# City Council Meeting (Apr 9, 2024)

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** April 9, 2024 12:00 PM EDT (2024-04-09T12:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024
**Outcome:** Council discussed the FY25 budget, including a 4.11% pay raise and a $75 million bond package, and approved a motion to suspend rules 7-0.

## Summary

**Meeting Overview**
On April 9, 2024, the Asheville City Council held a work session focused on the development of the Fiscal Year 2025 (FY25) budget. The primary agenda items involved a review of employee compensation and benefits, an update on the General Fund budget, and a discussion regarding General Obligation (GO) bond packages for capital projects.

**Key Decisions**
The Council recorded one formal vote during the session. Councilwoman Maggie Ullman moved to suspend the Council rules pursuant to Rule 19(d) of the Asheville City Council Rules of Procedure in order to take action by vote. This motion passed with a 7-0 tally. While the document summaries indicate the Council reached a consensus to move forward with staff’s recommendation for a $75 million GO bond package in 2024 and another in 2028, the transcript summary notes that no formal votes were taken on the budget or bond proposals themselves, as the session was primarily a discussion and information-gathering phase.

**Discussion Highlights**
City Manager Deborah Campbell opened the session by highlighting that slowing revenue growth and increasing costs make it challenging to balance the budget, necessitating a reliance on fund balance. Finance Director Tony McDowell provided a detailed outline of the budget development process, including FY25 key dates and guiding principles. He explained that personnel costs represent 62% of General Fund Expenditures, while operating costs make up the remainder.

Regarding compensation, McDowell presented staff’s recommendation to provide a 4.11% increase to all employees. This proposal aims to meet the Just Economic Pledged Annual Living Wage for the lowest-paid employee and address pay compression. He noted that the employer’s contribution to benefits is 75%, with employee contributions at 16%. Council members raised concerns about the long-term sustainability of relying on fund balance to cover these salary increases and discussed the impact on employee morale.

The session also covered capital planning challenges associated with GO bonds. Staff recommended a total package of $75 million in 2024, with an additional GO bond vote scheduled for 2028. Potential project areas for these funds include housing, transportation, parks and recreation, and public safety. Additionally, the Council discussed the possibility of reinstating a retiree health benefits program, noting significant increases in healthcare program costs.

**Follow-ups**
Staff agreed to provide additional information and modeling on various compensation scenarios. The City Manager is to provide the Council with a memorandum addressing the information requested during the worksession, particularly regarding employee salaries and fund balance usage. Furthermore, the City Manager will coordinate with Buncombe County to present information to the Council regarding the county's appraisal practices and their potential impact on property taxes. Staff will utilize the feedback received to finalize the Manager’s Proposed Budget.

**Impact**
This work session set the stage for the upcoming budget cycle, with the Council scheduled to review the Manager’s proposed budget on May 14, 2024. Following that, a public hearing is set for May 28, 2024, and final budget adoption is scheduled for June 11, 2024. The discussions underscore the city's current fiscal constraints, specifically the tension between the need for competitive employee compensation and the limited growth in revenue, which may influence how residents see their tax dollars allocated between personnel costs and capital infrastructure projects in the coming years.

## Agenda

- [Present: Mayor Esther E. Manheimer, Presiding; Vice-Mayor Sandra Kilgore; Councilwoman S. Antanette Mosley; Councilwoman Kim Roney; Councilwoman Sheneika Smith; Councilwoman Sage Turner; Councilwoman Maggie Ullman; City Manager Debra Campbell; City Attorney Brad Branham; and City Clerk Magdalen Burleson](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10584) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10584.md))
- [City Manager Campbell said that today’s key takeaways will be (1) Slowing revenue growth and increasing costs make it challenging to fund new initiatives and will require us to use fund balance to balance the budget; (2) As a result, staff is recommending a focus on employee compensation, and capital funding via the November General Obligation (GO) Bond; (3) Staff is recommending a 4.11% pay increase for all employees, which will bring our lowest pay up to the Just Economics Pledged Living Wage and avoid causing additional compression issues; and (4) For the November GO Bond referendum staff is recommending a total package of $75M in 2024 with an additional GO Bond vote in 2028.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10585) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10585.md)) — starts at 4:15 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=255))
- [Finance Director Tony McDowell provided the following outline of his presentation: (1) Compensation & Benefits (a) Council scenario requests from prior workession; (b) Staff recommendation; and (c) Health care - employer and employee increases; (2) General Fund Budget Update; and (3) November 2024 GO Bond (a) Review options for size; (b) Update estimated taxpayer impacts; and (c) Staff recommendations on size and buckets.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10586) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10586.md)) — starts at 5:07 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=307))
- [He then reviewed the budget development process, Fiscal Year (FY) 25 budget key dates, guiding principals, and Council’s FY 25 priorities.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10587) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10587.md)) — starts at 5:07 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=307))
- [He provided Council with a recap of the key takeaways from th eMarch 26 worksession as follows: (1) Recommended budget will align with Council, community and organizational priorities; (2) Increasing costs are outpacing revenue growth in the General Fund. Therefore, will likely need to use revenue from Fund Balance; (3) Recruiting and retaining a talented workforce is essential to service delivery; and (4) GO bond will help address significant capital needs. He said today staff will respond to any questions from the March 26 worksession and provide staff recommendations since no other worksessions are currently scheduled.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10588) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10588.md)) — starts at 5:07 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=307))
- [Regarding compensation, he explained that the City’s General Fund Expenditures for personnel is 62%, operating costs are 22%, interfund transfers are 5% and capital and debt at 11%.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10589) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10589.md)) — starts at 5:07 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=307))
- [He said at the March 26 worksession Council requested information on (1) Flat dollar amount increase for all employees; (2) Cost to get employees to Just Economics pledged and full annual living wage rates; and (3) Other potential scenarios for employee compensation.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10590) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10590.md)) — starts at 12:15 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=735))
- [Staff’s recommendation is (1) Provide 4.11% increase to all employees, meeting Just Economic Pledged Annual Living Wage Rate; (2) Requires an additional $4.3 million; (3) Affordable within existing resources only with fund balance usage - Any compensation increase will require use of fund balance; and (4) Staff recommendation is similar to what other municipalities in Buncombe County are considering.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10591) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10591.md)) — starts at 12:51 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=771))
- [Regarding benefits, he explained that the employer’s contribution is 75%, the employee contributions are 16%, and the other is 9% - for a total of $19,022,937.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10592) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10592.md)) — starts at 1:04:08 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=3848))
- [He the provided a General Fund Budget update as follows: (1) Staff continues to refine revenue estimates - Growth now expected to be approximately 3.0%; (2) Adjusting salaries by 4.11% and budgeting health care cost increases will add about $4.6M to the General Fund base budget; and (3) Staff is estimating that fund balance usage will be similar to the $8.1M used in the current budget - May fall slightly under the 15% policy goal.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10593) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10593.md)) — starts at 1:04:36 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=3876))
- [He asked Council if they have issues or concerns with staff’s recommendation of a 4.11% salary increase for all employees and continued analysis of a retiree health benefit.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10594) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10594.md)) — starts at 1:20:17 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=4817))
- [Mr. McDowell then provided Council with the GO Bond March 26 recap, including the capital planning challenges and opportunities; identified general capital projects; “Steady State” voting; and potential property tax impact, noting that the figures are based on current values before 2025 revaluation.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10595) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10595.md)) — starts at 1:20:35 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=4835))
- [He said potential November 2024 referenda are (1) Housing (land banking, Housing Trust Fund support); (2) Transportation (street resurfacing, sidewalks, greenways); (3) Parks, Recreation and Entertainment (court/field renovations, recreation center improvements); and (4) Public Safety and Facilities (police/fire stations, building renovations).](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10596) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10596.md)) — starts at 1:20:35 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=4835))
- [At the March 26 worksession, Council requested information on (1) $100 million bond in 2024, followed by $50 million bond in 2028; and (2) Timeline for additional information about bond packages.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10597) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10597.md)) — starts at 1:20:35 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=4835))
- [He then provided Council with the referenda size and timing and why the four year cycle is the staff’s recommended timing (1) Show successful execution of projects before second vote; (2) Can adjust second vote based on changing conditions and needs; (3) Can alternate with County referenda; (4) Lower overall cost to property tax payers; and (5) Fewer referenda to communicate about and debt issuances (staff time & cost).](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10598) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10598.md)) — starts at 1:20:35 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=4835))
- [He then showed an example timeline of a large multi-year project.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10599) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10599.md)) — starts at 1:45:17 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6317))
- [He reviewed with Council why the $150 Million GO Bond package is the recommended amount (1) Meaningful, but achievable (a) Longer timeline to execute, but double 2016; and (b) Better prepared, lessons learned from 2016; (2) Reasonable taxpayer burden; and (3) Maintains safe amount of debt per capita.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10600) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10600.md)) — starts at 1:46:08 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6368))
- [He then showed the potential property impact of a property tax value of $350,788 - annual impact of 2 x $75 Million - $140; and 1 x $100 Million and 1 x $50 Million - $158.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10601) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10601.md)) — starts at 1:46:45 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6405))
- [He then reviewed the recent issuances by mid-size municipalities.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10602) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10602.md)) — starts at 1:48:19 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6499))
- [He then showed a chart of 2024 GO Bond categories with the $75 Million Scenario and the $100 Million Scenario.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10603) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10603.md)) — starts at 1:48:50 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6530))
- [Additional information on the GO Bond is (1) Provide more specific project information as part of overall capital plan in the City Manager’s Recommended Budget on May 14 - An itemized project list is not required for ballot; (2) Additional information over the course of required Council actions to include referenda on ballot; and (3) City Manager’s Office, CAPE, Finance & Management Services staff and outside organization(s) will coordinate information sharing with community leading up to November 2024 vote.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10604) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10604.md)) — starts at 1:51:19 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6679))
- [He then reviewed the GO Bond Council actions for the next meetings.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10605) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10605.md)) — starts at 1:51:45 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6705))
- [A summary of recommendation is (1) $75 million bond package in 2024 - Housing; Transportation; Parks, Rec & Entertainment; and Public Safety & Facilities; and (2) $75 million bond package in 2028.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10606) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10606.md)) — starts at 1:52:16 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6736))
- [He asked if Council had any issues or concerns with staff’s recommendation of a $75 Million 2024 GO Bond followed by a $75 Million 2028 GO Bond.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10607) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10607.md)) — starts at 1:52:16 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6736))
- [There was considerable discussion regarding compensation with the major concern being the use of Fund Balance to fund the employee salary piece.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10608) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10608.md)) — starts at 1:52:16 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6736))
- [There was considerable discussion regarding benefits, again with the major concern being the use of Fund Balance.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10609) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10609.md)) — starts at 1:52:16 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6736))
- [There was discussion regarding the General Fund budget update, with various questions/comments were responded to by City Manager Campbell and Mr. McDowell.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10610) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10610.md)) — starts at 1:52:16 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6736))
- [There was discussion regarding the GO Bonds, with various questions/comments were responded to by City Manager Campbell and Mr. McDowell.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10611) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10611.md)) — starts at 1:52:16 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6736))
- [It was the consensus of Council to have City Manager Campbell provide Council with a memorandum containing the information requested at this worksession.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10612) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10612.md)) — starts at 1:52:16 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6736))
- [Mayor Manheimer said that it looks like the only outstanding issue is how to do employee salaries, without using Fund Balance.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10613) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10613.md)) — starts at 1:52:16 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=6736))
- [Mayor Manheimer said that the City can only inform and educate.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10614) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10614.md)) — starts at 2:19:15 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=8355))
- [Councilwoman Ullman moved, pursuant to Rule 19 (d) of the Asheville City Council Rules of Procedure, to suspend the Council rules in order to take action by vote during the present worksession. This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Smith and carried unanimously.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10615) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10615.md)) — starts at 2:19:37 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=8377))
  Vote: Councilwoman Ullman moved, pursuant to Rule 19 (d) of the Asheville City Council Rules of Procedure, to suspend the Council rules in order to take action by vote during the present worksession. — Passed; 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024#vote-4239))
- [## Closed Session](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10616) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10616.md)) — starts at 2:19:54 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=8394))
- [Councilwoman Ullman moved to go into closed session for the following reasons: (1) to prevent disclosure of information that is privileged and confidential, pursuant to the laws of North Carolina, or a public record within the meaning of Chapter 132 of the General Statutes. The law that makes the information privileged and confidential is N.C.G.S. 143-318.10(a)(1). The statutory authorization is contained in N.C.G.S. 143-318.10 (e); and (2) To consult with an attorney employed by the City about the handling of a claim with respect to which the attorney-client privilege between the City and its attorney must be preserved, including, but not limited to the handling of the following matter: Chris and Kelly Dunbar, individually and as Trustees for the Chris and Kelly Dunbar Trust v. City of Asheville and Buncombe County, acting by and through their joint Historic Resources Commission, Buncombe County Superior Court File Number 23-CVS-4147. The statutory authorization is N.C. Gen. Stat. sec. 143-318.11(a)(3).](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10617) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10617.md)) — starts at 2:20:44 ([watch](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024?t=8444))
- [At 5:34 p.m., Vice-Mayor Kilgore moved to come out of closed session.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10618) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10618.md))
- [Mayor Manheimer adjourned the meeting at 5:34 p.m.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10619) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/item/10619.md))

## Votes

- Councilwoman Ullman moved, pursuant to Rule 19 (d) of the Asheville City Council Rules of Procedure, to suspend the Council rules in order to take action by vote during the present worksession. — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024#vote-4239))

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/live/aA5fctF2bp0?si=Sl4jfNq7FYtt8YyL
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/1321/segments

## Documents

- [minutes_2024-04-09.pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/1929/documents/4315/minutes-2024-04-09)

## Sources

- [City of Asheville WordPress](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/meetings/city-council-meeting-apr-9-2024/)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
