# Downtown Commission – September 22, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Downtown Commission
**Date:** September 22, 2023 9:05 AM EDT (2023-09-22T09:05:45-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4679/downtown-commission-september-22-2023
**Outcome:** The Downtown Commission heard updates on the Thomas Wolfe Auditorium HVAC failure, McCormick Field renovation, and Courtyard by Marriott hotel, but deferred approving minutes due to a lack of quorum.

## Summary

**Meeting Overview**
The Downtown Commission of the City of Asheville met on September 22, 2023. Chair Bryan Moffitt called the meeting to order, but the commission did not achieve a quorum due to the absence of several members. Consequently, the approval of previous minutes was deferred to the next meeting. No formal votes or motions were recorded during the session.

**Key Discussions and Updates**
A significant portion of the meeting focused on the Thomas Wolfe Auditorium, where Chris Corral, General Manager of the Harris-Cherokee Center, presented an update regarding a major HVAC failure that occurred in May 2023. Corral explained that a "quick fix" repair is underway to allow the venue to reopen at reduced capacity for non-ticketed events by late fall, while full capacity restoration is targeted for February or March 2024, contingent on council approval to use enterprise fund balance for emergency repairs. Corral also presented four long-term renovation concepts, with costs ranging from approximately $8 million to $198 million over 20 years. Chair Moffitt emphasized that without a Broadway-capable fly system, the venue is limited in the types of shows it can host. A council work session is scheduled for September 26 to discuss funding appetite and renovation scale.

The commission also reviewed the McCormick Field baseball stadium renovation, which is moving through the conditional zoning process. Chris Corral presented a new site plan that includes a new right-field structure, a 360-degree wraparound concourse, and a video scoreboard approximately 60 feet high. The project requires conditional zoning for height and parking, with a neighborhood meeting held recently where residents requested an approved traffic and parking plan. The project is on track for a Technical Review Committee meeting on October 16, a Planning and Zoning meeting on October 18, and Council approval on October 24, with construction expected to begin in August 2024.

Regarding the College Street and Patton Avenue buffered bike lane project, Anna Sexton, a planner from the Transportation Department, provided an update on the finalized design, which includes left-side bike lanes and high-visibility crosswalks. Chair Moffitt clarified that the commission is not voting on this item, as they previously voted to support the project in December 2022; this session was for an update only. Staff will present to City Council on October 10 to seek a resolution of support for implementation.

In the development review for the proposed Courtyard by Marriott hotel at 215 Haywood Street, Clay Mitchell, Urban Planner, presented the site plan for a six-story building with underground parking. Members discussed the lack of early disclosure of public benefits, such as green roofs or art, with Chair Moffitt advocating for requiring developers to disclose sustainability features early in the application process. The commission also debated the definition of "activated" ground-floor spaces and the composition of neighborhood meetings, with concerns raised that these meetings may consist primarily of other hotel owners, limiting diverse community input.

**Community Input**
Public comment was received on downtown safety, with a resident reporting frequent overdoses, tents, and a dead body left in front of Woolworths, requesting more funding for police patrols. A business owner on Wall Street echoed these concerns, noting that staff were afraid to come to work due to people sleeping on patios and the presence of needles. A council member responded by stating, "I recognize there's a problem... I've been meeting with businesses for the last several weeks... trying to gather information and ideas and solutions and then bring them to council and the city manager."

Public comment was also received on the bike lane project. A resident expressed opposition, arguing that funds should go to security rather than bike lanes. An architect raised concerns that spring-loaded delineators might not stop loading trucks from parking in the bike lane. A member of the Multimodal Transportation Committee read a letter supporting the project, emphasizing Vision Zero goals. A property owner argued that the single remaining traffic lane is inadequate for the volume of emergency vehicles and deliveries. In response, a council member suggested that if the project is implemented, data collection and analysis should be conducted to determine if it is working. Chair Moffitt noted that because the project primarily uses paint and stanchions, it can be adjusted if it is not working, and stated, "I expect that staff... were taking notes on a lot of these issues. We'll communicate that... to council as the project proceeds."

**Follow-ups and Next Steps**
The chair stated their intention to submit a recommendation to City Council for the current vacant commission seat, noting that the nominee represents a constituency of younger residents and business owners that has been lacking since a previous member left. The chair also mentioned another candidate with a public safety focus as a strong option for a future seat, stating they would present these names to Council for consideration.

Staff provided updates on downtown cleanliness, public safety, and homelessness. Dana Frankel reported that the Compass Point Village Permanent Supportive Housing recently opened with 85 units, and the Shangri-La Step-Up Project is on track for occupancy in the first quarter of 2024. Frankel stated that a representative from the City Manager’s Office will attend and provide updates on cleanliness and safety every other month, starting next month. Staff is also working on finalizing a plan detailing the resources needed to continue the Community Responder Program permanently, with an update scheduled for the City Council’s Environment and Safety Committee meeting on October 24.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukqGcdv5mCI
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3196/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukqGcdv5mCI)
