# Reparations Commission – May 15, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Reparations Commission
**Date:** May 15, 2023 5:52 PM EDT (2023-05-15T17:52:59-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4771/reparations-commission-may-15-2023
**Outcome:** The Reparations Commission approved the agenda and minutes, and staff announced a hold on new data requests to clear the backlog of 68 incomplete items.

## Summary

**Reparations Commission Meeting Recap: May 15, 2023**

The City of Asheville Reparations Commission convened on May 15, 2023, to review progress on its Independent Fiscal Assessments (IFAs) and plan for an upcoming in-person retreat. The meeting included a review of survey feedback from the previous session, updates on health and education initiatives, a status report on data requests, and a discussion regarding the structure and objectives of the Commission’s next gathering.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The Commission voted to approve the agenda and the minutes from the previous meeting. Additionally, staff announced a decision to place a hold on new data requests from IFAs starting June 15, 2023. This hold is intended to allow staff to prioritize and complete the current backlog of approximately 68 incomplete data requests. A motion to adjourn the meeting was made and seconded, though no specific vote tally or final outcome was recorded in the transcript summary.

**Discussion Highlights**
The meeting featured updates from two key IFAs. The Health and Wellness IFA presented efforts to address historic healthcare guidelines, barriers for formerly incarcerated individuals, and environmental racism, announcing a community storytelling event hosted by the Shiloh Community Association. The Education IFA presented three draft recommendations: addressing the disproportionate suspension of Black students, a "Black Teacher Retention Promise" including housing allowances and recruitment strategies, and a letter to school boards outlining persistent system issues.

Staff provided a dashboard update indicating that of approximately 100 data requests submitted, about 30 were completed and 68 remained incomplete. Staff explained that many incomplete requests require extensive manual research or state-level data access. Chair Dwight Mullen emphasized the need for unity and patience within the Commission, noting that reparations movements often implode due to internal intentions rather than external attacks. He also expressed a lack of trust in placing education recommendations solely in the hands of those responsible for existing disparities.

**Community Input**
Public comments focused heavily on the necessity of moving from philosophical discussions to concrete proposals, budgets, and programs. One public commenter expressed frustration that communities have spent 10–12 years creating plans without receiving necessary resources, urging the Commission to use existing data sources to set immediate goals rather than waiting for new data. They stated they would attend the retreat but would leave if it did not produce tangible results. Another public commenter agreed, emphasizing a desire for results rather than "wasting time and money."

Other public commenters discussed the retreat strategy. One suggested that while visiting different IFAs creates a culture of sharing, a second retreat after the summer might be a better venue for IFAs to work together on recommendations, emphasizing the need to define what reparations means. Another commenter listed priorities for the retreat as developing an independent assessment committee and an implementation committee, stating, "time is not on our side." A final commenter questioned how the Commission’s recommendations are distinct from general equity work, arguing that historical data is needed to make direct connections between government actions and harms.

Regarding the Health and Wellness IFA, a public commenter asked about immediate actions to eliminate health disparities, specifically infant mortality. The Health and Wellness spokesperson replied that the group is investigating the closure of hospitals and community outreach departments that previously addressed inequities. Regarding the Education IFA, a public commenter asked if recommendations had been vetted by attorneys. The Education facilitator responded that the group had spoken with attorneys to refine wording to navigate legal constraints in North Carolina, noting that some proposals were written strategically to avoid naming specific groups to ensure they could be passed. During a round-table discussion on the retreat, a public commenter expressed frustration with polling members on their feelings about a retreat that had already been voted on. Chair Dwight Mullen responded by explaining that the Commission was seeking specific inputs on the retreat’s objectives that were not covered in the initial survey.

For the public comments regarding the retreat strategy (specifically those suggesting a second retreat, listing priorities for committees, and questioning the distinction between reparations and equity work), no specific member or staff member responded.

**Follow-ups**
Staff members Matt Baker and Katherine Cutchall agreed to continue working on the incomplete data requests, prioritizing those marked as "critical" by IFA facilitators. Katherine Cutchall noted that a new full-time staff member would start in Special Collections the following week to help with historical data transcription. The Education IFA stated they would rework their letter to the Asheville City Schools Board, send a draft to the Buncombe County Board, and reach out to other IFAs within the next month to align proposals. The Health and Wellness IFA stated they would continue their own research, including reviewing the Community Health Assessment and contacting accreditation agencies, while waiting for official data requests to be fulfilled. No staff members or commission members explicitly agreed to specific follow-up actions regarding the retreat itself.

**Impact**
This meeting highlights the Commission's transition from data gathering to actionable policy development. The decision to pause new data requests signals a shift toward finalizing the research phase to allow for the development of concrete recommendations. The public feedback underscores a significant community demand for tangible outcomes, such as budgets and implementation plans, rather than continued study or philosophical debate. The upcoming retreat will be a critical juncture for the Commission to address these concerns and define the specific mechanisms for reparations in Asheville.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9giQGUCV9d0
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2620/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9giQGUCV9d0)
