# Environment & Safety Committee – September 26, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Environment and Safety Committee
**Date:** September 26, 2023 11:00 AM EDT (2023-09-26T11:00:13-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4676/environment-safety-committee-september-26-2023
**Outcome:** The Environment and Safety Committee approved the August minutes unanimously and paused further analysis of the solicitation ordinance to focus on an education campaign.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Environment and Safety Committee held a remote meeting on September 26, 2023, to review urban forestry updates, single-use plastic reduction efforts, and the status of the solicitation ordinance. The committee’s primary decision was to approve the minutes from the August 22, 2023 meeting, which passed unanimously with ayes from Vice Mayor Kilgore, Councilwoman Smith, and Chair Ullman. No other formal votes were taken during the session.

A significant portion of the meeting focused on the solicitation and panhandling ordinance. Staff presented data on panhandling and pedestrian collisions, noting that the city has recently adopted technical amendments to the ordinance. After discussion, the committee agreed to pause further policy analysis regarding the expansion of high-traffic zones and the regulation of roadside panhandling. Instead, staff will focus on an education and outreach campaign for the already-adopted technical amendments. Staff committed to returning to the committee in December or January with data on the effectiveness of these changes.

During the opening public comment period, four residents called in to voice opposition to expanding the solicitation ordinance. One resident argued that the data does not support expanding zones to the River Arts District and urged a holistic analysis of accident causes. Another resident criticized the police department’s data, alleging that declines in calls were due to underreporting rather than decreased activity, and called for the abolition of the ordinance. A third resident questioned the consequences of fines for those who cannot pay and proposed creating "high giving zones" to support individuals with resources. A fourth resident expressed concern that the current approach eradicates poverty from public view rather than preventing it. No specific members responded to these comments during the transcript.

In the discussion, Chair Ullman expressed hesitancy about continuing to research the solicitation policy without knowing what other public safety issues the committee could be addressing, stating that it felt like a piece of the puzzle was missing. Vice Mayor Kilgore requested that staff add a column to the data analysis to identify the specific causes of pedestrian collisions, such as impairment or failure to obey traffic laws, to provide better context. Deputy Police Chief Mike Lamb noted that providing this additional data would not require additional staff time, as the information is already collected. Councilwoman Smith clarified that the decision to pause was not a retreat due to pressure, but a step back to ensure the city makes the right moves for safety.

The committee also received an annual update from the Urban Forestry Commission, which discussed ongoing amendments to tree canopy preservation and planting standards. The Urban Forestry Commission Chair noted that the tree planting standard task force is considering expanding certain standards from the downtown area to the entire city. Additionally, the Sustainability Director presented an update on the single-use plastic reduction project, explaining that state preemption has prevented the city from taking further policy action on plastic bags. Consequently, staff recommended shifting focus toward education and voluntary reduction efforts.

Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Staff agreed to pause work on expanding high-traffic zones and to provide data on the impact of technical changes and any significant increases in crashes in December or January. Staff also agreed to add a column to the data analysis to identify the cause of pedestrian collisions and to arrange a broader conversation with public safety departments regarding other ordinances that could help reach council goals. The Urban Forester stated that a final draft of the "appropriate species list" for developers is expected by mid-October. Finally, the Sustainability Director stated that staff will work with the Sanitation Division and Communications Department to develop an education and engagement campaign for voluntary plastic reduction.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MGAUR3oY-n0
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2843/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MGAUR3oY-n0)
