# Noise Advisory Board – June 12, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Noise Advisory Board
**Date:** June 12, 2023 1:00 PM EDT (2023-06-12T13:00:09-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4752/noise-advisory-board-june-12-2023
**Outcome:** The Noise Advisory Board approved the previous minutes and prepared a presentation on vehicular noise and waste hauler recommendations for the Environment and Safety Committee.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Noise Advisory Board held a virtual meeting on June 12, 2023. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a review of the monthly staff report, a discussion on upcoming presentations to the Environment and Safety Committee, and an update on the ongoing decibel investigation.

The board’s primary decision at this meeting was the approval of the minutes from the previous session. A motion was made to approve these minutes, and a roll call vote was taken. The transcript records affirmative votes from Rick Freeman and Dave Ledger. While the transcript does not explicitly record the votes of the other present members or a final tally, the Chair stated, "Great. Thanks," implying the motion was approved.

A significant portion of the meeting focused on preparations for a presentation to the Environment and Safety Committee scheduled for June 27, 2023. Rick Freeman and Jessica Tomasin reviewed a slide deck containing recommendations for addressing vehicular noise, a waste hauler plan, and public feedback on the current noise ordinance. Rick Freeman clarified the board’s intent, stating, "We're not asking for 24 by 7 enforcement we're looking for best practices from other locations other cities that would make a dent and people would understand that there's a deterrent and that people can be cited." He further noted that if the committee approved the first two recommendations (vehicular noise and waste hauler) but delayed the third (ordinance review), the board would accept that outcome to secure backing for immediate action.

The board also discussed the methodology for the ongoing decibel investigation. Rick Freeman provided an update on participant recruitment, noting that approximately 10 participants had already agreed to take part. A debate arose regarding whether to use C-weighted (DBC) or A-weighted (DBA) measurements. Reb Haizlip argued for using DBC, stating, "If most of these are entertainment-related venue noise complaints... DBC is a more deleterious form of noise for health outcomes... particularly with music venues, it is important because the low frequency is associated with performance, and the low frequency does not get adequately captured in an A-level reading." Reb Haizlip, Dave Ledger, and Carmelo Papillonio agreed to work together to define the standardized methodology, with Reb Haizlip stating they could likely write the methodology in a week.

Regarding the staff report, a discussion occurred about technical difficulties accessing certain links within the document. Rick Freeman suggested that staff consider a process to test report links before meetings, possibly during the planning meeting the week before, to ensure board members can access them. Additionally, regarding a tax amendment change related to noise data, staff member Todd Justice stated, "At this point, I don't know enough about it and I don't know, you know, what kind of data we're going to get, if it's going to be significant or if it's going to be something we can rely on for a tax amendment change or not. So I think we wait and see what we get."

There were no public comments during the designated period. However, during the "New Business" segment, a participant who is not on the official board roster remarked, "I hope everybody gets an opportunity to read that article I sent out this morning. It’s interesting." When asked if it was the Times article, the participant confirmed, "Yeah, it’s a good one."

Several follow-up actions were identified. Rick Freeman and Jessica Tomasin will present their slides to the Environment and Safety Committee on June 27, 2023. Reb Haizlip will reach out to Dave Ledger and Carmelo Papillonio to schedule a meeting to finalize the decibel measurement methodology. Rick Freeman will send an update to the approximately 10 participants in the decibel investigation. Additionally, Rick Freeman asked board members to use their networks to encourage friends and colleagues to submit positive comments for the upcoming Safety and Environmental meeting and stated he would inform the Citizens Association of North Carolina (CAN) to distribute the link to their staff. Finally, Jeffrey Santiago reported that he has a list of outdoor event dates through September and will continue to add to it to help the compliance team plan around events.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g8UHv1gyia0
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2602/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g8UHv1gyia0)
