# City Council Work Session – November 14, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** November 14, 2023 3:31 PM EST (2023-11-14T15:31:21-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4643/city-council-work-session-november-14-2023
**Outcome:** Council heard staff recommendations to finance $11.3 million in parking garage repairs and include the Municipal Building renovation in the 2025 Capital Improvement Plan.

## Summary

On November 14, 2023, the Asheville City Council held a work session to review two major infrastructure presentations: the second part of the Comprehensive Facility Study and an assessment of the city’s parking garages. The session focused on the long-term planning and financial implications of maintaining and upgrading city-owned assets, specifically the Municipal Building, the Parkside site, and the four downtown parking structures.

**Key Decisions and Recommendations**
No formal votes were taken during this work session. However, staff presented specific recommendations for future action. For the parking garages, staff recommended financing approximately $11.3 million in immediate and base repairs through the Parking Enterprise Fund using a limited obligation bond over a 20-25 year period. Staff also recommended establishing a recurring budget of $1 million per year, adjusted for inflation, to maintain the garages for the next 30 years, starting in 2026. Regarding the facility study, staff recommended that the plan to renovate the Municipal Building for the Police Department and build a new Fire Department headquarters at the Parkside site be included in the 2025 Capital Improvement Plan (CIP).

**Discussion Highlights**
The Comprehensive Facility Study presentation, led by Walter Eyre, Building Construction Program Manager, and City Manager Deborah Campbell, used the Municipal Building and Parkside sites as a case study for capital project processes. Eyre noted that the 1925 Municipal Building currently has a space deficit of approximately 13,000 square feet, which is projected to grow to 17,000 square feet in the future. The proposed conceptual plan involves moving the Fire Department Headquarters and Station 1 to a new structure at the 2.4-acre Parkside site (Phase C1) to allow for the renovation of the Municipal Building for the Police Department (Phase B1). Eyre emphasized that the city is at a "tipping point" where reinvestment is necessary to establish a regular maintenance schedule. He described the Municipal Building as a "workhorse" where the cost to renovate and relocate is high.

The parking garage assessment, presented by Walker Consultants, highlighted that the four city-owned garages (Harris-Cherokee, Wall Street, Rankin, and Biltmore Avenue) require immediate attention. Enrique Villalobos, P.E., of Walker Consultants, stated that deferring repairs would result in more costly and complex work in the future, and that tearing down and rebuilding the structures would be twice as expensive as maintaining them. A parking study indicated that while weekday utilization is low, weekend utilization exceeds efficiency thresholds. The study recommends demand-based pricing and moving monthly and contract parkers to the less utilized Harris-Cherokee garage to free up space for visitors.

During the Q&A, Mayor Esther Manheimer raised concerns about the funding source, asking, "The elephant in the room that we haven't talked about yet is where's all this money come from?" She noted the council would need to consider the equities of funding capital projects with property taxes. Council members also expressed concern about the impact of increased parking rates on local residents. One council member noted that without a way to charge tourists more than locals, the costs would fall on residents. Another council member expressed worry about increasing rates while downtown workers struggle, requesting historic revenue data by deck to better inform rate decisions.

**Follow-ups**
Staff members agreed to several specific follow-up actions. Walter Eyre agreed to perform additional calculations on the feasibility of building taller on the Municipal Building site through adaptive reuse. A staff member from the Finance department, referred to as Tony, agreed to build a financial model to determine the debt service cost of financing the $11.3 million parking repair over 20-25 years. Additionally, this staff member agreed to pull historic revenue data for the parking fund and previous repair investments to assist in rate decision-making. Walter Eyre also stated that staff will identify opportunities to review other facility sites beyond the Municipal Building and Parkside in the coming months.

**Next Steps**
Finance-led capital work sessions are scheduled for December. The Council will review the Capital Improvement Plan later this year. Mayor Manheimer also referenced a separate General Obligation (GEO) bond issue expected on the November ballot, noting it was not part of this work session's decisions.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X2HnLPP1l_I
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2498/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X2HnLPP1l_I)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
