# Downtown Commission – October 27, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Downtown Commission
**Date:** October 27, 2023 9:00 AM EDT (2023-10-27T09:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4654/downtown-commission-october-27-2023
**Outcome:** The Downtown Commission discussed a plan to update design guidelines and reviewed a proposal to convert two buildings into a 15-room hotel.

## Summary

The Downtown Commission of the City of Asheville convened on October 27, 2023, to address public safety, design guidelines, development impacts, and city updates. The meeting began with the unanimous approval of action minutes from the August and September 22 meetings. No public comments were recorded during the initial designated comment period. The meeting concluded with a unanimous motion to adjourn, and the commission agreed to schedule the next meeting for December 15, 2023, moving it from the originally planned date of the day after Thanksgiving.

**Public Safety and Homelessness Updates**
Deputy Chief Mike Lamb of the Asheville Police Department presented crime statistics, noting that downtown violent crime is 21% lower year-to-date compared to 2022 and 24% lower than the five-year average. This decrease was attributed to increased proactive enforcement. Assistant City Manager Ben Woody provided an update on homelessness services and city partnerships. He committed to attend the commission every other month to discuss public safety and cleanliness and requested that commission members encourage constituents and stakeholders to subscribe to the new monthly city newsletter to stay informed on these issues.

**Design Guidelines and Development Review**
Staff presented a plan to update the outdated 2009-2010 design guidelines, which involves forming an informal working group and utilizing a $50,000 budget for architectural consulting. Staff members Dana Frankel and David will follow up with commission members to identify interest in serving on this working group. The commission also conducted a Level 1 review of a project converting two existing residential/commercial structures into a 15-room hotel. This review sparked a broader discussion regarding hotel development, community benefits, and displacement.

**Community Input and Strategic Discussion**
During the hotel review, a public commenter expressed frustration that current hotel rates are high, citing examples of $600/night, and that recommendations for community benefits lack enforcement power. The commenter inquired about commitments to living wages or price caps. Vice Chair Eva Michelle Spicer acknowledged the commenter’s concerns, stating that the commission has shared this frustration for a year. She noted that while the commission currently lacks direct enforcement power, it is exploring procedural changes, such as requiring community benefits tables earlier in the application process. Commissioner Jefferson Ellison expressed skepticism that living wage requirements would be met by hotels. Vice Chair Spicer emphasized that the commission has the power to change the hotel overlay district, including adjusting the room number that triggers points and modifying the point scale, advocating for a proactive rather than a reactive approach.

**Staff Updates and Follow-Up Actions**
Staff provided updates on the Patton Avenue sidewalk project, the outdoor dining program, Carter-Ann-Patton stormwater work, and the upcoming Patton Avenue Corridor Study. Commissioner Steven Lee Johnson expressed concern that the horizontal development review process is not adequately addressing pedestrian experience, community benefits, stormwater, or heat island effects. Discussion continued on the potential for the city council to open the hotel overlay district for changes to codify new standards, as well as the ongoing bid process for the "Clean and Safe" initiative. Assistant City Manager Ben Woody explained that the city is adding peer support response to the Community Responder Program, creating a multidisciplinary team that includes trained peers alongside firefighters. Chair Bryan Moffitt indicated an interest in learning more about this program’s specifics.

Several follow-up actions were identified during the meeting. Staff members Dana Frankel and David will contact commission members to gauge interest in the design guidelines working group. Staff member Dana Frankel plans to present updates on public benefits achieved from hotels to the Planning and Economic Development Committee of Council in January and requested that commission members share key points to inform these discussions. Vice Chair Eva Michelle Spicer proposed an informal, non-public "pub meeting" for interested members to refine details on hotel reviews and community benefits before formal council sessions. Additionally, the chair suggested asking the Asheville Downtown Association (ADA) to conduct a lighting survey alongside their sidewalk surveys, and staff noted that a new dashboard for lighting outages is available via the Asheville app.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KwmlCFvNPiA
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2514/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KwmlCFvNPiA)
