# City Council Meeting (Jan 10, 2023)

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** January 10, 2023 12:00 PM EST (2023-01-10T12:00:00-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023
**Outcome:** Council adopted the 2023 budget calendar and legislative agenda, reduced the Human Relations Commission to nine members, and established a review committee for the water outages.

## Summary

The City Council adopted the 2023 Budget Calendar by a vote of 7-0, establishing the schedule for the development of the Fiscal Year 2023-24 budget, which includes a public hearing on May 23, 2023, and final adoption on June 13, 2023. The Council also passed a resolution 7-0 to adopt the 2023 City Council Legislative Agenda, directing the City Attorney to share the document with the local delegation in the North Carolina General Assembly. This agenda outlines the city’s legislative priorities for the year, including opposition to limits on short-term rental regulation, support for affordable housing funding, and support for state and federal reparations efforts.

In the consent agenda, the Council unanimously approved several items, including a resolution to ratify a contract with Daikin Applied Americas Inc. for emergency safety repairs to the HVAC system at Harrah’s Cherokee Center - Asheville. The Council also passed an ordinance 7-0 to reduce the total number of members on the Human Relations Commission of Asheville from 15 to 9, allowing up to three members to be non-city residents who reside within Buncombe County. Additionally, the Council approved a resolution 7-0 setting a public hearing for February 14, 2023, to consider closing an unopened right-of-way connecting to the east side of Buncombe Street.

The Council authorized the City Manager to execute a change order to the contract with Motorola Solutions Inc. by a vote of 7-0, adding station alerting equipment at the Broadway Public Safety Station. By a vote of 7-0, the Council authorized the execution of grant agreements with the Buncombe County Tourism Development Authority and adopted a budget amendment in the amount of $6,458,425 from the Tourism Product Development Fund. These funds are allocated to four projects: the Swannanoa River Greenway ($2,300,000), Coxe Avenue Green Street ($1,950,000), Asheville Municipal Golf Course Revitalization Phase I ($1,641,425), and WNC Nature Center - Gateway to the Southern Appalachians Enhancement ($576,000). The Council also approved a resolution to execute a contract amendment with Equinox Environmental Consultation and Design for the Swannanoa River Greenway Phase II.

The Council adopted an ordinance amending Chapter 15 of the Code of Ordinances to prohibit the use of plastic bags for curbside brush and leaf collection, effective August 1, 2023. The Council established a nine-member independent review committee to assess the city’s response to the December 2022 water outages and infrastructure needs. The Council appointed Jesse Warren to the Asheville City Schools Board of Education and approved various appointments to boards and commissions, including the Board of Adjustment, Historic Resource Commission, and Urban Forestry Commission.

## Discussion Highlights

The primary focus of the meeting was the response to recent water outages in southern and western Asheville. City Manager Deborah Campbell stated, "We regret that this happened, and we are taking immediate and long-term steps to prevent and minimize this event... from occurring again." Water Resources Director David Melton explained the complexity of the outage, noting that system pressures can exceed 400 pounds and average 170 pounds, which speaks to the city's topography. He clarified that the decision to isolate the southern system was made to preserve as much of the water system in service as possible, stating that without separation, the city would have had a boil water advisory for the whole system.

Regarding the independent review committee, a friendly amendment was proposed to add the descriptor "disaster specialist" to the "emergency response professional" role. A Councilmember asked if the current role was sufficient, and the Chief responded, "I think that it would be impossible to have somebody that... disaster management and emergency preparedness are the same discipline. So I think that would absolutely capture those concerns with that representative." Mayor Esther Manheimer provided historical context on funding constraints, stating, "We're sort of... doing the best job we can do with our fiscal arm tied behind our back," and noted significant investments like the $38.5 million North Fork Reservoir Project.

City Attorney Brad Branham presented the 2023 Legislative Agenda, stating, "It is the largest legislative agenda that we've put together in my time as city attorney." He highlighted nine items, including opposing limits on short-term rental regulation and supporting affordable housing funding. Assistant City Manager Ben Woody addressed communications during the outage, stating, "I think we were pretty conservative in terms of... not over promising and under delivering at times we just didn't have enough information that we felt comfortable putting out that information." He apologized to residents and businesses for the inconvenience.

## Community Input

During public comment on the consent agenda, one commenter expressed concern that the city was allocating funds for greenways and Cox Avenue renovations while lacking money for proper water system maintenance, stating, "I don't blame you or council. I know that it's been a tough week." No member or staff responded. Another commenter criticized the 2023 budget calendar for offering only one opportunity for public comment on budget priorities before the May 23rd hearing and requested a "people's budget" and participatory budgeting. No member or staff responded.

Regarding the water outage, a resident of a HUD-subsidized building in South Asheville described the outage as a "public health crisis" and a "betrayal of public trust," noting some neighbors were without water for 10 days or more. A West Asheville homeowner and emergency management professional supported the committee but requested the inclusion of a disaster recovery specialist and representation for the rental population. A lifelong South Asheville resident warned that past task force recommendations were often ignored. A representative for Congressman Chuck Edwards thanked the Council for their responsiveness. A resident argued the issue is a "money problem" rather than a water problem, citing state laws that prevent Asheville from charging differential rates to out-of-city customers. A resident highlighted the lack of communication, noting the city took two days to acknowledge the outage and initially withheld maps. An urban farmer in West Asheville expressed interest in serving on the committee and thanked Councilmember Sage Turner for visiting the Candler area.

In general public comments, a representative for businesses on Cox Avenue criticized the allocation of tourism development funds to street cleaning as a "bandaid on a broken leg." A resident criticized the city for initially withholding outage maps due to "consumer privacy" or "homeland security" concerns. The Secretary of the Asheville Pickleball Association expressed appreciation for the Council and Parks & Rec in negotiating a shared court concept. A resident stated that "actionable buy-in is a lot more efficient at establishing public trust than PR spin."

## Follow-ups

The Assistant City Manager outlined a proposed timeline for the independent review committee: Council to appoint members on January 24; the County Commission to appoint members on February 7; the committee to begin analysis immediately and provide an update in 30 days (mid-to-late March); and a final report within 90 days (mid-to-late May). The Assistant City Manager confirmed that staff has already begun replacing, sealing, and enclosing equipment at the Mills River treatment plant and other plants to prevent future cold-weather failures. The Assistant City Manager stated that the fire department selected Persis Consulting to help move forward with continuity of operations and emergency operation plans, which is scheduled to come to council for contract approval on January 24. The Clerk’s Office will re-advertise the open seats for the Asheville Area Riverfront Development Commission and the Audit Committee, as no eligible applications were received. During the yard waste ordinance discussion, the Sustainability Director agreed to provide data updates on the city’s performance toward its goal of reducing waste by 50% by 2035.

## Impact

The establishment of the independent review committee aims to provide a comprehensive account of the December 2022 water outages and assess the city’s operational, emergency response, and communication efforts. The committee will analyze needed infrastructure, process, and policy changes to maximize prevention and improve future response and mitigation. The adoption of the 2023 Legislative Agenda provides direction to the city’s local delegation in the North Carolina General Assembly regarding legislative priorities, including short-term rental regulation, affordable housing, and fair housing protections. The reduction of the Human Relations Commission from 15 to 9 members is intended to make it easier to achieve quorum and alleviate recruitment difficulties. The prohibition of plastic bags for curbside brush and leaf collection supports the city’s goal to reduce waste by 50% by 2035 and improves staff safety and community cleanliness. The approval of tourism development grant funds supports capital improvement projects that have a significant connection to tourism development, including the Swannanoa River Greenway and Coxe Avenue Green Street.

## Agenda

- [Adoption of a resolution approving the 2023 Legislative Agenda and direction to share with Asheville’s Local Delegation](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/46444) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/46444.md))
- [Motion to adopt the 2023 Budget Calendar](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48731) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48731.md))
  Vote: Motion to adopt the 2023 Budget Calendar — Passed; 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14869))
- [Resolution to ratify the execution of a contract with Daikin Applied Americas Inc. for safety repairs to the HVAC system at Harrah’s Cherokee Center - Asheville](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48732) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48732.md))
  Vote: Resolution to ratify the execution of a contract with Daikin Applied Americas Inc. for safety repairs to the HVAC system at Harrah’s Cherokee Center - Asheville — Passed; 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14870))
- [Ordinance to reduce the total number of members on the Human Relations Commission of Asheville from 15 to 9](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48733) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48733.md))
  Vote: Ordinance to reduce the total number of members on the Human Relations Commission of Asheville from 15 to 9, retaining existing members until their present term expires, resignation, or removal; and to allow up to 3 members to be non-city residents who currently reside within Buncombe County — Passed; 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14871))
- [Resolution setting a public hearing on February 14, 2023, to consider closing an unopened right-of-way connecting to the east side of Buncombe Street](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48734) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48734.md))
  Vote: Resolution setting a public hearing on February 14, 2023, to consider closing an unopened right-of-way connecting to the east side of Buncombe Street between Commerce Street and Aston Street, and declaring its intent to close this right-of-way — Passed; 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14872))
- [Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a change order to the contract with Motorola Solutions Inc.](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48735) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48735.md))
  Vote: Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a change order to the contract with Motorola Solutions Inc. to add additional station alerting equipment at the Broadway Public Safety Station — Passed; 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14873))
- [Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute grant agreements with the Buncombe County Tourism Development Authority](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48736) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48736.md))
  Vote: Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute grant agreements with the Buncombe County Tourism Development Authority for Tourism Product Development grant funds — Passed; 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14874))
- [Budget amendment in the amount of $6,458,425 from the Buncombe County Tourism Development Authority Tourism Product Development Fund](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48737) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48737.md))
  Vote: Budget amendment, in the amount of $6,458,425, from the Buncombe County Tourism Development Authority Tourism Product Development Fund to fund the (1) Swannanoa River Greenway in the amount of $2,300,000; (2) Coxe Avenue Green Street in the amount of $1,950,000; (3) Asheville Municipal Golf Course Revitalization Phase I in the amount of $1,641,425; and (4) WNC Nature Center - Gateway to the Southern Appalachians Enhancement in the amount of $576,000 — Passed; 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14875))
- [Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract amendment with Equinox Environmental Consultation and Design](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48738) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48738.md))
- [Manager’s Report - Recognition of Sanitation Workers for Assisting residents in Need](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48739) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48739.md))
- [Public hearing to consider adoption of the South Slope: A Southside Neighborhood Vision Plan](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48740) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48740.md))
- [Ordinance amending Chapter 15, Solid Waste Management, of the Code of Ordinances related to yard waste collection](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48741) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48741.md))
- [Resolution adopting the 2023 City Council Legislative Agenda](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48742) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48742.md))
  Vote: Resolution adopting the 2023 City Council Legislative Agenda — Passed; 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14879))
- [Resolution establishing an independent review committee focused on reviewing the water outage](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48743) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48743.md))
- [Resolution appointing a member to the Asheville City Schools Board of Education](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48744) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48744.md))
  Vote: Resolution appointing a member to the Asheville City Schools Board of Education — Passed; 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14881))
- [Boards & Commissions Appointments and Reappointments](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48745) ([markdown](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/item/48745.md))

## Votes

- Motion to adopt the 2023 Budget Calendar — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14869))
- Resolution to ratify the execution of a contract with Daikin Applied Americas Inc. for safety repairs to the HVAC system at Harrah’s Cherokee Center - Asheville — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14870))
- Ordinance to reduce the total number of members on the Human Relations Commission of Asheville from 15 to 9, retaining existing members until their present term expires, resignation, or removal; and to allow up to 3 members to be non-city residents who currently reside within Buncombe County — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14871))
- Resolution setting a public hearing on February 14, 2023, to consider closing an unopened right-of-way connecting to the east side of Buncombe Street between Commerce Street and Aston Street, and declaring its intent to close this right-of-way — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14872))
- Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a change order to the contract with Motorola Solutions Inc. to add additional station alerting equipment at the Broadway Public Safety Station — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14873))
- Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute grant agreements with the Buncombe County Tourism Development Authority for Tourism Product Development grant funds — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14874))
- Budget amendment, in the amount of $6,458,425, from the Buncombe County Tourism Development Authority Tourism Product Development Fund to fund the (1) Swannanoa River Greenway in the amount of $2,300,000; (2) Coxe Avenue Green Street in the amount of $1,950,000; (3) Asheville Municipal Golf Course Revitalization Phase I in the amount of $1,641,425; and (4) WNC Nature Center - Gateway to the Southern Appalachians Enhancement in the amount of $576,000 — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14875))
- Resolution adopting the 2023 City Council Legislative Agenda — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14879))
- Resolution appointing a member to the Asheville City Schools Board of Education — Passed, 7-0 ([link](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023#vote-14881))

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/live/9_9wEy0JxRQ?feature=share
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2537/segments

## Documents

- [action_agenda_2023-01-10.pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26303/action-agenda-2023-01-10)
- [minutes_2023-01-10.pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26319/minutes-2023-01-10)
- [Consent A - December 13.pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26518/consent-a-december-13)
- [Consent B - Budget Calendar (3).pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26513/consent-b-budget-calendar-3)
- [Consent C - Harrah's HVAC Emergency Repair Contract.pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26501/consent-c-harrahs-hvac-emergency-repair-contract)
- [Consent F - Broadway Public Safety Station (3).pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26483/consent-f-broadway-public-safety-station-3)
- [New B - Presentation - Water Outage (2).pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26335/new-b-presentation-water-outage-2)
- [New B - REVISED Independent Review Com-Water (1).pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26351/new-b-revised-independent-review-com-water-1)
- [Manager's Report - Employee Recognition (1).pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26371/managers-report-employee-recognition-1)
- [Agenda - January 10.pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26388/agenda-january-10)
- [New D - Master January Bd and Com Appointments.pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26402/new-d-master-january-bd-and-com-appointments)
- [New A - Legislative Agenda - 2023 (1).pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26417/new-a-legislative-agenda-2023-1)
- [New C - School Board Appointment.pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26428/new-c-school-board-appointment)
- [Consent H - Swannanoa Greenway Ph 2.pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26445/consent-h-swannanoa-greenway-ph-2)
- [Unfinished A - Plastic Bags Prohibited in Brush and Leaf Collection.pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26462/unfinished-a-plastic-bags-prohibited-in-brush-and-leaf-collection)
- [Consent D - HRCA Membership.pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26507/consent-d-hrca-membership)
- [Consent G - TPDF Awards.pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26472/consent-g-tpdf-awards)
- [Consent E - Intent to close a ROW Buncombe Street .pdf](https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4418/documents/26493/consent-e-intent-to-close-a-row-buncombe-street)

## Sources

- [City of Asheville WordPress](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/meetings/city-council-meeting-jan-10-2023/)
- [Resolutions](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1IRhqD3OFBOekaXRv7M_cUN4s_feeUhnE/view?usp=share_link)
- [Ordinances](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1OiTtJ1-tpXO3kAIeAPdfNahGZkjENJmZ/view?usp=share_link)
- [Public Input](https://publicinput.com/n7387)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
