# Environment & Safety Committee – July 25, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Environment and Safety Committee
**Date:** July 25, 2023 11:00 AM EDT (2023-07-25T11:00:32-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4720/environment-safety-committee-july-25-2023
**Outcome:** The committee recommended that staff apply for two public safety grants and sent proposed solicitation ordinance amendments to the full Council.

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Environment and Safety Committee held a remote meeting on July 25, 2023, to address public safety initiatives, grant applications, and ordinance updates. The committee reviewed eight agenda items, focusing primarily on the transition of the Downtown Safety Initiative, proposed changes to solicitation ordinances, and the status of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan.

**Key Decisions**
The committee took three formal votes, all of which passed unanimously (3-0). First, the committee approved the minutes from the June 27, 2023 meeting. Second, the committee voted to recommend that staff apply for and accept the 2023 High Intensity Drug Trafficking Area (HIDA) Program grant ($154,638) and the 2024 Governor’s Highway Safety Program Bike Safe Grant ($5,000). Third, the committee voted to recommend that staff apply for the 2024 HIDA Program grant ($154,638).

Regarding the solicitation ordinances, the committee voted unanimously to recommend proposed amendments to the full Council for consideration at its August 22, 2023 meeting. These recommended amendments include increasing the distance restriction for solicitation from 6 feet to 10 feet, adding high-traffic zones in the River Arts District and West Asheville (specifically along Haywood Road) upon staff recommendation, and prohibiting the act of giving money from a vehicle to a solicitor.

**Discussion Highlights**
City Attorney Brad Branham emphasized the importance of removing ambiguity and ensuring the solicitation ordinances comply with recent Supreme Court rulings and statutory authorities. He noted that if the committee felt the current 6-foot distance was not achieving the necessary regulatory interest, expanding it to 10 feet was a viable option for the Council to consider. Deputy Police Chief Mike Lamb reported that increased officer presence downtown has led to officers witnessing crimes in progress, allowing for immediate reporting, investigation, and subsequent citations or arrests. Assistant City Manager Ben Woody stated that proactive engagement by law enforcement and community responders is needed to address complicated factors in the city. Parks and Recreation Director D. Tyrell McGirt highlighted that the master plan process focuses on existing parks and facilities while promoting new ideas, partnerships, and innovation.

**Community Input**
During opening public comment, a representative of the Asheville Coalition for Public Safety advocated for increased entry-level raises for police officers to improve recruitment and retention, and requested the creation of a separate public safety committee distinct from the climate change committee. They expressed support for the solicitation ordinance amendments, arguing that retaining officers would allow for a fully staffed police department year-round rather than relying on 30-day initiatives. No specific member responded to this comment.

During closing public comment, a West Asheville resident expressed encouragement regarding increased police presence but reported a frightening incident on their property and noted that neighbors are afraid to report issues due to perceived low police force levels. This commenter supported the expansion of high-traffic areas. Another West Asheville resident expressed concern that increasing the solicitation distance to 10 feet would force unhoused individuals into "invisibility" and suggested directing resources toward alternatives like the "Be Loved Street Pantries." This commenter also argued that adding police with lethal force does not solve core problems and that more unarmed professionals trained in mental health and substance use are needed. A fourth public commenter criticized the increase in police funding, claimed police were "falsely inflating" crime numbers, and argued that true safety comes from caring for those in need rather than incarceration. Chair Maggie Ullman thanked this caller and noted the three-minute time limit, inviting them to submit further comments in writing. No other member responded to the content of these comments.

**Follow-ups**
Council Member Smith suggested that staff provide suggestions for a community campaign or partnerships with organizations such as the Rotary or nonprofits to support the ordinance changes, focusing on "reimagining public safety." Staff confirmed that the Climate Action Plan will be reviewed by master plan consultants to ensure equity and resilience hubs are considered. Staff will continue weekly meetings with the consultant and begin comprehensive public engagement, including surveys and focus groups, in August and September. Additionally, staff confirmed that the police department and Community Responders will continue proactive presence in downtown and other data-driven high-crime areas, while the city will continue to prioritize lighting improvements, parking garage safety, and cleanliness services. A new Constituent Services Manager, Stephanie Gillum, has been appointed to serve as a single point of contact for community inquiries.

**Impact**
These decisions and discussions reflect the city’s ongoing efforts to balance public safety enforcement with community well-being. The recommendation to amend the solicitation ordinances will move to the full Council in August, where it will be considered alongside the recent legal landscape regarding panhandling. The continuation of the Downtown Safety Initiative’s strategies, including the appointment of a dedicated Constituent Services Manager, aims to provide a more consistent and responsive approach to safety concerns in high-crime areas.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjSZNRB13gU
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2942/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjSZNRB13gU)
