# Environment & Safety Committee – October 24, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Environment and Safety Committee
**Date:** October 24, 2023 11:00 AM EDT (2023-10-24T11:00:23-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4656/environment-safety-committee-october-24-2023

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Environment and Safety Committee held a remote meeting on October 24, 2023. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, updates on emergency preparedness, a review of police and fire department operations, and public comment.

## Key Decisions
The committee voted unanimously (3 Ayes, 0 Nays) to approve the minutes from the September 26 meeting. Additionally, the committee voted unanimously (3 Ayes, 0 Nays) to support the Fire Department’s Community Responder Program by using opioid settlement funding for program expansion. This motion was forwarded to the full Council for further consideration.

## Discussion Highlights
Staff provided an update on the finalization of the Emergency Operations Plan (EOP) and Continuity of Operations Plan (COOP), highlighting the new Emergency Operations Center located at the Broadway Public Safety Station. City Manager Deborah Campbell noted that the city has been implementing the plan as they have gone along due to recent incidents, stating, "It is working for our organization."

Deputy Police Chief Mike Lamb presented the APD Quarterly Crime Update, reporting a decline in violent crime compared to 2022, though levels remain higher than the previous four years, and a continued decline in property crime from 2019 highs. The discussion covered resource deployment, drone usage, and the balance between enforcement and community service. Deputy Chief Lamb emphasized the department's focus on community engagement, stating, "Our greatest concern tool being out here is relationship building... The amount of enforcement that we do is very small... It’s more about relationship building and being more of a presence, trusting presence within the community." Councilwoman Shanika Smith questioned the geographic distribution of these proactive efforts, asking, "What are we doing for other geographic areas that kind of need that proactive approach as well?"

Assistant Fire Chief Patrick Crudup presented the results of the Community Responder Pilot Program, stating, "The Community Responder Pilot Program is considered a success and staff plans to transition it to a permanent program service within AFD." Chair Maggie Ullman also raised the topic of Civilian Traffic Investigators, noting that Burlington, North Carolina, has started a similar virtual response unit, and expressed a desire to start the conversation on implementing such a unit in Asheville.

## Community Input
During the first round of public comment, a resident expressed concern that recent crime updates lacked depth, specifically noting that a reported drop in rape statistics did not align with the five-year trend line, and requested that the city look at 10-year trends. No specific member responded directly to this comment. Another resident from West Asheville raised concerns about an APD operation targeting 62 repeat offenders for low-level offenses, arguing that mass citations push individuals deeper into the criminal justice system rather than providing rehabilitation. Vice Mayor Sandra Kilgore responded by asking Deputy Chief Lamb to elaborate on services provided upon release from detention. Deputy Chief Lamb explained that APD works with outreach workers and behavioral health partners, noting that while they use a data-driven approach to target repeat offenders, they also offer resources and counseling to help individuals break cycles of addiction and mental health crises.

In the second round of public comment, a resident from East West Asheville requested transparency regarding the APD drone program, specifically how it balances public safety with civil liberties, and noted that APD’s transparency dashboard and citation data had disappeared from the city’s open data portal. No specific member responded directly to this comment.

## Follow-ups
City Manager Deborah Campbell agreed to have the APD Chief and Deputy Chief attend a future meeting to describe the APD organizational structure, units, and resource deployment. She also agreed to provide information on the use of drones, including regulations, benefits, and the transparency of drone footage. Regarding the potential implementation of a Civilian Traffic Investigator unit, City Manager Campbell stated that staff would return in a month or two to provide information. Interim Fire Chief Chris Baczynski and City Manager Campbell indicated that training for elected officials on the EOP/COOP and the EOC will be scheduled once the plans are finalized. Staff will present the opioid settlement strategy to the full Council; the City Manager noted that the total available funds for the city over 18 years is approximately $2.7 million, with about $572,181 currently in hand. Finally, the committee agreed to cancel the December 26 meeting and instead hold a longer meeting on November 28 to cover the Municipal Climate Action Plan and Solid Waste Plan.

## Impact
These decisions and discussions impact residents by shaping how the city responds to emergencies and public safety concerns. The transition of the Community Responder Program to a permanent service funded by opioid settlement money aims to provide ongoing support for community members. The upcoming training for elected officials on emergency plans ensures that city leadership is prepared for crises. Furthermore, the commitment to provide detailed information on police drone usage and organizational structure addresses resident concerns regarding transparency and civil liberties in law enforcement operations.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0dDly1XKmGU
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2516/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0dDly1XKmGU)
