{0}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [275 x 75] intentionally omitted <==**

## **ZONING MAP AMENDMENT** _**STAFF ANALYSIS Legislative Hearing**_ 

**==> picture [524 x 505] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
 LOCATION MAP  A. CASE<br>ZPH2023-00040<br>East Valley LLC Rezoning<br>B. PROPERTY INFORMATION<br>• PIN(s):  9678470815<br>• Addresses:  1700 & 1702 Tunnel Rd.<br>• Owner(s):  East Valley LLC<br>• Acreage:   .99 total acres<br>• Utilities:  Public water and sewer<br>• Access Road:  Tunnel Rd.<br>C. REZONING REQUEST<br>Existing:      R-2 Residential<br>Summary:    Marc Wright of East Valley LLC<br>has requested to rezone one parcel of land<br>from R-2(Residential) to EMP (Employment).<br>Proposed:    EMP – Employment<br>D. PUBLIC NOTICE Planning Board  Board of Commissioners<br>Citizen Times and BC website:  1/10/24 &1/11/24  2/9/24<br>Mailed to owners within 1,000 ft:   1/11/24  2/6/24<br>Physical posting on site:   1/12/24  2/9/24<br>Hearing Date:  1/22/24  2/20/24<br>E. RECOMMENDATION & SUMMARY OF CONSISTENCY REVIEW<br>Staff recommends that the rezoning of the parcel be approved as it<br>STAFF:  APPROVAL<br>conforms to the recommendations from the Comprehensive Plan’s<br>GEC Character Map, the Plan Policies and Actions, and neighborhood<br>PLANNING BOARD: APPROVAL<br>consistency.<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Page **1** of **6**
{1}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [528 x 201] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
F. SPOT ZONING ANALYSIS<br>Spot Zoning: A zoning ordinance, or amendment, which singles out and<br>reclassifies a relatively small tract owned by a single person and surrounded by a<br>much larger area uniformly zoned, so as to impose upon the smaller tract  POTENTIAL<br>greater restrictions than those imposed upon the larger area, or so as to relieve  CONSISTENT SPOT<br>the small tract from restrictions to which the rest of the area is subjected, is  ZONING<br>called “spot zoning.” Spot Zoning, David W. Owens, April, 2020, quoting Blades v.<br>City of Raleigh, 280 N.C. 531, 547, 187 S.E.2d 35, 45 (1972).<br>1. Staff Analysis of spot zoning:<br>The subject acreage is adjacent to property currently zoned EMP.  Based on<br>X<br>the nature of the request, Staff does not have concerns related to spot<br>zoning.<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [528 x 398] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
G. 2043 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN CONSISTENCY<br>PLEASE NOTE:  If a rezoning request is approved that is not consistent with the adopted comprehensive<br>plan, the zoning amendment shall have the effect of also amending any future land use map (e.g., the<br>Growth, Equity, and Conservation Map) in the approved plan. No additional request or application for a<br>plan amendment shall be required per the statute.<br>NOT<br>GEC CHARACTER FRAMEWORK (FUTURE LAND USE MAP): CONSISTENT<br>CONSISTENT<br>1. FLUM CATEGORY DESCRIPTION<br>The proposed rezoning is consistent with the Character area description of  X<br>‘Mixed Use I’ where this parcel is located.<br>2. WASTEWATER & POTABLE WATER TYPE<br>X<br>The parcel has access to public water and sewer.<br>3. DENSITY<br>The proposed zoning district has a maximum density of up to 12 units an  X<br>acre which is consistent with the Character area recommendations.<br>4. PRIMARY AND SECONDARY LAND USES<br>The uses allowed in the proposed zoning district match those  X<br>recommended in the Character Framework for this area.<br>NOT<br>PLAN POLICIES AND ACTIONS: CONSISTENT<br>CONSISTENT<br>5. Proximity to Transportation Corridor (Transportation Action 4)<br>The parcel is located on a major transportation corridor, Tunnel Rd., which  X<br>turns into US HWY 70.<br>6. Support higher density residential development near job centers and<br>amenities (Transportation Action 4)<br>X<br>The rezoning from R-2 to EMP will not result in any change to the allowable<br>density.<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Page **2** of **6**
{2}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [528 x 639] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
7. Prioritize environmental conservation of other natural lands (such as<br>intact forest lands, wetlands, and other unique habitats) to protect and<br>increase the capacity to sustain the county’s existing biodiversity (Env.<br>N/A<br>Conserv. Action 3)<br>This parcel is in the Mixed Use I area on the GEC Map. This is a growth area<br>and so this question does not apply.<br>8. Prioritize the conservation of physical connections between natural<br>landscapes to avoid fragmentation of large forest blocks in order to<br>X<br>benefit wildlife migration (Env. Conserv. Action 3)<br>This rezoning would not cause the fragmentation of a large forest block.<br>9. Using the guidance of the GEC Map, work with private development<br>partners to bring new sites to market that have promising transportation<br>access, proximity to current and future economic corridors, a robust utility<br>service, labor draw, community synergies, etc. (Economic Dev. Action 2) X<br>The rezoning of this parcel will increase the land use options for the existing<br>and future property owners. It is located on Tunnel Rd., a major<br>transportation corridor.<br>10. Support the creation of place-based community gathering destinations at<br>Walkable Destination Centers, Mixed Use Areas, and Rural Centers<br>identified on the GEC Map (Economic Dev. Action 3)<br>The EMP Employment District is primarily intended to concentrate sites<br>N/A<br>for office uses, industrial uses, storage and warehousing, and wholesale<br>trade. Rezoning the subject parcel to EMP would not necessarily result in<br>the creation of more place-based community gathering destinations in the<br>Mixed Use I area where it is located.<br>11. Integrate equity considerations into projects that improve air, water, and<br>land quality by utilizing tools including redlining maps of Asheville and<br>other municipalities and EPA’s Environmental Justice Screening Tool Equity Analysis is not<br>(Health Action 7)  recommended for this<br>The parcel is not in an area identified on the red lining map of Asheville and  parcel.<br>does not score high on the Buncombe County Community Index Map Equity<br>Index.<br>NOT<br>ENVIRONMENTAL:  CONSISTENT<br>CONSISTENT<br>12. Steep Slope/High Elevation and Protected Ridge Overlay Districts<br>X<br>The parcel is not within an Overlay District.<br>13. Regulated Flood Hazard Areas<br>X<br>The parcel is not located within a regulated flood hazard area.<br>14. High or Moderate Hazard Stability Areas<br>X<br>The parcel does not contain hazard stability areas.<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Page **3** of **6**
{3}------------------------------------------------
**==> picture [528 x 559] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
NOT<br>H. NEIGHBORHOOD CONSISTENCY  CONSISTENT<br>CONSISTENT<br>1. CURRENT DEVELOPMENT TYPES:<br>Subject acreage has the following adjacent zonings and uses:<br>DIRECTION  ZONING  ADJACENT USES<br>NORTH R-2 Residential Residential Building Lot<br>X<br>EAST R-2 Residential Residential Builidng Lot<br>Multiple Residence and<br>SOUTH EMP Employment<br>Manufacturing<br>WEST EMP Employment Medical Office<br>2. Does the proposed rezoning allow for any transition between higher<br>density or intensity uses and lower density or intensity uses?  (Examples<br>include medium intensity zoning between a low and high intensity district,<br>topographic separations, other natural features to ensure a transition or buffer.)<br>The rezoning of the property from R-2 to EMP will cause an increase in the<br>types and intensity of uses allowed on the property. The properties to the  X<br>north and east of the subject parcel are zoned R-2. While there would not<br>be a zoning district transition between them and the proposed EMP zoning<br>district there is currently a wooded area buffering these parcels from the<br>subject parcel and buffering is required for any commercial development<br>adjacent to a residential use.<br>3. Are the uses allowed in the proposed zoning district compatible with the<br>existing uses in the area?<br>The proposed zoning district allows a variety of uses from residential to<br>X<br>commercial, storage, and  industrial. The existing uses in the area includes<br>single-family residential, warehouse storage, and medical office. Tunnel<br>Road is a major transportation corrdior and the EMP zoning district is well<br>suited for this location.<br>4. ALLOWED DEVELOPMENT TYPES AFTER CHANGE:<br>The proposed rezoning would allow additional uses in the EMP district that are not currently allowed<br>in the R-2 districts. Examples of uses that would be allowed after the rezoning include commercial<br>planned unit developments,  adult entertainment establishments, asphalt plants, concrete plants,<br>motor vehicle maintenance and repair, nighclubs, bars, veterinary clinics, banks, cargo terminals,<br>hotels or motels, manufacturing facilities, restaurants, retail, warehousing, vacation rental complexes,<br>and more.<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Page **4** of **6**
{4}------------------------------------------------
## **5. DENSITY & DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS COMPARISON:** 

**==> picture [529 x 524] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
Existing District:  Proposed District:<br>R-2 Residential  EMP Employment<br>No Public Sewer<br>30,000 SF  30,000 SF<br>Min. Lot  Public Sewer/No<br>10,000 SF  10,000 SF<br>Size  Water<br>6,000 SF  5,000 SF<br>Public Water & Sewer<br>Max. dwelling units per acre  12  12<br>10/7/15 with public sewer<br>Setbacks (Front/Side/Rear)  20/10/20<br>20/10/20 septic system<br>Max. height  35 feet 90 feet<br>6. PREVIOUS ZONING ACTIONS & RELEVANT SITE HISTORY:<br>There are currently two structures on the property that appear to have been there since before 1998.<br>There does not seem to be any record of previous zoning actions for this parcel.<br>I. COMPARISON OF ZONING ORDINANCE DISTRICT STATEMENT OF INTENT<br>EXISTING ZONING DISTRICT – R-2  PROPOSED ZONING DISTRICT – EMP<br>The R-2 District is primarily intended to provide   The EMP Employment District is primarily intended<br>locations for residential development and  to provide appropriately located sites for<br>supporting recreational, community service  employment concentrations primarily for office uses,<br>and educational uses in areas where public  industrial uses, storage and warehousing, and<br>water and sewer services are available or will  wholesale trade. Such locations should currently have<br>likely be provided in the future. These areas  public water and sewer services available or be<br>will usually be adjacent to R-1 Residential  expected to have these services in the future. Only<br>Districts, will provide suitable areas for  those manufacturing uses will be allowed which meet<br>residential subdivisions requiring public water  all local, state and federal environmental standards,<br>and sewer services, and in order to help  and do not involve obnoxious noise, vibrations,<br>maintain the present character of R-1 districts,  smoke, gas, fumes, odor, dust, fire hazards, or other<br>will not allow manufactured home parks. objectionable conditions which would be detrimental<br>to the health, safety, and general welfare of the<br>community. These areas will also include sites<br>suitable for supportive activities such as community<br>service, commercial service, and residential uses.<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Page **5** of **6**
{5}------------------------------------------------
## **J. EQUITY ANALYSIS** 

**==> picture [500 x 65] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
1. Buncombe County Government is utilizing an Equity Analysis Tool for certain types of planning-<br>related development decisions. The following is Staff’s Equity Analysis for this rezoning:<br>Based on this parcel’s ranking on the Community Index Map, this parcel is not located in an equity<br>opportunity area.<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **K. PLANNING BOARD RECOMMENDATION** 

**==> picture [517 x 150] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
1. BOARD BASIS FOR DECISION MAKING<br>The Board must determine if there is a reasonable basis for the requested change in light of its effect on<br>all involved including the following considerations:<br>• The requested change does not directly or indirectly result in the creation of spot zoning<br>• Size of the tract in question<br>• Compatibility of the change with the adopted 2043 Comprehensive Plan<br>• Benefits and detriments resulting from the change for the owner of the newly zoned property,<br>their neighbors, and the surrounding community<br>• Relationship between the uses envisioned under the new zoning and the uses currently present in<br>adjacent tracts<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [503 x 28] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
References: Good Neighbors of South Davidson v. Town of Denton, 355 N.C. 254, 559 S.E.2d 768 (2002)<br>Chrismon v. Guilford County, 322 N.C. 611, 370 S.E.2d 579 (1988)<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **L. BOARD OPTIONS** 

**==> picture [528 x 94] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
The following options are available to the Board:<br>a. Recommend approval of the proposed rezoning, as presented.<br>b. Recommend approval of a portion of the proposed rezoning.<br>c. Recommend denial of the proposed rezoning, as presented.<br>M.  ATTACHMENTS<br>• Application  • Maps<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


Page **6** of **6**
