# Historic Resources Commission – June 14, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Historic Resources Commission
**Date:** June 14, 2023 4:03 PM EDT (2023-06-14T16:03:59-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4747/historic-resources-commission-june-14-2023
**Outcome:** The Commission approved three preservation applications and deferred the Biltmore Village development to a future meeting.

## Summary

**Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: June 14, 2023**

The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission met on June 14, 2023, to review preservation applications and a large-scale development proposal. The Commission began by unanimously accepting the minutes from the previous month. The agenda included three new Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) applications for properties in the Albemarle Park and Montford Historic Districts, all of which were approved. The Commission also continued its review of a multi-building mixed-use development in Biltmore Village, which was deferred to a future meeting.

The Commission approved three COA applications unanimously. For 35 Canterbury Road in the Albemarle Park Historic District, the Commission approved the removal of a deteriorated, non-contributing greenhouse and the construction of a new sunroom addition on the west elevation. This approval included a condition that skylight specifications be submitted for staff review and approval. For 8 Short Street in the Montford Historic District, the Commission approved the installation of a 4-foot metal picket fence in the front, side, and rear yards, citing security needs for a pedestrian cut-through. This approval included a condition that a landscaping plan for screening the fence be submitted for staff review and approval. For 123 West Chestnut Street, also in the Montford Historic District, the Commission approved the replacement of a front chain-link fence with a 4-foot metal ornamental picket fence and the construction of a gravel parking pad in the rear yard with matching fencing. No additional conditions were attached to this approval.

The most significant discussion of the meeting concerned the application for 1 Angle Street and 10 Kitchen Place in Biltmore Village. The applicant presented revised conceptual massing and height studies for a multi-building development, addressing previous concerns regarding the 30-foot facade limit and story counts defined in the Biltmore Village Development Plan. Staff noted that the proposed design was consistent with the architectural style of the area. However, members raised concerns about the scale of Building 4 relative to nearby landmarks, such as the Grand Bohemian and the church steeple. Debate also focused on whether a 6-foot setback for upper stories on Buildings 1 and 2 was sufficient to visually reduce the building’s mass from the street. Additional topics included the impact of loading docks and a garage entrance on Boston Way, a narrow two-way street, and the preservation of existing sweetgum trees along Kitchen Place.

Public comment was received only for the 1 Angle Street and 10 Kitchen Place item. A public commenter, identified as the president of an architecture firm, argued that the Commission should not set a precedent for redefining the "primary facade" to allow habitable space above 30 feet and requested more technical, 3D modeled images rather than "romantic sketches." A commissioner responded that the level of drawing information provided was appropriate for the current stage of the process, prioritizing scale and massing over detailing. Another public commenter, representing a local cathedral, expressed support for the project, stating that progress is essential for the community. A third public commenter, a retired architectural historian, emphasized that the church was historically the highest point in the village and that the relationship between the church and surrounding buildings is critical. A fourth public commenter, a trustee for a local trust, raised concerns about traffic on Boston Way, suggesting changes to Building 4 setbacks or moving the entrance to Hendersonville Road. A staff member clarified that parking and transportation issues are typically resolved in technical review and planning/zoning processes, not solely by the Commission. The architect responded that Boston Way is the only feasible location for vehicle entry/exit due to safety and traffic volume on other streets. Finally, a public commenter asked the applicant to research and incorporate historic details from a previous grocery store located on the site. Members did not directly respond to the comments regarding support for the development, historical context, or the request for historic research.

The Commission voted unanimously to continue the 1 Angle Street and 10 Kitchen Place application to the August meeting. During the discussion, the architect for the project stated that the team is continuing to work on the design, specifically regarding the massing of Building 4 and the replacement of sweetgum trees with linden trees per the Olmsted plan. The architect also agreed to provide more detailed 3D views and scaled drawings, specifically comparing Building 4’s height to the Grand Bohemian, and to address the setback and massing concerns for Buildings 1 and 3. A staff member agreed to look up the setback dimensions used in a previous addition in the Flatiron district for comparison. The civil engineer stated that the team is studying curb-to-curb dimensions to maintain safe two-way movement on Boston Way, potentially removing on-street parking adjacent to the project.

These decisions impact the historic character of the Albemarle Park, Montford, and Biltmore Village districts. The approvals for the three smaller properties allow for specific modifications to fences and additions that align with the Commission’s guidelines for those areas. The deferral of the large Biltmore Village development means that no final decision has been made on that project at this time. The Commission will revisit the application in August after the applicant provides additional information on massing, height, and traffic circulation as requested during this meeting.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RpQFLFT-ZoA
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2623/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RpQFLFT-ZoA)
