# Equity & Engagement Committee – December 15, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Equity and Engagement Committee
**Date:** December 15, 2023 11:32 AM EST (2023-12-15T11:32:38-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4618/equity-engagement-committee-december-15-2023
**Outcome:** The Equity and Engagement Committee approved the November 30 minutes and discussed the Juneteenth program shift and language accessibility assessment.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Equity and Engagement Committee convened on December 15, 2023, to review ongoing equity initiatives and approve recent records. The agenda covered updates on holiday celebrations, reparations efforts, technology upgrades for community spaces, and language accessibility improvements.

## Key Decisions
The only formal action taken at this meeting was the approval of the minutes from the November 30, 2023 meeting. A roll call vote was conducted, with Councilwoman Roni and Councilwoman Turner voting "Aye." The Chair stated, "Myself and the motion carries," resulting in the approval of the minutes. No votes were taken on the other agenda items, which were presented as informational updates or discussions without a request for a formal decision.

## Discussion Highlights
The committee received an update on the three-year contract renewal (2024–2026) with the Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Association of Asheville-Buncombe County. The Director of Community and Regional Entertainment Facilities explained that the Juneteenth program is shifting from a single large festival to a week-long series of events, including lunch-and-learns, a distinguished speaker reception, a gala, and a collaboration with the Asheville Downtown Association for a "Downtown After 5" event. The Director noted that the previous festival model required significant staff time with limited revenue opportunities to offset costs, stating, "The big challenge with the festival is just there's a lot of work and staff time... come to put together for that. Not a lot of great revenue opportunities to offset the costs. And so this is trying to really... spread out the event over a week and not have one big festival that has the opportunity to really just become like a big party downtown with a lot of with lack of controls."

Regarding the Community Reparations Commission (CRC), the Director of Equity and Inclusion provided a monthly update on budget reviews, the status of the "cease to harm" audit, and the CRC’s request to extend their timeline. Councilwoman Roney expressed concern about lingering confusion in the community regarding the extension and the City's support, stating, "I just know that if I can continue to have one-on-one phone calls and one-on-one emails, but there's still like a general confusion as at an organizational level... that might help."

The committee also discussed the completion of the Language Accessibility Assessment. Councilwoman Roney emphasized the importance of internal capacity before external advertising, noting, "One of the things that I learned doing radio is that if you just put stuff on a website that's in Spanish, but then we're not ready to serve people in Spanish is skipping a really important step of belonging." Councilwoman Turner expressed enthusiasm for training existing staff rather than only recruiting new hires, saying, "I'm excited by the out of the box thinking that we would just offer training to our staff instead of just trying to recruit more staff. I love it." Additionally, the Director of Communications & Public Engagement clarified that high scores on the Climate Justice Index do not automatically determine site selection for the ARPA Upfit Community Space project, stating, "I want to make sure everybody listening in today understands that just because there is a high CJI score, that's not the be all end all. There's other considerations that will need to be taken into consideration, one of those being the resources that are available in an area."

## Follow-ups
The Director of Communications & Public Engagement explicitly agreed to share the committee’s feedback on language accessibility priorities with different departments that might have budgeting opportunities in these areas. This feedback included prioritizing stipends for bilingual employees, external language education, and language access standards in contracting. No other explicit follow-up commitments were made by staff or members.

## Impact
These discussions highlight the City’s ongoing efforts to refine how it supports community events and addresses equity gaps. The shift in the Juneteenth programming aims to create a more sustainable and controlled event structure, while the language accessibility work focuses on ensuring that internal staff capabilities match external communications to better serve non-English speaking residents. The updates on the Community Reparations Commission and the technology upgrades for vulnerable neighborhoods provide residents with visibility into the progress and challenges of these major equity initiatives.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=woUm2Hw_vP0
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2473/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=woUm2Hw_vP0)
