**|**Occupied and Vacant Housing Units by Tenure**<br>**2023 Estimates**|**Occupied and Vacant Housing Units by Tenure**<br>**2023 Estimates**|**Occupied and Vacant Housing Units by Tenure**<br>**2023 Estimates**|**Occupied and Vacant Housing Units by Tenure**<br>**2023 Estimates**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|||**Total**<br>**Occupied**|**Owner**<br>**Occupied**|**Renter**<br>**Occupied**|**Vacant**|**Total**|
|**Morganton**|Number|6,887|4,176|2,711|826|7,713|
||Percent|89.3%|60.6%|39.4%|10.7%|100.0%|
|**Burke County**|Number|35,602|27,300|8,302|4,536|40,138|
||Percent|88.7%|76.7%|23.3%|11.3%|100.0%|
||Number|4,313,442|2,852,254|1,461,188|572,512|4,885,954|
|**North Carolina**|Percent|88.3%|66.1%|33.9%|11.7%|100.0%|



Source: 2010 Census; ESRI; NCOSBM; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research 

In total, there are an estimated 40,138 housing units within the PSA (Burke County) in 2023. Based on estimates, of the 35,602 total occupied housing units in the PSA, 76.7% are owner occupied and 23.3% are renter occupied. This distribution of product by tenure within the PSA is more heavily weighted toward owner-occupied housing than the state of North Carolina, which has a 66.1% share of owner-occupied housing units. Overall, 11.3% of the total housing units within the PSA are classified as vacant. Vacant units are comprised of a variety of units including abandoned properties, rentals, for-sale, and seasonal housing units. Within the Morganton Submarket, there is a notably higher share (39.4%) of renter-occupied housing units compared to the PSA and state. This is likely due, in large part, to the high population density (914.3 persons per square mile) within Morganton. The share (10.7%) of vacant housing units in the submarket is slightly less than both the PSA and state. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-2** 

~~**Packet Pg. 155**~~
{84}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following table compares key housing age and conditions for each of the study areas and the state based on 2017-2021 American Community Survey (ACS) data. Housing units built over 50 years ago (pre-1970), overcrowded housing (1.01+ persons per room), or housing that lacks complete kitchens or bathroom plumbing are illustrated for each area by tenure (renter or owner). It is important to note that some occupied housing units may have more than one housing issue. 

|**Morganton**<br>**Burke County**<br>**North**<br>**Carolina**|**Pre-1970**<br>**Renter**<br>**Number**<br>**Percent**<br>1,200<br>40.8%<br> <br>3,235<br>38.1%<br>329,937<br>24.0%|**Product**<br>**Owner**<br>**Number**<br>**Percent**<br>1,918<br>57.5%<br>8,259<br>31.9%<br>581,137<br>21.8%|**Housing Age and Conditions**<br>**Overcrowded**<br>**Renter**<br>**Owner**<br>**Number**<br>**Percent**<br>**Number**<br>**Percent**<br>308<br>10.5%<br>39<br>1.2%<br>497<br>5.9%<br>290<br>1.1%<br>54,665<br>4.0%<br>35,713<br>1.3%|**Incomplete Plumbing or Kitchen**<br>**Renter**<br>**Owner**<br>**Number**<br>**Percent**<br>**Number**<br>**Percent**<br>90<br>3.1%<br>41<br>1.2%<br>98<br>1.2%<br>350<br>1.4%<br>21,880<br>1.6%<br>14,436<br>0.5%|
|---|---|---|---|---|



Source: American Community Survey (2017-2021); ESRI; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research 

Within the PSA (Burke County), 38.1% of renter-occupied housing units and 31.9% of owner-occupied housing units were built prior to 1970. Both shares represent larger proportions of pre-1970 product as compared to the shares for the state of North Carolina (24.0% and 21.8%, respectively). As such, the housing stock in the PSA is, on average, older than housing statewide. While the share of owner-occupied housing in the PSA experiencing overcrowding (1.1%) is less than the statewide share, the share of renter-occupied housing experiencing this issue (5.9%) is larger than the statewide share (4.0%). Incomplete plumbing or kitchens appear to be somewhat more prevalent issues for owner-occupied housing units within the PSA as compared to the state, with 1.4% of owner households in the PSA experiencing these issues. 

Within the Morganton Submarket, 40.8% of renter-occupied housing units and 57.5% of owner-occupied housing units were built prior to 1970. As a result, the housing inventory in the submarket is older than both the PSA and state, particularly the owner-occupied housing units. The shares of renter-occupied housing units experiencing overcrowding (10.5%) and incomplete plumbing or kitchens (3.1%) are both notably higher than the corresponding shares in the PSA and state of North Carolina. As such, it appears renters in the Morganton Submarket are considerably more likely to experience housing condition issues than owners in the area. Overall, there are approximately 595 renter households and 640 owner households within the PSA that live in substandard housing conditions (overcrowded or lacking complete kitchens or indoor plumbing). 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-3** 

~~**Packet Pg. 156**~~
{85}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following table compares key household income, housing cost, and housing affordability metrics of the PSA (Burke County) and the state. Cost burdened households are defined as those paying over 30% of their income toward housing costs, while severe cost burdened households pay over 50% of their income toward housing. 

||**Household Income, Housing Costs and Affordability**|**Household Income, Housing Costs and Affordability**|**Household Income, Housing Costs and Affordability**|**Household Income, Housing Costs and Affordability**|**Household Income, Housing Costs and Affordability**|**Household Income, Housing Costs and Affordability**|**Household Income, Housing Costs and Affordability**|**Household Income, Housing Costs and Affordability**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
||**2023**<br>**Households**|**Median**<br>**Household**<br>**Income**|**Estimated**<br>**Median**<br>**Home**<br>**Value**|**Average**<br>**Gross**<br>**Rent**|**Share of Cost**<br>**Burdened**<br>**Households***||**Share of Severe Cost**<br>**Burdened**<br>**Households****||
||||||**Renter**|**Owner**|**Renter**|**Owner**|
|**Morganton**|6,887|$47,913|$201,493|$787|44.2%|13.2%|22.2%|5.5%|
|**Burke County**|35,602|$55,356|$185,407|$761|36.8%|13.5%|18.3%|6.0%|
|**North Carolina**|4,313,442|$65,879|$262,944|$1,067|43.2%|18.9%|20.7%|7.6%|



Source: American Community Survey (2017-2021); ESRI; NCOSBM; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research *Paying more than 30% of income toward housing costs **Paying more than 50% of income toward housing costs 

The PSA’s (Burke County) median home value of $185,407 is 29.5% lower than the state’s estimated median home value of $262,944. The average gross rent of $761 in the PSA is approximately 28.7% lower than the state’s average gross rent of $1,067. The median household income for the PSA ($55,356) is 16.0% lower than that for the state. Overall, these factors result in lower shares of cost burdened renter households (36.8%) and owner households (13.5%) in the PSA compared to the shares within the state (43.2% and 18.9%, respectively). While the estimated median household income in the Morganton Submarket ($47,913) is 13.4% lower than median household income in the PSA, the estimated median home value ($201,493) and average gross rent ($787) in the submarket are higher than those in the PSA. Although the share of cost burdened owners (13.2%) is slightly lower in the Morganton Submarket, there is a notably higher share of cost burdened renters (44.2%) as compared to the PSA. Regardless, there are approximately 3,055 renter households and 3,686 owner households in the PSA that are housing cost burdened. Of these, approximately 1,519 renter households and 1,638 owner households are _severe_ housing cost burdened (paying 50% or more of their income toward housing costs). Within the Morganton Submarket, nearly 1,200 renter households and approximately 551 owner households are cost burdened, of which 602 renter households and 230 owner households are severe cost burdened. Overall, this data illustrates the importance of affordable rental and for-sale housing for the residents of Burke County and Morganton. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-4** 

~~**Packet Pg. 157**~~
{86}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

**==> picture [424 x 251] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
The following graph illustrates substandard housing and cost burdened<br>households:<br>Substandard & Cost Burdened Housing<br>Morganton Renter Morganton Owner PSA Renter PSA Owner<br>4,000<br>3,500<br>3,686<br>3,000<br>3,055<br>2,500<br>2,000<br>1,500<br>1,000 595 640 1,200<br>398<br>500<br>80 551<br>0<br>Substandard Cost Burdened<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Based on the 2017-2021 American Community Survey (ACS) data, the following is a distribution of all occupied housing by units in structure by tenure (renter or owner) for the various study areas. 

**==> picture [546 x 132] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Renter-Occupied Housing   Owner-Occupied Housing<br>by Units in Structure  by Units in Structure<br>Mobile  Mobile<br>4 Units  5 Units  4 Units  5 Units<br>Home/  Total  Home/  Total<br>or Less  or More  or Less  or More<br>Other  Other<br>Number  1,627  1,083  229  2,939  2,993  108  235  3,336<br>Morganton<br>Percent  55.4%  36.8%  7.8%  100.0%  89.7%  3.2%  7.0%  100.0%<br>Number  4,522  1,645  2,316  8,483  20,842  114  4,937  25,893<br>Burke County<br>Percent  53.3%  19.4%  27.3%  100.0%  80.5%  0.4%  19.1%  100.0%<br>Number  709,819  500,086  164,257  1,374,162  2,339,335  30,264  290,904  2,660,503<br>North Carolina<br>Percent  51.7%  36.4%  12.0%  100.0%  87.9%  1.1%  10.9%  100.0%<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Source: American Community Survey (2017-2021); ESRI; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research 

Over one-half (53.3%) of the _rental_ units in the PSA (Burke County) are within structures of four units or less, with mobile homes comprising an additional 27.3% of the PSA rental units. The combined share of these two structure types (80.6%) is a notably larger share compared to that of the state (63.7%). Only 19.4% of rental units in the PSA are situated within structures containing five or more units, which are considered to be conventional multifamily apartment properties. Within the Morganton Submarket, the share of rental units in structures of five or more units (36.8%) is significantly higher than that within the PSA and noteworthy. Among _owner_ units in the PSA, a vast majority of the housing units are within structures of four units or less, with mobile homes comprising 19.1% of units in the PSA and 7.0% of units in the Morganton Submarket. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-5** 

~~**Packet Pg. 158**~~
{87}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following graphs illustrate the number of housing units in structure by tenure (renter/owner): 

## **Renter-Occupied Housing by Units in Structure (2017-2021)** 

**==> picture [418 x 188] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
4 or Less 5 or More Mobile/Other<br>60.0%<br>50.0% 55.4% 53.3%<br>51.7%<br>40.0%<br>36.8% 36.4%<br>30.0%<br>27.3%<br>20.0%<br>19.4%<br>10.0%<br>12.0%<br>7.8%<br>0.0%<br>Morganton Burke County North Carolina<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **Owner-Occupied Housing by Units in Structure (2017-2021)** 

**==> picture [418 x 188] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
4 or Less 5 or More Mobile/Other<br>90.0%<br>80.0% 89.7% 87.9%<br>80.5%<br>70.0%<br>60.0%<br>50.0%<br>40.0%<br>30.0%<br>19.1%<br>20.0%<br>10.9%<br>7.0%<br>10.0% 3.2%<br>0.4% 1.1%<br>0.0%<br>Morganton Burke County North Carolina<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-6** 

~~**Packet Pg. 159**~~
{88}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **B. HOUSING SUPPLY ANALYSIS (BOWEN NATIONAL SURVEY)** 

## 1. Introduction 

Bowen National Research conducted research and analysis of various housing alternatives within Morganton and Burke County (PSA). This analysis includes rental housing (multifamily and non-conventional), vacation rental housing, for-sale and owner-occupied housing, and senior care facilities. 

Note that as Bowen National Research previously conducted a Housing Needs Assessment for Burke County in 2018, comparisons between current (2023) and 2018 housing supply have been provided when available. 

## 2. Multifamily Rental Housing 

Between August and October of 2023, Bowen National Research surveyed (both by telephone and in-person) a total of 47 multifamily rental housing projects within Morgantown and the PSA (Burke County). While this survey does not include all properties in the market, it does include a majority of the larger properties. The overall survey is considered representative of the performance, conditions and trends of multifamily rental housing in the market. Projects identified, inventoried, and surveyed operate as market-rate and under a number of affordable housing programs including the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) program and various HUD programs. Definitions of each housing program are included in _Addendum E: Glossary_ . 

Property managers and leasing agents for each project were surveyed to collect a variety of property information including vacancies, rental rates, unit mixes, year built and other features. Most properties were personally visited by staff of Bowen National Research and were also rated based on general exterior quality and upkeep, and each property was mapped as part of this survey. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-7** 

~~**Packet Pg. 160**~~
{89}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The distribution of the surveyed multifamily rental housing supply by program type is illustrated in the following table. 

|**Project Type**|**Projects**|**Total**<br>**Units**|**Vacant**<br>**Units**|**2023**<br>**Occupancy**<br>**Rate**|**2018**<br>**Occupancy**<br>**Rate**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Morganton**||||||
|Market-Rate|18|934|57|93.9%|95.2%|
|Tax Credit|6|262|0|100.0%|100.0%|
|Tax Credit/Government-Subsidized|2|76|0|100.0%|100.0%|
|Government-Subsidized|11|467|2|99.6%|100.0%|
|Total|37|1,739|59|96.6%|97.9%|
|**Burke County (PSA)**||||||
|Market-Rate|21|1,002|57|94.3%|94.7%|
|Tax Credit|7|322|0|100.0%|100.0%|
|Tax Credit/Government-Subsidized|4|134|0|100.0%|100.0%|
|Government-Subsidized|15|697|2|99.7%|100.0%|
|Total|47|2,155|59|97.3%|98.0%|



Source: Bowen National Research 

Typically, in healthy and well-balanced markets, multifamily rentals operate at an overall 94% to 96% occupancy rate. As the preceding table illustrates, the rental properties surveyed in the PSA (Burke County) have an overall occupancy rate of 97.3%. Among the 59 total vacancies in the PSA, 96.6% (57 units) are contained within market-rate projects. While the surveyed Tax Credit projects in the PSA are fully occupied, governmentsubsidized properties in the PSA are operating at an occupancy rate of 99.7%. Additionally, a vast majority of the Tax Credit and governmentsubsidized properties maintain waiting lists. Although the overall occupancy rate of 97.3% in the PSA represents a slight decrease from the occupancy rate (98.0%) during our initial survey in 2018, the occupancy rate is still considered high for multifamily rentals. Further, 46 (78.0%) of the 59 total vacancies reported are concentrated within one property (Riverview Apartments).  According to management, this market-rate property was recently sold and is undergoing renovations.  This has likely contributed to the lower occupancy rate and vacancies at this property. When excluding this property, the 2,055 additional units surveyed in the PSA are 99.4% occupied.  This is a higher occupancy rate than that reported in 2018 (98.0%). 

Overall, more than three-quarters (78.7%) of the surveyed multifamily properties are located within the Morganton Submarket. It is noteworthy that all multifamily rental vacancies in the PSA are attributed to properties in the Morganton Submarket. Despite this, the overall occupancy rate in the submarket is 96.6%. While this represents a decrease in the occupancy rate from 2018 (97.9%), the occupancy rate in the Morganton Submarket is still considered slightly elevated. Also, as previously discussed, the majority (78.0%) of the vacant units reported are concentrated within one marketrate property (Riverview Apartments).  When excluding this property, the 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-8** 

~~**Packet Pg. 161**~~
{90}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

36 additional properties surveyed in the Morganton Submarket are 99.2% occupied, a higher overall rate than that reported in 2018 (97.9%). With high occupancy rates and the prevalence of waiting lists, particularly among the Tax Credit and government-subsidized units, there appears to be significant pent-up demand for multifamily rental housing within Burke County and Morganton. 

The following table summarizes the share of properties that maintain wait lists and the corresponding total number of households and/or the maximum length of wait for the next available unit by project type. 

|**Project Type**|**Projects**|**# Maintain**<br>**Wait List**|**% Maintain**<br>**Wait List**|**Waiting List**<br>**(Households/Months)**|
|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Morganton**|||||
|Market-Rate|18|2|11.1%|5-10 HH|
|Tax Credit|6|5|83.3%|12-80 HH|
|Tax Credit/Government-Subsidized|2|2|100.0%|4-6 HH|
|Government-Subsidized|11|8|72.7%|16-48 HH/12-18 Months|
|**Burke County (PSA)**|||||
|Market-Rate|21|2|9.5%|5-10 HH|
|Tax Credit|7|6|85.7%|12-200 HH|
|Tax Credit/Government-Subsidized|4|4|100.0%|4-15 HH|
|Government-Subsidized|15|12|80.0%|6-120 HH/12-18 Months|



As the preceding table illustrates, wait lists are maintained among properties of all types throughout the PSA (Burke County).  This indicates there is pent-up demand for multifamily rental product across all affordability/income levels within the county.  Wait lists are, however, most extensive among affordable (i.e., Tax Credit and/or government-subsidized) properties, which is not uncommon and demonstrates significant demand for such product in the county. 

## _Market-Rate Apartments_ 

A total of 21 multifamily projects with at least some market-rate units were surveyed in Burke County (PSA), 18 of which are in Morganton. Overall, these properties contain 1,002 market-rate units, of which 934 (93.2%) are in Morganton. The following table summarizes the market-rate units by bedroom/bathroom type. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-9** 

~~**Packet Pg. 162**~~
{91}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|**Market-Rate Rental Housing**|**Market-Rate Rental Housing**|**Market-Rate Rental Housing**|**Market-Rate Rental Housing**|**Market-Rate Rental Housing**|**Market-Rate Rental Housing**|**Market-Rate Rental Housing**|**Market-Rate Rental Housing**|**Market-Rate Rental Housing**||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Bedroom**|**Baths**|**Units**|**Distribution**|**Vacancy**|**%**<br>**Vacant**|**2023 Median**<br>**Collected Rent**|**2018 Median**<br>**Collected Rent**|**% Change**<br>**(2018-2023)**||
|**Morganton**||||||||||
|One-Bedroom|1.0|212|22.7%|4|1.9%|$1,385|$615|125.2%||
|Two-Bedroom|1.0|88|9.4%|1|1.1%|$1,175|$650|80.8%||
|Two-Bedroom|1.5|203|21.7%|2|1.0%|$1,225|$670|82.8%||
|Two-Bedroom|2.0|353|37.8%|50|14.2%|$1,400|$570|145.6%||
|Three-Bedroom|1.5|6|0.6%|0|0.0%|$1,150|$625|84.0%||
|Three-Bedroom|2.0|70|7.5%|0|0.0%|$1,400|$795|76.1%||
|Three-Bedroom|2.5|2|0.2%|0|0.0%|$1,150|$650|76.9%||
|**Total Market-Rate**||**934**|**100.0%**|**57**|**6.1%**|-|-|-||
|**Burke County (PSA)**||||||||||
|One-Bedroom|1.0|212|21.2%|4|1.9%|$1,385|$615|125.2%||
|Two-Bedroom|1.0|120|12.0%|1|0.8%|$1,175|$650|80.8%||
|Two-Bedroom|1.5|239|23.9%|2|0.8%|$1,200|$670|79.1%||
|Two-Bedroom|2.0|353|35.2%|50|14.2%|$1,400|$570|145.6%||
|Three-Bedroom|1.5|6|0.6%|0|0.0%|$1,150|$625|84.0%||
|Three-Bedroom|2.0|70|7.0%|0|0.0%|$1,400|$795|76.1%||
|Three-Bedroom|2.5|2|0.2%|0|0.0%|$1,150|$650|76.9%||
|**Total Market-Rate**||**1,002**|**100.0%**|**57**|**5.7%**|-|-|-||



Source: Bowen National Research 

The market-rate units within the PSA (Burke County) are 94.3% occupied. Overall, two-bedroom units comprise the largest share (71.1%) of the surveyed market-rate supply in the PSA, followed by one-bedroom units (21.2%). Among the most common unit configuration, two-bedroom/twobathroom units have an occupancy rate of 85.8%; however, 46 of the 50 vacancies for this unit configuration are located within one property that was recently sold and is currently undergoing renovations, as previously detailed. The occupancy rate among the remaining unit configurations ranges between 98.1% and 100.0%. 

Among the most common market-rate unit configurations in the PSA, median collected rents range from $1,200 (two-bedroom/one-and-one-halfbathroom) to $1,400 (two-bedroom/two-bathroom). Among these two common configurations, rents have increased by 79.1% and 145.6%, respectively, since 2018. While two market-rate unit configurations have experienced rent increases of more than 100.0% since our analysis in 2018, these are attributed to characteristics of two specific properties. Specifically, a new market-rate property (Murphy’s Farm) was introduced in 2022 and an existing property (Riverview Apartments) changed ownership and underwent renovations and notable rent increases during this time period. These aforementioned factors have heavily influenced median collected market-rate rents among the one-bedroom/one-bath and twobedroom/two-bath unit configurations. Nonetheless, other unit configurations have experienced median collected rent increases of 76.1% or more since 2018.  These are significant increases demonstrating the strength of the Burke County rental market and have likely exacerbated affordability issues within the county. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-10** 

~~**Packet Pg. 163**~~
{92}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Because 93.2% of the market-rate units in the PSA are located in the Morganton Submarket, the performance metrics in both the PSA and Morganton Submarket are nearly identical. Despite a relatively healthy overall occupancy rate, median collected rents for market-rate units in the PSA have increased rapidly since 2018. In addition, the very high occupancy rates and limited supply of three-bedroom units, specifically, may represent a future development opportunity in the market. 

The following graph illustrates the 2018 and 2023 median market-rate rents among common bedroom types offered in the PSA (Burke County) and Morganton. 

**==> picture [441 x 479] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Market-Rate Median Collected Rents (2018 vs 2023)<br>Morganton 2018 Morganton 2023 PSA 2018 PSA 2023<br>$1,400<br>$1,200<br>$1,000<br>$800<br>$600<br>$400<br>$200<br>$0<br>1-Br/1.0-Ba 2-Br/1.0-Ba 2-Br/2.0-Ba 3-Br/2.0-Ba<br>The following is a distribution of multifamily rental projects and units<br>surveyed by year built in Burke County:<br>Year Built - Market-Rate<br>Year Built  Projects  Units  Vacancy Rate<br>Morganton<br>Pre 1980  12  437  1.1%<br>1980 to 1989  3  227  20.3%*<br>1990 to 1999  - - -<br>2000 to 2009  1  22  0.0%<br>2010 to present  2  248  2.4%<br>Burke County (PSA)<br>Pre 1980  13  467  1.1%<br>1980 to 1989  4  233  19.7%*<br>1990 to 1999  1  32  0.0%<br>2000 to 2009  1  22  0.0%<br>2010 to present  2  248  2.4%<br>Source: Bowen National Research<br>*46 vacancies within 1 property currently undergoing renovations and re-leasing units<br>$1,385 $1,385 $1,400 $1,400 $1,400 $1,400<br>$1,175 $1,175<br>$795 $795<br>$650 $650<br>$615 $615<br>$570 $570<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-11** 

~~**Packet Pg. 164**~~
{93}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The largest share (46.6%) of market-rate units in the PSA (Burke County) was built prior to 1980, with a notable share (24.8%) having been built since 2010. It is also important to note that nearly one-quarter (24.0%) of the market-rate product in the PSA, or 240 units, was built after the preliminary study in 2018. All 240 of these units are located within the Murphy’s Farm property which was added to the county rental market in 2022. 

As previously stated, 93.2% of the market-rate units in the PSA are located in the Morganton Submarket; therefore, the distribution of the market-rate supply by year built in the PSA is highly representative of the distribution in the Morganton Submarket. Overall, a significant portion of the marketrate supply in the PSA is relatively old, although there has been a notable number of new units introduced within the market in recent years. Aside from the projects built from 1980 to 1989, which have a vacancy rate of 19.7% that is primarily attributed to one property undergoing renovations, vacancy rates are very low regardless of development period in the PSA. This indicates there is a high level of demand for market-rate multifamily rentals in Burke County, regardless of age. 

The distribution of surveyed market-rate units in the PSA (Burke County) and Morganton by development period is shown in the following graph. 

**==> picture [449 x 243] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Market-Rate Units by Year Built<br>Morganton Burke County<br>500<br>450<br>467<br>400 437<br>350<br>300<br>250<br>248 248<br>200 227 233<br>150<br>100<br>50 32 22 22<br>0<br>0<br>Before 1980 1980-1989 1990-1999 2000-2009 2010-present<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-12** 

~~**Packet Pg. 165**~~
{94}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Representatives of Bowen National Research personally visited the surveyed rental projects within the study areas and rated the exterior quality of each property on a scale of "A" (highest) through "F" (lowest). All properties were rated based on quality and overall appearance (i.e., aesthetic appeal, building appearance, landscaping and grounds appearance). The following is a distribution of the surveyed market-rate supply by quality rating. 

|**Quality Rating– Market-Rate**|**Quality Rating– Market-Rate**|**Quality Rating– Market-Rate**|**Quality Rating– Market-Rate**|**Quality Rating– Market-Rate**|**Quality Rating– Market-Rate**|**Quality Rating– Market-Rate**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Market-Rate Properties**||||**Median Collected Rent by Bedroom Type**|||
|**Quality**<br>**Rating**|**Projects**|**Total**<br>**Units**|**Vacancy**<br>**Rate**|**One-**<br>**Br.**|**Two-**<br>**Br.**|**Three-**<br>**Br.**|
|**Morganton**|||||||
|A-|1|240|2.5%|$1,448|$1,813|-|
|B+|1|58|0.0%|$975|$1,438|-|
|B|12|447|11.2%|$1,050|$1,225|$1,400|
|B-|3|177|0.6%|-|$1,200|$1,400|
|C+|1|12|0.0%|$750|$950|-|
|**Burke County (PSA)**|||||||
|A-|1|240|2.5%|$1,448|$1,813|-|
|B+|1|58|0.0%|$975|$1,438|-|
|B|10|480|10.4%|$1,050|$1,225|$1,400|
|B-|6|198|0.5%|-|$1,200|$1,400|
|C+|3|26|0.0%|$750|$950|$1,150|



Source: Bowen National Research 

Over three-quarters (77.6%) of the surveyed market-rate supply in the PSA (Burke County) consist of product with a “B” quality rating or higher. This is indicative of an inventory of market-rate product that is mostly in good to very good condition. While the vacancy rates do not appear to correlate to condition ratings, the properties with higher quality ratings typically have higher median collected rents. This correlation is most apparent among the two-bedroom units in the PSA, where the median collected rents steadily increase as the quality rating increases. 

Although the exterior quality of a project can influence the achievable rent, the design of the units themselves, as well as the unit and project amenities offered can also greatly impact the achievable rent for any given unit configuration. The unit designs and amenities offered at a specific project are often affected by such things as the target market (i.e., families, seniors, young professionals, etc.) and the household income segment the project seeks to serve. As such, the common amenities offered among market-rate product, particularly newer product, should be considered for future marketrate product. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-13** 

~~**Packet Pg. 166**~~
{95}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## _Tax Credit Apartments_ 

Tax Credit housing is developed under the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) program. Typically, these projects serve households with income of up to 60% of Area Median Household Income (AMHI), though recent legislation allows for some units to target households with incomes of up to 80% of AMHI. A total of seven surveyed multifamily projects in the PSA (Burke County) offer Tax Credit units. Of these projects, six are located in the Morganton Submarket. It is also worth noting that two of the seven properties (64 units, or 19.9% of the supply) are age-restricted to seniors aged 55 years and older. This section focuses only on the _non-subsidized_ Tax Credit units, while the Tax Credit units operating with concurrent subsidies are discussed in the government-subsidized section of this report (starting on page VI-18). 

The following table summarizes the breakdown of non-subsidized Tax Credit units surveyed within Morganton and Burke County (PSA). 

|**Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized) Rental Housing**|**Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized) Rental Housing**|**Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized) Rental Housing**|**Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized) Rental Housing**|**Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized) Rental Housing**|**Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized) Rental Housing**|**Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized) Rental Housing**|**Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized) Rental Housing**|**Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized) Rental Housing**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Bedroom**|**Baths**|**Units**|**Distribution**|**Vacancy**|**%**<br>**Vacant**|**2023 Median**<br>**Collected Rent**|**2018 Median**<br>**Collected Rent**|**% Change**<br>**(2018-2023)**|
|**Morganton**|||||||||
|One-Bedroom|1.0|74|28.2%|0|0.0%|$481|$432|11.3%|
|Two-Bedroom|1.0|60|22.9%|0|0.0%|$475|$455|4.4%|
|Two-Bedroom|2.0|76|29.0%|0|0.0%|$675|$570|18.4%|
|Three-Bedroom|1.0|4|1.5%|0|0.0%|$505|$485|4.1%|
|Three-Bedroom|2.0|48|18.3%|0|0.0%|$770|$650|18.5%|
|**Total Tax Credit**||**262**|**100.0%**|**0**|**0.0%**|-|-|-|
|**Burke County (PSA)**|||||||||
|One-Bedroom|1.0|83|25.8%|0|0.0%|$477|$432|10.4%|
|Two-Bedroom|1.0|65|20.2%|0|0.0%|$475|$455|4.4%|
|Two-Bedroom|2.0|98|30.4%|0|0.0%|$675|$570|18.4%|
|Three-Bedroom|1.0|4|1.2%|0|0.0%|$505|$485|4.1%|
|Three-Bedroom|2.0|72|22.4%|0|0.0%|$720|$650|10.8%|
|**Total Tax Credit**||**322**|**100.0%**|**0**|**0.0%**|-|-|-|
|Source: Bowen National Research|||||||||



The non-subsidized Tax Credit units within the PSA are 100.0% occupied, which includes units located within the Morganton Submarket. These occupancy rates are extremely high and are evidence of the county’s strong demand for affordable rental housing. The occupancy rate for the nonsubsidized Tax Credit units in the PSA and Morganton in 2018 was also 100.0%, which further illustrates the consistent demand for affordable rentals in Burke County. It is worth noting that six of the seven (85.7%) non-subsidized Tax Credit properties in Burke County maintain a wait list. Individual wait lists contain up to 200 households in the PSA, with up to 80 households on an individual wait list in the Morganton Submarket. Overall, this illustrates the significant pent-up demand for this type of housing in the PSA. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-14** 

~~**Packet Pg. 167**~~
{96}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The 322 Tax Credit units surveyed in the PSA consist of a broad mix of unit types, with two-bedroom units comprising the largest overall share (50.6%), followed by one-bedroom (25.8%) and three-bedroom (23.6%) units. Among the most common configuration, the two-bedroom/two-bathroom units in the PSA have a median collected rent of $675, which is 51.8% lower than the median collected rent for a _market-rate_ unit ($1,400) in the PSA of the same configuration. It is also noteworthy that the median collected rent for this unit type in the PSA increased by 18.4% since 2018. While twobedroom/two-bathroom units also represent the largest share of Tax Credit units in the Morganton Submarket and performance metrics are identical to those for the PSA, one-bedroom/one-bathroom units comprise only a slightly smaller share (28.2%) of the Morganton Tax Credit supply. Onebedroom/one-bathroom units in the submarket have a median collected rent of $481, which is 65.3% less than market-rate units ($1,385) with the same configuration. While the rent for this unit configuration increased by 11.3% since 2018, the increase in median rent for each Tax Credit configuration is remarkably less than the increases for each market-rate configuration. However, it is important to understand that non-subsidized Tax Credit properties are limited to rent increases which correspond with increases to maximum allowable Tax Credit rent limits for a given area. Thus, rents among Tax Credit properties typically do not increase at the same rates as market-rate product. Despite the increased Tax Credit rents since 2018, nonsubsidized Tax Credit units continue to offer a significant value in the PSA and Morganton Submarket. Overall, the very high occupancy rates in both the PSA and Morganton Submarket indicate that low-income households likely struggle to find available Tax Credit housing, regardless of household size. As many of these households are compelled to secure housing from the available inventory of market-rate and non-conventional rentals, which typically have much higher rents, this can result in a greater share of costburdened households in the area. 

The following graph illustrates the 2018 and 2023 median Tax Credit rents among common bedroom types offered in the PSA and Morganton. 

**==> picture [439 x 183] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Tax Credit Median Collected Rents (2018 vs 2023)<br>Morganton 2018 Morganton 2023 PSA 2018 PSA 2023<br>$800<br>$700<br>$600<br>$500<br>$400<br>$300<br>$200<br>$100<br>$0<br>1-Br/1.0-Ba 2-Br/1.0-Ba 2-Br/2.0-Ba 3-Br/2.0-Ba<br>$770<br>$720<br>$675 $675<br>$650 $650<br>$570 $570<br>$481 $477 $455 $475 $455 $475<br>$432 $432<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-15** 

~~**Packet Pg. 168**~~
{97}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following is a distribution of Tax Credit product surveyed by year built for the PSA and Morganton Submarket (Note: The Tax Credit program started in 1986): 

|**Year Built– Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized)**|**Year Built– Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized)**|**Year Built– Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized)**|**Year Built– Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized)**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Year Built**|**Projects**|**Units**|**Vacancy Rate**|
|**Morganton**||||
|1990 to 1999|2|74|0.0%|
|2000 to 2009|2|52|0.0%|
|2010 to present|2|136|0.0%|
|**Burke County (PSA)**||||
|1990 to 1999|2|74|0.0%|
|2000 to 2009|2|52|0.0%|
|2010 to present|3|196|0.0%|



Source: Bowen National Research 

Among the surveyed Tax Credit supply, the largest share (60.9%) of Tax Credit units developed in the PSA was built since 2010. Since the time of the original study in 2018, one new property (Pond View Apartments) containing a total of 60 Tax Credit units has been built in the PSA, representing 18.6% of the total supply of Tax Credit units. Within the Morganton Submarket, slightly over one-half (51.9%) of the Tax Credit units were built since 2010. Overall, the PSA and Morganton Submarket have a relatively modern inventory of Tax Credit rentals, which has increased in recent years. Despite the increase in supply, occupancy rates in the PSA and Morganton remain exceptionally high and wait lists maintained among existing properties demonstrate ongoing demand for such product in the PSA. 

The distribution of Tax Credit units in the PSA and Morganton by year built is shown in the following graph: 

**==> picture [456 x 194] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Tax Credit Units by Year Built<br>Morganton Burke County<br>200<br>175 196<br>150<br>125<br>136<br>100<br>75<br>50 74 74<br>52 52<br>25<br>0<br>1990-1999 2000-2009 2010-present<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-16** 

~~**Packet Pg. 169**~~
{98}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Representatives of Bowen National Research personally visited the surveyed Tax Credit rental projects within the market and rated the exterior quality of each property on a scale of "A" (highest) through "F" (lowest). All properties were rated based on quality and overall appearance (i.e., aesthetic appeal, building appearance, landscaping and grounds appearance). The following is a distribution of the Tax Credit properties by quality rating. 

|**Quality Rating- Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized)**|**Quality Rating- Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized)**|**Quality Rating- Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized)**|**Quality Rating- Tax Credit (Non-Subsidized)**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Quality Rating**|**Projects**|**Total Units**|**Vacancy Rate**|
|**Morganton**||||
|B|3|164|0.0%|
|B-|3|98|0.0%|
|**Burke County (PSA)**||||
|B+|1|60|0.0%|
|B|3|164|0.0%|
|B-|3|98|0.0%|



Source: Bowen National Research 

All of the surveyed Tax Credit projects in the PSA have a quality rating of “B-” or higher, indicating that the Tax Credit product in the market is in good to very good condition. This is not surprising given that five of the seven projects (71.4%) were built since 2000, with one project having been built in 2020. 

Rents for projects operating under federal programs, such as the LIHTC program, are limited to the percent of Area Median Household Income (AMHI) to which the units are specifically restricted. For the purposes of this analysis, we have illustrated programmatic rent limits at 50% of AMHI (typical federal program restrictions), 60% of AMHI, and 80% of AMHI (maximum LIHTC program restrictions) in the following table. It should be noted that all rents are shown as _gross rents_ , meaning they include tenantpaid rents and tenant-paid utilities. 

|**Maximum Allowable AMHI Gross Rents (2023)**<br>**Burke County**|**Maximum Allowable AMHI Gross Rents (2023)**<br>**Burke County**|**Maximum Allowable AMHI Gross Rents (2023)**<br>**Burke County**|**Maximum Allowable AMHI Gross Rents (2023)**<br>**Burke County**|**Maximum Allowable AMHI Gross Rents (2023)**<br>**Burke County**|**Maximum Allowable AMHI Gross Rents (2023)**<br>**Burke County**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Percent**<br>**of AMHI**|**Studio**|**One-**<br>**Bedroom**|**Two-**<br>**Bedroom**|**Three-**<br>**Bedroom**|**Four-**<br>**Bedroom**|
|50%|$625|$669|$802|$927|$1,035|
|60%|$750|$803|$963|$1,113|$1,242|
|80%|$1,000|$1,071|$1,284|$1,484|$1,656|



Source: Novogradac & Company LLP; HUD Office of Policy Development and Research; Bowen National Research 

Maximum allowable rents are subject to change on an annual basis and are only _achievable_ if the project with such rents is marketable. As a result, the preceding rent table should be used as a guide for setting maximum rents under the Tax Credit program, and achievable rents should be determined by using individual market data from this report or a separate site-specific market feasibility study. It is of note, however, that maximum allowable Tax Credit rent levels for Burke County have increased by approximately 30% since our original analysis in 2018. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-17** 

~~**Packet Pg. 170**~~
{99}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## G _overnment-Subsidized Housing_ 

A total of 19 projects were surveyed within the county that offer at least some units that operate with a government subsidy. Government-subsidized housing typically requires residents to pay 30% of their adjusted gross income toward rent and generally qualifies households with incomes of up to 50% of Area Median Household Income (AMHI). The 19 projects with a subsidy include 831 units, of which 134 units also operate with concurrent Tax Credits. A total of 13 of the 19 properties, or 65.3% of the total units, are located within the Morganton Submarket. 

The government-subsidized units surveyed within the PSA (Burke County) and Morganton Submarket are summarized as follows. 

|**Government Subsidized Rental Housing**|**Government Subsidized Rental Housing**|**Government Subsidized Rental Housing**|**Government Subsidized Rental Housing**|**Government Subsidized Rental Housing**|**Government Subsidized Rental Housing**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Bedroom**|**Baths**|**Units**|**Distribution**|**Vacancy**|**% Vacant**|
|**Morganton**||||||
|**Subsidized Tax Credit**||||||
|One-Bedroom|1.0|40|52.6%|0|0.0%|
|Two-Bedroom|1.0|36|47.4%|0|0.0%|
|**Total Subsidized Tax Credit**||**76**|**100.0%**|**0**|**0.0%**|
|**Government Subsidized**||||||
|One-Bedroom|1.0|153|32.8%|1|0.7%|
|One-Bedroom|2.0|11|2.4%|1|9.1%|
|Two-Bedroom|1.0|173|37.0%|0|0.0%|
|Two-Bedroom|1.5|18|3.9%|0|0.0%|
|Three-Bedroom|1.0|86|18.4%|0|0.0%|
|Four-Bedroom|1.5|20|4.3%|0|0.0%|
|Five-Bedroom|2.0|6|1.3%|0|0.0%|
|**Total Subsidized**||**467**|**100.0%**|**2**|**0.4%**|
|**Burke County (PSA)**||||||
|**Subsidized Tax Credit**||||||
|One-Bedroom|1.0|48|35.8%|0|0.0%|
|Two-Bedroom|1.0|60|44.8%|0|0.0%|
|Two-Bedroom|2.0|16|11.9%|0|0.0%|
|Three-Bedroom|1.0|10|7.5%|0|0.0%|
|**Total Subsidized Tax Credit**||**134**|**100.0%**|**0**|**0.0%**|
|**Government Subsidized**||||||
|One-Bedroom|1.0|230|33.0%|1|0.4%|
|One-Bedroom|2.0|11|1.6%|1|9.1%|
|Two-Bedroom|1.0|244|35.0%|0|0.0%|
|Two-Bedroom|1.5|44|6.3%|0|0.0%|
|Three-Bedroom|1.0|129|18.5%|0|0.0%|
|Four-Bedroom|1.5|33|4.7%|0|0.0%|
|Five-Bedroom|2.0|6|0.9%|0|0.0%|
|**Total Subsidized**||**697**|**100.0%**|**2**|**0.3%**|



Source: Bowen National Research 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-18** 

~~**Packet Pg. 171**~~
{100}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The government-subsidized units, including the subsidized Tax Credit units, within the PSA and Morganton Submarket are 99.8% occupied with only two vacancies. In addition, a vast majority of the subsidized projects in the PSA and Morganton Submarket maintain wait lists, with individual wait lists totaling up to 120 households or 18 months for the next available subsidized unit. It is noteworthy that the government-subsidized units were fully occupied at the time of the 2018 analysis, which illustrates the persistent demand for affordable rentals in the market. Based on this research, it is evident that there is substantial pent-up demand for housing that is affordable to very low-income renter households (earning 50% or less of Area Median Household Income). Because of the very limited options available, many very low-income households must consider the non-subsidized multifamily housing options or non-conventional housing options, such as single-family homes, duplexes, or mobile homes. 

We also evaluated the potential number of existing subsidized affordable housing units that are at risk of losing their affordable status. A total of 10 properties in the county operate as subsidized projects under a current HUD contract. Because these contracts have a designated renewal date, it is important to understand if these projects are at risk of an expiring contract in the near future that could result in the reduction of affordable rental housing stock (Note: HUD contract renewal or expiration dates within five years are shown in red). 

|**Expiring HUD Contracts**<br>**Burke County, North Carolina**|**Expiring HUD Contracts**<br>**Burke County, North Carolina**|**Expiring HUD Contracts**<br>**Burke County, North Carolina**|**Expiring HUD Contracts**<br>**Burke County, North Carolina**|**Expiring HUD Contracts**<br>**Burke County, North Carolina**|**Expiring HUD Contracts**<br>**Burke County, North Carolina**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Property Name**|**Total**<br>**Units**|**Assisted**<br>**Units**|**Expiration**<br>**Date**|**Program**<br>**Type **|**Target**<br>**Population**|
|Agape Retirement Home,Inc.|30|30|12/31/2035|202/8 NC|Senior|
|ARC/HDS Burke Co. GH #1|6|5|9/30/2028|202/8 NC|Disabled|
|ARC/HDS Burke Co. GH #3|7|6|12/31/2023|PRAC/811|Disabled|
|Buena Vista Apartments|30|30|8/31/2040|Sec 8 NC|Senior|
|Green Acres Apartments|30|30|3/31/2033|Sec 8 NC|Senior|
|CHC of Burke #1|7|6|8/31/2024|PRAC/811|Disabled|
|CAC of Burke Co./Town Square|11|10|8/31/2024|PRAC/811|Disabled|
|CHC of Burke Co. #2|7|6|2/18/2024|PRAC/811|Disabled|
|Southmont Apartments|26|26|11/30/2040|Sec 8 NC|Senior|
|Valdese Village Apartments|34|34|12/31/2023|515/8 NC|Family|
|Source: HUDUser.gov Assistance & Section 8 Contracts Database (Updated 11.1.23); Bowen National Research||||||



While all HUD supported projects are subject to annual appropriations by the federal government, it appears that six out of 10 total projects in Burke County have overall renewal dates within the next five years and are at a _potential_ risk of losing their government assistance in the near future. Given the high occupancy rates and wait lists among the market’s surveyed subsidized properties, it will be important for the area’s low-income residents that the projects with pending expiring HUD contracts be preserved in order to continue to house some of the market’s most economically vulnerable residents. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-19** 

~~**Packet Pg. 172**~~
{101}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

According to a representative with the Western Piedmont Housing Authority, which distributes vouchers across Burke, Alexander, Caldwell, and Catawba counties, there are approximately 2,675 vouchers issued in the four counties, of which 279 (10.4%) are issued within Burke County. This represents a significant increase in the number of vouchers issued compared to 2018, when 1,074 total vouchers were issued among the four counties. However, it was also noted by housing authority representatives that approximately 124 (4.6%) of the issued vouchers across the four counties are currently going unused, likely due to holders of these vouchers being unable to locate/obtain a quality affordable rental housing unit that will accept the voucher. There is a total of 888 households currently on the waiting list for additional vouchers, which is a decrease from the number of households on the wait list in 2018 (1,203 households). The waiting list is closed, and it is unknown when the waiting list will reopen. Annual turnover within the voucher program is estimated at 202 households. Based on the preceding factors, persons/households which place their names on the waiting list for vouchers in 2023 would likely not have an opportunity to obtain a voucher for more than four years. This reflects the continuing need for affordable housing alternatives and/or Housing Choice Voucher assistance. 

In addition to the Tax Credit program, affordable rental projects can be developed under federal programs that use Fair Market Rents or the HOME Program rents. The following table illustrates the 2023 Fair Market Rents and Low HOME and High HOME rents for Burke County, North Carolina. 

|**Studio**|**One-**<br>**Bedroom**|**Two-**<br>**Bedroom**|**Three-**<br>**Bedroom**|**Four-**<br>**Bedroom**|
|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Fair Market Rents (2023)**|||||
|$646|$650|$791|$1,033|$1,179|
|**Low/High HOME Rent (2023)**|||||
|$625/$646|$650/$650|$791/$791|$927/$1,033|$1,035/$1,179|



Source: HUD Office of Policy Development and Research (huduser.gov) 

The preceding rents, which are updated annually, can be used by developers as a guide for the possible rent structures incorporated at their projects within Burke County. It is also of note that properties with rents set near or below area Fair Market Rent levels often attract voucher holders. Thus, a property with rents similar to Fair Market Rents and/or HOME rent limits could help alleviate some of the pent-up demand for affordable product capable of accommodating voucher holders in the Burke County area. 

The Fair Market Rent for a two-bedroom unit ($791) is significantly lower than the corresponding median rent for a two-bedroom/one-bathroom market-rate unit ($1,175) but higher than the median rent ($477) for the surveyed two-bedroom/one-bathroom non-subsidized Tax Credit units in the PSA. While this likely indicates that Housing Choice Voucher (HCV) 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-20** 

~~**Packet Pg. 173**~~
{102}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

holders would be able to secure a two-bedroom Tax Credit unit with an HCV, the lack of available multifamily Tax Credit units in the PSA suggests most HCV holders must choose from either market-rate rentals, which have significantly higher median collected rents, or non-conventional rentals (typically single-family homes, duplexes, mobile homes, etc.). An analysis of non-conventional rentals is included later in this section. 

A map illustrating the location of all multifamily apartments surveyed within the market is included on the following page. Note the number designations for each property illustrated on the map correspond with the Map ID numbers assigned to each property surveyed as illustrated by the Field Survey of Conventional Rentals (Addendum A). 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-21** 

~~**Packet Pg. 174**~~
{103}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 175**
{104}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## 3. Non-Conventional Rental Housing 

Non-conventional rentals are generally considered rental units consisting of single-family homes, duplexes, units over store fronts, mobile homes, etc. Typically, these rentals are older, offer few amenities, and lack on-site management and maintenance. For the purposes of this analysis, we have assumed that rental properties consisting of four or less units within a structure are non-conventional rentals. Based on data from the American Community Survey (2017-2021), the number and share of units within renter-occupied structures is summarized in the following table: 

|||**Renter-Occupied Housing**<br>**by Units in Structure**|**Renter-Occupied Housing**<br>**by Units in Structure**|**Renter-Occupied Housing**<br>**by Units in Structure**|**Renter-Occupied Housing**<br>**by Units in Structure**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|||**1 to 4 Units**|**5 Units**<br>**or More**|**Mobile Home**<br>**/Other**|<br>**Total**|
|**Morganton**|Number|1,627|1,083|229|2,939|
||Percent|55.4%|36.8%|7.8%|100.0%|
|**Burke County**|Number|4,522|1,645|2,316|8,483|
||Percent|53.3%|19.4%|27.3%|100.0%|
||Number|709,819|500,086|164,257|1,374,162|
|||||||
|**North Carolina**|Percent|51.7%|36.4%|12.0%|100.0%|
|||||||



Source: American Community Survey (2017-2021); ESRI; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research 

As the preceding table illustrates, non-conventional rentals with four or fewer units per structure and mobile homes comprise a vast majority of the local rental housing market, as they represent 80.6% of rental units in the PSA (Burke County). This is a significantly larger share of nonconventional rentals as compared to the share for the state (63.7%). Although non-conventional rentals comprise 63.2% of all rentals in the Morganton Submarket, this is a notably smaller share of non-conventional rentals as compared to the entirety of Burke County. The share of mobile homes in the PSA (27.3%) is much higher than the corresponding shares in the Morganton Submarket (7.8%) and state (12.0%). Given the urban composition of the Morganton Submarket, it is not surprising that the share of mobile homes is smaller and the share of multifamily apartments (36.8%) in the area is notably higher than the PSA. 

The following table summarizes monthly gross rents (per unit) for area rental alternatives within the PSA (Burke County), Morganton Submarket, and the state of North Carolina, based on American Community Survey data. While this data encompasses all rental units, which includes multifamily apartments, a majority (80.6%) of the PSA’s rental supply consists of non-conventional rentals. Therefore, it is reasonable to conclude that the following provides insight into the overall distribution of rents among the non-conventional rental housing units. It should be noted, gross rents include tenant-paid rents and tenant-paid utilities. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-23** 

~~**Packet Pg. 176**~~
{105}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|||**Estimated Monthly Gross Rents by Market**|**Estimated Monthly Gross Rents by Market**|**Estimated Monthly Gross Rents by Market**|**Estimated Monthly Gross Rents by Market**|**Estimated Monthly Gross Rents by Market**|**Estimated Monthly Gross Rents by Market**|**Estimated Monthly Gross Rents by Market**|**Estimated Monthly Gross Rents by Market**|**Estimated Monthly Gross Rents by Market**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|||**<$300**|**$300 -**<br>**$500**|**$500 -**<br>**$750**|**$750 -**<br>**$1,000**|**$1,000 -**<br>**$1,500**|**$1,500 -**<br>**$2,000**|**$2,000+**|**No Cash**<br>**Rent**|**Total**|
|**Morganton**|Number|313|209|884|841|410|89|56|137|2,939|
||Percent|10.6%|7.1%|30.1%|28.6%|14.0%|3.0%|1.9%|4.7%|100.0%|
|**Burke County**|Number|506|785|2,897|2,077|1,021|184|66|947|8,483|
||Percent|6.0%|9.3%|34.2%|24.5%|12.0%|2.2%|0.8%|11.2%|100.0%|
||Number|43,515|72,654|229,027|312,525|434,987|142,282|51,173|88,001|1,374,164|
|**North Carolina**|Percent|3.2%|5.3%|16.7%|22.7%|31.7%|10.4%|3.7%|6.4%|100.0%|



Source: American Community Survey (2017-2021); ESRI; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research 

As the preceding table illustrates, the largest share (34.2%) of PSA (Burke County) rental units have rents between $500 and $750, followed by units with rents between $750 and $1,000 (24.5%). Collectively, units with gross rents below $1,000 account for 74.0% of all PSA rentals, which is a much larger share of such units when compared to the state (47.9%). Overall, this demonstrates the dominance of the lower and moderately priced product among the non-conventional rental units in the market. Regardless, 15.0% of rental units in the PSA have gross rents over $1,000, which illustrates some opportunities exist to achieve premium rents in the market. In addition, these units provide some alternatives to home ownership for higher income residents in the PSA. By comparison, 76.4% of rental units in the Morganton Submarket have rents less than $1,000, while 18.9% have rents of $1,000 or more. 

During October and November 2023, Bowen National Research identified 34 non-conventional rentals that were listed as _available_ for rent in the PSA (Burke County), of which nine are located in the Morganton Submarket. These properties were identified through a variety of online sources. Through this extensive research, we believe that we have identified most vacant non-conventional rentals in the PSA. While these rentals do not represent all non-conventional rentals, they are representative of common characteristics of the various non-conventional rental alternatives available in the area. As a result, these available rentals provide a good baseline to compare the rental rates, number of bedrooms, number of bathrooms, and other features of non-conventional rentals. When compared to the overall non-conventional inventory of the PSA (6,838 units), these 34 units represent an overall vacancy rate of 0.5%, which is considered very low. By comparison, the nine available units in the Morganton Submarket represent a vacancy rate of 0.5%, demonstrating the lack of available nonconventional rentals within Burke County and the Morganton Submarket. It is also noteworthy that the vacancy rate of non-conventional rentals in the PSA reported in our original 2018 analysis was 0.3%, illustrating that availability among non-conventional rentals has been consistently low in the area. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-24** 

~~**Packet Pg. 177**~~
{106}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The available non-conventional rentals identified in the PSA (Burke County) and Morganton Submarket are summarized in the following table. 

|**Available Non-Conventional Rentals**|**Available Non-Conventional Rentals**|**Available Non-Conventional Rentals**|**Available Non-Conventional Rentals**|**Available Non-Conventional Rentals**|**Available Non-Conventional Rentals**|**Available Non-Conventional Rentals**|**Available Non-Conventional Rentals**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Bedroom Type**|**Units**|**Average**<br>**Number**<br>**of Baths**|**Average**<br>**Year**<br>**Built**|**Average**<br>**Square**<br>**Feet**|**Rent**<br>**Range**|**Average**<br>**Rent**|**Average**<br>**Rent Per**<br>**Square**<br>**Foot**|
|**Morganton**||||||||
|One-Bedroom|1|1.0|1907|-|$800|$800|-|
|Two-Bedroom|2|1.5|1922|932|$1,200-$1,400|$1,300|$1.48|
|Three-Bedroom|5|2.0|1969|1,532|$1,500-$2,500|$1,960|$1.32|
|Four-Bedroom|1|3.0|1966|2,700|$2,100|$2,100|$0.78|
|**Burke County (PSA)**||||||||
|One-Bedroom|4|1.0|1929|513|$700-$900|$800|$1.69|
|Two-Bedroom|14|1.5|1969|1,091|$500-$2,500|$1,121|$1.10|
|Three-Bedroom|14|2.0|1982|1,586|$1,000-$2,500|$1,698|$1.14|
|Four-Bedroom|2|2.5|1948|2,400|$2,100-$2,500|$2,300|$0.98|



Sources: Trulia, Rent.com, Rentals.com, Apartments.com, Realtor.com 

The available non-conventional rentals identified in the PSA (Burke County) have rents ranging from $500 to $2,500, depending on the bedroom type. Two- and three-bedroom units, which comprise the largest individual shares (41.2%, each) of the available units in the PSA, have average rents of approximately $1,121 to $1,698, respectively. The average rents for these bedroom types represent increases of 80.8% and 116.6% when compared to the average rents for the same bedroom types in 2018 ($620 and $784, respectively). When typical tenant utility costs (at least $200) are also considered, the inventoried non-conventional two-bedroom units have an average _gross_ rent of approximately $1,321, while the average gross rent for a three-bedroom unit is $1,898. The average rents for both bedroom types are moderately higher than the typical rents for a comparable marketrate apartment ($1,200 and $1,400) and significantly higher than the typical Tax Credit apartment ($675 and $720) in the PSA with the same configuration. As such, it is unlikely that low-income residents would be able to afford most non-conventional rental housing in the area, even if units were available. Based on this analysis, the inventory of available nonconventional rentals is limited and typical rents for this product indicate that such housing is not a viable alternative for most lower income households in either the PSA or Morganton Submarket. 

A map delineating the location of identified non-conventional rentals currently available to rent in the PSA (Burke County) and Morganton Submarket is included on the following page. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-25** 

~~**Packet Pg. 178**~~
{107}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 179**
{108}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## 4. Vacation Rental Housing 

The PSA (Burke County) is a popular tourist destination due to the variety of outdoor activities offered in the area and attractions such as Lake James and Lake James State Park. As such, short-term vacation rentals and second homes comprise a notable share of the PSA housing market, particularly in certain areas of the county. This section of analysis attempts to estimate the influence of short-term rentals and second homes in Burke County and the effect on the overall housing market. 

In an effort to quantify the share that seasonal and recreational homes comprise of the overall housing market in the PSA, the following table illustrates the number of homes classified as “Seasonal or Recreational Units” by the U.S. Census and American Community Survey (ACS). While this data does not specifically identify whether a housing unit is a short-term rental or a second home, it provides a reasonably accurate estimate for the number of homes that are not readily available for long-term occupancy (rental or for-sale) in the market. While a notable share of these homes in an area likely indicates a robust tourism base, it can contribute to housing shortages for permanent residents if long-term housing options are absorbed by this market. Positive changes between time periods in the following table are illustrated in green, while negative changes are illustrated in red. 

|||**Seasonal/Recreational Housing Units- 2010/2021**|**Seasonal/Recreational Housing Units- 2010/2021**|**Seasonal/Recreational Housing Units- 2010/2021**|**Seasonal/Recreational Housing Units- 2010/2021**|**Seasonal/Recreational Housing Units- 2010/2021**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|||**Seasonal/**<br>**Recreational**<br>**Units**|**Total Vacant**<br>**Units**|**Total Housing**<br>**Units**|**Seasonal/**<br>**Recreational**<br>**% of Total**<br>**Vacant Units**|**Seasonal/**<br>**Recreational**<br>**% of Total**<br>**Housing Units**|
|**Morganton**|2010|65|984|7,675|6.6%|0.8%|
||2021|34|969|7,231|3.5%|0.5%|
||% Change|**-47.7%**|**-1.5%**|**-5.8%**|**-47.0%**|**-37.5%**|
|**Burke County**|2010|882|5,072|40,836|17.4%|2.2%|
||2021|1,101|5,266|39,642|20.9%|2.8%|
||% Change|**24.8%**|**3.8%**|**-2.9%**|**20.1%**|**27.3%**|
|**North Carolina**|2010|191,508|582,373|4,327,516|32.9%|4.4%|
||2021|197,746|639,094|4,673,733|30.9%|4.2%|
||% Change|**3.3%**|**9.7%**|**8.0%**|**-6.1%**|**-4.5%**|



Source: 2010 Census; American Community Survey (2017-2021); ESRI; Urban Decision Group; Bowen National Research 

As the preceding illustrates, a total 1,101 units representing approximately 2.8% of the total housing units in the PSA (Burke County) in 2021 were classified as seasonal/recreational, which represents a smaller share of such units as compared to the state (4.2%). However, between 2010 and 2021, the number of seasonal/recreational units in the PSA increased by 24.8%, a much higher rate of increase as compared to the increase for the state (3.3%). Within the Morganton Submarket, seasonal/recreational units only comprise 0.5% of all housing units in the area, and this share has decreased since 2010. As such, it is apparent that seasonal/recreational units have 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-27** 

~~**Packet Pg. 180**~~
{109}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

minimal influence on the housing market in the Morganton Submarket. Overall, the influence of seasonal/recreational units on the PSA housing market appears to be comparably less than the influence statewide; however, the prevalence of these units in Burke County has increased over time. Additionally, the influence of seasonal/recreational units likely increases in specific portions of the PSA which are in close proximity to area tourist attractions. A detailed analysis of the seasonal/recreational housing segment is presented on the following pages, which includes maps illustrating the location and concentration of the seasonal/recreational units identified in the PSA. 

The following table illustrates the number and share of short-term rentals by bedroom type in the PSA (Burke County) based on data provided by AllTheRooms, a market intelligence company that provides data related to short-term rental markets throughout the country. While this data likely does not identify all short-term rental properties within the PSA due to various advertising resources, the data utilizes listings from Airbnb and Vrbo, which are generally considered two of the leading companies in the online marketplace for short-term and vacation rentals. As such, the data illustrated is highly representative of the typical short-term rental housing in the market, and likely encompasses a significant portion of the total shortterm rental units within the area. 

|**Burke County Short-Term Rentals by Bedroom Type**<br>**Active Listings (Last 30 Days) as of January 1, 2024**|**Burke County Short-Term Rentals by Bedroom Type**<br>**Active Listings (Last 30 Days) as of January 1, 2024**|**Burke County Short-Term Rentals by Bedroom Type**<br>**Active Listings (Last 30 Days) as of January 1, 2024**|**Burke County Short-Term Rentals by Bedroom Type**<br>**Active Listings (Last 30 Days) as of January 1, 2024**|**Burke County Short-Term Rentals by Bedroom Type**<br>**Active Listings (Last 30 Days) as of January 1, 2024**|**Burke County Short-Term Rentals by Bedroom Type**<br>**Active Listings (Last 30 Days) as of January 1, 2024**|**Burke County Short-Term Rentals by Bedroom Type**<br>**Active Listings (Last 30 Days) as of January 1, 2024**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Bedroom Type**|**Airbnb**<br>**Listings**|**Airbnb**<br>**Share**|**Vrbo**<br>**Listings**|**Vrbo**<br>**Share**|**Total**<br>**Listings**|**Total**<br>**Share**|
|Studio|6|3.2%|0|0.0%|6|2.9%|
|One-Bedroom|68|36.2%|3|15.0%|71|34.1%|
|Two-Bedroom|52|27.7%|7|35.0%|59|28.4%|
|Three-Bedroom|42|22.3%|6|30.0%|48|23.1%|
|Four-Bedroom|17|9.0%|4|20.0%|21|10.1%|
|Five-Bedroom+|3|1.6%|0|0.0%|3|1.4%|
|Total|188|100.0%|20|100.0%|208|100.0%|



Source: AllTheRooms; Bowen National Research 

As the preceding illustrates, there are approximately 208 active listings for Airbnb and Vrbo units in the PSA (Burke County). Of these, one- and twobedroom units comprise the largest shares (34.1% and 28.4%, respectively) of short-term rentals in the PSA. Three-bedroom units also comprise a notable share (23.1%) of the total short-term rentals in the area. However, it is important to understand that the number of short-term rentals is likely much higher than illustrated because this data only encompasses listings that have been active (listed as available for rent) in the last 30 days. As such, second homes that are currently occupied by the owner and not available for rent during this time span will not be included in these totals. Regardless, this data illustrates a reasonable approximation of the distribution of short-term rentals by bedroom type in the PSA. 

**==> picture [574 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Packet Pg. 181<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-28**
{110}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

While second homes do not represent a viable _long-term_ occupancy option for households in an area because they are likely occupied by the owner for at least part of the year, short-term rentals and vacation homes are also typically unaffordable as a permanent residence due to the high daily rates charged. In an effort to demonstrate why these homes are not reasonable options for long-term occupancy, and to illustrate the financial incentive of owners to rent these homes on a short-term/vacation basis, the following table illustrates the average daily rates by bedroom type from 2020 to 2023 for the Airbnb and Vrbo listed rentals in the PSA. The monthly equivalent rent if the unit were occupied for an entire month is also supplied based on the average rent from 2020 to 2023 for each bedroom type. Note that the rates listed for each bedroom type encompass the average for the entire year and likely fluctuate in any given month based on the peak tourism months for the area. 

|**Average Daily Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|**Average Daily Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|**Average Daily Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|**Average Daily Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|**Average Daily Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|**Average Daily Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|**Average Daily Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|**Average Daily Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Airbnb Listings**||||||||
|**Bedroom Type**|**2020**|**2021**|**2022**|**2023**|**Average**<br>**2020-2023**|**% Change**<br>**2020-2023**|**Monthly**<br>**Equivalent**|
|Studio|$66|$113|$139|$139|$114|110.6%|$3,475|
|One-Bedroom|$86|$94|$105|$114|$100|32.6%|$3,034|
|Two-Bedroom|$118|$124|$134|$136|$128|15.3%|$3,893|
|Three-Bedroom|$170|$184|$186|$193|$183|13.5%|$5,574|
|Four-Bedroom|$165|$165|$235|$312|$219|89.1%|$6,669|
|Five-Bedroom+|$378|$382|$394|$392|$387|3.7%|$11,756|
|Total|$118|$124|$139|$157|$135|33.1%|$4,091|
|**Vrbo Listings**||||||||
|**Bedroom Type**|**2020**|**2021**|**2022**|**2023**|**Average**<br>**2020-2023**|**% Change**<br>**2020-2023**|**Monthly**<br>**Equivalent**|
|Studio|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|
|One-Bedroom|$143|$167|$136|$122|$142|-14.7%|$4,319|
|Two-Bedroom|$196|$190|$197|$204|$197|4.1%|$5,985|
|Three-Bedroom|$270|$245|$233|$259|$252|-4.1%|$7,657|
|Four-Bedroom|$343|$322|$225|$369|$315|7.6%|$9,574|
|Five-Bedroom+|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|
|Total|$251|$241|$214|$228|$234|-9.2%|$7,102|



Source: AllTheRooms; Bowen National Research N/A – Not Available 

As the preceding illustrates, average _daily_ rental rates by bedroom type for the Airbnb listings between 2020 and 2023 range from $100 (one-bedroom) to $387 (five-bedroom or larger), which is equivalent to approximately $3,034 to $11,756 per _month_ . Similarly, the average daily rental rates for the Vrbo listings range from $142 (one-bedroom) to $315 (four-bedroom), which is the equivalent of $4,319 to $9,574 per month. Although the preceding calculations are based on the unit being occupied each day during a given month, the data illustrates the premiums that these rentals can achieve and demonstrates the financial motivation to build vacation rentals and/or convert existing housing stock into a short-term rental. It is also apparent that these homes do not represent viable long-term housing options for households due to the cost. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-29** 

~~**Packet Pg. 182**~~
{111}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following table illustrates the average annual occupancy rate by bedroom type for the Airbnb and Vrbo listed rentals in the PSA from 2020 to 2023. 

|**Average Occupancy Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|**Average Occupancy Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|**Average Occupancy Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|**Average Occupancy Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|**Average Occupancy Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|**Average Occupancy Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|**Average Occupancy Rate by Bedroom Type by Year**<br>**Burke County Short-Term Rentals**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Airbnb Listings**|||||||
|**Bedroom Type**|**2020**|**2021**|**2022**|**2023**|**Average**<br>**2020-2023**|**% Change**<br>**2020-2023**|
|Studio|18%|26%|28%|9%|20.3%|-50.0%|
|One-Bedroom|53%|60%|51%|43%|51.8%|-18.9%|
|Two-Bedroom|51%|59%|52%|42%|51.0%|-17.6%|
|Three-Bedroom|39%|59%|47%|40%|46.3%|2.6%|
|Four-Bedroom|51%|59%|44%|44%|49.5%|-13.7%|
|Five-Bedroom+|16%|21%|28%|38%|25.8%|137.5%|
|Total|48%|58%|49%|41%|49.0%|-14.6%|
|**Vrbo Listings**|||||||
|**Bedroom Type**|**2020**|**2021**|**2022**|**2023**|**Average**<br>**2020-2023**|**% Change**<br>**2020-2023**|
|Studio|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|
|One-Bedroom|35%|37%|36%|29%|34.3%|-17.1%|
|Two-Bedroom|36%|40%|33%|23%|33.0%|-36.1%|
|Three-Bedroom|38%|40%|30%|22%|32.5%|-42.1%|
|Four-Bedroom|24%|37%|35%|22%|29.5%|-8.3%|
|Five-Bedroom+|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|
|Total|33%|39%|32%|23%|31.8%|-30.3%|



Source: AllTheRooms; Bowen National Research 

Between 2020 and 2023, the overall annual occupancy rate for short-term rentals in the PSA ranges from 31.8% (Vrbo) to 49.0% (Airbnb). Among the Airbnb listed units, one-bedroom units have the highest average occupancy rate (51.8%), followed by two-bedroom (51.0%) and fourbedroom (49.5%) units. While one-bedroom (34.3%) and two-bedroom (33.0%) units also have the highest average occupancy rates among the Vrbo units, three-bedroom units have the third highest occupancy rate (32.5%). Regardless, the preceding data illustrates that, on average, shortterm rentals in the PSA are occupied approximately one-third to one-half of the year. 

While the preceding table encompasses _annual_ occupancy data since 2020, it should be noted that many areas with elevated levels of tourism experience a peak season during certain months of the year. In an effort to better understand the seasonal effect on the short-term rental industry and illustrate the peak tourism months for the area, the following table shows the average daily rate, average occupancy rate, and average monthly revenue per listing for _Airbnb_ rentals for the previous two years. Note that the months with the three highest occupancy rates and average monthly revenues during each year are illustrated in red text. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-30** 

~~**Packet Pg. 183**~~
{112}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|**Burke County Short-Term Rental Market Metrics by Month***|**Burke County Short-Term Rental Market Metrics by Month***|**Burke County Short-Term Rental Market Metrics by Month***|**Burke County Short-Term Rental Market Metrics by Month***|**Burke County Short-Term Rental Market Metrics by Month***|**Burke County Short-Term Rental Market Metrics by Month***|**Burke County Short-Term Rental Market Metrics by Month***|**Burke County Short-Term Rental Market Metrics by Month***|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Month**|**Average**<br>**Daily**<br>**Rate**|**Average**<br>**Occupancy**<br>**Rate**|**Average**<br>**Monthly**<br>**Revenue**|**Month**|**Average**<br>**Daily**<br>**Rate**|**Average**<br>**Occupancy**<br>**Rate**|**Average**<br>**Monthly**<br>**Revenue**|
|January 2022|$114|41%|$1,217|January 2023|$157|36%|$1,348|
|February 2022|$127|41%|$1,302|February 2023|$153|40%|$1,409|
|March 2022|$121|48%|$1,571|March 2023|$152|**44%**|$1,726|
|April 2022|$132|**57%**|**$1,949**|April 2023|$144|41%|$1,279|
|May 2022|$127|53%|$1,810|May 2023|$157|43%|$1,425|
|June 2022|$137|54%|$1,894|June 2023|$152|42%|$1,345|
|July 2022|$143|**61%**|**$2,329**|July 2023|$169|**44%**|**$1,899**|
|August 2022|$145|45%|$1,726|August 2023|$159|35%|$1,580|
|September 2022|$143|43%|$1,541|September 2023|$151|43%|$1,736|
|October 2022|$154|**57%**|**$2,189**|October 2023|$164|**49%**|**$2,111**|
|November 2022|$141|48%|$1,585|November 2023|$170|43%|**$1,923**|
|December 2022|$171|41%|$1,846|December 2023|$155|23%|$435|



Source: AllTheRooms; Bowen National Research *Only includes data for Airbnb listed properties 

As the preceding illustrates, the months with the three highest average occupancy rates and average monthly revenues in 2022 were April, July, and October. Similarly, the highest occupancy rates in 2023 were during the months of March, July, and October, while the months with the highest average monthly revenues were July, October, and November. It is notable, however, that there is not a large decrease in occupancy rates during any specific time of the year and the peak months are not contiguous in either year. This is indicative of a short-term rental market that does not exhibit a typical peak season that is associated with most markets. As such, it appears that the PSA (Burke County) benefits from tourism year-round. While this data further provides the financial motivation for property owners to collect consistent revenues for short-term rentals, it also illustrates that these properties do not represent housing options for area residents, even on a short-term basis, due to availability and costs. 

Overall, short-term vacation rentals play a vital role in the tourism industry within Burke County and are an important element of the local economy. This provides a significant financial incentive for entrepreneurs to build new units, convert existing permanent housing units, and rent second homes when not being personally utilized. According to the 2022 Economic Impact Study published by Visit North Carolina, visitors to Burke County spent nearly $134 million within the county during 2022, which represents an increase of 10.3% over 2021. While only 2.8% of the total housing units in the PSA were seasonal/recreational in 2021, this share increased by 27.3% between 2010 and 2021. Although this growth is critical in order to continue to expand the area’s tourism base, it will be important to monitor the local housing supply to ensure adequate and income-appropriate housing is available to the permanent residents of Burke County. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-31** 

~~**Packet Pg. 184**~~
{113}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

A map delineating the location of identified short-term/vacation rentals in the area is on the following page, followed by maps illustrating various metrics associated with seasonal/recreational housing by census tracts in the PSA (Burke County). Note that due to differences in how these properties are identified, data points considered when generating the following maps may not align. Specifically, the “vacation” homes identified through sources such as Airbnb and Vrbo may not have been considered/identified as a “seasonal” unit by the owners as part of the American Community Survey. Nonetheless, the following maps illustrate where concentrations of vacation/seasonal homes are most likely to be located throughout the PSA (Burke County). 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-32** 

~~**Packet Pg. 185**~~
{114}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 186**
{115}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 187**
{116}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 188**
{117}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **C.  FOR-SALE HOUSING SUPPLY** 

## 1. Introduction 

Bowen National Research obtained for-sale housing data from the local Multiple Listing Service provider for all of Burke County. This included historical for-sale residential data and currently available for-sale housing stock. While this sales data does not include all for-sale residential transactions or available supply in the county, it does consist of the majority of such product and therefore, it is representative of market norms for forsale housing product. The available supply does not include foreclosures, auctions, or for-sale by owner housing. _It should also be noted that, due to limited available data, 2020 historical sales data is not included within this analysis._ 

The following table summarizes the available and recently sold homes for the Morganton Submarket and Burke County (PSA). 

|**Sold/Currently Available For-Sale Housing Supply**|**Sold/Currently Available For-Sale Housing Supply**|**Sold/Currently Available For-Sale Housing Supply**|**Sold/Currently Available For-Sale Housing Supply**|**Sold/Currently Available For-Sale Housing Supply**|
|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Status**|**Homes**|**Median Price (2023)**|**Median Price (2018)^**|**Median Price % Change**<br>**2018-2023**|
|**Morganton**|||||
|Sold*|660|$229,500|$128,750|78.3%|
|Available**|24|$289,950|$189,000|53.4%|
|**Burke County (PSA)**|||||
|Sold*|3,311|$210,000|$120,000|75.0%|
|Available**|125|$289,000|$179,450|61.0%|



Source: Multiple Listing Service (MLS) 

*Sales from January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023 (Excludes 2020 sales data); **As of October 31, 2023 

^2018 sold data reflects inventory from January 2014 to January 2018; 2018 available data reflects inventory as of January 24, 2018 

Within the PSA (Burke County), 3,311 homes were sold between January 1, 2019 and October 31, 2023 (excluding 2020) at a median sales price of $210,000. This equates to an average of approximately 72 homes sold per month, or an annualized average of around 864 homes sold during this time. The for-sale housing stock _available_ as of October 31, 2023 within the PSA consists of 125 units with a median list price of $289,000. By comparison, 660 homes were sold in the Morganton Submarket between January 1, 2019 and October 31, 2023 at a median sales price of $229,500. This is equivalent to approximately 14 homes sold per month, or an annualized average of 168 homes sold during this time period. The current available for-sale housing stock in the Morganton Submarket consists of 24 homes at a median list price of $289,950, which is comparable to the median list price of the available homes in the PSA. The data also illustrates that the median price of the available for-sale homes increased by 61.0% in the PSA and 53.4% in the Morganton Submarket between 2018 and 2023. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-36** 

~~**Packet Pg. 189**~~
{118}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## 2. Historical For-Sale Analysis 

The following table illustrates the annual sales activity from January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023 for each study area, with full year sales volume projections for 2023 shown in parenthesis. 

||**Sales History by Year (2019 through 2023*) **|**Sales History by Year (2019 through 2023*) **|**Sales History by Year (2019 through 2023*) **|**Sales History by Year (2019 through 2023*) **|**Sales History by Year (2019 through 2023*) **|**Sales History by Year (2019 through 2023*) **|**Sales History by Year (2019 through 2023*) **|**Sales History by Year (2019 through 2023*) **|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Year**|**Morganton**||||**Burke County (PSA)**||||
||**Number**<br>**Sold**|**Percent**<br>**Change**|**Median**<br>**Sales Price**|**Percent**<br>**Change**|**Number**<br>**Sold**|**Percent**<br>**Change**|**Median**<br>**Sales Price**|**Percent**<br>**Change**|
|2019|168|-|$171,000|-|773|-|$160,000|-|
|2020|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|N/A|
|2021|188|-|$224,500|-|985|-|$205,000|-|
|2022|172|-8.5%|$257,750|14.8%|899|-8.7%|$230,000|12.2%|
|2023*|132<br>(159)|-23.3%<br>(-7.6%)|$287,450|11.5%|654<br>(788)|-27.1%<br>(-12.3%)|$250,000|8.7%|



Source: Multiple Listing Service (MLS) N/A – Not Available *As of October 31, 2023 (Full year projection shown in parenthesis) 

The median sales price of homes sold within the PSA (Burke County) increased by 56.3% between January 1, 2019 and October 31, 2023. While the number of homes sold annually in the PSA increased between 2019 and 2021, it is noteworthy that sales volume decreased by 8.7% in 2022, and it is projected that volume will decrease by 12.3% year over year in 2023. Within the Morganton Submarket the median sales price of homes sold increased by 68.1% between January 1, 2019 and October 23, 2023. Similar to the PSA, sales volume within the submarket increased between 2019 and 2021, but decreased in 2022 (8.5%). Additionally, the number of home sales in the Morganton Submarket is projected to decrease by 7.6% in 2023 based on the sales volume through October 31, 2023. The recent decline in home sales is likely attributed to rising interest rates and/or construction costs during this time period. These factors combined with the continued increase in sales/listing prices likely create challenges for some potential buyers while others decide to delay their purchase. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-37** 

~~**Packet Pg. 190**~~
{119}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Recent home sales volume and median price by year for the PSA (Burke County) are illustrated in the following graphs: 

**==> picture [441 x 467] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Morganton Annual Sales/Median Price (2019-2023*)<br>Number Sold Median Price<br>200 $290,000<br>$287,450<br>175 188 $275,000<br>172<br>150 168 $260,000<br>159<br>$257,750<br>125 $245,000<br>100 $224,500  $230,000<br>75 $215,000<br>50 $200,000<br>25 $185,000<br>$171,000<br>0 $170,000<br>2019 2021 2022 2023*<br>Burke County Annual Sales/Median Price (2019-2023*)<br>Number Sold Median Price<br>1,000 $250,000<br>985 $250,000<br>$240,000<br>800 899 $230,000<br>773 $230,000  788<br>$220,000<br>600<br>$205,000  $210,000<br>$200,000<br>400<br>$190,000<br>200 $180,000<br>$170,000<br>$160,000<br>0 $160,000<br>2019 2021 2022 2023*<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


*Excludes 2020 sales data (unavailable); 2023 full year projection 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-38** 

~~**Packet Pg. 191**~~
{120}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The distribution of homes sold between January 2019 and October 2023 (excluding 2020) by _price point_ for the PSA and Morganton Submarket is summarized in the following table. 

||**Sales History by Price (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)***|**Sales History by Price (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)***|**Sales History by Price (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)***|**Sales History by Price (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)***|**Sales History by Price (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)***|**Sales History by Price (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)***|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Sales Price**|**Morganton**|||**Burke County (PSA)**|||
||**Number**<br>**Sold**|**Percent**<br>**of Supply**|**Average Days**<br>**on Market**|**Number**<br>**Sold**|**Percent**<br>**of Supply**|**Average Days**<br>**on Market**|
|Up to $99,999|48|7.3%|82|338|10.2%|78|
|$100,000 to $199,999|220|33.3%|75|1,210|36.5%|79|
|$200,000 to $299,999|206|31.2%|75|935|28.2%|77|
|$300,000 to $399,999|111|16.8%|88|451|13.6%|84|
|$400,000+|75|11.4%|107|377|11.4%|109|
|Total|660|100.0%|81|3,311|100.0%|83|



Source: Multiple Listing Service (MLS) *Excludes 2020 sales data 

As the preceding table illustrates, home sales by price point within the PSA between 2019 and 2023 were primarily concentrated among product priced between $100,000 and $199,999 (36.5%). A notable share (28.2%) of product sold was priced between $200,000 and $299,999, while one-quarter (25.0%) of recent sales were priced at $300,000 or higher. While product that sold for less than $400,000 had an average number of days on market of 84 days or less, product priced at $400,000 and higher had an average number of days on market of 109 days. This indicates demand for affordable and moderately priced for-sale housing may be slightly greater than the higher priced for-sale alternatives. Within the Morganton Submarket, slightly larger shares of product sold for between $200,000 and $299,999 (31.2%) and $300,000 or higher (28.2%) compared to the PSA. Subsequently, homes priced below $200,000 within Morganton comprised a lower share (40.6%) than that reported for the PSA (46.7%). It is noteworthy that, at the time of the 2018 study, the shares of historical sales (between 2014 and 2018) that sold for less than $200,000 in the PSA (81.4%) and Morganton Submarket (79.8%) were significantly greater than those reported at the time of this analysis. Additionally, the overall average number of days on market in the PSA (83 days) and Morganton (81 days) are notably lower than those reported in our original analysis conducted in 2018. Specifically, historic homes sales data evaluated at the time of our 2018 analysis revealed that Burke County homes experienced an overall average of 172 days on market, while those within Morganton were on the market for approximately 179 days on average. Thus, while home prices have steadily increased since 2018, so has demand. This is likely due in part to the more limited supply of for-sale product within the county in recent years, resulting in prospective buyers having to act more rapidly when homes that meet their needs become available. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-39** 

~~**Packet Pg. 192**~~
{121}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Recent home sales by _price point_ in the PSA is shown in the following graph: 

**==> picture [449 x 541] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Sales History by Price<br>Morganton Burke County<br>1,400<br>1,200<br>1,210<br>1,000<br>800 935<br>600<br>400<br>220 206 451<br>377<br>200 48 338 111 75<br>0<br>Up to $99,999 $100k- $200k- $300k- $400,000+<br>$199,999 $299,999 $399,999<br>The following graph illustrates the change in average number of days on<br>market since 2018:<br>Change in Average Days on Market (2018 vs 2023)<br>Avg. Days on Market 2018* Avg. Days on Market 2023**<br>180<br>179<br>160 172<br>140<br>120<br>100<br>80<br>81 83<br>60<br>40<br>20<br>0<br>Morganton Burke County<br>*Sales from January 2014 to January 2018<br>**Sales from January 2019 through October 2023<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-40** 

~~**Packet Pg. 193**~~
{122}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following table illustrates recent home sales for the study areas by _bedroom type._ 

|**Sales History by Bedroom Type (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Bedroom Type (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Bedroom Type (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Bedroom Type (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Bedroom Type (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Bedroom Type (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Bedroom Type (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Bedroom Type (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Bedroom Type (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Bedrooms**|**Number**<br>**Sold**|**Average**<br>**Baths**|**Average**<br>**Square**<br>**Feet***|**Average**<br>**Year**<br>**Built**|**Price**<br>**Range**|**Median**<br>**Sales Price**|**Median**<br>**Price per**<br>**Sq. Ft.***|**Average**<br>**Days on**<br>**Market**|
|**Morganton**|||||||||
|Studio/One-Br.|5|1|877|1938|$75,000-$435,000|$92,500|$155.68|83|
|Two-Br.|155|1|1,127|1950|$30,000-$312,000|$147,600|$131.58|153|
|Three-Br.|320|2|1,784|1969|$37,000-$794,900|$231,250|$138.73|76|
|Four-Br.|155|3|2,711|1965|$83,500-$942,500|$310,000|$122.77|97|
|Five+-Br.|25|3.5|3,483|1968|$172,000-$1,150,000|$389,400|$140.64|152|
|Total|660|2|1,908|1963|$30,000-$1,150,000|$229,500|$132.33|81|
|**Burke County (PSA)**|||||||||
|Studio/One-Br.|34|1|950|1967|$46,000-$435,000|$109,500|$147.09|88|
|Two-Br.|674|1|1,178|1957|$9,100-$2,895,000|$149,900|$139.19|72|
|Three-Br.|2,071|2|1,718|1989|$9,000-$2,300,000|$220,000|$138.24|78|
|Four-Br.|450|3|2,667|1977|$35,000-$3,800,000|$300,000|$123.85|107|
|Five+-Br.|82|3.5|3,561|1970|$150,000-$1,710,000|$377,000|$123.21|132|
|Total|3,311|2|3,266|1980|$9,000-$3,800,000|$210,000|$135.96|82|



Source: Multiple Listing Service (MLS) 

*Excludes 4 listings from Morganton and 45 listings from PSA with no square footage information ^Excludes 2020 sales data 

Three-bedroom units comprise the largest share of recent sales by bedroom type in both the PSA (Burke County) and Morganton Submarket. Within the PSA, three-bedroom units represent 62.5% of the units sold during the time period. These three-bedroom homes have a median sales price of $220,000 and have the second shortest average number of days on market (78 days). This represents an increase of 76.1% in the median sales price for this bedroom type since the time of the previous study in 2018 ($124,950) which analyzed historical sales between 2014 and 2018. Twobedroom units in the PSA, which comprise 20.4% of historical sales, have a median sales price of $149,900. Similarly, the median sales price for historical sales increased by 92.2% for this bedroom type since the previous study. Within the Morganton Submarket, three-bedroom units also account for the largest share (48.5%) of recent home sales. The median sales price for this common bedroom type in the submarket ($231,250) is 5.1% higher than the corresponding median sales price within the PSA. Similar to the PSA, the historical sales price for this bedroom type in the Morganton Submarket increased 74.0% since the previous study in 2018 ($132,900). 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-41** 

~~**Packet Pg. 194**~~
{123}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Recent home sales by bedroom type in the PSA (Burke County) and Morganton are shown in the following graph: 

**==> picture [445 x 193] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Sales History by Bedrooms<br>Morganton Burke County<br>2,250<br>2,000<br>2,071<br>1,750<br>1,500<br>1,250<br>1,000<br>750<br>500 674 320<br>155 155<br>250 5 34 450 25 82<br>0<br>Studio/One-Br. Two-Br. Three-Br. Four-Br. Five+-Br.<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Recent home sales by _year built_ for the PSA (Burke County) and Morganton Submarket are illustrated in the following table. 

|**Sales History by Year Built (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Year Built (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Year Built (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Year Built (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Year Built (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Year Built (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Year Built (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|**Sales History by Year Built (January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2023)^**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Year Built**|**Number**<br>**Sold**|**Average**<br>**Beds/Baths**|**Average**<br>**Square**<br>**Feet****|**Price**<br>**Range**|**Median**<br>**Sales Price**|**Median**<br>**Price per**<br>**Sq. Ft.****|**Average**<br>**Days on**<br>**Market**|
|**Morganton**||||||||
|Before 1970|405|3/2|1,766|$30,000-$770,000|$198,000|$124.45|82|
|1970 to 1979|76|3/2|2,078|$80,000-$942,500|$247,500|$131.75|73|
|1980 to 1989|52|3/2|1,851|$105,000-$480,000|$258,750|$138.15|72|
|1990 to 1999|44|3/2.5|2,199|$85,000-$1,150,000|$278,250|$151.05|83|
|2000 to 2009|47|3/2.5|2,305|$79,100-$593,000|$315,000|$144.15|74|
|2010 to present|36|3/2.5|2,340|$102,000-$695,000|$376,750|$165.01|114|
|Total|660|3/2|1,908|$30,000-$1,150,000|$229,500|$132.33|81|
|**Burke County (PSA)**||||||||
|Before 1970|1,308|3/2|1,584|$9,100-$2,300,000|$178,535|$128.72|79|
|1970 to 1979|428|3/2|1,857|$9,000-$942,500|$210,000|$127.54|82|
|1980 to 1989|300|3/2|1,738|$14,000-$3,800,000|$209,000|$129.92|80|
|1990 to 1999|413|3/2|1,845|$13,000-$1,525,000|$195,000|$127.32|82|
|2000 to 2009|482|3/2.5|2,072|$38,500-$2,895,000|$255,000|$144.20|85|
|2010 to present|376|3/2.5|1,944|$46,000-$2,282,661|$307,500|$185.52|95|
|Total|3,307*|3/2|3,266|$9,000-$3,800,000|$210,000|$135.96|82|



Source: Multiple Listing Service (MLS) *Excludes 4 listings from PSA with no year-built information **Excludes 4 listings from Morganton and 45 listings from PSA with no square footage information ^Excludes 2020 sales data 

Approximately 39.6% of recent home sales in the PSA have been homes built prior to 1970. Homes built during this development period have a median sales price of $178,535, which is the lowest median sales price among the various development periods. In addition to the age of these homes, this is also likely attributed to the smaller average size (1,584 square 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-42** 

~~**Packet Pg. 195**~~
{124}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

feet) of homes built during this development period. While these homes may be affordable to many lower income households and first-time homebuyers in the area, these older homes are more likely to require repairs or modernization compared to homes built in later development periods. Overall, the distribution of homes by development period is relatively balanced among the remaining cohorts (between 9.1% and 14.6%). Homes built in the newest development period (2010 to present) in the PSA have the highest median sales price ($307,500) and highest median price per square foot ($185.52) of any development period. 

Within the Morganton Submarket, homes built prior to 1970 comprise a notably larger share (61.4%) of recent home sales in the area. As such, it appears that owner-occupied homes in the submarket are typically older than homes in the entirety of the PSA. Regardless, homes built during this development period in the Morganton Submarket have a median sales price of $198,000, which is 10.9% higher than the median price of homes built during the same development period in the PSA. While the average number of days on market for historical sales in the PSA (82 days) and Morganton Submarket (81 days) are relatively low, homes built during the most recent development period in the study areas have the highest average number of days on market (95 and 114 days, respectively). This is likely due to the higher prices for these modern homes, as compared to homes built during the older development periods. 

Recent home sales by _year built_ in the PSA and Morganton are shown in the following graphs: 

**==> picture [441 x 233] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Morganton Sales History by Year Built (w/ Median Price)<br>Number Sold Median Price<br>450 $380,000<br>400 $376,750  $360,000<br>405<br>350 $340,000<br>$315,000<br>$320,000<br>300<br>$300,000<br>250 $278,250<br>$280,000<br>200 $258,750<br>$247,500  $260,000<br>150<br>$240,000<br>100 $220,000<br>$198,000<br>50 76 $200,000<br>52 44 47 36<br>0 $180,000<br>Before 1970 1970-79 1980-89 1990-99 2000-09 2010 to present<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-43** 

~~**Packet Pg. 196**~~
{125}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

**==> picture [441 x 234] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Burke County Sales History by Year Built (w/ Median Price)<br>Number Sold Median Price<br>1,400 $310,000<br>$307,500  $295,000<br>1,200 1,308<br>$280,000<br>1,000<br>$265,000<br>800 $255,000  $250,000<br>600 $235,000<br>$210,000  $220,000<br>400 $209,000  482<br>428 413 $205,000<br>376<br>200 $178,535  300 $195,000  $190,000<br>0 $175,000<br>Before 1970 1970-79 1980-89 1990-99 2000-09 2010 to present<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


A map illustrating the location of all homes sold since January of 2019 (excluding 2020 sales data) within the PSA and Morganton is included on the following page. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-44** 

~~**Packet Pg. 197**~~
{126}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 198**
{127}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## 3. Available For-Sale Housing Supply 

Based on information provided by the local Multiple Listing Service provider for the PSA (Burke County), we identified 125 housing units within the PSA that were listed as _available_ for purchase as of October 31, 2023. This is a notable decrease from the 240 homes that were available in 2018. Of those 125 available housing units, 24 (19.2%) were located within the Morganton Submarket. While there are likely additional for-sale residential units available for purchase, such homes were not identified during our research due to the method of advertisement or simply because the product was not actively marketed. Regardless, the available inventory of for-sale product identified in this analysis provides a good baseline for evaluating the for-sale housing alternatives offered in Burke County. 

There are two inventory metrics most often used to evaluate the health of a for-sale housing market. These metrics include _Months Supply of Inventory_ (MSI) and availability rate. The MSI for the PSA was calculated based on sales history occurring between January 1, 2019 and October 31, 2023 (excluding 2020), which equates to an overall absorption rate of approximately 72 homes per month. Overall, based on the monthly absorption rate of 72 homes, the 125 homes listed as available for purchase in the PSA represent approximately 1.7 months of supply. Within the Morganton Submarket, the 24 available homes at an absorption rate of 14 homes per month also equates to 1.7 months of available supply. Typically, healthy and well-balanced markets have an available supply that should take about four to six months to absorb (if no other units are added to the market). Therefore, the PSA and Morganton Submarket inventories are considered low and indicate limited available supply. This also represents a significant decrease in MSI for both areas compared to our original analysis in 2018, which were approximately 5.5 and 4.4 months, respectively. When comparing the 125 available units with the overall inventory of 26,917 owner-occupied units, the PSA has a vacancy/availability rate of 0.5%, which is well below the normal range of 2.0% to 3.0% for a well-balanced for-sale/owner-occupied market. While the availability rate of 0.6% in the Morganton Submarket is slightly higher, both are considered relatively low rates and indicate very limited availability. Further, the current availability rates, 0.5% (PSA) and 0.6% (Morganton), are lower than those reported at the time of our original analysis in 2018, 1.0% (PSA) and 1.5% (Morganton). Thus, the for-sale market has experienced reduced availability within each of the study areas since 2018. To get a better understanding of housing availability in the PSA, we have conducted a more refined analysis of available supply by price point, bedroom type, and year built. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-46** 

~~**Packet Pg. 199**~~
{128}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following table summarizes the distribution of available for-sale residential units by _price point_ for the PSA and Morganton Submarket. 

|**List Price**<br>Up to $99,999<br>$100,000 to $199,999<br>$200,000 to $299,999<br>$300,000 to $399,999<br>$400,000+<br>Total|**Available For-Sale Housing by Price (January**<br>**Morganton**<br>**2018**<br>**2023**<br>**Number**<br>**Available**<br>**Percent**<br>**of Supply**<br>**Number**<br>**Available**<br>**Percent of**<br>**Supply**<br>13<br>24.5%<br>3<br>12.5%<br>20<br>37.7%<br>2<br>8.3%<br>6<br>11.3%<br>8<br>33.3%<br>9<br>17.0%<br>5<br>20.8%<br>5<br>9.4%<br>6<br>25.0%<br>53<br>100.0%<br>24<br>100.0%|**2018 vs. October 2023)**<br>**Burke County (PSA)**<br>**2018**<br>**2023**<br>**Number**<br>**Available**<br>**Percent**<br>**of Supply**<br>**Number**<br>**Available**<br>**Percent of**<br>**Supply**<br>62<br>25.8%<br>9<br>7.2%<br>75<br>31.3%<br>19<br>15.2%<br>40<br>16.7%<br>40<br>32.0%<br>24<br>10.0%<br>20<br>16.0%<br>39<br>16.3%<br>37<br>29.6%<br>240<br>100.0%<br>125<br>100.0%|
|---|---|---|



Source: Multiple Listing Service (MLS) and Bowen National Research 

The largest share (32.0%) of available homes in the PSA as of October 2023 are priced between $200,000 and $299,999, though homes priced at $400,000 or higher comprise only a slightly smaller share (29.6%). While homes priced below $200,000 comprise a notable share (22.4%) of the available supply, this share has decreased significantly compared to the share reported in our 2018 analysis (57.0%). The limited and decreasing supply of product priced under $200,000 may make it more difficult for lower-income households, including first-time homebuyers, to find affordable for-sale housing in the county. The available inventory by price point in the Morganton Submarket has a similar distribution compared to the PSA. As with the PSA, the current share (20.8%) of available homes priced below $200,000 has decreased significantly compared to the share from the 2018 analysis (62.2%). While there is a relatively balanced distribution of available homes by price point in the PSA and Morganton Submarket, there is overall limited availability. 

The number of available homes in the PSA and Morganton by _price point_ are illustrated in the following graph: 

**==> picture [446 x 201] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Available For-Sale Housing by Price<br>Morganton Burke County<br>45<br>40<br>35 40<br>37<br>30<br>25<br>20<br>15 19 20<br>9 8<br>10 5 6<br>5 3 2<br>0<br>Up to $99,999 $100k- $200k- $300k- $400,000+<br>$199,999 $299,999 $399,999<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-47** 

~~**Packet Pg. 200**~~
{129}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The available for-sale housing by bedroom type in the PSA and Morganton Submarket is summarized in the following table. 

|**Available For-Sale Housing by Bedroom Type (As of October 31, 2023)**|**Available For-Sale Housing by Bedroom Type (As of October 31, 2023)**|**Available For-Sale Housing by Bedroom Type (As of October 31, 2023)**|**Available For-Sale Housing by Bedroom Type (As of October 31, 2023)**|**Available For-Sale Housing by Bedroom Type (As of October 31, 2023)**|**Available For-Sale Housing by Bedroom Type (As of October 31, 2023)**|**Available For-Sale Housing by Bedroom Type (As of October 31, 2023)**|**Available For-Sale Housing by Bedroom Type (As of October 31, 2023)**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Bedrooms**|**Number**<br>**Available**|**Average**<br>**Baths**|**Average**<br>**Square Feet**|**Average**<br>**Year Built**|**Price**<br>**Range**|**Median**<br>**List Price**|**Median Price**<br>**Per Sq. Ft.**|
|**Morganton**||||||||
|One-Br.|-|-|-|-|-|-|-|
|Two-Br.|6|2|1,513|1964|$90,000-$335,000|$195,000|$127.71|
|Three-Br.|12|2.5|2,045|1985|$189,900-$789,900|$306,900|$177.29|
|Four-Br.|4|2.5|1973|1950|$70,000-$425,000|$342,000|$152.01|
|Five+-Br.|2|4|4,199|1934|$489,000-$525,000|$507,000|$121.21|
|Total|24|2.5|2,079|1970|$70,000-$789,900|$289,950|$159.82|
|**Burke County (PSA)**||||||||
|One-Br.|5|2|916|1958|$127,500-$424,900|$194,900|$261.11|
|Two-Br.|23|2|1,271|1971|$58,800-$649,500|$199,000|$332.68|
|Three-Br.|79|2|2,049|1992|$49,900-$2,459,000|$299,900|$194.46|
|Four-Br.|13|3|2,554|1975|$70,000-$1,375,000|$389,000|$153.77|
|Five+-Br.|5|4|3,902|1970|$385,000-$1,800,000|$525,000|$142,17|
|Total|125|2|1,987|1985|$48,900-$2,459,000|$289,000|$183.80|



Source: Multiple Listing Service (MLS) 

Overall, the median list price of available product in the PSA (Burke County) is $289,000. This represents a 61.0% increase over the median list price in 2018 ($179,450). The available for-sale supply in the PSA primarily consists of three-bedroom units (63.2%). The three-bedroom homes have a median list price of $299,900 ($194.46 per square foot). This represents a 69.8% increase in the median price of three-bedroom homes compared to our 2018 analysis ($176,600), which had a median price per square foot of $98.29 at that time. Two-bedroom homes in the PSA, which comprise the second largest share (18.4%) of available homes, have a median price of $199,000. Notably, the median price for this bedroom type has increased 148.8% since our analysis in 2018 ($80,000). Within the Morganton Submarket, three-bedroom homes comprise the largest share (50.0%) of the available homes, and the $306,900 median list price for this bedroom type represents an increase of 62.5% from the median list price reported in our 2018 analysis (62.5%). Regardless of bedroom type, the median list prices of available homes in the PSA and Morganton Submarket have increased substantially since 2018, while the overall availability of homes has decreased. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-48** 

~~**Packet Pg. 201**~~
{130}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The number of available homes by _bedroom type_ in the PSA and Morganton are shown in the following graph: 

**==> picture [451 x 225] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Available For-Sale Housing by Bedrooms<br>Morganton Burke County<br>80<br>79<br>70<br>60<br>50<br>40<br>30<br>20<br>23 12<br>10 5 6 4 5<br>0 13 2<br>0<br>Studio/One-Br. Two-Br. Three-Br. Four-Br. Five+-Br.<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


The distribution of available homes by _year built_ for the PSA and Morganton Submarket is summarized in the following table. 

|**Available For-Sale Housing by Year Built (As of October 31, 2023)**|**Available For-Sale Housing by Year Built (As of October 31, 2023)**|**Available For-Sale Housing by Year Built (As of October 31, 2023)**|**Available For-Sale Housing by Year Built (As of October 31, 2023)**|**Available For-Sale Housing by Year Built (As of October 31, 2023)**|**Available For-Sale Housing by Year Built (As of October 31, 2023)**|**Available For-Sale Housing by Year Built (As of October 31, 2023)**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Year Built**|**Number**<br>**Available**|**Average**<br>**Beds/Baths**|**Average**<br>**Square Feet**|**Price**<br>**Range**|**Median**<br>**List Price**|**Median Price per**<br>**Sq. Ft.**|
|**Morganton**|||||||
|Before 1970|13|3/2|2,123|$70,000-$649,000|$284,900|$134.25|
|1970 to 1979|4|3/2.5|2,462|$265,000-$525,000|$339,950|$154.21|
|1980 to 1989|2|3/3|2,197|$279,900-$480,000|$379,950|$177.14|
|1990 to 1999|-|-|-|-|-|-|
|2000 to 2009|1|2/2|1,176|$264,900|$264,900|$225.26|
|2010 to present|4|3/2.5|1,724|$236,500-$789,900|$282,700|$213.32|
|Total|24||2,079|$70,000-$789,900|$289,950|$159.82|
|**Burke County (PSA)**|||||||
|Before 1970|37|3/2|1,673|$58,800-$649,900|$220,000|$154.98|
|1970 to 1979|20|3/2|2,337|$49,900-$895,000|$289,500|$160.41|
|1980 to 1989|13|3/2.5|1,772|$174,900-$1,390,000|$279,900|$165.57|
|1990 to 1999|11|3/2.5|2,468|$99,000-$2,459,000|$450,000|$207.69|
|2000 to 2009|12|3/2.5|1,887|$169,900-$1,450,000|$320,000|$213.28|
|2010 to present|32|3/3|2,090|$205,000-$2,399,000|$387,500|$228.73|
|Total|125|3/2|1,987|$48,900-$2,459,000|$289,000|$183.80|



Source: Multiple Listing Service (MLS) 

As shown in the preceding table, 29.6% of the available for-sale housing product in the PSA was built before 1970, while product built since 2010 represents 25.6% of the available inventory. The overall median price per square foot of the available homes in the PSA is $183.80 per square foot. The median price per square foot in the PSA increases for each subsequent development period, with homes built before 1970 having the lowest 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-49** 

~~**Packet Pg. 202**~~
{131}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

median price per square foot ($154.98) and homes built since 2010 having the highest median price per square foot ($228.73). Homes built prior to 1970 comprise a much larger share (54.2%) of the available inventory within the Morganton Submarket, while homes built since 2010 only comprise 16.7% of the available inventory. As such, the available inventory in the Morganton Submarket is comparably older than the inventory in the PSA, overall. With an overall median list price of $289,000 in the PSA, and a median list price of $220,000 for product built in the oldest development period (pre-1970), it is unlikely that most lower-income households and first-time homebuyers can afford the typical for-sale home in the PSA, regardless of age. Overall, there is limited availability in the PSA and Morganton Submarket, and a significant share of the available for-sale homes, particularly in the Morganton Submarket, was built prior to 1970 and are more likely to require additional costs updating and/or repair. 

The distribution of available homes in the PSA and Morganton by year built is shown in the following graphs. 

**==> picture [441 x 233] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Morganton Available For-Sale Housing by Year Built (w/ Median Price)<br>Number Sold Median Price<br>14 $400,000<br>$379,950<br>$360,000<br>12 13<br>$339,950  $282,700  $320,000<br>10 $264,900  $280,000<br>$284,900<br>$240,000<br>8<br>$200,000<br>6<br>$160,000<br>4 $120,000<br>4 2 4 $80,000<br>2 1<br>$40,000<br>0 N/A<br>0 $0<br>Before 1970 1970-79 1980-89 1990-99 2000-09 2010 to present<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-50** 

~~**Packet Pg. 203**~~
{132}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

**==> picture [441 x 234] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Burke County Available For-Sale Housing by Year Built (w/ Median Price)<br>Number Sold Median Price<br>40 $450,000<br>$450,000<br>35<br>37<br>$387,500  $400,000<br>30<br>32<br>25 $350,000<br>20<br>20 $320,000<br>15 $279,900  $300,000<br>$289,500<br>10 13<br>12<br>11 $250,000<br>5 $220,000<br>0 $200,000<br>Before 1970 1970-79 1980-89 1990-99 2000-09 2010 to present<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


The following table summarizes changes in availability and pricing among homes for purchase within the PSA (Burke County) since the time of our original analysis in 2018. 

||**Available PSA For-Sale Housing Stock Comparison (2018-2023)**|**Available PSA For-Sale Housing Stock Comparison (2018-2023)**|**Available PSA For-Sale Housing Stock Comparison (2018-2023)**|
|---|---|---|---|
||**2018**|**2023**|**Change**|
|Number of Available Homes|240|125|-115 (-47.9%)|
|Availability Rate|1.0%|0.5%|-0.5|
|Months Supply of Inventory (MSI)|5.3|1.7|-3.6|
|Median List Price|$179,450|$289,000|61.0%|
|Median PricePerSq.Ft.|$96.55|$183.80|90.4%|



Source: Multiple Listing Service (MLS) and Bowen National Research 

As indicated throughout this section and summarized in the preceding table, the Burke County for-sale market has experienced a notable decline in availability and significant increases in pricing since the time of our 2018 study. This likely creates challenges for households which would like to relocate within or to Burke County and limits potential demographic growth within the area. 

A map illustrating the location of available for-sale homes in the PSA (Burke County) and Morganton Submarket as of October 2023 is included on the following page. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-51** 

~~**Packet Pg. 204**~~
{133}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 205**
{134}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **D. SENIOR CARE HOUSING** 

Burke County, like areas throughout the country, has a large senior population that requires a variety of senior housing alternatives to meet its diverse needs. Seniors that are generally aged 65 or older may seek a more leisurely lifestyle or need assistance with Activities of Daily Living (ADLs). As part of this analysis, we evaluated two levels of care that typically respond to older adults seeking, or who need, alternatives to their current living environment. This includes assisted living and nursing care. These housing types, from least assisted to most assisted, are summarized below. Note that there were no independent living or congregate care facilities (independent living with basic housekeeping or laundry services and meals) identified in the county. 

_Adult Care Homes_ are state licensed residences for aged and disabled adults who may require 24-hour supervision and assistance with personal care needs. People in adult care homes typically need a place to live, with some help with personal care (such as dressing, grooming and keeping up with medications), and some limited supervision. Medical care may be provided on occasion but is not routinely needed. Medication may be given by designated, trained staff. This type of facility is very similar to what is commonly referred to as “assisted living.” These facilities generally offer limited care that is designed for seniors who need some assistance with daily activities but do not require nursing care. 

_Nursing Homes_ provide nursing care and related services for people who need nursing, medical, rehabilitation or other special services. These facilities are licensed by the state and may be certified to participate in the Medicaid and/or Medicare programs. Certain nursing homes may also meet specific standards for sub-acute care or dementia care. 

We referenced Medicare.com and the websites for each of the departments previously discussed to identify all licensed and certified senior care facilities and cross referenced this list with other senior care facility resources. As such, we believe that we identified most licensed facilities in the county, though not all were surveyed as part of this Housing Needs Assessment. 

A total of 13 senior care facilities, containing a total of 834 marketed beds/units, were identified and surveyed. The following table summarizes the surveyed facilities by property type. 

|**Surveyed Senior Care Facilities- PSA (Burke County)**|**Surveyed Senior Care Facilities- PSA (Burke County)**|**Surveyed Senior Care Facilities- PSA (Burke County)**|**Surveyed Senior Care Facilities- PSA (Burke County)**|**Surveyed Senior Care Facilities- PSA (Burke County)**|**Surveyed Senior Care Facilities- PSA (Burke County)**|**Surveyed Senior Care Facilities- PSA (Burke County)**|**Surveyed Senior Care Facilities- PSA (Burke County)**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Project Type**|**Projects**|**Marketed**<br>**Beds/Units**|**Vacant**|**Occupancy**<br>**Rate**|**2018**<br>**Occupancy**<br>**Rate**|**National**<br>**Occupancy**<br>**Rate***|**Base Monthly**<br>**Rent**|
|Assisted Living|7|323|96|70.3%|80.6%|82.6%|$2,500-$5,627|
|Nursing Homes|6|511|55|87.5%|83.4%|82.4%|$6,874-$15,482|
|Total|13|834|151|81.9%|84.2%|84.4%|$2,500-$15,482|



*Source: NIC Map Vision LLC, 3Q2023 Market Fundamentals 

Note: In some cases, daily rates were converted to monthly rates 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-53** 

~~**Packet Pg. 206**~~
{135}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The county is reporting an overall occupancy rate of 81.9% for the surveyed senior care facilities. Within individual project types, nursing homes in the PSA have an occupancy rate of 87.5%, while the occupancy rate among assisted living facilities is 70.3%. While the occupancy rate for the nursing homes in the PSA is above the corresponding national occupancy rate for the 3[rd] quarter of 2023 (82.4%), the occupancy rate for the assisted living facilities in the PSA is significantly lower than the reported national occupancy rate (82.6%). Although the current occupancy rate for the nursing homes in the PSA is higher than the rate for the county in 2018 (83.4%), the 70.3% occupancy rate among the assisting living facilities in the county is notably lower than the rate (80.6%) from the previous study. 

The overall senior care facility occupancy rate of 81.9% is below the national occupancy rate of 84.4% and represents a decrease of more than two full percentage points from the overall occupancy rate in 2018 (84.2%). This decrease can be primarily attributed to the low occupancy rate among the assisted living facilities. In total, three of the surveyed assisted living facilities in the PSA have occupancy rates of less than 70%. Representatives at the facilities cited ongoing staffing shortages following the COVID-19 pandemic as the primary reason for the low occupancy rates in their respective facilities. Although the overall occupancy rate for the assisted living facilities in the PSA is considered low, it should be noted that three of the surveyed facilities have occupancy rates of 95% or higher, and one facility currently maintains a waiting list of five households. Demographic projections over the next five years indicate that senior households, age 75 and older, are expected to increase by 1,086 households (21.6% increase) in Burke County. These demographic projections, along with the high occupancy rates at select facilities in the PSA, indicate the occupancy rates for senior care facilities in the county will likely increase if no additional beds are added to the market. As such, the occupancy rate for these units, particularly those in nursing homes, should continue to be monitored to ensure that an adequate housing supply is available for the increasing number of senior households in the PSA. 

The monthly fees for senior care housing in the previous table should be considered as a base of comparison for the future projects considered in the county. It is important to note that many senior care facilities with services accept Medicaid payments from eligible residents, reducing their costs. A summary of the individual senior care facilities surveyed in Burke County is included in Addendum C. 

A map illustrating the location of surveyed senior care facilities in the county is included on the following page. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-54** 

~~**Packet Pg. 207**~~
{136}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 208**
{137}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **E. PLANNED & PROPOSED** 

In order to assess housing development potential, we evaluated recent residential building permit activity and identified residential projects in the development pipeline within the PSA (Burke County). Understanding the number of residential units and the type of housing being considered for development in the market can assist in determining how these projects are expected to meet the housing needs of the market. 

The following tables illustrate single-family and multifamily building permits issued within the PSA (Burke County) and the Morganton Submarket for the most recent ten-year period (2013-2022) available. 

|**Housing Unit Building Permits for Burke County:**|**Housing Unit Building Permits for Burke County:**|**Housing Unit Building Permits for Burke County:**|**Housing Unit Building Permits for Burke County:**|**Housing Unit Building Permits for Burke County:**|**Housing Unit Building Permits for Burke County:**|**Housing Unit Building Permits for Burke County:**|**Housing Unit Building Permits for Burke County:**|**Housing Unit Building Permits for Burke County:**|**Housing Unit Building Permits for Burke County:**|**Housing Unit Building Permits for Burke County:**||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Permits**|**2013**|**2014**|**2015**|**2016**|**2017**|**2018**|**2019**|**2020**|**2021**|**2022**||
|Multifamily Permits|0|0|101|50|38|124|83|81|167|240||
|Single-Family Permits|104|94|123|134|149|161|207|221|235|303||
|Total Units|104|94|224|184|187|285|290|302|402|543||
|Source: SOCDS Building Permits Database at http://socds.huduser.org/permits/index.html||||||||||||
|**Housing Unit Building Permits for Morganton, NC:**||||||||||||
|**Permits**|**2013**|**2014**|**2015**|**2016**|**2017**|**2018**|**2019**|**2020**|**2021**|**2022**||
|Multifamily Permits|0|0|97|46|38|60|75|79|101|128||
|Single-Family Permits|7|9|11|7|9|10|11|11|13|12||
|TotalUnits|7|9|108|53|47|70|86|90|114|140||



Source: SOCDS Building Permits Database at http://socds.huduser.org/permits/index.html 

A total of 2,615 residential building permits were issued in the PSA (Burke County) between 2013 and 2022. Of these, 66.2% (1,731 permits) were singlefamily building permits. Approximately 262 total permits, on average, were issued in the PSA each year during this time. It is noteworthy that 36.1% of the total permits (945 permits) were issued in 2021 and 2022. Additionally, 46.0% of the multifamily permits (407 permits) issued since 2013 were issued in the last two years. This indicates there has been a significant increase in residential development activity in Burke County recently, particularly among multifamily units. Within the Morganton Submarket, a total of 724 residential building permits were issued between 2013 and 2022. Of these, 86.2% (624 permits) were multifamily building permits. Similar to the building permits in the PSA, 36.7% of the multifamily permits issued since 2013 in the Morganton Submarket were issued in 2021 and 2022, indicating a recent increase in residential development activity in the area. Overall, it appears there has been a significant increase in residential development activity in Burke County over the last couple of years, particularly among multifamily apartments, which illustrates the growing interest in development within the area. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-56** 

~~**Packet Pg. 209**~~
{138}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

We conducted interviews with representatives of area building and permitting departments and conducted extensive online research to identify residential projects either planned for development or currently under construction within Burke County. Note that additional projects may have been introduced into the pipeline and/or the status of existing projects may have changed since the time interviews and research were completed. 

## Multifamily Housing 

Based on interviews with local planning/building representatives and online research, it was determined there are several rental projects currently in the development pipeline within the Morganton Submarket and the PSA (Burke County). The known details of these projects are summarized in the following table: 

|**Multifamily Rental Housing Development**|**Multifamily Rental Housing Development**|**Multifamily Rental Housing Development**|**Multifamily Rental Housing Development**|**Multifamily Rental Housing Development**|
|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Project Name & Address**|**Type**|**Units**|**Developer**|**Status/Details**|
|**Morganton**|||||
|**Dixon Street**<br>101 Dixon St.|Affordable|37|Industrial<br>Commons|**Planned:**ECD 2026|
|**Riverbend Apartments**<br>634 Independence Blvd.|Tax Credit|66|Fred Mills|**Planned:**Allocated Tax Credits in 2023;<br>General-occupancy one-, two-, and three-<br>bedroom units at 40%, 50% and 60%<br>AMHI; ECD 2025|
|**White Street**<br>Corner of White St.<br>& East Union St.|Market-Rate|66|Norvell Properties<br>and Amicus|**Planned:**ECD 2026|
|**400 Block Meeting Street**<br>Between White S. & Church St.|Market-Rate|54|400 Meeting Street,<br>LLC|**Planned:**ECD 2025|
|**PSA (Burke County)**|||||
|**Pine Crossing**<br>605 Pineburr Ave. SW, Valdese|Tax Credit|66|WNC Housing<br>Partnership|**Under Construction:**General-occupancy<br>one-, two-, and three-bedroom units at 40%,<br>50% and 60% AMHI; ECD early 2024|
|**Historic Valdese Weaver Mill**<br>108 Praley St., Valdese|Tax Credit|60|Northwestern<br>Housing<br>Enterprises|**Planned**: Allocated Tax Credits in 2021;<br>No construction has started; To include<br>one- and two-bedroom general-occupancy<br>units at 60% AMHI.|
|**Tron’s Place**<br>251 Praley St. NW, Valdese|Tax Credit|60|MC Morgan &<br>Associates, Inc.|**Planned:**Allocated Tax Credits in 2021;<br>Expected to begin construction early 2024;<br>Senior 55+ complex; to include one- and<br>two-bedroom units at 40%, 50%, 60% and<br>80% AMHI|
|**Former Chesterfield Elementary**<br>**School**<br>2142 Pax Hill Rd., Morganton*|N/A|31|N/A|**Proposed:**Early stages; Studio to two-<br>bedroom units; Set aside for teachers; No<br>details available|
|N/A – Not available|||||



ECD – Estimated Completion Date 

*Morganton mailing address but located outside Morganton city limits 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-57** 

~~**Packet Pg. 210**~~
{139}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## For-Sale Housing 

There are five for-sale projects currently in the development pipeline within the Morganton Submarket and the PSA (Burke County). The known details of these projects are summarized in the following table: 

**==> picture [546 x 228] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
For-Sale Housing Development<br>Project Name & Address  Type  Units  Developer  Status/Details<br>Morganton<br>Under Construction:  1,730 square-foot<br>Fletcher Street Townhomes  two-bedroom units from $250,000 to<br>300 Fletcher St.  Townhome  27  TruWest, LLC  $300,000<br>400 Block Meeting Street<br>Townhomes  400 Meeting Street,  Planned:  2,100 square-foot two-bedroom<br>Between White St. & Church St.  Townhome  16  LLC  units from $350,000 to $400,000<br>PSA (Burke County)<br>Under Construction:  1,400 to 1,800<br>Edelweiss Subdivision  Campfire Homes,  square-foot three-bedroom units from<br>Harris Ave. NW, Valdese  Single-family  19  LLC  $280,000+<br>Under  Construction:  Current  plans<br>Southpointe on Lake James  include four-bedroom units; Square feet<br>1649 Southpointe Dr., Morganton* Single-family  300  Crescent  from 3,000 square feet;<br>McCracken Ford  Under Construction:  Current homes under<br>1760 Plantation Loop,  construction are 1,975 to 2,290 square-foot<br>Morganton* Single-family  N/A  N/A  three-bedroom units from $434,000<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


N/A – Not Available 

*Morganton mailing address but located outside of Morganton city limits 

## Senior Housing 

There were no senior facilities planned or under construction at the time of this study. 

We have considered the currently planned projects in the housing gap estimates included in Section VIII of this report. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VI-58** 

~~**Packet Pg. 211**~~
{140}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **VII. OTHER HOUSING MARKET FACTORS** 

## **INTRODUCTION** 

Factors other than demography, employment, and supply (all analyzed earlier in this study) can affect the strength or weakness of a given housing market. The following additional factors influence a housing market’s performance and needs, and are discussed relative to the PSA (Burke County) and compared with state and national data, when applicable: 

**==> picture [423 x 45] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
|||||
|---|---|---|---|
|•|Public Transit Analysis|•|Development Opportunities|
|•|Community Services|•|Development Costs & Government Regulations|
|•|Residential Blight|•|Developer/Investor Identification|

**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **A. TRANSPORTATION ANALYSIS** 

Public transit, including its accessibility, geographic reach, and rider fees can affect the connectivity of a community and influence housing decisions. As a result, we evaluated public transportation that serves the residents of Burke County. 

Greenway Public Transportation provides transit services to Burke County residents, primarily within the city of Morganton. The Morganton Loop route is a flexible, fixed-route transit service where drivers can deviate up to three-quarters of a mile from set stops if a passenger has made a reservation at least one business day in advance. Transportation operating hours are Monday through Friday between 9:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m. Transit costs are $1.25 for  a single ride fare, $3.00 for a one-day pass, $16.00 for a oneweek pass, $45.00 for a thirty-day pass, and $100 for a student semester pass. A reduced fare is available for qualifying riders such as seniors age 65 and older, individuals with a disability, and Medicare card holders.  The service area for the Morganton Loop route is shown in the Source 1: https://www.mygreenway.org/burke-routes picture to the right. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-1** 

~~**Packet Pg. 212**~~
{141}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Greenway Public Transportation also provides paratransit van and dial-a-ride demand response services. The demand response service offers shared ride, curbto-curb,  public transportation, while the complementary ADA service provides curb-to-curb (or door-to-door upon request) transportation within three-quarters of a mile of the fixed-route bus service to qualifying individuals. Transportation operating hours are Monday through Friday from 5:45 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. and Saturday from 8:45 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.  The cost of demand response transportation is $2.50 for a single ride fare, $5.00 for out-of service area fare, $2.50 for a single paratransit fare, and $22.50 for a 10-ticket book. 

## Walkability 

The ability to perform errands or access community services conveniently by walking, rather than driving, contributes favorably to personal mobility. A person whose residence is within walking distance of major neighborhood services and amenities will most likely find their housing market more desirable. Conversely, residents who are not within a reasonable walking distance of major community services or employment are often adversely impacted by the limited walkability of their neighborhood, which could impact their quality of life and/or limit the appeal of residing within the less walkable areas. 

|**Walk**<br>**Score®**|**Description**|
|---|---|
|**90–100**|**Walker's Paradise**<br>Daily errands do not require a car.|
|**70–89**|**Very Walkable**<br>Most errands can be accomplished<br>on foot.|
|**50–69**|**Somewhat Walkable**<br>Some amenities are within walking<br>distance.|
|**25–49**|**Car-Dependent**<br>A few amenities are within walking<br>distance.|
|**0–24**|**Very Car-Dependent**<br>Almost all errands require a car.|



The online service Walk Score was used to evaluate walkability within some of the more populated areas of Burke County. Walk Score analyzes a specific location’s proximity to a standardized list of community attributes. It assesses not only distance but also the number and variety of neighborhood amenities. A Walk Score can range from a low of zero to a high of 100 (the higher the score, the more walkable the community). The table to the right illustrates the Walk Score ranges and corresponding descriptors. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-2** 

~~**Packet Pg. 213**~~
{142}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Walk Score was used to calculate the walkability of some additional populated areas within Burke County. The Walk Score addresses were selected to the best of our ability by focusing on areas with either a higher population or a higher level of traffic/interest.  Note that scores were calculated from a location in the **central portion** of each community. The following table includes the addresses within each community selected and the corresponding Walk Score of that location. 

According to Walk Score, the central area of Morganton has the highest overall score of other commercialized/populated areas in Burke County (see table below) with a Walk Score of 70 and a Bike Score of 47. The Walk Score of 70 indicates that the overall city is very walkable and that most errands can be accomplished on foot, while the Bike Score of 47 indicates the city overall is somewhat bikeable with minimal bicycling infrastructure. 

**==> picture [241 x 181] intentionally omitted <==**

|**Location**|**Walk**<br>**Score**|**Walk Score**<br>**Descriptor**|
|---|---|---|
|Morganton (136 West Union Street)|70|Very Walkable|
|Valdese (212 Main Street West)|64|Somewhat Walkable|
|Hildebran (101b Old State Highway 10 West)|42|Car-Dependent|
|Drexel (700 South Main Street)|35|Car-Dependent|
|Connelly Springs (500 Malcolm Boulevard)|25|Car-Dependent|
|Glen Alpine (101 East Main Street)|19|Very Car-Dependent|
|Source: WalkScore.com|||



The central portion of the town of Valdese (Walk Score of 64) has the secondhighest score in Burke County, with the central areas of this community deemed somewhat walkable, which indicates that some errands may require a car to complete, but some can be accomplished on foot. The central areas of the towns of Hildebran, Drexel, Connelly Springs, and Glen Alpine have scores below 50, indicating that they are car-dependent or very car-dependent. As such, residents living in less walkable areas are likely to experience some challenges accessing certain community services, particularly lower-income residents that do not have access to a vehicle. When contemplating the location of new residential housing, communities should consider areas in or near some of the more walkable neighborhoods that allow convenient access to community services, particularly for affordable housing development. 

The following map illustrates the Walk Score locations in the PSA (Burke County). 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-3** 

~~**Packet Pg. 214**~~
{143}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**==> picture [91 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Packet Pg. 215<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>
{144}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **B. COMMUNITY SERVICES** 

The location, type, and number of community attributes (both services and amenities) can have a significant impact on housing market performance and the ability of a market to support existing and future residential development. Typically, a geographic area served by an abundance of amenities and services should be more desirable than one with minimal offerings, and its housing market should perform better accordingly. As a result, community attributes were examined in Burke County as part of this Housing Needs Assessment. 

Burke County is located in the western portion of North Carolina. The county is located between the Mountain Region of North Carolina to the west and the Piedmont Region of North Carolina to the east. Burke County is bordered by Avery and Caldwell counties to the north, Catawba County to the east, Lincoln County to the southeast, Cleveland County and Rutherford County to the south, and McDowell County to the west. Burke County consists of the city of Morganton and several towns, including Glen Alpine, Drexel, Valdese, Rutherford College, Connelly Springs, and Hildebran. 

Most community services for the county are located in the city of Morganton, which serves as the largest municipality in the county as well as the seat of government for Burke County. Each of the smaller towns in the county has a basic supply of community services for its residents. A summary of community services in each municipality is listed as follows: 

## **Morganton** 

The city of Morganton, the largest incorporated community in the county, is approximately 57.0 miles east of Asheville, North Carolina and approximately 71.0 miles northwest of Charlotte, North Carolina. Major commercial arterials in Morganton include Interstate 40, U.S. Highway 64, and U.S. Highway 70. A variety of community services are accessible for city and county residents such as gas stations, convenience stores, grocery stores, discount department stores, pharmacies, banks and restaurants. Grocery stores serving the Morganton area include Walmart Supercenter, Walmart Neighborhood Market, Food Lion, Ingles Markets, and ALDI. Shopping centers containing a variety of retailers and restaurants include Morganton Heights and Magnolia Plaza. Morganton Heights includes Walmart Supercenter, Dick’s Sporting Goods and T.J. Maxx as major stores along with several fast casual and casual dining restaurants. Magnolia Plaza includes Rural King, Big Lots, and Harbor Freight Tools along with several fastfood restaurants. Downtown Morganton, a 38-block area in the central portion of the city, includes municipal and county government facilities, professional offices, small business retailers, and locally owned restaurants.  Morganton has a notable supply of recreational facilities including several parks, a greenway system, an indoor aquatic center, an outdoor pool, and two recreation centers. Police and fire protection is provided by the Morganton Public Safety Department. The Burke County Sheriff also has its main office in downtown Morganton. UNC Health Blue Ridge, a 184-bed not-for-profit hospital, is the largest medical facility in Burke County. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-5** 

~~**Packet Pg. 216**~~
{145}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **Glen Alpine** 

The town of Glen Alpine is approximately 6.0 miles west of downtown Morganton. U.S. Highway 70 is the main thoroughfare through the town, while the nearest access to Interstate 70 is approximately 3.0 miles southeast of the town. Glen Alpine has a limited number of community services in the central portion of town, which include a post office, town hall, pharmacy, restaurant, dollar store and a specialty home goods store. The nearest grocery stores, major retailers, and a wider selection of dining options are in Morganton. Glen Alpine Elementary School is located near the central portion of the town and W.A. Young Elementary School is located southeast of Glen Alpine. Lake James State Park is approximately 8.0 miles east of Glen Alpine. 

## **Drexel** 

The town of Drexel is located approximately 6.0 miles east of downtown Morganton. Community services are primarily located along or near North Main Street (State Route 114). Community services in Drexel include a post office, gas station, convenience store, and a restaurant. Drexel Elementary School and the R.O. Huffman Center (community center) are located in the southern portion of the town. Additional community services are located immediately south of the town along U.S. Highway 70. These additional community services include a pharmacy, restaurants, a coffee shop, dollar store, and discount grocery store. 

## **Valdese** 

The town of Valdese is located approximately 7.5 miles east of downtown Morganton.  Community services are located along U.S. Highway 70, which serves as the main commercial arterial in the town. Community services in the town are primarily located in downtown Valdese, which is located in the southern portion of the town. Downtown Valdese includes several local retailers, restaurants, gas stations, convenience stores, a pharmacy, a post office, town offices, a library and Centennial Fountain Park. A grocery store (Food Lion) is located in the western portion of the Valdese along U.S. Highway 70. The northern portion of Valdese includes Jimmy C. Draughn High School, McGalliard Falls Park, and Valdese Lakeside Park, which is along the south shore of Rhodhiss Lake. Access to Interstate 40 is approximately 1.5 miles south of downtown Valdese. 

## **Rutherford College** 

The town of Rutherford College is approximately 9.5 miles east of downtown Morganton. Community services are primarily located along Malcolm Boulevard, which intersects with U.S. Highway 70 in the southern portion of the town. Malcolm Boulevard includes restaurants, gas stations, convenience stores, professional offices, and medical office space. UNC Health Blue Ridge (formerly Valdese General Hospital) is a medical facility that includes a 24-hour emergency department. Malcolm Boulevard also has several vacant parcels of commercial land being offered for sale, which could potentially increase the number of community services in Rutherford College in future years. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-6** 

~~**Packet Pg. 217**~~
{146}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **Connelly Springs** 

The town of Connelly Springs is approximately 11.0 miles east of downtown Morganton. U.S. Highway 70 and Interstate 40 are each located within the southern portion of the town. Connelly Springs consists of several light manufacturing facilities, a hardware store, a furniture sales store, and local restaurants. The town also includes a post office and town hall. The nearest pharmacy is in Rutherford College and the nearest grocery store is in Valdese. The northern portion of the town is sparsely populated and extends to Rhodhiss Lake. 

## **Hildebran** 

The town of Hildebran is located in the eastern portion of Burke County, approximately 5.0 miles southwest of downtown Hickory and approximately 16.0 miles east of downtown Morganton. U.S. Highway 70 is the main commercial arterial for the town, while access to Interstate 40 is along the town’s southern boundary. Community services in Hildebran include a Food Lion grocery store, CVS Pharmacy, restaurants, gas stations, convenience stores, and banks. Municipal amenities include a public library and community park. As Hildebran is located near Catawba County and the city of Hickory, several of the nearest community services are also located in the Hickory area. 

## **County-wide amenities and services** 

Burke County is served by Burke County Public Schools. This school district consists of 14 elementary schools, five middle schools, four high schools, and four district-wide schools. Burke County Public Schools had an enrollment of 11,338 students throughout all grade levels for the 2022-2023 school year. Western Piedmont Community College (WPCC), part of the North Carolina Community College System, has an enrollment of approximately 2,200 students for college transfer and degree programs and approximately 2,700 students in continuing education programs. WPCC offers over 100 degrees, diplomas, and certificates at its Morganton campus for a wide variety of academic programs, including accounting and finance, business administration, building construction technology, general education, and nursing. The Burke County Recreation Department operates and maintains several parks and a conference center. 

Public safety services are provided by the Burke County Sheriff’s Office for police protection services. Select municipalities in Burke County also operate their own police departments. Burke County Emergency Medical Services (EMS) has seven stations located in the county, which provide pre-hospital medical transport and additional response services. Medical facilities in Burke County consist of a hospital, a medical care center, an urgent care center, and several medical offices operated by UNC Health Blue Ridge. Pharmacies are located in several towns throughout Burke County. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-7** 

~~**Packet Pg. 218**~~
{147}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

In summary, most community services in Burke County are located in the Morganton area.  Several smaller towns in the county include a basic level of community services for their residents, including grocery stores, pharmacies, gas stations, convenience stores, and restaurants. An expanded selection of community services for the smaller towns in the county is typically available in Morganton, which serves as the largest municipality and seat of government for Burke County. Residents in the eastern portion of Burke County may also drive to Catawba County and the city of Hickory for community services. Community services within Burke County are primarily located along U.S. Highway 70 and Interstate 40, which serve as major east-west commercial arterials. It is anticipated that most future residential development will be in areas within reasonable proximity to the more commonly needed community services (e.g., shopping and healthcare). However, as a large industrial/commercial megasite is currently in the planning stages for western Burke County, this area could also attract future residential development. This is due to the fact that the development of this megasite is expected to enhance access to utility connections in western Burke County. 

A map of notable community services within the study area is included on the following page. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-8** 

~~**Packet Pg. 219**~~
{148}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 220**
{149}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **C. RESIDENTIAL BLIGHT** 

Blight, which is generally considered the visible decline of property, can have a detrimental effect on nearby properties within a neighborhood. Blight can be caused by several factors, including economic decline, population decline, and/or the high cost to maintain/upgrade older housing. There are specific references to blight within the North Carolina General Statutes. Specifically, Chapter 160A-503 (Definitions) states the following: 

_**"Blighted parcel"** shall mean a parcel on which there is a predominance of buildings or improvements (or which is predominantly residential in character), and which, by reason of dilapidation, deterioration, age or obsolescence, inadequate provision for ventilation, light, air, sanitation, or open spaces, high density of population and overcrowding, unsanitary or unsafe conditions, or the existence of conditions which endanger life or property by fire and other causes, or any combination of such factors, substantially impairs the sound growth of the community, is conducive to ill health, transmission of disease, infant mortality, juvenile delinquency and crime, and is detrimental to the public health, safety, morals or welfare._ 

The 2022 Burke County Land Use Plan (Blueprint Burke) includes several action steps to encourage residential development. Two of these action steps reference dilapidated or uninhabitable structures in the county. Action Step 2.5 states that the county should _actively seek to phase out non-conforming housing structures as they become dilapidated or vacant in areas where specific types of housing are desirable to encourage development_ . Action Step 2.6 states that the county should _actively seek the removal or repair of uninhabitable structures, both stick-built and manufactured housing units, to maintain community safety, character, and property values._ Implementation of both action steps would likely reduce the number of blighted residential structures in the county via redevelopment or blight removal projects. 

The City of Morganton Code of Ordinances includes language pertaining to blight within its municipal boundaries. Morganton’s Code of Ordinances defines a blighted area as (in part) _an area in which there is a predominance of buildings or improvements (or which is predominantly residential in character), and which, by reason of dilapidation, deterioration, age or obsolescence, inadequate provision for ventilation, light air, sanitation, or open spaces, high density or population and overcrowding, unsanitary or unsafe conditions, or the existence of conditions which endanger life or property by fire and other causes, or any combination of such factors, substantially impairs the sound growth of the community_ (Section 2-7184. – Definitions). This definition of blight further states that at least two-thirds of buildings within an area must meet the definition of blight in order to be determined a blighted area by the planning commission. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-10** 

~~**Packet Pg. 221**~~
{150}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The City of Morganton Development and Design Services department provides a list of common nuisance violations on its website. Several items on this list could be identified as blight or serve as precursors to blight, including tall grass and weeds, accumulation of junk, and junk/abandoned vehicles. Any of these items present at a property could result in a violation issued by the city’s code enforcement division. 

Note that several municipalities in the county as well as the county itself adhere to minimum housing standards authorized by North Carolina state law. These minimum housing standards include minimum _structural_ standards regarding a building’s foundation, exterior and interior walls, floors, ceilings, roofs, porches, and additional appurtenances. These minimum structural standards exist in part to prevent existing buildings within an area from exhibiting characteristics of blight. 

For the purposes of this analysis, these code violations and definitions were used as initial identifiers of possible blight. Residential properties within the study area that meet any of the following criteria were classified as blighted. Summary definitions of the most common forms of residential blight are listed below: 

**Boarded Up Structure.** This is a building or structure with multiple windows and/or doors that have boards placed on those points of entry and for which it appears the unit has been abandoned and that no work or repair appears to be underway. 

**==> picture [219 x 164] intentionally omitted <==**

**Building or Structure Which is in a State of Disrepair.** This is a residential structure exhibiting noticeable signs of disrepair or neglect such as, but not limited to, deteriorated exterior walls and/or roof coverings, broken or missing windows or doors which constitute a hazardous condition or a potential attraction to trespassers, or building exteriors, walls, fences, signs, retaining walls, driveways, walkways, sidewalks or other structures on the property which are broken, deteriorated, or substantially defaced, to the extent that the disrepair is visible from any public right of way or visually impacts neighboring public or private property or presents an endangerment to public safety. 

**==> picture [219 x 158] intentionally omitted <==**

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-11** 

~~**Packet Pg. 222**~~
{151}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

**Unkempt Property.** This is a property showing clear signs of overgrown, diseased, dead, or decayed trees, weeds or vegetation that may create a public safety hazard or substantially detract from the aesthetic and property values of neighboring properties. This may also include properties which have notable refuse or garbage clearly visible from the street or abandoned/broken appliances, cars in disrepair and on blocks, or other items of unused and unsightly property that may be deemed a public nuisance or otherwise detract from the aesthetic and property values of neighboring properties. An unkempt property may also lack a proper access point (i.e., a functional driveway) in order to provide access to the residential structure. 

Using the preceding descriptions of blight, Bowen National Research identified properties in Burke County that were in various stages of disrepair, abandoned, boarded up, fire damaged or otherwise appeared to be in an unsafe condition. A representative of Bowen National Research personally visited residential neighborhoods in Burke County, generally evaluating the exterior condition of the occupied and vacant housing stock via a windshield survey. Residential housing stock evaluated as part of this survey primarily consisted of single-family houses and mobile homes along with a few apartment buildings. 

From this in-person observation, 75 residential units were identified that exhibited a significant level of exterior blight. It should be noted that the interiors of properties were not evaluated as part of this survey. These 75 residential units represent approximately 0.2% of the 39,583 total housing units in Burke County. Typically, blighted residential units in a city or county represent less than 0.5% of all residential units. Note that blighted units in the city of Morganton represent 0.7% of the 7,713 total housing units in the city. The 0.7% rate is slightly above the county rate of 0.2% and may indicate that additional measures could be implemented to mitigate the number of blighted residential structures in the city. Blighted residential properties represent potential nuisances, safety hazards, and are potentially detrimental to nearby property uses and values. As a general guideline, we identified properties that were considered to exhibit visual evidence of _significant_ exterior deficiencies and disrepair. Many of these structures are boarded up, have missing siding or roof shingles, or show signs of damage that make such units either uninhabitable or represent serious safety or public nuisance issues. 

Note that representatives of Bowen National Research did not visit every residential street within Burke County. This analysis primarily focused on incorporated municipalities within the county located along the U.S. Highway 70 corridor. A more extensive survey of residential blight within the county would have likely uncovered additional residential units that exhibited characteristics of blight. As such, areas noted within this summary illustrate possible geographic areas of focus for mitigation of residential blight within the county. 

A map illustrating the approximate location of residential blight in Burke County is included on the following page. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-12** 

~~**Packet Pg. 223**~~
{152}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 224**
{153}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following table illustrates the total number and share of blighted residential units identified by location within Burke County. 

**==> picture [312 x 133] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Location of Blighted Units (Burke County)<br>Number of   Share of<br>Location Blighted Units  Blighted Units<br>Morganton  51  68.0%<br>Drexel  6  8.0%<br>Valdese  6  8.0%<br>Unincorporated Area* 5  6.7%<br>Glen Alpine  4  5.3%<br>Connelly Springs  2  2.7%<br>Rutherford College  1  1.3%<br>Total  75  100.0%<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Source: Bowen National Research Note: Total shares of units may not equal 100.0% due to rounding. Location includes city/town limits and its adjacent extra territorial jurisdiction (ETJ). *Unincorporated areas outside of a city/town ETJ. 

**==> picture [361 x 218] intentionally omitted <==**

As indicated by the preceding table and chart, a total of 75 blighted residential units were identified in areas of Burke County as part of our research. The majority (68.0%) of blighted units were located in the city of Morganton, while the remainder of blighted units were scattered among several towns and adjacent areas along the U.S. Highway 70 and Interstate 40 corridors. 

The following table identifies streets within areas of Burke County that contain blighted residential units. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-14** 

~~**Packet Pg. 225**~~
{154}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|||~~**3.2.b**~~|~~**3.2.b**~~|
|---|---|---|---|
|**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH**<br>**VII-15**<br>**Abandoned Homes/Homes in Disrepair (Burke County)**<br>**Location**<br>**Street**<br>**Homes Abandoned**<br>**or in Disrepair**<br>**Share of**<br>**Blighted Homes**<br>Connelly Springs<br>Connelly Church St.<br>Old Blue Ridge Ln.<br>**Total**<br>1<br>1<br>**2**<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>**2.7%**<br>Drexel<br>Bumgarner Dr.<br>N. Main St.<br>Park Ave.<br>Reece Rd.<br>**Total**<br>3<br>1<br>1<br>1<br>**6**<br>4.0%<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>**8.0%**<br>Glen Alpine<br>Cannonball St.<br>Catawba St.<br>Hennessee St.<br>Pea Ridge St.<br>**Total **<br>1<br>1<br>1<br>1<br>**4**<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>**5.3%**<br>Morganton<br>Asheville St.<br>Avery Ave.<br>Bay St.<br>Bouchelle St.<br>S. Chestnut St.<br>W. Concord St.<br>E. Concord St.<br>Coulter St.<br>Dale Cir.<br>Dickinson St.<br>Elm St.<br>Fletcher St.<br>Herron St.<br>Hopewell Rd.<br>Jones St.<br>Kirk St.<br>E. Meeting St.<br>Old N.C. 18<br>Perry St.<br>Poplar St.<br>Regan St.<br>Roper St.<br>Steakhouse Rd.<br>E. Union St.<br>Vine St.<br>Walker Rd.<br>White St.<br>Wilson St.<br>**Total**<br>1<br>1<br>2<br>2<br>1<br>2<br>2<br>1<br>2<br>2<br>4<br>4<br>1<br>2<br>2<br>1<br>1<br>1<br>1<br>1<br>1<br>4<br>1<br>1<br>1<br>6<br>2<br>1<br>**51**<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>2.7%<br>2.7%<br>1.3%<br>2.7%<br>2.7%<br>1.3%<br>2.7%<br>2.7%<br>5.3%<br>5.3%<br>1.3%<br>2.7%<br>2.7%<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>5.3%<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>8.0%<br>2.7%<br>1.3%<br>**68.0%**<br>Rutherford College<br>Malcolm Blvd.<br>**Total **<br>1<br>**1**<br>1.3%<br>**1.3%**<br>Unincorporated Areas*<br>Icard School Rd.<br>Miller Bridge Rd.<br>Old N.C. 10<br>Walker Rd.<br>**Total**<br>1<br>2<br>1<br>1<br>**5**<br>1.3%<br>2.7%<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>**6.7%**<br>Valdese<br>Lincoln Ave. NW<br>Morganton St. NW<br>Orchard St. SW<br>Praley St. SW<br>**Total**<br>1<br>1<br>1<br>3<br>**6**<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>1.3%<br>4.0%<br>**8.0%**<br>**Grand Total **<br>**75**<br>**~100.0%**<br>Source: Bowen National Research<br>*Unincorporated areas outside of city/town extra territorial jurisdiction (ETJ); Location includes city/town limits with adjacent ETJ areas.<br>Streets with at least four homes abandoned and/or in disrepair displayed inred font; Totals may not add up to 100.0% due to rounding.<br>~~**..**~~<br> <br>||~~**..**~~||
||||**Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen National Research Housing Study)**|
|||||
|||||



Source: Bowen National Research 

*Unincorporated areas outside of city/town extra territorial jurisdiction (ETJ); Location includes city/town limits with adjacent ETJ areas. Streets with at least four homes abandoned and/or in disrepair displayed in red font; Totals may not add up to 100.0% due to rounding. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-15** 

~~**Packet Pg. 226**~~
{155}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

As the previous table illustrates, the identified blighted residential units in Burke County are primarily located in the city of Morganton. The identified blighted units in Morganton are generally dispersed throughout the city and are not concentrated along a specific street or neighborhood. Note that streets in Morganton with four or more blighted units (depicted in red font in the previous table) reflect the location of either mobile home parks or apartment buildings.  The preceding list of streets, as well as areas noted on the preceding map, illustrate possible geographic areas of focus for mitigation of residential blight within the county. 

In addition to our on-site efforts to identify residential blight, we identified published secondary data sources that provide insight on possible blighted residential units in the county. This includes estimates of vacant housing units provided by the United States Census and ESRI. Based on these estimates, there are approximately 4,481 vacant units in Burke County, which represent 11.3% of all housing units in the county. Note that 62.1% of vacant units are classified as “other vacant,” which reflects vacant homes that are not otherwise offered for rent/for sale or for seasonal, recreational, or occasional use. The U.S. Census Bureau allows census respondents to provide the reason that a home is vacant. These categories include “needs repairs,” “being repaired,” and “possibly abandoned/to be demolished/condemned” among others. Regardless of the reason selected by respondents, homes that are vacant for a long period of time are generally less likely to be maintained or repaired on a regular basis, therefore allowing these homes to potentially become blighted over time. The 62.1% share of “other vacant” units in Burke County equates to approximately 2,782 housing units, which could be considered the largest possible estimate for the number of homes in the county that could potentially become blighted without regular maintenance and/or repair. While this does not represent a full accounting of residential units exhibiting residential blight, it is reasonable to associate properties identified as “other vacant” as a possible proxy for likely residential blight.  Taking into consideration the total number of housing units in Burke County (39,583), the 2,782 “other vacant” housing units represent 7.0% of all housing units in the county. It is important to reiterate and understand that this is not to say that 7.0% of the county housing stock is blighted. Rather, this illustrates housing structures which could potentially become blighted overtime if ignored/neglected for an extended period of time. 

## **D. DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITIES** 

Housing markets expand when the number of households increases, either from inmigration or from new household formations. In order for a given market to grow, households must find acceptable and available housing units (either newly created or pre-existing). If acceptable units are not available, households will not enter the housing market and the market may stagnate or decline. Rehabilitation of occupied units does not expand housing markets, although it may improve them. For new housing to be created, land and/or existing buildings (suitable for residential use) must be readily available, properly zoned, and feasibly sized for development. The absence of available residential real estate can prevent housing market growth 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-16** 

~~**Packet Pg. 227**~~
{156}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

unless unrealized zoning densities (units per acre) are achieved on existing properties. 

Market growth strategies that recommend additional housing units should have one or more of the following real estate options available: 1) land without buildings, including surface parking lots (new development), 2) unusable buildings (demolition-redevelopment), 3) reusable non-residential buildings (adaptivereuse), and 4) vacant reusable residential buildings (rehabilitation). Reusable residential buildings should be unoccupied prior to acquisition and/or renovation, in order for their units to be newly created within the market. In addition to their availability, these real estate offerings should be zoned for residential use (or capable of achieving the same) and of a feasible size for profitability. 

Based on online and on-the-ground research conducted in October of 2023, Bowen National Research identified sites that could support potential residential development in Burke County. Real estate listings and information from the county tax assessor were also used to supplement the information collected for this report. It should be noted that these potential housing development properties were selected without complete knowledge of availability, price, or zoning status and that the vacancy and for-sale status was not confirmed. Although this search was not exhaustive, it does represent a list of some of the most obvious real estate opportunities in the PSA (Burke County). The investigation resulted in 38 properties being identified. Of the 38 total properties, eight properties contain at least one existing building that is not necessarily vacant and may require demolition, new construction, or adaptive reuse. The remaining 30 properties were vacant or undeveloped parcels of land that could potentially support residential development. It should be noted that our survey of potential development opportunities in Burke County consists of properties that were actively marketed for sale at the time of this report as well as those identified in person while conducting on-the-ground research. 

Information on housing development opportunity sites in Burke County is presented in the following table. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-17** 

~~**Packet Pg. 228**~~
{157}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|||||||||~~**3.2.b**~~|~~**3.2.b**~~|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|~~**..**~~||||||||~~**..**~~||
||||||||||**Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen National Research Housing Study)**|
|**Development Opportunity Sites**||||||||||
|**Map**<br>**Code**|**Street Address**|**Location**|**Year**<br>**Built**|**Building Size**<br>**(Square Feet)**|**Land Size**<br>**(Acres)**|**Zoning District**||||
|1|3637 Miller Bridge Rd.|Connelly<br>Springs|-|-|31.61|IND-Industrial||||
|2|511 Malcolm Blvd.|Connelly<br>Springs|-|-|1.27|C-B-Central Business||||
|3|1141 Malcolm Blvd.|Connelly<br>Springs|-|-|2.36|C-B-Central Business||||
|4|1000 Malcolm Blvd.|Connelly<br>Springs|-|-|2.09|C-B-Central Business||||
|5|1130 U.S. 70|Connelly<br>Springs|-|-|2.25|H-B-Highway Business||||
|6|500 U.S. Highway 70 East|Hildebran|-|-|9.60|G-M-General Manufacturing District||||
|7|123 Main Ave. West|Hildebran|1977|2,150|0.43|N-B-Neighborhood Business District||||
|8|320 Kirksey Dr.|Morganton|-|-|40.12|LID-Low Intensity District||||
|9|100-104 Queen St.|Morganton|1928|4,480|0.05|CBD-Central Business District||||
|10|102 Morganton Heights Blvd.|Morganton|-|-|18.14|HID-High Intensity District||||
|11|102 Bayern Crest|Morganton|-|-|0.57|LID-Low Intensity District||||
|12|Williams Rd.|Morganton|-|-|41.47|HID-High Intensity District||||
|13|1164 Piedmont Rd.|Morganton|-|-|3.46|N-B-Neighborhood Business||||
|14|Sanford Dr.|Morganton|-|-|8.49|HID-High Intensity District||||
|15|539 E. Fleming Dr.|Morganton|-|-|1.29|HID-High Intensity District||||
|16|1307 E. Union St.|Morganton|1901|3,000|73.00|MID-Medium Intensity District||||
|17|3479 Jamestown Rd.|Morganton|-|-|2.94|R-3-Residential District||||
|18|536 Causby Rd.|Morganton|-|-|45.20|MID-Medium Intensity District||||
|19|802-804 Burkemont Ave.|Morganton|1940<br>1949<br>1950<br>1950|936<br>884<br>1,272<br>792|2.48|HID-High Intensity District||||
|20|3890 Bedford St.|Morganton|-|-|2.63|R-1-Residential District||||
|21|5867 Rich Rd.|Morganton|-|-|57.50|R-MU-Rural Mixed-Use||||
|22|Hopewell Rd.|Morganton|-|-|92.98|LID-Low Intensity District||||
|23|4550 Firetower Dr.|Morganton|-|-|49.00|R-1-Residential District||||
|24|Carbon City Rd.|Morganton|-|-|14.00|LID-Low Intensity District||||
|25|Laurel Hills Dr. (Lot 49)|Morganton|-|-|0.49|LID-Low Intensity District||||
|26|1807-1809 S. Sterling St.|Morganton|-|-|2.09|MID-Medium Intensity District||||
|27|400 Carbon City Rd.|Morganton|-|-|25.42|HID-High Intensity District||||
|28|Bouchelle St./E. Meeting St.|Morganton|-|-|0.56|CBD-Central Business District||||
|29|1034 E. Union St.|Morganton|1930<br>1945<br>1957|1,024<br>5,135<br>1,648|1.51|HID-High Intensity District||||
|30|905 Carbon City Rd.|Morganton|1900|720|1.38|MID-Medium Intensity District||||
|31|201 W. Main St.|Morganton|2000|3,392|2.52|B-1||||
|32|Salem Rd./Lee Loop|Morganton|-|-|2.49|CU-Conditional Use District||||
|33|Mimosa Hills Dr.|Morganton|-|-|0.42|LID-Low Intensity District||||
|34|101 N. Main St.|Morganton|-|-|60.00|M-1–Manufacturing District||||
|35|1261 Burkemont Ave.|Morganton|-|-|1.07|HID-High Intensity District||||
|36|826 N. Green St.|Morganton|-|-|166.22|HID-High Intensity District||||
|37|Katherine St. SE|Valdese|-|-|6.50|R-1-Residential District||||
|38|408Pineburr Ave. SE|Valdese|1926|75,790|3.45|B-2 -General BusinessDistrict||||
|**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH**<br>**VII-18**<br>Sources: LoopNet, CREXI, Realtor.com, Burke County GIS and several other real estate websites.<br>Note: Total land area includes total building area. Property class designation provided for properties in instances where zoning could not be verified.<br>N/A – Not Available<br>||||||||||
|||||||||||
|||||||||||



Sources: LoopNet, CREXI, Realtor.com, Burke County GIS and several other real estate websites. Note: Total land area includes total building area. Property class designation provided for properties in instances where zoning could not be verified. N/A – Not Available 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-18** 

~~**Packet Pg. 229**~~
{158}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

In summary, the availability of potential residential development sites (properties capable of delivering new housing units) within the PSA (Burke County) does not appear to be a significant obstacle to increasing the number of housing units. Our cursory investigation for sites within the PSA (both land and buildings) identified 38 properties that are potentially capable of accommodating future residential development via new construction or adaptive reuse. In some instances, adjacent parcels and/or buildings were adjoined to create one potential site location. The 38 identified properties listed in the preceding table represent approximately 777 acres of land and at least 101,000 square feet of existing structure area. Thirteen (13) of the identified properties consist of over 10 acres of land each, providing the ability to develop large residential projects. A total of eight properties have at least one existing building or structure ranging in size from 720 square feet to 75,790 square feet, potentially enabling the redevelopment of such structures into single-family or multifamily projects. However, not all of these properties may be feasible to redevelop as housing due to overall age, condition, or structural makeup (availability and feasibility of identified properties were beyond the scope of this study). 

Given that it appears there are several housing development sites within the PSA that can potentially support new residential development, the location within the PSA where new residential units will have the greatest chance of success is the next critical question. The desirability of a particular neighborhood or location is generally influenced by proximity to work, school, entertainment venues, recreational amenities, retail services, dining establishments, and major roadways. As such, sites within or near established municipalities are likely conducive to new residential units due to the proximity of existing infrastructure, area services and employment opportunities. 

The availability of infrastructure, including water, sewer, roads, electric power, natural gas, and broadband, is a critical factor in determining where real estate development occurs. As higher population densities and taller, multistory structures are directly correlated with lower housing costs, areas of Burke County with municipal water and sewer utilities have a unique opportunity to accommodate housing that is affordable and attainable. For example, developers of Low-Income Housing Tax Credit properties are generally unwilling to submit applications for projects that are not served by public water and sewer utilities, which generally limits multifamily development in areas outside of cities and towns. Access to public utilities and the area’s utility capacity were not considered as part of this study and would require engineering services to assess public utility factors that ultimately impact the viability of a site to support residential development. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-19** 

~~**Packet Pg. 230**~~
{159}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following table summarizes total acreage and overall share of acreage by zoning classification for the 38 identified properties. Note that individual shares in the table below may not add up to 100% due to rounding. 

|**Total Acreage and Share of Acreage by**<br>**Zoning District Category**<br>**Burke County, North Carolina**|**Total Acreage and Share of Acreage by**<br>**Zoning District Category**<br>**Burke County, North Carolina**|**Total Acreage and Share of Acreage by**<br>**Zoning District Category**<br>**Burke County, North Carolina**|
|---|---|---|
|**Zoning District**<br>**Category**|**Total**<br>**Acreage**|**Share of**<br>**Total Acreage**|
|Mixed-Use|656.33|84.5%|
|Residential|61.07|7.9%|
|Industrial|41.21|5.3%|
|Commercial|18.44|2.4%|
|**Total **|**777.05**|**100.0%**|



Note that a significant share (84.5%) of acreage identified within the 38 potential housing development sites is designated for mixed-use. This is primarily due to properties identified within the municipal boundaries of Morganton, which have zoning districts for low-, medium-, and high-density development. The significant supply of mixed-use acreage could potentially allow a wide variety of residential development. The combined share of acreage (7.7%) within a commercial or industrial zoning district may only permit limited types of residential development or may require a change in zoning or variance based on local or county ordinances. 

It is critical to point out that the properties identified in this section do not represent all properties that are available for residential development.  There are likely many sites, both parcels and buildings, within the PSA (Burke County) that could be placed on the market and made available for development.  Future housing strategies may involve public outreach efforts to encourage property owners to notify a designated organization (e.g., local government or economic development representatives, a land bank authority, local Habitat for Humanity officials, local housing authority representatives, etc.) of properties that may be made available for purchase and subsequent development opportunities. 

A map illustrating the location of the 38 potential housing development opportunity properties is on the following page. The Map Code number in the summary table on page VII-18 is used to locate each property. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-20** 

~~**Packet Pg. 231**~~
{160}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 232**
{161}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **E. DEVELOPMENT COSTS AND GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS** 

This section evaluates potential financial and regulatory barriers to residential development in Burke County. For the purposes of this analysis, potential financial barriers to development include land costs, labor costs, utility installation costs, and property taxes. Regulatory barriers to development that were considered in this section focused on residential zoning for the county as a whole as well as larger municipalities. 

## Development Costs 

_Land costs_ , including acquisition costs and taxes, factor into the development of real estate and could be a potential barrier to development. When land costs are bundled into construction costs, a greater picture emerges of overall development costs. Availability of land suitable for development, which typically includes access to utilities and municipal water and sewer, also affects land costs. 

A common barrier to development is the _lack of available land_ within a municipality or county for a large-scale residential project, especially within established areas. The type of vacant parcel needed for a large-scale residential project typically has to meet several criteria in order to be shovel-ready, including availability of utilities, a location outside of a designated flood zone, and proximity to community services. Once these factors are considered, the number of available parcels suitable for development greatly diminishes. This in turn drives up prices for land that meets most or all of these criteria. 

A search for vacant parcels listed for sale in Burke County was conducted on Realtor.com and 456 vacant parcels were identified within the county as of December 2023. As the majority (89.0%) of these are comprised of smaller parcels containing less than five acres, our analysis has been refined to focus on larger parcels (five acres or larger) which are likely to be more conducive to larger scale multifamily and single-family residential developments. A total of 50 parcels that are five acres or larger in size were identified for sale within the county. From these 50 parcels, we analyzed those which are less than 50 acres, non-waterfront, and located along/near more heavily traveled thoroughfares and/or within relative proximity to community services throughout the county. Such parcels are likely to be most conducive to traditional multifamily development. 

The following table illustrates pricing for the selected parcels within Burke County and for similar properties located in adjacent counties. Avery County has been excluded from this analysis of land costs given its more rural nature and general lack of vacant parcels that are conducive to multifamily residential development. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-22** 

~~**Packet Pg. 233**~~
{162}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|**Median Price Per Acre of Vacant Land**<br>**(As of December 2023)**|**Median Price Per Acre of Vacant Land**<br>**(As of December 2023)**|**Median Price Per Acre of Vacant Land**<br>**(As of December 2023)**|
|---|---|---|
|**County**|**Median Acreage**|**Median Price Per Acre**|
|**Burke**|**5.66**|**$19,305**|
|Caldwell|10.64|$51,754|
|Catawba|20.00|$53,619|
|Cleveland|20.18|$54,979|
|McDowell|15.76|$15,677|
|Rutherford|12.06|$15,553|



Source: Realtor.com, Bowen National Research 

As the preceding illustrates, Burke County has a much lower price per acre as compared to several adjacent counties. Note that Burke County also has the lowest median acreage figure (5.66 acres) among comparable properties in adjacent counties. While Burke County has numerous listings for vacant land larger than the median acreage figure, many of these listings are for “raw land” in rural areas of the county with asking prices generally ranging from $5,000 to $10,000 per acre. By comparison, land listings in Caldwell, Catawba, and Cleveland counties have a wider range of vacant land within areas that could support residential development. In fact, there were three listings for vacant land in Cleveland County specifically marketed for multifamily development that were listed at $100,000 per acre or more. Based on pricing, vacant land within Burke County represents a value as compared to similar parcels located in more developed counties. 

_Labor costs_ and availability of skilled and qualified labor are also important factors for development costs. Burke County is part of the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA) according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). According to BLS data, the mean annual wage for construction and extraction occupations in the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton MSA is $45,230. This is a lower annual wage for these occupations than the mean annual wage offered in the state of North Carolina ($47,720). Mean annual wages for construction and extraction occupations in the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton MSA range from $35,150 for helpers of electricians to $62,870 for first-line supervisors. Note that construction and extraction occupations only account for approximately 25 out of every 1,000 jobs in the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton MSA, as compared to approximately 40 out of every 1,000 jobs statewide. The construction sector accounts for approximately 2.5% of the MSA job market, likely contributing to a shortage of skilled and qualified workers for construction projects. This shortage of skilled and qualified workers can often result in increased costs for construction projects, which in turn can result in higher rents and home prices. This labor shortage in the construction sector appears to be an ongoing trend impacting much of the United States. 

The following table illustrates the employment number, share, and corresponding typical annual mean wages for detailed occupations within the construction and extraction sector for the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton MSA, the Asheville MSA, the Charlotte-Concord-Gastonia MSA and the state of North Carolina. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-23** 

~~**Packet Pg. 234**~~
{163}------------------------------------------------
||||||||||||||~~**3.2.b**~~|~~**3.2.b**~~|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|||||||||||~~**..**~~|||~~**..**~~||
|||||||||||||||**Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358(HousingNeeds Assessment) -Revised2-7-24  (4307 :BNR- BowenNationalResearch Housing Study)**|
||**Typical Wages by Detailed Construction & Extraction Occupations**||||||||||||||
|**Occupation**<br>**Type**|**Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton**<br>**MSA**|||**Asheville MSA**|||**Charlotte-Concord-**<br>**Gastonia MSA**|||**North Carolina**<br>|||||
||**Employment**||**Mean**<br>**Wage**|**Employment**||**Mean**<br>**Wage**|**Employment**||**Mean**<br>**Wage**|**Employment**|||**Mean**<br>**Wage**<br>||
||**Number**|**Share**||**Number**|**Share**||**Number**|**Share**||**Number**|**Share**||||
|First-Line<br>Supervisors of<br>Construction<br>Trades &<br>Extraction<br>Workers|<br>660|18.8%|$62,870|1,160|17.3%|$65,820|8,780|18.7%|$69,360|30,290|18.7%||$66,720<br>||
|Brickmasons<br>&<br>Blockmasons|<br>30|0.9%|$42,680|50|0.7%|$43,560|650|1.4%|$46,570|1,580|1.0%||$45,130<br>||
|Carpenters|320|9.1%|$43,280|850|12.6%|$42,360|3,570|7.6%|$46,500|14,710|9.1%||$44,220<br>||
|Cement<br>Masons &<br>Concrete<br>Finishers|100|2.8%|$42,650|180|2.7%|$43,050|1,660|3.5%|$45,970|5,190|3.2%||$44,500<br>||
|Construction<br>Laborers|590|16.8%|$35,950|1,250|18.6%|$36,570|9,940|21.2%|$37,840|31,600|19.5%||$36,760<br>||
|Operating<br>Engineers &<br>Other<br>Construction<br>Equipment<br>Operators|380|10.8%|$43,280|650|9.7%|$44,800|3,870|8.2%|$47,530|14,910|9.2%||$45,500<br>||
|Electricians|580|16.5%|$47,120|770|11.5%|$48,670|7,150|15.2%|$52,050|22,640|13.9%||$50,900<br>||
|Painters,<br>Construction<br>&<br>Maintenance|90|2.6%|$39,960|210|3.1%|$39,650|1,070|2.3%|$42,860|4,350|2.7%||$39,620<br>||
|Pipelayers|120|3.4%|$39,070|170|2.5%|$41,910|940|2.0%|$44,130|3,020|1.9%||$41,710<br>||
|Plumbers,<br>Pipefitters, &<br>Steamfitters|<br>240|6.8%|$47,240|570|8.5%|$50,020|3,660|7.8%|$52,230|14,400|8.9%||$49,210<br>||
|Roofers|90|2.6%|$37,870|120|1.8%|$44,320|820|1.7%|$43,440|2,660|1.6%||$42,890<br>||
|Sheet Metal<br>Workers|50|1.4%|$44,780|80|1.2%|$46,580|730|1.6%|$45,910|2,910|1.8%||$47,540<br>||
|Helpers –<br>Electricians|160|4.5%|$35,150|350|5.2%|$35,040|1,490|3.2%|$36,440|5,930|3.7%||$35,760<br>||
|Helpers –<br>Pipelayers,<br>Plumbers,<br>Pipefitters, &<br>Steamers|<br>80|2.3%|$35,300|130|1.9%|$36,930|910|1.9%|$37,180|3,350|2.1%||$36,040<br>||
|Construction<br>& Building<br>Inspectors|<br>30|0.9%|$53,230|180|2.7%|$58,450|1,670|3.6%|$64,920|4,850|3.0%||$62,410<br>||
|Total|3,520|100.0%|$45,230|6,720|100.0%|$46,200|46,910|100.0%|$49,520|143,640|100.0%||$47,720<br>||
|**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH**<br>**VII-24**<br>Source – Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) – May 2022<br>Note: Total reflects only Construction and Extraction occupations illustrated in this table; Construction and Extraction occupations not related to building<br>construction have been excluded.<br>~~**Pk P 23**~~<br>|||||||||||||||
|||||||||||||~~**Pk P 23**~~|||
|||||||||||||~~**acet g. 5**~~|||



~~**Packet Pg. 235**~~
{164}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Based on a competitive analysis of wages in the construction sector depicted in the preceding table, the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton MSA in which the subject county (Burke County) is located typically has lower wages for construction occupations than nearby MSAs as well as the state of North Carolina. This may result in lower residential development costs for future projects in Burke County compared to other nearby areas. Although labor costs are lower compared to nearby MSAs, note that a significant share of both stakeholders and developers surveyed in Burke County noted that cost of labor/materials is one of the most significant barriers to residential development in the county. Despite the lower labor rates compared to nearby MSAs, labor costs do appear to be a significant barrier to development in the county. 

_Utility costs for natural gas and electric service_ , specifically the cost to tap into or run utility service at a specific location, also factors into overall development costs. Fees paid by the developer or contractor to establish natural gas and electric service are typically passed on to the buyer upon completion of a single-family house, condominium unit, or townhouse. The total price of a new residential home or unit often includes tap fees for water, sewer, electric and natural gas utilities, which can vary by location. In Burke County, electric service is provided by Duke Energy Carolinas. 

As of October 2023, electric rates for Duke Energy Carolinas customers consist of $14.00 per month (basic facilities charge) and an energy usage rate of $0.094884 per kilowatt-hour. Note that the North Carolina Utilities Commission approved an overall 14.6% increase in utility rates for Duke Energy Carolinas customers during a three-year period starting in January 2024. The largest rate increase (8.3%) during this three-year period will occur in 2024. The City of Morganton also provides electric service via its city-owned public utility to residents. Morganton charges its electric customers $12.50 per month (basic facilities charge) and an energy usage rate of $0.0961 per kilowatt-hour during summer months (June to September) and $0.0915 per kilowatt-hour during non-summer months (October to May). 

Burke County is also part of the service area for Piedmont Natural Gas. Customers of Piedmont Natural Gas pay a $10.00 per month service charge and a rate of $1.42895 per therm (100,000 British Thermal Units) between November and March and a rate of $1.42430 per therm between April and October. One therm is approximately 29 kilowatt-hours of energy. 

Water and wastewater (sewer) utilities are supplied by various service providers within Burke County. The county’s water and sewer department provides water and/or wastewater service to a small portion of the county’s households, while several municipalities in the county provide water and sewer utilities to its citizens. The water and wastewater (sewer) rates for Burke County and select municipalities are listed in the following table. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-25** 

~~**Packet Pg. 236**~~
{165}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|**Water/Wastewater (Sewer) Fees by Location (Burke County)**|**Water/Wastewater (Sewer) Fees by Location (Burke County)**|**Water/Wastewater (Sewer) Fees by Location (Burke County)**|**Water/Wastewater (Sewer) Fees by Location (Burke County)**|**Water/Wastewater (Sewer) Fees by Location (Burke County)**|
|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Location**|**Monthly**<br>**Water Fee**|**Consumption**<br>**Rate**|**Monthly**<br>**Sewer Fee**|**Consumption**<br>**Rate**|
|Burke County|$50.00|$6.00/1,000 gal|$50.00|$6.00/1,000 gal|
|Morganton (within city)|$10.50|$1.37/1,000 gal|$17.83|$3.60/1,000 gal|
|Morganton (outside city)|$17.55|$2.74/1,000 gal|$27.30|$7.39/1,000 gal|
|Drexel|$34.65|$2.45/1,000 gal|$19.00|$1.73/1,000 gal|
|Valdese|$36.65|$3.70/1,000 gal|$7.85|$2.65/1,000 gal|
|Rutherford College|$18.40|$5.75/1,000 gal|$20.60|$5.25/1,000 gal|



Source: City of Morganton FY 2023-2024 Fee Schedule, North Carolina Water and Wastewater Rates Dashboards (UNC School of Government) 

Water and wastewater rates and associated fees vary greatly depending on location in Burke County. Morganton has the lowest monthly water fees and rates for households living in the city compared to other locations in the county while Burke County system customers pay the highest rates and fees. Monthly water fees range from $10.50 for residents within the city of Morganton to $50.00 for users of the Burke County water system. Consumption rates for water usage range from $1.37 per 1,000 gallons for Morganton city residents to $6.00 per 1,000 gallons for Burke County water system customers. Consumption rates for wastewater/sewer service (based on water usage) range from $1.73 per 1,000 gallons in Drexel to $6.00 per 1,000 gallons for Burke County sewer customers. 

We recognize the preceding utility fees would generally only apply to and/or be the responsibility of a tenant/homeowner.  They have been presented, however, to illustrate fees associated with typical utilities in the Burke County area should a developer decide to include some utility costs/expenses in the cost of rent for a multifamily property. 

Water and sewer connection fees (commonly referred to as tap fees) were also verified for Burke County and Morganton. These connection (or tap) fees are typically paid by homebuilders and developers during the construction process. The water tap fee for the Burke County system is $1,500 while the sewer tap fee is $1,000, reflecting a combined total of $2,500. Morganton has a two-tiered pricing structure depending on if a customer resides within the city limits or outside the city. Customers in the city of Morganton pay a $1,500 water tap fee and a $1,500 sewer tap fee ($3,000 total), while customers outside the city pay a $2,000 water tap fee and a $2,000 sewer tap fee ($4,000 total).  Based on our research, counties adjacent to Burke County and the larger municipalities therein generally have water tap fees ranging from $541 to $1,660 and sewer tap fees ranging from $1,080 to $2,700.  Thus, Burke County/Morganton water/sewer tap fees are considered similar to/competitive with those of the surrounding areas. 

_Government Development Fees_ in the form of permit fees charged by city, town, or county governments also factor into development costs. Note that development costs can vary considerably among individual communities within a given county. In an attempt to better understand these cost factors, the base fees for a new singlefamily residential structure were compiled for areas of Burke County outside of municipal boundaries and for the city of Morganton.  It should be noted that the 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-26** 

~~**Packet Pg. 237**~~
{166}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

base fees included in this analysis may not represent all applicable fees required for a new construction project in each area due to the variance that exists among individual projects and the specifics of the applicable ordinances in each community.  As a result, the base fees that follow should be used as a general guideline for the initial cost to begin a residential construction project in each of the communities included. 

Burke County bases its building fees on the overall _value_ of a structure. For this example, we used a structure that is valued at $300,000. The total base fees assessed for a $300,000 structure are $1,205. These fees include a $35 zoning permit fee and base miscellaneous fees of $1.00 for every $256.41 in structure value. Note that the miscellaneous fees include plumbing, electric, and mechanical fees billed as part of the total base fee. The $1.00 figure per $256.41 in structure value was derived from building fees paid to Burke County for new residential structures in November 2023. 

The City of Morganton bases its building fees on the overall _square footage_ of a structure. For this example, we used a single-family structure that is 3,000 square feet in size. The City of Morganton applies a rate of $0.449064 per square foot for residential structures, which includes plumbing, electric, and mechanical fees. Using this rate, a 3,000 square-foot single-family residential structure built in the city would have total base fees of approximately $1,397 (rounded to the nearest dollar). These total base fees also include a $50 zoning permit fee. Based on research conducted for a similarly sized new residential structure in adjacent counties, total building fees in Burke County and the City of Morganton are within the range of building fees assessed in these counties. Therefore, total building fees assessed by Burke County and the City of Morganton are not considered to be a barrier to development compared to adjacent counties. 

_Property taxes_ vary by county in North Carolina, based on municipality, school district, fire and police protection services, and special taxing districts. Each county establishes its own base tax rate for all residents, then additional taxes and assessments are applied based on municipality, school district location, and special tax districts (if applicable). According to information provided by the North Carolina Department of Revenue (NCDOR), the base property tax rate in Burke County is $0.5600 for every $100 in valuation. For a home valued at $300,000, the property taxes would be $1,680. 

By comparison, the base property tax rates in adjacent counties range from a low of $0.3985 in Catawba County to a high of $0.6875 in Cleveland County (per $100 in valuation). Using the same $300,000 home as an example, the annual property tax bill would range from $1,195.50 to $2,062.50 in adjacent counties. The property tax rate in Burke County is within the middle portion of this range, which should enable the county to compete well within the region and likely contributes to the growth of the county. Municipal property taxes in Burke County, which are paid by property owners within municipal boundaries, are paid in addition to county property taxes.  Municipal property tax rates vary considerably in the county and range from $0.05 to $0.525 per $100 in valuation. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-27** 

~~**Packet Pg. 238**~~
{167}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following table shows a comparison of property tax millage rates for municipalities in Burke County: 

|**Tax Millage Rates (Fiscal Year 2023-2024) for Burke County Municipalities**|**Tax Millage Rates (Fiscal Year 2023-2024) for Burke County Municipalities**|**Tax Millage Rates (Fiscal Year 2023-2024) for Burke County Municipalities**|**Tax Millage Rates (Fiscal Year 2023-2024) for Burke County Municipalities**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Municipality**|**Tax Millage Rate**<br>**(County)**|**Tax Millage Rate**<br>**(Municipality)**|**Combined Tax**<br>**Millage Rate**|
|Connelly Springs|$0.5600|$0.0500|**$0.6100**|
|Drexel|$0.5600|$0.3500|**$0.9100**|
|Glen Alpine|$0.5600|$0.2900|**$0.8500**|
|Hickory*|$0.5600|$0.4550|**$1.0150**|
|Hildebran|$0.5600|$0.1500|**$0.7100**|
|Long View*|$0.5600|$0.4900|**$1.0500**|
|Morganton|$0.5600|$0.5000|**$1.0600**|
|Rhodhiss*|$0.5600|$0.5250|**$1.0850**|
|Rutherford College|$0.5600|$0.1200|**$0.6800**|
|Valdese|$0.5600|$0.5150|**$1.0750**|



Source: North Carolina Department of Revenue (NCDOR) – FY 2023-24 Property Tax Rates *Reflects portion of municipality that is in Burke County Millage rates per $100 of taxable value Fire department assessment districts and special tax districts not included in table above. The two lowest tax millage rates reflected in **blue font.** The two highest tax millage rates reflected in **red font** . 

Tax millage rates for municipalities in Burke County range from a low of $0.6100 per $100 valuation in Connelly Springs to a high of $1.0850 per $100 valuation in the portion of Rhodhiss located within Burke County. Note that smaller municipalities in the county typically have lower millage rates while larger municipalities have higher millage rates. 

The following table compares the overall range and median property tax millage rate figures in Burke County with adjacent counties in North Carolina. Note that the “base” tax figure shown in the table is the base county tax rate outside of municipalities. 

|**Tax Millage Rates (FY 2023-24)**<br>**Burke County and Adjacent**<br>**North Carolina Counties**|**Tax Millage Rates (FY 2023-24)**<br>**Burke County and Adjacent**<br>**North Carolina Counties**|**Tax Millage Rates (FY 2023-24)**<br>**Burke County and Adjacent**<br>**North Carolina Counties**|**Tax Millage Rates (FY 2023-24)**<br>**Burke County and Adjacent**<br>**North Carolina Counties**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**County**|**Combined Tax**<br>**Millage Rates***|**County**|**Combined Tax**<br>**Millage Rates***|
|**Burke**|**$0.5600 (Base)**<br>**$0.9625 (Median)**<br>**$1.0750 (High)**|Cleveland|$0.6875 (Base)<br>$0.9125 (Median)<br>$1.2050 (High)|
|Avery|$0.4000 (Base)<br>$0.8000 (Median)<br>$1.0500 (High)|Lincoln|$0.4990 (Base)<br>$0.9390 (Median)<br>$0.9990 (High)|
|Caldwell|$0.6300 (Base)<br>$1.0600 (Median)<br>$1.1550 (High)|McDowell|$0.5675 (Base)<br>$1.0275 (Median)<br>$1.1175 (High)|
|Catawba|$0.3985 (Base)<br>$0.8073 (Median)<br>$0.8885 (High)|Rutherford|$0.4540 (Base)<br>$0.7875 (Median)<br>$1.0440 (High)|



Source: North Carolina Department of Revenue (NCDOR) – FY 2023-24 Property Tax 

Rates 

**Counties** 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-28** 

~~**Packet Pg. 239**~~
{168}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Based on property tax millage rates for Fiscal Year 2023-2024, Burke County has a higher _median_ property tax millage rate for its municipalities compared to most of the adjacent North Carolina counties. Of the seven adjacent counties, only McDowell and Caldwell counties have higher median property tax millage rates for municipalities within these respective counties. Note that the tax rates within the table reflect a combination of county and municipal tax millage rates for comparison purposes. Overall, we do not believe property taxes in Burke County are excessively high compared to adjacent locations and likely do not have a significant influence on residential development. 

## Residential Zoning 

Residential zoning codes generally dictate the type of housing that is built within a particular area.  In this section we evaluate county and municipal zoning codes in an attempt to identify any deficiencies that may adversely impact residential development. _Note that all parcels in Burke County are subject to zoning regulations._ Municipalities in Burke County have zoning districts for properties within their respective planning areas. In addition, Burke County has zoning regulations for parcels located outside municipal boundaries. A review of zoning regulations that permit some level of residential development in Burke County is listed in the following table. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-29** 

~~**Packet Pg. 240**~~
{169}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## _Zoning Districts – Burke County_ 

|||~~**3.2.b**~~|~~**3.2.b**~~|
|---|---|---|---|
|**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH**<br>**VII-30**<br>_Zoning Districts – Burke County_<br>**Burke County– Zoning Districts**<br>**Zoning District**<br>**Description**<br>**R-1**Residential District<br>Intended to be limited exclusively to single-family site built and modular dwelling units.<br>Single-family dwellings, family care homes, and short-term rentals are permitted by right<br>within this zoning district. Accessory dwelling units are considered to be an accessory use,<br>while family child care homes may be approved as a special use.<br>**R-2**Residential District<br>This zoning district is exclusively residential while allowing a wider variety of structure<br>types compared to the R-1 zoning district. Single-family dwellings, duplexes, family care<br>homes, family child care homes, Class A manufactured homes, and short-term rentals are<br>permitted by right within this zoning district. Accessory dwelling units are considered to<br>be an accessory use, while multiple-family dwelling units may be approved as a special<br>use.<br>**R-3**Residential District<br>A less restrictive residential district that allows a broader range of residential uses<br>compared to the R-1 and R-2 districts.  Single-family dwellings, duplexes, multiple-family<br>dwellings, family care homes, family child care homes, manufactured homes (Class A and<br>B) and short-term rentals are all permitted by right in this zoning district. Accessory<br>dwelling units are considered to be an accessory use, while mobile home parks may be<br>approved as a special use.<br>**R-MU**Rural Mixed-Use District<br>Intended to allow residential and non-residential development to occur with fewer<br>restrictions in less urbanized areas of the county. Single-family dwellings, duplexes,<br>family care homes, family child care homes, manufactured homes (Class A, B, C, and D),<br>mixed-use development, and short-term rentals are all permitted by right in this zoning<br>district. Accessory dwelling units are considered to be an accessory use, while multiple-<br>family dwellings and mobile home parks may each be approved as a special use.<br>**PRMU**Planned Residential Mixed-Use<br>District<br>Intended to allow developments composed of a mix of residential, retail, and office uses<br>promoting innovative arrangements of buildings and open space uses. Single-family<br>dwellings, duplexes, family care homes, mixed-use development, and short-term rentals<br>are all permitted by right in this zoning district. Accessory dwelling units are considered<br>to be an accessory use, while multiple-family dwellings and mobile home parks may each<br>be approved as a special use.<br>**CON**Conservation District<br>Allows low-density residential development and associated uses and is primarily designed<br>to prevent large numbers of housing units from impacting rural landscapes. Single-family<br>dwellings, duplexes, family care homes, and short-term rentals are permitted by right<br>within this zoning district. Accessory dwelling units are considered to be an accessory use,<br>while family child care homes and mixed-use development projects may each be approved<br>as a special use.<br>**O-I**Office & Institutional District<br>Designed to provide a wide range of civic, institutional, retail, service, and office uses.<br>Residential land uses are not permitted by right within this zoning district. Mixed-use<br>development projects may be approved as a special use.<br>**N-B**Neighborhood Business District<br>Intended for the use of businesses and other uses which are properly located near<br>established rural neighborhoods. Residential land uses are not permitted by right within<br>this zoning district. Mixed-use development projects may be approved as a special use.<br>**G-B **General Business District<br>Established to provide suitable locations for commercial activities which serve the general<br>public. Mixed-use development projects are permitted by right within this zoning district.<br>Source: Burke County Zoning Ordinance<br>Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis.<br>The Burke County Zoning Ordinance permits a wide variety of residential<br>development types by right in residential zoning districts. While the R-1 zoning<br>district exclusively permits single-family detached dwellings, the R-2 and R-3<br>zoning districts each allow for higher-density structures either by right or by special<br>use permit. The two mixed-use districts (R-MU and PRMU) also allow a wide<br>range of residential structures to be built, though multiple-unit structures (e.g.,<br>~~**..**~~<br> <br>||~~**..**~~||
||||**Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen National Research Housing Study)**|
|||||
|||||



Source: Burke County Zoning Ordinance 

Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. 

The Burke County Zoning Ordinance permits a wide variety of residential development types by right in residential zoning districts. While the R-1 zoning district exclusively permits single-family detached dwellings, the R-2 and R-3 zoning districts each allow for higher-density structures either by right or by special use permit. The two mixed-use districts (R-MU and PRMU) also allow a wide range of residential structures to be built, though multiple-unit structures (e.g., 

~~**Packet Pg. 241**~~ 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-30**
{170}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

apartment buildings) require a special use permit in both mixed-use districts. A table summarizing permitted land uses within each Burke County zoning district is included later in this section. 

Lot area requirements, setbacks and building height restrictions for zoning districts that allow residential development are listed in the following table: 

|**Burke County– Lot Area, Setbacks and Building Height Requirements by Zoning District**|**Burke County– Lot Area, Setbacks and Building Height Requirements by Zoning District**|**Burke County– Lot Area, Setbacks and Building Height Requirements by Zoning District**|**Burke County– Lot Area, Setbacks and Building Height Requirements by Zoning District**|**Burke County– Lot Area, Setbacks and Building Height Requirements by Zoning District**|**Burke County– Lot Area, Setbacks and Building Height Requirements by Zoning District**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Zoning District**|**Minimum**<br>**Lot Size**<br>**(Sq. Ft.)**|**Front Yard**<br>**Setback**|**Side**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**|**Rear Yard**<br>**Setback**|**Maximum**<br>**Building**<br>**Height**|
|**R-1**Residential District|21,780-30,000|30-45 ft.|15-20 ft.|20 ft.|35 ft.|
|**R-2**Residential District|21,780-30,000|30-45 ft.|15-20 ft.|20 ft.|35 ft.|
|**R-3**Residential District|25,000-40,000|30-45 ft.|15-20 ft.|20 ft.|35 ft.|
|**R-MU**Rural Mixed-Use District|30,000-50,000|30-45 ft.|15-20 ft.|20 ft.|35 ft.|
|**PRMU**Planned Residential Mixed-Use District|25,000-40,000|30-45 ft.|15-20 ft.|20 ft.|35 ft.|
|**CON**Conservation District|Not Listed|Not Listed|Not Listed|Not Listed|35 ft.|
|**O-I**Office & Institutional District|87,120-108,900|40 ft.|30-35 ft.|30 ft.|50 ft.*|
|**N-B**Neighborhood Business District|25,000-40,000|40 ft.|30-35 ft.|30 ft.|50 ft.*|
|**G-B**General BusinessDistrict|30,000-50,000|40ft.|30-35ft.|30ft.|50ft.*|



Source: Burke County Zoning Ordinance 

Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. 

Minimum lot size range reflects properties in areas with public water and sewer (low) and properties in areas with no public utilities (high). Minimum front yard setback is 45 feet for a residential lot adjacent to a minor arterial, major collector street, or urban major thoroughfare. Minimum side yard setback is 20 feet for a residential corner lot. 

*Non-residential buildings that exceed 50 feet in height require a special use permit. 

Minimum lot size requirements among residential zoning districts vary based on whether a parcel is located within an area that has public water and sewer utilities. The minimum lot size for the R-1 and R-2 zoning districts ranges from 21,780 square feet for parcels within areas with public water and sewer utilities to 30,000 square feet for areas _without_ public water and sewer utilities. Due to the larger minimum lot size requirements, maximum density is limited to two to four units per acre for single-family and duplex dwellings, respectively. By comparison, the R-3, R-MU and PRMU zoning districts may allow mixed-use properties with a residential component (e.g., residential units over first-floor retail), which could potentially allow multifamily and/or mixed-use development on larger parcels within this district. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-31** 

~~**Packet Pg. 242**~~
{171}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The permitted residential land uses within the county’s zoning districts are shown in the following table. 

**==> picture [528 x 204] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts<br>Burke County<br>Zoning Districts<br>Land Use Type R-1  R-2  R-3  R-MU  PRMU  CON  O-1  N-B  G-B<br>Accessory dwelling unit  A  A  A  A  A  A  -- -- --<br>Duplex dwelling unit  -- P  P  P  P  P  -- -- --<br>Family care home  P  P  P  P  P  P  -- -- --<br>Family child care home  S  P  P  P  S  S  -- -- --<br>Manufactured home (Class A)  -- P  P  P  -- -- -- -- --<br>Manufactured home (Class B)  -- -- P  P  -- -- -- -- --<br>Manufactured home (Class C)  -- -- -- P  -- -- -- -- --<br>Manufactured home (Class D)  -- -- -- P  -- -- -- -- --<br>Mixed-use development  -- -- -- P  P  S  S  S  P<br>Mobile home park  -- -- S  S  -- -- -- -- --<br>Multiple-family dwelling unit  -- S  P  S  S  -- -- -- --<br>Short-term rental  P  P  P  P  P  P  -- -- --<br>Single-family dwelling unit  P  P  P  P  P  P  -- -- --<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Source: Burke County Zoning Ordinance Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. Legend: P = permitted use; S = special use approval required; A = accessory use; -- land use not permitted. 

Residential zoning districts listed in the preceding tables allow a wide variety of dwelling types including single-family homes, duplexes, and multiple-family dwelling units. Mixed-use developments are not permitted in the R-1, R-2, and R- 3 zoning districts, but are permitted by right in the mixed-use zoning districts (RMU and PRMU) as well as the General Business District (G-B). Commercial zoning districts within the county’s planning area do not permit land uses that are exclusively residential. However, these commercial zoning districts do allow for mixed-use development either by right or by special use permit. Note that shortterm rentals are permitted in all residential zoning districts but are prohibited in commercial zoning districts. 

A zoning map of Burke County is included on the following page. An updated version of the county zoning map is provided on the Burke County GIS website. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-32** 

~~**Packet Pg. 243**~~
{172}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Current Zoning Map** 

**as of January 2023** 

**==> picture [55 x 55] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [490 x 108] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [490 x 107] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [490 x 108] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [197 x 225] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [149 x 187] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [129 x 92] intentionally omitted <==**

**Packet Pg. 244**
{173}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

_Zoning Districts – City of Morganton_ 

|**City of Morganton– Base Zoning Districts**|**City of Morganton– Base Zoning Districts**|
|---|---|
|**Zoning District**|**Description**|
|**LID**Low Intensity District|Established primarily for single-family residential uses at a variety of densities<br>depending on location and proximity to transportation corridors and services.<br>Accessory dwellings/structures, family care homes, single-family dwellings, two-<br>family dwellings, and multifamily dwellings are permitted by right within this zoning<br>district.|
|**MID**Medium Intensity District|Intended for a variety of medium- to high-density residential and low- to medium-<br>intensity<br>civic,<br>institutional,<br>office,<br>service,<br>and<br>retail<br>uses.<br>Accessory<br>dwellings/structures, boarding and rooming houses, family care homes, single-family<br>dwellings, two-family dwellings, multifamily dwellings, residential care facilities, and<br>residential shelters are permitted by right within this zoning district.|
|**HID**High Intensity District|Established to accommodate high-density residential and a wide variety of civic,<br>institutional, retail, service and office uses along major arterials. Accessory<br>dwellings/structures, boarding and rooming houses, family care homes, single-family<br>dwellings, two-family dwellings, multifamily dwellings, residential care facilities, and<br>residential shelters are permitted by right within this zoning district.|
|**CBD**Central Business District|Established to protect and promote the continued vitality of downtown Morganton with<br>the intention of providing a concentration of activities in a pedestrian-oriented setting.<br>Activities include retail trade, office, professional services, and high-density<br>residential. Accessory dwellings/structures, family care homes, single-family<br>dwellings, two-family dwellings, and multifamily dwellings are permitted by right<br>within this zoning district.|
|**SID**State Institutional District|Established to accommodate a variety of institutional and government uses on land<br>owned by the State of North Carolina. Accessory dwellings/structures, family care<br>homes, single-family dwellings, two-family dwellings, multifamily dwellings,<br>residential care facilities, and residential shelters are permitted by right within this<br>zoning district.|



Source: City of Morganton Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) – Article 3 – Zoning Districts and Uses Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. 

The City of Morganton Unified Development Ordinance permits a variety of development types within its base zoning districts. Single-family dwellings, duplexes, and multifamily dwellings are permitted by right in each of the zoning districts listed in the preceding table. Note that three zoning districts were created based on the level of development _intensity_ (low, medium, or high) in a given area. This focus on development intensity (rather than land use type) permits a wider range of mixed-use development to occur in these zoning districts. The Central Business District (CBD) was established to promote and protect pedestrianoriented activities in the downtown area, while the State Institutional District (SID) was established to guide development of areas owned by the State of North Carolina. 

In addition to the base zoning districts summarized in the preceding table, the City of Morganton has also established overlay districts. According to the City’s Unified Development Ordinance, base zoning districts that include an overlay district would be subject to additional requirements. A summary of overlay districts that have a significant impact on residential development is included in the following table. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-34** 

~~**Packet Pg. 245**~~
{174}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|**City of Morganton– Overlay Districts**<br>**Overlay District**<br>**Description**<br>Neighborhood Conservation Overlay (NC-O)<br>Intent of this overlay district is to protect and conserve established neighborhoods<br>within the Low Intensity District (LID) and Medium Intensity District (MID) from<br>more intensive or incompatible uses. Land uses within this overlay district are primarily<br>single-family residential.<br>Manufactured Home Overlay (MH-O)<br>Intent of this overlay district is to allow for manufactured homes on individual lots and<br>set minimum standards for installation of these homes.<br>Corridor Overlay (C-O)<br>Intent of this overlay district is to establish a minimum standard of development along<br>the city’s main thoroughfares to enhance its appearance and promote economic<br>development.<br>River District Overlay (RD-O)<br>Intent of this overlay district is to protect and conserve the natural setting of area in the<br>vicinity of the Catawba River and Catawba Meadows Park.<br>RestrictedResidentialOverlay (RR-O)<br>Purpose of this overlay district is to restrict land uses to residential and ancillary uses<br>while allowing higher densities associated with Medium Intensity District (MID), High<br>IntensityDistrict (HID), and Central BusinessDistrict (CBD)zones.<br>Source: City of Morganton Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) – Article 3 – Zoning Districts and Uses<br>Note: Table only includes overlay districts that have significant impact on residential development.|
|---|



Of the listed overlay districts in the City’s Unified Development Ordinance, the Neighborhood Conservation Overlay (NC-O) and the Restricted Residential Overlay (RR-O) appear to have the greatest impact on residential development in the city. While the low-, medium-, and high-intensity zoning districts allow a wide range of development types, these overlays restrict the types of land uses that can be built within these zoning districts. For example, the intent of the NC-O is to protect and conserve established residential neighborhoods in the LID and MID zoning districts. Therefore, the NC-O may prohibit or limit certain land uses that would adversely affect established residential neighborhoods. The RR-O also restricts land uses within the MID, HID, and CBD zoning districts. 

Lot area requirements, setbacks and building height restrictions for zoning districts in the city of Morganton that allow residential development are listed in the following table: 

|**City of Morganton– Lot Area, Setbacks and Building Height Requirements**<br>**Zoning District**<br>**Minimum**<br>**Lot Area**<br>**(Sq. Ft.)***<br>**Maximum**<br>**Density**<br>**(DU/A)****<br>**Minimum**<br>**Lot**<br>**Width**<br>**Front**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>**LID**Low Intensity District<br>20,000<br>2-6 DU/A<br>25-80 ft.<br>10-30 ft.<br>**MID**Medium Intensity District<br>20,000<br>2-10 DU/A<br>25-70 ft.<br>10-20 ft.<br>**HID**High Intensity District<br>6,000<br>6-20 DU/A<br>25-60 ft.<br>10-20 ft.<br>**CBD**Central Business District<br>N/A<br>N/A<br>N/A<br>0-5 ft.<br>**SID**StateInstitutional District<br>N/A<br>N/A<br>25-50ft.<br>20ft.|**by Zoning**<br>**Side**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>0-10 ft.<br>0-10 ft.<br>0-10 ft.<br>N/A<br>0-10ft.|**District**<br>**Rear**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>15-25 ft.<br>15-20 ft.<br>5-20 ft.<br>N/A<br>5-20ft.|**Maximum**<br>**Building**<br>**Height**<br>35 ft.<br>35-50 ft.<br>35-65 ft.<br>35-65 ft.<br>65ft.|
|---|---|---|---|



Source: City of Morganton Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) – Article 4 – Development and Performance Standards Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. DU/A – Dwelling Units/Acre 

*Minimum lot size for infill development of less than two acres shall be equal to the average of all lots within 200 feet of the property. **Low figure reflects base maximum residential density. High figure reflects performance maximum residential density. Low minimum lot width reflects attached units. High minimum lot width reflects base figure for detached dwellings. Low setback figures reflect attached units. High setbacks reflect base figures for detached dwellings. Low maximum height reflects base figures for detached dwellings. High maximum height reflects performance standards. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-35** 

~~**Packet Pg. 246**~~
{175}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Minimum lot size requirements and maximum density requirements for Morganton zoning districts have ranges according to base standards and performance standards. According to the Unified Development Ordinance, performance standards are defined as _a set of landscaping, open space, parking, infrastructure and building design development standards for residential development seeking density bonuses_ . The preceding table shows the maximum density that could be achieved if a number of density bonuses are met for development projects in the city. The allowable density increase for projects is determined by a point system, in which points are awarded for achieving certain development standards related to open space, residential yard size, wall materials, garages, roofs, and porches (among additional standards). In the High Intensity District (HID), residential projects can have a maximum of 20 dwelling units per acre if enough density bonuses are achieved based on performance standards. A summary of performance standards can be viewed in Article 4 of the Unified Development Ordinance. 

The permitted residential land uses within the city of Morganton’s zoning districts are shown in the following table. 

|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**City of Morganton**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**City of Morganton**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**City of Morganton**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**City of Morganton**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**City of Morganton**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**City of Morganton**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**City of Morganton**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Land Use Type**|**Zoning Districts & Overlay District Notes**||||||
||**LID**|**MID**|**HID**|**CBD**|**SID**|**Overlay District Notes**|
|Accessory dwellings and structures|P|P|P|P|P||
|Boarding and rooming houses|P|P|P|--|--|Land use not permitted in NC-O|
|Family care home|P|P|P|P|P||
|Manufactured homes on individual lots|--|--|--|--|--|Land use permitted in MH-O|
|Multifamily dwellings|P|P|P|P|P|Land use not permitted in NC-O|
|Single-family dwellings (detached)|P|P|P|P|P||
|Two-family dwellings (duplexes)|P|P|P|P|P|Land use not permitted in NC-O|
|Residential care facilities|--|P|P|--|P|Land use not permitted in NC-O|
|Residential shelters|--|P|P|--|P|Land use not permitted in NC-O|



Source: City of Morganton Zoning Ordinance 

Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. Legend: P = permitted use; -- land use not permitted. 

Note that permitted land uses within zoning districts are subject to restrictions within overlay districts as defined in the Unified Development Ordinance. For example, manufactured homes on individual lots are not permitted in any of the five zoning districts displayed in the preceding table. However, manufactured homes on individual lots are permitted within the Manufactured Home Overlay (MH-O) district. Several land use types are permitted in all five zoning districts, including multifamily dwellings and duplexes. However, both multifamily dwellings and duplexes would not be permitted within the Neighborhood Conservation Overlay (NC-O) district. Although some land uses may or may not be permitted within certain zoning districts, the presence of an overlay district determines whether that land use is permitted (or not permitted) within a given area of the city. 

A municipal zoning map for the city of Morganton is included on the following page. An updated version of the municipal zoning map is provided on the City of Morganton GIS website. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-36** 

~~**Packet Pg. 247**~~
{176}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [613 x 100] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [613 x 100] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [613 x 100] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [613 x 100] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [613 x 100] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [613 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**
{177}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

_Zoning Districts – Town of Drexel_ 

|**Zoning District**<br>**R-20**Residential District<br>**R-12**Residential District<br>**R-8**Residential District|**Town of Drexel– Zoning Districts**<br>**Description**<br>Intended to provide areas for low-density residential development. Single-family<br>dwellings, modular homes, two-family dwellings, manufactured homes (single-wide<br>and double-wide), manufactured home parks, nursing/rest homes, family care homes,<br>multifamily dwellings, condominiums, and townhouses are all permitted within this<br>zoning district. Group housing developments may be permitted as a special use<br>subject to approval by the zoning board of adjustment.<br>Intended as a low- to medium-density residential neighborhood for single-family<br>dwellings. In addition to single-family dwellings, modular homes, manufactured<br>homes (double-wide), nursing/rest homes, family care homes, condominiums, and<br>townhouses are all permitted within this zoning district. Group housing<br>developments may be permitted as a special use subject to approval by the zoning<br>board of adjustment.<br>Intended as a medium-density residential neighborhood consisting of single-family,<br>two-family, and multiple-family dwellings with access to both public water and<br>sewer systems. In addition to single-family, two-family, and multifamily dwellings,<br>modular homes, manufactured homes (double-wide), rooming/boarding houses,<br>nursing/rest homes, family care homes, condominiums, and townhouses are all<br>permitted within this zoning district. Group housing developments may be permitted<br>as a special use subject to approval by the zoning board of adjustment.|
|---|---|



Source: Town of Drexel Zoning Ordinance 

Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. 

Residential zoning districts in Drexel permit a wide variety of land uses and structure types, including single-family, two-family, and multifamily dwellings. Note that higher density housing is permitted even in zoning districts intended for lower density development. Manufactured and modular housing is also permitted in all three residential zoning districts. The Drexel zoning ordinance does not permit residential land uses within its commercial and industrial zoning districts. 

Lot area requirements, setbacks and building height restrictions for zoning districts in the town of Drexel that allow residential development are listed in the following table: 

|**Town of Drexel– Lot Area, Setbacks**<br>**Zoning District**<br>**Minimum Lot**<br>**Area**<br>**(Sq. Ft.)**<br>**R-20**Residential District<br>20,000<br>**R-12**Residential District<br>12,000<br>**R-8**Residential District<br>8,000-12,000|**and Building**<br>**Maximum**<br>**Density**<br>**(DU/A)**<br>13 DU/A<br>3 DU/A<br>13 DU/A|**Height Requirements by Zoning District**<br>**Minimum**<br>**Lot**<br>**Width**<br>**Front**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>**Side**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>**Rear**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>100 ft.<br>30 ft.<br>15 ft.<br>40 ft.<br>80 ft.<br>35 ft.<br>10 ft.<br>30 ft.<br>60-85 ft.<br>35 ft.<br>10-15 ft.<br>30 ft.|**Maximum**<br>**Building**<br>**Height**<br>Not listed<br>35 ft.<br>35 ft.|
|---|---|---|---|



Source: Town of Drexel Zoning Ordinance Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. DU/A – Dwelling Units/Acre 

In R-20 and R-8 districts, 3,000 square feet of lot area is required for each additional unit in excess of two not to exceed 13 dwelling units per acre. In R-20 district, each building over 15 feet in height must increase its side yard setback by one foot for each additional foot in height. Corner lots require an additional 10 feet of side yard setback along the street. In R-8 district, minimum required lot area is 8,000 square feet for single-family dwellings and 12,000 square feet for two-family dwellings. In R-8 district, minimum lot width ranges from 60 feet for single-family dwellings to 85 feet for multiple-family dwellings. Minimum lot width must increase by 10 feet for each dwelling unit in excess of two. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-38** 

~~**Packet Pg. 249**~~
{178}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Residential zoning districts include well-defined requirements pertaining to minimum lot sizes, minimum lot widths, and setbacks for properties within these districts. The R-20 and R-8 zoning districts each allow for a greater maximum density of up to 13 dwelling units per acre to accommodate multifamily dwellings. The R-20 and R-8 zoning districts also require a larger minimum lot area for each dwelling containing three or more units. The R-20 zoning district does not have a maximum height limit listed within the zoning ordinance. However, a structure over 15 feet in height must increase its side yard setback by one foot for each additional foot of structure height. 

The permitted land uses within the city of Drexel’s residential zoning districts are shown in the following table. 

**==> picture [321 x 257] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts<br>Town of Drexel<br>Zoning Districts<br>Land Use Type R-20  R-12  R-8<br>Accessory buildings  A  A  A<br>Condominiums  P  P  P<br>Family care homes  P  P  P<br>Group housing developments  S  S  S<br>Manufactured homes (double-wide)  P  P  P<br>Manufactured homes (single-wide)  P  -- --<br>Manufactured home park  P  -- --<br>Modular homes  P  P  P<br>Multifamily dwellings  P  -- P<br>Nursing/rest homes  P  P  P<br>Rooming/boarding houses  -- -- P<br>Single-family dwellings  P  P  P<br>Townhouses  P  P  P<br>Two-family dwellings  P  -- P<br>Source: Town of Drexel Zoning Ordinance<br>Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded<br>from this analysis.<br>Legend: P = permitted use; S = special use; A = accessory use; -- land use not permitted<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Most residential land use types are permitted within Drexel’s residential zoning districts. Single-family dwellings, condominiums, double-wide manufactured homes, modular homes, and townhouses are permitted within all three residential zoning districts. Manufactured home parks are only permitted in the R-20 zoning district, while multifamily dwellings and two-family dwellings are not permitted in the R-12 zoning district. 

A municipal zoning map for the town of Drexel is included on the following page. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-39** 

~~**Packet Pg. 250**~~
{179}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [595 x 848] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
�<br>��<br>��<br>� ��<br>������<br>��������������<br>��<br>���������<br>��<br>�������<br>�<br>������������<br>���<br>���<br>�<br>�������<br>�����������<br>�����������<br>���<br>��<br>�����������<br>�������������<br>�<br>�<br>�������<br>��� ���<br>������� �<br>��������<br>�������<br>��������<br>��<br>�����������<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>��<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>��<br>���������<br>��<br>���<br>�������<br>��<br>�<br>���������<br>�<br>�<br>���<br>�<br>����<br>�<br>� �<br>��<br>�<br>��<br>���<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>����<br>����<br>�<br>�������<br>��<br>�<br>���������<br>�<br>��<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>����������<br>�������<br>�����<br>������<br>���<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>����<br>�<br>�������������<br>������<br>�� ��<br>���<br>�������<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>���<br>��<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>����������<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>�������<br>���<br>�<br>�<br>���<br>��������<br>�<br>�<br>�������������<br>�<br>���<br>����������<br>����������<br>������<br>���<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>����<br>�<br>������<br>�<br>�<br>��������<br>�����<br>�<br>�������<br>�<br>����<br>����<br>������������<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�����<br>�������<br>��<br>��<br>����� ��������<br>�������<br>����<br>�<br>�����������<br>����������<br>�������������<br>�������<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>�����<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>����<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>�������<br>����������<br>�����������<br>�<br>�������<br>�<br>���<br>�<br>������������<br>��������<br>��<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>������������<br>�<br>�<br>�������<br>���<br>��<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>����<br>�<br>���������<br>�<br>�������<br>�<br>�<br>���<br>�<br>���������<br>���<br>���������������<br>���������<br>��<br>���<br>�����<br>�����<br>������������������<br>�����<br>��<br>��<br>�����������<br>��������<br>�<br>������<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>���������������<br>�����������<br>�����������<br>�<br>���<br>�������<br>��������<br>���<br>����������<br>�����������<br>������<br>��������������<br>�������<br>������<br>�������<br>�������<br>�������<br>����������<br>���<br>��������������<br>�<br>������<br>������<br>�����<br>��������<br>�<br>��<br>�����<br>�<br>��������<br>� ����������<br>���<br>�<br>���������<br>������������<br>���������<br>�������<br>�<br>���<br>��������<br>����<br>��<br>���������������<br>������� �� ��������� �� ������ ����� ��������� ����� ������� �����<br>3.2.b<br>���� ������� ������<br>Packet Pg. 251<br>������������������������������������������������������� �����������������������������������������������������������<br>������������������ ��� ������� �����<br>������ ���<br>����� ����� �������<br>������������� ��������������� ������������������� ������������������������ ���������������������������������������������������������������������<br>���������<br>��<br>��������<br>�������� ������ ���� ������� ��������������������<br>�������������<br>������ ��<br>����������<br>������ ��<br>������� ����<br>����������� ���������������������� �������������������������������������������������� �����<br>��<br>����������<br>��� �������<br>�����������<br>������ ����������<br>�<br>�������������������������������������<br>����<br>����� ������� �����<br>����� ���������� ���<br>���<br>�<br>������ ��<br>���� ��������<br>��� ���� ����<br>��� ��� ���<br>������������� �������<br>���� ������� ��<br>���<br>�<br>����<br>�<br>������<br>�<br>���������<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>���<br>���<br>�����������<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>�����<br>�<br>���<br>�<br>������<br>����������<br>�<br>�<br>�����<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�������<br>����������<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>����������<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>���������<br>�<br>���������<br>�������<br>���������<br>�������<br>�����������<br>��<br>��<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>������<br>�<br>��<br>������<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�������<br>��<br>�<br>������<br>����<br>������<br>����<br>�<br>� ����<br>���<br>��������<br>�<br>����<br>������<br>�<br>�������<br>��<br>���<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>���<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>���<br>��<br>����������<br>��<br>�<br>��<br>���<br>�<br>���<br>���<br>�<br>��<br>������<br>�<br>�<br>���������<br>�<br>���<br>���������<br>�<br>�������<br>��<br>��<br>�������<br>���������<br>������<br>����<br>���������<br>�����������<br>���<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>��<br>��<br>����<br>����<br>�<br>�<br>�������<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>����<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>�������<br>�<br>��<br>����<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>� �����<br>�<br>�<br>����<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>����������<br>��<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>����������<br>��<br>�<br>����<br>��<br>�<br>���������<br>��<br>���<br>����������<br>�<br>���<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�������<br>��<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>� ������<br>������<br>�<br>����<br>�����<br>�<br>�� �<br>�<br>�<br>��������� �<br>����<br>�<br>�����<br>����<br>�<br>�<br>�<br>����<br>��<br>�<br>�������<br>�� �<br>� �<br>�<br>���<br>��<br>��<br>�����������<br>����<br>���<br>�<br>��<br>��<br>�<br>�����������<br>�<br>��<br>�<br>������������<br>�<br>���������������<br>��<br>��<br>������<br>�<br>� �<br>����������<br>������������<br>�<br>������<br>�����<br>��<br>��<br>������������<br>����������<br>���<br>�<br>���<br>�� �<br>������<br>��<br>�<br>��<br>��<br>�����<br>�<br>�������<br>���������<br>������������<br>������������<br>�����������������<br>����������<br>�<br>� ��������<br>�<br>� ���<br>���<br>���������<br>����������<br>�� ��������<br>��������<br>��������<br>�������<br>�<br>������<br>���������������<br>��<br>���<br>�<br>���������<br>����������������<br>�<br>����������<br>�<br>������������<br>�<br>���������<br>�����<br>���������<br>Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen<br>��<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>
{180}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## _Zoning Districts – Town of Valdese_ 

|**Town of Valdese– Zoning Districts**|**Town of Valdese– Zoning Districts**|
|---|---|
|**Zoning District**|**Description**|
|**R-12**Residential District|Purpose of this zoning district is to provide an adequate amount of land for agricultural<br>uses and single-family residential development. Family care homes, modular homes, and<br>single-family homes (excluding manufactured homes) are permitted by right in this zoning<br>district. Accessory dwellings are permitted with special requirements, while residential<br>care facilities, 10-acre exempt developments, and gated subdivisions each require a special<br>use permit.|
|**R-12A**Residential District|Intended to be a medium-high density residential living area consisting of single-family,<br>two-family, and multifamily dwellings. Boarding houses, family care homes, modular<br>homes, single-family homes (excluding manufactured homes) and two-family homes<br>(duplexes) are all permitted by right within this zoning district. Accessory dwellings are<br>permitted with special requirements, while multifamily buildings, planned unit<br>developments (residential), residential care facilities, 10-acre exempt developments, and<br>gated subdivisions each require a special use permit.|
|**R-8**Residential District|Intent is to provide for town-scaled residential development within walking distance<br>(generally within ¼ mile) of services. Boarding houses, family care homes, manufactured<br>homes (Class A), modular homes, single-family homes, and two-family homes (duplexes)<br>are all permitted by right within this zoning district. Accessory dwellings are permitted<br>with special requirements, while mixed uses, multifamily buildings, planned unit<br>developments (residential), residential care facilities, 10-acre exempt developments, and<br>gated subdivisions each require a special use permit.|
|**O-I**Office-Institutional District|Designed to provide a wide range of professional and institutional uses as well as space<br>for public and quasi-public uses. Mixed uses, modular homes, nursing homes, residential<br>care facilities, and single-family homes (excluding manufactured homes) are permitted by<br>right in this zoning district. Accessory dwellings are permitted with special requirements,<br>while multifamily buildings and planned unit developments (residential) require a special<br>use permit.|
|**B-1**Central Business District|The purpose of this zoning district is to accommodate and encourage further expansion<br>and renewal in the historic/business core of the town of Valdese. A variety of business,<br>retail, professional, financial, cultural, and other related services are encouraged in an<br>effort to provide the mix of activities necessary for shoppers. Boarding houses and mixed<br>uses are permitted by right in this zoning district. Modular homes, multifamily buildings,<br>planned unit developments (residential), and single-family homes (excluding<br>manufactured homes) each require a special use permit.|
|**B-2**General Business District|Intends to encourage the establishment of areas for a general business that do not require<br>a central location. Boarding houses, mixed uses, nursing homes, and residential care<br>facilities are all permitted by right in this zoning district. Modular homes, multifamily<br>buildings, planned unit developments (residential), and single-family homes (excluding<br>manufactured homes) each require a special use permit.|



Source: Town of Valdese Zoning Ordinance 

Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. 

Residential land uses are permitted in both residential and commercial zoning districts in Valdese. Several types of residential structures are permitted by right in all residential zoning districts, including single-family homes, modular homes, and duplexes. Multifamily buildings and residential planned unit developments require a special use permit in the R-8 and R-12A zoning districts as well as the three commercial zoning districts (O-I, B-1 and B-2). Mixed uses are also permitted by right within these commercial zoning districts. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-41** 

~~**Packet Pg. 252**~~
{181}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Lot area requirements, setbacks and building height restrictions for zoning districts that allow residential development are listed in the following table: 

|**Town of Valdese– Lot Area, Setbacks and Building**<br>**Zoning District**<br>**Minimum**<br>**Lot Area**<br>**(Sq. Ft.)**<br>**Maximum**<br>**Density**<br>**(DU/A)**<br>**R-12**Residential District<br>12,000-40,000<br>3 DU/A<br>**R-12A**Residential District<br>12,000-40,000<br>11 DU/A<br>**R-8**Residential District<br>8,000-40,000<br>12 DU/A<br>**O-I**Office-Institutional District<br>None<br>N/A<br>**B-1**Central Business District<br>None<br>N/A<br>**B-2**General Business District<br>None<br>N/A|**Height Requirements**<br>**Minimum**<br>**Lot**<br>**Width**<br>**Front**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>70 ft.<br>35 ft.<br>70 ft.<br>35 ft.<br>50-70 ft.<br>20 ft.<br>None<br>20 ft.<br>None<br>0 ft.<br>None<br>40 ft.|**by Zoning District**<br>**Side**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>**Rear**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>10-15 ft.<br>25 ft.<br>10-15 ft.<br>25 ft.<br>10-15 ft.<br>25 ft.<br>10 ft.<br>15 ft.<br>0-15 ft.<br>0-15 ft.<br>10-20 ft.<br>10-20 ft.|**Maximum**<br>**Building**<br>**Height**<br>40 ft.<br>40 ft.<br>40 ft.<br>50 ft.<br>50 ft.<br>50 ft.|
|---|---|---|---|



Source: Town of Valdese Zoning Ordinance 

Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. Information displayed for residential structures only. DU/A – Dwelling Units/Acre 

Minimum lot area displayed for structures that have access to water and sewer (low) and for structures that do not have access to water or sewer (high). Multifamily structures require an additional 4,000 square feet of lot area for the second unit and 3,000 square feet for each additional unit. Minimum lot areas may be subject to whether a development requires a sedimentation/erosion control plan under North Carolina state law. In R-12A district, multifamily dwellings with more than three units require an additional 10 feet of lot width for each additional unit. In B-1 district, lots adjoining a residential district require a minimum side yard and/or rear yard setback of 15 feet. In B-2 district, lots adjoining a residential district require a minimum side yard and/or rear yard setback of 20 feet. 

Minimum lot areas in the three residential zoning districts (R-8, R-12, and R-12A) vary considerably based on the location of water and sewer utilities as well as a state-mandated sedimentation/erosion control plan. The minimum lot size in the R- 8 district can be as low as 8,000 square feet for a multifamily dwelling unit served by water and sewer utilities, while single-family dwellings without access to water or sewer utilities may have a minimum lot size as high as 40,000 square feet (0.92 acres). Maximum density in residential zoning districts ranges from three to 12 dwelling units/acre. Note that commercial zoning districts (O-I, B-1, and B-2) do not have minimum lot size or lot width requirements, which may permit structures to be built on a large portion of available lots within these zoning districts. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-42** 

~~**Packet Pg. 253**~~
{182}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The permitted land uses within residential zoning districts in the town of Valdese are summarized in the following table. 

|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Valdese**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Valdese**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Valdese**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Valdese**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Valdese**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Valdese**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Valdese**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Land Use Type**|**Zoning Districts**||||||
||**R-12**|**R-12A**|**R-8 **|**O-I **|**B-1 **|**B-2 **|
|Accessory dwellings|R|R|R|R|--|--|
|Boarding houses|--|P|P|--|P|P|
|Family care homes|P|P|P|--|--|--|
|Gated subdivisions|S|S|S|--|--|--|
|Manufactured homes (Class A)|--|--|P|--|--|--|
|Mixed uses|--|--|S|P|P|P|
|Modular homes|P|P|P|P|S|S|
|Multifamily buildings|--|S|S|S|S|S|
|Nursing Homes|--|--|--|P|--|P|
|Planned unit development (residential)|--|S|S|S|S|S|
|Residential care facility|S|S|S|P|--|P|
|Single-family homes|P|P|P|P|S|S|
|10-acre exempt development|S|S|S|--|--|--|
|Two-family homes (duplexes)|--|P|P|--|--|--|



Source: Town of Valdese Zoning Ordinance Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. Legend: P – Permitted by right; R – Permitted with special requirements; S – Special use permit needed; -- land use not permitted 

Residential zoning districts listed in the preceding table allow a wide variety of dwelling types by right or by special use permit. These dwelling types include single-family homes, modular homes, duplexes, and multifamily buildings. Mixed uses require a special use permit in the R-8 zoning district but are permitted by right in commercial zoning districts (O-I, B-1, and B-2). Multifamily buildings and residential planned unit developments are not permitted by right in any zoning district but do require a special use permit in five of the six zoning districts displayed in the preceding table. 

A municipal zoning map for the town of Valdese was unable to be obtained at the time of this analysis. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-43** 

~~**Packet Pg. 254**~~
{183}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## _Zoning Districts – Town of Rutherford College_ 

|||~~**3.2.b**~~|~~**3.2.b**~~|
|---|---|---|---|
|**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH**<br>**VII-44**<br>_Zoning Districts – Town of Rutherford College_<br>**Town of Rutherford College– Zoning Districts**<br>**Zoning District**<br>**Description**<br>**R-20**Residential District<br>Intended to provide for low-density residential development. Permitted uses include<br>single-family dwellings and single-family modular homes. Group home developments and<br>planned unit developments are defined as special uses and are permitted subject to Board<br>of Adjustment review and approval.<br>**R-15**Residential District<br>Established as a district in which the principal use of land is for low-density residential<br>and agricultural purposes. Permitted uses include single-family dwellings, single-family<br>modular homes, multifamily dwellings, condominiums, and individual mobile homes.<br>Class B manufactured homes on individual lots are permitted based on conditions listed in<br>Section 152.097 of the zoning ordinance. Group home developments and planned unit<br>developments are defined as special uses and are permitted subject to Board of Adjustment<br>review and approval.<br>**R-10**Residential District<br>Established as a district in which the principal use of the land is for high-density residential<br>development. Permitted uses include single-family dwellings, modular homes (off-frame),<br>condominiums, and multifamily dwellings. Mixed-use developments are considered a<br>conditional use subject to Board of Adjustment review and approval.<br>**O-I**Office and Institutional District<br>Intended to provide for the conversion of older homes into office or apartment structures<br>where appropriate and to provide a buffer between business and residential areas.<br>Permitted uses include single-family dwellings, single-family modular homes,<br>condominiums, child care homes and family care homes. Accessory buildings for private<br>residential purposes, mixed-use buildings erected for both dwelling and business purposes,<br>skilled nursing/assisted living facilities, and conversion of residential structures to provide<br>additional dwelling units are defined as special uses and are permitted subject to Board of<br>Adjustment review and approval.<br>**CB**Central Business District<br>Intended to provide the town with compact and efficient retail shopping, consumer<br>services, financial, and government services. Permitted uses include single-family<br>dwellings, single-family modular homes, condominiums, child care homes and family care<br>homes. Accessory buildings/guest cottages, mixed-use buildings erected for both dwelling<br>and business purposes, skilled nursing/assisted living facilities, and conversion of<br>residential structures to provide additional dwelling units are defined as special uses and<br>are permitted subject to Board of Adjustment review and approval.<br>**HB**Highway Business District<br>Intended to provide for offices, personal services and retail along major thoroughfares and<br>collector streets in the town. Permitted uses include single-family dwellings, single-family<br>modular homes, condominiums, child care homes, family care homes, and skilled<br>nursing/assisted living facilities. Accessory buildings/guest cottages, mixed-use buildings<br>erected for both dwelling and business purposes and conversion of residential structures<br>to provide additional dwelling units are defined as special uses and are permitted subject<br>to Board of Adjustment review and approval.<br>**GM**General Manufacturing<br>This zoning district provides for the location of manufacturing and other uses which would<br>be incompatible with general business areas. Permitted uses include single-family<br>dwellings, single-family modular homes, condominiums, child care homes, family care<br>homes, and skilled nursing/assisted living facilities.<br>Source: Town of Rutherford College Zoning Ordinance<br>Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis.<br>Residential land uses are permitted by right or by special use in residential,<br>commercial, and industrial zoning districts in Rutherford College. Note that single-<br>family dwellings and modular homes are permitted by right in all zoning districts.<br>Planned unit developments must be approved by conditional/special use in all<br>zoning districts but the R-10 district, while multifamily buildings are permitted by<br>right in most zoning districts. Please refer to the Permitted Land Uses table later in<br>this section for a summary of permitted land uses in each zoning district.<br>~~**..**~~<br> <br>||~~**..**~~||
||||**Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen National Research Housing Study)**|
|||||
|||||



Source: Town of Rutherford College Zoning Ordinance 

Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. 

Residential land uses are permitted by right or by special use in residential, commercial, and industrial zoning districts in Rutherford College. Note that singlefamily dwellings and modular homes are permitted by right in all zoning districts. Planned unit developments must be approved by conditional/special use in all zoning districts but the R-10 district, while multifamily buildings are permitted by right in most zoning districts. Please refer to the Permitted Land Uses table later in this section for a summary of permitted land uses in each zoning district. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-44** 

~~**Packet Pg. 255**~~
{184}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Lot area requirements, setbacks and building height restrictions for zoning districts that allow residential development are listed in the following table: 

|**Town of Rutherford College– Lot Area,**<br>**Zoning District**<br>**Minimum**<br>**Lot Area**<br>**(Sq. Ft.)**<br>**R-20**Residential District<br>20,000-21,780<br>**R-15**Residential District<br>14,520-15,000<br>**R-10**Residential District<br>10,000<br>**O-I**Office and Institutional District<br>10,000<br>**CB**Central Business District<br>10,000<br>**HB**Highway Business District<br>None<br>**GM**General Manufacturing District<br>None|**Setbacks and Building Height Requirements by Zoning District**<br>**Maximum**<br>**Density**<br>**(DU/A)**<br>**Minimum**<br>**Lot**<br>**Width**<br>**Front**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>**Side**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>**Rear**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>2 DU/A<br>100 ft.<br>30 ft.<br>15 ft.<br>40 ft.<br>6 DU/A<br>100 ft.<br>25 ft.<br>15 ft.<br>30 ft.*<br>6 DU/A<br>60 ft.<br>25 ft.<br>10 ft.<br>25 ft.<br>N/A<br>100 ft.<br>30 ft.<br>15 ft.<br>25 ft.<br>N/A<br>Not listed<br>30 ft.<br>10-15 ft.<br>25 ft.<br>N/A<br>100 ft.<br>50 ft.<br>15-20 ft.<br>30 ft.<br>N/A<br>Not listed<br>25 ft.<br>10 ft.<br>10 ft.|**Maximum**<br>**Building**<br>**Height**<br>Not listed<br>35 ft.<br>35 ft.<br>35 ft.<br>80 ft.<br>50 ft.<br>Not listed|
|---|---|---|



Source: Town of Rutherford College Zoning Ordinance 

Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. DU/A – Dwelling Units/Acre 

*Rear yard setback must be 20% of the mean lot depth not to exceed 30 ft. 

Corner lots must have an additional 10 ft. of side yard setback along the street. Buildings taller than 35 ft. in O-I district shall be required to increase side yard setback one foot for each additional foot of building height. Buildings taller than 50 ft. in HB district shall be required to increase side yard setback one foot for each additional foot of building height. Side yard setback for properties in CB district is 15 feet when abutting a residential district. 

Minimum lot areas in the R-20 and R-15 residential districts vary based on whether a state mandated sedimentation/erosion control plan is required for the lot. The low figure for both residential zoning districts reflect lots that do not require this control plan. Maximum density ranges from two dwelling units per acre in the R-20 district to six dwelling units per acre in the R-10 district. Building height in the O-I and HB zoning districts can be increased above the listed minimum height for each zoning district if increased side yard setback requirements are met. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-45** 

~~**Packet Pg. 256**~~
{185}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The permitted land uses within residential zoning districts in the town of Rutherford College are summarized in the following table. 

|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Rutherford College**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Rutherford College**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Rutherford College**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Rutherford College**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Rutherford College**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Rutherford College**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Rutherford College**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Rutherford College**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Land Use Type**|**Zoning Districts**|||||||
||**R-20**|**R-15**|**R-10**|**O-I**|**CB**|**HB**|**GM**|
|Accessory buildings<br>(private residential purposes)|--|--|--|S|S|S|--|
|Child care home|--|--|--|P|P|P|P|
|Condominiums|--|P|P|P|P|P|P|
|Conversion of residential structures<br>(additional dwelling units)|--|--|--|S|S|S|--|
|Duplexes|--|P|P|P|P|P|P|
|Family care homes|--|--|--|P|P|P|P|
|Group home developments|S|S|--|--|--|--|--|
|Manufactured homes (Class B)|--|P*|--|--|--|--|--|
|Mixed-use buildings|--|--|S|S|S|S|S|
|Mobile homes|--|P|--|--|--|--|--|
|Modular homes|P|P|P|P|P|P|P|
|Multifamily dwellings|--|P|P|--|P|P|P|
|Planned unit developments|S|S|--|S|S|S|S|
|Single-family dwelling|P|P|P|P|P|P|P|
|Skilled nursing/assisted-living facilities|--|--|--|S|S|P|P|



Source: Town of Rutherford College Zoning Ordinance 

Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. Legend: P – permitted land use; S – special use (requires additional approval); -- land use not permitted *Permitted subject to conditions outlined in Section 152.097 of zoning ordinance. 

As indicated by the permitted land use table, single-family dwellings and modular homes are permitted in residential, commercial, and industrial zoning districts. In fact, a wide variety of residential housing types are permitted in both commercial and industrial districts in Rutherford College. Condominiums and duplex dwellings are permitted in all zoning districts except in the R-20 residential district. 

A municipal zoning map for the town of Rutherford College is included on the following page. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-46** 

~~**Packet Pg. 257**~~
{186}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [558 x 767] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.2.b<br>ESTES DR<br>� 70 � 70<br>OLD LAIL AV<br>� 40<br>� 40<br>RUTHERFORD COLLEGE  RUTHERFORD COLLEGE<br>VICINITY INSET IN CALDWELL COUNTY INSET TOWN OF Rutherford College Town Limits Zoning Districts<br>SAWMILLS ETJ SAWMILLS RUTHERFORD COLLEGE Rutherford College ETJCounty Boundary CB - Central BusinessGM - General Manufacturing<br>CALDWELL COUNTY Zoning Map Parcels HB - Highway Business<br>Water Supply Watershed WS-IV Critical* OI - Office and Institutional<br>RUTHERFORD COLLEGE Connelly Springs Town Limits R15 - Residential<br>ETJ Valdese Town Limits R20 - Residential<br>RUTHERFORD COLLEGE CONNELLY  Lakes OD-M<br>VALDESE SPRINGS Flood Hazard Areas Railroads<br>AE Rivers<br>INSETS NOT TO SCALE BURKE COUNTY PREMIER RD � 0 0.125 0.25 0.5Miles AEFW Roads Packet Pg. 258<br>This map was updated on July 02, 2018 by the Western Piedmont Council of Governments using the latest data provided by the Town of Rutherford College, Burke County GIS, NC Floodplain Mapping Program,and ESRI.  Document Path: Z:\region_data\burke\rcollege.sw\RutherfordCollegeZoningPortraitSize_2018.mxd<br>BUCKINGHAM ST<br>CHARLES ST<br>SIMPSON AV<br>LOVELADY RD NE<br>GREEN ST<br>GRIFFIN ST<br>STURGILL LN<br>HAZEL ST<br>LOWMAN ST<br>PERKINS RD SE<br>HARBOR RIDGE DR<br>STUART AV SE<br>CRANBROOK AV SE<br>WHITE ST<br>HIGH VISTA CT NE<br>ICARD ST CAMPUS ST<br>LOVELADY RD<br>TUTHEROW ST<br>SPRING ST<br>EXIT 113<br>MAIN CIRCLE ST<br>CHAPEL ST<br>WEST ST<br>GARDIOL AV NE<br>CROSS ST<br>HEAVNER AV<br>COBBS PL<br>EXIT 112 MOURGLEA AV<br>RODRICK ST<br>I 40 E<br>I 40 W FASHION AV<br>ALPINE ST<br>OAK TER<br>EXIT 112<br>CRYSTAL LN<br>SHADY GROVE RD<br>BRAVARD ST<br>HILLTOP ST<br>CARSON AV<br>REFOUR AV SE<br>BEIERSDORF DR<br>MAIN ST E<br>CRUMP ST<br>ABEE AV<br>EXCELSIOR DR<br>HILLTOP ST<br>BUTLER ST<br>MILL ST<br>US 70<br>TALMON ST<br>GOINS DR SE<br>TOMLINSON LOOP<br>CIRCLE DR<br>RIVERCLIFF DR E<br>OLD WYE TRL<br>OKIES ST<br>CARNEGIE ST<br>DUNCAN ST<br>FAT AV NE<br>RUTHERFORD COLLEGE RD<br>REFOUR RD NE<br>BLEYNAT ST<br>RIDGE TOP DR<br>MINERAL SPRINGS MTN RD<br>CASTLE RD<br>SETZER ST<br>CARPENTER RD<br>PINE ST<br>G W ABEE ST<br>COLDWATER ST<br>CLUB CIR NE<br>AZALEA DR<br>LIBERTY ST WOODLAWN DR<br>MALCOLM BLVD<br>DOGWOOD ST<br>ICARD GROVE AV<br>SPANN ST<br>ANCHOR LN<br>SPRCO<br>BEREA AV<br>ADAMS ST<br>KISER ST<br>RIVERWALK DR<br>N<br>ING NE<br>ELDRED ST SE<br>LAKE RHODHISS DR NE<br>BERRY LN<br>S<br> RD<br>LLY<br>COLEMAN DR<br>SOPHIA ST<br>COTTON MILL ST<br>CARSWELL ST<br>LUCAS ST<br>LLOYD ST<br>CURVILLE ST NE<br>RIDGE ST<br>MOOSE ST<br>TWIN COVE DR<br>ISRAEL CHAPEL RD<br>LAKE FRONT DR<br>SHADY GROVE RD<br>CANNON LN<br>Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen National Research Housing Study)<br>HARBOR WATCH DR<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>
{187}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

_Zoning Districts – Town of Connelly Springs_ 

|**Town of Connelly Springs– Zoning Districts**|**Town of Connelly Springs– Zoning Districts**|
|---|---|
|**Zoning District**|**Description**|
|**R-1**Residential Low-Density District|This zoning district is composed of low-density residential sections of the community<br>along with open areas where similar residential development appears likely to occur.<br>Single-family dwellings (excluding manufactured homes), accessory buildings to<br>residential uses, and family care/group home developments are permitted in this zoning<br>district. Nursing homes are defined as a special use which must be approved by the Board<br>of Adjustment after a public hearing is held.|
|**R-2**Residential Medium-Density District|Established to provide a medium density living environment consisting of single-family<br>detached dwellings, two-family dwellings, modular homes and related uses in areas that<br>have public water or sewer facilities. Single-family dwellings (excluding manufactured<br>homes), two-family dwellings, modular homes, accessory buildings to residential uses,<br>and family care/group home developments are permitted in this zoning district. Nursing<br>homes are defined as a special use which must be approved by the Board of Adjustment<br>after a public hearing is held.|
|**R-3**Residential High-Density District|Established as a district in which the principal use of land is for single-family, two-family,<br>and multifamily residences in addition to modular and manufactured homes located on<br>individual lots as well as within manufactured home parks. Single-family dwellings<br>(excluding manufactured homes), two-family dwellings, multifamily dwellings, modular<br>homes, manufactured homes on individual lots, manufactured home parks, group<br>multifamily developments, planned unit developments, and accessory buildings to<br>residential uses are permitted in this zoning district. Nursing homes, rooming/boarding<br>houses, tourist homes, and family care/group home developments are defined as a special<br>use which must be approved by the Board of Adjustment after a public hearing is held.|
|**H-B**Highway Business|Intended to provide for offices, personal services, and retail for the community along major<br>thoroughfares and collector streets in the Connelly Springs Planning Area. Boarding<br>houses, tourist homes, and rest/convalescent homes are permitted in this zoning district.<br>Mixed-use buildings erected for both dwelling and business purposes are defined as a<br>special use which must be approved by the Board of Adjustment after a public hearing is<br>held.|
|**G-M** General Manufacturing|This zoning district provides for the location of industrial and other uses which would be<br>incompatible with general business areas. Boarding houses, tourist homes, and<br>rest/convalescenthomes are permittedinthiszoning district.|



Source: Town of Connelly Springs Zoning Ordinance 

Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. 

Connelly Springs has its residential zoning districts split into low-, medium-, and high-density zones. Single-family dwellings are permitted in all three residential zoning districts, while two-family dwellings are permitted in the R-2 and R-3 zoning districts. Multifamily buildings and group multifamily developments are each permitted in the R-3 (high density) zoning district. Mixed-use buildings are defined as a special use in the H-B district, which requires additional approval along with a public hearing. A summary table of permitted land uses in Connelly Springs zoning districts is included later in this section. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-48** 

~~**Packet Pg. 259**~~
{188}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Lot area requirements, setbacks and building height restrictions for zoning districts that allow residential development are listed in the following table: 

|**Town of Connelly Springs**<br>**Zoning District**<br>**R-1**Residential Low-Density District<br>**R-2**Residential Medium-Density District<br>**R-3**Residential High-Density District<br>**H-B**Highway Business<br>**G-M**General Manufacturing|**– Lot Area, Setbacks and Building Height**<br>**Minimum**<br>**Lot Area**<br>**(Sq. Ft.)**<br>**Maximum**<br>**Density**<br>**(DU/A)**<br>**Minimum**<br>**Lot**<br>**Width**<br>30,000-50,000<br>1 DU/A<br>100 ft.<br>25,000-40,000<br>2 DU/A<br>100 ft.<br>21,780-30,000<br>8 DU/A<br>75 ft.<br>21,780<br>N/A<br>100 ft.<br>43,560<br>N/A<br>200 ft.|**Requirements by Zoning District**<br>**Front**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>**Side**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>**Rear**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>50 ft.<br>12-15 ft.<br>35 ft.<br>40 ft.<br>12-15 ft.<br>35 ft.<br>30 ft.<br>10-12 ft.<br>30 ft.<br>50 ft.<br>15-20 ft.<br>30 ft.<br>50 ft.<br>15 ft.<br>20 ft.|**Maximum**<br>**Building**<br>**Height**<br>35 ft.<br>35 ft.<br>35 ft.<br>50 ft.<br>65 ft.|
|---|---|---|---|



Source: Town of Connelly Springs Zoning Ordinance 

Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. DU/A – Dwelling Units/Acre 

In R-1, R-2, and R-3 districts, minimum lot area range reflects lots with access to public water and sewer (low) and lots without access to either one (high). In R-3 district, multifamily dwellings require an additional 5,000 square feet of lot area for the second unit and an additional 3,000 square feet of lot area for each additional unit. 

Side lots abutting a street require a minimum of 15 feet of setback in R-1 and R-2 districts and a minimum of 12 feet of setback in R-3 district. In R-3, H-B, and G-M districts, front yard depth and total lot width shall be increased by one foot for each two feet of building height above minimum. 

The minimum lot areas in Connelly Springs residential zoning districts are established based on access to public water and sewer services. Minimum lot areas are lower for locations served by public water and sewer and higher for areas that lack one or both services. Maximum density ranges from one dwelling unit per acre in the R-1 district to eight dwelling units per acre in the R-3 district. Maximum building heights established in the R-3, H-B, and G-M districts can be exceeded based on increases in front yard depth and total lot width. 

The permitted land uses within residential zoning districts in the town of Connelly Springs are summarized in the following table. 

|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Connelly Springs**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Connelly Springs**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Connelly Springs**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Connelly Springs**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Connelly Springs**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Connelly Springs**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Land Use Type**|**Zoning Districts**|||||
||**R-1**|**R-2**|**R-3**|**H-B**|**G-M**|
|Accessory buildings|P|P|P|--|--|
|Family care/group home developments|P|P|S|--|--|
|Group multifamily developments|--|--|P|--|--|
|Manufactured homes|--|--|P|--|--|
|Manufactured home parks|--|--|P|--|--|
|Mixed-use buildings|--|--|--|S|--|
|Modular homes|--|P|P|--|--|
|Multifamily dwellings|--|--|P|--|--|
|Nursing homes|S|S|S|--|--|
|Planned unit developments|--|--|P|--|--|
|Rest/convalescent homes|--|--|S|P|P|
|Rooming/boarding houses|--|--|S|P|P|
|Single-family dwellings|P|P|P|--|--|
|Tourist homes|--|--|S|P|P|



Source: Town of Connelly Springs Zoning Ordinance 

Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. Legend: P – Permitted land use; S – Special use requiring approval; -- Land use not permitted 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-49** 

~~**Packet Pg. 260**~~
{189}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The R-1 and R-2 districts permit single-family dwellings but do not permit multifamily buildings. The R-3 (high density) district in Connelly Springs allows a much wider range of residential development types that includes multifamily buildings and planned unit developments. The H-B zoning district permits mixeduse development as a special use that requires additional approval. 

A municipal zoning map for the town of Connelly Springs was unable to be obtained at the time of this analysis. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-50** 

~~**Packet Pg. 261**~~
{190}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## _Zoning Districts – Town of Hildebran_ 

|||~~**3.2.b**~~|~~**3.2.b**~~|
|---|---|---|---|
|**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH**<br>**VII-51**<br>_Zoning Districts – Town of Hildebran_<br>**Town of Hildebran– Zoning Districts**<br>**Zoning District**<br>**Description**<br>**R-20**Residential Low-Density District<br>This zoning district is composed of low-density residential sections of the community<br>along with certain open areas where similar residential development appears likely to<br>occur as indicated by the Land Development Plan. Permitted uses include single-family<br>dwellings, accessory buildings to residential uses, and family care and group homes<br>(outside ¼ mile radius of an existing family care or group home). Long-term care facilities<br>are classified as a special use which can be permitted when authorized by the Hildebran<br>Board of Adjustment after a public meeting is held.<br>**R-10**Residential High-Density District<br>Established as a zoning district in which the principal use of land is for single-family, two-<br>family, and multifamily residences. Permitted uses include single-family dwellings,<br>duplexes, accessory buildings to residential uses, and family care and group homes<br>(outside ¼ mile radius of an existing family care or group home). Manufactured homes on<br>individual lots are also permitted in the Manufactured Home Overlay (MHO) within this<br>zoning district. Long-term care facilities, multifamily dwellings, and manufactured home<br>parks (in the MHO only) are classified as a special use which can be permitted when<br>authorized by the Hildebran Board of Adjustment after a public meeting is held.<br>**N-B**Neighborhood Business District<br>Intended for the use of businesses and other uses which are property located near<br>residential areas and which cater to the everyday needs of a limited residential area.<br>Although this zoning district is primarily intended for business uses, several residential<br>land uses are permitted in this zoning district. Permitted uses include single-family<br>dwellings, duplexes, accessory buildings to residential uses, family care and group homes<br>(outside ¼ mile radius of an existing family care or group home) and child care homes.<br>Long-term care facilities and mixed-use buildings are each classified as a special use which<br>can be permitted when authorized by the Hildebran Board of Adjustment after a public<br>meeting is held.<br>**CBD**Central Business District<br>Intended to serve as the center of the town’s financial business, professional, cultural, and<br>governmental activities by providing a variety of supporting personal services and retail<br>trade activities. Permitted uses include single-family dwellings, duplexes, mixed-use<br>buildings, accessory buildings to residential uses, family care and group homes (outside ¼<br>mile radius of an existing family care or group home) and child care homes. Long-term<br>care facilities and multifamily dwellings are each classified as a special use which can be<br>permitted when authorized by the Hildebran Board of Adjustment after a public meeting<br>is held.<br>**H-B**Highway Business District<br>Intended to provide for offices, personal services, and retailing of goods for the<br>community. This zoning district is located on major thoroughfares and collector streets in<br>the Hildebran Planning Area. Permitted uses include accessory uses/buildings and family<br>care homes. Long-term care facilities are classified as a special use which can be permitted<br>when authorized by the Hildebran Board of Adjustment after a public meeting is held.<br>**G-M **General Manufacturing District<br>This zoning district provides for the location of industrial and other uses which would be<br>incompatible with general business areas. Permitted uses include accessory uses/buildings<br>and family care homes. Long-term care facilities are classified as a special use which can<br>be permitted when authorized by the Hildebran Board of Adjustment after a public meeting<br>is held.<br>Source: Town of Hildebran Zoning Ordinance<br>Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis.<br>In addition to the zoning districts summarized in this section, Hildebran also has<br>two overlay districts: the Manufactured Home Overlay district (MHO) and the<br>Interstate Overlay district (IO). The MHO district allows for manufactured homes<br>on individual lots as well as the establishment of manufactured home parks in the<br>R-10 zoning district. Note that manufactured homes can only be developed in the<br>R-10 zoning district as part of the MHO. The IO district exists, in part, to promote<br>~~**..**~~<br> <br>||~~**..**~~||
||||**Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen National Research Housing Study)**|
|||||
|||||



Source: Town of Hildebran Zoning Ordinance 

Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. 

In addition to the zoning districts summarized in this section, Hildebran also has two overlay districts: the Manufactured Home Overlay district (MHO) and the Interstate Overlay district (IO). The MHO district allows for manufactured homes on individual lots as well as the establishment of manufactured home parks in the R-10 zoning district. Note that manufactured homes can only be developed in the R-10 zoning district as part of the MHO. The IO district exists, in part, to promote 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-51** 

~~**Packet Pg. 262**~~
{191}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

compatible residential uses for properties surrounding Interstate 40 interchanges in the town’s planning area. This overlay district applies to development of vacant parcels as well as proposed changes of current land uses to mixed-use or multifamily buildings. Existing single-family dwellings, duplexes, and manufactured homes used as residences are exempt from IO district requirements. 

Lot area requirements, setbacks and building height restrictions for zoning districts that allow residential development are listed in the following table: 

|**Town of Hildebran–**<br>**Zoning District**<br>**R-20**Residential Low-Density District<br>**R-10**Residential High-Density District<br>**N-B**Neighborhood Business District<br>**CBD**Central Business District<br>**H-B**Highway Business District<br>**G-M**General ManufacturingDistrict|**Lot Area, Setbacks and Building Height Requirements**<br>**Minimum**<br>**Lot Area**<br>**(Sq. Ft.)**<br>**Maximum**<br>**Density**<br>**(DU/A)**<br>**Minimum**<br>**Lot**<br>**Width**<br>**Front**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>15,000-20,000<br>8 DU/A<br>100 ft.<br>40 ft.<br>10,000<br>9 DU/A<br>75 ft.<br>30 ft.<br>8,000<br>N/A<br>100 ft.<br>35 ft.<br>None<br>N/A<br>None*<br>None<br>None<br>N/A<br>100 ft.<br>50 ft.<br>43,560<br>N/A<br>200ft.<br>50ft.|**by Zoning District**<br>**Side**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>**Rear**<br>**Yard**<br>**Setback**<br>12-15 ft.<br>30 ft.<br>10-12 ft.<br>30 ft.<br>12-15 ft.<br>30 ft.<br>0-15 ft.<br>0-15 ft.<br>15-20 ft.<br>30 ft.<br>20-25ft.<br>30ft.|**Maximum**<br>**Building**<br>**Height**<br>35 ft.<br>35 ft.<br>35 ft.<br>50 ft.<br>50 ft.<br>65ft.|
|---|---|---|---|



Source: Town of Hildebran Zoning Ordinance Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. DU/A – Dwelling Units/Acre 

Minimum side yard setback for properties abutting a street is 15 feet. 

In all districts except the R-20 district, buildings cannot exceed maximum height limit unless front yard depth and total side yard width increases by one foot for every two feet of additional building height. *There is no minimum lot width for properties in the CBD district. However, minimum lot _frontage_ on a public street is 35 feet. In CBD, the minimum side yard and rear yard setbacks for lots abutting a residential district is 15 feet. 

Minimum lot areas for residential and commercial zoning districts in the town of Hildebran are generally lower than in towns of similar size in Burke County. The minimum lot area in the R-20 (low density) zoning district ranges from 15,000 square feet for properties with access to public water and sewer to 20,000 square feet for properties lacking access to both public water and sewer utilities. The R-10 district (high density) has a minimum lot area of only 10,000 square feet for singlefamily properties with decreasing lot area requirements for residential structures containing two or more units. The Central Business District (CBD) and the Highway Business District (H-B) do not have defined minimum lot area requirements. Note that the CBD also lacks a minimum lot width requirement. However, properties in the CBD must include a minimum of 35 feet of frontage along a public street. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-52** 

~~**Packet Pg. 263**~~
{192}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The permitted land uses within the town of Hildebran’s residential zoning districts are summarized in the following table. 

|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Hildebran**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Hildebran**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Hildebran**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Hildebran**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Hildebran**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Hildebran**|**Permitted Land Uses within Zoning Districts**<br>**Town of Hildebran**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Land Use Type**|**Zoning Districts**||||||
||**R-20**|**R-10**|**N-B**|**CBD**|**H-B**|**G-M**|
|Accessory uses and buildings|P|P|P|P|P|P|
|Child care home|P|P|P|P|--|--|
|Family care and group homes|P|P|P|P|P|P|
|Long-term care facility|S|S|S|S|S|S|
|Manufactured home parks|--|S*|--|--|--|--|
|Manufactured homes|--|P*|--|--|--|--|
|Mixed-use buildings|--|--|S|P|--|--|
|Modular homes|P|P|P|P|--|--|
|Multifamily dwellings|--|S|--|S|--|--|
|Planned Unit Development (PUD)|P**|P**|P**|P**|P**|P**|
|Single-family dwellings|P|P|P|P|--|--|
|Two-family dwellings (duplexes)|--|P|P|--|--|--|



Source: Town of Hildebran Zoning Ordinance Note: Zoning districts that do not permit residential development were excluded from this analysis. Legend: P – Land use permitted; S – Special use permit required; -- Land use not permitted *Manufactured Home Overlay (MHO) district only. **Land use permitted with conditions. 

Hildebran permits some form of residential development within its residential, commercial, and industrial zoning districts. The two residential zoning districts (R20 and R-10) allow the widest range of residential structures. Permitted residential land uses in the R-20 district (low density) include single-family dwellings, while permitted land uses in the R-10 district include two-family dwellings and multifamily buildings. Manufactured homes on individual lots and manufactured home parks are only permitted in the R-10 district within the Manufactured Home Overlay (MHO) district. Mixed-use buildings are classified as a special use in the Neighborhood Business (N-B) district while multifamily buildings are classified as a special use in the Central Business District (CBD). Note that land use types classified as special use require approval by the Hildebran Board of Adjustment after a public hearing is held. Each of the zoning districts listed in the preceding table also allows Planned Unit Developments (PUDs) as part of a conditional zoning district. Planned Unit Developments permit several types of residential land uses including single-family dwellings, two-family dwellings, multifamily buildings, and mixed uses. 

A municipal zoning map for the town of Hildebran is included on the following page. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-53** 

~~**Packet Pg. 264**~~
{193}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [600 x 796] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.2.b<br>Packet Pg. 265<br>Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>
{194}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## Conclusion 

Based on the preceding analysis, the more densely populated municipalities within the county are all generally well-served by nearby area services and have access to various employment opportunities. Access throughout Burke County and each of the municipalities contained therein, is enhanced by various arterial roadways and major highways. Most notably, U.S. Highway 70 and Interstate 40 which provide east/west access throughout the county. 

While some blighted structures were identified throughout the county, such structures do not appear to dominate any particular area, though they were mostly concentrated within the Morganton Submarket. This is to be expected, however, given the more densely populated/more heavily developed nature of Morganton compared to other municipalities within the county. Various residential development opportunity sites were identified throughout the county. Similar to the blighted structures identified, the various residential development sites identified are also mostly located in the Morganton Submarket. In total, the 38 sites identified contain approximately 777 acres of land and more than 100,000 square feet of existing structure area which could potentially be redeveloped into residential product. Thus, Burke County appears to have various viable site options for residential developers to consider. 

It does not appear that residential development costs associated with labor costs, utility costs, government fees, or taxes/assessments are significantly higher in Burke County compared to adjacent counties. Additionally, water/sewer connection fees within Burke County and Morganton are competitive with those for adjacent counties and the larger municipalities therein where development is most likely to occur. It is also of note that the median price per acre of vacant land ($19,305/acre) within Burke County is considerably lower than those reported for three of the five adjacent counties evaluated within this analysis. Construction labor rates within the Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton MSA are generally lower than those reported for the state of North Carolina. However, it is also important to note that the construction sector accounts for approximately only 2.5% of the MSA job market, a slightly lower figure than that reported for the state of North Carolina (4.0%) as a whole. Thus, while labor rates may be lower within the Burke County area, there is also a more limited skilled labor force within the area as compared to the state, which could potentially limit development within the area. 

All parcels in Burke County are subject to zoning regulations. Unincorporated areas of the county not within the municipal limits of a city or town are subject to zoning regulations at the county level. Zoning regulations for Burke County and its individual municipalities primarily favor lower-density development. Burke County zoning regulations do permit multifamily dwellings in residential and mixed-use zoning districts with the exception of the R-1 zoning district. However, multifamily dwellings are only permitted by right in the R-3 district and require a special use permit in the remaining zoning districts that allow multifamily development. This likely limits larger multifamily development in areas outside of 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-55** 

~~**Packet Pg. 266**~~
{195}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

municipal boundaries of a town or city within the county. Note that base zoning districts in the City of Morganton focus on intensity levels (e.g., low-, medium- or high-intensity development) instead of land use type (e.g., residential or commercial). Due to this focus on intensity levels, the City of Morganton appears to have more flexibility within its zoning regulations for higher density development. 

## **F. DEVELOPER/INVESTOR IDENTIFICATION** 

Given the scope and variety of housing challenges that exist within Burke County, the community would benefit from encouraging the involvement of both public and non-public entities to develop and invest in the numerous housing development opportunities that exist in the county and its municipalities. To that end, we have compiled a list of various residential developers, philanthropic organizations, investors/lenders, and federal and state housing finance organizations that are active in North Carolina, with an emphasis on western North Carolina. In some cases, we have provided links to membership directories given the extensive list of organization members that could be included. Each organization’s name, website (or phone number) and type of entity are provided in the following table. 

|**Entity Name**|**Website**|**Website**||
|---|---|---|---|
|**Housing Developer**||||
|Flatiron Partners LLC|https://flatirondevelopment.com|||
|Habitat for Humanityof Burke County|https://www.burkehabitat.org/|||
|Western Piedmont HousingAuthority|https://www.wpcog.org/regional-housing-authority|||
|Opportunities South|None Found;Phone: 919-417-0125|||
|Pendergraph Development LLC|None Found;Phone: 919-755-0558|||
|Volunteers Of America of The Carolinas|https://www.voa.org/offices/volunteers-of-america-carolinas|||
|Wallick Asset Management LLC|www.wallick.com|||
|Weaver-Kirkland Housing|www.weaver-kirkland.com|||
|Western NC HousingPartnership|https://wnchousing.org|||
|Workforce Homestead|None Found;Phone: 828-351-9151|||
|**Housing Investor/Lender**||||
|Atlantic BayMortgage Group||www.atlanticbay.com||
|Churchill Stateside Group||https://csgfirst.com||
|CommunityAffordable HousingEquityCorporation(CAHEC)||www.cahec.com||
|Greystone Affordable HousingInitiatives||www.greystone.com||
|Homestar Financial Corporation||www.homestarfc.com||
|HomeTrust Bank||https://htb.com||
|HUD Lenders(list of all)||www.hud.gov/program_offices/housing/sfh/lender/lenderlist||
|Movement Mortgage||https://movement.com||
|North Carolina HousingFinance Agency||www.nchfa.com||
|PNC Bank||www.pnc.com||
|RedStone EquityPartners||https://rsequity.com||
|State Employees Credit Union||https://www.ncsecu.org||
|United States Department of Agriculture(USDA)||www.rd.usda.gov/wv||
|Wells Fargo||www.wellsfargo.com||



**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-56** 

~~**Packet Pg. 267**~~
{196}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

(Continued) 

|**Entity Name**|**Website**|**Website**||
|---|---|---|---|
|**Qualified Opportunity Zone Investors**||||
|Allagash OpportunityZone Partners||www.allagashoz.com||
|Blueprint Southeast OZ Fund||None Found;Phone: 404-281-1254||
|Capital Square||None Found;Phone: 404-229-5645||
|Carolina OpportunityFund||www.carolinaopportunityfunds.com||
|CEI-Boulos Capital Management||None Found;Phone: 401-533-0580||
|CRE Models||www.cremodels.com||
|Decennial Fund Management LP||www.decennialgroup.com||
|Economic Innovation Group||https://eig.org/opportunityzones/resources||
|Enterprise Community||www.enterprisecommunity.org/opportunity360||
|HousingAssistance Corporation||www.housing-assistance.com||
|Javelin 19||www.javelin19.com||
|National MinorityTechnologyCouncil||None Found;Phone: 202-600-7828||
|Origin Investments||https://origininvestments.com||
|Pinnacle Partners||www.pinnacleoz.com||
|Pintar Investment Company||None Found;Phone: 407-450-1889||
|PrimeCore Management,LLC||None Found;Phone: 803-605-7503||
|Reonomy||www.reonomy.com||
|Smart Growth America||https://Smartgrowthamerica.org||
|Strategic Rivermont Fund Manager,LLC||www.thestrategicgroup.com||
|**Foundations/Nonprofits**||||
|CommunityFoundation of Western North Carolina|https://cfwnc.org|||
|Dogwood Health Trust|https://dogwoodhealthtrust.org|||
|WAMY CommunityAction|https://wamycommunityaction.org|||



The preceding list of nearly 50 organizations representing potential residential development partners in the area is not exhaustive, as there are certainly other organizations that could be participants in supporting residential development projects in Burke County. The community may want to research other resources to identify developers and investors, such as contacting real estate brokers, North Carolina Economic Development Association, North Carolina Housing Coalition, North Carolina Bankers Association, and Affordable Housing Investors Council. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VII-57** 

~~**Packet Pg. 268**~~
{197}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

**VIII.  HOUSING GAP ESTIMATES** 

## **A. INTRODUCTION** 

This section of our report provides five-year housing gap estimates for both rental and for-sale housing within the PSA (Burke County). The assessment includes demand from a variety of sources and focuses on the housing demand potential of Burke County, though consideration is given to potential support that may originate from outside the county. 

Housing to meet the needs of both current and future households in the market will most likely involve multifamily, duplex, and single-family housing alternatives. There are a variety of financing mechanisms that can support the development of housing alternatives such as federal and state government programs, as well as conventional financing through private lending institutions. These different financing alternatives often have specific income and rent/price restrictions, which affect the market they target. 

We evaluated the market’s ability to support rental and for-sale housing based on four levels of income/affordability. While there may be overlap among these levels due to program targeting and rent/price levels charged, we have established specific income stratifications that are exclusive of each other in order to eliminate double counting demand. We used HUD’s published income and rent limits for Burke County. 

The following table summarizes the income and housing affordability segments used in this analysis to estimate potential housing demand. 

|**Household Income/Wage & Affordability Levels**|**Household Income/Wage & Affordability Levels**|**Household Income/Wage & Affordability Levels**|**Household Income/Wage & Affordability Levels**|**Household Income/Wage & Affordability Levels**||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Percent AMHI**|**Income Range***|**Hourly Wage****|**Affordable Rents*****|**Affordable Prices^**||
|≤ 50%|≤ $35,650|≤ $17.14|≤ $891|≤ $118,833||
|51%-80%|$35,651-$57,040|$17.15-$27.42|$892-$1,426|$118,834-$190,133||
|81%-120%|$57,041-$85,680|$27.43-$41.19|$1,427-$2,142|$190,134-$285,600||
|121%+|$85,681+|$41.20+|$2,143+|$285,601+||
|AMHI – Area Median Household Income||||||



*Based on HUD limits for Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton, North Carolina MSA (4-person limit) **Assumes full-time employment 2,080 hours/year (Assumes one wage earner household) ***Based on assumption tenants pay up to 30% of income toward rent 

^Based on assumption homebuyer can afford to purchase home priced three times annual income after 10% down payment 

While different state and federal housing programs establish income and rent restrictions for their respective programs, in reality, there is potential overlap between windows of affordability between the programs. Further, those who respond to a certain product or program type vary. This is because housing markets are highly dynamic, with households entering and exiting by tenure and economic profile. Further, qualifying policies of property owners and management impact the households that may respond to specific project types. As such, while a household may prefer a certain product, ownership/ 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VIII-1** 

~~**Packet Pg. 269**~~
{198}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

management qualifying procedures (i.e., review of credit history, current income verification, criminal background checks, etc.) may affect housing choices that are available to households. 

Regardless, we have used the preceding income segmentations as the ranges that a typical project or lending institution would use to qualify residents, based on their household income. Ultimately, any new product added to the market will be influenced by many decisions made by the developer and management. This includes eligibility requirements, design type, location, rents/prices, amenities, and other features. As such, our estimates assume that the rents/prices, quality, location, design, and features of new housing product are marketable and will appeal to most renters and homebuyers. 

## **B. HOUSING GAP ESTIMATES** 

The primary sources of demand for new housing (rental and for-sale) include the following: 

- Household Growth 

- Units Required for a Balanced Market 

- Replacement of Substandard Housing 

- • External (Outside Burke County) Commuter Support • Severe Cost Burdened Households • Step-Down Support 

Since the focus of this report is on the specific housing needs of the PSA (Burke County), we have focused the housing demand estimates on the metrics that only impact this area. 

## New Household Growth 

In this report, household growth projections from 2023 to 2028 are based on ESRI estimates. This projected growth was evaluated for each of the targeted income segments. It should be noted that changes in the number of households within a specific income segment do not necessarily mean that households are coming to or leaving the market, but instead, many of these households are likely to experience income growth or loss that would move them into a higher or lower income segment. Furthermore, should additional housing become available, either through new construction or conversion of existing units, demand for new housing could increase. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VIII-2** 

~~**Packet Pg. 270**~~
{199}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## Units Required for a Balanced Market 

The second demand component considers the number of units a market requires to offer balanced market conditions, including some level of vacancies. A healthy _**rental**_ market requires approximately 4% to 6% of the rental market to be available while a healthy _**for-sale**_ housing market should have approximately 2% to 3% of its inventory vacant. Such vacancies allow for inner-market mobility, such as households upsizing or downsizing due to changes in family composition or income, and for people to move into the market. When markets have too few vacancies, rental rates and housing prices often escalate at an abnormal rate, homes can get neglected, and potential renters and/or homebuyers can leave the market. Conversely, an excess of rental units and/or for-sale homes can lead to stagnant or declining rental rates and home prices, property neglect, or existing properties being converted to rentals or for-sale housing. Generally, markets with low vacancy rates often require additional units, while markets with high vacancy rates often indicate a surplus of housing. For the purposes of this analysis, we have utilized a vacancy rate of _**5% for rental**_ product and _**3% for for-sale**_ product to establish balanced market conditions. 

## Replacement of Substandard Housing 

Demand for new units as replacement housing takes into consideration that while some properties are adequately maintained and periodically updated, a portion of the existing stock reaches a point of functional obsolescence over time and needs to be replaced. This comes in the form of either units that are substandard (lacking complete plumbing and/or are overcrowded) or units expected to be removed from the housing stock through demolitions. Based on demographic data included in this report, approximately 5.9% of _**renter**_ households and 1.4% of _**owner**_ households in the PSA (Burke County) are living in substandard housing (e.g., lacking complete plumbing or are overcrowded). Lower income households more often live in substandard housing conditions than higher income households, which we have accounted for in our gap estimates. 

## External Commuter Support 

Market support can originate from households not currently living in the market. This is particularly true for people who work in Burke County but commute from outside of the county and would consider moving to Burke County, if adequate and affordable housing that met residents’ specific needs was offered. Currently, there are few _available_ housing options in the market. As such, external market support will likely be created if new housing product is developed in Burke County. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VIII-3** 

~~**Packet Pg. 271**~~
{200}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Based on our experience in evaluating housing markets throughout the country, it is not uncommon for new product to attract as much as 50% of its support from outside of county limits. As a result, we have assumed that a portion of the demand for new housing will originate from the 13,883 commuters traveling into the PSA (Burke County) from areas outside of county limits. For the purposes of this analysis, we have used a conservative demand ratio of up to 30% for the PSA to estimate the demand that could originate from outside of Burke County. 

## Severe Cost Burdened Households 

HUD defines severe cost burdened households as those paying 50% or more of their household income toward housing costs.  While such households are housed, the disproportionately high share of their income being utilized for housing costs is considered excessive and often leaves little money for impacted households to pay for other essentials such as healthy foods, transportation, medical/healthcare, and education. Therefore, households meeting these criteria were included in our estimates. 

## - Step down Support 

It is not uncommon for households of a certain income level (typically higher income households) to rent or purchase a unit at a lower price point despite the fact they can afford a higher priced unit/home. Using housing cost and income data reported by American Community Survey (ACS), we have applied a portion of this step-down support to lower income demand estimates. In some instances, step-down support constitutes a large portion of potential/total demand as upwards of 80% or 90% of households with moderate and higher incomes within the county pay less than 30% of their income toward housing costs. 

**Note:** In terms of the development pipeline, we only included residential rental units that are confirmed as planned or under construction.  Conversely, we have excluded projects that have not secured financing, are under preliminary review, or have not established a specific project concept (e.g., number of units, pricing, target market, etc.). Any vacant housing units are accounted for in the “Balanced Market” portion of our demand estimates. 

It is also important to point out and understand that the housing gap estimates included in this analysis will differ from those provided in our original analysis in 2018. This is due to enhancements made to our demand methodology since the time of our original report. Thus, our current housing gap estimates will not provide an apples-to-apples comparison with those previously provided.  Additionally, housing gap estimates contained within this report are representative of the needs to cure all housing deficiencies within the county.  Specifically, these estimates demonstrate the total number 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VIII-4** 

~~**Packet Pg. 272**~~
{201}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

of new housing units required over the five-year projection period (20232028) to meet the demands of the market based on the demand components detailed on the preceding pages. These estimates also assume that a wide variety of product (both rental and for-sale) is developed within each income segment, in terms of unit designs, bedroom type, amenities offered, etc. throughout all portions of the county.  We recognize it is unlikely the number of units needed as calculated by our demand estimates will be developed during the projection period due to infrastructure limitations, regulatory/governmental policies, funding availability, etc.  As such, the following housing gap estimates should be utilized as a guide for future development to determine the greatest need by affordability level within the rental and for-sale segments of the Burke County housing market. 

The following table summarizes the _**rental**_ housing gaps for Burke County by affordability level. 

||**Burke County, North Carolina**|**Burke County, North Carolina**|**Burke County, North Carolina**|**Burke County, North Carolina**|
|---|---|---|---|---|
||**Rental Housing Gap Estimates (2023-2028)**||||
|**Percent of Median Income**|**≤ 50%**|**51%-80%**|**81%-120%**|**121%+**|
|**Household Income Range**|**<$35,650**|**$35,651-$57,040**|**$57,041-$85,680**|**$85,681+**|
|**Monthly Rent Range**|**≤ $891**|**$892-$1,426**|**$1,427-$2,142**|**$2,143+**|
|Household Growth|-336|62|131|99|
|Balanced Market*|206|0|33|46|
|Replacement Housing**|507|119|31|14|
|External Market Support^|167|158|83|72|
|Severe Cost Burdened^^|273|137|46|0|
|Step-Down Support|95|2|-5|-92|
|Less Pipeline Units|-78|-151|-120|0|
|**Overall Units Needed**|**834**|**327**|**199**|**139**|



*Based on Bowen National Research’s survey of area rentals **Based on ESRI/ACS estimates of units lacking complete indoor plumbing or are overcrowded ^Based on Bowen National Research proprietary research and ACS migration patterns for Burke County ^^Based on ESRI/ACS estimates of households paying 50% or more of income toward housing 

Based on the preceding demand estimates, it is clear that there is some level of rental housing demand among all household income levels within Burke County over the five-year projection period. Overall, there is a housing need for 1,499 additional rental units in the county over the next five years. The housing gaps range from a low of 139 units needed that have rents at $2,143 or higher to a high of 834 units needed with rents at or below $891.  Without the addition of new rental product similar to the numbers cited in the preceding table, the area will not meet the growing and changing housing needs of the market. 

Based on the demographics of the market, including projected household growth estimates and projected changes in household compositions (e.g., household size, ages, etc.), it appears that approximately one-third of the demand for new rental housing could be specifically targeted to meet the needs of area seniors, though a project could be built to meet the housing 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VIII-5** 

~~**Packet Pg. 273**~~
{202}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

needs of both seniors and families concurrently. For general-occupancy projects, a unit mix of around 35% to 45% one-bedroom units, 30% to 40% two-bedroom units, and 15% to 25% three-bedroom units should be the general goal for future rental housing.  Senior-oriented projects should consider unit mixes closer to 50% for both one- and two-bedroom units each. Additional details of the area’s rental housing supply are included in Section VI and may serve as a guide for future rental housing development design decisions. 

While available land, along with topographical challenges and access to infrastructure (e.g., water and sewer) may limit where and how much housing product can be added to the market, we believe high-density multifamily product would do well in this market, particularly on sites closer to some of the more walkable and/or densely populated areas of the county. However, such multifamily product would also likely do well in areas outside of the municipalities, as long as the sites have convenient access to primary thoroughfares. Some lower density, single-story duplexes and four-plexes would also be well received, particularly among seniors seeking to downsize from large units, as well as homeowners seeking a more maintenance-free residence. 

The following table summarizes the _**for-sale**_ housing gaps for Burke County by affordability level. 

||**Burke County, North Carolina**|**Burke County, North Carolina**|**Burke County, North Carolina**|**Burke County, North Carolina**|
|---|---|---|---|---|
||**For-Sale Housing Gap Estimates (2023-2028)**||||
|**Percent of Median Income**|**≤ 50%**|**51%-80%**|**81%-120%**|**121%+**|
|**Household Income Range**|**<$35,650**|**$35,651-$57,040**|**$57,041-$85,680**|**$85,681+**|
|**Price Point**|**≤ $118,833**|**$118,834-$190,133**|**$190,134-$285,600**|**$285,601+**|
|Household Growth|-871|-607|163|2,139|
|Balanced Market*|182|157|112|244|
|Replacement Housing**|179|78|36|36|
|External Market Support^|374|217|199|400|
|Severe Cost Burdened^^|197|98|33|0|
|Step-Down Support|0|872|988|-1,860|
|Less Pipeline Units|0|0|-14|-29|
|**Overall Units Needed**|**61**|**815**|**1,517**|**930**|



*Based on MLS inventory of available homes 

**Based on ESRI/ACS estimates of units lacking complete indoor plumbing or are overcrowded ^Based on Bowen National Research proprietary research and ACS migration patterns for Burke County ^^Based on ESRI/ACS estimates of households paying 50% or more of income toward housing 

The overall for-sale housing gap in the county is approximately 3,323 units over the five-year projection period. While all home price segments and affordability levels have some level of need, the greatest gap appears to be for housing priced between $190,134 and $285,600 (1,517 units) with the next greatest gap for housing priced at or above $285,601 (930 units). Thus, forsale product is most in need among moderate to higher-income households, which is typical of most markets. The relatively limited supply of product at 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VIII-6** 

~~**Packet Pg. 274**~~
{203}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

all price levels will increase demand for lower priced units, as many buyers may “step down” to a lower price point. This will place greater pressure on the market’s lower priced product and create greater challenges for lower income households and first-time homebuyers who already have limited housing alternatives that are affordable to them. 

In most markets, if there is support for new housing at a particular price point or concept and such product is not offered in a specific area, households may leave the area to seek this housing alternative elsewhere, defer their purchase decision, or seek another housing alternative. Additionally, households considering relocation to the PSA (Burke County) may not move to the PSA if the housing product offered does not meet their needs in terms of pricing, quality, product design, or location. As such, the PSA housing stock may not be able to meet current or future demand, which may limit the market’s ability to serve many of the households seeking to purchase a home in the PSA, particularly lower-income households. Regardless, we believe opportunities exist to develop a variety of product types at a variety of price points. The addition of such housing will better enable the PSA to attract and retain residents (including local employees), as well as seniors, families, and younger adults. 

In terms of product design, we believe a variety of for-sale product could be successful in Burke County. Based on current and projected demographics, as well as the available inventory of for-sale housing, we believe a combination of one- and two-bedroom condominium units could be successful, particularly if they are located in or near more walkable areas. Such product could be in the form of townhome or rowhouse product. Additionally, detached or attached single-story cottage-style condominium product, primarily consisting of two-bedroom units, could be successful in attracting/serving area seniors, particularly those seeking to downsize from their single-family homes. Smaller detached units or duplexes may be a product to develop in some of the smaller infill lots within the various municipalities. Larger, traditional detached single-family homes catering to families could be successful in this market, particularly product serving moderate- and higherincome households, though affordable for-sale housing product for lower income and first-time homebuyer households would also do well in this market. Such product should primarily consist of three-bedroom units, with a smaller share of four-bedroom units. The for-sale housing supply of Burke County is summarized in Section VI and can provide additional details of project concept considerations for future for-sale product in the county. 

Overall, there is potential support for a variety of residential development alternatives in the PSA (Burke County). It is important to understand that the housing demand estimates shown in this report assume no major changes occur in the local economy and that the demographic trends and projections provided in this report materialize. As such, our demand estimates should be 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VIII-7** 

~~**Packet Pg. 275**~~
{204}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

considered conservative and serve as a baseline for development potential. Should new product be developed, it is reasonable to believe that people will consider moving to Burke County, assuming the housing is aggressively marketed throughout the region. 

It is critical to understand that the estimates provided in this report (both rental and for-sale) represent potential units of demand by targeted income level. The actual number of units that can be supported will ultimately be contingent upon a variety of factors including the location of a project, proposed features (i.e., pricing, amenities/features, bedroom type, unit mix, square footage, etc.), product quality, design (i.e., townhouse, single-family homes, or traditional rental units), management and marketing efforts. As such, each targeted segment outlined in the tables included in this section may be able to support more or less than the number of units shown in the table. The potential number of supportable units should be considered a general guideline to residential development planning. The potential development of the planned industrial/commercial megasite in western Burke County could also impact/influence residential development potential within the county. Should this development come to fruition and create additional employment opportunities in Burke County, demographic projections and housing gaps may exceed those illustrated/contained within this report. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**VIII-8** 

~~**Packet Pg. 276**~~
{205}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **IX.  COMMUNITY INPUT RESULTS AND ANALYSIS** 

## **A. INTRODUCTION** 

To gain information, perspective and insight about Burke County housing issues and the factors influencing housing decisions by its residents, developers and others, Bowen National Research conducted targeted surveys of four specific groups: Stakeholders, Employers, Residents/Commuters, and Developers. These surveys were conducted between August and December of 2023 and questions were customized to solicit specific information relative to each segment of the market that was surveyed. 

The surveys were conducted through the SurveyMonkey.com website.  In total, 282 survey responses were received from a broad cross section of the community. The following is a summary of the four surveys conducted by our firm. 

_**Stakeholder Survey**_ – A total of 25 respondents representing community leaders (stakeholders) from a broad field of expertise participated in a survey that inquired about common housing issues, housing needs, barriers to development, and possible solutions or initiatives that could be considered to address housing on a local level. 

_**Employer Survey**_ – A total of 12 respondents representing some of the area’s employers participated in a survey that inquired about general employee composition, housing situations and housing needs. The survey also identified housing issues and the degree housing impacts local employers. 

_**Resident/Commuter Survey**_ – A total of 240 respondents participated in a survey that inquired about current housing conditions and needs as well as the overall housing market in Burke County.  Respondents included Burke County residents and non-resident commuters. 

_**Developer Survey**_ – A total of five respondents participated in a survey that inquired about the type of developments they are currently involved in or would be interested in pursuing, the current barriers that exist for residential development in Burke County, and possible priorities that would encourage future residential development in the area. 

It should be noted that the overall total number of respondents summarized for each survey indicates the number of individuals that responded to at least one survey question.  In some instances, the number of actual respondents to a _specific_ survey question may be less than these stated numbers. 

Key findings from the surveys are included on the following pages. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-1** 

~~**Packet Pg. 277**~~
{206}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **B. STAKEHOLDER SURVEY RESULTS** 

A total of 25 area stakeholders from a broad range of organization types participated in the housing survey with the following results. Note that percentages may not add up to 100.0% due to rounding or because respondents were able to select more than one answer. 

Stakeholder respondents were asked to provide the type of organization they represent. Note that respondents were able to select more than one type of organization. A total of 25 respondents provided input to this question with the following distribution: 

|**Stakeholder Respondents by Organization Type**|**Stakeholder Respondents by Organization Type**|**Stakeholder Respondents by Organization Type**|
|---|---|---|
|**Type**|**Number of**<br>**Respondents**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|Local Government/Municipal Official|8|32.0%|
|Economic Development/Chamber of Commerce|4|16.0%|
|Housing Developer|3|12.0%|
|Realtor Association/Board of Realtors|3|12.0%|
|Education|3|12.0%|
|Agency on Aging/Senior Services|2|8.0%|
|Landlord/Property Management|2|8.0%|
|Construction/Builder|2|8.0%|
|Housing Authority|1|4.0%|
|Manufacturing/Production|1|4.0%|
|Other|3|12.0%|



Stakeholder respondents were asked to provide the degree that certain housing types are needed within Burke County (as a whole) and Morganton. A total of 24 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following results: 

|**Housing Needs by Type**|**Housing Needs by Type**|**Housing Needs by Type**|**Housing Needs by Type**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Burke County**||**Morganton**||
|**Housing Type**|**Weighted**<br>**Score***|**Housing Type**|**Weighted**<br>**Score***|
|Affordable Workforce|91.7|Affordable Workforce|88.6|
|For-Sale (Homeowner)|86.5|For-Sale (Homeowner)|85.2|
|Rental|80.2|Rental|83.0|
|Single-Person/Young Professionals|77.1|Single-Person/Young Professionals|83.0|
|Special Needs (Homeless, Disabled, etc.)|69.8|Special Needs (Homeless, Disabled, etc.)|77.3|
|Senior Apartments (Independent Living)|59.4|Senior Apartments (Independent Living)|62.5|
|SeniorCareFacilities (Assisted and Nursing)|53.1|SeniorCareFacilities (Assisted and Nursing)|60.2|
|*High Need = 100.0, Moderate Need = 50.0, Low Need = 25.0||||



**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-2** 

~~**Packet Pg. 278**~~
{207}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Stakeholder respondents were asked to rank the need for specific housing styles in Burke County (as a whole) and Morganton. A total of 24 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following results: 

|**Housing Needs by Style**|**Housing Needs by Style**|**Housing Needs by Style**|**Housing Needs by Style**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Burke County**||**Morganton**||
|**Housing Style**|**Weighted**<br>**Score***|**Housing Style**|**Weighted**<br>**Score***|
|Detached Houses (Single-Family Homes)|92.7|Detached Houses (Single-Family Homes)|90.9|
|Apartments|74.0|Apartments|77.3|
|Duplex/Triplex/Townhomes|62.5|Duplex/Triplex/Townhomes|65.9|
|Condominiums|51.0|Condominiums|53.4|
|Mobile Homes/Manufactured Housing|47.9|Mobile Homes/Manufactured Housing|43.2|



*High Need = 100.0, Moderate Need = 50.0, Low Need = 25.0 

Stakeholder respondents were asked to estimate the demand for rental housing by price range for Burke County (as a whole) and Morganton.  A total of 24 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following results: 

|**Rental Housing Demand by Price Range**|**Rental Housing Demand by Price Range**|**Rental Housing Demand by Price Range**|**Rental Housing Demand by Price Range**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Burke County**||**Morganton**||
|**Price Range**|**Weighted**<br>**Score***|**Price Range**|**Weighted**<br>**Score***|
|$500-$749/month|93.8|$500-$749/month|90.9|
|$750-$999/month|84.4|$750-$999/month|89.8|
|$1,000-$1,249/month|67.7|$1,000-$1,249/month|69.3|
|$1,250-$1,499/month|46.9|$1,250-$1,499/month|60.2|
|$1,500/month or more|35.4|$1,500/month or more|44.3|



*High Demand = 100.0, Moderate Demand = 50.0, Low Demand = 25.0 

Stakeholder respondents were asked to estimate the demand for for-sale/owner housing by price range for Burke County (as a whole) and Morganton.  A total of 24 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following results: 

|**For-Sale/Owner Housing Demand by Price Range**|**For-Sale/Owner Housing Demand by Price Range**|**For-Sale/Owner Housing Demand by Price Range**|**For-Sale/Owner Housing Demand by Price Range**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Burke County**||**Morganton**||
|**Price Range**|**Weighted**<br>**Score***|**Price Range**|**Weighted**<br>**Score***|
|$150,000-$199,999|97.9|$150,000-$199,999|97.7|
|$200,000-$249,999|79.2|$200,000-$249,999|80.7|
|$250,000-$299,999|70.8|$250,000-$299,999|71.6|
|$300,000 or more|56.3|$300,000 or more|56.8|



*High Demand = 100.0, Moderate Demand = 50.0, Low Demand = 25.0 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-3** 

~~**Packet Pg. 279**~~
{208}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Stakeholder respondents were asked to rank the degree to which specific housing issues are experienced in Burke County (as a whole) and Morganton. A total of 24 respondents provided insight to this question with the following distribution: 

**==> picture [550 x 169] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Housing Issues Experienced<br>Burke County  Morganton<br>Weighted  Weighted<br>Issue  Score* Issue  Score*<br>Limited Availability  100.0  Limited Availability  97.7<br>Home Purchase Affordability  83.3  Rent Affordability  81.8<br>Substandard Housing (Quality/Condition)  79.2  Home Purchase Affordability  81.8<br>Cost of Renovation/Upkeep  79.2  Cost of Renovation/Upkeep  81.8<br>Rent Affordability  75.0  Substandard Housing (Quality/Condition)  70.5<br>Lack of Down Payment for Purchase  72.9  Lack of Down Payment for Purchase  70.5<br>Lack of Public Transportation  68.8  Overcrowded Housing  69.0<br>Overcrowded Housing  63.6  Lack of Public Transportation  59.1<br>Lack of Community Services (grocery, doctor, etc.)  52.1  Foreclosure  45.2<br>Foreclosure  50.0  Lack of Community Services (grocery, doctor, etc.)  38.6<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


*Often = 100.0, Somewhat = 50.0, Never = 0.0 

Stakeholder respondents were asked to rank the priority that should be given to specific housing construction types. A total of 24 respondents provided insight to this question with the following results: 

|**Priority of Housing Construction Types**|**Priority of Housing Construction Types**|**Priority of Housing Construction Types**|**Priority of Housing Construction Types**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Burke County**||**Morganton**||
|**Construction Type**|**Weighted**<br>**Score***|**Construction Type**|**Weighted**<br>**Score***|
|New Construction|82.3|New Construction|79.8|
|Renovation/Revitalization of Existing Housing|76.0|Renovation/Revitalization of Existing Housing|76.2|
|Adaptive Reuse (i.e., Warehouse Conversion)|54.2|Adaptive Reuse (i.e., Warehouse Conversion)|66.7|
|Mixed-Use (Office/Retail with Housing)|43.8|Mixed-Use (Office/Retail with Housing)|61.9|



*High Priority = 100.0, Moderate Priority = 50.0, Low Priority = 25.0 

Stakeholder respondents were asked to rank the priority that should be given to certain funding types for housing development or preservation. A total of 24 respondents provided insight to this question with the following results: 

|**Priority of Housing Funding Types**|**Priority of Housing Funding Types**|**Priority of Housing Funding Types**|**Priority of Housing Funding Types**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Burke County**||**Morganton**||
|**Funding Type**|**Weighted**<br>**Score***|**Funding Type**|**Weighted**<br>**Score***|
|Homebuyer Assistance|79.2|Homebuyer Assistance|81.8|
|Tax Credit Financing|67.7|Project-Based Rental Subsidy|72.7|
|Project-Based Rental Subsidy|64.6|Tax Credit Financing|71.6|
|Other Homeowner Assistance|63.0|Other Homeowner Assistance|67.9|
|Other Rental Housing Assistance (i.e., Vouchers)|61.5|Other Rental Housing Assistance (i.e., Vouchers)|63.6|



*High Priority = 100.0, Moderate Priority = 50.0, Low Priority = 25.0 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-4** 

~~**Packet Pg. 280**~~
{209}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Stakeholder respondents were asked to identify common barriers or obstacles (all that apply) that limit residential development in _Burke County_ (as a whole).  A total of 24 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following results: 

|**Common Barriers/Obstacles to Residential Development– Burke County**|**Common Barriers/Obstacles to Residential Development– Burke County**|**Common Barriers/Obstacles to Residential Development– Burke County**|
|---|---|---|
|**Barrier/Obstacle**|**Number of**<br>**Respondents**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|Cost of Labor/Materials|21|87.5%|
|Cost of Land|16|66.7%|
|Lack of Infrastructure|16|66.7%|
|Financing|14|58.3%|
|Availability of Land|13|54.2%|
|Lack of Transportation|10|41.7%|
|Local Government Regulations ("red tape")|7|29.2%|
|Community Support|5|20.8%|
|Lack of Parking|4|16.7%|
|Lack of Community Services|3|12.5%|



In addition to the answers in the previous table, four respondents noted that _the lack of available qualified labor/subcontractors, the lack of available lots to support large residential developments, and the lack of utilities/infrastructure outside of Morganton and Valdese_ limit residential development. 

Stakeholder respondents were asked to identify common barriers or obstacles (all that apply) that limit residential development in _Morganton_ .  A total of 23 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following results: 

|**Common Barriers/Obstacles to Residential Development- Morganton**|**Common Barriers/Obstacles to Residential Development- Morganton**|**Common Barriers/Obstacles to Residential Development- Morganton**|
|---|---|---|
|**Barrier/Obstacle**|**Number of**<br>**Respondents**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|Availability of Land|22|95.7%|
|Cost of Labor/Materials|20|87.0%|
|Cost of Land|17|73.9%|
|Financing|16|69.6%|
|Lack of Infrastructure|13|56.5%|
|Local Government Regulations ("red tape")|11|47.8%|
|Lack of Parking|6|26.1%|
|Lack of Transportation|5|21.7%|
|Community Support|4|17.4%|
|LackofCommunity Services|2|8.7%|



In addition to the answers in the previous table, three respondents provided openended feedback to this question.  Similar to Burke County, two respondents noted _the lack of available qualified labor/subcontractors_ as a barrier to development in Morganton.  However, one respondent cited _the limited sewer capacity_ as a barrier to development within Morganton. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-5** 

~~**Packet Pg. 281**~~
{210}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Stakeholder respondents were asked to provide options that they believe could reduce or eliminate obstacles/barriers to residential development.  A total of 21 respondents provided feedback through an open-ended response.  A summary list of responses follows: 

**==> picture [400 x 519] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
• Availability of gap financing<br>• Higher density residential developments<br>• Seek state and federal provided assistance for infrastructure development<br>• Development of housing at a variety of price points<br>• Promotion of vocational/trade schools<br>• Increase availability of financing options<br>• Increase incentives for developers/Fast-track process for qualified builders<br>• Financing resources for developers<br>• Expand infrastructure (water/sewer) to new areas of the county<br>• Provide incentives for owners to sell vacant lots for development<br>• Place limitations on HOAs and corporate purchases of land<br>• Identification and promotion of development opportunities<br>• Reduced zoning restrictions (both residential and commercial)<br>• Increased transportation options<br>• Create partnerships among private and public sectors and employers to develop<br>housing<br>• Reevaluate income-based housing assistance limits due to rising costs of fuel,<br>groceries, etc.<br>Stakeholder respondents were asked if there are any other issues, priorities, or<br>opportunities that they believe are important that would support residential<br>development in the area.  A total of 12 respondents provided additional feedback<br>to this question.  Although many topics were addressed in previous questions, some<br>additional topics cited by respondents include:<br>• Utilization of state-owned properties<br>• Government assistance with infrastructure costs<br>• Address substance abuse issues, provide homeless shelters, and improve<br>neighborhood safety<br>• Land banking<br>• Conversion of vacant commercial properties into affordable housing<br>• Educating residents on the existing public transit options that are available<br>(Greenway Transit)<br>• Limitations on Airbnbs/short-term rentals<br>• Rental registry portal that provides opportunity for tenants to report substandard<br>housing issues<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-6** 

~~**Packet Pg. 282**~~
{211}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## Stakeholder Survey Conclusions 

Based on the feedback provided by area stakeholders, it appears that Burke County and Morganton are most in need of affordable workforce housing (both for-sale and rental) and housing that targets single-person households and/or young professionals. While single-family detached homes were rated as the top style in both Burke County and Morganton, apartments and duplex/triplex/townhomes were also considered substantial needs.  Although it appears the most notable need by price point is for affordable rental ($500 to $749/month) and for-sale ($150,000 to $199,999) housing, there is a significant need for housing at a variety of affordability levels based on feedback from respondents.  Limited availability is one of the most common housing issues experienced in both Burke County and Morganton. However, home purchase affordability, substandard housing, the cost of renovation and upkeep, and rent affordability are also very common housing issues within the markets. Stakeholder respondents believe new construction, the renovation/revitalization of existing housing, and adaptive reuse should be priorities in both markets.  A substantial share of respondents also rated mixed-used development as an important priority within the Morganton Submarket.  Funding types such as homebuyer assistance, tax credit financing, project-based rental subsidies, and other homeowner assistance programs were rated as top priorities by respondents.  Overall, the cost of labor and materials, the lack of infrastructure support, financing, and the availability and cost of land were cited as the most common barriers to residential development within Burke County and Morganton. While these barriers likely limit the ability of the area to attract new households and result in households living in substandard and cost-burdened housing situations, stakeholders provided a variety of possible solutions (page IX-6) that could potentially reduce or eliminate many of these barriers. 

Tables summarizing the top stakeholder responses for Burke County (as a whole) and Morganton are included on the following pages. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-7** 

~~**Packet Pg. 283**~~
{212}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|**Category**<br>Housing Needs by Type<br>Housing Needs by Style<br>Rental Housing by Price Range<br>For-Sale/Owner Housing<br>by Price Range<br>Housing Issues Experienced<br>Priority by Construction Type<br>Priority by Funding Types<br>Common Residential Barriers|•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•|**Burke County, North Carolina**<br>**Summary of Stakeholder Survey Results**<br>**Top Responses**<br>Affordable Workforce<br>For-Sale (Homeowner)<br>Rental<br>Single-Person/Young Professionals<br>Detached Houses (Single-Family Homes)<br>Apartments<br>Duplex/Triplex/Townhomes<br>$500-$749/Month<br>$750-$999/Month<br>$1,000-$1,249/Month<br>$150,000-$199,999<br>$200,000-$249,999<br>$250,000-$299,999<br>Limited Availability<br>Home Purchase Affordability<br>Substandard Housing (Quality/Condition)<br>Cost of Renovation/Upkeep<br>Rent Affordability<br>Lack of Down Payment for Purchase<br>New Construction<br>Renovation/Revitalization of Existing Housing<br>Adaptive Reuse (i.e., Warehouse Conversion)<br>Homebuyer Assistance<br>Tax Credit Financing<br>Project-Based Rental Subsidy<br>Other Homeowner Assistance<br>Cost of Labor/Materials<br>Cost of Land<br>Lack of Infrastructure<br>Financing<br>Availability of Land|**Consensus**<br>**91.7***<br>**86.5***<br>**80.2***<br>**77.1***<br>**92.7***<br>**74.0***<br>**62.5***<br>**93.8***<br>**84.4***<br>**67.7***<br>**97.9***<br>**79.2***<br>**70.8***<br>**100.0***<br>**83.3***<br>**79.2***<br>**79.2***<br>**75.0***<br>**72.9***<br>**82.3***<br>**76.0***<br>**54.2***<br>**79.2***<br>**67.7***<br>**64.6***<br>**63.0***<br>**87.5%**<br>**66.7%**<br>**66.7%**<br>**58.3%**<br>**54.2%**|
|---|---|---|---|



*Denotes weighted score 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-8** 

~~**Packet Pg. 284**~~
{213}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|**Category**<br>Housing Needs by Type<br>Housing Needs by Style<br>Rental Housing by Price Range<br>For-Sale/Owner Housing<br>by Price Range<br>Housing Issues Experienced<br>Priority by Construction Type<br>Priority by Funding Types<br>Common Residential Barriers|•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•<br>•|**Morganton, North Carolina**<br>**Summary of Stakeholder Survey Results**<br>**Top Responses**<br>Affordable Workforce<br>For-Sale (Homeowner)<br>Rental<br>Single-Person/Young Professionals<br>Detached Houses (Single-Family Homes)<br>Apartments<br>Duplex/Triplex/Townhomes<br>$500-$749/Month<br>$750-$999/Month<br>$1,000-$1,249/Month<br>$150,000-$199,999<br>$200,000-$249,999<br>$250,000-$299,999<br>Limited Availability<br>Rent Affordability<br>Home Purchase Affordability<br>Cost of Renovation/Upkeep<br>Substandard Housing (Quality/Condition)<br>Lack of Down Payment for Purchase<br>New Construction<br>Renovation/Revitalization of Existing Housing<br>Adaptive Reuse (i.e., Warehouse Conversion)<br>Mixed-Use (Office/Retail with Housing)<br>Homebuyer Assistance<br>Project-Based Rental Subsidy<br>Tax Credit Financing<br>Other Homeowner Assistance<br>Availability of Land<br>Cost of Labor/Materials<br>Cost of Land<br>Financing<br>Lack of Infrastructure|**Consensus**<br>**88.6***<br>**85.2***<br>**83.0***<br>**83.0***<br>**90.9***<br>**77.3***<br>**65.9***<br>**90.9***<br>**89.8***<br>**69.3***<br>**97.7***<br>**80.7***<br>**71.6***<br>**97.7***<br>**81.8***<br>**81.8***<br>**81.8***<br>**70.5***<br>**70.5***<br>**79.8***<br>**76.2***<br>**66.7***<br>**61.9***<br>**81.8***<br>**72.7***<br>**71.6***<br>**67.9***<br>**95.7%**<br>**87.0%**<br>**73.9%**<br>**69.6%**<br>**56.5%**|
|---|---|---|---|



*Denotes weighted score 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-9** 

~~**Packet Pg. 285**~~
{214}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **C. EMPLOYER SURVEY RESULTS** 

A total of 12 representatives from area employers responded to the housing survey. Note that percentages may not add up to 100.0% due to rounding or because respondents were able to select more than one answer. 

Employer respondents were asked to describe the primary business activity of their company.  A total of 11 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following distribution: 

**==> picture [267 x 73] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Employer Respondents by Business Type<br>Type  Number  Share<br>Manufacturing  6  54.6%<br>Construction  3  27.3%<br>Retail  1  9.1%<br>Education  1  9.1%<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Employer respondents were asked to approximate the number of people they employ locally. A total of 11 respondents provided feedback to this question.  Based on the survey responses, approximately 2,482 individuals are employed by these companies with the following distribution of firms by number of employees: 

- 1 to 50 Employees: **4 (36.4%)** 

- 51 to 100 Employees: **1 (9.1%)** 

- 101 to 250 Employees: **3 (27.3%)** 

- 251 to 500 Employees: **2 (18.2%)** 

- 500+ Employees: **1 (9.1%)** 

Employer respondents were asked to approximate the number of employees by employment status (part-time, full-time, seasonal). A total of 12 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following distribution: 

- Part-Time: **14.6%** 

- Full-Time: **77.1%** 

- Seasonal: **8.3%** 

Employer respondents were asked to approximate the percentage of their employees who reside in Burke County. A total of 12 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following distribution: 

**==> picture [343 x 97] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Share of Employees That Live Within County<br>Number of  Share of<br>Response  Respondents  Respondents<br>Less than 10%  1  8.3%<br>Between 10% and 25%  0  0.0%<br>Between 26% and 50%  0  0.0%<br>Between 51% and 75%  4  33.3%<br>More than 75%  7  58.3%<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-10** 

~~**Packet Pg. 286**~~
{215}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Employer respondents were asked to estimate the number of _new jobs by annual wages_ that their company expects to create over the next three years.  A total of 10 respondents provided insight to this question. The following table summarizes the employer responses and provides the estimated total number of new jobs by annual salary: 

|**Estimated New Jobs Created by Employers by Annual Salary**<br>**(Next Three Years)**|**Estimated New Jobs Created by Employers by Annual Salary**<br>**(Next Three Years)**|
|---|---|
|**Annual**<br>**Salary**|**Estimated Total Number**<br>**of New Jobs (Share)**|
|Less than $25,000|42 (15.4%)|
|$25,000 to $50,000|139 (51.1%)|
|$51,000 to $75,000|32 (11.8%)|
|$76,000 to $100,000|7 (2.6%)|
|Over $100,000|52 (19.1%)|
|**Estimated Total of New Jobs**<br>**Created by Employers**|**272 (100.0%)**|



As the preceding table illustrates, employer respondents estimate job creation over the next three years of approximately 272 new jobs. Nearly two-thirds (66.5%) of the estimated new jobs in the county are expected to pay annual salaries of $50,000 or less, while 19.1% are expected to pay salaries of $100,000 or more. It is important to note that these are estimates provided by respondents based on current economic conditions and these estimates can change for a variety of reasons at any point in time. 

Employer respondents were asked if they have had difficulty attracting or retaining employees due to housing related issues in the past couple of years. A total of 12 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following distribution: 

- Yes: **4 (33.3%)** 

- No: **4 (33.3%)** 

- Unknown: **4 (33.3%)** 

Employer respondents were asked to identify the three most common housing issues/challenges experienced by their employees. Employers could select options from a list of common housing issues that was provided. A total of 12 respondents provided feedback to this question. The following table illustrates the top responses: 

|**Top Housing Issues Experienced by Employees**|**Top Housing Issues Experienced by Employees**|
|---|---|
|**Issue**|**Share of Respondents**|
|Lack of Available Housing|66.7%|
|Unaffordable Rental Housing|58.3%|
|Unaffordable For-Sale Housing|41.7%|
|Housing is Far From Work|25.0%|
|Lack of Quality Housing|16.7%|
|Housing is Not Near Transit|16.7%|
|Renovation/Repair Costs|16.7%|



**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-11** 

~~**Packet Pg. 287**~~
{216}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Employer respondents were then asked if the housing issues that their employees or prospective employees experience are impacting the company.  Employers could select from a list of impact options that was provided. A total of 12 respondents provided feedback to this question.  The following table illustrates their responses: 

**==> picture [398 x 145] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Impacts for Employers Resulting from Housing Issues<br>Response  Share of Respondents<br>Adversely Impacts Productivity  41.7%<br>Unable to Grow/Expand Business  33.3%<br>Difficulty Attracting Employees  25.0%<br>Difficulty Retaining Employees  25.0%<br>Adds to Company Costs  25.0%<br>Adversely Impacts Company Morale  8.3%<br>Limits Hours of Operation  8.3%<br>Difficult to Stay In Business  8.3%<br>Other   8.3%<br>Unknown  33.3%<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Employer respondents were then asked if additional housing was provided in Burke County that adequately served the needs of employees, to what degree would this increase the likelihood that their company would employ more people over the next three years. A total of 12 respondents supplied answers to this question with the following distribution: 

- Much More Likely: **3 (25.0%)** 

- Somewhat Likely: **4 (33.3%)** 

- Not Likely/No Impact: **1 (8.3%)** 

- Unknown: **4 (33.3%)** 

Employer respondents were asked if their company currently provides any type of housing assistance to employees and to specify the type provided. A total of 11 respondents provided feedback to this question. Although the majority of respondents (eight, or 72.7%) indicated that they do not provide any type of housing assistance, **three** respondents (27.3%) indicated that they provide some type of assistance.  Assistance types included housing relocation assistance and payroll advances for security deposits, utility connection, etc. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-12** 

~~**Packet Pg. 288**~~
{217}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Employer respondents were then asked what type of housing assistance, if any, they would consider providing for their employees.  Note that respondents could select more than one type of program.  A total of 12 respondents provided insight to this question with the following distribution: 

|**Potential Employer Provided Housing Assistance Programs**|**Potential Employer Provided Housing Assistance Programs**|
|---|---|
|**Program**|**Share of Respondents**|
|Rental Security Deposit Assistance|8.3%|
|Housing Counseling/Placement Services|8.3%|
|Housing Relocation Services/Assistance|8.3%|
|Housing Relocation Reimbursement|8.3%|
|Partnering In/Developing Employee Housing|8.3%|
|Other|8.3%|
|None|75.0%|



Employer respondents were asked to indicate the level of importance of future government housing programs, policies or incentives that could be implemented to assist employees with housing or addressing the market’s housing issues.  A total of 12 respondents provided feedback to this question.  The following table provides a weighted summary of the responses: 

|**Housing Programs, Policies, and Initiatives by Degree of Importance**|**Housing Programs, Policies, and Initiatives by Degree of Importance**|
|---|---|
|**Program**|**Weighted**<br>**Score***|
|New Housing Development/Redevelopment|72.7|
|Renter Assistance|59.1|
|Housing Assistance for Public Employees (Police, Fire, Teachers, Etc.)|52.3|
|Development of More Public Housing|52.1|
|Homebuyer Assistance|47.9|
|Direct Government Investment in Land for Workforce Housing (Land Banking)|36.4|



*Most Important = 100.0, Somewhat Important = 50.0, Least Important = 25.0 

Employer respondents were asked, in terms of product pricing, what are the three most needed housing price points for their employees. Employers could select from a list of pricing options that was provided. A total of 12 respondents provided feedback to this question with the results illustrated in the following table: 

|**Most Needed Housing Price Points for Employees**|**Most Needed Housing Price Points for Employees**|
|---|---|
|**Type of Housing Product (Price)**|**Share of Respondents**|
|Moderate Market-Rate Rental Housing ($750-$1,250/month)|75.0%|
|Affordable Rental Housing (Under $750/month)|66.7%|
|Entry Level/Workforce For-Sale Housing (Below $200,000)|66.7%|
|Moderate For-Sale Housing ($200,000-$300,000)|50.0%|
|Higher-End For-Sale Housing (Above $300,000)|16.7%|
|Higher-End Market-Rate Rental Housing (Above $1,250/month)|8.3%|



Employer respondents were then asked, in terms of product type, what are the most needed types of housing for their employees.  Employers could select from a list of housing product types that was provided. A total of 12 respondents provided feedback to this question with the results illustrated in the following table: 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-13** 

~~**Packet Pg. 289**~~
{218}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|**Most Needed Housing Types for Employees**|**Most Needed Housing Types for Employees**|
|---|---|
|**Type of Housing Product**|**Share of Respondents**|
|Single-Family Homes (Owner)|91.7%|
|Multifamily Apartments|58.3%|
|Single-Family Homes (Rental)|50.0%|
|Duplex/Townhome (Rental)|25.0%|
|Duplex/Townhome (Owner)|16.7%|
|Mobile Homes/Manufactured Housing|16.7%|
|Condominiums (Owner)|8.3%|
|Condominiums (Rental)|8.3%|



Employer respondents were asked to provide any additional comments regarding housing issues and needs that impact employees within Burke County.  A total of five respondents provided feedback in the form of an open-ended response. Feedback from respondents included topics related to _establishing apartments for short-term employee occupancy, the lack of affordable housing options for employees (rentals and small, single-family homes), the lack of public transportation options, and maintenance-free housing options for seniors looking to downsize (to free up housing for the workforce)_ . 

## Employer Survey Conclusions 

Based on the feedback provided by area employers, it appears that one-third (33.3%) of employers in the county have experienced staffing issues as a result of housing.  Overall, the lack of available housing and affordability (rental and forsale) are the top issues experienced by employees in the area.  These housing issues adversely impact productivity, prevent businesses from growing or expanding, add to company costs, and create difficulty attracting and retaining employees for a notable share of employers.  The majority (58.3%) of employer respondents indicated that they would be at least “somewhat” more likely to hire new employees if adequate housing were available in the county, with over 100 additional employees expected to be hired as a result. Despite the issues that housing can create for employers, it is noteworthy that approximately three-quarters of the surveyed employers do not currently provide housing assistance and would not consider providing housing assistance programs in the future. Among various future government housing programs and initiatives, employer respondents consider new housing development/redevelopment, renter assistance, housing assistance for public employees, and the development of additional public housing to be the most important. Overall, the consensus among area employers is that Burke County is most in need of moderate market-rate rental housing ($750 to $1,250 per month), affordable rental housing (under $750 per month), and entry level for-sale housing (below $200,000). Among product types, it appears that employers consider single-family homes (both rental and for-sale) and multifamily apartments to be the most critical need in the area. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-14** 

~~**Packet Pg. 290**~~
{219}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following table summarizes the top employer responses to critical questions contained within this survey: 

|**Category**<br>Difficulty Attracting/Retaining<br>Employees Due to Housing<br>Housing Issues for Employees<br>Impacts for Employers<br>Effects of Adequate Housing<br>Supply<br>Employer Housing Assistance<br>Housing Assistance Program<br>Consideration<br>Housing Program or Policy<br>Importance<br>Housing Needs by Price<br>Housing Needs by Product Type|**Burke County, North Carolina**<br>**Summary of Employer Survey Results**<br>**Top Needs / Issues**<br>• Yes<br>• No<br>• Lack of Available Housing<br>• Unaffordable Rental Housing<br>• Unaffordable For-Sale Housing<br>• Adversely Impacts Productivity<br>• Unable to Grow/Expand Business<br>• Difficulty Attracting Employees<br>• Difficulty Retaining Employees<br>• Adds to Company Costs<br>• Somewhat/Much More Likely to Hire New Employees<br>• Additional Employees Hired<br>• Provide Some Type of Housing Assistance (i.e., Relocation/Payroll Advances)<br>• Do Not Currently Provide Housing Assistance to Employees<br>• Rental Security Deposit Assistance, Housing Counseling/Placement<br>Assistance, Relocation Services/Assistance, or Development of Employee<br>Housing<br>• Would Not Consider Housing Assistance<br>• New Housing Development/Redevelopment<br>• Renter Assistance<br>• Housing Assistance for Public Employees (Police, Fire, Teachers, etc.)<br>• Development of More Public Housing<br>• Moderate Market-Rate Rental Housing ($750-$1,250/month)<br>• Affordable Rental Housing (Under $750/month)<br>• Entry Level/Workforce For-Sale Housing (Below $200,000)<br>• Moderate For-Sale Housing ($200,000-$300,000)<br>• Single-Family Homes (Owner)<br>• Multifamily Apartments<br>• Single-Family Homes (Rental)|**Consensus**<br>**33.3%**<br>**33.3%**<br>**66.7%**<br>**58.3%**<br>**41.7%**<br>**41.7%**<br>**33.3%**<br>**25.0%**<br>**25.0%**<br>**25.0%**<br>**58.3%**<br>**Up to 104**<br>**27.3%**<br>**72.7%**<br>**8.3%**<br>**75.0%**<br>**72.7***<br>**59.1***<br>**52.3***<br>**52.1***<br>**75.0%**<br>**66.7%**<br>**66.7%**<br>**50.0%**<br>**91.7%**<br>**58.3%**<br>**50.0%**|
|---|---|---|



*Denotes weighted score 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-15** 

~~**Packet Pg. 291**~~
{220}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **D. RESIDENT/COMMUTER SURVEY RESULTS** 

A total of 240 individuals responded to the housing survey with the following results.  Note that percentages may not add up to 100.0% due to rounding or because respondents were able to select more than one answer. 

## Current Housing Situation 

Respondents were asked if they currently reside in Burke County.  A total of 240 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following results: 

|**Respondents by Area of Residence**|**Respondents by Area of Residence**|**Respondents by Area of Residence**|
|---|---|---|
|**Response**|**Number of**<br>**Respondents**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|Yes (Reside in Burke County)|198|82.5%|
|No (Do Not Reside in Burke County)|42|17.5%|



_Resident_ respondents were asked if they work in Burke County.  A total of 197 resident respondents provided feedback to this question with the following distribution: 

|**Resident Respondents by Area of Employment**|**Resident Respondents by Area of Employment**|**Resident Respondents by Area of Employment**|
|---|---|---|
|**Response**|**Number of**<br>**Respondents**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|Yes (Work in Burke County)|187|94.9%|
|No (Do Not Work in Burke County)|10|5.1%|



_Non-resident_ respondents were asked to provide the ZIP code of their current residence.  A total of 42 non-resident respondents provided feedback to this question with the following results: 

|**Respondents by Area of Residence**|**Respondents by Area of Residence**|**Respondents by Area of Residence**|
|---|---|---|
|**ZIP Code (City/County)**|**Number of**<br>**Respondents**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|28645 (Lenoir / Caldwell County)|14|33.3%|
|28601 (Hickory / Catawba County)|5|11.9%|
|28752 (Marion / McDowell County)|4|9.5%|
|28761 (Nebo / McDowell County)|3|7.1%|
|28150 (Shelby / Cleveland County)|2|4.8%|
|28602 (Hickory / Catawba County)|2|4.8%|
|28613 (Conover / Catawba County)|2|4.8%|
|28658 (Newton / Catawba County)|2|4.8%|
|AllOthers|8|19.0%|



**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-16** 

~~**Packet Pg. 292**~~
{221}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Respondents were asked to provide their typical commute time to work (one way). A total of 200 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following distribution: 

|**Respondents by Commute Time**|**Respondents by Commute Time**|**Respondents by Commute Time**|**Respondents by Commute Time**|**Respondents by Commute Time**|**Respondents by Commute Time**|**Respondents by Commute Time**|**Respondents by Commute Time**|**Respondents by Commute Time**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Residency/Commute Status**||**< 15**<br>**Minutes**|**15-30**<br>**Minutes**|**31-45**<br>**Minutes**|**46-60**<br>**Minutes**|**60 +**<br>**Minutes**|**Work at**<br>**Home**|**Do Not**<br>**Work**|
|Resident /<br>Work in Burke County|Number|111|38|2|0|0|6|1|
||Share|70.3%|24.1%|1.3%|0.0%|0.0%|3.8%|0.6%|
|Non-Resident /<br>Work in Burke County|Number|1|21|15|4|1|0|0|
||Share|2.4%|50.0%|35.7%|9.5%|2.4%|0.0%|0.0%|



## Current Housing Market 

Respondents were asked how they would describe the overall housing market in Burke County.  A total of 85 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following distribution: 

|**Housing Market Rating**|**Housing Market Rating**|**Housing Market Rating**|
|---|---|---|
|**Rating**|**Number of**<br>**Respondents**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|Good, No Issues|2|2.4%|
|Fair, Some Issues|30|35.3%|
|Poor, Many Issues|49|57.7%|
|No Opinion|4|4.7%|



Respondents were asked to identify issues that negatively impact the local housing market.  Respondents could select applicable options from a list and/or provide an open-ended response.  A total of 86 respondents provided feedback to this question. The following table illustrates the top issues cited by respondents: 

|**Top Issues Negatively Impacting the Local Housing Market**|**Top Issues Negatively Impacting the Local Housing Market**|**Top Issues Negatively Impacting the Local Housing Market**|
|---|---|---|
|**Issue**|**Number of**<br>**Respondents**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|High Prices or Rents|70|81.4%|
|Not Enough Housing/Rental Options (Few Vacancies)|59|68.6%|
|Mismatch Between Local Jobs/Wages and Housing Costs|31|36.1%|
|Neglected/Blighted Properties/Neighborhood (Poor Condition)|16|18.6%|
|Property/Income Taxes|13|15.1%|
|Owners Unable to Afford Home Maintenance/Upkeep|12|14.0%|
|Housing Being Converted to Short-Term/Vacation Rentals|8|9.3%|
|Lack of Public Transportation|6|7.0%|
|Excessive/Rising Utility Costs|5|5.8%|



Respondents were asked to provide the reason that they believe it is difficult for people to find suitable housing in Burke County.  Respondents could select applicable options from a list and/or provide an open-ended response.  A total of 86 respondents provided feedback to this question.  The following table illustrates the top reasons cited by respondents: 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-17** 

~~**Packet Pg. 293**~~
{222}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|**Top Reasons for Difficulty Locating Suitable Housing**|**Top Reasons for Difficulty Locating Suitable Housing**|**Top Reasons for Difficulty Locating Suitable Housing**|
|---|---|---|
|**Issue**|**Number of**<br>**Respondents**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|Housing Not Affordable|72|83.7%|
|Not Enough Housing (Limited Availability)|61|70.9%|
|Lack of Housing to Meet Specific Needs (i.e., Number of Bedrooms)|26|30.2%|
|Lack of Down Payment or Rental Deposit|26|30.2%|
|Poor Quality of Housing|17|19.8%|
|Landlords Not Accepting Housing Choice Vouchers|11|12.8%|
|Undesirable Location/Neighborhood|10|11.6%|
|Age of Housing (Too Old)|10|11.6%|



Respondents were asked to rank the degree that specific housing types are needed in Burke County.  A total of 84 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following results: 

**==> picture [398 x 215] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Degree of Need for Specific Housing Types<br>Weighted<br>Housing Type  Score*<br>Rental Housing ($500-$1,000/month)  92.3<br>For-Sale Housing ($100,000-$200,000)  91.1<br>Housing for Ages 25-40  87.2<br>Family Housing (2+ Bedrooms)  86.7<br>Senior Apartments (Independent Living)  67.5<br>Single-Person (Studio/One-Bedroom)  63.2<br>Rentals that Accept Housing Choice Vouchers  62.8<br>Senior Care Facilities (Assisted Living/Nursing Care)  59.2<br>For-Sale Housing ($201,000-$300,000)  56.9<br>Senior Condominiums (For-Sale Housing)  56.2<br>Rental Housing ($1,001-$1,500/month)  54.9<br>Communal Housing (Shared Living Space)  31.8<br>For-Sale Housing (Over $300,000)  24.0<br>Rental Housing (Over $1,500/month)  19.0<br>*High Need = 100.0, Minimal Need = 25.0, No Need = 0.0<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Respondents were asked to rank the degree that specific housing styles are needed in Burke County.  A total of 83 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following results: 

**==> picture [398 x 143] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Degree of Need for Specific Housing Styles<br>Weighted<br>Housing Style  Score*<br>Apartments  83.5<br>Modern Move-In Ready Single-Family Homes  80.7<br>Ranch Homes/Single Floor Plan Units  80.6<br>Duplex/Triplex/Townhomes  70.5<br>Low Cost Fixer-Uppers (Single-Family Homes)  67.4<br>Condominiums  59.8<br>Single-Room Occupancy (SRO)  41.9<br>Accessory Dwelling Unit (Above Garage, Income Suite, Etc.) 40.4<br>*High Need = 100.0, Minimal Need = 25.0, No Need = 0.0<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-18** 

~~**Packet Pg. 294**~~
{223}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Respondents were asked to identify the most significant housing issue that exists within Burke County today.  A total of 65 respondents provided feedback to this question through an open-ended response.  Topics cited by respondents include _the increasing costs of real estate and overall affordability, limited availability (rentals and for-sale homes), the mismatch between prices and quality, the mismatch between prices and wages, homelessness, the lack of income-based housing, rising taxes, the inability to afford to maintain housing, the high cost of labor, materials, and interest rates, the lack of senior-oriented housing, and the lack of infrastructure (water, sewer, etc.) in certain areas of the county._ 

Respondents were asked to share any other comments or concerns about housing in Burke County.  A total of 26 respondents provided additional feedback through an open-ended response.  As with previous questions, the topics of affordability, availability, and wages were commonly cited by respondents.  Additional topics included _the prevalence of homelessness, the lack of amenities compared to surrounding areas, the presence of blighted homes in the county, and the need to provide incentives to attract more developers to the area_ .  While most respondents cited housing issues that are present in Burke County, some respondents noted that _Burke County is a highly desirable place to live with advantages such as a low crime rate compared to surrounding counties_ . 

Non-resident respondents were asked if they have any interest in living in Burke County, should housing become available.  A total of 36 non-resident respondents provided feedback to this question with the following distribution: 

|**Non-Resident Interest in Living in Burke County**|**Non-Resident Interest in Living in Burke County**|
|---|---|
|**Response**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|Yes|61.1%|
|No|38.9%|



Non-resident respondents were asked what style of housing they would be interested in living in within Burke County.  A total of 22 non-resident respondents provided feedback to this question with the following distribution: 

|**Preferred Housing Style**|**Preferred Housing Style**|
|---|---|
|**Housing Style**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|Modern, Move-In Ready Single-Family Home|77.3%|
|Ranch Homes or Single Floor Plan Unit|59.1%|
|Low-Cost Fixer-Upper|31.8%|
|Apartment|9.1%|
|Duplex/Triplex/Townhome|9.1%|
|Condominium|9.1%|
|Other|9.1%|
|Single-Room Occupancy|4.6%|
|Accessory Dwelling Unit (income suite)|4.6%|
|Senior Living|4.6%|



**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-19** 

~~**Packet Pg. 295**~~
{224}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Non-resident respondents were asked to provide the number of bedrooms they would require if relocating to Burke County.  A total of 22 non-resident respondents provided feedback to this question with the following distribution: 

|**Number of Bedrooms Required**|**Number of Bedrooms Required**|
|---|---|
|**Bedrooms**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|Studio|0.0%|
|One-Bedroom|4.6%|
|Two-Bedroom|45.5%|
|Three-Bedroom|22.7%|
|Four-Bedroom+|27.3%|



Non-resident respondents were asked what they would be willing to pay per month (including utility costs) to live in Burke County.  A total of 22 non-resident respondents provided feedback to this question with the following distribution: 

|**Monthly Housing Costs Willing to Pay**|**Monthly Housing Costs Willing to Pay**|
|---|---|
|**Monthly Payment**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|No Expense|0.0%|
|Up to $500|4.6%|
|$501-$750|13.6%|
|$751-$1,000|22.7%|
|$1,001-$1,250|9.1%|
|$1,251-$1,500|27.3%|
|$1,501-$2,000|4.6%|
|Over $2,000|18.2%|



Non-resident respondents were asked if there is anything, besides housing, that could be addressed, added, or changed in Burke County that would increase the likelihood of them moving to Burke County.  A total of eight non-resident respondents provided feedback to this question through an open-ended response. Topics cited by respondents include the need for more restaurants and shopping, improved downtown area in Morganton, more community resources, address homeless issue, lower taxes and utility costs, improve schools, grant opportunities for small/minority owned businesses, and trade school opportunities. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-20** 

~~**Packet Pg. 296**~~
{225}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## Demographic Distribution 

Respondents were asked to provide their age.  A total of 85 respondents responded to this question. The distribution of responses is illustrated in the following table. 

|**Survey Respondent Age Distribution**|**Survey Respondent Age Distribution**|**Survey Respondent Age Distribution**|
|---|---|---|
|**Age Range**|**Number of**<br>**Respondents**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|17 years or younger|0|0.0%|
|18 to 22 years|3|3.5%|
|23 to 29 years|8|9.4%|
|30 to 39 years|15|17.7%|
|40 to 49 years|21|24.7%|
|50 to 59 years|19|22.4%|
|60 to 75 years|14|16.5%|
|76 years or older|4|4.7%|
|Prefer Not to Answer|1|1.2%|



Respondents were asked to provide their ethnicity.  A total of 84 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following distribution of responses. 

|**Survey Respondent Ethnicity Distribution**|**Survey Respondent Ethnicity Distribution**|**Survey Respondent Ethnicity Distribution**|
|---|---|---|
|**Ethnicity**|**Number of**<br>**Respondents**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|American Indian/Alaskan Native|0|0.0%|
|Asian/Pacific Islander|1|1.2%|
|Black/African American|3|3.6%|
|Hispanic/Latino|3|3.6%|
|White/Caucasian|72|85.7%|
|Preferred Not to Answer|3|3.6%|
|Other|2|2.4%|



Respondents were asked to estimate the gross annual income of all residents living in their household. A total of 82 respondents provided feedback to this question with the following distribution of responses. 

**==> picture [298 x 161] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Survey Respondent Household Income Distribution<br>Number of  Share of<br>Income Range  Respondents  Respondents<br>Less than $15,000  0  0.0%<br>$15,000-$24,999  3  3.7%<br>$25,000-$39,999  2  2.4%<br>$40,000-$59,999  18  22.0%<br>$60,000-$74,999  5  6.1%<br>$75,000-$99,999  17  20.7%<br>$100,000-$149,999  16  19.5%<br>$150,000-$199,999  11  13.4%<br>$200,000 or more  6  7.3%<br>Prefer Not To Answer  4  4.9%<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-21** 

~~**Packet Pg. 297**~~
{226}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## Resident/Commuter Survey Conclusions 

Based on the feedback provided by Burke County residents and commuters, over one-half (57.7%) of respondents rated the local housing market as “Poor.”  Some of the most commonly cited issues that negatively impact the housing market include high prices or rents, the lack of rental vacancies, and the mismatch of local wages and housing costs.  Housing affordability and limited availability were cited as the top reasons that people have difficulty finding suitable housing in Burke County.  While a variety of housing options appear to be in high demand within the county, respondents rated rental housing priced between $500 and $1,000 per month and for-sale housing priced between $100,000 and $200,000 as the housing types in the highest demand.  Apartments and single-family homes (both modern, move-in ready and ranch style) were cited as top housing styles needed in the county.  Regardless, it is noteworthy that 61.1% of non-resident respondents indicated that they would be interested in relocating to Burke County if suitable housing were available. 

The following table summarizes the top responses from residents and commuters to critical questions contained within the survey. 

|**Category**<br>Overall Housing Market Rating<br>Issues Negatively Impacting the<br>Local Housing Market<br>Reasons for Difficulty Locating<br>Suitable Housing<br>Demand for Housing Types<br>Demand for Housing Styles<br>Non-Resident Interest in Relocating<br>to Burke County|**Burke County, North Carolina**<br>**Summary of Resident/Commuter Survey Results**<br>**Top Needs / Issues**<br>•<br>Good, No Issues<br>•<br>Fair, Some Issues<br>•<br>Poor, Many Issues<br>•<br>High Prices or Rents<br>•<br>Not Enough Housing/Rental Options (Few Vacancies)<br>•<br>Mismatch Between Local Jobs/Wages and Housing Costs<br>•<br>Housing Not Affordable<br>•<br>Not Enough Housing (Limited Availability)<br>•<br>Lack of Housing to Meet Specific Needs (i.e., Number of Bedrooms)<br>•<br>Lack of Down Payment or Rental Deposit<br>•<br>Rental Housing ($500-$1,000/Month)<br>•<br>For-Sale Housing ($100,000-$200,000)<br>•<br>Housing for Ages 25-40<br>•<br>Family Housing (2+ Bedrooms)<br>•<br>Senior Apartments (Independent Living)<br>•<br>Apartments<br>•<br>Modern Move-In Ready Single-Family Homes<br>•<br>Ranch Homes/Single Floor Plan Units<br>•<br>Duplex/Triplex/Townhomes<br>•<br>Yes, Interested in Relocating|**Consensus**<br>**2.4%**<br>**35.3%**<br>**57.7%**<br>**81.4%**<br>**68.6%**<br>**36.1%**<br>**83.7%**<br>**70.9%**<br>**30.2%**<br>**30.2%**<br>**92.3***<br>**91.1***<br>**87.2***<br>**86.7***<br>**67.5***<br>**83.5***<br>**80.7***<br>**80.6***<br>**70.5***<br>**61.1%**|
|---|---|---|



**Consensus** 

*Denotes weighted score 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-22** 

~~**Packet Pg. 298**~~
{227}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **E. DEVELOPER SURVEY RESULTS** 

A total of five for-profit developers participated in the housing survey with the following results.  Note that percentages may not add up to 100.0% due to rounding or because respondents were able to select more than one answer. 

Developer respondents were asked to identify their company’s primary type of development activity. Five developer respondents provided feedback with the following distribution of results. 

|**Primary Type of Development Activity**|**Primary Type of Development Activity**|**Primary Type of Development Activity**|
|---|---|---|
|**Type of Development Activity**|**Number**|**Share**|
|Residential|3|60.0%|
|Commercial|0|0.0%|
|Both Residential & Commercial|2|40.0%|
|Neither Residential nor Commercial, but We DO Have Interest in Residential Development|0|0.0%|
|Neither Residential nor Commercial, We Have No Interest in Residential Development|0|0.0%|



Developer respondents were asked about the type of residential products that they typically develop or would be interested in developing. Respondents were permitted to select more than one answer to this question. All five developer respondents provided feedback on this question with the following results. 

|**Residential Product Types Developed by Respondents**|**Residential Product Types Developed by Respondents**|**Residential Product Types Developed by Respondents**|
|---|---|---|
|**Residential Product Type**|**Number of**<br>**Respondents**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|Single-Family Homes (Detached) For-Sale|4|80.0%|
|Multifamily Rentals (Apartments)|3|60.0%|
|Mixed-Use Product with Commercial and Residential|3|60.0%|
|Condominiums (For-Sale)|2|40.0%|
|Single-Family Homes (Detached) Rentals|2|40.0%|
|Attached Townhomes/Duplex/Etc. Rentals|2|40.0%|
|Attached Townhomes/Duplex/Etc. For-Sale|1|20.0%|
|Tiny Home Communities|1|20.0%|



Developer respondents were asked what market segments their product typically involves (or that they would seek to develop). Respondents were permitted to select all applicable answers to this question. All five developer respondents provided answers to this question. A distribution of responses is listed below. 

|**Residential Market Segments Served by Respondents**|**Residential Market Segments Served by Respondents**|**Residential Market Segments Served by Respondents**|
|---|---|---|
|**Market Segment**|**Number**|**Share**|
|Higher-End Market-Rate (Incomes Between $75,000-$100,000)|5|100.0%|
|Luxury (Incomes Above $100,000)|3|60.0%|
|Moderate/Affordable (Incomes Between $50,000-$75,000)|1|20.0%|
|Mixed-Income|1|20.0%|
|Low-Income (Incomes of<$50,000)|0|0.0%|



**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-23** 

~~**Packet Pg. 299**~~
{228}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Developer respondents were asked what population their product typically serves or attracts. Respondents were permitted to select all applicable answers to this question. Four developer respondents provided answers to this question. A distribution of responses is listed below. 

**==> picture [348 x 121] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Population Served/Attracted by Housing Product<br>Number of  Share of<br>Population  Respondents  Respondents<br>Older Adults (Ages 55+)  3  75.0%<br>Millennials (Ages 25-44)  2  50.0%<br>Middle Age (Ages 45-54)  2  50.0%<br>Seniors (Ages 65+)  2  50.0%<br>No Specific Population  1  25.0%<br>Young Adults (Under Age 25)  0  0.0%<br>Special Needs Population  0  0.0%<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Developer respondents were asked what the most common barriers are for residential development in their area.  All five respondents provided feedback to this question with the following distribution. 

|**Common Barriers to Residential Development**|**Common Barriers to Residential Development**|**Common Barriers to Residential Development**|**Common Barriers to Residential Development**|
|---|---|---|---|
|**Barrier**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|**Barrier**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|Cost of Labor/Materials|80.0%|Cost of Land|40.0%|
|Financing|80.0%|Government Fees|40.0%|
|Appraisals Too Low|60.0%|Lack of Skilled Labor|40.0%|
|Cost of Infrastructure|60.0%|Local Government Regulations ("red tape")|40.0%|
|Lack of Infrastructure|60.0%|Inconsistencies Between Government Entities|20.0%|
|Land/Zoning Regulations|60.0%|Lack of Community Support|20.0%|
|Availability of Land/Lack of Buildable Sites|40.0%|Lack of Local Government Support|20.0%|



Developer respondents that selected “Financing” as a common barrier to residential development were asked to elaborate as to how financing is a barrier and how this barrier impacts them. Three developer respondents provided comments: 

- _“Volatility in the treasury markets and associated financing costs.  Deposit ratio restraints have created a much larger demand for more significant earnest money injections.”_ 

- _“The financing issues impacting our business is really a product of financing issues from our customers on custom projects.  Appraisals have been an issue on non-lakefront (interior) lots due to lack of available sales for comparison.  Higher rates are also making a negative impact.”_ 

- _“We're finding fewer banks willing to do construction loans even though we can easily overcollateralize the loans.”_ 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-24** 

~~**Packet Pg. 300**~~
{229}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Developer respondents were asked to identify incentives, initiatives, or changes that local communities should prioritize in order to encourage residential development in the areas they actively develop. Respondents could select up to three answer choices provided in the survey. All five developer respondents provided answers. A distribution of answers by developer respondents is listed in the following table. 

|**Priority of Incentives/Initiatives/Changes to Encourage Residential Development**|**Priority of Incentives/Initiatives/Changes to Encourage Residential Development**|**Priority of Incentives/Initiatives/Changes to Encourage Residential Development**|
|---|---|---|
|**Incentive/Initiative/Change**|**Number of**<br>**Respondents**|**Share of**<br>**Respondents**|
|Encourage Updates to Subdivision Regulations/Loosen Development Requirements|4|80.0%|
|Government Assistance with Infrastructure|3|60.0%|
|Revisiting/Modifying Zoning (e.g., Density, Setbacks, etc.)|3|60.0%|
|Collaboration Between Public and Private Sectors|2|40.0%|
|Encourage Accessory Dwelling Unit Opportunities|2|40.0%|
|Expedited Environmental Review Process|2|40.0%|
|Expedited/Streamlined Permitting Process|2|40.0%|
|Government Sale of Public Land/Buildings at Discount or Donated|2|40.0%|
|Support/Change Code Enforcement|2|40.0%|
|Waiving/Lowering Development Fees|2|40.0%|
|Establishment of TIF Districts (a public financing method that is used as a subsidy for<br>redevelopment, infrastructure, and other community-improvement projects)|1|20.0%|
|Inform/Educate Development Community on Local Opportunities|1|20.0%|
|Tax Abatements/Credits|1|20.0%|



Developer respondents were asked what their level of interest is in partnering with certain entities to develop residential units in the county. Four respondents provided feedback with the following distribution. 

|**Interest in Partnering with Entities to Develop Residential Units**|**Interest in Partnering with Entities to Develop Residential Units**|
|---|---|
|**Entity**|**Weighted Response***|
|Public Entity|62.5|
|Local Employer|43.8|
|Nonprofit Group|25.0|



*Significant Interest = 100.0, Minimal Interest = 25.0, No Interest = 0.0 

Developer respondents were asked if there were any lending policies or procedures that could be implemented to support residential development projects. One respondent provided relevant comments. 

- _The ability to override federal/state appraisal guidelines where they are not applicable in our region (i.e., the overvaluation of above grade square footage compared to below grade footage)_ 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-25** 

~~**Packet Pg. 301**~~
{230}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

Developer respondents were asked to provide additional input on challenges or solutions related to residential development. Two respondents provided input in the form of open-ended comments. A summary of comments is listed below: 

- _Issues related to restrictive zoning on several sites.  The size of building setbacks and required building envelopes have created issues accommodating the homeowner’s desires._ 

- _Ability to keep the home price affordable, particularly due to the high interest rates._ 

Developer Survey Conclusions 

Among the five developers that participated in the survey, the majority are either currently involved in building, or are interested in building, single-family for-sale homes, multifamily rentals, and mixed-use product (commercial and residential). All respondents noted that they either develop or seek to develop higher-end market-rate housing (for incomes between $75,000 and $100,000), and the majority either develop or seek to develop luxury housing (for incomes above $100,000). While housing developed by the respondents most commonly serves older adults (ages 55 and older), half of the respondents noted that their developments also target millennials (ages 25 to 44), middle-aged adults (ages 45-54), and seniors (ages 65 and older).  Although low appraisal amounts, the cost and lack of infrastructure, and zoning regulations were cited as common barriers to development by the majority of respondents, the most common barriers noted were the cost of labor and materials and financing.  Developer respondents believe priority should be given to updating subdivision regulations and requirements, obtaining government assistance for infrastructure development, and revisiting and/or modifying zoning regulations. While there is minimal to moderate interest in partnering with local employers and nonprofit groups, developers appear to be more interested in partnering with public entities to develop residential units. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-26** 

~~**Packet Pg. 302**~~
{231}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

The following table summarizes the top developer responses to critical questions contained within this survey. 

|**Burke County, North Carolina**<br>**Summary of Developer Survey Results**|**Burke County, North Carolina**<br>**Summary of Developer Survey Results**|**Burke County, North Carolina**<br>**Summary of Developer Survey Results**|
|---|---|---|
|**Category**|**Top Needs / Issues**|**Consensus**|
|Residential Product Types<br>Developed by Respondents|• Single-Family Homes (Detached) For-Sale<br>• Multifamily Rentals (Apartments)<br>• Mixed-Used Product with Commercial and Residential|**80.0%**<br>**60.0%**<br>**60.0%**|
|Residential Market Segments<br>Served by Respondents|• Higher-End Market-Rate (Incomes Between $75,000-$100,000)<br>• Luxury (Incomes Above $100,000)<br>• Moderate/Affordable (Incomes Between $50,000-$75,000)<br>• Mixed-Income|**100.0%**<br>**60.0%**<br>**20.0%**<br>**20.0%**|
|Population Served/Attracted by<br>Housing Product|• Older Adults (ages 55+)<br>• Millennials (Ages 25-44)<br>• Middle-Age (Ages 45-54)<br>• Seniors (ages 65+)|**75.0%**<br>**50.0%**<br>**50.0%**<br>**50.0%**|
|Common Barriers to<br>Residential Development|• Cost of Labor/Materials<br>• Financing<br>• Appraisals Too Low<br>• Cost of Infrastructure<br>• Lack of Infrastructure<br>• Land/Zoning Regulations|**80.0%**<br>**80.0%**<br>**60.0%**<br>**60.0%**<br>**60.0%**<br>**60.0%**|
|Priority of Incentives/<br>Initiatives/Changes to Encourage<br>Residential Development|• Encourage Updates to Subdivision Regulations/Development Requirements<br>• Government Assistance with Infrastructure<br>• Revisiting/Modifying Zoning (i.e., Density, Setbacks, Etc.)|**80.0%**<br>**60.0%**<br>**60.0%**|
|Interest in Partnering<br>with Entities to<br>DevelopResidential Units|• Public Entity<br>• Local Employer<br>• Nonprofit Group|**62.5***<br>**43.8***<br>**25.0***|



*Denotes weighted score 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**IX-27** 

~~**Packet Pg. 303**~~
{232}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

# ADDENDUM A: 

# FIELD SURVEY OF CONVENTIONAL RENTALS 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**A ddendum A -1** 

~~**Packet Pg. 304**~~
{233}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** 

**Packet Pg. 305**
{234}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** Survey Date: October 2023 

**==> picture [7 x 13] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [7 x 13] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [7 x 13] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [7 x 13] intentionally omitted <==**

## Map ID  — Burke County, North Carolina 

|**Map**<br>**ID**|**Property**|**Prop**<br>**Type**|**Rating**<br>**Quality**|**Built**<br>**Year**|**Total**<br>**Units**|**Vacant**|**Occ.**<br>**Rate**||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|1|AGAPE Retirement Home|GSS|B|1985|30|0|100.0%||
|2|Alpine Mill|MRR|B+|1901|58|0|100.0%||
|3|Anderson Street Apts.|MRR|C+|1971|12|0|100.0%||
|4|ARC/HDS Burke CountyGH #1|GSS|C+|1983|5|0|100.0%||
|5|ARC/HDS Burke CountyGH #3|GSS|B|1993|6|0|100.0%||
|6|Bavarian Village Apts.|MRR|B-|1973|18|0|100.0%||
|7|Bost Road Apts.|MRR|B|2002|22|0|100.0%||
|8|Cambridge I|MRR|B-|1978|7|0|100.0%||
|9|Cambridge II|MRR|C+|1978|6|0|100.0%||
|10|Cascade Gardens|GSS|C|1971|100|0|100.0%||
|11|Cedarbrook Apts.|MRR|B|1988|103|0|100.0%||
|12|CHC of Burke County#1|GSS|B-|1995|6|1|83.3%||
|13|CHC of Burke County#2|GSS|B|1998|5|1|80.0%||
|14|Drexel|GSS|C+|1985|40|0|100.0%||
|15|Forest View Apts.|MRR|B-|1966|32|1|96.9%||
|16|Glenwood Hills Apts.|TAX|B|2011|60|0|100.0%||
|17|Green Acres|GSS|B-|1988|30|0|100.0%||
|18|High Meadows Apts.|GSS|B|1986|39|0|100.0%||
|19|High Timbers Apts.|MRR|B-|1984|6|0|100.0%||
|20|Hopewell Road Apts.|MRR|B-|2016|8|0|100.0%||
|21|Huffman Street Apts.|MRR|B|1975|7|0|100.0%||
|22|Meadow Brook Apts.|TAX|B-|1995|38|0|100.0%||
|23|Millside Manor|TGS|B|2003|28|0|100.0%||
|24|Mimosa Square Apts.|MRR|B|1964|20|0|100.0%||
|25|Morgan Hills Apts.|TGS|B|1986|48|0|100.0%||
|26|Morganton TradingCompany|MRR|B|1927|43|0|100.0%||
|27|Murphy's Farm|MRR|A-|2022|240|6|97.5%||
|28|Park View Apts.|MRR|B|1968|99|4|96.0%||
|29|Pond View Apts.|TAX|B+|2020|60|0|100.0%||
|30|Providence Place I-III|GSS|C|1968|150|0|100.0%||
|31|Riverview Apts.|MRR|B|1988|100|46|54.0%||
|32|Rock Creek Apts.|MRR|B|1973|30|0|100.0%||
|33|Rutherford Square Apts.|TGS|B|1987|24|0|100.0%||
|34|Sienna Apts.|TAX|B|2016|76|0|100.0%||
|35|South Mountain Apts.|MRR|B|1995|32|0|100.0%||
|36|Southmont Apts.|GSS|B-|1987|26|0|100.0%||



**==> picture [544 x 80] intentionally omitted <==**

Addendum A- **Packet Pg. 306** 3 

Bowen National Research
{235}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b** Survey Date: October 2023 

Map ID  — Burke County, North Carolina 

**==> picture [7 x 13] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [7 x 13] intentionally omitted <==**

|**Map**<br>**ID**|**Property**|**Prop**<br>**Type**|**Rating**<br>**Quality**|**Built**<br>**Year**|**Total**<br>**Units**|**Vacant**|**Occ.**<br>**Rate**||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|37|SterlingForest|GSS|C+|1986|24|0|100.0%||
|38|Stonebridge Apts.|GSS|B-|1979|60|0|100.0%||
|39|Terrace II|MRR|C+|1978|8|0|100.0%||
|40|Union Square|MRR|B|1985|24|0|100.0%||
|41|Valdese HousingAuthority|GSS|B-|1968|121|0|100.0%||
|42|Valdese Village|TGS|B|1984|34|0|100.0%||
|43|Village Creek|GSS|B+|1983|55|0|100.0%||
|44|Willow Ridge Apts.|TAX|B|2009|28|0|100.0%||
|45|Willow Run Apts.|TAX|B-|2000|24|0|100.0%||
|46|Willows Apts.|TAX|B-|1997|36|0|100.0%||
|47|Woodbridge Apts.|MRR|B-|1974|127|0|100.0%||



**==> picture [544 x 80] intentionally omitted <==**

Addendum A- **Packet Pg. 307** 4 

Bowen National Research
{236}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b Survey Date: October 2023** 

**Properties Surveyed — Burke County, North Carolina** 

Contact: Cindy Phone: (828) 874-3463 

**==> picture [8 x 13] intentionally omitted <==**

## **AGAPE Retirement Home** 

- 1 212 Church St. NW, Valdese, NC 28690 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

|Total Units:30<br>UC:0<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>HUD Section 8<br>1<br>Senior 62+<br>None|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|1<br>14 HH|Year Built: <br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|1985|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|



|1|212 Church St. NW,Valdese,NC 28690<br>Phone:(828)874-3463<br>Contact: Cindy<br>**AGAPE Retirement Home**|212 Church St. NW,Valdese,NC 28690<br>Phone:(828)874-3463<br>Contact: Cindy<br>**AGAPE Retirement Home**|
|---|---|---|
|||Total Units:30<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>Stories:<br>1<br>Year Built:1985<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>HUD Section 8<br>1<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:14 HH<br>AR Year:<br>Senior 62+<br>Yr Renovated:<br>None|
|2|109 E. FlemingDr.,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Phone:(828)390-6151<br>Contact: Ginny<br>**Alpine Mill**||
|||Total Units:58<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>Stories:<br>2<br>Year Built:1901<br>w/Elevator<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>Rent range based on floorplan<br>1, 2<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:5 HH<br>2018<br>AR Year:<br>Family<br>Yr Renovated:<br>None|
|3|224 N. Anderson St.,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Phone:(828)438-4111<br>Contact: Emily<br>**Anderson Street Apts.**||
|||Total Units:12<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>Stories:<br>2<br>Year Built:1971<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>1, 2<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:None<br>AR Year:<br>Family<br>Yr Renovated:<br>None|
|4|101 Stephens Dr.,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Phone:(828)438-6243<br>Contact: aPRIL<br>**ARC/HDS Burke County GH #1**||
|||Total Units:5<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>Stories:<br>1<br>Year Built:1983<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>HUD Section 8; Group home, designated for mentally disabled; Shared kitchen, living room, bathrooms & laundry room<br>1<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:Kept @ Corp<br>AR Year:<br>Disabled<br>Yr Renovated:<br>None|
|5|166 VFW Rd.,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Phone:(336)273-4404<br>Contact: Scott<br>**ARC/HDS Burke County GH #3**||
|||Total Units:6<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>Stories:<br>1<br>Year Built:1993<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>HUD Section 8 & 811; Group home, designated for disabled; Shared kitchen, living room, bathrooms & laundry room<br>1<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:None<br>AR Year:<br>Disabled<br>Yr Renovated:<br>None|



**==> picture [541 x 83] intentionally omitted <==**

**Addendum A-Packet Pg. 3085** 

**Bowen National Research**
{237}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b Survey Date: October 2023** 

**Properties Surveyed — Burke County, North Carolina** 

Contact: Kristin 

## **Bavarian Village Apts.** 

- 6 

- 207 Enola Rd, Morganton, NC 28655 

|ton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:18<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>2|UC:0<br>Family|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:(828)604-6647<br>2<br>None|Year Built: <br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|1973|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|



**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

Rent Special: None Notes: 

|ganton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:22<br>UC:0<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>2, 3<br>Family<br>None|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:(828)437-5757<br>Contact: Brenda<br>2<br>None|Year Built:2002<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|



- **Bost Road Apts.** 

- 7 

   - 325-331 Bost Rd., Morganton, NC 28655 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

|nton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:7<br>UC:0<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>1-br rent range due to<br>2, 3<br>Family<br>None|Occupancy:<br>upgrades<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:(828)438-4111<br>Contact: Emily<br>2<br>None|Year Built:1978<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|



- **Cambridge I** 

- 8 

   - 201 Patton St., Morganton, NC 28655 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

|n,NC 28655<br>Total Units:6<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>2<br>None|UC:0<br>Family|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:(828)438-4111<br>Contact: Emily<br>2<br>None|Year Built:1978<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|



- **Cambridge II** 

- 9 

   - 209 Falls St., Morganton, NC 28655 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

Notes: 

|n,NC 28655<br>Total Units:100<br>UC:0<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>Public Housing<br>1, 2, 3, 4<br>Family<br>None|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:(828)437-9101<br>Contact: Jessica<br>1,2<br>12-18 mos|Year Built:1971<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|



- **Cascade Gardens** 

- 10 

   - 644 1st St., Morganton, NC 28655 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [541 x 83] intentionally omitted <==**

**Addendum A-Packet Pg. 3096** 

**Bowen National Research**
{238}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b Survey Date: October 2023** 

**Properties Surveyed — Burke County, North Carolina** 

|n,NC 28680<br>Total Units:103<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>1, 2, 3|UC:0<br>Family|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:(828)433-0288<br>Contact: Rebecca<br>2<br>None|Year Built:1988<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|



## **Cedarbrook Apts.** 

11 242 Falls St, Morganton, NC 28680 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

Rent Special: None 

Notes: 

|ganton,NC 28680<br>Total Units:6<br>UC:0<br>**ty #1**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>1<br>Disabled|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|83.3%<br>1|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:<br>Contact: Scott<br>1<br>None|Year Built:1995<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|



- **CHC of Burke County #1** 

- 12 114 W. Erwin St., Morganton, NC 28680 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

Rent Special: None 

HUD Section 8 & 811; Group home, designated for mentally disabled; Shared kitchen, living room, bathrooms &Notes: laundry room 

|13<br>14<br>15|407 N. College St.,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Phone:<br>Contact: Scott<br>Total Units:5<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>80.0%<br>Stories:<br>1<br>Year Built:1998<br>**CHC of Burke County #2**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>HUD Section 8 & 811; Group home, designated for mentally disabled; Shared kitchen, living room, bathrooms &<br>laundry room<br>1<br>1<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:None<br>AR Year:<br>Disabled<br>Yr Renovated:<br>None<br>500 North Main St,Drexel,NC 28619<br>Phone:(828)433-8430<br>Contact: Ally<br>Total Units:40<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>Stories:<br>1,2<br>Year Built:1985<br>**Drexel**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>RD 515, has RA (15 units)<br>1, 2<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:50 HH<br>AR Year:<br>Family<br>Yr Renovated:<br>None<br>401 Lenoir Rd.,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Phone:(828)433-0288<br>Contact: Rebecca<br>Total Units:32<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>96.9%<br>Stories:<br>2<br>Year Built:1966<br>**Forest View Apts.**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>Opened 10/2018, stabilized occupancy 1/2020<br>2<br>1<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:None<br>AR Year:<br>Family<br>Yr Renovated:2018<br>None|
|---|---|



**==> picture [541 x 83] intentionally omitted <==**

**Addendum A-Packet Pg. 3107** 

**Bowen National Research**
{239}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b Survey Date: October 2023** 

**Properties Surveyed — Burke County, North Carolina** 

**==> picture [8 x 13] intentionally omitted <==**

|Morganton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:60<br>UC:0<br>**ts.**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>Tax Credit<br>1, 2, 3<br>Family<br>None|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|3<br>12|Phone:(828)430-3384<br>Contact: Ken<br>HH|Year Built:2011<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|



## **Glenwood Hills Apts.** 

## 16 

1300 Burkemont Ave, Morganton, NC 28655 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

|,NC 28655<br>Total Units:30<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>1, 2|UC:0<br>Senior 62+|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|1<br>1|Phone:(828)437-9101<br>Contact: Jessica<br>year|Year Built:1988<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|



- **Green Acres** 

- 17 

N. King St., Morganton, NC 28655 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

Rent Special: None 

HUD Section 8; Square footage estimatedNotes: 

|E,Valdese,NC 28690<br>Total Units:39<br>UC:0<br>**ts.**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>RD 515, has RA (39 units)<br>1, 2<br>Family<br>None|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:(828)874-4500<br>Contact: Diane<br>1,2<br>6 HH|Year Built:1986<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|



## **High Meadows Apts.** 18 2400 Mourglea Ave. SE, Valdese, NC 28690 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

|19<br>20|1713 WesleyRd.,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:6<br>UC:0<br>**High Timbers Apts.**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>2<br>Family<br>None<br>304 Hopewell Rd.,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:8<br>UC:0<br>**Hopewell Road Apts.**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>2<br>Family<br>None|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:<br>Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0<br>100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist: <br>Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:(828)438-4111<br>Contact: Emily<br>2<br>None<br>Phone:(828)438-4111<br>Contact: Emily<br>2<br>None|Year Built:1984<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:<br>Year Built:2016<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|



**==> picture [541 x 83] intentionally omitted <==**

**Addendum A-Packet Pg. 3118** 

**Bowen National Research**
{240}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b Survey Date: October 2023** 

**Properties Surveyed — Burke County, North Carolina** 

**==> picture [8 x 13] intentionally omitted <==**

|anton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:7<br>UC:0<br>**ts.**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>1, 2, 3<br>Family<br>None|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:(828)438-4111<br>Contact: Emily<br>2<br>None|Year Built:1975<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|



## **Huffman Street Apts.** 

## 21 

310 Huffman St., Morganton, NC 28655 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

Contact: Katie 

- **Meadow Brook Apts.** 

- 22 

102 Fiddlers Ct, Morgantown, NC 28655 

Phone: (828) 432-0093 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

|Total Units:38<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>Tax Credit<br>2, 3<br>None|UC:0<br>Family|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|1<br>36 HH|Year Built:1995<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|



|anton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:28<br>UC:0<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>1, 2<br>Senior 55+<br>None|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|2<br>4|Phone:(828)439-9989<br>Contact: Brenda<br>w/Elevator<br>HH|Year Built:2003<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|



## **Millside Manor** 23 

411 E. Union St., Morganton, NC 28655 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

- Tax Credit; HUD Section 8Notes: 

|24<br>25|720 W. Union St,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:20<br>UC:7<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>**Mimosa Square Apts.**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>7 units offline for remodeling or demolition.<br>1, 2, 3<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Family<br>None<br>906 Jamestown Rd.,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:48<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>**Morgan Hills Apts.**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>Tax Credit; RD 515, has RA (46 units)<br>1, 2<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Family<br>None|Stories:<br>Waitlist: <br>Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:(828)433-0288<br>Contact: Rebecca<br>1,2,3<br>None<br>Phone:(828)584-3306<br>Contact: Cathy<br>2<br>6 HH|Year Built:1964<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:1996<br>Year Built:1986<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:2002|
|---|---|---|---|---|



**==> picture [541 x 83] intentionally omitted <==**

**Addendum A-Packet Pg. 3129** 

**Bowen National Research**
{241}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b Survey Date: October 2023** 

**Properties Surveyed — Burke County, North Carolina** 

|anton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:43<br>UC:0<br>**g Company**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>1, 2<br>Family<br>None|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:(828)433-8080<br>Contact: Megan<br>2,3<br>w/Elevator<br>10 HH|Year Built: <br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|1927<br>2006|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|



## **Morganton Trading Company** 

26 305 E. Union St., Morganton, NC 28655 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

|,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:240<br>UC:0<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>1, 2<br>Family<br>None|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|97.5%<br>6|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:(828)523-9119<br>Contact: Kailey<br>3<br>None|Year Built:2022<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|



## **Murphy's Farm** 27 142 Patrick Murphy Dr, Morganton, NC 28655 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

Rent range due to unit location; Opened 6/2022 and did not pre-lease.Notes: 

|28<br>29<br>30|504 Bethel Rd,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Phone:(828)433-8624<br>Contact: Carmen<br>Total Units:99<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>96.0%<br>Stories:<br>2<br>**Park View Apts.**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>Rent range for townhomes with washer/dryer hookup<br>2, 3<br>4<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:None<br>Family<br>None<br>304 E. Main St,Hildebran,NC 28637<br>Phone:(828)597-9361<br>Contact: Jewell<br>Total Units:60<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>Stories:<br>3<br>**Pond View Apts.**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>Tax Credit; Preleasing 10/2019, opened 1/2020, stabilized occupancy 1/2021<br>1, 2, 3<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:200 HH<br>Family<br>None<br>Carolina St.,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Phone:(828)437-9101<br>Contact: Jessica<br>Total Units:150<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>Stories:<br>1,2<br>**Providence Place I-III**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>Public Housing<br>1, 2, 3, 4, 5<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:12-18 mos<br>Family<br>None|Year Built:1968<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:2018<br>Year Built:2020<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:<br>Year Built:1968<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|



**==> picture [541 x 83] intentionally omitted <==**

**Addendum A-Packet Pg. 31310** 

**Bowen National Research**
{242}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b Survey Date: October 2023** 

**Properties Surveyed — Burke County, North Carolina** 

**==> picture [544 x 626] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Riverview Apts. Contact: Carol<br>31<br>203 River Trail, Morganton, NC 28655 Phone: (828) 433-4934<br>Total Units: 100 UC: 25 Occupancy: 54.0% Stories: 2,3 Year Built: 1988<br>BR: 2 Vacant Units: 46 Waitlist: None AR Year:<br>Target Population: Family Yr Renovated: 2023<br>Rent Special: NO<br>               55 units under renovationNotes:<br>Rock Creek Apts. Contact: Emily<br>32<br>135 Ribet Ave SW, Valdese, NC 28690 Phone: (828) 438-4111<br>Total Units: 30 UC: 0 Occupancy: 100.0% Stories: 2 Year Built: 1973<br>BR: 2 Vacant Units: 0 Waitlist: None AR Year:<br>Target Population: Family Yr Renovated: 2018<br>Rent Special: None<br>Notes:<br>Rutherford Square Apts. Contact: Julie<br>33<br>101 Spann St, Connelly Springs, NC 28612 Phone: (828) 879-2606<br>Total Units: 24 UC: 0 Occupancy: 100.0% Stories: 2 Year Built: 1987<br>BR: 1, 2 Vacant Units: 0 Waitlist: 10 HH AR Year:<br>Target Population: Family Yr Renovated: 2017<br>Rent Special: None<br>               Tax Credit; RD 515, has RA (23 units)Notes:<br>Sienna Apts. Contact: Autumn<br>34<br>607 Valdese Ave, Morganton, NC 28655 Phone: (828) 433-5396<br>Total Units: 76 UC: 0 Occupancy: 100.0% Stories: 3 Year Built: 2016<br>BR: 1, 2, 3 Vacant Units: 0 Waitlist: 80 HH AR Year:<br>Target Population: Family Yr Renovated:<br>Rent Special: None<br>               Tax CreditNotes:<br>South Mountain Apts. Contact: Jacqueline<br>35<br>4602-5830 Willow Point Dr., Morganton, NC 28655 Phone: (828) 437-5757<br>Total Units: 32 UC: 0 Occupancy: 100.0% Stories: 1 Year Built: 1995<br>BR: 2 Vacant Units: 0 Waitlist: None AR Year:<br>Target Population: Family Yr Renovated:<br>Rent Special: None<br>Notes:<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [541 x 83] intentionally omitted <==**

**Addendum A-Packet Pg. 31411** 

**Bowen National Research**
{243}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b Survey Date: October 2023** 

**Properties Surveyed — Burke County, North Carolina** 

**==> picture [8 x 13] intentionally omitted <==**

|36|408 W. Concord St.,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Phone:(828)437-2323<br>Contact: Lisa<br>**Southmont Apts.**|408 W. Concord St.,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Phone:(828)437-2323<br>Contact: Lisa<br>**Southmont Apts.**|
|---|---|---|
|||Total Units:26<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>Stories:<br>1<br>Year Built:1987<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>HUD Section 8; Square footage estimated<br>1<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:26 HH<br>AR Year:<br>Senior 62+<br>Yr Renovated:<br>None|
|37|131 SterlingForest Dr,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Phone:(828)433-8430<br>Contact: Allie<br>**Sterling Forest**||
|||Total Units:24<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>Stories:<br>1,2<br>Year Built:1986<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>RD 515, has RA (24 units)<br>1, 2<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:yes<br>AR Year:<br>Family<br>Yr Renovated:<br>None|
|38|151 Stonebridge Dr.,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Phone:(828)437-8485<br>Contact: Olivia<br>**Stonebridge Apts.**||
|||Total Units:60<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>Stories:<br>1,2<br>Year Built:1979<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>RD 515, has RA (60 units)<br>1, 2<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:48 HH<br>AR Year:<br>Family<br>Yr Renovated:<br>None|
|39|101 MulberryHills,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Phone:(828)438-4111<br>Contact: Cindy<br>**Terrace II**||
|||Total Units:8<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>Stories:<br>2<br>Year Built:1978<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>2, 3<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:None<br>AR Year:<br>Family<br>Yr Renovated:<br>None|
|40|805 W. Union St.,Morganton,NC 28655<br>Phone:(828)433-0288<br>Contact: Rebecca<br>**Union Square**||
|||Total Units:24<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>100.0%<br>Stories:<br>2<br>Year Built:1985<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>2<br>0<br>Vacant Units:<br>Waitlist:None<br>AR Year:<br>Family<br>Yr Renovated:<br>None|



**==> picture [541 x 83] intentionally omitted <==**

**Addendum A-Packet Pg. 31512** 

**Bowen National Research**
{244}------------------------------------------------
**3.2.b Survey Date: October 2023** 

**Properties Surveyed — Burke County, North Carolina** 

**==> picture [8 x 13] intentionally omitted <==**

|se,NC 28690<br>Total Units:121<br>UC:0<br>**uthority**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>Public Housing<br>1, 2, 3, 4<br>Family<br>None|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|1,2<br>120|Phone:(828)874-0098<br>Contact: Peggy<br>HH|Year Built:1968<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|



## **Valdese Housing Authority** 

- 41 

1402 Lydia Ave, Valdese, NC 28690 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

|dese,NC 28690<br>Total Units:34<br>UC:0<br>Occupancy:<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>Tax Credit; RD 515, no RA & HUD Section 8<br>2, 3<br>Vacant Units:<br>Family<br>None|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|2<br>15|Phone:(828)879-9385<br>Contact: Kay Milton<br>HH|Year Built:1984<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:2005|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|



## **Valdese Village** 

- 42 1120 Refour Ave., Valdese, NC 28690 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

|rganton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:55<br>UC:0<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>RD 515, has RA (55 units)<br>1, 2<br>Family<br>None|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:(828)438-9796<br>Contact: Janice<br>1,2<br>16 HH|Year Built:1983<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|



## **Village Creek** 43 1515 S. Sterling St, Morganton, NC 28655 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

|organton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:28<br>UC:0<br>**.**<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>Tax Credit<br>1, 2<br>Senior 55+<br>None|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|2<br>20|Phone:(828)433-6161<br>Contact: Alicia<br>w/Elevator<br>HH|Year Built:2009<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|



- **Willow Ridge Apts.** 

- 44 105 Willow Run Dr., Morganton, NC 28655 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

|organton,NC 28655<br>Total Units:24<br>UC:0<br>BR:<br>Target Population:<br>Rent Special:<br>Notes:<br>Tax Credit<br>2, 3<br>Family<br>None|Occupancy:<br>Vacant Units:|100.0%<br>0|Stories:<br>Waitlist:|Phone:(828)438-8825<br>Contact: Elizabeth<br>2<br>None|Year Built:2000<br>AR Year:<br>Yr Renovated:|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|



## **Willow Run Apts.** 

- 45 115 Willow Run Dr., Morganton, NC 28655 

**==> picture [121 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [541 x 83] intentionally omitted <==**

**Addendum A-Packet Pg. 31613** 

**Bowen National Research**
{245}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [8 x 13] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [564 x 275] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.2.b<br>Properties Surveyed — Burke County, North Carolina Survey Date: October 2023<br>Willows Apts. Contact: Alicia<br>46<br>405 Old NC 18, Morganton, NC 28655 Phone: (828) 438-3690<br>Total Units: 36 UC: 0 Occupancy: 100.0% Stories: 1 Year Built: 1997<br>BR: 1, 2 Vacant Units: 0 Waitlist: 20 HH AR Year:<br>Target Population: Senior 55+ Yr Renovated:<br>Rent Special: None<br>               Tax CreditNotes:<br>Woodbridge Apts. Contact: Brenda<br>47<br>315 Golf Course Rd., Morganton, NC 28655 Phone: (828) 437-5757<br>Total Units: 127 UC: 0 Occupancy: 100.0% Stories: 2,3 Year Built: 1974<br>BR: 2, 3 Vacant Units: 0 Waitlist: None AR Year:<br>Target Population: Family Yr Renovated:<br>Rent Special: None<br>Notes:<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [541 x 83] intentionally omitted <==**

**Bowen National Research Addendum A-Packet Pg. 31714**
{246}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

# ADDENDUM B: 

# NON-CONVENTIONAL RENTAL SURVEY 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**Addendum B-1** 

~~**Packet Pg. 318**~~
{247}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|||~~**3.2.b**~~|~~**3.2.b**~~|
|---|---|---|---|
|**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH**<br>**Addendum B-2**<br>**Address**<br>**City**<br>**Type**<br>**Price**<br>**Square**<br>**Feet**<br>**Price Per**<br>**Square Foot**<br>**Bed**<br>**Bath**<br>**Year**<br>**Built**<br>**Source**<br>200 Rodoret Street North<br>Valdese<br>Single-family<br>$2,500<br>2,100<br>$1.19<br>4<br>2<br>1929<br>Trulia<br>2510 Loretta Lane<br>Morganton<br>Single-family<br>$2,500<br>2,800<br>$0.89<br>2<br>2.5<br>-<br>Trulia<br>5111 Burkemont Road<br>Morganton<br>Single-family<br>$1,600<br>1,446<br>$1.11<br>3<br>1.5<br>1971<br>Trulia<br>409 Italy Street Southeast<br>Valdese<br>Single-family<br>$1,600<br>1,040<br>$1.54<br>2<br>2<br>1932<br>Trulia<br>130 Sunset Drive<br>Morganton<br>Single-family<br>$1,900<br>1,705<br>$1.11<br>3<br>2<br>1964<br>Trulia<br>1531 Conley Road<br>Morganton<br>Single-family<br>$1,600<br>-<br>-<br>3<br>1.5<br>1977<br>Trulia<br>4030 Buff Street<br>Hickory<br>Single-family<br>$1,700<br>2,000<br>$0.85<br>3<br>2<br>1977<br>Trulia<br>132 Pump Street<br>Morganton<br>Single-family<br>$1,850<br>1,711<br>$1.08<br>3<br>2<br>2023<br>Rent.com<br>415 Bryant Road<br>Morganton<br>Mobile Home<br>$700<br>-<br>-<br>1<br>1<br>1980<br>Rent.com<br>1952 Country Way<br>Hickory<br>Single-family<br>$1,749<br>1,603<br>$1.09<br>3<br>3.5<br>2021<br>Trulia<br>415 Bryant Road<br>Morganton<br>Mobile Home<br>$700<br>-<br>-<br>2<br>1<br>1980<br>Rent.com<br>465 Bryant Road<br>Morganton<br>Mobile Home<br>$800<br>-<br>2<br>1<br>1969<br>Rent.com<br>300 Church Street NW<br>Valdese<br>Apartment<br>$900<br>600<br>$1.50<br>1<br>1<br>-<br>Rent.com<br>505 East Main Street<br>Morganton<br>Duplex<br>$850<br>-<br>-<br>2<br>1<br>-<br>Rentals.com<br>2358 Burke Memorial Park Road<br>Valdese<br>Apartment<br>$800<br>675<br>$1.19<br>2<br>1<br>1968<br>Rentals.com<br>300 Church Street NW<br>Morganton<br>Apartment<br>$800<br>425<br>$1.88<br>1<br>1<br>1900<br>Rent.com<br>1185 Carlisle Lane<br>Morganton<br>Apartment<br>$1,000<br>900<br>$1.11<br>2<br>1<br>2006<br>Rentals.com<br>1754 Zion Road<br>Morganton<br>Mobile Home<br>$1,000<br>-<br>-<br>3<br>2<br>1990<br>Rentals.com<br>301 Pitts Street<br>Morganton<br>Single-family<br>$1,300<br>900<br>$1.44<br>2<br>2<br>-<br>Rentals.com<br>6943 Rhodhiss Road<br>Connelly Springs<br>Apartment<br>$1,050<br>1,600<br>$0.66<br>3<br>1<br>1980<br>Rentals.com<br>1965 Cape Hickory Cutoff Road<br>Hickory<br>Duplex<br>$1,525<br>1,312<br>$1.16<br>3<br>2.5<br>-<br>Rentals.com<br>2696 West View Street<br>Hickory<br>Duplex<br>$1,300<br>740<br>$1.76<br>2<br>1<br>-<br>Rentals.com<br>3559 Hartland Road<br>Morganton<br>Single-family<br>$800<br>1,360<br>$0.59<br>2<br>2<br>1951<br>Apartments.com<br>315 Oakland Avenue<br>Morganton<br>Apartment<br>$950<br>800<br>$1.19<br>2<br>1<br>1977<br>Apartments.com<br>717 Amherst Road<br>Morganton<br>Apartment<br>$500<br>924<br>$0.54<br>2<br>2<br>2015<br>Realtor.com<br>502 North Terrace Place<br>Morganton<br>Single-family<br>$2,500<br>2,000<br>$1.25<br>3<br>2<br>1988<br>Trulia<br>~~**..**~~<br> <br>||~~**..**~~||
||||**Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR -**|
|||||
|||||



**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**Addendum B-2** 

~~**Packet Pg. 319**~~
{248}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|**Address**|**City**|**Type**|**Price**|**Square**<br>**Feet**|**Price Per**<br>**Square Foot**|**Bed**|**Bath**|**Year**<br>**Built**|**Source**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|317 Randolph Street|Morganton|Single-family|$1,400|1,191|$1.18|2|2|1922|Trulia|
|200 Williams Street|Morganton|Single-family|$1,800|1,258|$1.43|3|2|-|Trulia|
|132 Air Park Drive|Morganton|Mobile Home|$1,500|1,600|$0.94|3|2|1997|Trulia|
|106 Woodside Street|Morganton|Single-family|$2,100|2,700|$0.78|4|3|1966|Trulia|
|434 North Green Street|Morganton|Single-family|$1,800|1,600|$1.13|3|3|1951|Trulia|
|268 Asheville Street|Morganton|Single-family|$1,200|672|$1.79|2|1|-|Rent.com|
|109 Herron Street|Morganton|Apartment|$800|-|-|1|1|1907|Rentals.com|
|108 East Catawba Street|Morganton|Apartment|$2,200|1,200|$1.83|3|2|1939|Rentals.com|



## **BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**Addendum B-3** 

~~**Packet Pg. 320**~~
{249}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

ADDENDUM C: 

# SENIOR CARE HOUSING SURVEY 

**Addendum C-1** 

~~**Packet Pg. 321**~~
{250}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

|**Assisted Living**|**Assisted Living**|**Assisted Living**|**Assisted Living**|**Assisted Living**|**Assisted Living**|**Assisted Living**|**Assisted Living**|**Assisted Living**|**Assisted Living**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Map**<br>**ID**|**Facility Name**|**Address**|**City**|**Year Built/**<br>**Renovated**|**Licensed**<br>**Beds**|**Marketed**<br>**Beds**|**Vacant**<br>**Beds**|**Occ.**<br>**Rate**|**Base Monthly Rates**|
|A-1|Autumn Care of Drexel|307 Oakland Ave.|Morganton|Est. 1960|20|20|1|95.0%|$5,596|
|A-2|Berkeley|330 Juniper Street|Morganton|2019|63|63|20|68.3%|$3,590 to $4,370|
|A-3|Burke Long Term Care|125 Camellia<br>Garden Street|Morganton|Est. 1980|24|24|0|100.0%|$2,500|
|A-4|Grace Ridge|500 Lenoir Rd.|Morganton|Est. 1980|35|35|18|48.6%|$5,627|
|A-5|Jonas Ridge Adult Care|9051 Hwy 181|Jonas<br>Ridge|1978|57|57|14|75.4%|Semi-Private $3,345<br>Private $4,525<br>Private w/bath $5,000|
|A-6|McAlpine Adult Care|3806 Kathy Road|Morganton|1994|60|60|3|95.0%|$3,000|
|A-7|Morganton Long Term Care,<br>SouthviewFacility|151 Southview<br>Street|Morganton|1995|64|64|40|37.5%|Semi-Private $3,200<br>Private $5,600|



Est. – Estimated 

|**Nursing Care**|**Nursing Care**|**Nursing Care**|**Nursing Care**|**Nursing Care**|**Nursing Care**|**Nursing Care**|**Nursing Care**|**Nursing Care**|**Nursing Care**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**Map**<br>**ID**|**Facility Name**|**Address**|**City**|**Year Built/**<br>**Renovated**|**Licensed**<br>**Beds**|**Marketed**<br>**Beds**|**Vacant**<br>**Beds**|**Occ.**<br>**Rate**|**Base Monthly Rates**|
|N-1|Autumn Care of Drexel|307 Oakland Ave.|Morganton|Est. 1960|100|100|4|96.0%|Semi-Private $6,874<br>Private $6,965|
|N-2|College Pines Health and<br>Rehabilitation|95 Locust Street|Connelly<br>Springs|Est. 2019|100|100|6|94.0%|Semi-Private $7,452<br>Private $8,060|
|N-3|Carolina Rehab Center of Burke|3647 Miller Bridge<br>Road|Connelly<br>Springs|2003|90|90|4|95.6%|Semi-Private $13,444<br>Private $15,482|
|N-4|Grace Heights Health &<br>Rehabilitation|109 Foothills Drive|Morganton|1970|120|106|0|100.0%|Semi-Private $7,452<br>Private $8,364|
|N-5|Grace Ridge|500 Lenoir Rd.|Morganton|1980|25|25|4|84.0%|$10,950|
|N-6|Magnolia Lane Nursing and<br>Rehabilitation Center|107 Magnolia Drive|Morganton|1960|121|90|37|58.9%|$7,908-$8,364|



Est. – Estimated 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**Addendum C-2** 

~~**Packet Pg. 322**~~
{251}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **ADDENDUM D: QUALIFICATIONS** 

## **The Company** 

Bowen National Research employs an expert staff to ensure that each market study includes the highest standards. Each staff member has hands-on experience evaluating sites and comparable properties, analyzing market characteristics and trends, and providing realistic recommendations and conclusions. The Bowen National Research staff has national experience and knowledge to assist in evaluating a variety of product types and markets. 

## **Primary Contact and Report Author** 

**==> picture [178 x 183] intentionally omitted <==**

**Patrick Bowen** , President of Bowen National Research, has conducted numerous housing needs assessments and provided consulting services to city, county and state development entities as it relates to residential development, including affordable and market-rate housing, for both rental and for-sale housing, and retail development opportunities. He has also prepared and supervised thousands of market feasibility studies for all types of real estate products, including housing, retail, office, industrial and mixed-use developments, since 1996. Mr. Bowen has worked closely with 

many state and federal housing agencies to assist 

them with their market study guidelines. Mr. Bowen has his bachelor’s degree in legal administration (with emphasis on business and law) from the University of West Florida and currently serves as Vice Chair and Trustee of the National Council of Housing Market Analysts (NCHMA). 

|**Housing Needs Assessment Experience**|**Housing Needs Assessment Experience**|**Housing Needs Assessment Experience**|
|---|---|---|
|**Location**|**Client**|**Completion**<br>**Year**|
|Dublin, GA|Cityof Dublin PurchasingDepartments|2018|
|Evansville, IN|Cityof Evansville,IN - Department of Metropolitan Development|2018|
|Beaufort County, SC|Beaufort County|2018|
|Burke County, NC|Burke CountyBoard of REALTORS|2018|
|Ottawa County, MI|HOUSING NEXT|2018|
|Bowling Green, KY|Cityof BowlingGreen Kentucky|2019|
|Evansville, IN|Cityof Evansville,IN - Department of Metropolitan Development|2019|
|Zanesville, OH|Cityof Zanesville Department of CommunityDevelopment|2019|
|Buncombe County, NC|Cityof Asheville Communityand Economic Development Department|2019|
|Cleveland County, NC|Cleveland CountyGovernment|2019|
|Frankstown Twp., PA|Woda Cooper Companies,Inc.|2019|
|Taylor County, WV|Taylor CountyDevelopment Authority|2019|
|Lac Courte Oreilles Reservation, WI|Lac Courte Oreilles Ojibwa CommunityCollege|2019|
|Owensboro, KY|Cityof Owensboro|2019|
|Asheville, NC|Cityof Asheville Communityand Economic Development Department|2020|



**Addendum D- 1** ~~**Packet Pg. 323**~~ 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH**
{252}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

(continued) 

|||~~**3.2.b**~~|~~**3.2.b**~~|
|---|---|---|---|
|**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH**<br>**Addendum D-2**<br>(continued)<br>**Housing Needs Assessment Experience**<br>**Location**<br>**Client**<br>**Completion**<br>**Year**<br>Evansville, IN<br>Cityof Evansville,IN - Department of Metropolitan Development<br>2020<br>Youngstown, OH<br>Youngstown Neighborhood Development Corporation(YNDC)<br>2020<br>Richlands, VA<br>Town of Richlands,Virginia<br>2020<br>Elkin, NC<br>Elkin Economic Development Department<br>2020<br>Grand Rapids, MI<br>Grand Rapids Area Chamber of Commerce<br>2020<br>Morgantown, WV<br>Cityof Morgantown<br>2020<br>Erwin, TN<br>Unicoi CountyEconomic Development Board<br>2020<br>Ferrum, VA<br>Countyof Franklin(Virginia)<br>2020<br>Charleston, WV<br>Charleston Area Alliance<br>2020<br>Wilkes County, NC<br>Wilkes Economic Development Corporation<br>2020<br>Oxford, OH<br>Cityof Oxford - CommunityDevelopment Department<br>2020<br>New Hanover County, NC<br>New Hanover CountyFinance Department<br>2020<br>Ann Arbor, MI<br>Smith Group,Inc.<br>2020<br>Austin, IN<br>Austin Redevelopment Commission<br>2020<br>Evansville, IN<br>Cityof Evansville,IN - Department of Metropolitan Development<br>2021<br>Giddings, TX<br>Giddings Economic Development Corporation<br>2021<br>Georgetown County, SC<br>Georgetown County<br>2021<br>Western North Carolina (18 Counties)<br>Dogwood Health Trust<br>2021<br>Carteret County, NC<br>Carteret CountyEconomic Development Foundation<br>2021<br>Ottawa County, MI<br>HOUSING NEXT<br>2021<br>Dayton, OH<br>Miami ValleyNonprofit HousingCollaborative<br>2021<br>High Country, NC (4 Counties)<br>NC REALTORS<br>2022<br>Evansville, IN<br>City of Evansville, IN-Department of Metropolitan Development<br>2022<br>Barren County, KY<br>The Barren CountyEconomic Authority<br>2022<br>Kirksville, MO<br>Cityof Kirksville<br>2022<br>Rutherfordton, NC<br>Town of Rutherfordton<br>2022<br>Spindale, NC<br>Town of Spindale<br>2022<br>Wood County, WV<br>Wood County Development Authority & Parkersburg-Wood County<br>Area Development Corporation<br>2022<br>YanceyCounty,NC<br>YanceyCounty<br>2022<br>Cherokee County,NC<br>Economic and Workforce Development,Tri-CountyCommunityCollege<br>2022<br>Rowan County,KY<br>Morehead-Rowan CountyEconomic Development Council<br>2022<br>AveryCounty,NC<br>AveryCounty<br>2022<br>Muskegon,MI<br>Cityof Muskegon<br>2023<br>Firelands Region,OH<br>Firelands Forward<br>2023<br>Marshall County,WV<br>Marshall CountyCommission<br>2023<br>Lebanon County,PA<br>Lebanon CountyCoalition to End Homelessness<br>2023<br>Northern,MI<br>HousingNorth<br>2023<br>Muskegon County,MI<br>CommunityFoundation for Muskegon County<br>2023<br>Mason County,MI<br>Mason CountyChamber Alliance<br>2023<br>Oceana County,MI<br>Dogwood CommunityDevelopment<br>2023<br>Allegan County,MI<br>Allegan CountyCommunityFoundation<br>2023<br>BowlingGreen,KY<br>Cityof BowlingGreen<br>2023<br>Fayette County,PA<br>Fay-Penn Economic Development Council<br>2023<br>Tarboro,NC<br>Town of Tarboro<br>2023<br>Southwest Region,WV(10 Counties)<br>Advantage Valley<br>2023<br>Lake County,MI<br>FiveCAP,Inc.<br>2023<br>Owensboro,KY<br>Cityof Owensboro<br>2023<br>~~**..**~~<br> <br>||~~**..**~~||
||||**Attachment: Burke County, NC 23-358 (Housing Needs Assessment) - Revised 2-7-24  (4307 : BNR - Bowen National Research Housing Study)**|
|||||
|||||



**Addendum D- 2** ~~**Packet Pg. 324**~~ 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH**
{253}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **The following individuals provided research and analysis assistance:** 

**Craig Rupert** , Market Analyst, has conducted more than 1,000 market feasibility studies throughout the United States since 2010, within both urban and rural markets as well as on various tribal reservations. Mr. Rupert has prepared market studies for numerous types of housing including market-rate, Tax Credit, and various government-subsidized rental product, for-sale product, senior living (assisted living, nursing care, etc.), as well as market studies for retail/commercial space. Market studies prepared by Mr. Rupert have been used for submittal as part of state finance agency Tax Credit and HUD 221 (d)(4) applications, as well as various other financing applications submitted to local, regional, and national-level lenders/financial institutions.  Mr. Rupert has a bachelor’s degree in Hospitality Management from Youngstown State University. 

**Christopher Bunch** , Market Analyst, has more than a decade of experience in conducting both site-specific market feasibility studies and broader housing needs assessments. He has conducted on-site market research of a variety of housing product, conducted stakeholder interviews and completed specialized research on housing market attributes including the impact of military personnel, heirs and estates and other unique factors that impact housing needs. 

**Desireé Johnson** is the Director of Operations for Bowen National Research. Ms. Johnson is responsible for all client relations, the procurement of work contracts, and the overall supervision and day-to-day operations of the company. Ms. Johnson also coordinates and oversees research staff and activities. She has been involved in the real estate market research industry since 2006. Ms. Johnson has an Associate of Applied Science in Office Administration from Columbus State Community College. 

**Pat McDavid,** Research Specialist, has conducted housing research for housing needs assessments completed throughout the country. Additionally, he is experienced in analyzing demographic and economic data in rural, suburban and metropolitan communities. Mr. McDavid has been a part of the development of market strategies, operational and fiscal performance analysis, and commercial, industrial and government (local, state, and federal) client consultation within the construction and manufacturing industries. He holds a bachelor’s degree in Secondary Earth Science from Western Governors University. 

**Jody LaCava** , Research Specialist, has nearly a decade of real estate research experience. She has extensive experience in surveying a variety of housing alternatives, including rental, for-sale, and senior housing.  She has experience in conducting on-site research of real estate, evaluating existing housing properties, conducting interviews, and evaluating community services.  She has been involved in industry leading case studies, door-to-door resident surveys and special needs housing research. 

**Addendum D- 3** ~~**Packet Pg. 325**~~ 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH**
{254}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

**In-House Researchers** – Bowen National Research employs a staff of in-house researchers who are experienced in the surveying and evaluation of all rental and for-sale housing types, as well as in conducting interviews and surveys with city officials, economic development offices and chambers of commerce, housing authorities and residents. 

_**No subconsultants were used as part of this assessment.**_ 

**Addendum D- 4** ~~**Packet Pg. 326**~~ 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH**
{255}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

## **ADDENDUM E:  GLOSSARY** 

Various key terms associated with issues and topics evaluated in this report are used throughout this document.  The following provides a summary of the definitions for these key terms.  It is important to note that the definitions cited below include the source of the definition, when applicable. Those definitions that were not cited originated from the National Council of Housing Market Analysts (NCHMA). 

_**Area Median Household Income (AMHI)**_ is the median income for families in metropolitan and non-metropolitan areas, used to calculate income limits for eligibility in a variety of housing programs. HUD estimates the median family income for an area in the current year and adjusts that amount for different family sizes so that family incomes may be expressed as a percentage of the area median income. For example, a family's income may equal 80% of the area median income, a common maximum income level for participation in HUD programs. (Bowen National Research, Various Sources) 

_**Available rental housing**_ is any rental product that is currently available for rent.  This includes any units identified through Bowen National Research survey of affordable rental properties identified in the study areas, published listings of available rentals, and rentals disclosed by local realtors or management companies. 

_**Basic Rent**_ is the minimum monthly rent that tenants who do not have rental assistance pay to lease units developed through the USDA-RD Section 515 Program, the HUD Section 236 Program and the HUD Section 223 (d) (3) Below Market Interest Rate Program. The Basic Rent is calculated as the amount of rent required to operate the property, maintain debt service on a subsidized mortgage with a below-market interest rate, and provide a return on equity to the developer in accordance with the regulatory documents governing the property. 

_**Contract Rent**_ is (1) the actual monthly rent payable by the tenant, including any rent subsidy paid on behalf of the tenant, to the owner, inclusive of all terms of the lease (HUD & RD) or (2) the monthly rent agreed to between a tenant and a landlord (Census). 

_**Cost overburdened households**_ are households that pay more than 30% or 35% (depending upon source) of their annual household income toward housing costs. Typically, such households will choose a comparable property (including new affordable housing product) if it is less of a cost burden. 

_**Elderly Person**_ is a person who is at least 62 years of age as defined by HUD. 

_**Elderly or Senior Housing**_ is housing where (1) all the units in the property are restricted for occupancy by persons 62 years of age or older or (2) at least 80% of the units in each building are restricted for occupancy by households where at least one household member is 55 years of age or older and the housing is designed with amenities and facilities designed to meet the needs of senior citizens. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**Addendum E-1** 

~~**Packet Pg. 327**~~
{256}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

_**Extremely low-income**_ is a person or household with income below 30% of Area Median Income adjusted for household size. 

_**Fair Market Rent (FMR)**_ are the estimates established by HUD of the gross rents (contract rent plus tenant paid utilities) needed to obtain modest rental units in acceptable condition in a specific county or metropolitan statistical area. HUD generally sets FMR so that 40% of the rental units have rents below the FMR. In rental markets with a shortage of lower priced rental units HUD may approve the use of Fair Market Rents that are as high as the 50[th] percentile of rents. 

_**Frail Elderly**_ is a person who is at least 62 years of age and is unable to perform at least three “activities of daily living” comprising of eating, bathing, grooming, dressing or home management activities as defined by HUD. 

_**Garden apartments**_ are apartments in low-rise buildings (typically two to four stories) that feature low density, ample open space around buildings, and on-site parking. 

_**Gross Rent**_ is the monthly housing cost to a tenant which equals the Contract Rent provided for in the lease plus the estimated cost of all tenant paid utilities. 

_**Household**_ is one or more people who occupy a housing unit as their usual place of residence. 

_**Housing Choice Voucher (Section 8 Program)**_ is a federal rent subsidy program under Section 8 of the U.S. Housing Act, which issues rent vouchers to eligible households to use in the housing of their choice. The voucher payment subsidizes the difference between the Gross Rent and the tenant’s contribution of 30% of adjusted gross income, (or 10% of gross income, whichever is greater). In cases where 30% of the tenant’s income is less than the utility allowance, the tenant will receive an assistance payment. In other cases, the tenant is responsible for paying his share of the rent each month. 

_**Housing unit**_ is a house, apartment, mobile home, or group of rooms used as a separate living quarters by a single household. 

_**HUD Section 8 Program**_ is a federal program that provides project based rental assistance. Under the program HUD contracts directly with the owner for the payment of the difference between the Contract Rent and a specified percentage of tenants’ adjusted income. 

_**HUD Section 202 Program**_ is a federal program, which provides direct capital assistance (i.e., grant) and operating or rental assistance to finance housing designed for occupancy by elderly households who have income not exceeding 50% of the Area Median Income. The program is limited to housing owned by 501(c)(3) nonprofit organizations or by limited partnerships where the sole general partner is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization. Units receive HUD project based rental assistance that enables tenants to occupy units at rents based on 30% of tenant income. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**Addendum E-2** 

~~**Packet Pg. 328**~~
{257}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

_**HUD Section 236 Program**_ is a federal program which provides interest reduction payments for loans which finance housing targeted to households with income not exceeding 80% of Area Median Income who pay rent equal to the greater of Basic Rent or 30% of their adjusted income. All rents are capped at a HUD approved market rent. 

_**HUD Section 811 Program**_ is a federal program, which provides direct capital assistance and operating or rental assistance to finance housing designed for occupancy by persons with disabilities who have income not exceeding 50% of Area Median Income. The program is limited to housing owned by 501(c)(3) nonprofit organizations or by limited partnerships where the sole general partner is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization. 

_**Income Limits**_ are the Maximum Household Income by county or Metropolitan Statistical Area, adjusted for household size and expressed as a percentage of the Area Median Income (AMI) for the purpose of establishing an upper limit for eligibility for a specific housing program. Income Limits for federal, state and local rental housing programs typically are established at 30%, 50%, 60% or 80% of AMI. 

_**Low-Income Household**_ is a person or household with gross household income between 50% and 80% of Area Median Income adjusted for household size. 

_**Low-Income Housing Tax Credit**_ is a program to generate equity for investment in affordable rental housing authorized pursuant to Section 42 of the Internal Revenue Code, as amended. The program requires that a certain percentage of units built be restricted for occupancy to households earning 80% or less of Area Median Income, and that the rents on these units be restricted accordingly. 

_**Market vacancy rate (physical)**_ is the average number of apartment units in any market which are unoccupied divided by the total number of apartment units in the same market, excluding units in properties which are in the lease-up stage.  Bowen National Research considers only these vacant units in its rental housing survey. 

_**Mixed income property**_ is an apartment property containing (1) both income restricted and unrestricted units or (2) units restricted at two or more income limits (i.e., low-income Tax Credit property with income limits of 30%, 50% and 60%). 

_**Moderate Income**_ is a person or household with gross household income between 40% and 60% of Area Median Income adjusted for household size. 

_**Multifamily**_ are structures that contain more than two housing units. 

_**New owner-occupied household growth**_ within a market is a primary demand component for new for-sale housing. For the purposes of this analysis, we have evaluated growth between 2023 and 2028. The 2023 households by income level are based on ESRI estimates that account for 2020 Census counts of total households for each study area.  The 2023and 2028 estimates are also based on growth projections by income level by ESRI. The difference between the two household estimates represents the new owner-occupied households that are projected to be added to a study area between 2023 and 2028. These estimates of growth are provided by each income level and corresponding price point that can be afforded. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**Addendum E-3** 

~~**Packet Pg. 329**~~
{258}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

_**Non-Conventional Rentals**_ are structures with four or fewer rental units. 

_**Overcrowded housing**_ is often considered housing units with 1.01 or more persons per room. These units are often occupied by multi-generational families or large families that are in need of more appropriately sized and affordable housing units.  For the purposes of this analysis, we have used the share of overcrowded housing from the American Community Survey. 

_**Pipeline housing**_ is housing that is currently under construction or is planned or proposed for development.  We identified pipeline housing during our telephone interviews with local and county planning departments and through a review of published listings from housing finance entities such as NCHFA, HUD and USDA **.** 

_**Population trends**_ are changes in population levels for a particular area over a specific period of time which is a function of the level of births, deaths, and net migration. 

_**Potential support**_ is the equivalent to the _housing gap_ referenced in this report.  The _housing gap_ is the total demand from eligible households that live in certain housing conditions (described in Section VIII of this report) less the available or planned housing stock that was inventoried within each study area. 

_**Project-based rent assistance**_ is rental assistance from any source that is allocated to the property or a specific number of units in the property and is available to each income eligible tenant of the property or an assisted unit. 

_**Public Housing or Low-Income Conventional Public Housing**_ is a HUD program administered by local (or regional) Housing Authorities which serves Low- and Very LowIncome households with rent based on the same formula used for HUD Section 8 assistance. 

_**Rent burden**_ is gross rent divided by adjusted monthly household income. 

_**Rent burdened households**_ are households with rent burden above the level determined by the lender, investor, or public program to be an acceptable rent-to-income ratio. 

_**Replacement of functionally obsolete housing**_ is a demand consideration in most established markets. Given the limited development of new housing units in the study area, homebuyers are often limited to choosing from the established housing stock, much of which is considered old and/or often in disrepair and/or functionally obsolete.  There are a variety of ways to measure functionally obsolete housing and to determine the number of units that should be replaced.  For the purposes of this analysis, we have applied the highest share of any of the following three metrics: cost burdened households, units lacking complete plumbing facilities, and overcrowded units.  This resulting housing replacement ratio is then applied to the existing (2023) owner-occupied housing stock to estimate the number of for-sale units that should be replaced in the study areas. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**Addendum E-4** 

~~**Packet Pg. 330**~~
{259}------------------------------------------------
~~**3.2.b**~~ 

_**Restricted rent**_ is the rent charged under the restrictions of a specific housing program or subsidy. 

_**Single-Family Housing**_ is a dwelling unit, either attached or detached, designed for use by one household and with direct access to a street. It does not share heating facilities or other essential building facilities with any other dwelling. 

_**Standard Condition:**_ A housing unit that meets HUD’s Section 8 Housing Quality Standards. 

_**Subsidized Housing**_ is housing that operates with a government subsidy often requiring tenants to pay up to 30% of their adjusted gross income toward rent and often limiting eligibility to households with incomes of up to 50% or 80% of the Area Median Household Income. (Bowen National Research) 

_**Subsidy**_ is monthly income received by a tenant or by an owner on behalf of a tenant to pay the difference between the apartment’s contract rent and the amount paid by the tenant toward rent. 

_**Substandard**_ housing is typically considered product that lacks complete indoor plumbing facilities.  Such housing is often considered to be of such poor quality and in disrepair that it should be replaced. For the purposes of this analysis, we have used the share of households living in substandard housing from the American Community Survey. 

_**Substandard conditions**_ are housing conditions that are conventionally considered unacceptable which may be defined in terms of lacking plumbing facilities, one or more major systems not functioning properly, or overcrowded conditions. 

_**Tenant**_ is one who rents real property from another. 

_**Tenant paid utilities**_ are the cost of utilities (not including cable, telephone, or internet) necessary for the habitation of a dwelling unit, which are paid by the tenant. 

_**Tenure**_ is the distinction between owner-occupied and renter-occupied housing units. 

_**Townhouse (or Row House)**_ is a single-family attached residence separated from another by party walls, usually on a narrow lot offering small front and back-yards; also called a row house. 

_**Vacancy Rate – Economic Vacancy Rate (physical)**_ is the maximum potential revenue less actual rent revenue divided by maximum potential rent revenue. The number of total habitable units that are vacant divided by the total number of units in the property. 

_**Very Low-Income Household**_ is a person or household with gross household income between 30% and 50% of Area Median Income adjusted for household size. 

_**Windshield Survey**_ references an on-site observation of a physical property or area that considers only the perspective viewed from the “windshield” of a vehicle.  Such a survey does not include interior inspections or evaluations of physical structures. 

**BOWEN NATIONAL RESEARCH** 

**Addendum E-5** 

~~**Packet Pg. 331**~~
