{0}------------------------------------------------
**3.5.b** 

**==> picture [112 x 30] intentionally omitted <==**

# Classification and Compensation Study 

**==> picture [104 x 104] intentionally omitted <==**

 Project Timeline and Methodology  Project Results  Internal Equity = Job Evaluation  External Equity = Market Study  Pay Plan Development  Recommendations 

**Packet Pg. 424**
{1}------------------------------------------------
**3.5.b** 

## **July Start** 

## Project Timeline 

**==> picture [609 x 290] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
July - September- December- February-<br>August November January March<br>Job Descriptions<br>Market Assessment Pay Plan<br>Development<br>Data Collection + Project Completion<br>Implementation<br>Position Review Calculations<br>FLSA Review Pay Policies<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [196 x 281] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

2 

**Packet Pg. 425**
{2}------------------------------------------------
**3.5.b** 

## **M ethodology** Project Overview 

## **COMPLETE** 

- **Data Collection** : project planning meetings to discuss goals for the study and current challenges experienced by existing classification and compensation plan, data collected from the County. 

- **Position Review** : Position Analysis Questionnaires (PAQ) used to review titles and make recommendations for changes, as necessary, SAFE job evaluation conducted to establish internal equity. 

- **Market Assessment** : collection of base pay and benefits information from peer organizations. 

- **Pay Plan Development** : pay plan development, grade assignments, and implementation calculations. 

## **IN PROGRESS** 

- **Project Completion** : final report, Board presentation, project documentation delivery, and training for staff. 

**==> picture [14 x 434] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Attachment: Burke Co. Final Presentation-  BOCC - Draft PPT Pay Class  (4309 : CM - Pay &<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **Data Collection** 

**==> picture [38 x 32] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [38 x 31] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [104 x 104] intentionally omitted <==**

**Project Completion** 

**Position Review** 

**Pay Plan Development** 

**Market Assessment** 

**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

3 

**Packet Pg. 426**
{3}------------------------------------------------
**3.5.b** 

## **M ethodology** Project Overview 

## **Project Initiation** 

• Planning meetings with County project team (Manager, Finance, HR) to establish goals and working relationships 

## • Data collection 

   - Pay structures 

   - Policy handbook 

   - Job descriptions 

   - Organization charts 

   - Union or collective bargaining contracts 

   - Census file (names, salaries, hire dates, etc.) 

- Leadership and Employee presentations 

   - Onsite presentations and 1:1 with Department heads (July 2023) 

- Position Analysis Questionnaires (PAQs) to be completed for all position titles included in the study. 

   - The PAQ is an online questionnaire distributed to all employees and routed directly to supervisors for review upon submission. 

**==> picture [14 x 434] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Attachment: Burke Co. Final Presentation-  BOCC - Draft PPT Pay Class  (4309 : CM - Pay &<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Project Initiation** 

**==> picture [38 x 32] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [38 x 31] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [104 x 104] intentionally omitted <==**

**Project Completion** 

**==> picture [60 x 36] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Position<br>Review<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [109 x 71] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Pay Plan<br>Development<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Market Assessment** 

**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

4 

**Packet Pg. 427**
{4}------------------------------------------------
## **M ethodology** Project Overview 

## **Position Review** 

- Using PAQs, we reviewed titles and will make recommendations for adjustments, as necessary 

- We conducted job evaluation using our point factor tool, called SAFE®. This process will establish a hierarchy of jobs within the County that is reflective of internal equity. 

   - _This is a measurement of the position, NOT the person in the position._ 

## • The 9 compensable factors: 

||1.<br>2.<br>3.<br>4.<br>5.|Education<br>Experience<br>Level of Work<br>Human Interaction<br>Physical Demands|6.<br>7.<br>8.<br>9.|Working Conditions<br>Independence of Actions<br>Impact on the Organization<br>Supervision Exercised||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|



- Additionally, we reviewed exempt/non-exempt designations for each position based on guidelines within the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). 

**==> picture [368 x 425] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.5.b<br>Project<br>Initiation<br>Project  Position<br>Completion Review<br>Pay Plan  Market<br>Development Assessment<br>Attachment: Burke Co. Final Presentation-  BOCC - Draft PPT Pay Class  (4309 : CM - Pay &<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [14 x 434] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Attachment: Burke Co. Final Presentation-  BOCC - Draft PPT Pay Class  (4309 : CM - Pay &<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

5 

**Packet Pg. 428**
{5}------------------------------------------------
## **M ethodology** Project Overview 

## **Market Assessment** 

- We partnered with the County to identify comparable and competitive peer organizations to include in the study. These are organizations that look like you and work like you relative to size (revenue, population served, or number of employees), service offerings, geography, growth, etc. Published salary survey data will be incorporated as a private sector comparison. 

   - Started by asking Department Heads to cultivate a list of peer organizations, final list was discussed and approved by ELT. 

- A summary of work + minimum qualifications will be included for each benchmark position to assist peers in providing an appropriate match. 

- Some adjustments were made to collected data to account for differences in work week, fiscal year, and geographic labor cost. _We do not weight the data._ 

- Results were analyzed for quality control; reports demonstrating market averages and a comparison to the market will be prepared for your review. 

**==> picture [55 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.5.b<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [375 x 442] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Project<br>Initiation<br>Project  Position<br>Completion Review<br>Pay Plan  Market<br>Development Assessment<br>Attachment: Burke Co. Final Presentation-  BOCC - Draft PPT Pay Class  (4309 : CM - Pay &<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

6 

**Packet Pg. 429**
{6}------------------------------------------------
**3.5.b** 

Market Assessment: Peer Organizations • The County identified 14 public peer organizations to be included in the study • Data was collected or compiled from 14 of those, **shown in bold below** . • Data from 3 published surveys included to represent the “private sector” 

**1. Buncombe County 2. Caldwell County 3. Catawba County 4. Cleveland County 5. Henderson County 6. Hickory, NC 7. Lincoln County 8. McDowell County 9. Moore County 10.Morganton, NC** 

**11.Nash County 12.Rowan County 13.Rutherford County 14.North Carolina State Depts** 15.Comp Analyst 16.Economic Research Institute 17.Bureau of Labor Statistics 

**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

7 

**Packet Pg. 430**
{7}------------------------------------------------
**3.5.b** 

Market 

Assessment: Cost of Labor Differentials 

Where cost of living is a measurement of goods and services in each area, the cost of labor is a measurement of compensation paid. 

Cost of labor can be impacted by the cost of living but is mainly influenced by the supply and demand of labor in each area (rate of unemployment and number of qualified laborers). 

|||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
||**Date Pulled**|**Client Name**|**Location**|**Geo Adjust**|**Client Avg Base**<br>|
||09.27.2023<br>Burke Co, NC<br>Morganton, NC|||90.3|45,342<br>|
|||||||
||**Peer #**|**Peer Organization**|**Locality Used**|**ERI Indicator**|**GeoDiff%**<br>|
||1<br>Buncombe County, North Carolina<br>Asheville, NC<br>2<br>Caldwell County, North Carolina<br>Lenoir, NC<br>3<br>Catawba County, North Carolina<br>Newton, NC<br>4<br>Cleveland County, North Carolina<br>Shelby, NC<br>5<br>Henderson County, North Carolina<br>Hendersonville, NC<br>6<br>Hickory, North Carolina<br>Hickory, NC<br>7<br>Lincoln County, North Carolina<br>Lincolnton, NC<br>8<br>McDowell County, North Carolina<br>Marion, NC<br>9<br>Moore County, North Carolina<br>Southern Pines, NC<br>10<br>Morganton, North Carolina<br>Morganton, NC<br>11<br>Nash County, North Carolina<br>Rocky Mount, NC<br>12<br>Rowan County, North Carolina<br>Salisbury, NC<br>13<br>Rutherford County, North Carolina<br>Rutherfordton, NC<br>14<br>North Carolina State Departments<br>North Carolina - State Average<br>15<br>Bureau of Labor Statistics<br>North Carolina - State Average<br>16<br>Comp Analyst<br>North Carolina - State Average<br>17<br>Economic Research Institute<br>North Carolina - State Average|||91.0|-0.7%<br>|
|||||90.3|0.0%<br>|
|||||91.1|-0.8%<br>|
|||||87.8|2.5%<br>|
|||||90.7|-0.4%<br>|
|||||90.3|0.0%<br>|
|||||94.2|-3.9%<br>|
|||||85.5|4.8%<br>|
|||||87.6|2.7%<br>|
|||||90.3|0.0%<br>|
|||||88.5|1.8%<br>|
|||||94.3|-4.0%<br>|
|||||86.2|4.1%<br>|
|||||92.4|-2.1%<br>|
|||||92.4|-2.1%<br>|
|||||92.4|-2.1%<br>|
|||||92.4|-2.1%<br>|



Cost of labor differentials collected from Economic Research Institutes Geographic Assessor tool which utilizes figures published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. 

8 **Packet Pg. 431**
{8}------------------------------------------------
**3.5.b** 

**External Equity** Market Assessments: Results 

• In total 204 positions were included in the market survey as benchmark positions. 

• Of those, 8 had insufficient data (less than 3 matches). 

- Where positions are grouped together within the current pay plans or align based on the results of SAFE job evaluation, the same consideration was made for establishing grade assignments for those positions without market data. 

• Overall, the study yielded market values for 96.1% of the County’s benchmark positions. Results were 

shared with ELT in October 2023. 

• Average minimum, midpoint, and maximum results were prepared for the 196 benchmarks with sufficient data. 

- _These benchmarks had 7.69 matches on average._ 

- • _About 29% of the benchmarks had 10 or more matches each._ 

• A comparison of current midpoints vs. the market average midpoint was also prepared. Additional 

market thresholds demonstrating 5% above and 5% below market were also prepared for consideration. 

• **On average, the County is 6.5% below market at the minimum, 7.2% below market at the** 

**midpoint, and 8.4% below market at the maximum.** 

**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

9 

**Packet Pg. 432**
{9}------------------------------------------------
## **M ethodology** 

## Project Overview 

- **Pay Plan Development** 

• Pay Plan: Baker Tilly used your existing pay plan to make recommendations for adjustment and developed new pay plans that are tailored to the study’s results. 

- Grade assignments: were determined based on existing equity (current grade groupings), internal equity (job evaluation) and external results (market midpoints). Next, positions were adjusted with respect to career progressions, supervisor-subordinate separation, and the County’s future growth. 

   - Conducted an on-site review with Department heads to gather feedback before finalizing grade assignments (January 2024). 

- Implementation: With finalized grade assignments, we prepared implementation calculations across 4 scenarios that will assist your organization in adopting the new classification and compensation system. 

**==> picture [382 x 509] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.5.b<br>Project<br>Initiation<br>Project  Position<br>Completion Review<br>Pay Plan  Market<br>Development Assessment<br>10<br>Packet Pg. 433<br>Attachment: Burke Co. Final Presentation-  BOCC - Draft PPT Pay Class  (4309 : CM - Pay &<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>
{10}------------------------------------------------
**3.5.b** 

**Pay Plan** Pay Plan Development 

• Baker Tilly led discussions with the County’s project team with regards to the number of pay plans, type of pay plans, and design of pay plans. • Determination for the number of pay plans an organization needs may be influenced by the diversity of jobs, diversity in grading procedures, internal equity versus external competitiveness, and even your organizational culture. • The County currently utilizes three pay structures (General, EMS & Detention, and Sheriff). 

• Baker Tilly recommended the adoption of three pay plans: • General= 211 positions • EMS= 9 positions • Sheriff & Detention= 20 positions 

• All pay plans were aligned to the midpoints at 105% of market (lead market compensation philosophy). 

**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

11 

**Packet Pg. 434**
{11}------------------------------------------------
**3.5.b** 

## **Pay Plan Design** 

## Current Pay Plan 

|**GRADE**<br>**MINIMUM**<br>**MIDPOINT**<br>**MAXIMUM**<br>**Range**<br>**Spread**<br>**Mid Diff**|**GRADE**<br>**MINIMUM**<br>**MIDPOINT**<br>**MAXIMUM**<br>**Range**<br>**Spread**<br>**Mid Diff**|**GRADE**<br>**MINIMUM**<br>**MIDPOINT**<br>**MAXIMUM**<br>**Range**<br>**Spread**<br>**Mid Diff**|**GRADE**<br>**MINIMUM**<br>**MIDPOINT**<br>**MAXIMUM**<br>**Range**<br>**Spread**<br>**Mid Diff**|**GRADE**<br>**MINIMUM**<br>**MIDPOINT**<br>**MAXIMUM**<br>**Range**<br>**Spread**<br>**Mid Diff**|**GRADE**<br>**MINIMUM**<br>**MIDPOINT**<br>**MAXIMUM**<br>**Range**<br>**Spread**<br>**Mid Diff**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|10|$24,785|$31,304|$37,824|53%||
|11|$26,027|$33,179|$40,332|55%|6.0%|
|12|$27,318|$34,831|$42,344|55%|5.0%|
|13|$28,684|$36,582|$44,479|55%|5.0%|
|14|$30,123|$38,408|$46,693|55%|5.0%|
|15|$31,630|$40,329|$49,028|55%|5.0%|
|16|$33,211|$42,344|$51,477|55%|5.0%|
|17|$34,868|$44,454|$54,040|55%|5.0%|
|18|$36,616|$46,685|$56,754|55%|5.0%|
|19|$38,444|$49,024|$59,603|55%|5.0%|
|20|$40,357|$51,470|$62,583|55%|5.0%|
|21|$42,388|$54,044|$65,700|55%|5.0%|
|22|$44,507|$56,746|$68,985|55%|5.0%|
|23|$46,731|$59,584|$72,436|55%|5.0%|
|24|$49,074|$62,571|$76,069|55%|5.0%|
|25|$51,532|$65,700|$79,869|55%|5.0%|
|26|$54,090|$68,978|$83,867|55%|5.0%|
|27|$56,797|$72,418|$88,039|55%|5.0%|
|28|$59,653|$76,057|$92,460|55%|5.0%|
|29|$62,633|$79,856|$97,079|55%|5.0%|
|30|$65,762|$83,842|$101,922|55%|5.0%|
|31|$69,041|$88,039|$107,038|55%|5.0%|
|32|$72,493|$92,435|$112,378|55%|5.0%|
|33|$76,119|$97,054|$117,990|55%|5.0%|
|34|$79,943|$101,922|$123,901|55%|5.0%|
|35|$83,942|$107,013|$130,085|55%|5.0%|
|36|$88,139|$112,365|$136,591|55%|5.0%|
|37|$92,530|$117,975|$143,421|55%|5.0%|
|38|$97,153|$123,876|$150,598|55%|5.0%|
|39|$102,021|$130,072|$158,123|55%|5.0%|
|40|$107,112|$136,566|$166,020|55%|5.0%|
|41|$112,477|$143,408|$174,340|55%|5.0%|
|42|$118,089|$150,573|$183,057|55%|5.0%|
|43|$124,000|$158,098|$192,196|55%|5.0%|
|44|$130,209|$166,008|$201,807|55%|5.0%|
|45|$136,710|$174,306|$211,902|55%|5.0%|
|46|$143,546|$183,022|$222,498|55%|5.0%|
|47|$150,723|$192,172|$233,622|55%|5.0%|
|48|$158,259|$201,782|$245,304|55%|5.0%|



**==> picture [520 x 221] intentionally omitted <==**

• Open plan (no defined steps), 39 grades (numbered 10-48) • Consistent 55% range spreads (distance from min to max) • Consistent 5% midpoint differential (distance between each grade at the midpoint) 

**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

12 

**Packet Pg. 435**
{12}------------------------------------------------
**3.5.b** 

## **Pay Plan Design** 

## Proposed General Pay Plan 

**==> picture [79 x 58] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Pay Plan Maximum<br>Regression<br>Pay Plan Midpoint<br>Pay Plan Minimum<br>Benchmark Position<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Each dot represents an benchmark position where the total SAFE score and market average midpoint intersects. 

The dark blue line is the “line of best fit” through all of the dots. The remaining lines represent the proposed pay plan. This does not reflect grade assignments. 

**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

13 

**Packet Pg. 436**
{13}------------------------------------------------
**3.5.b** 

## **Pay Plan Design** 

## Proposed General Pay Plan 

**==> picture [459 x 212] intentionally omitted <==**

|**Grade**|**Minimum**|**Midpoint**|**Maximum**|**Range Spread**|**Midpoint**<br>**Differential**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**50**|$27,660|$32,500|$37,341|35.00%||
|**51**|$29,872|$35,100|$40,327|35.00%|8.00%|
|**52**|$32,262|$37,908|$43,554|35.00%|8.00%|
|**53**|$34,843|$40,941|$47,038|35.00%|8.00%|
|**54**|$37,631|$44,216|$50,802|35.00%|8.00%|
|**55**|$40,641|$47,753|$54,865|35.00%|8.00%|
|**56**|$42,978|$51,573|$60,169|40.00%|8.00%|
|**57**|$46,416|$55,699|$64,982|40.00%|8.00%|
|**58**|$50,129|$60,155|$70,181|40.00%|8.00%|
|**59**|$54,139|$64,967|$75,795|40.00%|8.00%|
|**60**|$57,388|$68,865|$80,343|40.00%|6.00%|
|**61**|$60,831|$72,997|$85,163|40.00%|6.00%|
|**62**|$64,481|$77,377|$90,273|40.00%|6.00%|
|**63**|$69,639|$83,567|$97,495|40.00%|8.00%|
|**64**|$72,311|$88,581|$104,851|45.00%|6.00%|
|**65**|$80,989|$99,211|$117,434|45.00%|12.00%|
|**66**|$90,707|$111,116|$131,525|45.00%|12.00%|
|**67**|$101,592|$124,450|$147,308|45.00%|12.00%|
|**68**|$113,783|$139,384|$164,985|45.00%|12.00%|
|**69**|$124,888|$156,110|$187,332|50.00%|12.00%|
|**70**|$139,874|$174,843|$209,811|50.00%|12.00%|



- Open plan (no defined steps), 19 grades 

- • 35-50% range spreads 

- 6-12% midpoint differential 

- Aligned to 105% of market midpoints 

**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

14 

**Packet Pg. 437**
{14}------------------------------------------------
**3.5.b** 

## **Pay Plan Design** Proposed EMS Pay Plan 

|**Grade**|**Minimum**|**Midpoint**|**Maximum**|**Range**<br>**Spread**|**Midpoint**<br>**Differential**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**80**|$34,043|$40,000|$45,958|35.00%||
|**81**|$39,167|$47,000|$54,834|40.00%|17.50%|
|**82**|$45,042|$54,050|$63,059|40.00%|15.00%|
|**83**|$47,294|$56,753|$66,212|40.00%|5.00%|
|**84**|$49,660|$59,592|$69,524|40.00%|5.00%|
|**85**|$55,619|$66,743|$77,867|40.00%|12.00%|
|**86**|$60,625|$72,750|$84,875|40.00%|9.00%|
|**87**|$66,082|$79,298|$92,515|40.00%|9.00%|
|**88**|$72,029|$86,435|$100,841|40.00%|9.00%|
|**89**|$78,512|$94,214|$109,917|40.00%|9.00%|



**==> picture [444 x 201] intentionally omitted <==**

- Open plan (no defined steps), 10 grades 

- • 35-40% range spreads 

- • 5-17.5% midpoint differential 

- • Aligned to 105% of market midpoints 

**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

15 

**Packet Pg. 438**
{15}------------------------------------------------
**3.5.b** 

# **Pay Plan Design** Proposed Sheriff & Detention Pay Plan 

**==> picture [19 x 442] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Attachment: Burke Co. Final Presentation-  BOCC - Draft PPT Pay Class  (4309 : CM - Pay &<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


|**Grade**|**Minimum**|**Midpoint**|**Maximum**|**Range**<br>**Spread**|**Midpoint**<br>**Differential**|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|**100**|$45,833|$55,000|$64,166|40.00%||
|**101**|$48,583|$58,300|$68,016|40.00%|6.00%|
|**102**|$52,470|$62,964|$73,458|40.00%|8.00%|
|**103**|$56,668|$68,001|$79,335|40.00%|8.00%|
|**104**|$60,068|$72,081|$84,095|40.00%|6.00%|
|**105**|$66,074|$79,289|$92,504|40.00%|10.00%|
|**106**|$76,646|$91,975|$107,304|40.00%|16.00%|
|**107**|$89,676|$107,611|$125,546|40.00%|17.00%|
|**108**|$95,953|$115,144|$134,334|40.00%|7.00%|
|**109**|$102,670|$123,204|$143,738|40.00%|7.00%|
|**110**|$109,857|$131,828|$153,800|40.00%|7.00%|



**==> picture [463 x 163] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [344 x 91] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
•<br>Open plan (no defined steps), 11 grades<br>•<br>40% range spreads<br>•<br>6-16% midpoint differential<br>•<br>Aligned to 105% of market midpoints<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

16 

**Packet Pg. 439**
{16}------------------------------------------------
## **Pay Plan Development** 

## Grade Assignments 

- Positions were assigned based on the following: 

   - Internal equity (job evaluation scores) 

   - External equity (market midpoints) 

   - Existing equity (current midpoints and grade groupings) 

   - Career progressions 

   - Supervisor / Subordinate separation 

- The following information is NOT considered: 

   - The person in the position 

   - Performance 

   - Length of service 

   - Existing employee salary 

**==> picture [55 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.5.b<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


- Preliminary grade assignments were reviewed with the County’s project team to ensure positions were assigned to the correct grade and address any outliers. 

 Next, grade assignments were reviewed as a group with the County’s leadership. Some follow up information was needed to reevaluate positions or consider relevant data to finalize grade assignments. 

**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

17 

**Packet Pg. 440**
{17}------------------------------------------------
**Pay Plan Development** 

## Implementation Scenarios 

Criteria considered in developing implementation scenarios: 

- The County’s desired position within its defined market 

- Pay policies / practices that might dictate an employee's placement within their range 

- Employee’s years in position and service to the County 

- Pay compression within classifications 

Of 497 employees (general plan), years in position spans 

from 0 to 15 years with an average of 4.45 years (and median of 2 years). 

**==> picture [435 x 512] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.5.b<br>Distribution of Employee by Years in Position<br>140<br>120<br>100<br>80<br>60<br>40<br>20<br>0<br>0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16<br>18<br>Packet Pg. 441<br>Attachment: Burke Co. Final Presentation-  BOCC - Draft PPT Pay Class  (4309 : CM - Pay &<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>
{18}------------------------------------------------
**Pay Plan Development** 

**3.5.b** 

## Implementation Scenarios 

- Baker Tilly prepared 4 scenarios for Burke County to consider in its adoption of the new classification and compensation plan. 

- **No employee will receive a pay decrease as a result of the study.** 

- **Implementation cost reflects base pay in US dollars. Benefits and pay differentials are not included.** 

Implementation Scenarios for all three pay plans (General, Detention/Sheriff, and EMS): 

1. Employees below the minimum would move to the minimum. If any employee’s current salary is within the proposed range, they would retain their existing salary. 

2. Employees below the minimum would move to the minimum or receive a 2% adjustment (whichever is greater), capped at the maximum of their pay range. If any employee’s current salary is higher than that calculation, they would retain their existing salary. 

3. Employees below the minimum would move to the minimum, then all employees would receive a .5% adjustment multiplied by their years in position, capped at 15 years. If any employee’s current salary is higher than that calculation, they would retain their existing salary. 

- 3a. Employees below the minimum would move to the minimum or receive a 2% adjustment (whichever is greater), then all employees would receive a .5% adjustment multiplied by their years in position, capped at 15 years. If any employee’s current salary is higher than that calculation, they would retain their existing salary. 

**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

19 

**Packet Pg. 442**
{19}------------------------------------------------
**3.5.b** 

## Implementation Scenarios 

• For 716 staff, the current payroll is approximately $34,918,852.83. This figure includes 41 vacant full-time positions. 

||**Option 1- Move to Minimum**|**Option 1- Move to Minimum**|**Option 1- Move to Minimum**|**r**<br>|
|---|---|---|---|---|
||**# of Staff**|**Current Salary**|**% Increase**||
|Totals|716|$34,918,852.83|4.1%||
||||||
|Employees Below Minimum|403|$16,953,279.18|8.4%||
|Employees Within Range|305|$17,421,293.03|0.0%||
|Employees Above Maximum|8|$544,280.62|0.0%||
||||||
||||||
||**Option 2- Greater of Minimum or 2%**||||
||**# of Staff**|**Current Salary**|**% Increase**||
|Totals|716|$34,918,852.83|5.2%||
||||||
|Employees Below Minimum|403|$16,953,279.18|8.6%||
|Employees Within Range|305|$17,421,293.03|2.0%||
|Employees Above Maximum|8|$544,280.62|0.0%||
||||||
||||||
||**Option 3- Move to Minimum+ .5% per Years in**||||
||**# of Staff**|**Current Salary**|**% Increase**||
|Totals|717|$35,036,744.83|5.0%||
||||||
|Employees Below Minimum|403|$16,953,279.18|10.0%||
|Employees Within Range|306|$17,539,185.03|0.2%||
|Employees Above Maximum|8|$544,280.62|0.0%||
||||||
||||||
||**Option 3a: Greater of Min or 2% + .5%per Yea**||||
||**# of Staff**|**Current Salary**|**% Increase**||
|Totals|717|$35,036,744.83|5.9%||
||||||
|Employees Below Minimum|403|$16,953,279.18|10.0%||
|Employees Within Range|306|$17,539,185.03|2.1%||
|Employees Above Maximum|8|$544,280.62|0.0%||



- Option 2 (Average Adjustment for Impacted Employees): 

   - General Plan= 6.1% 

   - Sheriff & Detention= 7.3% 

   - EMS= 3.7% 

- Average Range Penetration: 

   - General Plan= 30.4% (Avg tenure 4.45 yrs) 

   - Sheriff & Detention= 19.3% (Avg tenure 2.9 yrs) 

   - EMS= 35.1% (Avg tenure 3.7 yrs) 

**==> picture [362 x 218] intentionally omitted <==**

**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

20 

**Packet Pg. 443**
{20}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [104 x 104] intentionally omitted <==**

## Conclusion 

**We urge Burke County to:** 

- Adopt the recommended position title and classification adjustments. 

- Adopt the proposed pay plans with grade assignments. 

- Adopt an implementation scenario that addresses the County’s compensation philosophy, business goals, and that is fiscally sustainable. 

- Continue efforts to maintain the classification and compensation system: 

   - Routinely review positions, job descriptions, and market conditions. 

   - Adjust the pay structure and salaries, annually, to keep pace with the market. 

   - Adopt general or merit increases, annually, to reward employees and ensure advancement through assigned pay ranges. 

Baker Tilly US, LLP, trading as Baker Tilly, is a member of the global network of Baker Tilly International Ltd., the members of which are separate and independent legal entities. © 2022 Baker Tilly US, LLP. 

**3.5.b** 

**==> picture [19 x 442] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Attachment: Burke Co. Final Presentation-  BOCC - Draft PPT Pay Class  (4309 : CM - Pay &<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**Packet Pg. 444**
{21}------------------------------------------------
## **M ethodology** 

## Next Steps 

## **Project Completion** 

- A final report will document the methodology used to conduct the study, our findings, and recommendations. 

- Presentation of the results to elected officials, senior leadership, employees, and/or designated staff as desired. 

- All project documentation will be delivered 

- We will provide training to HR staff to administer and maintain the new classification and compensation system–including the SAFE® job evaluation process. 

- Baker Tilly will utilize data captured by employee submitted PAQs as the basis for developing draft job descriptions. This information will have been reviewed and verified by supervisors to ensure completeness and accuracy of the information. Any adjustments to titles, FLSA designations, minimum qualifications, supervision exercised, and Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)-related information, etc. will be incorporated into the job description drafts. 

**==> picture [55 x 19] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
3.5.b<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [375 x 442] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Project<br>Initiation<br>Project  Position<br>Completion Review<br>Pay Plan  Market<br>Development Assessment<br>Attachment: Burke Co. Final Presentation-  BOCC - Draft PPT Pay Class  (4309 : CM - Pay &<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [29 x 29] intentionally omitted <==**

22 

**Packet Pg. 445**
