# Historic Resources Commission – October 16, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Historic Resources Commission
**Date:** October 16, 2023 4:06 PM EDT (2023-10-16T16:06:50-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4664/historic-resources-commission-october-16-2023
**Outcome:** The Historic Resources Commission approved four property applications in the Montford Historic District and discussed a proposed flag lot amendment scheduled for City Council.

## Summary

On October 16, 2023, the City of Asheville Historic Resources Commission convened to review property applications within the Montford Historic District and receive staff updates on preservation policy. The agenda included four Certificate of Appropriateness applications and discussions regarding equity in preservation efforts, gentrification, and a proposed zoning amendment.

## Key Decisions
The commission voted on four property applications, all of which received Certificates of Appropriateness with specific conditions or approvals:
*   **101 Santee Street:** The commission unanimously approved the application for an after-the-fact retaining wall constructed of precast concrete ("Verte Block") rather than the originally approved natural stone. A second unanimous motion was made to issue the certificate with the condition that the applicant submit a revised site plan for staff review to ensure adequate landscaping screening.
*   **8 Birch Street:** The commission approved the application to remove three windows on the west elevation and install a concrete track driveway. The vote was split, with all members voting in favor except one who opposed the decision, citing concerns that the driveway affects the historic character of the site. A second unanimous motion was made to issue the certificate with the condition that the applicant submit a revised landscaping plan indicating the species and types of plantings.
*   **159 Pearson Street:** The commission unanimously approved the application to complete an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) originally approved in 2016. A second unanimous motion was made to issue the certificate with the condition that the roof color be submitted to staff for review and approval.
*   **Woodside Place:** The commission unanimously approved the application for after-the-fact construction of stone veneer retaining walls and a stone stairway. A second unanimous motion was made to issue the certificate without conditions.

Additionally, the commission unanimously voted to approve the minutes from the September meeting, including findings of fact and conclusions of law. A motion to adjourn was made and seconded, ending the meeting.

## Discussion Highlights
Staff provided updates on several policy topics, highlighting the challenges of engaging diverse communities in preservation efforts. Staff noted that scheduling meetings on Wednesday evenings often excludes Black church communities, prompting a shift to other times to improve diversity in applicants. Staff also discussed the use of "street-side historic districts" to control front-yard aesthetics while allowing modern construction in the rear.

Regarding gentrification, staff addressed the tension between preserving neighborhood character and preventing displacement. Staff explained that wealthier, white neighborhoods often pursue conservation overlays, while vulnerable neighborhoods may distrust such measures due to fears of rising property values. Staff stated that successful preservation in vulnerable areas requires layered zoning changes combined with community support services, such as home repair funds and property tax assistance.

Staff also presented a detailed update on a citizen-proposed ordinance amendment regarding flag lots and cottage developments. Initiated by a private developer, the proposal seeks to narrow the required width of the flag portion of a lot from 20 feet to 5 feet and limit the number of flag lots per parcel. Staff noted that planners described these as "a few little tweaks" that could open up approximately 22,000 acres to development that had not been planned before. Staff advised that the item is a general rezoning amendment scheduled to go to City Council the following Tuesday.

During the review of 101 Santee Street, a commissioner expressed concern about setting a precedent by approving non-traditional materials, stating, "I don't like the idea that we're trying to find a solution for something that we're not happy with... I think it sets a pretty bad precedent." For 8 Birch Street, a commissioner noted, "I struggle with the parking in front just because a lot of the standards push us to no parking in the front of your house... I think the standards lead me to think that that changes the character of the front of the house when you have such a small lot and you add a parking thing."

## Community Input
A neighbor at 109 Santee Street expressed disappointment regarding the construction at 101 Santee Street, stating they had notified staff in late 2022 and early 2023 that contractors intended to use Verte Block and that grading was excessive. The commenter questioned the value of the historic district given the construction next door. Staff clarified that standard enforcement processes, including site inspections and a stop-work order from the Development Services Department, were followed, and that the commission relies on public reports to identify non-compliant work. A commissioner acknowledged the neighbor’s frustration and appreciation for their testimony.

For 8 Birch Street, a public commenter, speaking for the owner, suggested that if off-street parking is approved, the commission should consider allowing for electric vehicle charging, noting that an extension across the sidewalk would be undesirable. No specific response was recorded in the transcript. No public comments were recorded for 159 Pearson Street, Woodside Place, or the staff presentations.

## Follow-ups
*   **101 Santee Street:** The applicant agreed to submit a revised site plan for staff review to demonstrate adequate landscaping screening of the wall.
*   **8 Birch Street:** The applicant agreed to submit a revised landscaping plan indicating the species and types of plantings proposed to screen the driveway.
*   **159 Pearson Street:** The applicant agreed to submit the roof color to staff for review and approval.
*   **Legacy Neighborhood Coalition:** Staff stated they are continuing to meet with the Legacy Neighborhood Coalition to begin neighborhood planning specifically for legacy neighborhoods, moving beyond existing small area plans.

## Impact
These decisions allow for the completion or modification of four properties within the Montford Historic District, with conditions imposed to mitigate visual impacts on the historic streetscape. The staff updates highlight ongoing efforts to make preservation more equitable by adjusting meeting times and integrating community support services into zoning strategies to prevent displacement in vulnerable neighborhoods. Additionally, residents are advised to review staff reports for the flag lot and cottage development amendment, which is scheduled to go to City Council the following Tuesday, as it could affect a large area of approximately 22,000 acres. Staff also announced a site visit for a landmark designation application scheduled for Tuesday, October 24, at 11:00 a.m., and a commission retreat scheduled for November 17 at Citizen Vinyl.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7GCJloTy9vk
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2533/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7GCJloTy9vk)
