# Reparations Commission – September 18, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Reparations Commission
**Date:** September 18, 2023 5:59 PM EDT (2023-09-18T17:59:14-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4687/reparations-commission-september-18-2023
**Outcome:** The Reparations Commission tabled the draft resolution to extend its term and the education accountability structure for further review.

## Summary

The Reparations Commission approved the meeting agenda and the minutes from the previous meeting, with specific corrections to names and titles. No other formal votes were taken during the session. The proposal to change the meeting format to include non-live-streamed breakout sessions was not voted on; the Chair indicated the item would be considered further. The Education Impact Focus Area’s (IFA) recommendation for an accountability structure was tabled for the next meeting to allow for further review. A draft resolution to extend the Commission’s term by two years was also tabled, as members stated they were not prepared to vote on the item due to time constraints.

## Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the meeting focused on defining the term "reparations" within the context of Asheville-Buncombe County. Facilitator Renisha Crawford led a session where members contributed to a collective definition, emphasizing elements such as making amends for past wrongs, addressing systemic oppression, and investing in systems to close the racial wealth gap. Members discussed the distinction between local "community reinvestment" and federal reparations to avoid legal and financial risks, such as issues related to the Emoluments Clause. One Commissioner noted, "Without defining what reparations means to this committee... we don't have a target... I would like for us to speak with one voice."

The Commission also debated a proposal to restructure meetings to include non-live-streamed breakout working sessions. Several members strongly opposed ending live streams for any portion of the meeting, arguing it violates public access principles for a publicly funded body. One Commissioner stated, "I would recommend removing [the proposal to end live streaming]... This is deleterious to the notion of public input and the democratic process... I don't think that would even be legal anyway since we're using public dollars to have this process."

The most contentious discussion involved a draft resolution to extend the Commission’s term by two years. Members arguing for the extension contended that the current timeline was insufficient for the complex work required and that ending the term without adequate community engagement would be paternalistic. One Commissioner remarked, "We're about 400 years late... If we end this thing in April and we just say, 'Here is a report on everything we got,' you don't get a second chance." Conversely, members opposing the extension argued that seeking more time signals a lack of competence and further erodes public credibility. One Commissioner stated, "You look crazy. You had two years. And we're talking about extending it another two to the community. You've lost credibility with them already. And two more years is going to add more to it."

## Community Input

Two public commenters spoke during the designated period. A resident and homeowner in the East End, identifying as a descendant of a family whose home was surrendered to urban renewal in 1979, asked the Commission to formally request specific actions from the City and County. These requests included explicitly naming the policies that caused harms, requesting that the Carter Development Group present their full scope of work for the "Stop the Harm Audit," and retaining an actuary to calculate the monetary loss of wealth for displaced Black residents. The Chair asked the commenter to forward their comments in writing. No other member or staff member responded to the specific requests made.

A staff member, identified as the Director of the Kayla Program/Youth Leadership Academy, expressed support for keeping the name "Reparations" for the Commission, noting that renaming it might cause the public to question the work done in the previous two years. They also mentioned difficulty following the meeting due to not having access to the same privileged information as the commission members. Members did not respond to the comment.

## Follow-ups

Staff agreed to make corrections to the minutes regarding names and titles. The Project Manager agreed to send the latest version of the Education IFA accountability recommendation to all members and the Education IFA facilitator for feedback, and to facilitate connections between IFAs to merge similar recommendations. Facilitator Renisha Crawford agreed to compile the members' input on the definition of reparations and send it to the commission for review. Commission members agreed to review the Education IFA accountability recommendation and send comments or edits before the next meeting. The Chair stated that the discussion regarding the extension of the Commission’s term would be moved to the next agenda.

## Impact

This meeting highlights the internal debates surrounding the Commission's operational structure and its mandate. The decision to table the extension of the Commission’s term and the accountability structure indicates that the body has not yet reached a consensus on how to ensure the implementation of its recommendations or how long it will operate. The focus on defining "reparations" locally is significant as it attempts to distinguish the Commission's work from federal reparations efforts, potentially shaping the specific recommendations the body will eventually submit to the City and County. The public comment regarding the "Stop the Harm Audit" and urban renewal displacement underscores the community's demand for specific, data-driven acknowledgments of past harms, which the Commission has not yet formally adopted or acted upon.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AuzDXkFZ2Y8
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2546/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AuzDXkFZ2Y8)
