# Historic Resources Commission – May 10, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Historic Resources Commission
**Date:** May 10, 2023 4:03 PM EDT (2023-05-10T16:03:29-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4775/historic-resources-commission-may-10-2023
**Outcome:** Historic Resources Commission approved three renovation permits and two National Register nominations, and continued the Angle Street development application to June.

## Summary

The City of Asheville Historic Resources Commission (HRC) convened on May 10, 2023, to review Certificates of Appropriateness (COAs), National Register nominations, and a major development proposal. The commission began by unanimously accepting the minutes from the April meeting. The agenda included three routine COA applications within historic districts, a large-scale mixed-use development in Biltmore Village, and two National Register nominations.

The commission unanimously approved and issued Certificates of Appropriateness for three projects. For 6 Birch Street in the Montford Historic District, the approval covered the removal of a non-original, dilapidated porch and door on the east elevation of a one-story bungalow. For 60 Cumberland Avenue, also in the Montford Historic District, the commission approved a second-story addition on the rear elevation, the removal of a non-character-defining chimney, and roof and shingle replacement. For 60 Terrace Road in the Albemarle Park Historic District, the commission approved renovations to the "Foxden" accessory structure, including the removal of two structurally unsound chimneys, widening of a pedestrian entry, replacement of a light fixture, addition of brick paving, and the removal and replacement of a tree. No public comments were received for these three items.

The most significant discussion centered on a large-scale mixed-use development proposal at 1 Angle Street and 10 Kitchen Place in the Biltmore Village Historic District. The project involves four distinct building structures, and the debate focused heavily on building height, massing, and compliance with the 30-foot primary facade height limit and the 3.5-story limit in the Development Plan. Staff expressed primary concern regarding building height, noting that one cottage-type structure appeared to exceed 45 feet. Commissioners debated how to measure "facade" height, with one suggesting measurement to the top of the parapet wall for commercial buildings and to the peak of the roof for complex structures. Concerns were raised that flat elevations did not adequately show the building’s relationship to surrounding structures, such as the Grand Bohemian, All Souls Church, and New Morning Gallery. A motion was made to continue the application to the June 14, 2023 meeting, which passed unanimously.

During the review of the Angle Street project, several individuals provided testimony. A preservation architect stated he was initially opposed to the project but was "turned around" by the decision to divide the mass into four separate buildings to manage scale, though he expressed concern about the 20-foot first floor. A retired preservation specialist noted that in previous discussions regarding the Grand Bohemian, facade height was considered the full height of the elevation, and requested that the Cathedral be notified of future HRC meetings. The Dean of All Souls Cathedral expressed faith that the project would enhance the area and that a suitable solution would be found through collaboration. A representative for All Souls Church stated the church was open to providing access to its facilities for the development team. A resident and architect stated they were not in support of the project as presented, citing concerns about scale, massing, and the use of multiple materials, and suggested scaling back the design to use primarily commercial brick. The development team representative thanked the commissioners for their feedback and expressed a desire to work collaboratively to refine the design, noting that the team had already removed two floors from the initial design.

The commission also reviewed two National Register nominations. A motion was made to recommend approval of the nomination for the BK Miller House, a Rustic Revival style structure, which passed unanimously. A motion was made to support the nomination for Walton Street Park, an African American heritage site, which also passed unanimously. Additionally, the commission unanimously awarded the 2023 Historic Resources Champion Award to Dale Wayne Slessor.

Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Staff agreed to check the file for a formal inventory of contributing and non-contributing resources in Biltmore Village and to update the staff report with the correct land use sub-area information for the Angle Street site. Staff also agreed to send a follow-up email to commissioners regarding attendance at the Griffin Awards on May 25 and to coordinate with Dale Slessor regarding the event. Another staff member offered to review conceptual massing studies or renderings from the development team before the next meeting to provide feedback. The development team agreed to request a continuance to the June 14, 2023 meeting and committed to working on massing studies and refining the design, specifically regarding height calculations and the resolution of parapet and roof spring details, to better address concerns regarding height, scale, and context.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d2PfR05_yNo
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3043/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d2PfR05_yNo)
