# Planning and Zoning Commission – June 7, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Planning and Zoning Commission
**Date:** June 7, 2023 5:00 PM EDT (2023-06-07T17:00:57-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4756/planning-and-zoning-commission-june-7-2023

## Summary

**Meeting Overview**
The City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission held a meeting on June 7, 2023. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, the continuation of two pending items, and the review of three new proposals: a mixed-use development at 226 Hilliard Avenue, a conditional rezoning for a multi-family project at 319 Biltmore Avenue, and a signage amendment for the hospital campus at 509 Biltmore Avenue. The Commission also reviewed a technical amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO).

**Key Decisions**
The Commission voted 5-0 to approve the minutes from the May 3, 2023 meeting. Two items from the previous meeting, a site plan review for 68 Carter Street and a rezoning request for 99999 Grandview Place, were continued to the July 5, 2023 meeting by a 5-0 vote.

For the new agenda items, the Commission voted 5-0 to recommend approval of the Level 2 site plan review for 226 Hilliard Avenue; the Chair clarified that this Commission approval serves as the final decision for this specific item. The Commission voted 4-1 to approve the conditional rezoning request for 319 Biltmore Avenue, with one abstention. This item will proceed to City Council for final approval. The Commission voted 5-0 to approve the amendment to the Conditional Use Permit for 509 Biltmore Avenue, allowing additional signage. Finally, the Commission voted 5-0 to continue the UDO Text Amendment to the June 21, 2023 meeting because the final formal wording was not included in the packet.

**Discussion Highlights**
Staff presented the 226 Hilliard Avenue project, a four-story mixed-use building with 110 residential units and the renovation of a historic one-story building. Staff noted the site is less than 0.2 miles from the TRAX center. The applicant explained that design changes were made to address previous concerns about the building’s scale and "fortress-like" appearance.

Regarding 319 Biltmore Avenue, staff presented revisions to the conditional rezoning request, including increased commercial space and improved pedestrian connections. The applicant emphasized that the project’s density should be viewed in terms of people rather than units. During the discussion, the Deputy City Attorney clarified the legal distinction between accepting housing vouchers as a fair housing requirement and creating specific set-asides for project-based vouchers. A Commissioner, via an email read by the Chair, expressed disappointment with the high amount of parking and low retail space but stated that the community’s need for housing would tip the scales in favor of the project.

For the 509 Biltmore Avenue signage amendment, staff explained that while the Department of Transportation has standards for directional signs, there are no specific standards for signs on the hospital campus itself. Staff confirmed the proposed signs match the existing style on campus and are intended to improve wayfinding for pedestrians and cyclists.

The UDO Text Amendment was presented as a non-substantive cleanup to consolidate scattered "Allowed Uses" tables into a single location to reduce confusion. However, staff noted that the formal wording amendments were missing from the packet because the final text was still being finalized. A Commissioner questioned what the Commission would be voting on without the draft wording, leading to the decision to continue the item.

**Community Input**
A public commenter from the South French Ward neighborhood expressed strong support for the 226 Hilliard Avenue project, highlighting the pedestrian access, green buffers, and tree preservation. The Chair responded by noting that the project aligns with Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design principles by activating public spaces.

A public commenter representing an affordable housing advocacy organization raised concerns about the affordability metrics for the 319 Biltmore Avenue project, suggesting that the 10% of units designated for 80% Area Median Income be set aside for voucher holders. In response, the applicant stated they are open to adding language to the zoning conditions to work with the Housing Authority on project-based vouchers, provided it is subject to Housing Authority approval. The Commission agreed to include a condition that the applicant will work with the Housing Authority toward project-based rental assistance, with specific percentages to be determined prior to Council approval.

No public comments were recorded for the 509 Biltmore Avenue signage amendment or the UDO Text Amendment.

**Follow-ups**
Staff and the applicant for 226 Hilliard Avenue are working on finalizing technical and design conditions, including gate operation details and structural checks for the rooftop amenity space.

For 319 Biltmore Avenue, the applicant agreed to work with City departments to install a high-visibility crosswalk with a speed table on John Walker Avenue. The applicant also agreed to work with the City and NCDOT regarding sidewalk installation on Biltmore Avenue; if engineered plans for a turn lane or signal are not available by the end of 2023, the applicant will remove three existing curb cuts, or install a 10-foot sidewalk if plans confirm no turn lane. Additionally, the applicant agreed to work with the Housing Authority toward project-based rental assistance.

Staff agreed to have the final form of the UDO Text Amendment, including all internal reference changes, ready by Thursday and Friday of the following week to allow for a vote at the June 21, 2023 meeting.

**Impact**
These decisions affect the development of new housing and commercial spaces in downtown Asheville. The approval of the 226 Hilliard Avenue site plan finalizes a project that includes 110 residential units and a pedestrian walk-through connecting South Grove Street to Ashland Avenue. The conditional approval of the 319 Biltmore Avenue rezoning allows a 221-unit apartment complex, 30% of which is affordable, to proceed to City Council, with new conditions requiring the developer to collaborate with the Housing Authority on voucher assistance. The signage amendment for the hospital campus aims to improve navigation for visitors, pedestrians, and cyclists. The UDO amendment, once finalized, will streamline the zoning code by consolidating use tables, making it easier for residents and developers to determine permitted uses.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pX_LoGMV8sQ
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2607/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pX_LoGMV8sQ)
