# City Council Work Session – September 26, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** September 26, 2023 2:49 PM EDT (2023-09-26T14:49:50-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4675/city-council-work-session-september-26-2023
**Outcome:** Council directed staff to investigate two long-term renovation options for the Thomas Wolfe Auditorium and plan to request $1.4 million for HVAC repairs in October.

## Summary

On September 26, 2023, the Asheville City Council held a work session to discuss the future of the Thomas Wolfe Auditorium. The meeting focused on addressing immediate facility failures, specifically a major HVAC breakdown, and evaluating long-term renovation options for the 1939-built venue. No formal votes were taken during this session, which was designated for discussion and direction-setting.

**Key Decisions and Directions**
While no formal votes occurred, the Council established specific directions for staff. The Council directed staff to focus further investigation on two long-term renovation concepts: the "Patron-Driven Significant Renovation" (estimated at ~$150 million in 2028 dollars) and the "Improved Raked Floor" (estimated at ~$125 million). Council members explicitly stated they had no appetite for the "Do Nothing" option, the "Broadway Major Renovation" (estimated at $100M–$198M), or the "Multifurpose Flat Floor" (estimated at ~$110M). Regarding immediate repairs, staff recommended that the Council approve approximately $1.4 million from the enterprise fund balance to cover full capacity HVAC repairs. Staff stated they would return to a business meeting in October to request these funds. Additionally, staff proposed approaching the Tourism Development Authority (TDA) to match the $1.4 million in repair funds to help initiate design work for the long-term renovation.

**Discussion Highlights**
Staff presented the building’s current status, noting it generates $29.5 million annually in economic impact for Buncombe County but is currently operating at reduced capacity due to the HVAC failure. Chris Corle, Director of Community and Regional Entertainment Facilities, explained that a "quick fix" costing approximately $188,000 would restore partial capacity for about 1,300 seats, while the full capacity repair to restore all 2,431 seats is estimated at $1.2 million. Corle noted, "The building is in use... 129 days a year, which is about 35%... We're in the middle of our third instance of reduced capacity in that room."

Council members debated the merits of the various renovation options. Council Member Maggie Ullman stated, "I definitely think we need to take the do nothing off the table... I don't have appetite to pursue [the Broadway option]... We have a Broadway facility in Greenville. We have a Broadway facility in Knoxville." Another Council Member expressed interest in the Patron-Driven model if partners could secure significant private funding, stating, "I want to understand that [donor] capacity a little bit more because if we really have partners from the nonprofit side with the ability to pull in 25 or 50 million that makes me a lot more interested in the patron driven model." Council Member Kim Roney emphasized the need for infrastructure improvements, saying, "I also don't want to leave loading unfixed in whatever solution comes together." Council Member Sage Turner argued against the flat floor option, noting, "For me, that [flat floor] would be not a benefit to the community that might see it as a competition... I would like to take that off the table too."

Mayor Esther Manheimer cautioned against complacency, stating, "I don't want us to get complacent if we do some repairs to the structure... that we don't take our gas off or foot off the gas pedal in terms of making sure we move this along." The City Manager added, "We have delayed and deferred and this... actually we lose the more we invest in this facility the way it is. We're not going to get the return on investment that this community deserves."

**Follow-Ups**
Staff agreed to several specific actions following the session. Chris Corle stated that staff will return to the Council in October to request the $1.4 million for full capacity HVAC repairs. Staff will also conduct further investigation into the Patron-Driven and Improved Raked Floor options, pursue the TDA Lift Fund process (which opens in October) to seek matching funds for design, and gather stakeholder and public input to develop an economic business plan and financing feasibility study. Additionally, staff will provide a "lost business report" detailing shows that inquired but could not be hosted due to facility limitations, and will investigate the potential impact of the Duke Energy substation relocation on loading dock improvements. Mayor Esther Manheimer stated she is willing to "put some sweat equity into this" by meeting with partners to help assemble a portfolio of private contributions.

**Impact**
This work session addresses the immediate operational crisis at the Thomas Wolfe Auditorium, where unsafe temperatures have already led to event cancellations. The decisions made set the trajectory for both short-term repairs to restore the venue's full capacity and long-term strategic planning for its renovation. The focus on specific renovation models and the pursuit of public-private funding partnerships aims to resolve the building's aging infrastructure and code compliance issues, which staff noted are becoming increasingly costly to maintain without significant modernization.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=na_dJJrjdbo
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2531/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=na_dJJrjdbo)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
