# Boards & Commissions Committee – October 10, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Boards and Commissions Committee
**Date:** October 10, 2023 12:59 PM EDT (2023-10-10T12:59:37-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4667/boards-commissions-committee-october-10-2023
**Outcome:** The committee recommended amending the Human Relations Commission ordinance to remove racial membership requirements and made appointment recommendations for multiple advisory boards.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Boards and Commissions Committee met on October 10, 2023, to conduct the second round of interviews for Planning and Zoning Commission candidates, review a proposed amendment to the Human Relations Commission (HRC) ordinance, and make recommendations for various board and commission appointments. The committee also reviewed its 2024 work plan and adjusted its upcoming meeting schedule.

## Key Decisions
The committee approved the minutes from August 22, 2023, unanimously. Regarding the Human Relations Commission, the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend an amendment to Section 2185.25 of the Asheville City Code. This amendment removes racial characteristics as a requirement for membership while maintaining equal access for historically disadvantaged groups, citing recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions.

The committee made several appointment recommendations, all passing unanimously (3-0):
*   **Affordable Housing Advisory Committee:** Reappointed Brian Methvin and Scott Adams; appointed Rita Lee, Jane Christen, Chantel Simpson, and Stuart Ziton.
*   **Civic Center Commission:** Recommended Erica Gifford for the single vacancy.
*   **Civil Service Board:** Reappointed Carter Webb.
*   **Downtown Commission:** Appointed Jefferson Ellison.
*   **Human Relations Commission:** Reappointed Daniel Young and Crystal Reed; appointed Jack Hoda and John Miles.
*   **Noise Advisory Board:** Reappointed Jess Santiago and Carmelo Pionio. The third vacancy (restaurant representative) will be re-advertised.
*   **Sustainability Advisory Committee:** Appointed Christy Herbert and Justin Young.
*   **Urban Forestry Commission:** Appointed Christy Fiore.

For the Public Art and Cultural Commission, the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to postpone appointments until the January meeting, as the commission is restructuring its membership. The committee also agreed to hold its November meeting on November 14, 2023, and cancel its December meeting.

## Discussion Highlights
During the discussion of the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee, Councilwoman Rooney suggested substituting Jen Hampton for Jane Christen, noting that Christen’s application would remain on file for a year. However, the committee ultimately voted to keep the chair’s original recommendation. Regarding the Civic Center Commission, Councilwoman Rooney stated that local experience relationships would be helpful for public outreach, which led to the recommendation of Erica Gifford. Councilwoman Mosley expressed high regard for Jefferson Ellison, moving to appoint him to the Downtown Commission.

On the Human Relations Commission, Councilwoman Rooney highlighted the experience of applicant Jack Hoda in addressing the social determinants of health. For the Sustainability Advisory Committee, Councilwoman Mosley proposed a friendly amendment to recommend Christy Herbert and Justin Young, which the committee approved. Councilwoman Rooney also raised the idea of exploring an advisory board stipend program, similar to one in Durham, as a potential future agenda item.

## Community Input
A public commenter from East West Asheville expressed concern that the staff report’s justification for the Human Relations Commission ordinance changes relied on an overly broad interpretation of recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions. The commenter argued this could negatively impact city initiatives such as the reparation commission and minority business inclusion programs, and asked the committee and staff to clarify the legal basis. The commenter also encouraged the full council to pull the item from the consent agenda to allow for more public discussion. Members did not respond directly to the specific legal concerns during the public comment period. However, later during the discussion, Councilwoman Rooney stated she would feel more comfortable supporting the recommendation if the phrase "consistent with the accompanying staff report" was removed from the motion, citing her own questions about the federal court decisions.

## Follow-ups
Staff from the Equity and Inclusion Department agreed to conduct an environmental scan of compensation and accommodations for advisory board members, with results expected to be introduced to the Equity and Engagement Committee by the end of the year. Staff also agreed to reach out to current Public Art and Cultural Commission members to invite them to stay on during the restructure process. Additionally, staff confirmed that the Neighborhood Advisory Committee for zip code 28801 will continue to advertise for applicants, as none were received, and will provide updates on the realignment of boards and commissions project, including board member survey results, at the next committee meeting.

## Impact
These decisions ensure continuity and new leadership across the city’s advisory bodies, which provide input on housing, urban planning, public art, and civil rights. The amendment to the Human Relations Commission ordinance reflects a shift in membership criteria to align with recent legal precedents, while the postponement of Public Art and Cultural Commission appointments allows for a structured membership reorganization. The upcoming environmental scan on board member compensation aims to assess current support structures for volunteers serving the city.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VN3UlXx08Zg
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2525/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VN3UlXx08Zg)
