# Design Review Committee – July 20, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Design Review Committee
**Date:** July 20, 2023 12:30 PM EDT (2023-07-20T12:30:48-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4726/design-review-committee-july-20-2023

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Design Review Committee met on July 20, 2023, to review the formal design for the Carr Street Mixed-Use Tribute Hotel at 68 Carr Street. This Level 2 hotel project, which requires mandatory review and compliance, had been previously considered by the committee. The meeting also included the approval of the minutes from the June 15, 2023 session, which passed unanimously.

The primary focus of the meeting was the site design and streetscape of the hotel project. The applicant presented updated plans featuring new planters, pavers, and a "terraced flex zone" on Ann Street to address prior concerns regarding the lack of design detail in the public realm. Significant debate arose over the applicant’s decision to forgo a green roof, citing financial constraints and arguing that the stormwater retention benefits were not significant enough to replace underground retention. Additionally, the committee discussed the size of proposed street trees, with the applicant initially proposing 2-inch caliber trees.

A heated discussion took place regarding the distinction between "requirements" and "recommendations" in the Downtown Design Review Guidelines. Several members expressed frustration that the site design did not meet the higher design standards applied to the building's architecture. Jeremy Goldstein, Chair, stated, "I feel like this is turning into a conditional zoning process, which makes me very uncomfortable... I think that puts our city at risk," expressing concern over the lack of clear guidance on what the committee can require versus recommend. Member Steven Lee Johnson added, "If we accept the site as is... there is no purpose for the design review committee... We are not asking for anything that is out of the norm or unusual. We're just asking for something that is unique and innovative. It actually makes a difference."

In response to the committee's scrutiny, Tony Hauser, a landscape architect and civil engineer from WSP representing the applicant, stated, "I don't appreciate some of the comments you've made suggesting that this hasn't been designed... I am doing what my client is trying to do in order to develop a hotel in the city of Asheville in an affordable way... And we are meeting what the UDO requires and what the design review guidelines require." John Noor, legal counsel for the applicant, urged the committee to consider the improvements already made and move toward approval. Member Kathryn Ancaya noted, "I think that if the level of architecture was at the level of the site, you all would be having a fit... I think that needs change... I think that it's important for us all to understand that and to be respectful of the fact that typically the architecture is way more thought through... and I think that needs to change."

The committee voted to recommend approval of the Carr Street Mixed-Use Tribute Hotel as presented, subject to specific conditions. The motion, moved by Member Michael McDonough, included three requirements: the applicant must increase the street tree caliper size to 3 to 4 inches; the applicant must review the roofing product to ensure it has a low albedo/high emittance to minimize urban heat island effects; and the applicant must review the Ann Street terrace zone to remove any proposed handrails between that zone and the sidewalk to avoid creating a disconnected or hazardous space. The committee voted by show of hands, and the motion passed 7-2.

No public comments were recorded during the meeting. Regarding future actions, staff member Will Palmquist agreed to look into older documents to help the committee identify "low-hanging fruit" for immediate changes to the design guidelines, suggesting the committee send him their suggestions for discussion at the next meeting. Staff also indicated they would touch base with other staff members to determine the best interim approach for applying design standards while the formal guideline update process is underway.

This decision impacts the development of the Carr Street hotel, a project intended to be developed in an affordable way within the city. The conditions imposed aim to mitigate urban heat island effects and improve the safety and connectivity of the public realm on Ann Street. The committee’s vote reflects a compromise that allows the project to proceed while addressing specific design concerns raised by members regarding the quality of the site plan relative to the building architecture.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wxtyevXSfz4
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2578/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wxtyevXSfz4)
