# Board of Adjustment – September 25, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Board of Adjustment
**Date:** September 25, 2023 2:12 PM EDT (2023-09-25T14:12:20-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4678/board-of-adjustment-september-25-2023

## Summary

**Meeting Overview**
The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment held its regular meeting on September 25, 2023. The primary agenda item for the session was an evidentiary hearing regarding a variance request for a property at 376 Vance Gap Road. The board also reviewed administrative items, including the adoption of previous minutes and the appointment of a board secretary.

**Key Decisions**
The board unanimously approved the minutes from the August 2023 meeting. Additionally, the Chair appointed Hunter Spitzer as the secretary to the board, a decision made without objection. The central decision of the meeting was the approval of a variance request from owners Mark and Susan Stanton. The petitioners sought relief from Section 712.4 of the Unified Development Ordinance (Grading Extent) to allow for a total of 9,625 square feet of land disturbance. This amount includes the standard 15% allowable disturbance for the lot (7,775 square feet) plus an additional 1,850 square feet associated with a previously disturbed utility trench and MSD right-of-way. A roll call vote was taken, and the variance was granted by a 4-0 vote.

**Discussion Highlights**
During the hearing, Chair Paul Wilczynski noted that while five people typically sit on the board, only four were present for this vote. He informed the applicant that granting a variance requires four votes in favor and offered the option to postpone the vote until the next meeting to allow for a full quorum, which would permit a "no" vote. The applicant chose to proceed with the vote at that time.

Sam Starbaum, acting as the planner from the Center for the Arts and Sciences at the University, explained that the lot is located in a steep slope zone where land disturbance is limited in perpetuity. He clarified that the request was not for approval of the house design, but rather permission to disturb the land to accommodate the home footprint and the existing utility trench. Starbaum noted that the applicant’s design team worked to keep the footprint compact to meet the spirit of the law.

Mark Stanton, the applicant, stated that the lot was purchased for its mountain environment and that the home would serve as their primary residence. He argued that without the variance, they would face financial hardship due to higher construction costs for a narrower foundation and a lower property valuation. Stanton also mentioned that his wife suffers from a mobility issue, polymyalgia rheumatica, which makes stairs difficult, meaning a smaller footprint would make it nearly impossible to design a master bedroom on the main floor. He cited a letter from his neighbor and HOA president, Ron Patton, who supported the variance to maintain neighborhood character.

A board member moved to approve the variance, stating, "I feel like this is a reasonable request. You're not asking to do more than what would be allowed on this lot if there was no previous disturbance on it." Eric Edgerton, serving as Staff/Legal Counsel, clarified to the board that they are allowed to consider HOA covenants in their determinations, citing case law. Chair Wilczynski commented on the HOA's input, stating, "Speaking as a former president of an HOA, I give a lot of credit to the concept that HOAs have about whether buildings fit into the entire association."

**Community Input**
There was no public comment for this case. The Chair asked if anyone from the public would like to comment, and there were none.

**Follow-ups**
No specific follow-up actions were assigned to staff or members beyond the approval of the variance.

**Impact**
This decision allows the owners of 376 Vance Gap Road to proceed with land disturbance exceeding the standard limit for their steep slope zone. The variance permits the construction of a home with a footprint that accommodates the existing utility infrastructure and meets the specific accessibility needs of the residents, while maintaining the compact design intended to respect the environmental constraints of the area.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1EcUywuEeiI
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2844/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1EcUywuEeiI)
