# Reparations Commission – June 12, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Reparations Commission
**Date:** June 12, 2023 5:55 PM EDT (2023-06-12T17:55:12-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4750/reparations-commission-june-12-2023
**Outcome:** The Reparations Commission heard updates on housing, criminal justice, and economic development proposals and planned an upcoming retreat.

## Summary

On June 12, 2023, the City of Asheville Reparations Commission met at the Harris Center to review updates from its Interdisciplinary Focus Areas (IFAs) and plan for an upcoming retreat. The meeting focused on the commission’s mandate to increase generational wealth and reduce racial disparities in Asheville and Buncombe County, with significant discussion surrounding direct cash payments, housing land return, criminal justice reform, and economic development initiatives.

## Key Decisions
The only formal decision recorded at this meeting was the approval of the agenda and the minutes from the previous meeting. A motion was made and seconded, and the Chair stated that the item had been approved. No other votes were taken, and no specific tallies were recorded for this approval. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn, which was seconded and passed by a voice vote.

## Discussion Highlights
The Chair opened the meeting by advocating for direct cash payments to African Americans as a primary method for building assets and reducing disparities, explicitly urging the commission to consider this approach despite potential political opposition. The Chair stated, "The key element in reducing disparities is increasing the assets of African Americans. And increasing the assets means direct cash payment... Do not take stereotypical responses in that the folk will just waste the money. They do not." Commission member Dwayne McAfee supported this stance, stating, "I especially appreciate that [the Chair]... has been harping on [not taking anything off the table]... There is nothing that should be off of the table... Let's be bold... I'm demanding that there's a change. I'm demanding that there's accountability."

The Housing IFA presented draft recommendations focused on returning urban renewal land to the community, acquiring underutilized or vacant land, and creating a land acquisition program. The facilitator, Salamonita Merritt, noted that legal review is ongoing regarding how land can be legally conveyed or dedicated. The County Attorney, Brad, commented on the legal pathways, stating, "If we're defining what return is... dedicating it towards the purposes of reparations... is, I think, something that absolutely is a much easier legal path for us to do."

The Criminal Justice IFA outlined recommendations including eliminating racial disparities in courts, increasing Black participation in diversion programs, culturally relevant training for court personnel, and the immediate release of Black individuals incarcerated for petty crimes. The group discussed organizing these recommendations into categories such as policing reform, state policies, and accountability.

The Economic Development IFA presented a proposal for an Economic Development Center for Black Asheville, envisioned as a one-stop shop for small business development, workforce development, and financial literacy. The group presented budget figures, including approximately $1.7 million for brick-and-mortar costs and $92,000 per neighborhood for planning costs for six legacy Black neighborhoods. Member Dee Williams emphasized the specificity of the proposal, stating, "This is a proposal. This is not just talk... It looks like what we've done is we've not only cost out the incubator for Burton Street, but we've also costed out the planning costs for each of the six black legacy neighborhoods... We do have enough talent in this group to be able to develop pro formas and budgets around what we want to do." Member Bernard Oliphant suggested, "A better place to put that management structure is inside this one-stop hub... that management structure can help us prioritize set milestones and help us move forward."

The Arteria Collective, a youth documentation team, presented their work on intergenerational dialogue and youth perspectives on reparations. Youth members shared insights on the need for affordable healthcare, mental health resources, food security, and the importance of teaching Black history in predominantly white institutions. Youth member Eden Mosley stated, "Black history, especially African American history, is American history because it happened on American soil. So therefore, it should be taught." Commission member Joyce Harrison responded to the youth presentation by stating, "I would like to see the youth do some of the work that we can't do on the foot basis of talking to the elderly people in the community... The door is open to let them do something."

A representative from the Burton Street Neighborhood provided an update on local planning efforts, including the Burton Street Neighborhood Plan, efforts to position local residents for jobs in the redevelopment of the Bird Street Community Center, and the creation of a business incubator. The representative, Dwayne Barton, highlighted that the community has raised $1.5 million for these efforts and expressed frustration with the slow pace of institutional support, stating, "We're not waiting. And we're trying to build... I don't see no momentum coming our way. And we've been able to raise 1.5 million dollars and more money on the way. But the local institutions and organizations are still moving in slow motion."

The meeting concluded with a discussion on the agenda for the upcoming July 29th retreat, including defining reparations, shared goals, governance, and the need for breakout sessions. Commission member MZ Yehuda suggested, "I think we have some good facilitators amongst our IFA... I have a recommendation for Dr. Lavender if that's possible." Another member, Roy Harris, asked about information on the facilitator, leading to a discussion about trauma-informed facilitation.

## Community Input
No members of the public signed up for the formal public comment period.

## Follow-ups
*   **Housing IFA:** The facilitator stated they will share the "buckets" of recommendations at the next report-out and will continue working on the language for land return recommendations with legal counsel.
*   **Criminal Justice IFA:** The facilitator stated they will be putting together proposals for criminal justice to help the city and county move forward.
*   **Economic Development IFA:** The group stated they will discuss the Economic Development Center proposal at their next IFA meeting on Thursday, July 6, and invite commission members and the public to provide input.
*   **Retreat Logistics:** The Project Manager, Christine Edwards, confirmed the retreat date as Saturday, July 29th, from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. (tentative) at the Harris Center. She stated she would coordinate with the Chair and Vice Chair to finalize the time and agenda topics.
*   **Informal Conversations:** The Chair mentioned that informal, non-quorum conversations are being organized at Berry Temple, hosted by Dr. Mullen, and the Project Manager offered to create a virtual option for those who prefer it.
*   **Audit RFP:** Staff reported that the audit RFP closed on June 8th, proposals have been received, and the selection process is underway, with the auditor expected to be selected by the week of July 3rd.

## Impact
This meeting marked a significant step in the Reparations Commission’s work, moving from broad goals to specific, costed proposals and legal strategies. The emphasis on direct cash payments and the detailed budgeting for the Economic Development Center and land acquisition programs indicates a shift toward actionable policy frameworks. The inclusion of youth perspectives and the Burton Street Neighborhood’s report on community-led fundraising highlights the intersection of institutional action and grassroots momentum. The upcoming retreat on July 29th is expected to further refine the commission’s shared goals and governance structures, building on the specific recommendations presented by the IFAs.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oCkvMLkFkGo
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2601/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oCkvMLkFkGo)
