# Urban Forestry Commission – September 5, 2023 - Pt. 1 of 2

**Body:** City of Asheville — Urban Forestry Commission
**Date:** September 5, 2023 1:00 PM EDT (2023-09-05T13:00:45-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4697/urban-forestry-commission-september-5-2023-pt-1-of-2
**Outcome:** The Urban Forestry Commission approved alternative compliance requests for the Mission Hospital renovation and the 680 Haywood Road project and discussed concerns over tree removal for the Hall Creek Sidewalk Project.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Urban Forestry Commission convened on September 5, 2023, for the first part of its regular meeting. Chair Patrick Gilbert opened the session by noting the Commission’s goal to keep meetings within a two-hour timeframe, warning that discussion on "hot topics" might be cut short to stay on schedule. The agenda proceeded to alternative compliance requests, public comment, and staff reports.

**Key Decisions**
The Commission approved the August 2023 minutes by unanimous vote. The body then reviewed two alternative compliance requests. For the Mission Hospital renovation at 7 Granby Street, the Commission approved the request to adjust landscaping requirements, including reducing large maturing trees from seven to three on the east corner and relocating street trees to avoid utility conflicts. The Chair recorded this vote as unanimously approved with one abstention. For 680 Haywood Road, the Commission unanimously approved a revised plan that shifted one street tree into the parking lot landscaping to accommodate historic archaeological features and avoid utility connections.

**Discussion Highlights**
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to a written public comment regarding the Hall Creek Sidewalk Project. Several Commission members expressed concern over the potential removal of more than 70 trees on a private property and criticized the timing of the tree survey. Sharon Sumrall stated that the letter "disturbed" her regarding transparency issues, drawing a parallel to her own experiences with the Greenways project. Ed Macy suggested that the Commission communicate to Capital Projects that trees should be treated as "critical infrastructure" rather than obstacles. Karen Macneil agreed, arguing that better transparency on plan aspects affecting the tree canopy would foster goodwill. Zoe Hoyle called the situation "troubling" because the provided survey included species and size data the Commission had not previously seen. Chardin Detrich noted that the Commission needs to be involved earlier in the planning phase to have "teeth" in the process.

**Community Input**
During the public comment period, a resident submitted a written letter expressing frustration with the complexity of the tree removal permitting process for a single tree on a steep slope. Ed Macy responded that while the process involves multiple steps, it is necessary to maintain consistency with the "no net loss" policy. A staff member added that the resident had made several trips to the permit center and was expected to submit an alternative compliance request the following month. Additionally, a live caller attempted to join the meeting but experienced technical difficulties and left the line before speaking.

**Follow-ups**
Chair Patrick Gilbert agreed to contact the chairs of existing working groups to determine if they are interested in addressing transparency and earlier Commission involvement in capital projects. If no existing group takes on the issue, he stated he would create a separate working group and ask for volunteers from the Commission. Kim Roney, the Council Liaison, stated she is available to support any working group in formalizing recommendations or drafting documents. Furthermore, the City Arborist reported that he will remove up to three trees at the Beauty Golf Course while samples are sent to Raleigh for oak wilt testing, with one removal scheduled for the day following the meeting.

**Impact**
These decisions allow the Mission Hospital renovation and the 680 Haywood Road project to proceed with modified landscaping plans that accommodate existing utilities and archaeological findings. The discussion regarding the Hall Creek Sidewalk Project highlights ongoing tensions between infrastructure development and tree preservation, prompting the Commission to consider formal mechanisms for earlier involvement in capital projects to better protect the urban canopy.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mQ21jmfRjg
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2552/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mQ21jmfRjg)
