{0}------------------------------------------------

The Black Mountain Town Council held their regular meeting on Monday, July 8, 2024, at 6:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of Town Hall, 160 Midland Avenue, Black Mountain, NC 28711. 

## **1. CALL TO ORDER** 

Mayor C. Michael Sobol called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m. with the following members in attendance: Mayor C. Michael Sobol, Vice Mayor Archie Pertiller, Council Member Alice Berry, Council Member Doug Hay, Council Member Pam King, Council Member Ryan Stone. 

The following staff members were present: Josh Harrold, Town Manager; Jessica Trotman, Assistant Town Manager; Wesley Barker, Town Clerk; Josh Henderson, Recreation & Parks Director; John Coffey, Fire Chief; Chris Kuhn, Police Major; Jamey Matthews, Public Works Director. Attorney Brian Gulden was also present. 

Mayor Sobol led those in attendance in the pledge of allegiance and a moment of silence, then read the ethics statement. 

************** 

## **2. PROCLAMATIONS, AWARDS, RECOGNITIONS, SPECIAL RESOLUTIONS** 

Mayor C. Michael Sobol read a proclamation recognizing the month of July as “Recreation and Parks Month,” and Friday, July 19[th] as “Park and Recreation Professionals Day.” 

************** 

## **3. CITIZEN COMMENTS** 

No citizen comments. 

************** 

## **4. COMMUNICATIONS FROM STAFF, COUNCILS, COMMISSIONS & AGENCIES-** 

_none._ 

- ****************** 

## **5. CONSENT AGENDA** 

   - Town Manager Josh Harrold reviewed the consent agenda items with the Town Council. 

- **A. Adoption of Meeting Minutes:** June 6, 2024 Agenda Meeting and Budget Public Hearing; June 10, 2024 Regular Meeting; June 25, 2024 Special Called Meeting. 

11 


{1}------------------------------------------------
## _**Council Member Doug Hay made a motion to approve the minutes as presented with the amendment to June 10, 2024 minutes noting the Town Attorney Craig Justus’ presence. A vote of 5-0 in favor.**_ 

****************** 

- **B. Monthly Property Tax Collector Report.** 

_**Council Member Doug Hay made a motion to approve the tax collector report as presented. A vote of 5-0 in favor.**_ 

## ****************** 

- **C. Resolution to Authorize Abatement of Unsafe Conditions at 1154 Montreat Road.** 

_**Council Member Doug Hay made a motion to approve the following resolution as presented. A vote of 5-0 in favor.**_ 

## **RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING ABATEMENT OF UNSAFE CONDITIONS AND PUBLIC NUISANCE VIOLATIONS AT 1154 MONTREAT ROAD (PIN #0710-536021.00000)** 

## **RESOLUTION #R-24-25** 

**WHEREAS,** the Town of Black Mountain (the “Town”) received an anonymous complaint in August 2023 about nuisance trash and tall grass violations, unsafe electrical conditions, and unsafe building conditions on the deck and accessory structures on the property located at 1154 Montreat Road, Black Mountain, North Carolina, which property is listed of record as owned by Mary Ann Riddle (the “Property Owner”), through Deed recorded in Book 1328, Page 0561, Buncombe County, North Carolina Register of Deeds (the “Subject Property”); and 

**WHEREAS,** Town staff conducted a site of visit of the Subject Property in August of 2023 and confirmed the presence of trash in the yard, tall grass, and unsafe building conditions and the property was posted with an UNSAFE, DO NOT ENTER PLACARD; and 

**WHEREAS,** Town staff mailed a Notice of Unsafe Conditions letter to the Property Owner both by regular mail and certified mail, return receipt and the return receipt card was received with a signature and dated August 24, 2023; and 

**WHEREAS,** Town staff conducted a follow-up site visit on October 2, 2023, and while conditions had not been corrected, contact was made with the Property Owner on site who indicated that plans to correct the remaining violations were being made and staff did note that some progress and been made in removing the trash and debris; and 

**WHEREAS,** Town staff conducted a follow-up site visit on October 9, 2023, and noted that considerable progress had been made, the building was secure, a dumpster had been placed on site, and a lot of debris had been cleaned up; and 

12 


{2}------------------------------------------------
**WHEREAS,** an electrical permit was issued to the Property Owner on November 11, 2023, to replace light fixtures and make sure all plugs are working and the electrical system is in good order; and 

**WHEREAS,** in April of 2024, having received no inspection requests for the electrical work and the timeframe to correct all violations had passed, Town staff conducted a follow-up site visit and found unsafe structural building elements, unsafe electrical system, an inoperable and unsanitary plumbing system, no running water, and no electricity; and 

**WHEREAS,** on April 24, 2024, a Notice of Hearing was sent to the Property Owner informing the Property Owner of a hearing to be held before the Building Inspector on May 3, 2024, and noted that the Property Owner would have the opportunity to present any testimony and/or evidence pertaining to the matter; and 

**WHEREAS,** at the hearing on May 3, 2024, the Property Owner was not in attendance, however, Kevin Bates, Director of Swannanoa Valley Christian Ministries, was in attendance on behalf of the Property Owner’s son, who to our knowledge, had no legal right to be on the property; and 

**WHEREAS,** at the hearing on May 3, 2024, the Building Inspector issued an order to abate the unsafe structural building elements, the unsafe electrical system, the unsanitary plumbing system, and reconnect the water and electricity at the Subject Property; and 

**WHEREAS,** on May 7, 2024, the Property Owner’s daughter provided Power of Attorney paperwork for the Property Owner and indicated that it is their intent to sell the property; and 

**WHEREAS,** on May 14, 2024, the order from the Building Inspector was mailed via certified mail, return receipt to the Power of Attorney and the return receipt card was received on May 20, 2024, with the signature of the Power of Attorney; and 

**WHEREAS,** the Property Owner passed away on May 15, 2024; and 

**WHEREAS,** on June 12, 2024, the Building Inspector received a call from the Property Owner’s sister who informed the Building Inspector that the Power of Attorney was having difficulties obtaining executorship of the property; and 

**WHEREAS,** in the interest of the public, health, safety, and welfare, and, as a result of the Property Owner and the Power of Attorney of the Subject Property having failed to comply with the Order to Take Corrective Action, the Town has determined that it is now necessary for the Town to proceed with the clean-up and abatement of the unsafe conditions of the Subject Property and to remove all trash and debris, board the building, and remove the unsafe deck and accessory structures as permitted in NCGS 160D-1125. 

**NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED AND ORDAINED** by the Town Council of the Town of Black Mountain, North Carolina, that pursuant to NCGS 160D-1125 and significant 

13 


{3}------------------------------------------------
public health concerns, the clean-up of the Subject Property at 1154 Montreat Road, Black Mountain, North Carolina, is hereby authorized and the Town staff shall contract for and carry out the clean-up of the Subject Property in accordance with the terms of this Ordinance. 

## **ADOPTED** this 8[th] day of July 2024. 

**==> picture [87 x 141] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
**************<br>**************<br>**************<br>**************<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **6) PUBLIC HEARING-** _none._ 

**==> picture [172 x 18] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
7) CITIZEN COMMENTS-  none.<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


**==> picture [183 x 18] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
8) UNFINISHED BUSINESS-  none.<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **9) NEW BUSINESS** 

**A. Shared Parking Agreement with Wellspring Direct Primary Care.** 

Assistant Town Manager Jessica Trotman stated the Town had reached out to various businesses in the downtown area to inquire about providing shared parking in the evenings and on the weekends. Wellspring Direct Primary Care is interested in a shared parking agreement and this parking lot would provide 14 parking spaces and be available for public parking after 5:00 PM Monday through Friday, and all day on Saturday and Sunday. The Town will provide signage for the shared parking at the location. _**Vice Mayor Archie Pertiller made a motion to approve the shared parking agreement with Wellspring Direct Primary Care as presented. A vote of 5-0 in favor.**_ 

## _***A copy of this agreement is attached to these minutes as Attachment A***_ 

**==> picture [87 x 17] intentionally omitted <==**

**----- Start of picture text -----**<br>
**************<br>**----- End of picture text -----**<br>


## **B. Advisory Boards & Commissions Appointments.** 

**ABC Board Appointments-** The ABC Board has one seat expiring in July 2024. There were three applications received for this ABC Board seat. The Council voted via ballot method and the Town Clerk tabulated announcing that Sharon Tabor received a unanimous vote. 

_**Vice Mayor Archie Pertiller made a motion to appoint Sharon Tabor to the ABC Board for a second, three-year term. A vote of 5-0 in favor.**_ 

|**Board/Commission**|**Member Name**|**Term Expires**|
|---|---|---|
|ABC Board|Sharon Tabor|7/1/2027|



14 


{4}------------------------------------------------
**Active Mobility Commission Appointments-** The Active Mobility Commission has two seats expiring in July 2024 and has a current vacant seat. Member Julia Weatherford’s seat is expiring, but she has served two consecutive terms and will rotate off the Commission. There were two applications received for the Active Mobility Commission. This will continue to leave a vacant seat on the Commission. 

_**Council Member Doug Hay made a motion to appoint Julie White for a second, three-year term, and appoint Karen Neal for a first, three-year term. A vote of 5-0 in favor.**_ 

|**Board/Commission**|**Member Name**|**Term Expires**|
|---|---|---|
|Active MobilityCommission|Julie White|7/1/2027|
|Active MobilityCommission|Karen Neal|7/1/2027|



**Board of Adjustment Member Removal-** Town Clerk Wesley Barker explained to the Council that Ben Cooper, a member of the Board of Adjustment, has been absent from seven of the eight meetings held since July 2023, which violates the Town’s Advisory Board, Commission and Committee Member Handbook’s Attendance Policy. This policy, which requires members to adhere to attendance requirements, states “The Council may dismiss any member who misses three consecutive regular meetings, or one-half of meetings held in a single six-month period without good cause.” If this member is removed, it will leave a vacant unexpired seat on the Board of Adjustment to be appointed by Town Council. _**Council Member Pam King made a motion to remove Ben Cooper from the Board of Adjustment due to attendance issues. A vote of 5-0 in favor.**_ 

**Board of Adjustment Appointments-** The Board of Adjustment has two seats expiring in July 2024, and now has an unexpired vacant seat due to the aforementioned removal of member Ben Cooper. The Board of Adjustment has three (3) current member alternates, and Alternate #1, John Hines, and Alternate #2, Nichole Stallings, would now be eligible to be appointed to serve on the Board of Adjustment as full members, if Council approves, while Alternate #3, Linda Brinson, would move up to the Alternate #1 position. Further, one board member, whose seat is expiring in July 2024, is interested in being reappointed. There were two new applications received for the Board of Adjustment, and staff recommends these applicants be appointed to serve in the new alternate member roles of #2 and #3, respectively. Alternate Members do not currently have any term expirations. Some discussion ensued among Council Members. 

_**Council Member Alice Berry made a motion to appoint Lauren Dodgin for a second, threeyear term, appoint current Alternate #1 John Hines to a first, three-year term, appoint current Alternate #2 Nichole Stallings to a first, three-year term,  appoint David Barley as new Alternate #2, and appoint Amy Golden as new Alternate #3. A vote of 5-0 in favor.**_ 

|**Board/Commission**|**Member Name**|**Term Expires**|
|---|---|---|
|Board of Adjustment|Lauren Dodgin|7/1/2027|
|Board of Adjustment|John Hines|7/1/2027|



15 


{5}------------------------------------------------
|Board of Adjustment|Nichole Stallings|7/1/2027|
|---|---|---|
|Board of Adjustment- Alternate #2|David Barley|N/A|
|Board of Adjustment- Alternate #3|AmyGolden|N/A|



**Historic Preservation Commission-** The Historic Preservation Commission (HPC) has one seat expiring in July 2024 and has a current vacant seat. Commission member Jay Pamar’s seat is expiring, and did not reapply. There were two applications received for the HPC. If Town Council appoints both applicants, there would no longer be a vacancy on the commission. 

_**Vice Mayor Archie Pertiller made a motion to appoint Chris Zajac for a first three-year term, and appoint Melinda Hester for a first three-year term on the Historic Preservation Commission. A vote of 5-0 in favor.**_ 

|**Board/Commission**|**Member Name**|**Term Expires**|
|---|---|---|
|Historic Preservation Commission|Chris Zajac|7/1/2027|
|Historic Preservation Commission|Melinda Hester|7/1/2027|



**Planning Board Appointments-** The Planning Board has three seats expiring in July 2024. Staff is not yet done with the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) project but anticipates completion within the next year. Due to this, staff is recommending that current Planning Board members Pam Norton and Chas Fitzgerald, whose terms are both expiring in July 2024, and who have both served two full three-year terms, be reappointed for one (1) additional year to finish out the UDO project. Further, current Planning Board member Kathy Phillips’ seat is expiring, but is eligible to serve for a second, three-year term, if re-appointed by the Town Council. 

Town Clerk Wesley Barker stated the Town’s Advisory Board, Commission and Committee Members Handbook says, “the Town Council has expressed their preference to limit advisory board and commission members terms of service to two consecutive terms; however they have reserved the right to override that preference when they deem the circumstances of an individual’s service to the community to be of such notable importance as to warrant a continuation of service." Several Council Members felt it would be beneficial for these members to remain on the board through the completion of the UDO because they have been part of the process all along. Town Clerk Wesley Barker also informed the Council that with these special one-year appointments, if approved, these two seats would be appointed for two-year terms in 2025 to keep terms staggered, ensuring multiple members aren’t rotating off all at once. The Town Council acknowledged this suggestion. 

16 


{6}------------------------------------------------
_**Council Member Alice Berry made a motion to appoint Kathy Phillips for a second threeyear term, appoint Pam Norton for an additional one-year term, and appoint Chas Fitzgerald for an additional one-year term to the Planning Board. A vote of 5-0 in favor.**_ 

|**Board/Commission**|**Member Name**|**Term Expires**|
|---|---|---|
|PlanningBoard|KathyPhillips|7/1/2027|
|PlanningBoard|Pam Norton|7/1/2025|
|PlanningBoard|Chas Fitzgerald|7/1/2025|



**Recreation Commission Member Removal-** Town Clerk Wesley Barker explained to the Council that Sally Cochran, a member of the Recreation Commission, has been absent from more than three consecutive meetings, which violates the Town’s Advisory Board, Commission and Committee Member Handbook’s Attendance Policy. This policy, which requires members to adhere to attendance requirements, states “The Council may dismiss any member who misses three consecutive regular meetings, or one-half of meetings held in a single six-month period without good cause.” If this member is removed, it will leave a vacant unexpired seat on the Recreation Commission to be appointed by Town Council. _**Council Member Pam King made a motion to remove Sally Cochran from the Recreation Commission due to attendance issues. A vote of 5-0 in favor.**_ 

**Recreation Commission Appointments-** The Recreation Commission has two seats expiring in July 2024, and now has an unexpired vacant seat due to the removal of member Sally Cochran. Current members Joseph Scotto and Nathan West are eligible for reappointment and have applied. There was a total of five applications received for the Recreation Commission and the Town Council voted via ballot method from these applicants to choose two who will serve three-year terms, and one who will serve the unexpired term with two-years remaining. The following applicants received the following number of votes by Council members: 

|**Full three-year term: 2 seats**<br>**available**|**Number of Votes Received via Council**<br>**Ballot**|
|---|---|
|Joseph Scotto|5 of 5|
|Nathan West|5 of 5|
|||
|**1 Vacated, unexpired seat:**<br>**two-year term remaining**|**Number of Votes Received via Council**<br>**Ballot**|
|Richard Keefer|4 of 5|
|James Stutesman|1 of 5|



_**Vice Mayor Archie Pertiller made a motion to appoint Joseph Scotto for a second threeyear term, to appoint Nathan West for a second three-year term, and to appoint Richard Keefer to the unexpired vacated seat with a two-year term remaining on the Recreation Commission.  A vote of 5-0 in favor.**_ 

17 


{7}------------------------------------------------
|**Board/Commission**|**Member Name**|**Term Expires**|
|---|---|---|
|Recreation Commission|Joseph Scotto|7/1/2027|
|Recreation Commission|Nathan West|7/1/2027|
|Recreation Commission- unexpired term,<br>two-year term remaining.|Richard Keefer|7/1/2026|



****************** 

## **10) COMMUNICATION.** 

Attorney Brain Gulden stated work is continuing on the UDO draft. Town Manager Josh Harrold stated the Blue Ridge Rd. interchange project dates to begin construction has now been pushed back to 2026 by NCDOT. 

****************** 

## **11) COMMUNICATION FROM MAYOR AND TOWN COUNCIL.** 

Council Member Doug Hay complimented the Recreation and Parks and Public Works Departments on their work getting ready for the State Little League Tournament, and Council Member Pam King invited citizens to the Park Rhythms concerts. 

**************** **************** 

**12) CLOSED SESSION-** _none._ 

## **13) ADJOURNMENT-** _**With no further business to be discussed, Mayor C. Michael Sobol**_ 

## _**adjourned the meeting at 6:50 p.m.**_ 

C. Michael Sobol, Mayor 

ATTEST: 

_______________________ 

Wesley M. Barker, Town Clerk
