# Board of Adjustment – May 22, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Board of Adjustment
**Date:** May 22, 2023 2:00 PM EDT (2023-05-22T14:00:26-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4762/board-of-adjustment-may-22-2023
**Outcome:** The Board of Adjustment approved four of five variance requests, including two for accessory dwelling units, and denied a request to reduce an aquatic buffer.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment convened on May 22, 2023, to review the minutes from its March 2023 meeting and to hold five evidentiary hearings regarding variances from the City’s Unified Development Ordinance (UDO). The board addressed requests for relief related to accessory dwelling units (ADUs), aquatic buffers, parking standards, and steep slope land disturbance.

**Key Decisions**
The board unanimously accepted the minutes from the March 2023 meeting. Additionally, a motion was made to strike an unadvertised appeal from the agenda, which passed unanimously. The board then voted on five specific variance requests:
*   **73 Swannanoa Avenue:** The board voted 5-0 to approve a variance allowing the conversion of an existing, unpermitted accessory structure into a conforming ADU.
*   **51 Highland Street:** The board voted 5-0 to approve a variance for a two-story ADU replacing a deteriorating garage, which required 100% relief from side and rear setbacks. This approval included a condition that footers for the new structure must not extend over the property line.
*   **198 Hanover Street:** The board voted 1-4 to decline a request for relief from the 30-foot undisturbed aquatic buffer requirement for new single-family home construction.
*   **24 Florida Avenue:** The board voted 5-0 to approve a variance for disturbing the aquatic buffer to regularize an existing gravel driveway. Separately, the board voted 4-1 to approve a variance for parking and loading standards to accommodate a proposed duplex.
*   **108 Coal Ridge Road:** The board voted 5-0 to approve a variance increasing the allowable land disturbance percentage on a steep slope (Zone B) from 15% to 23.5% for new home construction.

**Discussion Highlights**
During the hearing for 51 Highland Street, Chair Paul Wilczynski praised the applicant’s submission, stating, "I was very impressed with the application that you filled out. I have never seen anyone answer those four questions in the detail that you did." Regarding the declined request at 198 Hanover Street, Member Bill Newman explained his vote, noting, "I do not have one [a modification] because I am not going to be able to support this variance... there is hardship on the land but there is not a hardship in relation to the application... the building could be two stories... there's many many options because it's new construction." For the 24 Florida Avenue parking variance, Newman stated, "I think that this parking spot is an elective item based off of their desired programming, so I'm not going to be able to support that one." In the 108 Coal Ridge Road case, Newman noted a potential conflict of interest, stating, "Stephen Lee Johnson in my office prepared some of these graphics for the applicants. However, he did that as a favor, as a friend, and so there's no conflict of interest for me to sit here... I'm uncomfortable with that." No member requested a recusal.

**Community Input**
A public commenter, identified as the downhill neighbor of the 51 Highland Street property, stated that neighbors were supportive of the project but expressed concern that the roof line on the fence line side might exceed 16 feet. The commenter also asked if a future owner could build a larger structure without re-approval. Staff member Tyler Kelly clarified that the variance was strictly for setbacks and that the proposed structure would meet current UDO height standards (under 25 feet), meaning the variance did not address building height. The neighbor then stated they had no further problems with the project.

Regarding 108 Coal Ridge Road, a public commenter, identified as the neighbor directly below the proposed build site, expressed concern about storm runoff and drainage from construction, citing past issues on Pinecroft Road. Staff member Tyler Kelly responded that because the disturbance exceeds 10,000 square feet, the site will be actively inspected by grading inspectors, and erosion control measures must be in place prior to inspection. A board member added that a geotechnical engineer must be involved for stability due to the steep slope. The applicant added that they had already engaged a geotechnical engineering firm and had a completed report indicating the soil was stable.

**Follow-ups**
No staff members or board members explicitly agreed to follow-up actions during this meeting. The applicants for 51 Highland Street and 108 Coal Ridge Road stated their own intentions to adjust their projects (decreasing structure size or obtaining a total survey, respectively), but these were commitments made by the applicants rather than the board or staff.

**Impact**
These decisions directly affect property rights and development standards in the City of Asheville. The approvals at 73 Swannanoa Avenue and 51 Highland Street allow for the creation or replacement of accessory dwelling units, potentially increasing housing density in those neighborhoods. The decline of the aquatic buffer variance at 198 Hanover Street maintains the existing environmental protection for that new construction site. The approvals at 24 Florida Avenue and 108 Coal Ridge Road allow for specific infrastructure changes and increased land disturbance on a steep slope, subject to the conditions and inspections outlined by staff and board members.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ii2OPv6CGzE
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2613/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ii2OPv6CGzE)
