# Policy, Finance & HR Committee – May 9, 2023

**Body:** City of Asheville — Policy, Finance and HR Committee
**Date:** May 9, 2023 10:00 AM EDT (2023-05-09T10:00:18-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/4776/policy-finance-hr-committee-may-9-2023

## Summary

The City of Asheville’s Policy, Finance and HR Committee met virtually on May 9, 2023, to review a specific land use incentive request and discuss future workforce compensation strategies. The committee’s primary focus was a request from Commonwealth Development Corporation for a property tax abatement for a new affordable housing project, alongside a request to revisit the city’s approach to staff living wages in upcoming budget cycles.

**Key Decisions**
The committee took two formal votes during the session. First, a motion was made to approve the minutes, which passed unanimously with a 3-0 vote. Second, the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend that the full City Council approve the Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIG) application for the Fairhaven Summit Apartments. This recommendation allows the item to proceed to the full City Council for final consideration.

**Discussion Highlights**
The central discussion involved the Fairhaven Summit Apartments, a 77-unit, 100% affordable housing project located at 3124 Sweeton Creek Road. Commonwealth Development Corporation requested a 21-year property tax abatement, which is the maximum cap allowed under city policy. Sasha Vertinsky, the Affordable Housing Officer, explained that the total grant value is approximately $1 million, equating to a subsidy of about $13,222 per unit. Sean Brady, the developer, clarified that the "gross rent" figures presented reflect revenue to the project from vouchers rather than the amount residents pay. He noted that the request for the LUIG is driven by a county funding requirement (AHSP) that forces the project to opt out of a property tax exemption that would otherwise be available to the nonprofit owner. Mayor Esther Mannheimer thanked the developer, stating, "We've seen a few 100% affordable housing projects in the last couple of years, and that's a good thing."

The committee also discussed the city’s staff living wage projections. Councilwoman Kim Roney expressed concern that the city is not looking early enough at the cost of living wages, stating, "I'm concerned that if we don't start to look at projections of what that could look like, we're not going to have the hands that it takes to meet the commitments... And we may end up seeing even more vacancies and issues with retention and recruitment." Mayor Mannheimer acknowledged the difficulty of the current process, noting, "I struggle with this conversation we have every year around what the new living wage amount is and how challenging it is to get there... with inflation, it's kind of run away from us, the number, in the last couple of years."

**Community Input**
There were no public comments recorded during the meeting. The chair confirmed there were no callers in the queue for public comment on the agenda item or for general public comment.

**Follow-ups**
Councilwoman Kim Roney requested that the committee look at living wage projections and the cost gap to reach a living wage in a future meeting. In response, Interim CFO Taylor Floyd stated that the base rate starting in the new fiscal year will be approximately $18.58, a 5% increase over $18. Taylor Floyd also confirmed that staff had previously estimated the cost to reach the full living wage rate, plus compression adjustments, at over $10 million during the March 14 budget work session. Mayor Esther Mannheimer agreed to include this topic in the full council’s retreat goals, stating, "I think this is a good one to put on everyone's radar... and include that so that staff can incorporate that in their work plan for next year."

**Impact**
The committee’s recommendation to approve the Land Use Incentive Grant supports the development of 77 additional 100% affordable housing units in the Fairhaven Summit area. By approving the 21-year tax abatement, the committee is facilitating a project that relies on specific county funding structures to remain financially viable for its nonprofit owner. Additionally, the agreement to incorporate living wage projections into the council’s retreat goals and staff work plan signals a shift toward earlier financial planning for workforce compensation, aiming to address potential retention and recruitment challenges identified by council members.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8WdpxrFZ8MQ
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3228/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8WdpxrFZ8MQ)
