# Environment & Safety Committee – May 23, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Environment and Safety Committee
**Date:** May 23, 2023 11:00 AM EDT (2023-05-23T11:00:09-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4760/environment-safety-committee-may-23-2023

## Summary

On May 23, 2023, the City of Asheville Environment and Safety Committee convened to review updates on two primary agenda items: the single-use plastic reduction initiative and the downtown safety initiative. The committee also voted to approve the minutes from its previous meeting on April 25, 2023.

## Key Decisions
The only formal vote taken during the session was the approval of the minutes from the April 25, 2023 meeting. The vote was unanimous, with ayes recorded from Vice Mayor Kilgore, Councilwoman Smith, and Chair Ullman. No other motions or votes were recorded in the transcript.

## Discussion Highlights: Single-Use Plastic Reduction
Staff presented findings from a public input survey and a sanitation analysis regarding single-use plastic bags and expanded polystyrene (styrofoam) takeout containers. Sustainability Director Bridget Herring noted that while resident interest was high, with nearly 7,000 survey responses, business participation was too low to draw conclusions about support. She highlighted that the data showed underrepresentation from people of color, renters, and low-to-moderate income households.

Sanitation Division Manager Jess Foster explained that current sanitation services are inadequate to capture single-use plastics, noting that the material recovery facility spends approximately 600 hours per week removing plastic bags from the sorting line. She stated that Buncombe County spends over $20,000 annually and 1,200 hours collecting blown litter. Foster added that dedicated curbside recycling for these items is not financially or operationally feasible due to millions of dollars in startup costs and a lack of processing infrastructure.

In response, Chair Maggie Ullman asked if the analysis suggested that prohibiting bags is a more viable path than expensive municipal collection programs. She expressed excitement about the direction of prohibiting these items at the point of sale, given the high level of resident willingness, but emphasized the need for representative input from all communities. Vice Mayor Sandra Kilgore expressed concern that small businesses, particularly those owned by Black and Hispanic residents, are facing significant cost increases with alternative materials, potentially making it impossible to profit. She suggested spreading awareness to areas of the city with lower participation rates to ensure the data is representative. City Manager Deborah Campbell stated that the city is not satisfied with the current response rates, particularly from the business community, and is making extra efforts to sharpen outreach to BIPOC communities and businesses.

## Discussion Highlights: Downtown Safety Initiative
Staff provided a three-week update on the city’s 60-day downtown safety initiative, which launched on May 1, 2023. Downtown Planning Manager Dana Frankel highlighted that the initiative is an interdisciplinary effort involving police, fire, sanitation, parks, and other departments. She noted that the first two weeks of data (May 1–14) showed increased law enforcement presence, multiple lighting assessments, and one community cleanup.

Deputy Police Chief Jim Baumstark reported that the police department has increased foot and bike patrols and is using a therapy dog, noting that community feedback has been positive regarding the visible collaboration among city departments. Captain Stepp of the Asheville Police Department stated that the department focused on education and verbal warnings in the first two weeks before moving to enforcement, explaining that verbal warnings are used for trespassing and loitering to educate individuals before issuing citations. Assistant Chief Patrick Crudup presented data on the Community Responder Pilot Program, noting 290 interactions to date, with over 90% being proactive.

Captain Sullivan of the Fire Department shared three success stories of the Community Responder Program, including helping a man stranded in Asheville return to his home in Marion, NC; de-escalating a situation at a Ben & Jerry’s by connecting a man to his doctor for medication; and assisting a man who had been homeless for a year into detox treatment. City Manager Deborah Campbell emphasized that the initiative is not an experiment but a foundation for how the city will work to deliver services more impactfully. She credited Councilwoman Shanika Smith, former Public Safety Committee Chair, for challenging staff to operationalize "reimagining public safety," and noted that the program is about helping people, not displacing them.

## Follow-ups
Staff explicitly agreed to several follow-up actions during the meeting. Regarding plastic reduction, Sustainability Director Bridget Herring stated that staff are developing strategies to engage "missing voices" (residents and businesses underrepresented in the initial survey) and plans to deploy these strategies in the next month or two. Staff will also conduct additional research on product availability, lifecycle costs of bag options, and the impact of the policy on waste reduction goals.

Regarding the downtown safety initiative, Assistant City Manager Ben Woody and Downtown Planning Manager Dana Frankel confirmed that staff are tracking activities in four categories (community support, cleanliness, environment improvement, and compliance) and will update the project website and send email updates every two weeks. Staff stated they will conduct a full analysis of the initiative’s impact, including crime data and cost, at the end of the 60-day period to inform next steps. Additionally, City Manager Deborah Campbell indicated that the city is looking at opportunities to use ARPA and opioid settlement funds to train more firefighters for the Community Responder Program and potentially expand coverage to other parts of the community, possibly through mid-year budget adjustments.

## Impact
These discussions provide residents with insight into the city's approach to managing waste and public safety. The plastic reduction update highlights the operational challenges of recycling single-use items and the ongoing effort to gather more representative data from diverse business and resident communities. The downtown safety update offers transparency into the specific actions taken by various city departments during the first phase of the 60-day initiative, including the shift from education to enforcement and the outcomes of the Community Responder Program.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNzHYS5pUd8
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2612/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNzHYS5pUd8)
