# Transit Committee – July 18, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Transit Committee
**Date:** July 18, 2023 5:00 PM EDT (2023-07-18T17:00:23-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4728/transit-committee-july-18-2023
**Outcome:** Transit Committee re-elected Sandy Aldridge as Vice Chair and discussed the stalled Joint City and County Transit Plan and draft ART system rules.

## Summary

The Transit Committee approved the minutes from March 21, April 25, May 16, and June 20, 2023, with all present members voting in favor. The committee also voted to maintain its current meeting schedule of 5:00 PM to 7:00 PM, rejecting a proposal to revert to the previous 3:00 PM to 5:00 PM timeframe. This motion passed with one member voting against and all other present members voting in favor. Additionally, the committee unanimously re-elected Sandy Aldridge as Vice Chair, effective April 19, 2023.

## Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the status of the Joint City and County Transit Plan. Staff reported that while the city included funding for the joint study in its budget, the county did not. A public commenter noted, "At this point in time, we are not moving forward with the joint study... It's unfortunate, but that we just found out kind of at the last minute when they approved their budget that that money was not included." Staff confirmed they are currently assessing next steps and options for moving forward with the study.

The committee reviewed draft rules for the Asheville Regional Transit (ART) system, incorporating feedback from the "Better Buses Together" (BBT) group. Staff agreed to incorporate suggested changes, including moving the consequences section, clarifying language regarding "certain circumstances," adding cart size limits, changing "should" to "must" for electronic devices, reclassifying stalking to Level 3, and adding appeal information. Staff stated they would produce a clean draft with these changes for the committee to review and vote on at the next meeting.

Concerns regarding driver conduct were raised by a committee member, who reported two instances of poor behavior: a driver discouraging a rider in an electric wheelchair from boarding and a driver refusing to kneel the bus for an injured rider. Barry Riley, staff, stated that drivers are required to kneel the bus when asked and that such behavior is "unacceptable." He explained that video footage is used to investigate complaints and that staff are willing to review the video with the complainant to clarify facts. In a separate discussion on system reliability, Barry Riley noted, "The city's objective is to be in the 72% on-time performance... The differences in whether you're going to be at 72% or 89%, quite honestly, is all about how much you're willing to spend on capital." He explained that while the "Swiftly" app is used for real-time tracking, the system does not currently adjust routes on the fly due to resource constraints.

## Community Input

During the designated public comment period, no comments were submitted. However, a public commenter provided input during the discussion on the Joint Transit Plan, expressing regret that the county did not include funding for the study in its budget. Additionally, a public commenter noted during the driver conduct discussion that staff are accessible via phone or email for immediate complaint reporting and that they will work with the committee member to review the specific video footage.

## Follow-ups

Staff agreed to meet with the committee member who filed the complaint about driver conduct to review the video footage together. Regarding the Joint Transit Plan, staff stated they are assessing next steps and options for moving forward with the study. Staff also agreed to produce a clean draft of the ART system rules incorporating the BBT group’s suggestions for the next meeting. Furthermore, staff confirmed they had contacted the maintenance department regarding a magnolia tree blocking visibility on the S6 route near Mayhew; the request was added to their work list, and staff will check back next week. Staff also agreed to investigate why the S6 route has been sitting at the station/Aspen area for extended periods recently and to look into generating reports on the accuracy of the "Swiftly" app's predictions versus actual arrival times.

## Impact

These decisions and discussions highlight the committee's focus on operational reliability and service quality. The decision to keep the 5:00 PM meeting time ensures continuity in the committee's schedule, while the re-election of the Vice Chair maintains leadership stability. The review of the ART system rules aims to clarify expectations for riders and drivers, potentially improving the overall rider experience. The investigation into on-time performance and the "Swiftly" app's accuracy addresses resident concerns about predictability, a key factor in rider confidence. The pause in the Joint City and County Transit Plan due to funding issues signals a potential delay in regional transit planning, which may affect future service expansions or improvements.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5QpUgaHyrfo
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2577/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5QpUgaHyrfo)
