# Planning & Economic Development – December 11, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Planning, Economic Development and Environment Committee
**Date:** December 11, 2023 4:02 PM EST (2023-12-11T16:02:36-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4626/planning-economic-development-december-11-2023
**Outcome:** The Planning, Economic Development and Environment Committee heard the Missing Middle Housing Study and continued the Public Arts and Cultural Commission update to the January 8 meeting.

## Summary

The Planning, Economic Development and Environment Committee of the City of Asheville held a remote meeting on December 11, 2023. The only formal vote taken during the session was to approve the minutes from the previous meeting, which passed by roll call. The Public Arts and Cultural Commission update was continued and scheduled to be heard at the January 8, 2024 meeting. The Missing Middle Housing Study was presented for information sharing only, with no vote taken on the study itself at this time.

## Discussion Highlights
The primary focus of the meeting was an informational presentation on the final draft of the Missing Middle Housing Study, a project that cost $115,000 plus staff time. Staff from the Planning and Urban Design Department presented findings indicating that a continued focus on single-family housing production will not sufficiently address the city’s housing shortage or price attainability. The study noted that two-thirds of residential zoning districts currently disallow "missing middle" housing types, such as duplexes, triplexes, quads, live-work spaces, and small multiplexes. Financial modeling included in the study suggested that allowing more units on the same land spreads costs, bringing unit prices closer to the 80–120% Area Median Income range, which is identified as the largest housing gap in Asheville.

The presentation also included a risk assessment map using a green/yellow/red system to identify neighborhoods vulnerable to displacement. Green areas were designated as "ready" for missing middle housing, while red areas indicated high vulnerability requiring caution and anti-displacement strategies. The study identifies 43 recommendations and 14 anti-displacement strategies, recommending the development of a missing middle housing plan and the broader allowance of these housing types in appropriate areas.

Committee members expressed strong support for the study’s direction. Chair Sandra Kilgore stated, "I am very excited to see this report... I think that it addresses a lot of the problems we've had here in Asheville as far as builders... these options here actually give them options where a lot of builders will be able to build the multi-family units and it's still balanced out, comes out on the balance sheet." Councilwoman Maggie Omen added, "I read this like with joy... I think this is just very much taking the council goals and priorities and the community's needs and moving it forward really substantially for us to work on." Councilwoman Sage Turner highlighted the importance of addressing the 80-120% income range, stating, "I have this growing concern that while we are doing everything we can to tackle the deepest affordability, we're leaving a whole group out and in some regards kind of forcing them into their own different kind of poverty and cost burdening them as a result. So I'm thrilled we're talking about that." Stephanie Monson Dahl, Director of Planning & Urban Design, emphasized the department's commitment to the process, noting, "We really want to make sure that you're okay with our approach, which is continued, prolonged community engagement throughout this year... We're coming to you guys very, very soon in January for full council." Urban Planner 3 Vidilla Satvika contributed, "The solution to housing is not going to be more incentives for single family housing construction... whatever policy decisions we make should reflect that."

## Community Input
One public commenter spoke during the public comment period, offering three main points regarding the study. First, the commenter agreed with opening up more housing options but cautioned against further restricting existing allowances, such as multiple single-family residences on a property, noting that Asheville’s topography makes large footprints difficult. Second, the commenter emphasized that the report is "zoning heavy" but lacks sufficient consideration of infrastructure, including water, sewer, and stormwater, suggesting that density decisions should be based on where infrastructure exists. Third, the commenter highlighted a finding from Raleigh’s "Missing Middle 2.0" study suggesting that flag lots are one of the least causes of displacement, as they allow property owners to retain their homes while participating in development. In response, Councilwoman Sage Turner stated, "Barry, if you're still listening, please send us that round two Raleigh study."

## Follow-ups
Staff committed to several specific actions following the presentation. Stephanie Monson Dahl stated that the department’s approach will include "continued, prolonged community engagement throughout this year" and proposed a monthly cadence of check-ins with the PED Committee starting in February to discuss implementation strategies and progress. Staff agreed to include an assessment of "low hanging fruit" (quick wins) in the staff report for the January 9 Full Council meeting, specifically identifying which strategies can be executed before the budget year turns. Additionally, staff acknowledged a request from Councilwoman Sage Turner to provide an email follow-up regarding whether the city is still expediting affordable housing projects through the Growth and Development department. Staff also confirmed that Flag Lots and Cottage Clusters will be presented to Full Council in January, alongside the Missing Middle Housing Study.

## Impact
This meeting marks a significant step in Asheville's housing strategy, moving from conceptual studies to actionable planning. The Missing Middle Housing Study provides a framework for increasing housing production beyond single-family homes, which staff and committee members agreed is necessary to address the city's housing shortage and improve price attainability for residents in the 80–120% Area Median Income range. The inclusion of anti-displacement strategies and a risk assessment map indicates an effort to balance development with the protection of vulnerable neighborhoods. The study will be presented to Full Council on January 9, 2024, where it may inform future zoning changes and housing policies.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ayvEPww2Wfc
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2484/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ayvEPww2Wfc)
